I like to keep in mind that the
AA program itself hasn't changed in any meaningful way in 70 years!! If the treatment hasn't changed, then studies done about that treatment 10, 20, 30 years ago very likely are
just as valid today as they were when they were first compiled. Additionally, the AA machine of treatment centers & 12 step recovery centers basically controls the debate, doing their level best to be sure studies aren't funded (our gov't cooperates with this!), or have great difficultly getting cooperation from AA members & officers.
Just because a study is slightly old doesn't automatically make it invalid - espescially if there are no new studies available. The atom bomb was based on research decades ago - does that mean it no longer works? Most of the bombs the USA has on rockets right now were made back in the 70's and 80's - does that mean they are no longer 'valid'???
True, technology changes - but the AA program doesn't, and hasn't , changed in decades!!
Do you have one - one single study - properly done, that demonstrates what you are claiming? Anything?? Anything at all other than your opinion????
I have the following (and although there are some older dates, many of the below reference dates such as 2001, 1998, 1997 etc - not very old) - and these are only a small sample. Plus - they basically all agree!! If studies done in the 60's agree with those in the 70's , and those agree with the ones done 80's and 90's - and those agree with those done in 200+ - if they all agree, that seems to me to suggest a very strong , valid conclusion.
Put up your studies, here are mine:
PROFESSIONAL and ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS RELATIONS IN OREGON; An Exploratory Study Report, No. 1, 1965, Milton A. Maxwell, Ph.D.
Mental Health Division, Oregon State Board of Control, Alcohol Studies and Rehabilitation Section
LC: HV5278.A78M3
A very small (20 page) report on Alcoholics Anonymous in Oregon in 1965, and its relations with alcoholism treatment professionals. He observed many of the failings of A.A. that are commonplace today, like resistance to taking medications even when needed, territorial jealousy, stubbornly clinging to outmoded and dogmatic ideas of alcoholism, and refusal to study treatment failures and revise the A.A. program. Dr. Maxwell hoped that those things would be changed and that A.A. would grow into a valuable ally for the professionals. Alas, none of that came to be.
(Note: Dr. Milton A. Maxwell eventually became a member of the Board of Trustees of Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc..)
The Natural History of Alcoholism: Causes, Patterns, and Paths to Recovery George E. Vaillant
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, England,
1983.
ISBN: 0-674-60375-3
LC: number RC565.V33 1983
Dewey: 616.86'1
The Natural History of Alcoholism Revisited George Vaillant
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, England,
1995.
ISBN: 0-674-60377-X (cloth); ISBN: 0-674-60378-8 (paperback).
Dewey: 616.861 V131n 1995
This book also contains most of the text of the previous one.
Heavy Drinking: The Myth of Alcoholism as a Disease Herbert Fingarette
University of California Press, Berkeley, CA,
1988.
ISBN: 0-520-06290-6
LC: number HV5292.F56
1988
Edited by LashL:
Trimmed for compliance with Rule 4. Please do not copy and paste lengthy tracts available elsewhere; instead, post a snippet and a link to the originating site.
http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html
Now, GodofPie - what (beside's your unsupported opinion) do
you have??