Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Aaalfie, your statement 'AA is what one wants to make it' is completely false, without evidence, and contrary to those documents which contain the AA program itself. If it's 'whatever you want to make it', then hell, just go to a support group and discuss potential solutions with other struggling folks (by the way, that is called SOS/Rational Recovery - that's what goes on at SOS meetings 'what one wants to make it' without all the godbothering).
And you keep going on about 'the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking' , however, there are 2 problems (at the least) with that statement:

1. It refers to 'membership' only, in a very technical sense, not anything related to 'Practicing the AA program to get, and stay sober' which is, after all, the whole point of membership - otherwise, why bother? What other benefit does AA claim membership provides??
2. The rest of the book does state what's necessary (the program uses 'suggested' such as 'I suggest you do this, if not you'll die, or end up in an insane ward - but they are just suggestions!! cough cough) - using statements such as 'our primary purpose is to develop a relationship with a Power greater than ourselves' and such as ' No human power could relieve our alcoholism, but God could and would if He were sought' etc.
Claiming AA is whatever you want to make it is simply foolishness & unsupportable - if you're not doing the AA program of clean house and trust in god, then you're doing something else - if it works for you, well great!! - but it's not AA.
 
Speaking of lies... evidence please. :rolleyes:

and

A poorly veiled accusation was made about AAers (my and others) honesty and my response was to same. If there was a better way to respond other than my so called platitude, I would like to hear it. Have you any suggestions?


So if it's poorly veiled, you bristle at the inference, but have no problems with telling someone that they are liars? So you won't mind then if others in this thread blatantly call you a liar as long as there is no veil. Gotcha.

My suggestion is to use some of your hard-earned counselor skills and make some assertive statements regarding your understanding of that implication. My understanding is that you won't do such a thing, but it's an honest answer to your honest question of what I would theoretically do.



It is not personal anecdote to point out that the steps are "suggested" and the third tradition states there are no requirements for membership "except a desire to stop drinking".

There have been many personal anecdotes on both sides, my own included, and it was to these that I was responding.

As I said earlier, it is inductive reasoning to go from specifics to general and that's what is being done here.



As we have time and again conceded, there are elements in the original big book text that are religious (written by a religious man/men), we have also ackowledged that there are groups (especially in the states) that are religious.
Does that make AA as a whole religious? Hardly.


As has been amply demonstrated, there is far more religiosity than mere "elements" in the big book, the 12 by 12, and all official AA literature. It is far more than "elements" when the vast majority of AA meetings are closed with the Lord's Prayer for example and it takes a vote of a home group meeting to even change it ("group conscience" doncha know).


-------------

I would like to take a moment to thank all the participants in this thread, both "sides" of the debate, for it's really helped me quite a bit in sharpening my own attitudes towards sobriety, AA, and what would be more effective for me.
 
If there's a completely sane logic to rock climbing, I probably wouldn't understand it even if you could explain it (especially if it involves climbing backwards, as you seem to suggest).

Sane logic ? Rock climbers want to climb. The point is they need to remain aware of the danger.

If that were true, there wouldn't be any movies, because there wouldn't be any actors. No rock and roll stars either. Or artists.

Wha ? What does that have to do with anythin' ?

The poster implicitly claimed immunity from an "affliction" with which he alleges that other posters here are "infected": magical thinking. My counterargument (regardless of whether you are capable of recognizing it as such) is that that IS a form of magical thinking.

Boy, can everyone use this kind of argument...
 
Speaking of lies... evidence please. :rolleyes:

This thread. Read it.

A charter? Like the 12 traditions?
Have you actually read them?

Yes, I have and they do not speak to the rights of the individual or minority, only to the rights of the "group" or "group conscience."

That's a fail on your part.

Tradition 2 is especially revealing in regard to the religious views allowed in AA. Your claim that an individual is free to hold their own believe is obviously made up in your mind as this tradition holds that "there is but one ultimate authority - a loving God as He may express Himself in our group conscience."

It is not personal anecdote to point out that the steps are "suggested" and the third tradition states there are no requirements for membership "except a desire to stop drinking".

What about the fifth tradition that states the primary purpose of AA is to carry the message? Doesn't that pretty much shoot to hell your claim that there is no proselytizing in AA.

"Each group has but one primary purpose - to carry it's message to the alcoholic who still suffers."

As we have time and again conceded, there are elements in the original big book text that are religious . . .

Although that is true, there are also many elements in current AA literature, steps, traditions, Big Book, etc., that are very religious.
 
Dancing David, I 100% agree with this statement you made:


"The definition of addiction is the behaviors not the substance."

Although I certainly cannot effectively argue with someone such as yourself, as you know more about it than I do, might I suggest that your statement seems to relate to mine in at least a roundabout way; that is, if the definition of addiction is behavior, then my phrase 'alcohol isn't addictive' or the phrase 'alcohol is addictive' by Aaalfie are both improper ways to phrase the questions (as both claims seem to me to be defining the addiction by the chemical used, not by the abuse behavior (which is and has been my contention for years, that is - that alcoholism is learned behavior that, through proper therapy & other techniques, can be unlearned once the immediate physical effects of alcohol have been removed, such as by a brief hospital stay).
Yes and no, it seems that some people have a biological prediposition to alcohol dependence. Other than that absolutely.
In other words, I tend to argue when someone makes the blanket statement 'alcohol is addictive' since the phrasing blames the chemical, not the behavior (hence removing responsibility from the individuals behavior).
Well some people seem to have a biological basis to the vulnerability.
This also ties in with my disagreement with AA's 'disease' model of addiction, since AA makes the blanket statement that alcohol abuse is a sin (variously phrased as 'caused by defects in character', or caused by 'shortcomings') -it seems to me that all of these are moral statements, not disease statements.
I don't like the term disease and especially not the moral stuff.
Of course AA starts off with a disease statement (The chapter 'The Doctor's Opinion') and then quickly replaces that using a bait & switch with the 'Sin' type of statements I noted above - the 12 steps certainly don't reference any 'disease', what they reference - and proclaim to treat - is a 'spiritual', 'moral', or 'sinful' condition.
And how does AA promote treatment of this 'spiritual' disease? Why of course, by getting closer to god - by developing & maintaining a relationship with a 'power' greater than ourselves.
A proven ineffective treatment.

Thanks for your comments Dancing David, I learn something new (hopefully) every thread.

As I have stated the problem with treatment analysis is the longitude of the study. Then demographic matching, you also can't have random assignment either.
 
Last edited:
Some behaviours and substances are mood altering but not addictive.

Some mood altering substances are only addictive to some people.


Well addiction is the behaviors, the withdrawal profile, addictive profile and biological vulnerability are compounding infuences, but the behaviors are the defintion.
 
I saw no counterargument. I saw a personal attack by calling him a superhero, I'm guessing to imply that he considers himself perfect or better than alcoholics. Maybe you would clarify your "counterargument"?
I'm not the least bit surprised that qayak missed my point there, and only slightly less surprised that you did, but I would have expected DD to get it at least.

I don't see much room to question whether the poster was claiming a superior position to that of anyone "infected" with the "magical thinking affliction". If there's a way to challenge that without incurring some risk of at least nicking the person making that claim, I might have found it if I had taken more time. As it is, I am offline at home due to a hard disk crash on Friday, and won't be able to devote more than a few minutes to it now (or anytime before I get that problem solved). I would also have thought that a careful review of that entire exchange might have made my argument clearer, but as I was apparently mistaken about that, I'll try to condense it:

It's part of an argument I've been making since very early in the discussion: Humans are hard-wired for "magical thinking". It's the very reason that such a thing as the "scientific method" exists, and the reason that critical thinking requires continuous effort and committment. I invoked "Reality Man" as a reductio ad absurdum metaphor to emphasize the point that to fancy one's self immune to magical thinking is itself a fantasy.

My position, relative to this context, is that there is a time for critical thinking, and a time to turn it off -- just like Tom Hanks' character in the movie "Castaway" did when he invented "Wilson" (an example I suggested much earlier in the thread).
 
Last edited:
I'm not the least bit surprised that qayak missed my point there, and only slightly less surprised that you did, but I would have expected DD to get it at least.

I don't see much room to question whether the poster was claiming a superior position to that of anyone "infected" with the "magical thinking affliction". If there's a way to challenge that without incurring some risk of at least nicking the person making that claim, I might have found it if I had taken more time. As it is, I am offline at home due to a hard disk crash on Friday, and won't be able to devote more than a few minutes to it now (or anytime before I get that problem solved). I would also have thought that a careful review of that entire exchange might have made my argument clearer, but as I was apparently mistaken about that, I'll try to condense it:

It's part of an argument I've been making since very early in the discussion: Humans are hard-wired for "magical thinking". It's the very reason that such a thing as the "scientific method" exists, and the reason that critical thinking requires continuous effort and committment. I invoked "Reality Man" as a reductio ad absurdum metaphor to emphasize the point that to fancy one's self immune to magical thinking is itself a fantasy.

My position, relative to this context, is that there is a time for critical thinking, and a time to turn it off -- just like Tom Hanks' character in the movie "Castaway" did when he invented "Wilson" (an example I suggested much earlier in the thread).

Speaking for myself, I got your argument from the first time you posted and I agree with it in the sense that it true of any individual to some degree or other.

However, I disregard it for a few reasons:

1) It is not a valid position to hold in a discussion on a specific topic.

2) It was used in an attempt to discount someone's argument without considering the merits of the argument.

3) That someone is guilty of magic think on other subjects does not take away from their position on subjects where they are not guilty of it.
 
Well addiction is the behaviors, the withdrawal profile, addictive profile and biological vulnerability are compounding infuences, but the behaviors are the defintion.

Can you explain a little more, or point me to a source? I don't really get that from reading definitions from various groups on the internet.

Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom