Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You don't.
I am the only one who will truly know; but it is an honest program ....:)

I notice the smillie...apparently you understand just how dishonest the program "is", (Lying to yourself by "faking it till you make it") and you somehow think that funny...

What a sick sense of humour.
 
How would it make AA work by removing the word god, if it doesn't work now?

And the same question can be asked of you: How will the removal of god stop AA from working, if it works now?

If Tinyal et al wish to make a fellowship that is more inclusive, then I suggest they start their own or join another. Either that or they wait until the rest of the fellowship is ready.

Why can't they just change the group conscience of AA?
 
Judges -- Supreme Court Judges, in fact -- have also consistently ruled that corporations are "persons" insofar as Constitutional rights are concerned. If that isn't enough to call into question the validity of the argument by court ruling method we're seeing attempted here, I could probably round up a sampling of other rulings that should drive the point home.


No, it isn't "argument by court ruling", it's called inductive reasoning. It's a way to find some level of objectivity in a difficult conceptual discourse.


My favorite passage in the Big Book has always been this, from page 133 of the third edition:

"One of the many doctors who had the opportunity of reading this book in manuscript form told us that the use of sweets was often helpful, of course depending upon a doctor's advice. He thought all alcoholics should constantly have chocolate available for its quick energy value at times of fatigue. He added that occasionally in the night a vague craving arose which would be satisfied by candy. Many of us have noticed a tendency to eat sweets and have found this practice beneficial."

So much for the Big Book as a source of medical authority.

But that's not the question at issue here, is it?


I'm not quoting the Big Book as a source of medical authority either. I believe the statement was made that no one has made a claim that AA was extremely effective. In their own book, AAers proudly claim that it is.

The other quotes are from others who aren't necessarily alcoholics, but praise AA as being spiritual and religious. In other words, it's a common perception that AA organization itself does nothing to hide -- on the contrary, it practically flaunts its religiosity.
 
Dancing David, I 100% agree with this statement you made:


"The definition of addiction is the behaviors not the substance."

Although I certainly cannot effectively argue with someone such as yourself, as you know more about it than I do, might I suggest that your statement seems to relate to mine in at least a roundabout way; that is, if the definition of addiction is behavior, then my phrase 'alcohol isn't addictive' or the phrase 'alcohol is addictive' by Aaalfie are both improper ways to phrase the questions (as both claims seem to me to be defining the addiction by the chemical used, not by the abuse behavior (which is and has been my contention for years, that is - that alcoholism is learned behavior that, through proper therapy & other techniques, can be unlearned once the immediate physical effects of alcohol have been removed, such as by a brief hospital stay).
In other words, I tend to argue when someone makes the blanket statement 'alcohol is addictive' since the phrasing blames the chemical, not the behavior (hence removing responsibility from the individuals behavior). This also ties in with my disagreement with AA's 'disease' model of addiction, since AA makes the blanket statement that alcohol abuse is a sin (variously phrased as 'caused by defects in character', or caused by 'shortcomings') -it seems to me that all of these are moral statements, not disease statements. Of course AA starts off with a disease statement (The chapter 'The Doctor's Opinion') and then quickly replaces that using a bait & switch with the 'Sin' type of statements I noted above - the 12 steps certainly don't reference any 'disease', what they reference - and proclaim to treat - is a 'spiritual', 'moral', or 'sinful' condition.
And how does AA promote treatment of this 'spiritual' disease? Why of course, by getting closer to god - by developing & maintaining a relationship with a 'power' greater than ourselves.
A proven ineffective treatment.

Thanks for your comments Dancing David, I learn something new (hopefully) every thread.
 
It is when your opponent is speaking in absolutes.


Then please address those who are not speaking in absolutes and present your evidence refuting them.



Please demonstrate where I or others have displayed magical thinking. What quyak did is build a strawman and then argue against that.


Could you point out that strawman and how it was a misrepresentation of the argument to which he was responding? I honestly didn't see it.




I plead not guilty. The poster implicitly claimed immunity from an "affliction" with which he alleges that other posters here are "infected": magical thinking. My counterargument (regardless of whether you are capable of recognizing it as such) is that that IS a form of magical thinking.


I saw no counterargument. I saw a personal attack by calling him a superhero, I'm guessing to imply that he considers himself perfect or better than alcoholics. Maybe you would clarify your "counterargument"?




Your comments have lost all validity given your ridiculous claims that alcohol is not addictive (or a drug, depending on how onbe read your comment around same).


Even if he's mistaken about one claim it does not therefore follow that all other claims are invalid or mistaken. At least he has been consistently coming up with studies and evidence trying to support his claims which is a far sight better than his detractors have been doing so far in this thread.



You don't.
I am the only one who will truly know; but it is an honest program ....:)


It may be an honest program but that in now way means that there are honest AAers.




Have you really researched those links? I blew it off before but you continue to post this "research" like it means something.
Here is your 2nd links facebook page. They have a dog in the fight.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Evide...le-with-Alcohol-Drug-Problems/116937031678751
33 Fans? Really? My pizza shop has 100 and I haven't done crap to it in 6 months.


Argumentum ad populum.

In other words, who the frack cares how popular a Facebook page is? Either the argument is sound or it is not.




And the Orange Papers? You guys are cut from the same resentful cloth.
So just to be clear to everyone on the forum, your argument is this guys research? If you look at his footnotes, he quotes studies and data ranging from 1944 to 1986. His evidence against AA is based on studies from over 60 years ago to the most recent which is about 25 years ago. You are aware that we now have physicians that are specialized in addiction medicine? Please show me a source from an addiction/alcohol board certified physician that considers the Orange Papers or Behavior Therapy Associates, LLP as a reliable source for addiction medicine. If you cannot come up with a better source than these, your argument is not only based on "pseudo-science" but you seem to dislike AA so much that you are willing to either be intellectually dishonest or are so blinded by anger/resentment you can't see the truth. Those of us that support AA have, time and again, explained that we understand the flaws in AA and that people should use what ever path leads them to sobriety. We try to be as honest and forthright as possible. You need to either find a reputable source to support your argument or leave the debate.


You and Alfie are using the same ad hominem arguments. "The people who wrote the Orange Papers are all whackos, so what they say is wrong."

So the studies Tinyal cites are all at least 25 years old and Dancing David just mentioned that the typical standard is three years. So I agree that studies that have been published within the last three years should be cited.


Your opinions and your data are a joke.

Is that your best refutation?




It is simply more evidence that it is the group (and individuals within) that determines practices and directions for the group, not central office New York, not Bill W, not the big book, not me, and not Tinyal.


More "group conscience" eh?



I am not making an argument. I am refuting yours. As I pointed out in my post, you seem to be letting your emotions get the better of you. I am not making the claims-you are. I will not stoop to petty bickering but I will once again point out that you have chosen dubious, unscientific or out dated sources.

*snip coin-related stuff*

Can you not see how flawed this logic is?

So let's agree that the Orange Papers website is full of crap. What about the other studies Tinyal has provided?



If Tinyal et al wish to make a fellowship that is more inclusive, then I suggest they start their own or join another. Either that or they wait until the rest of the fellowship is ready.

At any rate, when it is time to change, it will be changed - and not by people at the 'top', but the millions at the bottom

More "group conscience"?

Funny you saying this after I already posted the explicitly stated reasons for the TOP of the AA organization NOT to change the first 164 pages of the Big Book, when, according to both you and them, they state that changes are made to be more inclusive of its changing membership.

In other words, you all in Stralia can't be arsed to petition for changes made organization-wide. You seem (please note I'm emphasizing 'seem') to be very satisfied to have spirituality (and God in the text and ALL official literature) a core part of your program.
 
Parts is parts, in harm reduction you take half measures, so while cigarettes are not a good thing, quitting drinking is the first priority. And why I feel rehab should let peopel play cards.

The goal is to have the person be honest about their choices around drinkng and the consequences of those choices.

If they want to believe in Bo Peep and Sheepish Choir that is fine, as long as they are honest in that one area.

The goal is to stop drinking. DFD

There are some drug and alcohol detox unit here abouts that also ban smoking whilst clients are in.

I am a firm believer in 'one thing at a time'. Cigarettes are often the first thing in and the last to go.

I notice the smillie...apparently you understand just how dishonest the program "is", (Lying to yourself by "faking it till you make it") and you somehow think that funny...

What a sick sense of humour.

Thank you. :)

And the same question can be asked of you: How will the removal of god stop AA from working, if it works now?

I don't know, what would you like to change it to?

Why can't they just change the group conscience of AA?[/QUOTE]

I actually said that the millions below could change it - that would be the group conscience. :boggled:

Even if he's mistaken about one claim it does not therefore follow that all other claims are invalid or mistaken. At least he has been consistently coming up with studies and evidence trying to support his claims which is a far sight better than his detractors have been doing so far in this thread.

A bit like totally dismissing all the arguments a person puts up just because they believe in God, or are comfortable with the God word, I suppose?

Actually what Tinyal has managed to put up so far (with lots of shouting) are excerprts of the big book, his opinion and the orange papers.
The first is one man's opinion
The second is in tatters and is founded in revenge.
And the third is outdated, and it's goals preconceived.

It may be an honest program but that in now way means that there are honest AAers.

Nor does it mean there are not.

In fact if one follows the program (i.e. the steps), honesty, self honesty and integrity are some of the main keys to sobriety.
But I agree, not everyone in AA is honest, not everyone in AA is well either.

But I would strongly suggest that as a general rule, people in AA are far more honest than how they were when they weren't.
AAers have a lot more riding on their honesty than the general population.

You and Alfie are using the same ad hominem arguments. "The people who wrote the Orange Papers are all whackos, so what they say is wrong."

I only gives what I gets. :)

More "group conscience" eh?

Have you read the traditions?

So let's agree that the Orange Papers website is full of crap. What about the other studies Tinyal has provided? [/quote}

Such as the big book quotes? :rolleyes:

In other words, you all in Stralia can't be arsed to petition for changes made organization-wide. You seem (please note I'm emphasizing 'seem') to be very satisfied to have spirituality (and God in the text and ALL official literature) a core part of your program.

Sure.:)

And youze in Sepopotamia just hate the word God so much that you just have to spoil everyone elses fun. So sad. And so much for their spirituality. :p
 
A bit like totally dismissing all the arguments a person puts up just because they believe in God, or are comfortable with the God word, I suppose?

Actually what Tinyal has managed to put up so far (with lots of shouting) are excerprts of the big book, his opinion and the orange papers.
The first is one man's opinion
The second is in tatters and is founded in revenge.
And the third is outdated, and it's goals preconceived.

I only gives what I gets. :)

And youze in Sepopotamia just hate the word God so much that you just have to spoil everyone elses fun. So sad. And so much for their spirituality. :p


Your position is now abundantly clear for me, thank you.
 
I don't know, what would you like to change it to?

I didn't say change it, I said remove it.

I actually said that the millions below could change it - that would be the group conscience. :boggled:

Then why do you complain when someone, in this case Tinyal, puts in the effort to change it?

AA is a perfect example of mob rule where individuals and minorities are at the mercy of the majority.
 
Then please address those who are not speaking in absolutes and present your evidence refuting them.
I don't know what this means. What is it you would like me to refute?:boggled:






Could you point out that strawman and how it was a misrepresentation of the argument to which he was responding? I honestly didn't see it.
quyak made an analogy comparing AA to a Doctor. AA is not a Doctor.







Even if he's mistaken about one claim it does not therefore follow that all other claims are invalid or mistaken.
Where did I say this?

At least he has been consistently coming up with studies and evidence trying to support his claims which is a far sight better than his detractors have been doing so far in this thread.
You and I must have very different ideas as what constitutes evidence. I believe your mistake is believing an argument from authority. Consistently coming up with faulty studies and faulty and antiquated evidence is not defending your position and frankly makes tinyal appear to be angry and resentful. Dancing David pointed out many pages ago that there has been no reasonable double blinded long term study performed either proving or disproving the effectiveness of AA. Why is this so hard to understand? It has been explained, ad nauseum.







It may be an honest program but that in now way means that there are honest AAers.
One of most important tenants that I was taught in AA was that I needed to be brutally honest with my self. The program does not work if you continue to make rationalizations and lie to your self. Are you insinuating that I am somehow dishonest?





Argumentum ad populum.

In other words, who the frack cares how popular a Facebook page is? Either the argument is sound or it is not.
I'm not sure you understand what ad populum is. That was not my argument. It was an observation. My argument was his source was unreliable because it was denouncing AA on one hand and selling their own form of recovery "drinking in moderation". Not exactly what one would consider to be a reliable source. Do you think it is?








You and Alfie are using the same ad hominem arguments. "The people who wrote the Orange Papers are all whackos, so what they say is wrong."

So the studies Tinyal cites are all at least 25 years old and Dancing David just mentioned that the typical standard is three years. So I agree that studies that have been published within the last three years should be cited.
It is not ad hom to point out the obvious (at least obvious to me) poor reasoning that is used by the Orange Paper author(and I believe there is just one, not multiple authors). I provided detailed evidence why the Orange Papers were wrong and from that you took the above statement? I did not say that the author was a "whacko" I said that he was resentful. Whacko is crazy, resentful is angry. We learn a lot about that in AA and what to do with it.









So let's agree that the Orange Papers website is full of crap. What about the other studies Tinyal has provided?
Links please. I have debunked Orange Papers and this
http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm
Provide the links to the other disingenuous "research" tinyal has provided and I will take them as they come.
 
Then why do you complain when someone, in this case Tinyal, puts in the effort to change it?

I am not complaining, merely pointing out that the suppiort for change is not there. He (and others) just keep banging on about it ad nauseum.

AA is a perfect example of mob rule where individuals and minorities are at the mercy of the majority.

Actually AA is a perfect example of majority rule; of a democratic process - imagine?:boggled:
 
quyak made an analogy comparing AA to a Doctor. AA is not a Doctor.

a·nal·o·gy 
 
–noun
1. a similarity between like features of two things, on which a comparison may be based: the analogy between the heart and a pump. 2. similarity or comparability: I see no analogy between your problem and mine.
3. Biology . an analogous relationship.
4. Linguistics .
a. the process by which words or phrases are created or re-formed according to existing patterns in the language, as when shoon was re-formed as shoes, when -ize is added to nouns like winter to form verbs, or when a child says foots for feet.
b. a form resulting from such a process.
5. Logic . a form of reasoning in which one thing is inferred to be similar to another thing in a certain respect, on the basis of the known similarity between the things in other respects.
Hello! That's why it's called an analogy. :rolleyes:

One of most important tenants that I was taught in AA was that I needed to be brutally honest with my self. The program does not work if you continue to make rationalizations and lie to your self.

And yet, here we have a thread of many AA members rationalizing and lying to themselves and others.

Are you insinuating that I am somehow dishonest?

Well, there's always the other possibility . . .

I'm not sure you understand what ad populum is. That was not my argument. It was an observation. My argument was his source was unreliable because it was denouncing AA on one hand and selling their own form of recovery "drinking in moderation". Not exactly what one would consider to be a reliable source. Do you think it is?

You need to show that the information is wrong and that the reason the source is pushing it is to further their own cause. Just saying they have an interest doesn't mean squat.

It is not ad hom to point out the obvious (at least obvious to me) poor reasoning that is used by the Orange Paper author(and I believe there is just one, not multiple authors). I provided detailed evidence why the Orange Papers were wrong and from that you took the above statement? I did not say that the author was a "whacko" I said that he was resentful. Whacko is crazy, resentful is angry. We learn a lot about that in AA and what to do with it.

No, you simply stated that the studies were dated. That doesn't make them wrong and it doesn't make the author resentful. You have not shown a single thing wrong with the studies.

You will also note that the report is an analysis of all the studies. This is often done to get an overview of where things stand. There is nothing wrong with what the author did in using those older studies in the manner he did.

Links please. I have debunked Orange Papers and this

You have done no such thing. You need to go back to the 12 Steps and work on the "brutally honest" part a lot more.
 
Actually AA is a perfect example of majority rule; of a democratic process - imagine?:boggled:

I am pretty sure you think that is impressive but it really isn't.

A democracy is 4 wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner.

A republic is 4 wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner besides sheep.

Democracy without a charter to prevent the majority from impinging on the rights of individuals and minority groups, is mob rule. AA has no such charter.

It isn't democracy that makes a country great, it's the charter that controls the mob that does that.
 
I don't know what this means. What is it you would like me to refute?:boggled:


The points being raised that AA is religious. The OP asks why people such as yourself are claiming AA is NOT religious; there have been attempts at providing evidence other than personal anecdotal information to show that AA is considered a religious organization. It would be nice to be shown some evidence other than personal anecdotal information that AA is not a religious organization.




Where did I say this?


You didn't. Read the little bold name at the top of quote boxes. When the quote was originally attributed to you, for example, the first post has your name; I didn't include your name in the others. When I was responding to AAAlfie, I included his name in the first quote, then when I continued to quote him, I left it out for ease of my own cut and paste. I can see how it can get confusing however.




You and I must have very different ideas as what constitutes evidence. I believe your mistake is believing an argument from authority. Consistently coming up with faulty studies and faulty and antiquated evidence is not defending your position and frankly makes tinyal appear to be angry and resentful. Dancing David pointed out many pages ago that there has been no reasonable double blinded long term study performed either proving or disproving the effectiveness of AA. Why is this so hard to understand? It has been explained, ad nauseum.


Okay, perhaps I have been mistaken about my understanding on this part and I don't mind to apologize and move on.





One of most important tenants that I was taught in AA was that I needed to be brutally honest with my self. The program does not work if you continue to make rationalizations and lie to your self. Are you insinuating that I am somehow dishonest?


I wasn't speaking to you in the first place and I was making no insinuations regarding anyone's honesty. I was simply pointing out that AAAlfie had made a claim that the program is honest, probably implying that the people in the program could be reasonably considered to be honest as well. I find it rather grating at times to be quoted mindless platitudes. I get more than enough of that in the meetings I attend.




I'm not sure you understand what ad populum is. That was not my argument. It was an observation. My argument was his source was unreliable because it was denouncing AA on one hand and selling their own form of recovery "drinking in moderation". Not exactly what one would consider to be a reliable source. Do you think it is?


You were observing that the Orange Papers FB page had less friends than your own page. It was irrelevant to the argument as I understand it.

I trust your statements that you made with quotes from the website, so no, I don't consider it a reliable source. That's all I really am wanting from those who feel AA is great the way it is, such as yourself.





It is not ad hom to point out the obvious (at least obvious to me) poor reasoning that is used by the Orange Paper author(and I believe there is just one, not multiple authors). I provided detailed evidence why the Orange Papers were wrong and from that you took the above statement? I did not say that the author was a "whacko" I said that he was resentful. Whacko is crazy, resentful is angry. We learn a lot about that in AA and what to do with it.


Okay, to me, you seemed to come across as implying such.
 
And yet, here we have a thread of many AA members rationalizing and lying to themselves and others.

Speaking of lies... evidence please. :rolleyes:

Democracy without a charter to prevent the majority from impinging on the rights of individuals and minority groups, is mob rule. AA has no such charter.

It isn't democracy that makes a country great, it's the charter that controls the mob that does that.

A charter? Like the 12 traditions?
Have you actually read them?

The points being raised that AA is religious. The OP asks why people such as yourself are claiming AA is NOT religious; there have been attempts at providing evidence other than personal anecdotal information to show that AA is considered a religious organization. It would be nice to be shown some evidence other than personal anecdotal information that AA is not a religious organization.

It is not personal anecdote to point out that the steps are "suggested" and the third tradition states there are no requirements for membership "except a desire to stop drinking".

As we have time and again conceded, there are elements in the original big book text that are religious (written by a religious man/men), we have also ackowledged that there are groups (especially in the states) that are religious.
Does that make AA as a whole religious? Hardly. Nor do thee non deist groups make AA an atheist organisation? But they are still doing AA.

AA is what one wants to make it.

I wasn't speaking to you in the first place and I was making no insinuations regarding anyone's honesty. I was simply pointing out that AAAlfie had made a claim that the program is honest, probably implying that the people in the program could be reasonably considered to be honest as well. I find it rather grating at times to be quoted mindless platitudes. I get more than enough of that in the meetings I attend.

And it was a fair point made btw. One which cannot be proven in any sense that I can think of.
A poorly veiled accusation was made about AAers (my and others) honesty and my response was to same. If there was a better way to respond other than my so called platitude, I would like to hear it. Have you any suggestions?
 
GodofPie, you have shown no evidence whatever - none, nada, zip, showing The Orange Papers has been (your word) debunked. There are hundreds of pages just demonstrating the point that AA is religious, scores more showing how AA fits the current definitions of a religious cult no less - and I"m not speaking here of any studies done in the 80's, but of point-by-point, sentence by sentence comparisons using AA's program itself (AA's program is completely contained in big book & 12x12, no other literature is needed - certainly the first 100 members didn't need any of it, and the big book claims all you need is that one book itself, not even meetings) - the only and sole point you have is you are unhappy with the age of some of the studies (while offering none to support your viewpoint), as well as stating that chip records aren't, by themselves, a very good measure - a point made by AO himself in that summary. People can see and read for themselves that the chip data is only a small part of what's used, however.
Now, when it comes to AA, you seem to put some weight in the AA program - a program that has remained unchanged for over 70 years!! There is no current medical information in the big book (although there is an awlful lot of info on the sinful nature of alchies, as well as detailed instructions on how to pray) - there is basically none in any AA literature. Dr. Silkworths & Dr. Shoemaker's statements - their medical opinions - are old, outdated, and even back then they weren't supported by any data whatever, just guesses & wishful thinking (for instance, the 'allergy' statement by Dr. Silkworth).
I have personally been involved in trying to change or add to portions of the big book, specifically related to inserting the latest medical data on alcohol abuse, but have been forcefully rebuffed at both regional & national levels by committee's (who's funds come from GSO NY) and senior members. I can't even count the number of times I've been told one of the two following statements in response to these honest efforts, it must be many hundreds of times:

1. " We cannot change or alter the big book in any way, it was revealed to Bill by god, and who are we to change it?"
and
2. "We see no need to change, add to, or alter any portion of the AA program, as why change something that's worked so well for so long?"

Those two statements have shut down the efforts of hundreds of people (many of whom I've known for decades) who've attempted - in the smallest degree - to either lighten up on the god bothering contained in the big book & 12x12, or to add (not remove anything , just add) current medical information relating to substance abuse. All efforts have failed, as unsurprisingly the AA faithful rush to defend and keep things 'just the way god intended'. It wasn't only at some local meeting I've been told those things, but at state, regional, and national conferences.
Do you know the facts surrounding AA's triannual surveys? Perhaps you've wondered what happened to the multipages of data AA used to put out on their members, until people such as AO and many others started to parse that data to support the 5% recovery rate (that is, the 95% failure rate) of the AA program?? At that point, AA stopped releasing what would normally be public data. Cowards!
Until you have something better than your personal beliefs or experience to counter the actual data & logical conclusions used throughout the orange papers, your opinion is worth just as much as anyone else - and certainly less than those who've gone through the work to research their conclusions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom