Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm still curious why people insist AA is not religious. Is it because they genuinely think it isn't?
Actually yes, I genuinely think it isn't.

The AA Organization and Meetings, and religious rites and ceremonies, have zero correlation. No preachers, priests, rabbis, sufis or whatever-floats-your-boat exist.
 
Actually yes, I genuinely think it isn't.

The AA Organization and Meetings, and religious rites and ceremonies, have zero correlation. No preachers, priests, rabbis, sufis or whatever-floats-your-boat exist.

Earlier I posted a list of correlates. Which reminds me....

The original question of this thread was not, "Is AA religious," but, "Why do people insist AA is not religious?" Possible answers....

1. They don't realize it is. (Refer to my list of correlates.)
2. Wishful thinking.
 
Last edited:
Actually yes, I genuinely think it isn't.

The AA Organization and Meetings, and religious rites and ceremonies, have zero correlation. No preachers, priests, rabbis, sufis or whatever-floats-your-boat exist.

doglaugh.gif


Do you have everyone on your ignore list too?

GB
 
Nope.

Nothing new has been said in this thread for 38 pages:
Is! IsNot! Is! IsNot!

And no one is going to change their respective minds. Mmmmkay?
 
A person with a very great need to travel by air might attempt to assuage his fears by reminding himself that statistically it is much safer than travel by automobile -- but he can't simply reach down inside himself and turn off his fear by flipping some inner switch. For a God-believer, it would be a snap: in God's hands and all that. The atheist might have to work a little harder, but what I propose is that in dealing with the irrational, one need not limit one's self solely to what is rational. Sort of a "Render unto Caesar" kinda thing.

A snap? Really? That would mean that only atheists are bothered by phobias, because Christians could just tell themselves their problems are in God's hands, and the fear would go away.

Having known people who profess to be Christians who also appear to suffer from irrational fears, I doubt that. Got any evidence that Christians can stop fear due to phobias so easily?

I might even propose the opposite: that people who have trouble dealing with irrational fears are more apt to be religious because they're desperate for any comfort and are trying anything, even if it doesn't help. Which is fairly close to what you're saying, if I understand it--religion is a way for desperate people to try to find comfort, and it's why the "higher power" concept is useful for desperate alcoholics. But if it actually solved problems so easily, I'd expect the success rate to be much higher.
 
Nope.

Nothing new has been said in this thread for 38 pages:
Is! IsNot! Is! IsNot!

And no one is going to change their respective minds. Mmmmkay?

That may be so. But at least "is so Religious" has Evidence on "our" side. ;)

GB
 
A snap? Really? That would mean that only atheists are bothered by phobias, because Christians could just tell themselves their problems are in God's hands, and the fear would go away.

Having known people who profess to be Christians who also appear to suffer from irrational fears, I doubt that. Got any evidence that Christians can stop fear due to phobias so easily?

I might even propose the opposite: that people who have trouble dealing with irrational fears are more apt to be religious because they're desperate for any comfort and are trying anything, even if it doesn't help. Which is fairly close to what you're saying, if I understand it--religion is a way for desperate people to try to find comfort, and it's why the "higher power" concept is useful for desperate alcoholics. But if it actually solved problems so easily, I'd expect the success rate to be much higher.

This is why I think some of Dymanic's arguments are actually scoring a "goal" for the "is so Religious" side. He sometimes seems to be making the case for us when he takes this tack.

GB
 
Specifically, that you provide some evidence that shows that AA is not religious or a religious organization.

"Asked and answered" is a favourite of yours, isn't it? :rolleyes:

Actually yes, I genuinely think it isn't.

The AA Organization and Meetings, and religious rites and ceremonies, have zero correlation. No preachers, priests, rabbis, sufis or whatever-floats-your-boat exist.

Precisely.
No one has yet outlined exactly what god or set of religious beliefs are being followed.
That said, I think a certain argument could be made that in the states, there are large pockets of religious groups, that in itself does not make AA as a whole religious.

Earlier I posted a list of correlates. Which reminds me....

The original question of this thread was not, "Is AA religious," but, "Why do people insist AA is not religious?" Possible answers....

1. They don't realize it is. (Refer to my list of correlates.)
2. Wishful thinking.

3. It isn't
4. It is in some parts but not others
5. It can be if one chooses it to be.
 
"Asked and answered" is a favourite of yours, isn't it? :rolleyes:

Yes, it is. Of course, when I type it, you only need go back a post or two in order to find the last time the question was answered. I have looked through this entire thread and you have, in fact, not answered.

It is a subtle but important difference between our debating styles.

No one has yet outlined exactly what god or set of religious beliefs are being followed.

Not true.

That said, I think a certain argument could be made that in the states, there are large pockets of religious groups, that in itself does not make AA as a whole religious.

That's true. It's AA's literature and practices that make it religious.

3. It isn't

Already proved false.

4. It is in some parts but not others

Irrelevent as shown by your own words.

5. It can be if one chooses it to be.

Already proved false by your own words.
 
Yes, it is. Of course, when I type it, you only need go back a post or two in order to find the last time the question was answered. I have looked through this entire thread and you have, in fact, not answered.

And yet no evidence.

Not true.

Really?

Already proved false.

Rrriiiight. :boggled:

Irrelevent as shown by your own words.

Um.. OK.

Already proved false by your own words.

Huh?

Where's my irony meter?
 
"Asked and answered" is a favourite of yours, isn't it? :rolleyes:

Precisely.
No one has yet outlined exactly what god or set of religious beliefs are being followed.

And this BS is both an example of the disingenuity that makes claims of being genuine and honest dubious, and a perfect example of how "asked an answered" is sometimes the only deserved response to such BS.

It has been outlined in detail and proven exactly which God and set of Religious Beliefs are being followed (Protestant, and Protestant thinly disguised as Universalist), and, as Qayak points out, in posts right next to Alfie's own.

Ah, but he can't see them, because he either has these Inconvenient Truths on his ignore list, or he just willfully wears Blinders when posted by someone he has yet to put on his ignore list.

GB
 
Due to the Mod editing of some of the most key material in the following post, I am posting the link so that the Documentary Evidence contained in Dick B's post is available for your perusal:


The Washington Post thinks this is "News"????? Way to NOT do your research Michelle Boorstein.

A.A.’s Bill Wilson: A Christian Obscured from View
By Dick B.
© 2009 Dick B. All rights reserved

The Timeline of Bill Wilson Evidence

1. The East Dorset Congregational Church of East Dorset, Vermont—Wilson family church

Bill Wilson’s grandparents, the Wilsons, were among the founders of this church, and our examination of the church records and papers showed that the Wilson family owned Pew 15 in that church.

2. Bill Wilson’s paternal grandfather, William C. (“Willie”) Wilson—his conversion cure

Grandpa “Willie” was a long-time member of the East Dorset Congregational Church and a frequent participant in temperance and revival meetings. But Willie was beset with a ferocious drinking problem. Finally, he turned directly to God. He went to the top of nearby Mount Aeolus, cried out to God for help, and had a “white light” experience very similar to that which Bill Wilson had many years later at Towns Hospital. Grandpa Willie rushed down to the pulpit of the little East Dorset Congregational Church, announced that he had been saved, and never drank again—dying sober some 8 years later. This is an account Bill Wilson’s mother told over and over.

Edited by Locknar: <snip>...breach of Rule 4.


“To my friend
Dr. Jesse M. Bader
Yours in Christ
Bill Wilson
1/13/43”

Edited by Locknar: <snip>...breach of Rule 4


16. AAs, Twelve Step fellowships, churches, clergy, and professionals need to learn the
foregoing facts. Their evidentiary value lies in the following: (1) There is a pressing
importance today for Christians in the recovery arena to learn that they are not alone, that their beliefs and practices are the same as those held by the Christians Dr. Robert H. Smith and William G. Wilson who founded the A.A. recovery movement. (2) These same Christians need to know that their early fellowship itself was a Christian fellowship. (3) They need to know that there is nothing prohibitive in their present-day beliefs, principles, and practices that parallel those of the co-founders and of the early program. (4) They need to learn that the A.A. program today has been substantially changed and revised, that the facts about the Christian roots have been eliminated from view, and that there are those publishing literature and vocalizing in the fellowship today who are fostering a program of unbelief, of suppression of religious expressions, and intimidating those who rightfully tell in their own language and from their own point of view how they established their relationship with God. (5) They need to recognize how important it is to know that those who followed the early program achieved a documented 75% to 93 % success rate among those who really tried. (6) And they need to know that the diversity of religious and non-religious beliefs, the anti-Christian talk, and the provocative idolatry in literature and in meetings has no authority or governance, or control over any present-day efforts to recover today, wherever that recovery takes place, employing the same successful methods used by the early Christian fellowship of A.A. itself. Suppression of free belief and expression have no place in saving the lives of alcoholics, addicts, and those with life-controlling problem who want to recover today with the power of God. Without that knowledge, the freedom of alcoholics, addicts, and those with other life-controlling problems to believe, speak, and practice what the early AAs did and what they may choose to do will be in grave jeopardy. As will the very lives of believers.

Gloria Deo

Again, the attempts to "Universalize" AA do very little to hide its Protestant Christian Doctrines (which remain intact despite a few word changes), and NOTHING to hide its more generally Religious nature. Dick B's admonitions against the "watering down" of AA (and his acceptance of the dubious success claims) notwithstanding, he has thoroughly documented AA's Protestant core and roots (Michelle Boorstein could learn a thing or two about Research from Dick B).

And Again, a Universalist Religious Organization is still a Religious Organization.

Having taken a much needed vacation, I have caught back up with this thread. I see the AA Proselytizers have still not provided any evidence to back up their claims that AA is not religious, just more of the same Untestable Anecdotes, Red Herrings, and Sophistry.

There was a feeble attempt some pages back (I think by Dymanic) to create a False Distinction between a Religion and a Religious Organization. It really shouldn't have been difficult to point out to Dymanic that a Religion is The Set of Beliefs and Doctrines surrounding the Worship of a Deity or Deities, and that a Religious Organization is (1) a Group of People dedicated to the Practice of Said Religion (i.e. a Church), or (2) an Adjunctive Group based on Said Religion (i.e. faith-based Charities, faith-based Youth Groups, or faith-based Support Groups ;) ).

AA, like all Religious Organizations, is an Organization engaged in promoting Religion.

The fact that some local chapters and 12 Step based support groups have attempted to further Secularize the Steps (or adapt them to another Religion), doesn't alter the Step's intrinsically Religious (Protestant) Doctrines, nor does it alter the fact that the Central Organization of AA is a Religious Organization.

GB

The rest of the Dick B's article contained in my post can be found at the following site:

http://www.cyberrecovery.net/forums/showthread.php?t=22340

It is Concise, Thorough, and Conclusive. Despite some obvious differences between his and my perspectives, I dare say that Dick B's material is more Empirically Grounded than that of the allegedly "non-theist" AA members posting on this thread who continue to insist that AA isn't Religious.

GB
 
Last edited:
Precisely.
No one has yet outlined exactly what god or set of religious beliefs are being followed.

Even aside from all the evidence that the organization was based with the Christian Protestant god in mind, I don't see why an organization has to follow a specific set of religious beliefs to be a religious organization, as long as it encourages members to adopt some religious beliefs. "God as we understand Him" certainly fits within that.
 
I disagree. "Immersion" requires belief. I'll state it more strongly than that. "Immersion" means belief, for some values of "belief".

Then under your definition I am never immersed while watching a movie or other work of fiction.

This is central to the argument I've been making here all along.

Well, that explains it, then...

Addiction (in my layman's opinion) arises out of irrational thinking/feeling that takes place on levels to which we have limited access, at best.

I don't know. I have problems restraining myself when it comes to food; I guess you could call it an additction or obsession. But it is entirely my call, every time.

I think it would be difficult to make a good argument that fear of heights is entirely irrational. If it prevents one from engaging in activities that offer a decent risk/benefit payoff

Good example: I have fear of heights; even in situations which pose no danger to me whatsoever. In that respect it IS irrational.

A person in the grips of an addiction often needs similar reassurance. If drugs and/or alcohol have become his only means of coping, and if he is convinced that he simply cannot quit, he needs to believe that he can quit

Absolutely. But teaching him that he indeed _cannot_ quit without some higher power is dangerous, at best.
 
A snap? Really? That would mean that only atheists are bothered by phobias, because Christians could just tell themselves their problems are in God's hands, and the fear would go away.

Having known people who profess to be Christians who also appear to suffer from irrational fears, I doubt that. Got any evidence that Christians can stop fear due to phobias so easily?

I might even propose the opposite: that people who have trouble dealing with irrational fears are more apt to be religious because they're desperate for any comfort and are trying anything, even if it doesn't help. Which is fairly close to what you're saying, if I understand it--religion is a way for desperate people to try to find comfort, and it's why the "higher power" concept is useful for desperate alcoholics. But if it actually solved problems so easily, I'd expect the success rate to be much higher.

I think you've just won the thread.
 
Even aside from all the evidence that the organization was based with the Christian Protestant god in mind, I don't see why an organization has to follow a specific set of religious beliefs to be a religious organization, as long as it encourages members to adopt some religious beliefs. "God as we understand Him" certainly fits within that.

If that is the basis for the discussion, then you would be right and I would concede. But it isn't, and that is why atheists and agnostics world wide fit snugly into the fellowship of AA; because there is no requirement to adopt religious beliefs (nothwithstanding the concessions I make with some "corners of the states").

Absolutely. But teaching him that he indeed _cannot_ quit without some higher power is dangerous, at best.

What is this "danger" and "harm" that keeps coming up; there has yet to be an explanation and I am honestly confused.

Could you please explain what the apparent danger and harm is?

Speak for yourself...

Are you suggesting you could be convinced that AA is not a religious organisation? Frankly I doubt it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom