Aaalfie, your statement 'AA is what one wants to make it' is completely false, without evidence, and contrary to those documents which contain the AA program itself. If it's 'whatever you want to make it', then hell, just go to a support group and discuss potential solutions with other struggling folks (by the way, that is called SOS/Rational Recovery - that's what goes on at SOS meetings 'what one wants to make it' without all the godbothering).
And you keep going on about 'the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking' , however, there are 2 problems (at the least) with that statement:
1. It refers to 'membership' only, in a very technical sense, not anything related to 'Practicing the AA program to get, and stay sober' which is, after all, the whole point of membership - otherwise, why bother? What other benefit does AA claim membership provides??
2. The rest of the book does state what's necessary (the program uses 'suggested' such as 'I suggest you do this, if not you'll die, or end up in an insane ward - but they are just suggestions!! cough cough) - using statements such as 'our primary purpose is to develop a relationship with a Power greater than ourselves' and such as ' No human power could relieve our alcoholism, but God could and would if He were sought' etc.
Claiming AA is whatever you want to make it is simply foolishness & unsupportable - if you're not doing the AA program of clean house and trust in god, then you're doing something else - if it works for you, well great!! - but it's not AA.
And you keep going on about 'the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking' , however, there are 2 problems (at the least) with that statement:
1. It refers to 'membership' only, in a very technical sense, not anything related to 'Practicing the AA program to get, and stay sober' which is, after all, the whole point of membership - otherwise, why bother? What other benefit does AA claim membership provides??
2. The rest of the book does state what's necessary (the program uses 'suggested' such as 'I suggest you do this, if not you'll die, or end up in an insane ward - but they are just suggestions!! cough cough) - using statements such as 'our primary purpose is to develop a relationship with a Power greater than ourselves' and such as ' No human power could relieve our alcoholism, but God could and would if He were sought' etc.
Claiming AA is whatever you want to make it is simply foolishness & unsupportable - if you're not doing the AA program of clean house and trust in god, then you're doing something else - if it works for you, well great!! - but it's not AA.