Some rational points here that I concur with. But again, it's not really an argument against the religiosity of AA.
Let me try to paraphrase the opposing argument the way I see it, as briefly as possible, and we'll see if all this discussion about "belief" fits in:
"AA is religious because it refers to
God, and substituting
higher power for that is a mere ruse, because everyone knows that
God is the only thing to which such a phrase could possibly refer."
Or, alternatively:
"An atheist could never work the steps, because doing so requires
belief in a higher power, and atheism bespeaks a committment to rational thinking which precludes that."
My answer to the first version (again, as briefly as possible) is that statements in AA literature to the effect that: "
AA does not demand that you believe anything" and "
just try to practice the rest of the program as enthusiatically as possible" may be taken at face value; they say what they mean, they mean what they say. AA members are free to accept or reject whatever they choose, and they
do regularly exercise this freedom, in nearly as many different ways as there are individual members.
My answer to the second version is the same, with this added: If you are unable to identify anything in this universe that you could both rationally and meaningfully regard as a power greater than yourself, and upon which you could rely for guidance and strength; and if you are unwilling to pull a "Wilson"; that is, to try to find something that appealed more to your irrational nature than to your analytical nature (or if you are unwilling to acknowedge
having an irrational nature); and if you don't think you could benefit from attempting to work the steps without that; and if you are sure that the discomfort of being in the presence of those who espouse beliefs you do not share would outweigh any possible comfort from simply being in the presence of those who are recovering from a malady you do share, steps or no steps -- then AA probably cannot be of much help to you. (The good news is that you're probably not a redneck).
But it still doesn't make AA inherently religious.