Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mr. GodofPie, if you have insurance, you can call the number on your card and get information on what kinds of mental programs are covered. And ask your doctor for assistance on nutritional advice on how diet may help you, or if he can recommend a good nutritionist.

I just have a feeling that you haven't actually examined any of those options--you're answer was too pat.

And yes, you may have to spend money on some services, like a $10 dollar co-pay. If medications are needed, your doctor can help you find out if you can get discounted prices directly from the drug company.

If you needed an anti-biotic for bronchitis, you would get that drug from your doctor and not worry about the cost. The money you used to spend on liquor can be usefully invested in your health.

And seeing as you enjoy the meetings, you can still go to AA. But it's nice to know that there are other tools in your toolkit, things that can make life a lot easier, more comfortable and more enjoyable.

Dear Miss Nanny-My original Insurance, United Health Care, canceled my insurance because they said that there were not enough people in my group. My new insurance carrier would not cover mental health/addiction because it was a preexisting condition. How is the view from your ivory tower? BTW when my insurance was canceled I was on Prozac because of being the victim of multiple armed robberies,I was diagnosed with PTSD and double depression. Without insurance my script was $400 for a months supply of prozac. Needless to say I couldn't afford it. It was a great thing I had the AA group to fall back on for support. You are very condescending.
 
AA is a very poor choice for problems other than drinking (hell, it's not even a good choice for that with it's 95% failure rate!) - many studies have demonstrated a link between AA attendance and:

1. Increased risk of Binge Drinking
2. Increased rate of suicides
3. Moderaters/Group Leaders have no qualifications to address problems such as depression - the AA program itself urges attendees to 'turn' all of their problems over to a non-existent 'higher power', to admit loss of control over every aspect of their lives 'our lives have become unmanageable' is what it says, not 'our drinking has become unmanageable' (which would at least make sense).

Regardless of the fact that it's sorta free (strong peer pressure is applied at many meetings to pay for it anyway, with donations asked for at each and every meeting), I've talked personally to scores of doctors, psyche's & certified therapists - not a one of which suggested AA for problems other than alcohol. The AA program does claim to treat all of life's problems (just read the big book - says so in multiple areas plain as day) - of course, joining the church as a priest will also control your life (and they'll even pay for your health insurance, and housing!) - that's turning your life over to another non-existing higher power, and just as ineffective a 'treatment'. For anything.

As far as recent studies go, AA GSO no longer assists in medical studies by providing membership information to the medical field (as they did with they survey's years ago), due to the fact that all their studies (see George Valiant's study) started to show no more than 1 in 20 people were getting and staying sober - so they quit.

Just because one chooses to go to AA, and then stops drinking - or one's depression is lifted - doesn't mean AA had anything to do with it. Confirmation Bias anyone? Hanging out with similar people and talking about life is, however, a proven solution to some depressions - and AA provides that. Of course, you get the godbothering content as well. Why not remove the god bothering and just hang with friends and chat??
 
Your too funny godofpie - The Orange Papers has not been discredited, there are hundreds of studies on various aspects of AA in there, along with well documented historical information - none of which you've (or anyone else) has discredited.
None.
Just you claiming it's been discredited just because you dont' agree with it has no bearing on the truth of the matter - there are hundreds and hundreds of pages, backed up with years of documented research on that site. The only thing you've claimed is discredited (and then trying to paint the entire sites contents with the same brush) is some studies were done a decade or 2 ago on one particular topic - a statement I don't agree with , as , for instance, studies done decades ago on the damage drinking does, or smoking causes, are just as valid today - if nothing has changed, then a new study isn't needed - and AA itself has stopped cooperating with scientific studies, which says alot about what they believe.
I've read the entire site, and your claims are baseless.

Oh, I'm sure you'll just keep repeating yourself over and over - you are fooling no one but yourself - for which I feel sorry for you. Really I do - I havent' spent more than 21 years in AA trying to help people (without any need for god or any higher power bullcrap) because I dont' care about people - it's because I do care.

But you're opinion? just that - simple opinion. No facts whatever.
 
Imagine that. Behavior therapists' study finds behavior therapy most effective treatments (as well as, I suspect, of most economic benefit to behavior therapists).

The not-provided Costs of each program would also be helpful.
 
Imagine that. Behavior therapists' study finds behavior therapy most effective treatments (as well as, I suspect, of most economic benefit to behavior therapists).

The not-provided Costs of each program would also be helpful.

You're going to have to work a lot harder if you would like to discredit these studies just by merely trying to infer that the conclusions are biased based on presumed financial gain.
 
You're going to have to work a lot harder if you would like to discredit these studies just by merely trying to infer that the conclusions are biased based on presumed financial gain.
I've no interest in doing so, nor do I have a flock of post-docs to do all the work it would take.

Do you believe everything written in books?

I do know I have a successful AA experience, and had none with programs run by professionals.
 
I like to keep in mind that the AA program itself hasn't changed in any meaningful way in 70 years!! If the treatment hasn't changed, then studies done about that treatment 10, 20, 30 years ago very likely are just as valid today as they were when they were first compiled. Additionally, the AA machine of treatment centers & 12 step recovery centers basically controls the debate, doing their level best to be sure studies aren't funded (our gov't cooperates with this!), or have great difficultly getting cooperation from AA members & officers.

Just because a study is slightly old doesn't automatically make it invalid - espescially if there are no new studies available. The atom bomb was based on research decades ago - does that mean it no longer works? Most of the bombs the USA has on rockets right now were made back in the 70's and 80's - does that mean they are no longer 'valid'???

True, technology changes - but the AA program doesn't, and hasn't , changed in decades!!

Do you have one - one single study - properly done, that demonstrates what you are claiming? Anything?? Anything at all other than your opinion????

I have the following (and although there are some older dates, many of the below reference dates such as 2001, 1998, 1997 etc - not very old) - and these are only a small sample. Plus - they basically all agree!! If studies done in the 60's agree with those in the 70's , and those agree with the ones done 80's and 90's - and those agree with those done in 200+ - if they all agree, that seems to me to suggest a very strong , valid conclusion.

Put up your studies, here are mine:

PROFESSIONAL and ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS RELATIONS IN OREGON; An Exploratory Study Report, No. 1, 1965, Milton A. Maxwell, Ph.D.
Mental Health Division, Oregon State Board of Control, Alcohol Studies and Rehabilitation Section
LC: HV5278.A78M3
A very small (20 page) report on Alcoholics Anonymous in Oregon in 1965, and its relations with alcoholism treatment professionals. He observed many of the failings of A.A. that are commonplace today, like resistance to taking medications even when needed, territorial jealousy, stubbornly clinging to outmoded and dogmatic ideas of alcoholism, and refusal to study treatment failures and revise the A.A. program. Dr. Maxwell hoped that those things would be changed and that A.A. would grow into a valuable ally for the professionals. Alas, none of that came to be.
(Note: Dr. Milton A. Maxwell eventually became a member of the Board of Trustees of Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc..)

The Natural History of Alcoholism: Causes, Patterns, and Paths to Recovery George E. Vaillant
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, England, 1983.
ISBN: 0-674-60375-3
LC: number RC565.V33 1983
Dewey: 616.86'1

The Natural History of Alcoholism Revisited George Vaillant
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, England, 1995.
ISBN: 0-674-60377-X (cloth); ISBN: 0-674-60378-8 (paperback).
Dewey: 616.861 V131n 1995
This book also contains most of the text of the previous one.

Heavy Drinking: The Myth of Alcoholism as a Disease Herbert Fingarette
University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1988.
ISBN: 0-520-06290-6
LC: number HV5292.F56 1988


Edited by LashL: 
Trimmed for compliance with Rule 4. Please do not copy and paste lengthy tracts available elsewhere; instead, post a snippet and a link to the originating site.


http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html


Now, GodofPie - what (beside's your unsupported opinion) do you have??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've no interest in doing so, nor do I have a flock of post-docs to do all the work it would take.

Do you believe everything written in books?

I do know I have a successful AA experience, and had none with programs run by professionals.


Of course you have no interest in doing so. I doubt you even clicked any of the links or read any of the descriptions of the various treatment modalities described.

The request was made to provide evidence other than the Orange Papers of the inefficacies of AA as a treatment model. I linked to a study (that was linked to previously in this thread) that provided evidence that, prima facie, follows scientific principles in gathering, collating, and evaluating evidence.

As to costs, did you read about bibliotherapy? That's ranked fifth out of 48 as to efficacy in treating alcoholism. For twenty bucks, instead of the Big Book, you can purchase a different one which does the same thing (though without all of the God talk) such as those provided through Rational Recovery or a good book on CBT. Or go to the library. Check out those same books, and dozens more besides, for free.

Attend other self-help groups like Lifering which are also free to the member. No God talk in those meetings either, just a focus on concrete actions which you may implement in your life to effect the changes you desire.

Since this thread is asking why AA is insisted on not being religious, I think that alternatives to AA that are not religious is perfectly germane to the discussion.
 
Last edited:
Of course you have no interest in doing so. I doubt you even clicked any of the links or read any of the descriptions of the various treatment modalities described.

The request was made to provide evidence other than the Orange Papers of the inefficacies of AA as a treatment model. I linked to a study (that was linked to previously in this thread) that provided evidence that, prima facie, follows scientific principles in gathering, collating, and evaluating evidence.

As to costs, did you read about bibliotherapy? That's ranked fifth out of 48 as to efficacy in treating alcoholism. For twenty bucks, instead of the Big Book, you can purchase a different one which does the same thing, though without all of the God talk such as those provided through Rational Recovery or a good book on CBT. Or go to the library. Check out those same books, and dozens more besides, for free.

Attend other self-help groups like Lifering which are also free to the member. No God talk in those meetings either, just a focus on concrete actions which you may implement in your life to effect the changes you desire.

Since this thread is asking why AA is insisted on not being religious, I think that alternatives to AA that are not religious is perfectly germane to the discussion.

Well-stated Norseman :)
 
Well-stated Norseman :)


Well, thank you Tinyal.

I have learned a lot from this thread and especially from all of the insight you have provided into the upper-levels of the AA organization and the many, many quotes from sources integral to AA but rarely read or discussed (other than the Big Book and 12 by 12).

And again, I'll state that I have found this thread and (almost) everyone's participation in it to be of immense help in providing awareness and understanding about how I, myself, fit into my own recovery and the process I went through and where I want to go in my future sobriety.
 
Do you have one - one single study - properly done, that demonstrates what you are claiming?
Do you claim all, or any, of your cites were "properly done"? And go ahead and summarize what you think they claim.


Now, GodofPie - what (beside's your unsupported opinion) do you have??
My supported opinion is that AA helps me, and other techniques did not.
 
Of course you have no interest in doing so. I doubt you even clicked any of the links or read any of the descriptions of the various treatment modalities described.
I read the links provided.

The request was made to provide evidence other than the Orange Papers of the inefficacies of AA as a treatment model. I linked to a study (that was linked to previously in this thread) that provided evidence that, prima facie, follows scientific principles in gathering, collating, and evaluating evidence.
Yup, and scientific evaluation of impossible to define -- that is what is an alcoholic -- and for AA impossible to track, for lack of a better word 'crap' as study input yields crap.

As to costs, did you read about bibliotherapy? That's ranked fifth out of 48 as to efficacy in treating alcoholism. For twenty bucks, instead of the Big Book, you can purchase a different one which does the same thing (though without all of the God talk) such as those provided through Rational Recovery or a good book on CBT. Or go to the library. Check out those same books, and dozens more besides, for free.
Do you have a clue of what alcoholism is, and alcoholics' behavior? What a great idea! Just check out a book!

Attend other self-help groups like Lifering which are also free to the member. No God talk in those meetings either, just a focus on concrete actions which you may implement in your life to effect the changes you desire.
Glad to hear it. I'll stick with AA as I have no reason to change.

Since this thread is asking why AA is insisted on not being religious, I think that alternatives to AA that are not religious is perfectly germane to the discussion.
OK.
 
Dear Miss Nanny-My original Insurance, United Health Care, canceled my insurance because they said that there were not enough people in my group. My new insurance carrier would not cover mental health/addiction because it was a preexisting condition. How is the view from your ivory tower? BTW when my insurance was canceled I was on Prozac because of being the victim of multiple armed robberies,I was diagnosed with PTSD and double depression. Without insurance my script was $400 for a months supply of prozac. Needless to say I couldn't afford it. It was a great thing I had the AA group to fall back on for support. You are very condescending.

I did not mean to sound condescending. I apologize if it came across that way.

It is shameful that the insurance company canceled you; this is just not right. But sometimes doctors can provide information where you can get meds at reduced rates from the companies--that, or supply you with the samples they receive from their reps.

You might also want to check out NAMI, the National Alliance on Mental Illness. There might be some resources for you, and they have some forums on depression as well. I wish you peace.
 
Well, well. Sounds like the same thing to me.

A "power greater than ourselves" is the same as a "higher power"?

Whilst I agree over time I have become guilty of using the two as the same, when I look at them closely they are inherently different. I can see how a higher power could be associated with a god; but the other could be anything.

When the non deists talk about their hp, they are actually talking about pgto (I know this one does at any rate).

Actually, it doesn't, as explained at the beginning of the thread.

That is your claim.
Interestingly however, The Norseman has provided a link that says that AA does work.

Either way, why do you want to change the wording to make AA change its language if it doesn't work>

As far as recent studies go, AA GSO no longer assists in medical studies by providing membership information to the medical field ....

What membership information?

This link was provided previously. I still had it open in a browser tab, so it was easy for me to find.

http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

Alcoholics Anonymous was ranked 38th out of 48 treatment types.

Thanks for that.
Like what has been repeated by me ad nauseum here: AA does not claim to be the only game in town, nor does it claim to be the only way to get sober.

Since this thread is asking why AA is insisted on not being religious, I think that alternatives to AA that are not religious is perfectly germane to the discussion.

Indeed

The argument here is not whether or not AA works, but whether or not AA is religious.

Right through the thread AA 'opponents' have said it doesn't work. At the same time they say they want AAs language to change to make it more inclusive.
We see there are many other alternatives to AA for whom the god/hp/pgto term is unacceptable, so why do they want it to change?
 
AA is a very poor choice for problems other than drinking (hell, it's not even a good choice for that with it's 95% failure rate!) - many studies have demonstrated a link between AA attendance and:

1. Increased risk of Binge Drinking
2. Increased rate of suicides
3. Moderaters/Group Leaders have no qualifications to address problems such as depression - the AA program itself urges attendees to 'turn' all of their problems over to a non-existent 'higher power', to admit loss of control over every aspect of their lives 'our lives have become unmanageable' is what it says, not 'our drinking has become unmanageable' (which would at least make sense).

AA few questions around this please:
- what is the 95% measure rate (i.e. was it "sober after 12 months"?).
- You will find that an increase in binge drinking occurs after any intervention - check the local pub as they leave a detox or rehab.
- Are you suggesting AA forced a person into suicide? Imagine, AA not being able to help people get sober and yet help people to suicide. Your argument seems to have a contradiction here.
- I agree that AA members (for the most part) do not have qualifications in other areas and should not be giving advice around things like depression etc. You do however take some liberties with language here, namely:
-there are no leaders or moderators, only trusted servants and/or members who have their own experiences in sobriety. Tradition 10 das something to say about this too "Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy."
- step one says (and I know you know this:rolleyes:) "We admitted we were powerless over alcohol and our lives had become unmanagable". That does not for one second suggest we hand over every aspect of our lives to a hp. It says our lives were stuffed because of the grog.
 
Not according to the judicial system of the US. Why else would they exclusively "sentence" DUI offenders to AA?

You might have to ask them (the US judical system).
I could only guess (as are you) at their reasons, perhaps you could look up their policy on it? Frankly I doubt that they send peoiple there because it is the only treatment - I suspect it is cost.
In the meantime I have a couple of thoughts around that:
- If they sent people to other facilities/treatments it would cost money. Who would pay?
- People sent to AA by the courts would be having severely detrimental impact on success rates if/as they are not yet motivated to change.
- Are people who have a DUI alcoholics?
- Personally, I think the judicial system is abdicating its responsibility here.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom