Well godofpie, keeping in mind AA's promise that 'rarely have we seen a person fail ...etc' - it may very well qualify as 'magical' thinking if one believes that when the majority of data available suggests the complete opposite. In reality, AA fails 95% of the time or more (5% success rate). We not only shouldn't waste another minute recommending anyone to AA (we should be spending our time and funds researching an actual treatment that works).
AA - just as any other cult religous 'program' - also frequently has very negative effects for those people who do try to 'thoroughly follow their path', as stated and shown in the quote below from AO's website:
"And now we come to the most important point:
But h
ow effective is AA? That seemingly simple question has proven maddeningly hard to answer. Ask an addiction researcher a straightforward question about AA's success rate and you'll invariably get a distressingly vague answer.
That statement is not true at all. A.A. does not work.
A.A. has a terrible failure rate, and a high death rate, and a zero-percent improvement over normal spontaneous recovery.
The "addiction researchers" are not vague about the numbers unless they work for a 12-Step treatment center, and don't want to admit that they are selling quack medicine. The honest addiction researchers have produced very clear numbers:
1. Dr. Jeffrey Brandsma found that
A.A. indoctrination greatly increased the rate of binge drinking in alcoholics. People who were sent to A.A. ended up, after 9 months of A.A., doing FIVE TIMES as much binge drinking as another group of alcoholics who got no such help, and NINE TIMES as much binge drinking as another group that got Rational Behavior Therapy.
2. Dr. Keith Ditman found that A
.A. involvement increased the rate of re-arrests for public drunkenness in a group of street drunks.
3. Dr. Diana Walsh found that "free"
A.A. just messed up a lot of alcoholics and make them need more expensive hospitalization later.
4. Doctors Orford and Edwards conducted the largest and most expensive test of A.A. in England. They found that
having a doctor talk to alcoholics and their wives for only one hour, only one time, telling them to quit drinking or they would die, was just as effective as a whole year of A.A.-based treatment.
5. This one is the most damning evidence of all, because it came from a doctor who loves Alcoholics Anonymous, and is one of its biggest promoters. He is also a member of the Board of Trustees of Alcoholics Anonymous [World] Services, Inc.. Doctor George E. Vaillant (who later became a Professor of Psychology at Harvard University), clearly demonstrated that A.A. treatment kills patients. For eight years, while he tried to prove that A.A. works, his
A.A.-based treatment program had a zero-percent success rate above normal spontaneous remission, and worse, it had the highest death rate of any kind of alcoholism treatment that he studied. Dr. Vaillant candidly called the A.A. death rate "appalling". At the end of 8 years, the score with his first 100 A.A.-treated patients was: 5 sober, 29 dead, and 66 still drinking.
Those are not "vague numbers". "
These sorts of studies - and other's I have referenced - can be very upsetting to any of the AA faithful , but facts are facts - it takes 'magical thinking' to ignore them.
Remove god from AA - remove the stuff that talks about 'He is our Father, We are his Children' religious bofoonery, and what you have is a bunch of people, sitting in a room together, trying to support each other to get, and stay , sober.
THAT actually has some chance of being helpful (according to the following scientific study):
http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html
and
http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm
So in summary , belief that AA has other than a 95% failure rate - a rate that would get any other 'treatment' for nearly any other 'disease' thrown back - belief in AA's efficiency contrary to the
actual data certainly seems to qualify as magical thinking..