Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by A.A.Alfie
In short terms:
Alcholics have been running on self will their whole lives. They have been trying to manage everyone and everything.
I disagree. I think that those who abuse alcohol don't have ENOUGH self will. They have been medicating themselves in order to "fake it to make it" through life.

That struck me as odd too, though not having any personal experience with alcoholism, I thought maybe it made more sense to those who did. One of the reasons I don't enjoy drinking all that much, is because I'm the type who does like to "manage" things, and alcohol interferes with that. If an emergency occurs, I can make a better judgment sober than drunk, so I'll stay sober. If I were to turn my life over to a higher power, I'd figure it would take care of me, so being drunk would be okay since my input wouldn't be as important.

But since the concept apparently works for some people, there must be a difference in personality or a difference in meaning of "manage" and "self will."
 
I disagree. I think that those who abuse alcohol don't have ENOUGH self will. They have been medicating themselves in order to "fake it to make it" through life. This is like dumpster-diving in the dark, where it's impossible to make good choices.
I think it would be better to use science than pie-in-the-sky philosophies. Brain scans to discover which areas of the brain are misfiring. Proper diagnosis of mood disorders, and medication if needed. Nutrition to add strength and remove discomfort. Rational-Emotive Therapy to apply practical tools to deal with issues. And the removal of the phrase, "I am an alcoholic," which constantly defines the person as an state of illness, and I believe keeps a person from moving foward, and keeps dragging them down with a shameful title.
You think I am ashamed because I identify my self as as alcoholic? Interesting. I agree with all the sciency stuff you said. Could you please tell me where these services are offered for free for those of us that make too much money to qualify for gubnent assistance and who whose insurance won't cover it?
 
I have, multiple times in this thread, through the literature and my own personal experience. I'll do it again just for laughs. You are being intellectually dishonest, and it's plain to anyone who has spent time in the program, like myself. "Working the program" is a mantra, those that fail are dishonest people. When the steps are read in meetings, the preface is read as well--and is a belief firmly held by AA members (for the third time):



Furthermore, the The Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions book expands on the God thoughts:

Yes, I have been forced to post the entire introduction of Chapter 5 previously also. The penchant for True Believers to conveniently post truncated snippets that are directly contradicted by the previous and following paragraphs they deliberately omit is what causes me to question the Genuine nature of their arguments.

GB
 
You think I am ashamed because I identify my self as as alcoholic? Interesting. I agree with all the sciency stuff you said. Could you please tell me where these services are offered for free for those of us that make too much money to qualify for gubnent assistance and who whose insurance won't cover it?

Instead of pretending AA isn't religious, your time might be better spent protesting the For-Profit Insurance industry and championing Single Payer Health Care. Also instead of promoting a Religious Support Group (which is fine for those that self-identify as Religious), you might consider advocating for more of the "sciency stuff" like allowing studies of how Ibogaine and other Psychotropics help break addiction patterns, which are otherwise unfunded or not allowed in the US due to the Current Puritan Addiction Ideology.

GB
 
That struck me as odd too, though not having any personal experience with alcoholism, I thought maybe it made more sense to those who did. One of the reasons I don't enjoy drinking all that much, is because I'm the type who does like to "manage" things, and alcohol interferes with that. If an emergency occurs, I can make a better judgment sober than drunk, so I'll stay sober. If I were to turn my life over to a higher power, I'd figure it would take care of me, so being drunk would be okay since my input wouldn't be as important.

But since the concept apparently works for some people, there must be a difference in personality or a difference in meaning of "manage" and "self will."
I understand your confusion. For a long time it was assumed that all people that drank too much had no "will power." We now know that is not true. The (insert addictive substance here) changes our brain chemistry in a way that it does not affect the non alcoholic/addict. When we talk about "self will run riot", we mean this

"Most of us have been unwilling to admit we were real alcoholics. No person likes to think he is bodily and mentally different from his fellows. Therefore, it is not surprising that our drinking careers have been characterized by countless vain attempts that somehow, someday we will control and enjoy our drinking is the real obsession of every abnormal drinker. The persistence of this illusion is astonishing. Many pursue it into the gates of insanity or death. We alcoholics are men and women who have lost the ability to control our drinking. We know that no real alcoholic ever recovers control. All of us felt at times that we were regaining control, but such intervals – usually brief – were inevitably followed by still less control, which led in time to pitiful and incomprehensible demoralization."
 
Instead of pretending AA isn't religious, your time might be better spent protesting the For-Profit Insurance industry and championing Single Payer Health Care. Also instead of promoting a Religious Support Group (which is fine for those that self-identify as Religious), you might consider advocating for more of the "sciency stuff" like allowing studies of how Ibogaine and other Psychotropics help break addiction patterns, which are otherwise unfunded or not allowed in the US due to the Current Puritan Addiction Ideology.

GB
You make me laugh. What you have written is a strawman argument.
My question was "Where can I receive these treatments at a price I can afford?"
Rather than replying, "Such a place doesn't exist. Maybe someday" you wrote the above tripe. Please show me where I said that AA is not religious or retract your false assertion.
My stand has been since very early in this thread
AA is to Religion
what
Atheism is to the JREF
Most people are but you don't have to be one to be a member.
BTW, during the healthcare debate, I visited Sen. Richard Burr's office twice and signed multiple petitions, so put that in your pipe and smoke it.:)
 
I have a very close friend who got drunk at a party and drove himself home. So far so good. But once he got home, he realized he'd left his housemate stranded at the party, so he returned for him. He then got busted for DUI.

He told me if he'd been less concerned about his friend, he wouldn't have got busted. I guess he figured that made him a little less of a bum for drinking and driving.

So, off he goes to AA meetings, he did this on his own, no court order. He lasted three meetings and his BS detector finally just wouldn't shut off. I asked him the Q. posed in this thread and he laughed and said absolutely, it's very religious, that's why he quit going.

He's an agnostic and said the religious tone really bothered him. He quit drinking on his own and has got his life together, is doing great, teaches at a small college.

Just a second-hand take on the matter.
 
I understand your confusion. For a long time it was assumed that all people that drank too much had no "will power." We now know that is not true. The (insert addictive substance here) changes our brain chemistry in a way that it does not affect the non alcoholic/addict. When we talk about "self will run riot", we mean this

"Most of us have been unwilling to admit we were real alcoholics. No person likes to think he is bodily and mentally different from his fellows. Therefore, it is not surprising that our drinking careers have been characterized by countless vain attempts that somehow, someday we will control and enjoy our drinking is the real obsession of every abnormal drinker. The persistence of this illusion is astonishing. Many pursue it into the gates of insanity or death. We alcoholics are men and women who have lost the ability to control our drinking. We know that no real alcoholic ever recovers control. All of us felt at times that we were regaining control, but such intervals – usually brief – were inevitably followed by still less control, which led in time to pitiful and incomprehensible demoralization."

Part of the problem is that the Puritan Addiction Ideology still holds sway over nearly all Recovery Organizations, both religious and secular, and over the language of the propaganda that informs the general debate and the overall Cultural View. Behavioural based "Addiction", and Habituation is conflated with Neurologically based Addiction (which is the perhaps the one more deserving of the term "addiction"). Behavioural Models and Sin Models are thus conflated with dubious Disease Models, and the more empirical Chemical Imbalance Disorder Models of addiction.

GB
 
You make me laugh. What you have written is a strawman argument.
My question was "Where can I receive these treatments at a price I can afford?"
Rather than replying, "Such a place doesn't exist. Maybe someday" you wrote the above tripe. Please show me where I said that AA is not religious or retract your false assertion.
My stand has been since very early in this thread
AA is to Religion
what
Atheism is to the JREF

Most people are but you don't have to be one to be a member.
BTW, during the healthcare debate, I visited Sen. Richard Burr's office twice and signed multiple petitions, so put that in your pipe and smoke it.:)

This is the same sophistry that Dymanic employs to pretend that he's not arguing that AA isn't religious, even though he's spent most of the thread arguing that AA isn't religious. You want to have your Intellectual cake and Eat it too. I stand by my assertion until you can convincingly demonstrate that you are not employing Sophistry.

Instead of arguing in favour of Secular Non-Twelve Step Recovery Organizations, you have been arguing in favour of AA. So it would appear that you are the one employing fallacies and disingenuous arguments.

Richard Burr adamantly opposes "socialist" Big Gubment "Obamacare." So perhaps you could be more specific as to what sort of petitions you signed, and whether or not you support or oppose Sen. Richard Burr's disinformation. If by your statement you meant that you oppose Richard Burr's agenda, then we at least agree on one thing. :)

GB
 
Last edited:
I understand your confusion. For a long time it was assumed that all people that drank too much had no "will power." We now know that is not true. The (insert addictive substance here) changes our brain chemistry in a way that it does not affect the non alcoholic/addict. When we talk about "self will run riot", we mean this

"Most of us have been unwilling to admit we were real alcoholics. No person likes to think he is bodily and mentally different from his fellows. Therefore, it is not surprising that our drinking careers have been characterized by countless vain attempts that somehow, someday we will control and enjoy our drinking is the real obsession of every abnormal drinker. The persistence of this illusion is astonishing. Many pursue it into the gates of insanity or death. We alcoholics are men and women who have lost the ability to control our drinking. We know that no real alcoholic ever recovers control. All of us felt at times that we were regaining control, but such intervals – usually brief – were inevitably followed by still less control, which led in time to pitiful and incomprehensible demoralization."

Okay, I get that alcoholics have an actual, chemical difference in the brain that makes craving for alcohol much stronger than a "normal" person's (for lack of a better word).

But if that's true, seems there are only two ways to actually stop drinking: change the difference in the brain so not-drinking requires no more effort than it would for a "normal" person, so no unusual will-power is required. Or increase the will-power of the person so it's strong enough to overcome the excessive urge.

Neither of those is easy. That's the whole problem.

It would seem that accepting the fact that one has repeatedly tried to control drinking and failed, is mainly useful in stopping the feelings of guilt and frustration brought on by constantly trying and failing. That's good of course, since it should increase self-acceptance and allow someone to put more energy into trying new and hopefully more successful ways. But unless one can get brain chemistry to instantly change, it still really is about will power, and finding new and better ways to increase it.

Also, I'm not sure how the higher power fits into all this. Logic would seem to indicate that if a person has been trying to control his drinking and can't, the "higher power" is what has been forcing him to drink all along.
 
Okay, I get that alcoholics have an actual, chemical difference in the brain that makes craving for alcohol much stronger than a "normal" person's (for lack of a better word).
At least I'd say that alcoholics react differently to how alcohol makes them feel as opposed to social drinkers. Some people aver there are physiological differences in how their systems process alcohol.

But if that's true, seems there are only two ways to actually stop drinking: change the difference in the brain so not-drinking requires no more effort than it would for a "normal" person, so no unusual will-power is required. Or increase the will-power of the person so it's strong enough to overcome the excessive urge.

Neither of those is easy. That's the whole problem.

It would seem that accepting the fact that one has repeatedly tried to control drinking and failed, is mainly useful in stopping the feelings of guilt and frustration brought on by constantly trying and failing. That's good of course, since it should increase self-acceptance and allow someone to put more energy into trying new and hopefully more successful ways. But unless one can get brain chemistry to instantly change, it still really is about will power, and finding new and better ways to increase it.
The last thing an alcoholic wants to do is stop drinking. Those who want him stop are his family and friends, and eventually his superiors at work assuming he's still a functioning alcoholic and bothers to show up at work. Even when having legal system problems that have focussed on his drinking related behaviors, dui, spousal abuse, anger management, whatever, few want to quit.

Also, I'm not sure how the higher power fits into all this. Logic would seem to indicate that if a person has been trying to control his drinking and can't, the "higher power" is what has been forcing him to drink all along.
Again, alcoholics believe they are fully in control of their drinking and really really like how they feel while drinking. The only problem is 'everyone else'.
 
At least I'd say that alcoholics react differently to how alcohol makes them feel as opposed to social drinkers. Some people aver there are physiological differences in how their systems process alcohol.


The last thing an alcoholic wants to do is stop drinking. Those who want him stop are his family and friends, and eventually his superiors at work assuming he's still a functioning alcoholic and bothers to show up at work. Even when having legal system problems that have focussed on his drinking related behaviors, dui, spousal abuse, anger management, whatever, few want to quit.


Again, alcoholics believe they are fully in control of their drinking and really really like how they feel while drinking. The only problem is 'everyone else'.
QFT-nicely explained AlBell. Pup-I wish I could explain whatever trick of the mind is responsible for my serenity and sobriety because of the "turning my will over to a power greater than myself". AA is accused of cult like behavior because of the the repetitive sayings that they use but I'm not so sure that that isn't the key to what you are talking about. My brain was wired to drink all the time. The program helped rewire my brain. My alcohol cravings are almost non existent. I have been having drug dreams lately-dreams where I am using-but they are few and far between. When I first got sober the drinking/druging dreams were so lucid I would wake up in a cold sweat and swear that I had been out using. Someday, science will figure out why the AA program works and by what mechanisms but for now it is a mystery.
Gandolf-Sophistry? Really? I'm flattered. I had to google it to see what it meant. Trust me, I'm not that clever. My analogy stands. Unless you can prove that I'm smart enough to commit sophistry? Ha! Thought not. I win. Thread over. and I'm still waiting for your retraction.
Richard Burr sucks. I get it. Didn't vote for him. What am supposed to do, complain to someone else's Senator? And pLeAsE STop wITh thE RandoM CapitalizatIoN. iT Is gIVing mE A MigRAIne.
 
Part of the problem is that the Puritan Addiction Ideology still holds sway over nearly all Recovery Organizations, both religious and secular, and over the language of the propaganda that informs the general debate and the overall Cultural View. Behavioural based "Addiction", and Habituation is conflated with Neurologically based Addiction (which is the perhaps the one more deserving of the term "addiction"). Behavioural Models and Sin Models are thus conflated with dubious Disease Models, and the more empirical Chemical Imbalance Disorder Models of addiction.

GB

Small problem there GB, all behaviors are neurologically based, unless you are a dualist. :)
 
Last edited:
Okay, I get that alcoholics have an actual, chemical difference in the brain that makes craving for alcohol much stronger than a "normal" person's (for lack of a better word).

That seems to be true in three ways
-Type II alcoholism
-EToH withdrawal profile
-self medication of comorbid consition

it is not true for all people with alcohol addiction :)
 
You think I am ashamed because I identify my self as as alcoholic? Interesting. I agree with all the sciency stuff you said. Could you please tell me where these services are offered for free for those of us that make too much money to qualify for gubnent assistance and who whose insurance won't cover it?

Mr. GodofPie, if you have insurance, you can call the number on your card and get information on what kinds of mental programs are covered. And ask your doctor for assistance on nutritional advice on how diet may help you, or if he can recommend a good nutritionist.

I just have a feeling that you haven't actually examined any of those options--you're answer was too pat.

And yes, you may have to spend money on some services, like a $10 dollar co-pay. If medications are needed, your doctor can help you find out if you can get discounted prices directly from the drug company.

If you needed an anti-biotic for bronchitis, you would get that drug from your doctor and not worry about the cost. The money you used to spend on liquor can be usefully invested in your health.

And seeing as you enjoy the meetings, you can still go to AA. But it's nice to know that there are other tools in your toolkit, things that can make life a lot easier, more comfortable and more enjoyable.
 
Pup-I wish I could explain whatever trick of the mind is responsible for my serenity and sobriety because of the "turning my will over to a power greater than myself". AA is accused of cult like behavior because of the the repetitive sayings that they use but I'm not so sure that that isn't the key to what you are talking about.

Someday, science will figure out why the AA program works and by what mechanisms but for now it is a mystery.

I really do think this is a whole field where incredible progress can be made in the future.

I expect that there's some common response that many (most?) people have, when presented with the usual stimuli of religion, cults, "secret societies" military/martial arts training, and similar groups that encourage loyalty, submission to something, repetition, fellowship, etc. People clearly "get something out of it" that's rewarding.

Diverse groups have stumbled upon the cause and effect, but what is it really all about? And what kinds of people doesn't it work for, and why?
 
My previous posts make it abundantly clear that I'm arguing that emotional response IS "belief", on some level.

I suspect that you realize this perfectly well, and are being deliberately obtuse.

You know, I'm getting slightly tired of people who think that others who don't understand them are doing it on purpose. You're either too cynical, or ignorant of the ways of the world.

Unless, of course, you want me to claim that you know perfectly well what "higher power" means but are being deliberately obtuse ?

I've also made it abundantly clear that I do not intend to engage in that off-topic discussion. I will stick to my opinion that whatever it is, it arises out of (or is at least characterized by) irrational thinking/feeling.

Defining addiction has no bearing on a thread about alcoholism ? News to me.

Kindly point out where in the twelve steps it is taught that the alcoholic:

Your wish is my command:

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become unmanageable.
2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.
3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.
 
The preface: "Here are the steps we took which are suggested as a program of recovery" and all of the phraseology which follows. In other words, all of it.

Again, irrelevant whether or not it is suggested. It is TAUGHT. All teachings are suggested but all are influencial. If they don't think it's true they shouldn't teach it. But, of course, they DO think it's true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom