Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
But, I have yet to hear why people who want to change the language to make it more "inclusive" do so, when they also say AA doesn't work.

It's a "baby and the bathwater" issue that one assumes you learned in grade school. If you need more help with that, let me know.
 
Well, half true. ... he is trying to make an ineffective program, effective.

How? By changing the language. Good point. He also says it doesn't work. So ... back to my question...
why people who want to change the language to make it more "inclusive" do so, when they also say AA doesn't work

Tinyal isn't trying to destroy the fellowship,..

orly?
And this is only one quote from this page. :boggled:

We not only shouldn't waste another minute recommending anyone to AA (we should be spending our time and funds researching an actual treatment that works).
 
It's a "baby and the bathwater" issue that one assumes you learned in grade school. If you need more help with that, let me know.

Could you please explain this, to those of us that have lost those grade school brain cells?
 
Have you really researched those links? I blew it off before but you continue to post this "research" like it means something.
Here is your 2nd links facebook page. They have a dog in the fight.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Evide...le-with-Alcohol-Drug-Problems/116937031678751
33 Fans? Really? My pizza shop has 100 and I haven't done crap to it in 6 months.
And the Orange Papers? You guys are cut from the same resentful cloth.

From the Orange Papers (please forgive the length and it is by no means the full wall of text the author has on his site.)
Many, perhaps most, A.A. groups have a custom of giving out sobriety "medallions", or "coins", or "tokens" — choose whichever name you prefer. Beginners with no sober time get an aluminum "Just For Today" coin. Then the members collect coins for 30 days sober, 60 days, 90 days, 6 months, a year, and then multiple years. The count of how many of those coins are given away reveals that Alcoholics Anonymous has a horrendous dropout rate. Barely one percent of the newcomers get a 10-year coin, and only one in a thousand gets the 20-year coin.

Here is a table of the percentages of the new members who successfully earn any particular coin. The description of how the numbers were computed, is here.


All Numbers Scaled To 1000 Newcomers
Time Number per
1000 newcomers Percentage
Today 1000 100.0%
1 year 50 5%
2 years 29.54 2.95%
3 years 21.97 2.2%
4 years 17.8 1.78%
5 years 16.29 1.63%
6 years 13.26 1.33%
7 years 11.74 1.17%
8 years 10.6 1.06%
9 years 9.85 0.986%
10 years 11.74 1.17%
11 years 7.58 0.76%
12 years 7.58 0.76%
13 years 6.44 0.64%
14 years 6.06 0.61%
15 years 4.92 0.49%
16 years 3.41 0.34%
17 years 2.65 0.27%
18 years 2.27 0.23%
19 years 1.89 0.19%
20 years 1.52 0.15%
21 years 0.76 0.076%
22 years 0.76 0.076%
23 years 0.38 0.038%
24 years 0.38 0.038%
25 years 0.38 0.038%
26 years 0.24 0.024%
27 years 0.20 0.020%
28 years 0.16 0.016%
29 years 0.16 0.016%
30 years 0.16 0.016%
31 years 0.045 0.0045%
32 years 0.033 0.0033%
33 years 0.034 0.0034%
34 years 0.016 0.0016%
35 years 0.015 0.0015%
36 years 0.0045 0.00045%
37 years 0.0015 0.00015%
Now there are still a few problems with these numbers, like inventorying.

Look at the strange breaks in the chart at 10 years, 20 years, and 30 years. It appears that they lose one third of their members between 10 and 11 years, and half of their members between 20 and 21 years, and they lose more than two-thirds of their members — almost 3/4 — between 30 and 31 years.

No, not really.

What is really happening there is that the various clubs, groups, and intergroups stockpile and keep in inventory the coins for the lower numbers of years, so that they have them immediately on hand to give out to celebrants. But the numbers of people actually picking up the higher-numbered years' coins are so few that the groups do not inventory coins for the very high years. They special-order those coins one at a time when one of their oldtimer members has an upcoming birthday.

Where a given group will stop inventorying coins is a function of the size of the group. Small groups may stop inventorying the coins at 10 years. Larger groups, at 20 years. Very large groups, or intergroups, stop inventorying the coins at 30 years. It's pretty much human nature that they would pick round numbers like 10, 20 or 30. Hence the big non-linearities and apparent huge drop-out rates at 11, 21 and 31 years. We are just looking at sales of coins here, not actual membership numbers.

So the sales of a lot of the higher-years' coins do not represent success stories at all. Those coins have been purchased by clubs and groups, but not earned by anybody. They are just coins that were sold to the groups, and which are sitting in a box at the clubhouse, waiting for somebody to earn them. It appears that almost half of the 10-year coins, and fully half of the 20-year coins, and almost 3/4 of the 30-year coins fall into that category — just sitting in inventory, not yet earned by anybody.

Inventorying has a non-linear effect in distorting the numbers. Inventorying a moderate surplus of the coins for the first few years does not warp the numbers a lot, because so many of them are given out. But having just one spare 20- or 25- or 30-year coin sitting in the coin boxes of clubs and intergroups all over the USA may double the purchases of that particular denomination of coins. That is apparent from the huge discontinuities at 11, 21 and 31 years, where various groups cease inventorying.

Also notice the strange non-linearity between 7 and 10 years. They actually have 31 per thousand people getting 7-year coins, and then the numbers decline from there. But then they jump back up again at 10 years. I can only guess that maybe some people don't bother to pick up 8 or 9-year coins, but feel like 10 is a milestone that they want. But that would mean that they would have a zero-percent drop-out rate from 7 to 10 years, and only for those few years. Strange. I have no explanation for that anomaly.

[Later: one correspondent suggested that the answer is people picking up multiple coins at the 10-year point. Some people getting 10-year coins are so proud of themselves that they go to meetings all over town, picking up another coin at another meeting and enjoying the crowd applauding and cheering for them, again and again. And of course the same thing can happen with the other higher-year coins, especially the 20- and 30-year coins.]

I didn't bother to continue the last chart beyond 37 years because the following numbers are unreliable. That is, the sample size is too small. We are down into the noise level of the signal, where we can easily count all of the individual people in the state who have that many years, because such oldtimers are so rare. And the number of oldtimers jumps around randomly: 1, 2, 4, 8, 1, 8, 7... We need sales figures for the whole USA to see a smooth trend for those years.

Again, this is a very good indication of the A.A. attrition rate, but it is non-scientific and not 100% reliable. A.A. boosters who don't like these numbers are more than welcome to send in their state's total sales figures — preferably xeroxes or computer scans of the invoices for all of the purchases of coins from the manufacturers.


Please explain in detail the "science" that he used to compile these numbers.
Next-The Orange Papers foot notes-
Recovery Without Treatment, by Thomas Prugh
Alcohol Health and Research World, Fall 1986, pp. 24, 71 and 72.

Alcoholism as a Self-Limiting Disease, by Leslie R. H. Drew
Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, Vol. 29, 1968, pp. 956-967.

Spontaneous Remission in Alcoholics: Empirical Observations and Theoretical Implications, by Barry S. Tuchfeld
Journal of Studies on Alcohol, Vol. 42, No. 7, 1981, pp. 626-641.

Spontaneous Recovery in Alcoholics: A Review and Analysis of the Available Research, by R. G. Smart
Drug and Alcohol Dependence, Vol. 1, 1975-1976, p. 284.





References cited by Christine Le, Erik P. Ingvarson, and Richard C. Page,
in the excerpt from: Alcoholics Anonymous and the Counseling Profession: Philosophies in Conflict, in Journal of Counseling & Development, 07-01-1995, page 603.

Bebbington, P. E. (1976). The efficacy of alcoholics anonymous: The elusiveness of hard data. British Journal of Psychiatry, 128, 572- 580.
Bufe, C. Q. (1991). Alcoholics Anonymous: Cult or cure? San Francisco, CA: See Sharp.
Cross, G. M., Morgan, C. W., Mooney, A. J., Martin, C. A., & Rafter, J. A. (1990). Alcoholism treatment: A ten-year follow-up study. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 14(2), 169-173.
Glaser, E B., & Ogborne, A. C. (1982). Does AA really work? British Journal of Addiction, 77, 123-129
Hoffman, N. G., Harrison, P. A., & Belille, C. A. (1983). Alcoholics Anonymous after treatment: Attendance and abstinence. International Journal of the Addictions, 18(3), 311-318.
McBride, J. L. (1991). Abstinence among members of Alcoholics Anonymous. Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly, 8(1), 113-121.
Thurstin, A. H., Alfano, A. M., & Nerviano, V. J. (1987). The efficacy of AA attendance for aftercare of inpatient alcoholics: Some follow-up data. International Journal of the Addictions, 22, 1083-1090.
Vaillant, G. (1983). The Natural History of Alcoholism: Causes, Patterns, and Paths to Recovery. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University.




References cited by Prof. George Vaillant
in the quotes from The Natural History of Alcoholism: Causes, Patterns, and Paths to Recovery:

Baekeland, F., L. Lundwall, and B. Kissin. 1975. "Methods for the Treatment of Chronic Alcoholism: A Critical Appraisal." In Research Advances in Alcohol and Drug Problems, Vol. 2, ed. R. J. Gibbons, Y. Israel, H. Kalant, R. E. Popham, W. Schmidt, and R. G. Smart. New York: Wiley.
Beaubrun, M. H. 1967. "Treatment of Alcoholism in Trinidad and Tobago, 1956-65." British Journal of Psychiatry 113:643-658.
Belasco, J. A. 1971. "The Criterion Question Revisited." British Journal of Addiction 66:39-44.
Bratfos, O. 1974. The Course of Alcoholism: Drinking, Social Adjustment and Health. Oslo: Universitet Forlaget.
Bruun, K. 1963. "Outcome of Different Types of Treatment of Alcoholics." Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 24:280-288.
Cecil, R. 1940. Textbook of Medicine. New York: Saunders
Costello, R. M. 1975. "Alcoholism Treatment and Evaluation, II: Collation of Two Year Follow-up Studies." International Journal of Addictions 10:857-867.
Emrick, C. D. 1975. "A Review of Psychologically Oriented Treatment of Alcoholism, II: The Relative Effectiveness of Different Treatment Approaches and the Effectiveness of Treatment versus No Treatment." Journal of Studies on Alcohol 36:88-109.
Farquhar, J. 1978. "The Community-Based Model of Life Style Intervention Trails." American Journal of Epidemiology 108:103-111.
Farquhar, J. W., N. Maccoby, P. D. Wood, J. K. Alexander, H. Breitrose, B. W. Brown, Jr., W. L. Haskell, A. L. McAlister, A. J. Meyer, J. D. Nash, and M. P. Stern. 1977. "Community Education for Cardiovascular Health." Lancet 1:1192-1195.
Frank, J. D. 1961. Persuasion and Healing: A Comparative Study of Psychotherapy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Goodwin, D. W., J. B. Crane, and S. B. Guze. 1971. "Felons Who Drink: An 8-Year Follow-up." Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 32:136-147.
Gordis, E. 1976. "Editorial: What is Alcoholism Research?" Annals of Internal Medicine 85:821-823.
Hill, M. J., and H. T. Blane. 1967. "Evaluation of Psychotherapy with Alcoholics: A Critical Review." Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 28:76-104.
Imber, S., E. Schultz, F. Funderburk, R. Allen, and R. Flamer. 1976. "The Fate of the Untreated Alcoholic." Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 162(4):238-247.
Kendell, R. E., and M. C. Staton. 1966. "The Fate of Untreated Alcoholics." Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 27:30-41.
Kissin, B. 1977. "Comments on Alcoholism: A Controlled Trial of 'Treatment' and 'Advice'." Journal of Studies on Alcohol 38:1804-1808.
Lundquist, G. A. R. 1973. "Alcohol Dependence." Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 49:332-340.
Myerson, D. J., and J. Mayer. 1966. "Origins, Treatment and Destiny of Skid Row Alcoholic Men." New England Journal of Medicine 275:419-424.
Orford, J. and G. Edwards. 1977. Alcoholism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Robson, R. A., I. Paulus, and G. G. Clarke. 1965. "An Evaluation of the Effect of a Clinic Treatment Program on the Rehabilitation of Alcoholic Patients." Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 26:264-278.
Shadel, C. A. 1944. "Aversion Treatment of Alcohol Addiction." Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 5:216-228.
Sobell, M. B., and L. C. Sobell. 1973. "Alcoholics Treated by Individualized Behavior Therapy: One Year Treatment Outcome." Behavior Research and Therapy 11:599-618.
van Dijk, W. K., and A. van Dijk-Koffeman. 1973. "A Follow-up Study of 211 Treated Male Alcoholic Addicts." British Journal of Psychiatry 111:348-356.
Voegtlin, W. L., and W. R. Broz. 1949. "The Conditioned Reflex Treatment of Chronic Alcoholism, X: An Analysis of 3125 Admissions over a Period of Ten and a Half Years." Annals of Internal Medicine 30:580-597.
Wallerstein, R. S. 1956. "Comparative Study of Treatment Methods for Chronic Alcoholism: The Alcoholism Research Project at Winter V.A. Hospital." American Journal of Psychiatry 113:228-233.

So just to be clear to everyone on the forum, your argument is this guys research? If you look at his footnotes, he quotes studies and data ranging from 1944 to 1986. His evidence against AA is based on studies from over 60 years ago to the most recent which is about 25 years ago. You are aware that we now have physicians that are specialized in addiction medicine? Please show me a source from an addiction/alcohol board certified physician that considers the Orange Papers or Behavior Therapy Associates, LLP as a reliable source for addiction medicine. If you cannot come up with a better source than these, your argument is not only based on "pseudo-science" but you seem to dislike AA so much that you are willing to either be intellectually dishonest or are so blinded by anger/resentment you can't see the truth. Those of us that support AA have, time and again, explained that we understand the flaws in AA and that people should use what ever path leads them to sobriety. We try to be as honest and forthright as possible. You need to either find a reputable source to support your argument or leave the debate.
 
As a side issue, here in Australia (well every meeting I have attended) rarely gives out medallions except for very special occasions:

I have a 10 year coin: it is my only one.
A friend has a 25 year one, and I saw a 50th year one handed to a member last week.
 
Oh please, that's the best argument you have, that you don't like studies 25 years old?? I submit that AA hasn't changed except in the most minor details in at least 50 years, nor has the percentage/makup of alcohol abusers changed much in the same time frame. The core AA program (understood by GSO NY and reinforced by the yearly convention - which I have not only attended, but been heavily involved in for decades) is the first 164 pages, these haven't changed in any meaningful way ever - at all.

I referenced some of the many studies done over the years, all of which generally agree that AA is ineffective, and many that conclude it can also be very detrimental.

You don't like my data so you want me to go and research more that's better to your liking??? The hell with that - you don't like it, go and do your own research, come up with equally valid data that supports your position - it's not my job to support yours.

I doubt you'll bother - no skin off my teeth.
 
As a side issue, here in Australia (well every meeting I have attended) rarely gives out medallions except for very special occasions:

I have a 10 year coin: it is my only one.
A friend has a 25 year one, and I saw a 50th year one handed to a member last week.


In the USA, every meeting (actually, every group) I've been associated with (and I've lost count of how many) gives out medallions on a yearly basis - at the very least. I'd say the majority also give out 30/60/90 day ones as well - I've worked at more than a dozen Intergroup/Interarea offices, where these are normally stocked, and we were constantly shipping them out to groups all across the US - it was one of our primary means of support/income. Perhaps that's not the way in AU, I have no idea.
 
You don't like my data so you want me to go and research more that's better to your liking??? The hell with that - you don't like it, go and do your own research, come up with equally valid data that supports your position - it's not my job to support yours.

But your latest "data" suggests to you that alcohol is not addictive (and/or a drug, depending in the way you read your post). :rolleyes:

picture.php


Your opinions and your data are a joke.
 
Last edited:
In the USA, every meeting (actually, every group) I've been associated with (and I've lost count of how many) gives out medallions on a yearly basis - at the very least. I'd say the majority also give out 30/60/90 day ones as well - I've worked at more than a dozen Intergroup/Interarea offices, where these are normally stocked, and we were constantly shipping them out to groups all across the US - it was one of our primary means of support/income. Perhaps that's not the way in AU, I have no idea.

I don't doubt it, I am simply stating what I see in Australia.

It is yet another example of how things are done far differently in the states compared to elsewhere - I would be interested in hearing from members in Canada, Europe, Asian and elsewhere on what happens there too.

It is simply more evidence that it is the group (and individuals within) that determines practices and directions for the group, not central office New York, not Bill W, not the big book, not me, and not Tinyal.
 
How? By changing the language. Good point. He also says it doesn't work. So ... back to my question...
why people who want to change the language to make it more "inclusive" do so, when they also say AA doesn't work

Asked and answered.

And this is only one quote from this page. :boggled:

Are you daft? That has nothing to do with destroying the fellowship and everything to do with creating a program that works.

On another note, why is it that you think your position is more valid to the degree that Tinyal should leave AA and Alfie should be the one to stay? After all, you are the one pushing a program that has zero success while Tinyal is trying to create a better one.
 
Oh please, that's the best argument you have, that you don't like studies 25 years old?? I submit that AA hasn't changed except in the most minor details in at least 50 years, nor has the percentage/makup of alcohol abusers changed much in the same time frame. The core AA program (understood by GSO NY and reinforced by the yearly convention - which I have not only attended, but been heavily involved in for decades) is the first 164 pages, these haven't changed in any meaningful way ever - at all.

I referenced some of the many studies done over the years, all of which generally agree that AA is ineffective, and many that conclude it can also be very detrimental.

You don't like my data so you want me to go and research more that's better to your liking??? The hell with that - you don't like it, go and do your own research, come up with equally valid data that supports your position - it's not my job to support yours.

I doubt you'll bother - no skin off my teeth.
I am not making an argument. I am refuting yours. As I pointed out in my post, you seem to be letting your emotions get the better of you. I am not making the claims-you are. I will not stoop to petty bickering but I will once again point out that you have chosen dubious, unscientific or out dated sources. I don't believe you are a fraud but I do think that you are suffering from confirmation bias. You have come to a conclusion and are now trying shoe horn quasi evidence to fit your conclusion. I asked you a straight forward question. Explain to me the how in the name of FSM the Orange Papers author arrived at his conclusion scientifically. Let me point out a couple of problems. Here in Winston Salem, NC we have a chip system. It does not keep you sober but helps to mark your time in AA. The white chip (the chip of surrender-that you have made the decision to try and stop drinking) along with the 3 month (red) 6 month (yellow) 9 month (green) and 1 year (blue). All this are plastic poker chips. The 30 day and 60 day chips are aluminium, silver and gold, respectively. I have one of each of these except for the blue one year, I have about 4 or 5. I have never received an annual (brass, bronze?) chip, the ones that are ordered from central. I have 14 years sober and I don't have a single one. According to the Orange Papers reasoning I must be drunk. My Great Uncle James and my Aunt Judy were both in AA. I did not find this out until after I got sober. When My uncle passed away I got his chips. He got sober in the early 50's and died in the mid 80's. I was given his bronze chips. There were 6. He had 30+ years of sobriety when he died but according to the Orange Papers authors reasoning he was drunk all but 6 years of his sobriety. My aunt passed away a few years ago and I received some of her chips. She only had a few bronze ones yet she had over 20 years sober when she died. In that wall-of-text post I make earlier your boy says this
So the sales of a lot of the higher-years' coins do not represent success stories at all. Those coins have been purchased by clubs and groups, but not earned by anybody. They are just coins that were sold to the groups, and which are sitting in a box at the clubhouse, waiting for somebody to earn them. It appears that almost half of the 10-year coins, and fully half of the 20-year coins, and almost 3/4 of the 30-year coins fall into that category — just sitting in inventory, not yet earned by anybody.


I have refuted this.
And then there is this gem.
[Later: one correspondent suggested that the answer is people picking up multiple coins at the 10-year point. Some people getting 10-year coins are so proud of themselves that they go to meetings all over town, picking up another coin at another meeting and enjoying the crowd applauding and cheering for them, again and again. And of course the same thing can happen with the other higher-year coins, especially the 20- and 30-year coins.]
I honestly don't know how AA works where you live but I can say, unequivocally that it don't work that way 'round here.
http://www.w-saa.org/new_schedule/Current_AA_Schedule.pdf
Here is our meeting schedule. Unity is my home group but I have been to all these meetings and I am familiar with their operation. Bronze chip are ordered by request only. No inventories, no drawers full of unused chips laying around. The only ones that are kept in stock are the plastic poker chips. We have even run out of some of those before and I have seen members give up a chip so someone who is celebrating a milestone could have one. Can you not see how flawed this logic is?
 
Asked and answered.

Piffle! Huge fail. Where?

I have been paying very close attention, this has not been touched.

Are you daft? That has nothing to do with destroying the fellowship and everything to do with creating a program that works.

How would it make AA work by removing the word god, if it doesn't work now?

If Tinyal et al wish to make a fellowship that is more inclusive, then I suggest they start their own or join another. Either that or they wait until the rest of the fellowship is ready.

At any rate, when it is time to change, it will be changed - and not by people at the 'top', but the millions at the bottom
 
Last edited:
What Belz is saying is exactly what I have said but in a very polite way: unless you can support it you can't defend it.

But I would love to see you prove that alcohol is not addictive. It seems you justify it by saying that because only x% who try it suffer it (alcoholism).
It's a bit like saying that cancer isn't deadly because only x% that get it, die from it.

Cheers.

There is an addictive profile for alcohol, some people have a predisposition to it, and there is even something called probanding where people from families with a predisposition to alcohol addiction marry people from another families with the predisposition to alcohol addiction.

However alcohol and mood altering behaviors of all sorts can become addictive patterns of behaviors without the predisposition.
 
There are varying definitions of 'addictive drugs', one can find one definition from the AMA, another from the WHO, still others from various researchers & scientists. Some make a very broad definition such as 'any substance that can cause addiction', thereby defining the substance by the associated behaviors (or potential associated behaviors, or psychological reactions such as withdrawal). Other definitions (for instance, the one I referenced when I rather broadly stated alcohol wasn't per se addictive) are based on studies that have determined what percentage of casual users will continue to seek the drug, or what percentage of users (whether legal, or illegal) will experience withdrawal - physical or psychological.
I was referring to the fact that of all the substances typically thought of as 'addictive drugs', alcohol will only affect 10% of the users - a very low percentage similar to that of food, or sex - two things which most people couldn't;t define as 'addictive' - they are normal substances which, when abused, become addictive.
A casual user of alcohol has a very low risk of becoming psychologically addicted - in comparison, 90% of tobacco users become addicted within a few cigarettes - 80%+ of meth, cocaine, or heroin users become addicted. 40-50% of processed opiates (hydro and oxy codones) will - simply as a consequence of taking the drug - experience 'dependence' leading to addiction. By the definition I am using, neither LSD nor Pot are addictive, even though both are associated with dependence.
In terms of our current discussion, alcohol doesn't meet this level - oh it's certainly capable of becoming an addictive substance but this is behavior dependent, while in contrast, 90% of tobacco users will become addicted, regardless of behavior or mental state.
Taking this subject further would be an excellent topic for another post, where one compares varying levels of addictive potential, the difference between addiction and dependence, pseudo-addiction, and other behaviors.
So, in summary, I am stating that alcohol isn't 'addictive', chemically/behaviorally, in the same sense that, for instance, opiates and tobacco are - it's addictive in the same sense that food, or sex, or sky diving is - it can be used in an addictive fashion, it can certainly cause both physical and psychological withdrawal, but it is not medically 'addictive' in and of itself - many heavy drinkers can simply stop or moderate, however the same cannot be said of opiates, or tobacco, or cocaine compounds, for instance.
I realize my statement puts me in a minority position, but I do believe it's supportable (certainly debatable) by the evidence & scientific studies.
Does that help clarify what I meant?

Well Tinyal, while I admire many of the things you have said in this post you have fallen into the myth of psychological addiction and it is a myth.

Physical withdrawal, if you read the DSM and the ICD is not required for addiction, it can be part of the problems of substance dependence but it is not required.

Now marijuana and LSD as well as cocaine are all addictive to some people, regardless of the withdrawal symptoms and profile.

So you are just redefining addiction to suit yourself.
here is the deal;

All substance and mood altering behaviors are capable of meeting the criteria for 'addiction' i.e. dependence and they all have what is common?

A human body!

So unless you want to start down the crazy road to dualism and claiming that 'psychological addiction' does not involve physical process in a human brain you have to understand, all psychological i.e. brain processes are physical process.

The definition of addiction is the behaviors not the substance.
 
So, alcoholism isn't a disease, it's an addiction?

ad·dic·tion 

–noun
the state of being enslaved to a habit or practice or to something that is psychologically or physically habit-forming, as narcotics, to such an extent that its cessation causes severe trauma.


disease (dɪˈziːz)

— noun
1. any impairment of normal physiological function affecting all or part of an organism, esp a specific pathological change caused by infection, stress, etc, producing characteristic symptoms; illness or sickness in general
2. a corresponding condition in plants
3. any situation or condition likened to this: the disease of materialism

That would be my contention that I made way back, addiction is a behavioral disorder often with medical consequences.
 
Firstly, on my assertion that using the word 'addictive' in a technical sense doesn't apply to alcholol (or applies to alcholol in the same manner it applies to food, where in 96% of those who use alcholol or food do not demonstrate an abuse disorder) - I am still researching actual facts and figures, which I hope to have perhaps within a week.

Sorry, I am very familiar with the technical defintion and you are wrong, reread the DSM and ICD.

:)
 
Due to the fact that I want the conversation to move forward, and I also don’t want people to wait forever for me to come up with figures (as I just don’t have the research time – I may very will do so in the future, but cannot predict how long that might take – certainly more than a week) – due to these factors I retract my assertion that alcohol isn’t addictive.

:cool: Cool!

Addiction is defined by a pattern of behavior, not by the withdrawal profile of the drug.

I remember when cocaine was 'just psychologically addictive'.
 
As far as the danger of delusion or denial:

I'd think that some people suffering from addiction may already be used to coping by using those mechanisms. "One more won't hurt..." "I can quit tomorrow..." "I don't really drink that much more than other people..." "I'm not really an alcoholic because..."

That doesn't apply to every alcoholic, of course, and even those it does apply to may be able to separate one kind of denial from another, so they can reject "I'm not really an alcoholic despite all the evidence," for example, while accepting "There's a higher power in control despite the lack of evidence."

But if it's good for an alcoholic to face the truth without flinching, even if the evidence points to an uncomfortable conclusion, it seems contradictory to suggest at the same time that sometimes fooling oneself on important topics is okay.

Parts is parts, in harm reduction you take half measures, so while cigarettes are not a good thing, quitting drinking is the first priority. And why I feel rehab should let peopel play cards.

The goal is to have the person be honest about their choices around drinkng and the consequences of those choices.

If they want to believe in Bo Peep and Sheepish Choir that is fine, as long as they are honest in that one area.

The goal is to stop drinking. DFD
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom