Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know, I'm getting slightly tired of people who think that others who don't understand them are doing it on purpose. You're either too cynical, or ignorant of the ways of the world.
Or maybe I've overestimated you. You did take the time to read my previous posts along that line of discussion, right? Suppose we back up to here:
It's nothing but patterns of flickering light on the surface of a two-dimensional screen, and you know that, but it doesn't prevent you from becoming completely immersed in a particularly gripping drama -- and when that happens, there are measurable physiological responses.
I assumed that you did read that, because you responded:
No it isn't. "Immersion" doesn't mean "belief".
To which I answered:
I disagree. "Immersion" requires belief. I'll state it more strongly than that. "Immersion" means belief, for some values of "belief".
I suppose I might have realized that you were lost when you then accused me of moving the goalposts:
Your claim was that immersion was belief, not emotional response.
I thought the reference to "measurable physiological responses" would have made it clear enough that I was talking about emotional responses. In case it still isn't clear enough, I'll add that there is a reason that I have (several times now, I think) referred to "thinking/feeling". I've slashed those together to indicate that my position is that making a clear distinction between thought and emotion is difficult at best and impossible (if not entirely meaningless) at worst. It looks like this may be one of the few things GB and I agree on.


Defining addiction has no bearing on a thread about alcoholism ? News to me.
Well, here's another news flash: This isn't a thread about addiction (or even alcoholism). Have another look at the OP. Unless you can show some reason why those tangents should not be considered entirely off-topic, then, having already made my position on those issues clear, I will continue to feel no obligation to revisit them.
 
Here is an excellent article on why "letting go and letting God" is not always the best course of action. http://www.morerevealed.com/aadep/reclaim/forgiveness.html

I forgive the web designer for that yellow background, despite the assault on my eyes, which are still recovering. ;)

But seriously, it's the same argument I've made against religious people who suggest the benefits of forgiving others. To me, forgiving means giving up and deciding it's okay to be a victim, a bad thing. "Resentment" (not the word I'd use, but the idea of "not forgiving") is a positive force for change and justice.

I tend to combine "not forgiving" with, ironically, the philosophy behind the serenity prayer. There's no point is wasting energy trying to get revenge in ways that can't be accomplished or only make things worse. Instead, I'd rather concentrate effort on things that will either get justice, like punishing the perpetrator or getting reparations, or that will prevent future injustice, which seem the positive side of "not forgiving," like Mrs. Jones in the article.

That's kinda off topic, but relevant in the sense that it's the same disagreement I have with religions and apparently, if I needed AA, I'd have the same disagreement with that recommendation from them (I know, I know, it's just a suggestion, you don't have to, etc...)
 
I thought the reference to "measurable physiological responses" would have made it clear enough that I was talking about emotional responses.

Immersion is not belief, period. We call it "suspension of disbelief" for lack of better words, but it doesn't mean you start believing that the movie is true. You're clearly grasping at straws, here.
 
I forgive the web designer for that yellow background, despite the assault on my eyes, which are still recovering. ;)

Seriously, I thought everybody understood, back in 1998, that any color except white -- and maybe black -- was unacceptable as a background for web pages.
 
Immersion is not belief, period.
Appending a naked assertion with a "period" is neither a substitute for providing actual arguments nor an excuse for failing to do so.

We call it "suspension of disbelief" for lack of better words, but it doesn't mean you start believing that the movie is true. You're clearly grasping at straws, here.
It's nothing different from what I've been arguing all along. If it seems like grasping at straws to you, that's probably only because you weren't able to follow. Maybe I should just consider myself lucky that you finally seem to at least understand what I'm saying, whether you agree with it or not.

Yes, "suspension of disbelief". Interesting phrase, no? I submit that what that refers to is a surrendering of the cerebral (which does indeed recognize the illusory nature of the experience) to the visceral (which does not; hence, the physiological response). Render unto the visceral that which belongs to the visceral. I first introduced this example 26 pages ago:
In the movie "Castaway", Tom Hanks' character invented Wilson and imparted to his new companion some of his own humanity. He wasn't actually losing his mind. He didn't really believe Wilson was alive.
But, I will argue, on some level -- that is, on a visceral (or, if you prefer, emotional) level -- he DID belive it; or the trick would not have worked.
 
Appending a naked assertion with a "period" is neither a substitute for providing actual arguments nor an excuse for failing to do so.

You're the one making a claim, here. That when you're "immersed" in a movie, you actually believe what's happening. Your burden.

Maybe I should just consider myself lucky that you finally seem to at least understand what I'm saying, whether you agree with it or not.

So, now you're saying that immersion is NOT belief ? So why did you object to my "naked assertion", then ?

Yes, "suspension of disbelief". Interesting phrase, no? I submit that what that refers to is a surrendering of the cerebral (which does indeed recognize the illusory nature of the experience) to the visceral (which does not; hence, the physiological response).

Psycho-babbling crap. "I love her with all my heart" uses the word "heart" but doesn't mean that it's the organ doing the loving. "Suspension of disbelief" simply means that the illusion is convincing, not that you somehow forget that the movie isn't reality.
 
Your burden.
If you disagree, then explaining why you disagree is your burden.

So, now you're saying that immersion is NOT belief ?
Okay, I was wrong. You don't understand what I'm saying.

"I love her with all my heart" uses the word "heart" but doesn't mean that it's the organ doing the loving.
Doesn't automatically mean that it resides entirely in the brain, either. (You may have to think that over a while in order to understand what I'm saying; take your time).

"Suspension of disbelief" simply means that the illusion is convincing, not that you somehow forget that the movie isn't reality.
Convincing. Another interesting word. Would you perhaps be willing to agree that on some level you are "convinced"?
 
Are you ever going to provide evidence to back up your assertions Dymanic?

It's what we demand on every other thread challenging religious believers, why should AA believers be held to a different standard?

Too boot, when you argue for the "suspension of disbelief", you are just making a case FOR the Religiosity of AA and why it might be effective, so that really isn't an effective tactic on your part. Though it's true I do agree with you that thoughts and feelings are inextricably linked, it's difficult to see how this helps your case, and I think it's debatable just how "external" reality, sensory input, emotional reactions, the Imagination, and the intellectual process all interact to "create" our consciousness. I have certain leanings as I expressed in my discussion with DD, but the empirical data available thus far can be interpreted in any number of ways.

Not only that, but by employing this argument you contradict your own point that discussing tangential points such addiction and the effectiveness of certain "recovery techniques" is entirely off-topic. It's not my preferred choice to spend a lot of time on the tangential aspects of this discussion, but they are apparently relevant enough for you to discuss, and so it should be for others when they choose to respond.

It may indeed be the case (as Dick B believes) that fully accepting the Religious (especially the Christian) Nature of AA would be the way get the most benefit out of AA. In which case non-theists who wish to get the most benefit from AA might as well convert to the religion of their choice (at least to benefit from the slightly "Universalized" version of AA). If "suspending disbelief" is the best way to benefit from AA (which you seem to be suggesting, and I don't disagree in principle), then why settle for half measures? Commit to Belief/Faith!

Despite my opposition to a Religious Organization's tenets holding sway over the socio-political realm, I am not at all opposed to people following their Faith.

GB
 
Last edited:
Are you ever going to provide evidence to back up your assertions Dymanic?
What, you don't find my fudge recipe sufficient as evidence that your above logic is flawed?

It's what we demand on every other thread challenging religious believers, why should AA believers be held to a different standard?
Other than my having argued that AA is not religious, what evidence can you present that supports your indictment of me as an "AA believer"?

Too boot, when you argue for the "suspension of disbelief", you are just making a case FOR the Religiosity of AA and why it might be effective, so that really isn't an effective tactic on your part.
I submit that suspension of disbelief is not inherently religious in nature. "Wilson" was not a religious icon (though it's not a very long walk, I will readily admit). He was just an imaginary companion. There is nothing to suggest that Tom Hanks' character (Chuck Noland) was either crazy or particularly prone to flights of fancy -- in fact, he was a methodical, time-obsessed, systems analyst -- and, had Wilson not been lost at sea, it seems very unlikely that Noland would have continued to have lengthy conversations with him once he no longer needed to do so in order to maintain his sanity. I further submit that in creating Wilson, Noland was acting in as rational a manner as is possible for a human to act. Our capacity for pretending and imagining is arguably the source of our intellect; it is its nature. To refuse to acknowledge that is every bit as pathological as an inability to distinguish between fantasy and reality. It IS a failure to distinguish between fantasy and reality.

Not only that, but by employing this argument you contradict your own point that discussing tangential points such addiction and the effectiveness of certain "recovery techniques" is entirely off-topic.
The question is not whether a given individual (or group of individuals) finds the use of a symbol to be effective in dealing with his (their) own irrational patterns of thinking/feeling. The question is whether AA affirmatively obligates the individual to that, and limits the individual to the use of a particular symbol; say, the "God" of the Christian Bible -- you know, the way religions do. You say yes, I say no. Another 40 pages won't change that. We're probably lucky to have found even one thing we can agree on: that thoughts and feelings are inextricably linked.

If "suspending disbelief" is the best way to benefit from AA (which you seem to be suggesting, and I don't disagree in principle), then why settle for half measures?
Why should any individual settle for someone else's symbol? Would that not be the half measure?
 
I submit that suspension of disbelief is not inherently religious in nature. "Wilson" was not a religious icon (though it's not a very long walk, I will readily admit). He was just an imaginary companion. There is nothing to suggest that Tom Hanks' character (Chuck Noland) was either crazy or particularly prone to flights of fancy -- in fact, he was a methodical, time-obsessed, systems analyst -- and, had Wilson not been lost at sea, it seems very unlikely that Noland would have continued to have lengthy conversations with him once he no longer needed to do so in order to maintain his sanity. I further submit that in creating Wilson, Noland was acting in as rational a manner as is possible for a human to act. Our capacity for pretending and imagining is arguably the source of our intellect; it is its nature. To refuse to acknowledge that is every bit as pathological as an inability to distinguish between fantasy and reality. It IS a failure to distinguish between fantasy and reality.

The question is not whether a given individual (or group of individuals) finds the use of a symbol to be effective in dealing with his (their) own irrational patterns of thinking/feeling. The question is whether AA affirmatively obligates the individual to that, and limits the individual to the use of a particular symbol; say, the "God" of the Christian Bible -- you know, the way religions do. You say yes, I say no. Another 40 pages won't change that. We're probably lucky to have found even one thing we can agree on: that thoughts and feelings are inextricably linked.

Why should any individual settle for someone else's symbol? Would that not be the half measure?


(Emphasis mine)

So, to continue the "Wilson" to AA's God analogy, when then do the AAers leave God behind once they've reached sanity? In other words, you've suggested that rational people sometimes do irrational things to remain sane (MacBeth, anyone?). My understanding is that you're saying (and please correct me if I'm wrong) that many alcoholics that have issues with spirituality or God should believe in a power greater than themselves for the purposes of regaining sanity.

Also, to anyone who considers themselves atheist and/or who argue of the non-religiosity of AA, how do you reconcile the 2nd tradition which states:

2.—For our group purpose there is but one ultimate authority—a loving God as He may express Himself in our group conscience.

Doesn't seem to leave too much wiggle room to what they're specifically referring.




Are you ever going to provide evidence to back up your assertions Dymanic?

It's what we demand on every other thread challenging religious believers, why should AA believers be held to a different standard?

Too boot, when you argue for the "suspension of disbelief", you are just making a case FOR the Religiosity of AA and why it might be effective, so that really isn't an effective tactic on your part. Though it's true I do agree with you that thoughts and feelings are inextricably linked, it's difficult to see how this helps your case, and I think it's debatable just how "external" reality, sensory input, emotional reactions, the Imagination, and the intellectual process all interact to "create" our consciousness. I have certain leanings as I expressed in my discussion with DD, but the empirical data available thus far can be interpreted in any number of ways.

Not only that, but by employing this argument you contradict your own point that discussing tangential points such addiction and the effectiveness of certain "recovery techniques" is entirely off-topic. It's not my preferred choice to spend a lot of time on the tangential aspects of this discussion, but they are apparently relevant enough for you to discuss, and so it should be for others when they choose to respond.

It may indeed be the case (as Dick B believes) that fully accepting the Religious (especially the Christian) Nature of AA would be the way get the most benefit out of AA. In which case non-theists who wish to get the most benefit from AA might as well convert to the religion of their choice (at least to benefit from the slightly "Universalized" version of AA). If "suspending disbelief" is the best way to benefit from AA (which you seem to be suggesting, and I don't disagree in principle), then why settle for half measures? Commit to Belief/Faith!

Despite my opposition to a Religious Organization's tenets holding sway over the socio-political realm, I am not at all opposed to people following their Faith.

GB


Well said.




I forgive the web designer for that yellow background, despite the assault on my eyes, which are still recovering. ;)

But seriously, it's the same argument I've made against religious people who suggest the benefits of forgiving others. To me, forgiving means giving up and deciding it's okay to be a victim, a bad thing. "Resentment" (not the word I'd use, but the idea of "not forgiving") is a positive force for change and justice.

I tend to combine "not forgiving" with, ironically, the philosophy behind the serenity prayer. There's no point is wasting energy trying to get revenge in ways that can't be accomplished or only make things worse. Instead, I'd rather concentrate effort on things that will either get justice, like punishing the perpetrator or getting reparations, or that will prevent future injustice, which seem the positive side of "not forgiving," like Mrs. Jones in the article.

That's kinda off topic, but relevant in the sense that it's the same disagreement I have with religions and apparently, if I needed AA, I'd have the same disagreement with that recommendation from them (I know, I know, it's just a suggestion, you don't have to, etc...)


Meh. I read that page and I found the author to be seriously missing several points on the steps, forgiveness, and acceptance. Lots of strawman arguments as well, attributing certain beliefs to AA members which are not terribly accurate, especially of the group as a whole.
 
You're arguing that because the 12 steps do not explicitly preclude the possibility that an alcoholic might quit drinking without the help of a higher power, that omission constitutes an affirmative declaration that such a thing is not possible.

What omission? It is clearly stated in AA literature. These passages have been quoted over and over in this thread. You are cherry picking to suit your flawed premise.

Furthermore, it is clearly a philosophy within the groups. Again with my "weaselly words"--it's plain to anyone who has attended meetings.
 
Last edited:
What omission? It is clearly stated in AA literature.
That the alcoholic's only hope of quitting is through the 12 steps? I continue to dispute that, and I challenge you to provide even one passage from AA literature which explicitly says any such thing. While you're working on that, I'll offer a quote from AA literature which clearly states precisely the opposite:
So far, upon the total problem of actual potential alcoholics in the world, we have made only a scratch. In all probability, we shall never be able to touch more than a fair fraction of the alcohol problem in all its ramifications. Upon therapy for the alcoholic himself, we surely have no monopoly. Yet it is our great hope that all those who have as yet found no answer may begin to find one in the pages of this book and will presently join us on the highroad to a new freedom.
- Foreword to the second addition of the "Big Book".

If you feel, as GB does, that that claim IS contained in the steps, by all means, please do post them again just in case anyone missed them the first five hundred times. On the other hand, if you'd prefer to just stick with the bit about it being an implication, one which is "plain to anyone who has attended meetings", then I will stipulate (as one who has attended thousands of them) that there certainly are AA members who would subscribe to that viewpoint. It is possible (easy, in fact) to find AA members adhering to a wide range of bizzare and quite mistaken notions.
 
from the horses mouth- AA & religion

That the alcoholic's only hope of quitting is through the 12 steps? I continue to dispute that, and I challenge you to provide even one passage from AA literature which explicitly says any such thing. While you're working on that, I'll offer a quote from AA literature which clearly states precisely the opposite:
- Foreword to the second addition of the "Big Book".

If you feel, as GB does, that that claim IS contained in the steps, by all means, please do post them again just in case anyone missed them the first five hundred times. On the other hand, if you'd prefer to just stick with the bit about it being an implication, one which is "plain to anyone who has attended meetings", then I will stipulate (as one who has attended thousands of them) that there certainly are AA members who would subscribe to that viewpoint. It is possible (easy, in fact) to find AA members adhering to a wide range of bizzare and quite mistaken notions.

Hot news - The original big-book manuscript with marginalia and notes
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_fea_lifestyles_aa_s_big_book
Some of the edits made it into print, especially in early chapters for fragile readers. Many others were rejected as the still-anonymous personalities behind the notes fretted over how to handle God and religion, a Higher Power "bigger than ourselves" and the influence of the Oxford Group, a religious movement embraced by Wilson and his fellow founder, Ohio physician Bob Smith, but later considered a preachy hindrance in working with problem drinkers.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_fea_l...m for the treatment program Hazelden.[/quote]
 
Furthermore, it is clearly a philosophy within the groups. Again with my "weaselly words"--it's plain to anyone who has attended meetings.

shawmutt is correct. I quit drinking alcohol a little over 20 years ago.
Drinking alcohol for me in that time has become a non thing.
The same as not drinking soda pop after many years of doing so.
It's just something I don't do and because I don't do it I never give it a thought.

However the first 2 years of not drinking alcohol (the word sobriety is simply part of controlling word games) was a very very difficult time for me.

I went to AA for almost 2 years. I have never had any religious beliefs.
When I first started going to AA I wanted very badly what they said they could give me.

First they told me I was powerless and that the first step was to admit that.
Then they told me the only way the program would work was if I chose a higher power to turn over my problems to. Let go and let God.

I really wanted to quit drinking alcohol and using drugs so I wanted to do everything and anything they said so they could solve my problems for me. I'm powerless remember.
So I started going to different churches to find the religion that would help me get my life together.
Needless to say of all the many churches I went to none of them made any sense to me whatsoever.
This made me feel very bad and very much like a failure.
I mean, why didn't this God want me to be good and happy and perfect like everyone else was.

After almost 2 years of this turmoil and trying to follow their plan my boss said a few things to me that were so simple I couldn't believe I had never thought of it before. These simple ideas are of course NOT part of the AA plan because if it was then their would be no AA.

First off everyone is just as screwed up as I am and everyone is struggling to maintain. No matter how rich, famous or beautiful they are.
Also if I had no power then how could I have started all this to begin with.
I would simply drink myself to death if I were truly powerless as I had been trained to think. AA would have came to me NOT the other way around if I were powerless.
I alone control what I think, feel or do in any situation.

So after hearing this I'm sitting in a meeting and a guy talking says to the group "I have been coming to AA for 20 years and I know if I EVER miss a meeting I will be right back to drinking again!"

I stood up and walked out and never looked back.

I had a strong desire to change my life, BUT I had no desire to trade my old controlling crap for someone else's new controlling crap.

AA uses religion to control the masses like every other church or religious organization does!
 
So, to continue the "Wilson" to AA's God analogy, when then do the AAers leave God behind once they've reached sanity?
Since there isn't any such thing as an "AA's God", I guess the answer to your question is that it would depend on just what they started out with.

My understanding is that you're saying (and please correct me if I'm wrong) that many alcoholics that have issues with spirituality or God should believe in a power greater than themselves for the purposes of regaining sanity.
That seems a bit garbled. I'd say the presumption is that the alcoholic who arrives in AA (under his own volition, anyway) does so because has done a poor job of managing his own sanity (which is what drinking is, for the alcoholic: an attempt to manage his own mental/emotional health). The very act of seeking help is an implicit acknowledgement of that, and regardless of whether it is what he "should" do, it is in itself a crude form of believing that he can be restored to sanity by a power greater than himself.

For the alcoholic who "has issues with spirituality or God" (and who perhaps suffers from the same rigidity in thinking that has some posters in this thread insisting that "spirituality", "higher power", and "God" can only refer to the same thing: the God of the Christian Bible) the advice is to "practice the rest of the program as enthusiastically as possible".
(Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, page 27).

Also, to anyone who considers themselves atheist and/or who argue of the non-religiosity of AA, how do you reconcile the 2nd tradition which states:

2.—For our group purpose there is but one ultimate authority—a loving God as He may express Himself in our group conscience.

Doesn't seem to leave too much wiggle room to what they're specifically referring.
We've been playing whack-a-mole with that one since very early in the thread. Without any wiggling around, what that specifically refers to is resolution of group matters by majority vote (most often a simple show of hands).
 
If you disagree, then explaining why you disagree is your burden.

I already have. Now I'm waiting for your evidence.

Okay, I was wrong. You don't understand what I'm saying.

Gee, you're such a polite debater.

Perhaps you should stop moving the goalposts and actually state what you think clearly if you want me to understand you.

Doesn't automatically mean that it resides entirely in the brain, either.

Irrelevant.

Convincing. Another interesting word. Would you perhaps be willing to agree that on some level you are "convinced"?

Is there ANYTHING you have except semantics games ?
 
That the alcoholic's only hope of quitting is through the 12 steps?

No, that the alcoholic needs to use a higher power to work the twelve steps or will fail. There are too many quotes to type out in the Big Book, 12 Steps and 12 Traditions, pamphlets, Daily Reflections, etc. etc., but if you insist I'll have a stab at it.

As far as AA being the only way, this thread itself is chock full of testimonials from a few people about AA being the only way for them.
 
No, that the alcoholic needs to use a higher power to work the twelve steps or will fail. There are too many quotes to type out in the Big Book, 12 Steps and 12 Traditions, pamphlets, Daily Reflections, etc. etc., but if you insist I'll have a stab at it.

It actually says the opposite a number of times. Others (Tinyal and GB I think) said earlier in the thread that the AA website is full of these quotes that "AA is the only way" or similar. As yet, we have yet to see them (unless GB has raised them - I wouldn't know cos he's on ignore - that said, he couldn't cos they're not there).

As far as AA being the only way, this thread itself is chock full of testimonials from a few people about AA being the only way for them.

And that is their truth.
Some of us tried many things before AA, that might include:
counsellors, psychiatrists, psychologists, priests, barmen, family, friends, self-will, will power, reducing, experimentation, hypnotherapy, detoxes, rehabs, moving towns, changing friends, different social and sporting clubs etc etc.

Nothing worked, AA did - for them.
 
Last edited:
That the alcoholic's only hope of quitting is through the 12 steps? I continue to dispute that, and I challenge you to provide even one passage from AA literature which explicitly says any such thing. While you're working on that, I'll offer a quote from AA literature which clearly states precisely the opposite:

Quote:
So far, upon the total problem of actual potential alcoholics in the world, we have made only a scratch. In all probability, we shall never be able to touch more than a fair fraction of the alcohol problem in all its ramifications. Upon therapy for the alcoholic himself, we surely have no monopoly. Yet it is our great hope that all those who have as yet found no answer may begin to find one in the pages of this book and will presently join us on the highroad to a new freedom.


- Foreword to the second addition of the "Big Book".

I don't see that the quote clearly states that the other methods work. In fact, it could be stating just the opposite: There are lots of therapies to cure alcoholism, but since none of the others provide the answer, join us.

To "clearly state precisely the opposite" it would need to state that those other therapies do work for at least some people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom