DD, I think you're missing the forest for the trees, or the arguments for the semantics. I'm not disagreeing in principle with you, just pointing out that the mind/body connection doesn't end at the surface of our bag of skin.
Our senses and our molecules connect us to the Universe at large. Many things affect our biology and neurology which aren't in themselves bio-neurological. I don't see how any Empiricist can deny that.
So my question back at you is, if you aren't a Dualist, then are you a Monist?
Perhaps you'll see that it's not really a fair question, because Monism, like Dualism is simply a philosophical model that has its advantages, yet like all philosophical models cannot completely explain all phenomenon. Philosophical models are only useful up to a certain point by themselves, and tend to work best in a dialectic with other philosophical models.
To be a Die Hard in any particular model constrains one from seeing the "thing in itself", free of dogmatic conceptualizations.
So my other question to you, is how can you call yourself a "Hard Knock Behaviourist" without recognizing that Behaviourism is a philosophy of Psychology that is divorced from Neurology? This appears to be a contradiction of terms.
Behaviorism (or behaviourism), also called the learning perspective (where any physical action is a behavior), is a philosophy of psychology based on the proposition that all things that organisms do—including acting, thinking and feeling—can and should be regarded as behaviors. The behaviorist school of thought maintains that behaviors as such can be described scientifically without recourse either to internal physiological events or to hypothetical constructs such as the mind. Behaviorism comprises the position that all theories should have observational correlates but that there are no philosophical differences between publicly observable processes (such as actions) and privately observable processes (such as thinking and feeling)
Again, I am not strictly opposed to Behaviourism, though I think some of its propositions are not empirically sound. To a certain extent it is useful. But like all Philosophical models it runs into inconsistencies, sometimes internally within the model and sometimes when it runs up against aspects of reality better explained by other models.
Not to mention that Behaviourists like Skinner have shifted their own views or goalposts about what constitutes behaviourism. Some of his earlier work seems a bit "dualistic" if you ask me. Though I find that some of his ideas seem to match my own:
Skinner proposed that a complete account of behavior requires understanding of selection history at three levels: biology (the natural selection or phylogeny of the animal); behavior (the reinforcement history or ontogeny of the behavioral repertoire of the animal); and for some species, culture (the cultural practices of the social group to which the animal belongs). This whole organism then interacts with its environment.
Now that's a model of "Behaviourism"
that sounds remarkably like my post which you are picking apart. Though I'm not certain that at this point, Skinner's model can really be called Behaviourism. He seems to have adopted an approach that isn't attached to any one model, and instead employs a number of models that intersect to describe a more complex reality than which a "Hard Knock Behaviourist" might follow.
I really hate to be so side-tracked by such a Red Herring in the discussion of the Religiosity of AA. Though I find discussing this with you far more interesting than
Dymanic's specious, and disingenuous sophistry.
I like your straightforwardness and your honesty, even though I am beginning to realize that some of your own definitions seem to me internally inconsistent.
You have stated that you believe that anyone can change their behaviour, which is compatible with the classic definition of Behaviourism, but this seems incompatible with behaviour that is determined by Neurological Disorders, and Biological Predisposition. As I stated in a previous post, I believe people with such problems have little to no chance of actually changing their behaviours without some sort of Physical Mechanism involved.
In this sense, I agree with some in the recovery movement that at least some people are not at all able to exercise will to control their addictive behaviours.
However, these people have NO chance of being helped by a Recovery Support Group, religious or otherwise. Only some sort of chemical intervention is likely to help them.
You have also stated categorically that your adherence to a "Behaviourist" Model means you don't believe that the "Disease" Model has any validity at all. While I essentially agree that the Disease Model of Addiction isn't Generally Useful, I do not necessarily agree with you in the case of those "addictions" which are clearly rooted in Neurological Disorders. Biological Predisposition is another matter, as it is not necessarily a Disorder per se. Perhaps Cognitive therapy can be beneficial in helping those predisposed to addictive behaviour patterns manage their addictions at a moderate level, if not help them quit altogether.
As to some of the OTHER "triggers" for compulsive behaviour, I might agree with you that Psychological Behaviourist approaches such as Cognitive Therapy could be beneficial, though it would depend on a number of factors; including how much the compulsive behaviour has already disaffected the chemistry of the brain. In which case someone may be too far gone for Cognitive Therapy to work and chemical intervention necessary.
It would also depend on all the social environment factors, and whether or not a persons usage has actually become "compulsive" or is an expression of a need to cope with negative situational life circumstances. In the latter case, the regular usage of a drug of their choice may even be beneficial, and many people in situational circumstances are able to move back into moderate usage patterns entirely on their own if their circumstances change for the better.
If they cannot shift back on their own under improved circumstances, it may be that a combined approach of chemical intervention and cognitive therapy would be the most beneficial. And for some, support groups, religious and secular, might also help a bit.
And yes, for some people, no matter the actual cause of their "addiction," completely quitting may be the only solution once their pattern has been broken. But I certainly don't believe this to be the case for all so-called "addicts."
Now that I have explained more fully my view of things, it should be clear to you why I think any one particular approach, any "one size fits all" model is untenable, and why I think there is little hope for successfully treating "Addiction" in the current socio-political climate (imposed by Addiction Ideology) that even affects our Medical systems.
I do not dismiss out of hand any particular Model of addiction
excepting the Sin Model that AA promotes disguised as a "Disease" Model.
And the Disease Model itself I find dubious in its application across the board to all forms of "addiction", though it may be appropriate for those with a Neurological Disorder based Addiction. The Behaviorist Model actually gives me pause too, largely because it assumes that Behaviour is the Problem (much like the Sin Model) rather than a symptom; though I do think Cognitive Therapy can be quite beneficial.
So please don't be so quick to use the snarky and disingenuous gotcha debate tactics employed by the AA proselytizers (attempted but failed) against myself and others. Save the snark for those that are being intellectually dishonest. I have no beef with you, even if I do find some of your views questionable.
GB