Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think there is a significant derail here with the debate over whether AA works or not. That is not the issue--it could be the most successful program ever invented.

The issue is whether it's a religious program or not. All the slippery language that was used within the program when I was there, and the same language being used here, spells it out pretty clear. Just like I was "in denial" and "dishonest" for leaving the program and trying controlled drinking, an atheist within the program is just "in denial" and "dishonest" about their higher power. This is plain as day to anyone reading the literature and attending meetings.
 
I like to keep in mind that the AA program itself hasn't changed in any meaningful way in 70 years!! If the treatment hasn't changed, then studies done about that treatment 10, 20, 30 years ago very likely are just as valid today as they were when they were first compiled. Additionally, the AA machine of treatment centers & 12 step recovery centers basically controls the debate, doing their level best to be sure studies aren't funded (our gov't cooperates with this!), or have great difficultly getting cooperation from AA members & officers.

Just because a study is slightly old doesn't automatically make it invalid - espescially if there are no new studies available. The atom bomb was based on research decades ago - does that mean it no longer works? Most of the bombs the USA has on rockets right now were made back in the 70's and 80's - does that mean they are no longer 'valid'???

True, technology changes - but the AA program doesn't, and hasn't , changed in decades!!

Do you have one - one single study - properly done, that demonstrates what you are claiming? Anything?? Anything at all other than your opinion????

I have the following (and although there are some older dates, many of the below reference dates such as 2001, 1998, 1997 etc - not very old) - and these are only a small sample. Plus - they basically all agree!! If studies done in the 60's agree with those in the 70's , and those agree with the ones done 80's and 90's - and those agree with those done in 200+ - if they all agree, that seems to me to suggest a very strong , valid conclusion.

Put up your studies, here are mine:

PROFESSIONAL and ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS RELATIONS IN OREGON; An Exploratory Study Report, No. 1, 1965, Milton A. Maxwell, Ph.D.
Mental Health Division, Oregon State Board of Control, Alcohol Studies and Rehabilitation Section
LC: HV5278.A78M3
A very small (20 page) report on Alcoholics Anonymous in Oregon in 1965, and its relations with alcoholism treatment professionals. He observed many of the failings of A.A. that are commonplace today, like resistance to taking medications even when needed, territorial jealousy, stubbornly clinging to outmoded and dogmatic ideas of alcoholism, and refusal to study treatment failures and revise the A.A. program. Dr. Maxwell hoped that those things would be changed and that A.A. would grow into a valuable ally for the professionals. Alas, none of that came to be.
(Note: Dr. Milton A. Maxwell eventually became a member of the Board of Trustees of Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc..)

The Natural History of Alcoholism: Causes, Patterns, and Paths to Recovery George E. Vaillant
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, England, 1983.
ISBN: 0-674-60375-3
LC: number RC565.V33 1983
Dewey: 616.86'1

The Natural History of Alcoholism Revisited George Vaillant
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, England, 1995.
ISBN: 0-674-60377-X (cloth); ISBN: 0-674-60378-8 (paperback).
Dewey: 616.861 V131n 1995
This book also contains most of the text of the previous one.

Heavy Drinking: The Myth of Alcoholism as a Disease Herbert Fingarette
University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1988.
ISBN: 0-520-06290-6
LC: number HV5292.F56 1988


Edited by LashL: 
Trimmed for compliance with Rule 4. Please do not copy and paste lengthy tracts available elsewhere; instead, post a snippet and a link to the originating site.


http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html


Now, GodofPie - what (beside's your unsupported opinion) do you have??
tl;dr
DancingDavid for one has agreed that the Orange Papers cites are out dated and not valid and I value his opinion WWAAAYYYYY over yours. Even some of your supporters agreed that OP are crap. I explained, in length and great detail why the person that compiled the "chip study" that he used to discredit AA was not only flawed but how it was flawed. Your like people that quote the bible and then asked "how do you know that's true?" respond "cuz the bible tells me so!" Take a deep breath and work on those critical thinking skills. And maybe do a little work on that resentment.
 
Small problem there GB, all behaviors are neurologically based, unless you are a dualist. :)

Dualism is a useful philosophy until it isn't. I'm not attached to any one particular philosophical model. And in any case, there are numerous philosophical models, some of them quite different, that can be considered "Dualist"--even some that are Dualist at one level only to resolve into Monism at another level. How can I determine which form of "Dualism" you are applying?

And it doesn't necessarily follow that all behaviours are neurologically based, a claim that not even neurologists can empirically demonstrate. There is a whole Universe outside of our brain chemistry that interacts with it to generate what we consider consciousness. There are deterministic and indeterministic aspects of the Universe and our brains that interact in some manner. And an in-depth discussion of such is outside the purview of this thread.

There are a whole slew of socio-political/economic circumstances that affect our behaviour (including allegedly "addictive" behaviour) that are not neurological:

I think that we will eventually find that most effective is treating the underlying problems that cause people to fall into heavy abuse patterns (Schizophrenia, Depression, Anxiety, OCD, Chronic and Severe Pain, Genetic predisposition to addictive behaviour patterns, coping with personal Financial Problems, coping with abuse, coping with living in an oppressed population group, coping with living in a highly demanding society that forces most people to work for less and less and being put out of work and out of house by Fat Cats who control and destroy economies, coping with living in a War Zone...etc, etc.).

Even in one of your previous posts in which you disclaim "dualism", you yourself indicate that at some level you recognize distinctions between biologically based addiction patterns, and socially induced "addiction" patterns:

Ah, okay, well so the statement of a select group choosing a nomenclature that does not meet the definition of disease still applies.

It is a mental disorder, it does not have to involve withdrawal effects and therefore it is NOT a disease in the general sense.

It is a behavioral disorder. Just because of bunch of people decide that it is also a spiritual disorder, in groups that think it is effective to call it a spiritual disorder does not mean that it is a spiritual disorder.

It is a physical process as are ALL mental disorders AA Alfie, there is no dualistic separation from the mind and body, all minds are just brain processes.

So it is not a disease.

1. Some people who are alcoholics do not have a biological predisposition of alcoholism (i.e. they are not Type II alcoholics).
2. Some people who are alcoholics do not have physical withdrawal symptoms.

Therefore it is not a disease, it is a behavioral disorder like all addictions using a substance that in some cases will cause a physical withdrawal syndrome.

It is less of a disease that schizophrenia.

I might agree (up to a point) that there is no "dualistic separation" of mind and body/brain process. but I would go further and suggest that there is no abitrary "dualistic separation" between the bio-neurological process of an individual person from their whole environment, including the socio-political/economy we operate in--which is in and of itself not neurological. In this view, what we consider "mind" or "consciousness" is not simply our brain process, but a sort of feedback loop between our brain/body and the rest of the Universe.

Insofar as you yourself consider that "addiction" can be separated into those that are biologically predisposed, and/or have physical withdrawal symptoms; and those who are NOT biologically predisposed--you are tacitly acknowledging that there are indeed forms of habituation and/or abuse that are not necessarily neurologically induced (which isn't to say that ingestion of ANY substance doesn't end up having neurological effects).

Of course none of this has any bearing on AA being a religious organization, (which has been empirically demonstrated). But despite being tangential to the topic at hand, I feel that this has been a point worth discussing in the context of AA, "Addiction," and the Recovery Industry in general.

How can any single programme, religious, secular, or scientific begin to address the problems involved with "Addiction," unless we start distinguishing much more clearly than we have between people with serious neurological disorders, those with behavioural issues, and those who are simply medicating to cope with the travails of life? "Type 1" and "Type 2" "Addiction" doesn't even begin to cover this.

I must sincerely thank you for asking the question, because it has given me the opportunity to once again discuss these serious issues. :)

GB
 
Last edited:
tl;dr
DancingDavid for one has agreed that the Orange Papers cites are out dated and not valid and I value his opinion WWAAAYYYYY over yours. Even some of your supporters agreed that OP are crap. I explained, in length and great detail why the person that compiled the "chip study" that he used to discredit AA was not only flawed but how it was flawed. Your like people that quote the bible and then asked "how do you know that's true?" respond "cuz the bible tells me so!" Take a deep breath and work on those critical thinking skills. And maybe do a little work on that resentment.

A perfect example of why posting "snippets" is useless (thanks Mods :rolleyes:). Then folk like Godofpie and Alfie can just ignore any evidentiary information not actually in the body of the post. And the best the poster can hope is that others will actually take the time to read the links which may (or may not) discredit the rebutter's remarks.

Tinyal made an extremely valid point: that the Orange Papers as a whole cannot be discredited by a poke or two at one or two of the studies referenced in the Orange Papers.

And his other excellent point, is that none of those in self-denial have posted studies backing up their point of view, only "unsupported opinions" as Tinyal aptly put it. Again, "our side" has evidence. Where is yours Godofpie, Al Bell, Alfie, Dymanic? Put Up or Shut Up.

Your rhetorical obfuscations are nothing but smoke and mirrors to hide the fact that you have no case.

As "catching" Tinyal in a single "gaffe"** many pages back (regarding Alcohol's physical withdrawal symptoms in some people) is your only notch on the scoreboard, you guys are waaaaaaay behind by at least 1000 pts. And his "gaffe" in no way diminishes the vast tracts of empirical evidence Tinyal has brought to the table, particularly in comparison to your own multiple "gaffes," Red Herrings, Straw Men, and Sophistry.

Shawmutt, I generally agree with your sentiment that this aspect of the discussion is tangential (which is why I tend to stick mainly to the Religiosity of AA myself. I don't have time to cover all the bases myself), but the effectiveness of AA (or any Recovery group, even secular ones) is necessarily a factor in such discussions--simply because it has a bearing on whether or not a programme (religious or not) is useful. And I leave it to those posters who do have the time to take up that end of the argument.

GB

** Really just a misstatement, not necessarily a "gaffe". Tinyal was clearly making a point similar to that of Dancing David which I reposted above, and my own, that not all forms of "addiction" are equal, and that the term addiction in some cases (such as those without physical withdrawal symptoms) may be a misnomer.
 
Last edited:
godofpie said:
DancingDavid for one has agreed that the Orange Papers cites are out dated and not valid and I value his opinion WWAAAYYYYY over yours.

Appeal to authority involving someone you know over an internet forum is a new one to me.

And maybe do a little work on that resentment.

AA Speak really doesn't have any bearing on outsiders. It took me years to recover from the program, and it started with losing the vocabulary.
 
A "power greater than ourselves" is the same as a "higher power"?

Yes, obviously.

That is your claim.

No, that is my conclusion based on the evidence presented at the beginning of the thread, which you have apparently ignored.

Either way, why do you want to change the wording to make AA change its language if it doesn't work>

One has nothing to do with the other, so your question is meaningless.
 
No, that is my conclusion based on the evidence presented at the beginning of the thread, which you have apparently ignored.

No, other evidence has been produced since the beginning of the threas that you have ignored. :)

One has nothing to do with the other, so your question is meaningless.

Belz: AA should change its language
AAA: Why?
Belz: To be more inclusive to atheists
AAA: Anyone can join you know, and there aren't any rules around an HP.
Belz: BS!
AAA: Meh
Belz: It doesn't work anyway.
AAA: Why then do you want it to be more inclusive?
Belz: One has nothing to do with the other, so your question is meaningless
AAA: LOL!
 
I've no interest in doing so, nor do I have a flock of post-docs to do all the work it would take.

Do you believe everything written in books?

I do know I have a successful AA experience, and had none with programs run by professionals.

And were those professionals using CBT or RET, and does it matter in relating your sidetrack anecdote?
 
I did not mean to sound condescending. I apologize if it came across that way.

It is shameful that the insurance company canceled you; this is just not right. But sometimes doctors can provide information where you can get meds at reduced rates from the companies--that, or supply you with the samples they receive from their reps.
Um, pharmaceutical assistance is a bear, and there are income limits. many MHCs no longer accept samples. The best route is to talk to the treating doctor about possible generics. My doctor only gave me the samples as a starter, fortunately Walmart and my insurance like each other.

And then attending RA or SOS meeting or DFD AA groups if desired. Many of the techniques of CBT can be used on ones own, but it really helps to have a clinician.
You might also want to check out NAMI, the National Alliance on Mental Illness. There might be some resources for you, and they have some forums on depression as well. I wish you peace.

NAMI rocks although they have just a wee bit of woo.
 
This link was provided previously. I still had it open in a browser tab, so it was easy for me to find.

http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm


Alcoholics Anonymous was ranked 38th out of 48 treatment types.
You wouldn't happen to have a cite from an organization that doesn't have a dog in the fight?
From their site-

"Therapists providing moderation training

We have developed a list of therapists providing training in moderate drinking. However, we make no guarantees about the competence of these therapists or the results you might achieve with them. They have responded to postings and announcements in a number of professional discussion groups and journals that invited them to have their names published on this list.

In addition to this list of providers, you might also consider visiting the Moderation Management (MM) Web site. MM is a self-help group that has meetings around the country and a discussion group that acts like a meeting for many."

I don't think any reasonable person would consider this an unbiased study group. They have a product to sell and their study shows that their product works best.
 
Dualism is a useful philosophy until it isn't.
Not to me, it seems to always be incoherent. Duality has no apparent resolution other than monism. :)
I'm not attached to any one particular philosophical model. And in any case, there are numerous philosophical models, some of them quite different, that can be considered "Dualist"--even some that are Dualist at one level only to resolve into Monism at another level. How can I determine which form of "Dualism" you are applying?
The broadest possible, so you are saying that there are events of sensation, perception and consciousness that are not brain based? Seriously, tell me which those would be and at which point they are not based in brain events? :)
And it doesn't necessarily follow that all behaviours are neurologically based, a claim that not even neurologists can empirically demonstrate.
Oh really?
So just tell me, which aspect of human behavior does not involve the intersection and basis in brain events? :)
There is a whole Universe outside of our brain chemistry that interacts with it to generate what we consider consciousness.
There is?
Like what, that is an interesting idea, but it begins with sensation and ends in a brain events doesn't it? :)
There are deterministic and indeterministic aspects of the Universe and our brains that interact in some manner. And an in-depth discussion of such is outside the purview of this thread.
Nice dodge, there is nothing to human experience that does not begin and end in the brain. :)

There are a whole slew of socio-political/economic circumstances that affect our behaviour (including allegedly "addictive" behaviour) that are not neurological:
Oh really and how does that work?

Really... try it on, tell me how even one effects your behavior. :)
Even in one of your previous posts in which you disclaim "dualism", you yourself indicate that at some level you recognize distinctions between biologically based addiction patterns, and socially induced "addiction" patterns:
So? the basis is still dependant upon brain processes, where else is it?
:)
I might agree (up to a point) that there is no "dualistic separation" of mind and body/brain process. but I would go further and suggest that there is no arbitrary "dualistic separation" between the bio-neurological process of an individual person from their whole environment, including the socio-political/economy we operate in--which is in and of itself not neurological.
Except for one wee little idea, regardless of whether it is star light, social perception and interaction, it all begins at the arbitrary bag of organic molecules we call 'a body'.
In this view, what we consider "mind" or "consciousness" is not simply our brain process, but a sort of feedback loop between our brain/body and the rest of the Universe.
You show any brain event in isolation from a brain and I will agree, or a brain event that does not require sensation or perception at some time.

:)
Insofar as you yourself consider that "addiction" can be separated into those that are biologically predisposed, and/or have physical withdrawal symptoms; and those who are NOT biologically predisposed--you are tacitly acknowledging that there are indeed forms of habituation and/or abuse that are not necessarily neurologically induced (which isn't to say that ingestion of ANY substance doesn't end up having neurological effects).
Nope, all habituation is neurologically based. :)

Sorry, I am a hard knock behaviorist YMMV.
 
Appeal to authority involving someone you know over an internet forum is a new one to me.



AA Speak really doesn't have any bearing on outsiders. It took me years to recover from the program, and it started with losing the vocabulary.
Are you claiming that tinyal is not in AA? :confused:
Why do you consider a resentment AA speak? I certainly don't deny that I learned about resentments in AA but are you saying that they don't exist outside of AA? Before I got sober I had hate and anger inside of me I had been holding onto for years. There were people that I hated for the wrongs they had done me and I wished them dead. Today I don't hate anyone or anything. How do deal with anger and resentments is one of the most important coping skills I got from AA.
Appeal to authority not withstanding, I value the opinion of someone that argues in a rational and composed manner rather than someone that constantly, not occasionally but constantly writes in an aggressive format. I am curious shawmutt, what did you do to get sober?
 
I explained, in length and great detail why the person that compiled the "chip study" that he used to discredit AA was not only flawed but how it was flawed.

What I didn't get, though, was what it really mattered. The percentages were incredibly low, under 2 percent, with everything beyond 10 years under 1 percent.

So let's say every coin is given out, none stockpiled, no one gets more than one and there are five people who reach each anniversary without getting a coin for every one who actually receives a coin.... That's pretty generous, and yet the success rate still won't be far off from the 5 percent that people bandy about.

What do you think would be more realistic figures, as far as how many people reach each anniversary?

Edited to add: the original discussion starts around post 1484 and post 1492.
 
Last edited:
And were those other techniques CBT or RET?
State of the art today? No. At the time behavior mod was part of therapies involved.

I don't intend to start drinking again to discover if cbt can make me a social drinker.

http://www.springerlink.com/content/t8p75175l120574l/

Abstract
General or nonpreferential rational-emotive therapy (RET)is synonymous with cognitive behavior therapy (CBT).Specialized or preferential RET, however, differs from CBT in several ways. Cognitively, it has a pronounced philosophic emphasis, includes a humanistic-existentialist out-look, strives for pervasive and long-lasting rather than symptomatic change, tries to eliminate all self-ratings, stresses antimusturbatory rather than antiempirical disputing methods, recognizes the palliative aspects of cognitive distraction, discourages problem solving that is not accompanied by changes in clients' basic belief system, and emphasizes secondary as well as primary symptoms of emotional disturbance. Emotively, it stresses the discrimination of appropriate from inappropriate emotions, emphasizes methods of working directly with and on emotions, encourages forceful emotive interventions, and uses relationship procedures that heavily stress unconditional rather than conditional positive regard. Behaviorally, it favors penalization as well as reinforcement, is partial to in vivo desensitization and flooding, and makes sure that skill training is done within a philosophic framework of trying to help clients make basic changes in their irrational beliefs.
Whatever floats your boat I guess. Sounds like just the ticket for atheists who can't identify any power higher than their ego (so to speak) and have lots of time and money. I hazard a guess that alcoholism is the last thing that would be a topic. Which also fits right in with posters here who have no idea what later stage alcoholism entails.
 
DD, I think you're missing the forest for the trees, or the arguments for the semantics. I'm not disagreeing in principle with you, just pointing out that the mind/body connection doesn't end at the surface of our bag of skin.

Our senses and our molecules connect us to the Universe at large. Many things affect our biology and neurology which aren't in themselves bio-neurological. I don't see how any Empiricist can deny that.

So my question back at you is, if you aren't a Dualist, then are you a Monist?

Perhaps you'll see that it's not really a fair question, because Monism, like Dualism is simply a philosophical model that has its advantages, yet like all philosophical models cannot completely explain all phenomenon. Philosophical models are only useful up to a certain point by themselves, and tend to work best in a dialectic with other philosophical models.

To be a Die Hard in any particular model constrains one from seeing the "thing in itself", free of dogmatic conceptualizations.

So my other question to you, is how can you call yourself a "Hard Knock Behaviourist" without recognizing that Behaviourism is a philosophy of Psychology that is divorced from Neurology? This appears to be a contradiction of terms.

Behaviorism (or behaviourism), also called the learning perspective (where any physical action is a behavior), is a philosophy of psychology based on the proposition that all things that organisms do—including acting, thinking and feeling—can and should be regarded as behaviors. The behaviorist school of thought maintains that behaviors as such can be described scientifically without recourse either to internal physiological events or to hypothetical constructs such as the mind. Behaviorism comprises the position that all theories should have observational correlates but that there are no philosophical differences between publicly observable processes (such as actions) and privately observable processes (such as thinking and feeling)

Again, I am not strictly opposed to Behaviourism, though I think some of its propositions are not empirically sound. To a certain extent it is useful. But like all Philosophical models it runs into inconsistencies, sometimes internally within the model and sometimes when it runs up against aspects of reality better explained by other models.

Not to mention that Behaviourists like Skinner have shifted their own views or goalposts about what constitutes behaviourism. Some of his earlier work seems a bit "dualistic" if you ask me. Though I find that some of his ideas seem to match my own:

Skinner proposed that a complete account of behavior requires understanding of selection history at three levels: biology (the natural selection or phylogeny of the animal); behavior (the reinforcement history or ontogeny of the behavioral repertoire of the animal); and for some species, culture (the cultural practices of the social group to which the animal belongs). This whole organism then interacts with its environment.

Now that's a model of "Behaviourism" that sounds remarkably like my post which you are picking apart. Though I'm not certain that at this point, Skinner's model can really be called Behaviourism. He seems to have adopted an approach that isn't attached to any one model, and instead employs a number of models that intersect to describe a more complex reality than which a "Hard Knock Behaviourist" might follow.

I really hate to be so side-tracked by such a Red Herring in the discussion of the Religiosity of AA. Though I find discussing this with you far more interesting than Dymanic's specious, and disingenuous sophistry.

I like your straightforwardness and your honesty, even though I am beginning to realize that some of your own definitions seem to me internally inconsistent.

You have stated that you believe that anyone can change their behaviour, which is compatible with the classic definition of Behaviourism, but this seems incompatible with behaviour that is determined by Neurological Disorders, and Biological Predisposition. As I stated in a previous post, I believe people with such problems have little to no chance of actually changing their behaviours without some sort of Physical Mechanism involved. In this sense, I agree with some in the recovery movement that at least some people are not at all able to exercise will to control their addictive behaviours.

However, these people have NO chance of being helped by a Recovery Support Group, religious or otherwise. Only some sort of chemical intervention is likely to help them.

You have also stated categorically that your adherence to a "Behaviourist" Model means you don't believe that the "Disease" Model has any validity at all. While I essentially agree that the Disease Model of Addiction isn't Generally Useful, I do not necessarily agree with you in the case of those "addictions" which are clearly rooted in Neurological Disorders. Biological Predisposition is another matter, as it is not necessarily a Disorder per se. Perhaps Cognitive therapy can be beneficial in helping those predisposed to addictive behaviour patterns manage their addictions at a moderate level, if not help them quit altogether.

As to some of the OTHER "triggers" for compulsive behaviour, I might agree with you that Psychological Behaviourist approaches such as Cognitive Therapy could be beneficial, though it would depend on a number of factors; including how much the compulsive behaviour has already disaffected the chemistry of the brain. In which case someone may be too far gone for Cognitive Therapy to work and chemical intervention necessary.

It would also depend on all the social environment factors, and whether or not a persons usage has actually become "compulsive" or is an expression of a need to cope with negative situational life circumstances. In the latter case, the regular usage of a drug of their choice may even be beneficial, and many people in situational circumstances are able to move back into moderate usage patterns entirely on their own if their circumstances change for the better.

If they cannot shift back on their own under improved circumstances, it may be that a combined approach of chemical intervention and cognitive therapy would be the most beneficial. And for some, support groups, religious and secular, might also help a bit.

And yes, for some people, no matter the actual cause of their "addiction," completely quitting may be the only solution once their pattern has been broken. But I certainly don't believe this to be the case for all so-called "addicts."

Now that I have explained more fully my view of things, it should be clear to you why I think any one particular approach, any "one size fits all" model is untenable, and why I think there is little hope for successfully treating "Addiction" in the current socio-political climate (imposed by Addiction Ideology) that even affects our Medical systems.

I do not dismiss out of hand any particular Model of addiction excepting the Sin Model that AA promotes disguised as a "Disease" Model.

And the Disease Model itself I find dubious in its application across the board to all forms of "addiction", though it may be appropriate for those with a Neurological Disorder based Addiction. The Behaviorist Model actually gives me pause too, largely because it assumes that Behaviour is the Problem (much like the Sin Model) rather than a symptom; though I do think Cognitive Therapy can be quite beneficial.

So please don't be so quick to use the snarky and disingenuous gotcha debate tactics employed by the AA proselytizers (attempted but failed) against myself and others. Save the snark for those that are being intellectually dishonest. I have no beef with you, even if I do find some of your views questionable. :)

GB
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom