Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mr. AAAlfie, out of curiosity, were you raised with religion? (I realize this is a very personal question, so don't answer if you don't feel like it.) Thanks.
 
Mr. AAAlfie, out of curiosity, were you raised with religion? (I realize this is a very personal question, so don't answer if you don't feel like it.) Thanks.

Not the question asked but Alfie is an agnostic in the sense that it allows him to deny his belief in God when it suits his purpose.
 
A snap? Really? That would mean that only atheists are bothered by phobias, because Christians could just tell themselves their problems are in God's hands, and the fear would go away.
Not saying there's any guarantee that it would work (though I expect that it probably quite often does, or Christianity would not be as successful a meme as it is). I'm just that the Christian would have an easier time finding a convenient symbology for communicating with his irrational cognitive submodules.

Having known people who profess to be Christians who also appear to suffer from irrational fears, I doubt that. Got any evidence that Christians can stop fear due to phobias so easily?
Googling "faith stress hormones" suggests that there may actually be some evidence of that, further supported by a quick poke at one of the results:
http://www.umm.edu/altmed/articles/spirituality-000360.htm
which cites this study as a reference:
Benson H, Dusek JA, Sherwood JB, et al., Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in cardiac bypass patients: a multicenter randomized trial of uncertainty and certainty of receiving intercessory prayer. Am Heart J. 2006;151(4):934-42.

I think it's been discussed fairly frequently around here, and mining those discussions would likely bear more fruit as well, but given my current time constraints (home computer is still in the shop), I'm not going to be able to bore in any deeper right now. If necessary, I'd be willing to call it a conjecture.

I might even propose the opposite: that people who have trouble dealing with irrational fears are more apt to be religious because they're desperate for any comfort and are trying anything, even if it doesn't help.Which is fairly close to what you're saying, if I understand it--religion is a way for desperate people to try to find comfort, and it's why the "higher power" concept is useful for desperate alcoholics.
Yes, that's very close to what I'm saying.
But if it actually solved problems so easily, I'd expect the success rate to be much higher.
Can't speak to success rates. Not enough information.
 
Then under your definition I am never immersed while watching a movie or other work of fiction.
Really. Never experience an emotional response while watching a movie or reading a book?

Well, that explains it, then...
Maybe you can explain how it explains it.

I don't know. I have problems restraining myself when it comes to food; I guess you could call it an additction or obsession. But it is entirely my call, every time.
And if I didn't call it an addiction or an obsession?

Good example: I have fear of heights; even in situations which pose no danger to me whatsoever. In that respect it IS irrational.
Good example indeed. Would you say that having a fear of heights is your call?

Absolutely. But teaching him that he indeed _cannot_ quit without some higher power is dangerous, at best.
I don't disagree. But I don't agree that AA teaches that.
 
I don't see why an organization has to follow a specific set of religious beliefs to be a religious organization, as long as it encourages members to adopt some religious beliefs.
Earlier, I suggested that the term, "meta-religious" might be applied to AA.
 
Mr. AAAlfie, out of curiosity, were you raised with religion? (I realize this is a very personal question, so don't answer if you don't feel like it.) Thanks.

Nothing fundamental, I did go to a church based school in my teens. We were given weekly divinity classes and a weekly trip to the school church for service.
Apart from weddings, funerals and the odd AA meeting held in one, I haven't been to church in decades.

Why do you ask?

What is your definition of the term "higher power"??

Fair question.
If you are talking about a god I would honestly have trouble answering that in detail. I might simply suggest something like a creator or (as some say) "the great architect".
When applying the term to the broader definition adopted by AA (and myself), it can mean anything to which has greater power or authority. I have used these here and elsewhere time and again:
- nature is a power greater than myself
- a group of tens, hundreds and thousands is a power greater than myself,
- education, the collective wisdom and teachings of succesful people before me is a power greater than myself.

If you are asking what my higher power was/is, it is a kind of an amalgam of these three things.

Not the question asked but Alfie is an agnostic in the sense that it allows him to deny his belief in God when it suits his purpose.

Do you often have these compulsive tendencies? :rolleyes::)

But seriously, what do you think agnostic means?
 
Last edited:
If you are talking about a god I would honestly have trouble answering that in detail. I might simply suggest something like a creator or (as some say) "the great architect".

Sorry, but there is no evidence for any such thing.

When applying the term to the broader definition adopted by AA (and myself), it can mean anything to which has greater power or authority.

Rationally speaking, I simply do not accept that there is any such thing as a "greater power or higher authority".

I have used these here and elsewhere time and again:
- nature is a power greater than myself
- a group of tens, hundreds and thousands is a power greater than myself,
- education, the collective wisdom and teachings of succesful people before me is a power greater than myself.

Meaningless...just how can "nature, a number of people, or education" stop you from drinking better that the person can??
 
Last edited:
Do you often have these compulsive tendencies? :rolleyes::)

Remember, you're a counsellor, not a psychiatrist. :p

But seriously, what do you think agnostic means?

Someone who can't decide one way or the other based on the available evidence.

That would mean, someone who plainly states they do not know if there is a god consistently, not someone who says "there is a god," or "there isn't a god" depending on how badly they are trying to win a point in a discussion.

In other words, not you. :D
 
Sorry, but there is no evidence for any such thing.

Did I say there was? I was asked for a definition.

Rationally speaking, I simply do not accept that there is any such thing as a "greater power or higher authority".

So there is no-one or nothing stronger, smarter or with greater skills than you.
Got it. ;)

Meaningless...just how can "nature, a number of people, or education" stop you from drinking better that the person can??

Get to AA and find out. :p
Again, I was asked for a definition.

Someone who can't decide one way or the other based on the available evidence.

Roughly speaking, that would be mine too.

That would mean, someone who plainly states they do not know if there is a god consistently, not someone who says "there is a god," or "there isn't a god" depending on how badly they are trying to win a point in a discussion.

In other words, not you.

Can you now show me where I said "there is a god" or where "there isn't a god"? Otherwise you are lying - again.
 
Last edited:
Really. Never experience an emotional response while watching a movie or reading a book?

You're moving the goalposts. Your claim was that immersion was belief, not emotional response.

And if I didn't call it an addiction or an obsession?

Then I'd ask you for your definition of an addiction/obsession.

Good example indeed. Would you say that having a fear of heights is your call?

Dealing with it certainly is.

I don't disagree. But I don't agree that AA teaches that.

It's in the twelve steps, Dymanic. How can you say it doesn't teach that ?
 
It's amazing how an apologist will twist words and meanings so as to avoid having to admit something. "Higher power" has ceased having a meaning the moment it could mean anything.

Twisting words has become something of a pasttime in this thread. I think from the moment the AA opponents made the "suggested" steps, a "compulsory" requirement, and then a "power greater than ourselves" a conformist deity. :rolleyes:
 
What is the actual purpose and intent behind step 3?
What is achieved psychologically, morally or lifestyle with step 3? How is a lifestyle positively changed by 'turning over' ones will to a god of our understanding? By what mechanism is our 'will' being guided?
If you are admit you are 'powerless,' what is being 'turned over' in step 3?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom