Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
If someone said, "I have psychic powers", and someone else said, "No, you don't", would that be an attack on the person, or the argument?

As soon as that happens in the thread, we'll let you know. :rolleyes:
 
Sorry, you already did:


If someone said, "I have psychic powers", and someone else said, "No, you don't", would that be an attack on the person, or the argument?
I don't usually say that, I ask, what leads you to beleive that you have psychic powers?

So attack the argument, not the arguer. :D
 
Last edited:
"Why do people insist AA is not religious?"

What does it matter if AA is 'religious' or not? It only matters if they get sober or not and most recovering alcoholics I've known seldom become Christians or followers of any other religious belief system. Most simply become obnoxious self-proclaimed experts on the subject of addiction which is sad in a way but really annoying to those who are in earshot. It's great if they get off booze but please SHUT UP ALREADY! :) BTW, the program Intervention, on the A&E channel is excellent to learn about 'addiction' and you won't see much religious rhetoric in those stories.

As well, most addicts are so strung out, they wouldn't know spiritual from schmiritual or religion from schmeligion and God is the Last Thing on their mind if, at all. So you have made an unfounded assumption in the first place about AA being "religious" and 'spiritual' doesn't necessarily equate to "religious" either and certainly not necessarily to Christianity. Just as Catholicism or Mormonism etc. isn't necessarily a true Christian church. In other words, God may have done you a favor leading you away from being a Catholic? But instead of opening your heart to God, reading the bible etc. and honestly asking him to save you; you decided to turn away from God and put your faith in 'man' (i.e. your therapist) which will now almost certainly get you condemned? Your next step might be to declare yourself an atheist since you're so miserable? But here You are now whining like a juvenile in an idiotic forum babbling with cowering anonymous people who are probably laughing at Your ramblings and leading you by the nose to behave just like Them. How's that workin' for ya? But "misery loves company" and you've got plenty of hypocritical cyber-buddies/friends/pals to perish with here which probably also means God probably hasn't even called you yet to properly repent and be baptized in order to save your soul?

But the 'good news' is; you and your husband probably still have time to wake up from your miserable slumber and ask God to intervene in your lives and do it properly this time? And if you end up calling yourself an atheist, this is what I normally suggest to them:
Why do you call yourself an atheist when You can’t prove God does not exist any more than Christians can prove God does exist? Why do you like the taste of mustard? Why do you not like the taste of mustard? Who cares? Believers cannot prove the existence of God any more than Science can prove God doesn’t exist or can prove the big bang theory or intelligent design or any other theories of how mankind was created. That’s why it’s called a “theory” because theories cannot be proven unless/until they are proven and you’ll almost certainly be deceased without ever knowing or proving? So perhaps a better question is: why bother proclaiming you’re an atheist when you can’t prove the theory of Atheism either? ;)



But maybe you’re exploring forums because you’re not truly an atheist either and so you’re naturally trying to find out which “theory” might be best for You to believe? And if you really want to know if God exists, you shouldn’t be asking this forum but rather you have to ask God because that’s the way it works and if so, you’re in luck too because your options are simple too? It’s either True or False that God exists. Which means:

1. False; if God doesn’t exist and you’re content to choose death as your inevitable destiny, then you will die an atheist.

2. True; if God does exist and you choose death instead of eternal life in paradise, then you will die an atheist and then be resurrected only to suffer God’s wrath for eternity instead.



Hmmm, wonder what a sane person would hope for? What were the choices again? Oh ya, it’s either eternal paradise or eternal suffering. Yikes that’s a toughy! Who in their right mind would want to pass up the hope for ‘eternal suffering’? :)


Your choice. :) . . . tick . . . tick . . . tick . . .
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, wonder what a sane person would hope for? What were the choices again? Oh ya, it’s either eternal paradise or eternal suffering. Yikes that’s a toughy! Who in their right mind would want to pass up the hope for ‘eternal suffering’? :)


Your choice. :) . . . tick . . . tick . . . tick . . .

And the evidence for the choices is ...
 
Most simply become obnoxious self-proclaimed experts on the subject of addiction which is sad in a way but really annoying to those who are in earshot.
Yes, it is very annoying when someone preaches at you.

Your next step might be to declare yourself an atheist since you're so miserable?
Why? Many atheists are very happy people.

But here You are now whining like a juvenile in an idiotic forum babbling with cowering anonymous people who are probably laughing at Your ramblings and leading you by the nose to behave just like Them. How's that workin' for ya? But "misery loves company" and you've got plenty of hypocritical cyber-buddies/friends/pals to perish with here which probably also means God probably hasn't even called you yet to properly repent and be baptized in order to save your soul?
So maybe it's God's fault?

Why do you call yourself an atheist when You can’t prove God does not exist any more than Christians can prove God does exist?
For much the same reason that I don't believe in Xenu, the Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechauns and the Easter Bunny - none of which I can prove not to exist.

But maybe you’re exploring forums because you’re not truly an atheist either and so you’re naturally trying to find out which “theory” might be best for You to believe? And if you really want to know if God exists, you shouldn’t be asking this forum but rather you have to ask God because that’s the way it works and if so, you’re in luck too because your options are simple too? It’s either True or False that God exists. Which means:

1. False; if God doesn’t exist and you’re content to choose death as your inevitable destiny, then you will die an atheist.

2. True; if God does exist and you choose death instead of eternal life in paradise, then you will die an atheist and then be resurrected only to suffer God’s wrath for eternity instead.
Pascal's Wager is as flawed today as it was in the Seventeenth Century. It is a false dichotomy: there are more than just those two options. We could all be wrong and God might punish you for worshiping a false deity.

Hmmm, wonder what a sane person would hope for? What were the choices again? Oh ya, it’s either eternal paradise or eternal suffering. Yikes that’s a toughy! Who in their right mind would want to pass up the hope for ‘eternal suffering’? :)
The problem is that there are myriad competing claims about the nature of gods and the universe, and those making the claims offer exactly as much supporting evidence as you do: none at all. Even those Catholics and Mormons are just as convinced as you are that they have know the true path to salvation.


Your choice. :) . . . tick . . . tick . . . tick . . .
You'd better get right with Odin and Freyja if you want to go to Valhalla or Fólkvangr. Tick - tock.
 
Hmmm, wonder what a sane person would hope for? What were the choices again? Oh ya, it’s either eternal paradise or eternal suffering. Yikes that’s a toughy! Who in their right mind would want to pass up the hope for ‘eternal suffering’? :)

Because you either haven't thought about it or haven't grasped the concept:

Do you realize how long eternity is? Sure, it would be okay at first. You would be happy that your god saved you and you would willingly kiss his toes at every opportunity. But soon, after say 1000 years of ass kissing, any "sane" person would be sick of that.

What do you propose to do for eternity, walk through the garden, smell the flowers and pet the Tyrannasaurs? Maybe go skydiving each morning? How long will it take you to get sick of the same old, same old? Well, when you are sick of it, whether it be 100 years, a 1000 years or a million years, you still have an eternity to do it.

It might take you awhile to figure out that paradise is just a euphamism for "hell" but you will.
 
What does it matter if AA is 'religious' or not?

State-sanctioned sessions vs separation of church and state.

I, for one, do not want alcoholics to be fed the "higher power" and "you have no will of your own" nonsense. If they're going to get sober and heal they're better off realizing that they're the ones making the choices.

As well, most addicts are so strung out, they wouldn't know spiritual from schmiritual or religion from schmeligion and God is the Last Thing on their mind if, at all.

That's precisely why the religion must be removed from those groups.

1. False; if God doesn’t exist and you’re content to choose death as your inevitable destiny, then you will die an atheist.

2. True; if God does exist and you choose death instead of eternal life in paradise, then you will die an atheist and then be resurrected only to suffer God’s wrath for eternity instead.

You've forgotten 3, 4, 5, 6 and the 3500+ other choices; notably each and every other religion.

Oh, and some evidence for choices 2+ would be nice.

Hmmm, wonder what a sane person would hope for?

If they're smart they'll go with (1) until further evidence surfaces, instead of presuming that for which they have none, and risk choosing the wrong god anyway.

What were the choices again? Oh ya, it’s either eternal paradise or eternal suffering. Yikes that’s a toughy! Who in their right mind would want to pass up the hope for ‘eternal suffering’? :)

Someone who understands false dichotomies.
 
Dymanic said:
If someone said, "I have psychic powers", and someone else said, "No, you don't", would that be an attack on the person, or the argument?
As soon as that happens in the thread, we'll let you know."
"Sorry, no analogies allowed here".

Dancing David said:
I don't usually say that, I ask, what leads you to beleive that you have psychic powers?
"Though I was quick to follow qayak's lead in criticizing your argument as an ad hom, I'm no more interested than he is in supporting that by making any attempt at a direct answer to the question you asked".
 

The Washington Post thinks this is "News"????? Way to NOT do your research Michelle Boorstein.

A.A.’s Bill Wilson: A Christian Obscured from View
By Dick B.
© 2009 Dick B. All rights reserved

The Timeline of Bill Wilson Evidence

1. The East Dorset Congregational Church of East Dorset, Vermont—Wilson family church

Bill Wilson’s grandparents, the Wilsons, were among the founders of this church, and our examination of the church records and papers showed that the Wilson family owned Pew 15 in that church.

2. Bill Wilson’s paternal grandfather, William C. (“Willie”) Wilson—his conversion cure

Grandpa “Willie” was a long-time member of the East Dorset Congregational Church and a frequent participant in temperance and revival meetings. But Willie was beset with a ferocious drinking problem. Finally, he turned directly to God. He went to the top of nearby Mount Aeolus, cried out to God for help, and had a “white light” experience very similar to that which Bill Wilson had many years later at Towns Hospital. Grandpa Willie rushed down to the pulpit of the little East Dorset Congregational Church, announced that he had been saved, and never drank again—dying sober some 8 years later. This is an account Bill Wilson’s mother told over and over.

Edited by Locknar: 
<snip>...breach of Rule 4.


“To my friend
Dr. Jesse M. Bader
Yours in Christ
Bill Wilson
1/13/43”

Edited by Locknar: 
<snip>...breach of Rule 4


16. AAs, Twelve Step fellowships, churches, clergy, and professionals need to learn the
foregoing facts. Their evidentiary value lies in the following: (1) There is a pressing
importance today for Christians in the recovery arena to learn that they are not alone, that their beliefs and practices are the same as those held by the Christians Dr. Robert H. Smith and William G. Wilson who founded the A.A. recovery movement. (2) These same Christians need to know that their early fellowship itself was a Christian fellowship. (3) They need to know that there is nothing prohibitive in their present-day beliefs, principles, and practices that parallel those of the co-founders and of the early program. (4) They need to learn that the A.A. program today has been substantially changed and revised, that the facts about the Christian roots have been eliminated from view, and that there are those publishing literature and vocalizing in the fellowship today who are fostering a program of unbelief, of suppression of religious expressions, and intimidating those who rightfully tell in their own language and from their own point of view how they established their relationship with God. (5) They need to recognize how important it is to know that those who followed the early program achieved a documented 75% to 93 % success rate among those who really tried. (6) And they need to know that the diversity of religious and non-religious beliefs, the anti-Christian talk, and the provocative idolatry in literature and in meetings has no authority or governance, or control over any present-day efforts to recover today, wherever that recovery takes place, employing the same successful methods used by the early Christian fellowship of A.A. itself. Suppression of free belief and expression have no place in saving the lives of alcoholics, addicts, and those with life-controlling problem who want to recover today with the power of God. Without that knowledge, the freedom of alcoholics, addicts, and those with other life-controlling problems to believe, speak, and practice what the early AAs did and what they may choose to do will be in grave jeopardy. As will the very lives of believers.

Gloria Deo

Again, the attempts to "Universalize" AA do very little to hide its Protestant Christian Doctrines (which remain intact despite a few word changes), and NOTHING to hide its more generally Religious nature. Dick B's admonitions against the "watering down" of AA (and his acceptance of the dubious success claims) notwithstanding, he has thoroughly documented AA's Protestant core and roots (Michelle Boorstein could learn a thing or two about Research from Dick B).

And Again, a Universalist Religious Organization is still a Religious Organization.

Having taken a much needed vacation, I have caught back up with this thread. I see the AA Proselytizers have still not provided any evidence to back up their claims that AA is not religious, just more of the same Untestable Anecdotes, Red Herrings, and Sophistry.

There was a feeble attempt some pages back (I think by Dymanic) to create a False Distinction between a Religion and a Religious Organization. It really shouldn't have been difficult to point out to Dymanic that a Religion is The Set of Beliefs and Doctrines surrounding the Worship of a Deity or Deities, and that a Religious Organization is (1) a Group of People dedicated to the Practice of Said Religion (i.e. a Church), or (2) an Adjunctive Group based on Said Religion (i.e. faith-based Charities, faith-based Youth Groups, or faith-based Support Groups ;) ).

AA, like all Religious Organizations, is an Organization engaged in promoting Religion.

The fact that some local chapters and 12 Step based support groups have attempted to further Secularize the Steps (or adapt them to another Religion), doesn't alter the Step's intrinsically Religious (Protestant) Doctrines, nor does it alter the fact that the Central Organization of AA is a Religious Organization.

GB
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You would be happy that your god saved you and you would willingly kiss his toes at every opportunity. But soon, after say 1000 years of ass kissing, any "sane" person would be sick of that.

Ah yes, I remember that part of the big book, that said "in eternal paradise, the kissing of God's toes will be a daily obligatory ritual". Er... actually no, it doesn't. :boggled:

At the risk of further off topic comment, surely Q, any requirement like this would actually negate the concept of paradise. But some might consider kissing gods toes for eternity paradise, some not. Where in the big book does AA say that paradise is uniform for all?

We seem to have drifted a long way since our interesting post above, and frankly has become rather off topic.


The group's decision to use "higher power" and "God of your understanding" instead of "God" or "Jesus Christ" and to adopt a more inclusive tone was enormously important in making the deeply spiritual text accessible to the non-religious and non-Christian, AA historians and treatment experts say.

Again this supports what I have been saying all along: AA was founded in religious roots, genuine efforts were made to make it inclusive to all through a softening of some words - not the entire HISTORICAL text (I can yell too guys), and further change has been resisted to date: any further changes will be made by worldwide group conscience.
For those that don't like it, they are free to gather support for the changes they wish; when there is sufficient support then things will change.

Interestingly, many tens of thousands of atheists and agnostics worldwide use AA today (I base this on extrapolation of personal observation). Why are they successful? I can only imagine it is because they don't get too hung up on this God stuff and look at the bigger, more important picture, that of their sobriety.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You would be happy that your god saved you and you would willingly kiss his toes at every opportunity. But soon, after say 1000 years of ass kissing, any "sane" person would be sick of that.

Ah yes, I remember that part of the big book, that said "in eternal paradise, the kissing of God's toes will be a daily obligatory ritual". Er... actually no, it doesn't. :boggled:

At the risk of further off topic comment, surely Q, any requirement like this would actually negate the concept of paradise. But some might consider kissing gods toes for eternity paradise, some not. Where in the big book does AA say that paradise is uniform for all?

We seem to have drifted a long way since our interesting post above, and frankly has become rather off topic.

Step away from the Kool-Aid, Alfie.

Internet Ministry's crazy rantings have no bearing on AA's religousity. My response to IM's crazy rantings has no bearing on AA's religousity.

I do find it interesting that you think it important that you comment on this trivial, and off topic, post of mine but refuse to address any of the issues I have brought up in other posts. Specifically, that you provide some evidence that shows that AA is not religious or a religious organization.

My response to IM was just a way to kill time while I waited for you to gather your resources and respond.

Still waiting.
 
I'm still curious why people insist AA is not religious. Is it because they genuinely think it isn't?

It's really hard to tell sometimes. Some of the arguments are so disingenuous, it's hard to see how they could be made without a measure of self-awareness. In the case Alfie above, he simply puts people whose arguments he can't refute on an ignore list . Thus he can't see my post immediately before his, that refutes every argument he just proffered. :rolleyes:

The deliberateness of that act suggests that he recognizes the weakness of his argument on some level, perhaps only subconsciously whilst consciously being completely genuine in his assertion that AA is not religious.

But not being Psychic, I can't be entirely certain. ;)

GB
 
"Immersion" doesn't mean "belief".
I disagree. "Immersion" requires belief. I'll state it more strongly than that. "Immersion" means belief, for some values of "belief".

This is central to the argument I've been making here all along. Addiction (in my layman's opinion) arises out of irrational thinking/feeling that takes place on levels to which we have limited access, at best.

I think it would be difficult to make a good argument that fear of heights is entirely irrational. If it prevents one from engaging in activities that offer a decent risk/benefit payoff (which, to me, would include air travel, but not rock climbing), then it may become irrational -- but an inability to acknowledge real danger is just as irrational as being obsessed with dangers that do not exist. A person with a very great need to travel by air might attempt to assuage his fears by reminding himself that statistically it is much safer than travel by automobile -- but he can't simply reach down inside himself and turn off his fear by flipping some inner switch. For a God-believer, it would be a snap: in God's hands and all that. The atheist might have to work a little harder, but what I propose is that in dealing with the irrational, one need not limit one's self solely to what is rational. Sort of a "Render unto Caesar" kinda thing.

A person in the grips of an addiction often needs similar reassurance. If drugs and/or alcohol have become his only means of coping, and if he is convinced that he simply cannot quit, he needs to believe that he can quit, and that if he does, his whole world won't fall apart -- or, if the evidence overwhelmingly indicates that it will (as was the case for me personally) -- that things will somehow turn out ok anyway.

Dymanic said:
If that were true, there wouldn't be any movies, because there wouldn't be any actors. No rock and roll stars either. Or artists.
Wha ? What does that have to do with anythin' ?
A rational evaluation of the evidence will indicate that the odds are overwhelmingly against any one individual (skill notwithstanding) being among the vanishingly small percentage who achieve success in these endeavors. Sometimes success depends on ignoring the evidence and believing in the impossible (or the near impossible, or the apparently impossible)..
 
I'm still curious why people insist AA is not religious. Is it because they genuinely think it isn't?

I think so, although others reading the posts of those who think AA is not religious may draw a different conclusion.

I think a lot of what I see as dishonest arguing is really an attempt by others to reduce their own dissonance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom