Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
As far as AA being the only way, this thread itself is chock full of testimonials from a few people about AA being the only way for them.
A major problem with alcoholism and treatment is gathering data that provide valid measures of 'success'. Any program seems to provide 2% 'success'.

The success rate for first-time treatments -- AA or whatever floats your boat -- is presumably even less. After trying other programs until money runs out, and/or life becomes sufficiently unbearable, AA always remains as a no cost, court approved, widely available alternative.

I "graduated" from professional rehab and from AA a couple of times before it worked for me.

Only you will ever find out what if anything works for you. If you have time and money to try other methods, why not?

Most of us probably know people who were at least alcohol abusers when young who successfully stopped drinking by late middle age with no assistance.
 
I already have.
Have you? All I've seen from you is assertions (like: "Immersion is not belief, period."). If you've made any actual arguments, I must have missed them. Would you mind reposting them?

Now I'm waiting for your evidence.
Physiological response to media viewing has been studied a lot. I could bury you in cites, but I don't see that as even being the thing you're disputing.

Gee, you're such a polite debater.
I can be, but that horse left the barn so long ago in this thread that I don't even see much point in continuing to bring it up.

Perhaps you should stop moving the goalposts and actually state what you think clearly if you want me to understand you.
I don't know how I could state it any more clearly than this:

"Immersion" requires belief. I'll state it more strongly than that. "Immersion" means belief, for some values of "belief".

Or this:

I'm arguing that emotional response IS "belief", on some level.


Is there ANYTHING you have except semantics games ?
Right back atcha. My claim is that emotional/physiological response to imaginary stimuli constitutes a form of belief. If you have a counterargument that is NOT based on semantics, please proceed -- otherwise, let the semantics games begin.
 
No, that the alcoholic needs to use a higher power to work the twelve steps or will fail.
You obviously don't think much of the quote I just provided from page 27 of the 12&12 which refutes that claim. But there are two separate issues here. One is that a higher power is vital to working the steps. The other is that AA teaches that working the steps is any alcoholic's only hope to quit. I don't agree with either of those, but it was really the second one that I had in mind when we first began that particular exchange:
Absolutely. But teaching him that he indeed _cannot_ quit without some higher power is dangerous, at best.
I don't disagree. But I don't agree that AA teaches that.



As far as AA being the only way, this thread itself is chock full of testimonials from a few people about AA being the only way for them.
Testimonials from a few people in this thread appear to be attributed either very little weight, or a great deal of weight, depending on what best serves the purposes of the person referencing them.
 
I don't see that the quote clearly states that the other methods work. In fact, it could be stating just the opposite: There are lots of therapies to cure alcoholism, but since none of the others provide the answer, join us.

To "clearly state precisely the opposite" it would need to state that those other therapies do work for at least some people.
I like it.

I completely disagree, of course; I think it means just what it says -- but you made a nice argument there considering how little you had to work with. Practically pulled that one right out of thin air, you did.
 
I've no interest in doing so, nor do I have a flock of post-docs to do all the work it would take.

Do you believe everything written in books?

I do know I have a successful AA experience, and had none with programs run by professionals.


Sounds just like a believer telling me why his god was true.

AA doctrine is nothing more than the Christian "We have all sinned and come short of the glory of god' statement wrapped in a little more clothes and the "Give your life to Jesus" is replaced by "give your life to a Higher Power". With a wink, wink, nudge, nudge as to Who is the HP.
 
Have you? All I've seen from you is assertions (like: "Immersion is not belief, period."). If you've made any actual arguments, I must have missed them. Would you mind reposting them?

Depends. Do you promise to remember them ? ;)

"Immersion" requires belief. I'll state it more strongly than that. "Immersion" means belief, for some values of "belief".

I'm arguing that emotional response IS "belief", on some level.

It's the "on some level" and "some values" that I find interesting. It allows you a lot of wiggle room.

Right back atcha.

Where did I play semantics games ?

If you have a counterargument that is NOT based on semantics, please proceed -- otherwise, let the semantics games begin.

Ah! I see. So stating that a word doesn't mean what you WANT it to mean is semantics ? No, that's not it. We're not discussing fine points of context-related definitions. "Immersion" is not belief, unless you twist the definition of "belief" to mean pretty much anything you want. Incidently, THAT would be a semantics game.
 
No, that the alcoholic needs to use a higher power to work the twelve steps or will fail. There are too many quotes to type out in the Big Book, 12 Steps and 12 Traditions, pamphlets, Daily Reflections, etc. etc., but if you insist I'll have a stab at it.

As far as AA being the only way, this thread itself is chock full of testimonials from a few people about AA being the only way for them.


Yep we've had the usual religious conversion stories from people who are swearing their organization isn't religious.
 
You obviously don't think much of the quote I just provided from page 27 of the 12&12 which refutes that claim.

The rest of your paragraph refutes the the "refutation" on page 27:

But there are two separate issues here. One is that a higher power is vital to working the steps.

Which it is.

The other is that AA teaches that working the steps is any alcoholic's only hope to quit. I don't agree with either of those,...

Which it does.

You really need to work on not proving our case for us. ;)

Testimonials from a few people in this thread appear to be attributed either very little weight, or a great deal of weight, depending on what best serves the purposes of the person referencing them.

Not at all. Each "side" has presented anecdotal testimonials. And they only carry the same weight as any anecdotal testimonials.

GB
 
It's the "on some level" and "some values" that I find interesting. It allows you a lot of wiggle room.
Fair enough. I have made a number of references to "cognitive submodules", as I strongly subscribe to this model of human cognition. I'm simply arguing that belief is not a special mental state that exists in some privileged, executive area of the brain, and (with few exceptions) it is not a binary property. It represents a sum total (or perhaps more of a biased average) of the outputs of these cognitive submodules -- some of which act together in mutually reinforcing ways, and some of which compete against each other.

Has the popular obsession with the personal lives of celebrities, the general decline in attention span, and other symptoms of brain-fry from thousands of hours spent staring slack-jawed at television tubes, rendered the American electorate so collectively incapable of rational discourse and informed decision-making that Democracy in this country is rapidly approaching the point at which it must be considered a failed experiment? I don't know that it is completely meaningful to say that I have a "belief" on this question. It is fragmented. It sort of flickers. Sometimes I believe it, sometimes I don't. When I do believe it, it's usually at times when I'm feeling frustrated, or angry, or fearful, or maybe just tired.

In short: What I believe can be as much a matter of how I feel as what I think. Are you and I different in this regard?
 
Fair enough. I have made a number of references to "cognitive submodules", as I strongly subscribe to this model of human cognition. I'm simply arguing that belief is not a special mental state that exists in some privileged, executive area of the brain, and (with few exceptions) it is not a binary property. It represents a sum total (or perhaps more of a biased average) of the outputs of these cognitive submodules -- some of which act together in mutually reinforcing ways, and some of which compete against each other.

Has the popular obsession with the personal lives of celebrities, the general decline in attention span, and other symptoms of brain-fry from thousands of hours spent staring slack-jawed at television tubes, rendered the American electorate so collectively incapable of rational discourse and informed decision-making that Democracy in this country is rapidly approaching the point at which it must be considered a failed experiment? I don't know that it is completely meaningful to say that I have a "belief" on this question. It is fragmented. It sort of flickers. Sometimes I believe it, sometimes I don't. When I do believe it, it's usually at times when I'm feeling frustrated, or angry, or fearful, or maybe just tired.

In short: What I believe can be as much a matter of how I feel as what I think. Are you and I different in this regard?

Some rational points here that I concur with :) . But again, it's not really an argument against the religiosity of AA.

You're really just making a good case for Indeterminism as a factor of Consciousness (along with deterministic factors too of course), so we might get along famously on the "Is Free Will an Illusion?(but necessary for ethics)" Thread.

GB
 
I like it.

I completely disagree, of course; I think it means just what it says -- but you made a nice argument there considering how little you had to work with. Practically pulled that one right out of thin air, you did.

So much of the tone of AA literature has that 1930s-1950s salesman vibe, a mix of cockiness and false humility to disguise the hard sell.

The attitude of try our competitors, we don't care, is all a part of that. So I honestly don't know "just what it says," beyond the literal interpretation I posted, because anything else would require reading between the lines.
 
The rest of your paragraph refutes the the "refutation" on page 27:
Whatever I wrote certainly doesn't change what is written on page 27 of the 12&12.

Are you sure you really want to bestow upon me the power to single-handedly overturn passages from AA literature (your primary source of empirical evidence)?
 
Many people do, I had a girlfriend that just quit cocaine one day, and was a heavy user.

Some can, some struggle.

I also did that. Was a hardcore pot smoker for 15 years. New boyfriend said if you want to move in need to stop smoking. I did and have not smoked since 2005.
 
Some rational points here that I concur with. But again, it's not really an argument against the religiosity of AA.
Let me try to paraphrase the opposing argument the way I see it, as briefly as possible, and we'll see if all this discussion about "belief" fits in:

"AA is religious because it refers to God, and substituting higher power for that is a mere ruse, because everyone knows that God is the only thing to which such a phrase could possibly refer."

Or, alternatively:

"An atheist could never work the steps, because doing so requires belief in a higher power, and atheism bespeaks a committment to rational thinking which precludes that."

My answer to the first version (again, as briefly as possible) is that statements in AA literature to the effect that: "AA does not demand that you believe anything" and "just try to practice the rest of the program as enthusiatically as possible" may be taken at face value; they say what they mean, they mean what they say. AA members are free to accept or reject whatever they choose, and they do regularly exercise this freedom, in nearly as many different ways as there are individual members.

My answer to the second version is the same, with this added: If you are unable to identify anything in this universe that you could both rationally and meaningfully regard as a power greater than yourself, and upon which you could rely for guidance and strength; and if you are unwilling to pull a "Wilson"; that is, to try to find something that appealed more to your irrational nature than to your analytical nature (or if you are unwilling to acknowedge having an irrational nature); and if you don't think you could benefit from attempting to work the steps without that; and if you are sure that the discomfort of being in the presence of those who espouse beliefs you do not share would outweigh any possible comfort from simply being in the presence of those who are recovering from a malady you do share, steps or no steps -- then AA probably cannot be of much help to you. (The good news is that you're probably not a redneck).

But it still doesn't make AA inherently religious.
 
I don't see that the quote clearly states that the other methods work. In fact, it could be stating just the opposite: There are lots of therapies to cure alcoholism, but since none of the others provide the answer, join us.

To "clearly state precisely the opposite" it would need to state that those other therapies do work for at least some people.

No it doesn't say other methods work, it says thay AA doesn't have the monopoly on recovery. The way I read it is that there are other options.

Early in the thread some told us that AA said "AA is the only way", we have yet to see any actual evidence of this in their website or literature, in fact what has been produced is precisely the opposite.

Yep we've had the usual religious conversion stories from people who are swearing their organization isn't religious.

Who here has claimed "religious conversion"?
I think you are mixing sobriety and religion up, or are thinking of another thread.
If not, please show us who?

I also did that. Was a hardcore pot smoker for 15 years. New boyfriend said if you want to move in need to stop smoking. I did and have not smoked since 2005.

I know many smokers too who have smoked cigarettes for a long time and just quit cold turkey without assistance. Same with heavy drinkers. It was "no skin off their nose" to do so. Most addicts and alcoholics need more.

I know many addicts and alcoholics to who tried different things for many many years all to no avail. Some things help some people, others don't.

There is no one cure, AA is just part of the makeup of what's on offer in society today.
 
I know many smokers too who have smoked cigarettes for a long time and just quit cold turkey without assistance. Same with heavy drinkers. It was "no skin off their nose" to do so. Most addicts and alcoholics need more.

I know many addicts and alcoholics to who tried different things for many many years all to no avail. Some things help some people, others don't.

There is no one cure, AA is just part of the makeup of what's on offer in society today.

I got stuck going to AA/NA many years ago for huffing. I was only 13. What I found from AA and rehab was....

1 there was better drugs then sniffing paint smoked my first joint with someone I met in rehab

2 (going to women's meetings) Men drive you to drink/smoke ect

3 even tho at the time I had never drank booze I had to be a drunk because it goes hand and hand. (drinking and drugs)

When asked at a metting what got me to use they would give me stupid looks when I said I did. I saw others do it I tried it no peer pressure. I was even point blank asked by one of the women was it a guy I tried it the first time with. When I said nope I was alone I got another "look"

I am also the one who asked to go to rehab. I was having bad stomach pains from using and told my granddad that I guess I should go to rehab.
I was also treated like a moron for being in rehab for only huffing. All the crackheads would tease me. They would set there when it was free time and ask have you tried drug xyz? Everytime I would say nope they would set and giggle to each other about how lame I was.

I am now 33 years old and you could not pay me to drink I dislike the taste and the buzz. So I think all them old bats 20 years ago had no clue what they was talking about. I am no drunk.

They also prayed at the meetings. I went to 5 different groups.
Back then they used to auto put you into probation at the JDC when you got out of rehab. Putting yourself into it or not. I had one lady say she was not going to sign my card because I was reading a MAD mag BEFORE the meeting started. I would have got stuck in lockdown at the JDC for that. I needed so many cards a week and was told what meeting I had to go to.
By the grace of my granddad making a fuss I got it signed.
 
Last edited:
Dynamic said:
You obviously don't think much of the quote I just provided from page 27 of the 12&12 which refutes that claim.

Anyone can cherry pick one or two quotes to argue their claim, you might even believe the claim. I spent years going over these chapters. Anyone who reads your quote in context will be wholly unconvinced. It doesn't refute the claim in any form, merely states that "the group" can be used as a gateway to a real "higher power". It goes further with the "knowledge is dumb" sentiment.

But there are two separate issues here. One is that a higher power is vital to working the steps. The other is that AA teaches that working the steps is any alcoholic's only hope to quit. I don't agree with either of those...

You don't have to--that doesn't change the program's philosophy or message.

just try to practice the rest of the program as enthusiatically as possible

Right, the program demands rigorous honesty and "thoroughly following their path" to get sober, but it's OK to "fake it until you make it". Absurd. The usual result of this is a dry drunk.

AAAlfie said:
Early in the thread some told us that AA said "AA is the only way", we have yet to see any actual evidence of this in their website or literature...

How about member testimonals, like, oh, I don't know...

AAAlfie said:
And that is their truth.
Some of us tried many things before AA, that might include:
counsellors, psychiatrists, psychologists, priests, barmen, family, friends, self-will, will power, reducing, experimentation, hypnotherapy, detoxes, rehabs, moving towns, changing friends, different social and sporting clubs etc etc.

Nothing worked, AA did - for them.

It comes straight from the Big Book: "Here are some of the methods we have tried: Drinking beer only, limiting the number of drinks, never drinking alone, never drinking in the morning, drinking only at home, never having it in the house, never drinking during business hours, drinking only at parties, switching from scotch to brandy, drinking only natural wines, agreeing to resign if ever drunk on the job, taking a trip, not taking a trip, swearing off forever (with and without a solemn oath), taking more physical exercise, reading inspirational books, going to health farms and sanitariums, accepting voluntary commitment to asylums--we could increase the list ad inifinitum (pg 31)".

Group think at it's finest. :rolleyes:

The program would be better served if it attempted to distinguish the problem drinkers from the alcoholic. In fact, the Big Book says just this.
 
Last edited:
They also prayed at the meetings. I went to 5 different groups.
Back then they used to auto put you into probation at the JDC when you got out of rehab. Putting yourself into it or not. I had one lady say she was not going to sign my card because I was reading a MAD mag BEFORE the meeting started. I would have got stuck in lockdown at the JDC for that. I needed so many cards a week and was told what meeting I had to go to.
By the grace of my granddad making a fuss I got it signed.

Every AA meeting I ever went to had praying in it. I went to several hundred meetings in four different states during the two years I was involved with AA and every single meeting had praying.

In every one of those meetings if my head wasn't bowed in prayer with everyone else's then the meetings would ALWAYS turn into a "getting me right with God and my sobriety" meeting.

No matter what book says this or what words in the book really mean that talk that has been going on in this very long thread.
No can tell me AA is not a religious organization because I lived it and seen it in action.
 
I went to several hundred meetings in four different states during the two years I was involved with AA and every single meeting had praying.
Every session of the US Congress also opens with a prayer. Does that make Congress a religious organization?

In every one of those meetings if my head wasn't bowed in prayer with everyone else's then the meetings would ALWAYS turn into a "getting me right with God and my sobriety" meeting.
One wonders how they'd know.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom