Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.

I have been pretty busy and won't have much time until after 6:00 pm tonight, but let me try to explain.

Let's say you go to doctor AA for a severe illness.

He gives you 12 things to do in order to heal you.

You don't follow them because you feel they are just suggestions. You change them to whatever you want. So that you don't take the antibiotic, you go dancing instead, etc.

If you don't get better, you blame yourself for not following Dr. AA's advice but if you do get better you credit Dr. AA. for his great advice but in either case, you didn't follow the suggestions so how can Dr. AA.'s advice be responsible for the cure or lack there of?
 
Last edited:
Let's say you go to doctor AA for a severe illness.

He gives you 12 things to do in order to heal you.

You don't follow them because you feel they are just suggestions. You change them to whatever you want. So that you don't take the antibiotic, you go dancing instead, etc.

If you don't get better, you blame yourself for not following Dr. AA's advice but if you do get better you credit Dr. AA. for his great advice but in either case, you didn't follow the suggestions so how can Dr. AA.'s advice be responsible for the cure or lack there of?

Sounds like you're describing magical thinking...an affliction a few people here seem to be "infected" with...at least that is my conclusion judging from the irrational posts I've read here.
 
Sounds like you're describing magical thinking...an affliction a few people here seem to be "infected" with...at least that is my conclusion judging from the irrational posts I've read here.
Naturally, "Reality Man" does not suffer from this debilitating affliction. That's what makes him such a cool superhero.
 
Naturally, "Reality Man" does not suffer from this debilitating affliction. That's what makes him such a cool superhero.

The last vestige of discussion, an entire post attacking the person and not the argument.
 
Sounds like you're describing magical thinking...an affliction a few people here seem to be "infected" with...at least that is my conclusion judging from the irrational posts I've read here.
Because, as has been mentioned many times before, the literature is but one component of AA. I have never worked the steps all the way through with a sponsor. I have not picked up a chip in about 10 years. Yet the first 2 years of sobriety I was at our local AA club house daily getting help from other people in recovery on how to "live life on life's terms." Is your fictional DR free? AA is. My neurologist tells me she thinks I have sleep apena. The hospital called me yesterday and said that after they filed my insurance I would owe an additional $1800. She wanted to know if I wanted to set up payments. I told her I was already financing my diverticulitis @ $61 per month and could not afford another payment. I told her to cancel the appointment.
For those with no money AA is gift from FSM.
Please demonstrate where I or others have displayed magical thinking. What quyak did is build a strawman and then argue against that.
 
The last vestige of discussion, an entire post attacking the person and not the argument.
I plead not guilty. The poster implicitly claimed immunity from an "affliction" with which he alleges that other posters here are "infected": magical thinking. My counterargument (regardless of whether you are capable of recognizing it as such) is that that IS a form of magical thinking.
 
Sounds like you're describing magical thinking...an affliction a few people here seem to be "infected" with...at least that is my conclusion judging from the irrational posts I've read here.

On thinking about this (Pup and Dynamic's posts) I have think it comes down to control. What I mean is, we were trying to control lifes events that we actually had no control over. The serenity prayer is a key to addressing this also (I have left out "god" deliberately - I do not want to detract from the point):

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change
Courage to change the things I can
And wisdom to know the difference


The very act of "handing over" my expectations in any outcome is very liberating. Most alcoholics were/are in one sense or another control freaks, perfectionists or similar. By releasing my expectations of people, places and things, I no longer have a one sided emotional investment in the end result. This helps keep ones ego, resentments and self-pity in tact (three main enemies of the alky).

Others might use a different term: "Hope for the best and prepare for the worst". As such all bases are covered.

In this sense, there is no act of handing over to a higher power, just a matter of allowing for all expectations, not just the one we hope for. And/or releasing ourselves from the involvement of things that have (probably) nothing to do with us anyway.

Cheers

Look at your avatar. It is a bully.

Actually, my name is Alfie, the characters are Alfie and Spike. :boggled:

But yours is a hot chick and car.
What would Freud say.... I wonder. ;)
 
Last edited:
Well godofpie, keeping in mind AA's promise that 'rarely have we seen a person fail ...etc' - it may very well qualify as 'magical' thinking if one believes that when the majority of data available suggests the complete opposite. In reality, AA fails 95% of the time or more (5% success rate). We not only shouldn't waste another minute recommending anyone to AA (we should be spending our time and funds researching an actual treatment that works).
AA - just as any other cult religous 'program' - also frequently has very negative effects for those people who do try to 'thoroughly follow their path', as stated and shown in the quote below from AO's website:

"And now we come to the most important point:

But how effective is AA? That seemingly simple question has proven maddeningly hard to answer. Ask an addiction researcher a straightforward question about AA's success rate and you'll invariably get a distressingly vague answer.

That statement is not true at all. A.A. does not work. A.A. has a terrible failure rate, and a high death rate, and a zero-percent improvement over normal spontaneous recovery.

The "addiction researchers" are not vague about the numbers unless they work for a 12-Step treatment center, and don't want to admit that they are selling quack medicine. The honest addiction researchers have produced very clear numbers:

1. Dr. Jeffrey Brandsma found that A.A. indoctrination greatly increased the rate of binge drinking in alcoholics. People who were sent to A.A. ended up, after 9 months of A.A., doing FIVE TIMES as much binge drinking as another group of alcoholics who got no such help, and NINE TIMES as much binge drinking as another group that got Rational Behavior Therapy.

2. Dr. Keith Ditman found that A.A. involvement increased the rate of re-arrests for public drunkenness in a group of street drunks.

3. Dr. Diana Walsh found that "free" A.A. just messed up a lot of alcoholics and make them need more expensive hospitalization later.

4. Doctors Orford and Edwards conducted the largest and most expensive test of A.A. in England. They found that having a doctor talk to alcoholics and their wives for only one hour, only one time, telling them to quit drinking or they would die, was just as effective as a whole year of A.A.-based treatment.

5. This one is the most damning evidence of all, because it came from a doctor who loves Alcoholics Anonymous, and is one of its biggest promoters. He is also a member of the Board of Trustees of Alcoholics Anonymous [World] Services, Inc.. Doctor George E. Vaillant (who later became a Professor of Psychology at Harvard University), clearly demonstrated that A.A. treatment kills patients. For eight years, while he tried to prove that A.A. works, his A.A.-based treatment program had a zero-percent success rate above normal spontaneous remission, and worse, it had the highest death rate of any kind of alcoholism treatment that he studied. Dr. Vaillant candidly called the A.A. death rate "appalling". At the end of 8 years, the score with his first 100 A.A.-treated patients was: 5 sober, 29 dead, and 66 still drinking.

Those are not "vague numbers". "

These sorts of studies - and other's I have referenced - can be very upsetting to any of the AA faithful , but facts are facts - it takes 'magical thinking' to ignore them.

Remove god from AA - remove the stuff that talks about 'He is our Father, We are his Children' religious bofoonery, and what you have is a bunch of people, sitting in a room together, trying to support each other to get, and stay , sober. THAT actually has some chance of being helpful (according to the following scientific study):

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html

and

http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

So in summary , belief that AA has other than a 95% failure rate - a rate that would get any other 'treatment' for nearly any other 'disease' thrown back - belief in AA's efficiency contrary to the actual data certainly seems to qualify as magical thinking..
 
Last edited:
I remain completely bewildered as to why you are in AA Tinyal.
You have been there for 20 years (supposedly), and presumably it has given you relief (in part at least).
Yet here you are wanting to remove/destroy the very fellowship that assisted you when you needed help.

You are coming off as one with an awful lot of sour grapes dude.

Your comments have lost all validity given your ridiculous claims that alcohol is not addictive (or a drug, depending on how onbe read your comment around same).

You want to change the language to be more inclusive to all, yet say it doesn't work.:confused:

Why?
 
On thinking about this (Pup and Dynamic's posts) I have think it comes down to control. What I mean is, we were trying to control lifes events that we actually had no control over. The serenity prayer is a key to addressing this also (I have left out "god" deliberately - I do not want to detract from the point):

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change
Courage to change the things I can
And wisdom to know the difference


The very act of "handing over" my expectations in any outcome is very liberating. Most alcoholics were/are in one sense or another control freaks, perfectionists or similar. By releasing my expectations of people, places and things, I no longer have a one sided emotional investment in the end result. This helps keep ones ego, resentments and self-pity in tact (three main enemies of the alky).

Others might use a different term: "Hope for the best and prepare for the worst". As such all bases are covered.

In this sense, there is no act of handing over to a higher power, just a matter of allowing for all expectations, not just the one we hope for. And/or releasing ourselves from the involvement of things that have (probably) nothing to do with us anyway.
Cheers
This.
And I still use the serenity prayer to this day when I am feeling out of sorts or frustrated over something I am trying to control, like my teenage daughter. And by "prayer" I mean finding a quite place, sitting peacefully and comfortably and repeating it over and over in my mind, very similar to what I do using bio feedback to control my migraines. Do the haters consider bio feedback to be "magical thinking" or woo?
 
You want to change the language to be more inclusive to all, yet say it doesn't work.:confused:

And you say anyone who isn't happy should try to change the group conscience but then you complain when they do that. Why?
 
How convenient of you to "forget" that at the end of that cartoon alfie becomes the bully.

Actually, if you really do recall the cartoon, you will remember that Sylvester became the bully when Spike lost his nerve. Alfie (or was he called Chester) came to the rescue of his big mate by dispatching the bully.

So much for your comaprisons. :p

At any rate, I am called Alfie because of a Derek and Clyde skit.

Pot..kettle...black...

Evidence/examples/comparisons.
Anything? :)
 
Last edited:
How so? Unless you're claiming that he's lying about not drinking?

One can certainly say that Alfie isn't proof that AA does work: just because he credits AA with his abstinence doesn't mean he's right. But how do you get to claim that he's proof it doesn't work?

How do we know he's been abstinent.
 
And you say anyone who isn't happy should try to change the group conscience but then you complain when they do that. Why?

I don't "complain" about it at all.
I simply cast my vote like everyone else. I have no soapbox on this issue; it's simply that (at this time) I see no reason for change.
I have explained more than once. :boggled:

But, I have yet to hear why people who want to change the language to make it more "inclusive" do so, when they also say AA doesn't work.
 
I remain completely bewildered as to why you are in AA Tinyal.
You have been there for 20 years (supposedly), and presumably it has given you relief (in part at least).
Yet here you are wanting to remove/destroy the very fellowship that assisted you when you needed help.

Well, half true. Tinyal isn't trying to destroy the fellowship, he is trying to make an ineffective program, effective.

Tinyal has my respect because he isn't just burying his head in the sand when it comes to a problem. He addresses the problem and makes an attempt to correct it. It's the fellowship he is trying to save while throwing out the other junk.

Meanwhile, you appear to have a very unreasonable fear of any type of change. Denial and avoidance has never solved a problem. Tinyal's ideas may seem revolutionary to you, I know . . . but you should try it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom