Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The broadest possible, so you are saying that there are events of sensation, perception and consciousness that are not brain based? Seriously, tell me which those would be and at which point they are not based in brain events? :)

Oh really?
So just tell me, which aspect of human behavior does not involve the intersection and basis in brain events? :)

Really... try it on, tell me how even one effects your behavior. :)

Some of your statements require a more direct response. As the above are all restatements of the same question I will answer with a segment I have already posted but seems to not have sunk in.

...coping with personal Financial Problems, coping with abuse, coping with living in an oppressed population group, coping with living in a highly demanding society that forces most people to work for less and less and being put out of work and out of house by Fat Cats who control and destroy economies, coping with living in a War Zone...etc, etc.).

First, I never said that behaviour didn't involve an "intersection in brain events." Quite the opposite in fact. I did however question that behaviour always has a "BASIS" in brain events.

The Brain is simply responding to "external" stimuli. And much of behaviour has as much basis in that "external" stimuli as it does in the brain. The above examples are just a few of many empirical "external" factors that modify our behaviour.

Numerous experiments in Propaganda and Behaviour Modification have empirically demonstrated that Behaviour can be modified and manipulated by "external" events. From Edward Bernays, to Ewen Cameron, and many others, in many experiments and studies, many quite unethical and illegal involving techniques we might consider Torture, have demonstrated beyond all doubt that our brains don't merely form the "basis" of our reality or behaviour, but in fact respond to stimuli which in turn can alter our behaviour.

In fact Cognitive Therapy is nothing if not a means to manipulate our brains to generate new behaviour patterns. This in essence is placing the "basis" for some behaviour patterns COMPLETELY "OUTSIDE" our bag of skin which does not separate us from the "external" world, but connects us to it.

However, because in fact our brains DO have some strong intrinsic patterns, it can take extreme events to significantly alter those patterns. Some of those extreme events I have listed several times already. Experiencing Traumatic events: Earthquakes, Hurricanes, Homelessness, Poverty, Dislocation, Rape, War, Torture and others, also can significantly alter behaviour.

So it's no surprise that milquetoast approaches to changing behaviour rarely are particularly effective except in the most susceptible people. Something Military Tyrants and Religious Leaders have known for thousands of years.

Many techniques range from simple indoctrination on a regular basis, hypnosis, altering the brain through the introduction of chemicals, deprivation of sleep and food, repetitive music, regular exercise regimens, all the way to outright torture and Terrorism.

Some of these techniques are benign enough that an individual can use them him or herself to achieve the desired state of consciousness and the resultant behaviour patterns. Others are used to create behaviour patterns in people that make them more conducive to authoritarian control.

So I really don't think that there is any empirical basis to claim that the Brain, in and of itself, is the only "basis" for behaviour. I can only meet you halfway on the proposition that behaviour is dependent on "brain processes."

I am not stating "brain events in isolation of a brain," I am stating that brain events are NOT in isolation from "Outside" events.

If anything, my views tend more towards monism than yours appear to at face value, but I think that may just be due to semantic issues. I expect if you consider more closely what I am saying, you will find that we are more in agreement than not.

So perhaps in examining the various effectiveness of certain techniques of Behaviour Modification, we can determine what sorts of techniques can help to "break" the various forms of "addictive" patterns of behaviour.

GB
 
No, other evidence has been produced since the beginning of the threas that you have ignored. :)

You mean Tinyal's and other's "5%" figure ? Or do you have some numbers of your own ?

Belz: AA should change its language
AAA: Why?
Belz: To be more inclusive to atheists
AAA: Anyone can join you know, and there aren't any rules around an HP.
Belz: BS!
AAA: Meh
Belz: It doesn't work anyway.
AAA: Why then do you want it to be more inclusive?
Belz: One has nothing to do with the other, so your question is meaningless
AAA: LOL!

Indeed. Making it more inclusive has nothing to do with its efficacy. I can't say I'm surprised that you didn't understand that, however.
 
State of the art today? No. At the time behavior mod was part of therapies involved.

I don't intend to start drinking again to discover if cbt can make me a social drinker.

http://www.springerlink.com/content/t8p75175l120574l/


Whatever floats your boat I guess. Sounds like just the ticket for atheists who can't identify any power higher than their ego (so to speak) and have lots of time and money. I hazard a guess that alcoholism is the last thing that would be a topic. Which also fits right in with posters here who have no idea what later stage alcoholism entails.

Are you feeling better yet?
So thanks for answering the question, the therapies you dismissed were not CBT or RET.

Assume away.
 
DD, I think you're missing the forest for the trees, or the arguments for the semantics. I'm not disagreeing in principle with you, just pointing out that the mind/body connection doesn't end at the surface of our bag of skin.
Sure it does, we don't sense magnetism the way some birds might, ye we are part of the universe and no our bodies end at the skin.
Our senses and our molecules connect us to the Universe at large. Many things affect our biology and neurology which aren't in themselves bio-neurological. I don't see how any Empiricist can deny that.
i asked you, and you could answer, like what?
i have a reason for asking.

So what is it that you think effects you. Or more specifically your behavior?
So my question back at you is, if you aren't a Dualist, then are you a Monist?
Objective monist, I am some form of natural phenomenologist, I can't remember the exact distinction.
[/quote]

Perhaps you'll see that it's not really a fair question, because Monism, like Dualism is simply a philosophical model that has its advantages, yet like all philosophical models cannot completely explain all phenomenon. Philosophical models are only useful up to a certain point by themselves, and tend to work best in a dialectic with other philosophical models.
[/quote]
As stated i believe dualism is incoherent.
To be a Die Hard in any particular model constrains one from seeing the "thing in itself", free of dogmatic conceptualizations.
I believe blanket statements are errors, so what exists in human reality that does not fall into behaviorism?
So my other question to you, is how can you call yourself a "Hard Knock Behaviourist" without recognizing that Behaviourism is a philosophy of Psychology that is divorced from Neurology? This appears to be a contradiction of terms.
Um, it is all based upon neurology eventually, I am not a radical behaviorist but a pragmatic methodologist.
Again, I am not strictly opposed to Behaviourism, though I think some of its propositions are not empirically sound.
Not, it is solely based upon observable phenomena, the validity of self report is another issue.
To a certain extent it is useful. But like all Philosophical models it runs into inconsistencies, sometimes internally within the model and sometimes when it runs up against aspects of reality better explained by other models.
It explains human reality quite well, it does not explain QM or Newtonian mechanics.

So what do you think it doesn't explain in human reality?
Not to mention that Behaviourists like Skinner have shifted their own views or goalposts about what constitutes behaviourism.
So, chemistry is not what Levosier developed either, there are internal behavior and behaviors that are 'avolitional' they are still behaviors.
Some of his earlier work seems a bit "dualistic" if you ask me. Though I find that some of his ideas seem to match my own:



Now that's a model of "Behaviourism" that sounds remarkably like my post which you are picking apart.
Behaviorism is now like 50+ years old and I am not Skinner,
Though I'm not certain that at this point, Skinner's model can really be called Behaviourism. He seems to have adopted an approach that isn't attached to any one model, and instead employs a number of models that intersect to describe a more complex reality than which a "Hard Knock Behaviourist" might follow.
I know, it is still behaviorism.
I really hate to be so side-tracked by such a Red Herring in the discussion of the Religiosity of AA. Though I find discussing this with you far more interesting than Dymanic's specious, and disingenuous sophistry.

I like your straightforwardness and your honesty, even though I am beginning to realize that some of your own definitions seem to me internally inconsistent.
Ask away.
You have stated that you believe that anyone can change their behaviour, which is compatible with the classic definition of Behaviourism, but this seems incompatible with behaviour that is determined by Neurological Disorders, and Biological Predisposition.
I did not make any blankets statements, CBT is not going to be as effective in certain areas.
As I stated in a previous post, I believe people with such problems have little to no chance of actually changing their behaviours without some sort of Physical Mechanism involved.
Um, if you missed it, 'behaviors and CBT involve a physical mechanism, I also believe in co current treatment.
In this sense, I agree with some in the recovery movement that at least some people are not at all able to exercise will to control their addictive behaviours.
Which is why they have to choose other things to modify, once you are in the liquor store it is too late.
However, these people have NO chance of being helped by a Recovery Support Group, religious or otherwise. Only some sort of chemical intervention is likely to help them.
Really depends, I am not for single mode of treatment as stated way early in the thread.
You have also stated categorically that your adherence to a "Behaviourist" Model means you don't believe that the "Disease" Model has any validity at all.
From my POV and definition, no.
While I essentially agree that the Disease Model of Addiction isn't Generally Useful, I do not necessarily agree with you in the case of those "addictions" which are clearly rooted in Neurological Disorders.
Not really, but you would have to be specific, I have know many to self medicate bipolar with alcohol, so the basis is an imbalance in the neural network for the bipolar.
Biological Predisposition is another matter, as it is not necessarily a Disorder per se. Perhaps Cognitive therapy can be beneficial in helping those predisposed to addictive behaviour patterns manage their addictions at a moderate level, if not help them quit altogether.
I never said it was a silver bullet either.
As to some of the OTHER "triggers" for compulsive behaviour, I might agree with you that Psychological Behaviourist approaches such as Cognitive Therapy could be beneficial, though it would depend on a number of factors; including how much the compulsive behaviour has already disaffected the chemistry of the brain. In which case someone may be too far gone for Cognitive Therapy to work and chemical intervention necessary.
yes and no, co current treatment.
It would also depend on all the social environment factors, and whether or not a persons usage has actually become "compulsive" or is an expression of a need to cope with negative situational life circumstances. In the latter case, the regular usage of a drug of their choice may even be beneficial, and many people in situational circumstances are able to move back into moderate usage patterns entirely on their own if their circumstances change for the better.
I do not believe in redrinking or moderation for addicts, when they are abusers that is separate but as stated I agree with Jack Trimpey, abstinence from your primary is teh big choice.
If they cannot shift back on their own under improved circumstances, it may be that a combined approach of chemical intervention and cognitive therapy would be the most beneficial. And for some, support groups, religious and secular, might also help a bit.
As stated redrinking is not a strategy I agree with in addicts.
And yes, for some people, no matter the actual cause of their "addiction," completely quitting may be the only solution once their pattern has been broken. But I certainly don't believe this to be the case for all so-called "addicts."
I think it is the goal sate.

More later.
Now that I have explained more fully my view of things, it should be clear to you why I think any one particular approach, any "one size fits all" model is untenable, and why I think there is little hope for successfully treating "Addiction" in the current socio-political climate (imposed by Addiction Ideology) that even affects our Medical systems.

I do not dismiss out of hand any particular Model of addiction excepting the Sin Model that AA promotes disguised as a "Disease" Model.

And the Disease Model itself I find dubious in its application across the board to all forms of "addiction", though it may be appropriate for those with a Neurological Disorder based Addiction. The Behaviorist Model actually gives me pause too, largely because it assumes that Behaviour is the Problem (much like the Sin Model) rather than a symptom; though I do think Cognitive Therapy can be quite beneficial.

So please don't be so quick to use the snarky and disingenuous gotcha debate tactics employed by the AA proselytizers (attempted but failed) against myself and others.
I withdrawal all the smiley faces in my former post.
:id:

:D
Save the snark for those that are being intellectually dishonest.
:P
I have no beef with you, even if I do find some of your views questionable. :)

GB
 
I can't say I'm surprised that you didn't understand that, however.

I'm pretty sure he understands but dishonesty has been his hallmark in the entire thread.

The hilarious thing is that if, pretend for a moment, Alfie really is a professional counsellor what do you suppose he can tell his clients about performing an honest assessment of themselves? :D
 
DD, I understand that you and I will probably never agree that some "addicts" can return to moderate usage (though I think this is because I don't classify all forms of over-drinking or excessive-drug using as necessarily "addiction").

Fair Enough! You have your view, I have mine. :) (non-snarky smiley face :D )

There are a certain number of other issues we do seem to agree on.

Maybe I've misinterpreted some of your statements that initially seemed rather clear. But I think perhaps you are also misunderstanding my points. I await your response to my second post above to see if we can get past what I think may be some semantic issues.

GB
 
What I didn't get, though, was what it really mattered. The percentages were incredibly low, under 2 percent, with everything beyond 10 years under 1 percent.

So let's say every coin is given out, none stockpiled, no one gets more than one and there are five people who reach each anniversary without getting a coin for every one who actually receives a coin.... That's pretty generous, and yet the success rate still won't be far off from the 5 percent that people bandy about.

What do you think would be more realistic figures, as far as how many people reach each anniversary?

Edited to add: the original discussion starts around post 1484 and post 1492.
His whole methodology is flawed. It presupposes several things-
That all or even most AA'ers celebrating an anniversary get a chip ordered from central/national. My personal knowledge(and Alfie's) dispute this.
That AA'ers live forever. If you die you don't pick up chips anymore. It's a rule.
As I pointed out in an earlier post I have never picked up the specially ordered chips that the OP talk about yet tinyal says no birthday goes unadorned in his group. I have no knowledge of the rest of the planet. I will say that I have been to AA meetings on the NC coast (vacation) and in Vegas (pizza convention) and they use the plastic chip system like we do. Maybe you could stop by your local AA group and ask them how they mark time? I would guess that they use the plastic poker chips like we do but if they use the mail ordered bronze chips that would be a feather in tinyal's cap.
And the 5% number that keeps getting repeated is not based on science. DancingDavid pointed out up thread that no long term study has been done and until one is, efficacy of AA is unknown.
I thought it might help if you could see what we are talking about. This is the free poker chip that one receives in our group at one year or any multiple of years.
mms_picture-34.jpg

This is my uncle's 8 year chip. These are the ones that are special ordered from central/national.
mms_picture-35.jpg

I don't know how much they cost because I have never bought one. The blue ones are free. In my group, if you get 1 year or 20 years, you get the same blue chip. See my point?
 
Last edited:
Some of your statements require a more direct response. As the above are all restatements of the same question I will answer with a segment I have already posted but seems to not have sunk in.



First, I never said that behaviour didn't involve an "intersection in brain events." Quite the opposite in fact. I did however question that behaviour always has a "BASIS" in brain events.
Well it seems to, give an example that doesn't?
The Brain is simply responding to "external" stimuli. And much of behaviour has as much basis in that "external" stimuli as it does in the brain. The above examples are just a few of many empirical "external" factors that modify our behaviour.
Un, behaviorism is little more than operant pavlovian conditiong, and the transaction still takes place in the brain, no matter what.

More later.
Numerous experiments in Propaganda and Behaviour Modification have empirically demonstrated that Behaviour can be modified and manipulated by "external" events.
And those events are transmitted through the sensation to the perceptions are they not?
From Edward Bernays, to Ewen Cameron, and many others, in many experiments and studies, many quite unethical and illegal involving techniques we might consider Torture, have demonstrated beyond all doubt that our brains don't merely form the "basis" of our reality or behaviour, but in fact respond to stimuli which in turn can alter our behaviour.

In fact Cognitive Therapy is nothing if not a means to manipulate our brains to generate new behaviour patterns. This in essence is placing the "basis" for some behaviour patterns COMPLETELY "OUTSIDE" our bag of skin which does not separate us from the "external" world, but connects us to it.
Sorry you can't modify teh behavior without teh brain, stop, screeech, crash.

Have you tried driving without a brain, it doesn't go so well.

the basis is in the brain.
However, because in fact our brains DO have some strong intrinsic patterns, it can take extreme events to significantly alter those patterns. Some of those extreme events I have listed several times already. Experiencing Traumatic events: Earthquakes, Hurricanes, Homelessness, Poverty, Dislocation, Rape, War, Torture and others, also can significantly alter behaviour.

So it's no surprise that milquetoast approaches to changing behaviour rarely are particularly effective except in the most susceptible people. Something Military Tyrants and Religious Leaders have known for thousands of years.

Many techniques range from simple indoctrination on a regular basis, hypnosis, altering the brain through the introduction of chemicals, deprivation of sleep and food, repetitive music, regular exercise regimens, all the way to outright torture and Terrorism.

Some of these techniques are benign enough that an individual can use them him or herself to achieve the desired state of consciousness and the resultant behaviour patterns. Others are used to create behaviour patterns in people that make them more conducive to authoritarian control.

So I really don't think that there is any empirical basis to claim that the Brain, in and of itself, is the only "basis" for behaviour. I can only meet you halfway on the proposition that behaviour is dependent on "brain processes."

I am not stating "brain events in isolation of a brain," I am stating that brain events are NOT in isolation from "Outside" events.

If anything, my views tend more towards monism than yours appear to at face value, but I think that may just be due to semantic issues. I expect if you consider more closely what I am saying, you will find that we are more in agreement than not.

So perhaps in examining the various effectiveness of certain techniques of Behaviour Modification, we can determine what sorts of techniques can help to "break" the various forms of "addictive" patterns of behaviour.

GB
 
Why would you assume I need to "feel better"? Do you Project much about other things too?

Considering the amount of rude content your post had in response to single thing I posted I can assume you are rude or that you weren't feeling good. I asked you a question and you were very strange.
Good say sir.
 
Well the allegedly "non-theist" AAers lost their case over 30 pages ago. This thread has just been running on their unsupported denials since then. ;) I think they just realized that they have no more sophistry that hasn't already been slain.

I know we have our differences DD, but kudos are in order for your contributions to the "cause." :)

GB
 
Are you claiming that tinyal is not in AA? :confused:

? No, I'm claiming that you are using DD as an authority and it strikes me as odd. Not that DD can't be an authority, just that you don't really know what the person's credentials are or anything other than his argument style.

Why do you consider a resentment AA speak? I certainly don't deny that I learned about resentments in AA but are you saying that they don't exist outside of AA?

The AA speak part is not the concept of resentments per se, it's "working on them". No one outside of 12 step programs "works on resentments".

Before I got sober I had hate and anger inside of me I had been holding onto for years. There were people that I hated for the wrongs they had done me and I wished them dead. Today I don't hate anyone or anything. How do deal with anger and resentments is one of the most important coping skills I got from AA.

That is the AA speak I am referring to when you said "work on your resentments". Here is an excellent article on why "letting go and letting God" is not always the best course of action. http://www.morerevealed.com/aadep/reclaim/forgiveness.html

Appeal to authority not withstanding, I value the opinion of someone that argues in a rational and composed manner rather than someone that constantly, not occasionally but constantly writes in an aggressive format.

See above.

I am curious shawmutt, what did you do to get sober?

Stopped drinking, attended meetings just about every day in assorted formats, worked the steps three or four times over, had sponsors, had sponsees, got involved in committees up to and including on the state level (in CT), ran the state newsletter for two years, attended conferences--and I did it for about four and a half years.
 
Last edited:
That is the AA speak I am referring to when you said "work on your resentments". Here is an excellent article on why "letting go and letting God" is not always the best course of action. http://www.morerevealed.com/aadep/reclaim/forgiveness.html

People work on resentments because they are one of the key triggers (for many) in people picking up a drink.
The identification of the causes of a problem will always be part of any treatment.
 
Last edited:
? No, I'm claiming that you are using DD as an authority and it strikes me as odd. Not that DD can't be an authority, just that you don't really know what the person's credentials are or anything other than his argument style.

I am not an authroity nor do I play one on TV, I know more about butterfly gardening that I do AA!
 
... I know more about butterfly gardening that I do AA!
That doesn't seem to stop many here from discussing AA in great detail.

As to AA being religious, anyone who thinks AA meetings are religious needs to attend a few more, also attend a few church services, and see if they can spot the difference. Or they can keep reading books. Hopefully after they read a book on piloting they don't hijack a 747 to apply the "skills" learned.
 
Hard drive failure really sucks. Guess I'll just pick up where I left off.

Show me where in the 12 Steps that it says you can quit without the aid of a "Power greater than ourselves" (which the Steps define clearly as God). You can't do it, can you. Because that would be a flagrant lie.
You haven't left yourself much room here. You might have followed shawmutt's lead by including some weasel words like "it's plain to anyone who has spent time in the program..." -- but you didn't do that. You're arguing that because the 12 steps do not explicitly preclude the possibility that an alcoholic might quit drinking without the help of a higher power, that omission constitutes an affirmative declaration that such a thing is not possible. Do you need a reductio ad absurdum example to illustrate just how trivially flawed that logic is?

Here's how I make chocolate fudge:

Mix together 3 cups sugar, 2/3 cup of powdered unsweetened cocoa, 1 pinch salt.
Stir in 1 1/2 cups milk.
Bring to a rolling boil in a large saucepan while stirring constantly.
Reduce heat to medium and cook to soft ball without stirring.
Remove from heat, add 1/2 stick butter and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract.
Let cool 10-15 minutes.
Beat vigorously until mixture begins to set.
Pour quickly onto buttered plate or into square pan.

Now. Show me where in that is the claim -- either stated or implied -- that this is the only possible way to make a batch of chocolate fudge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom