Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
How could that be useful ? If you _weren't_ in that situation you could just let go, so obviously you need to be quite aware of
that fact.
I think one of the reasons I'm not a rock climber is that my limited experiences in that area suggest that I am prone to becoming so acutely aware of that fact that I freeze. I might possibly work through that if I had some good enough reason to try, but the thing is, I think it's a stupid hobby anyway.
 
This may be true, but there is no reason to remain that way...just "giving in" to magical thinking because it is "easier" is flat out stupid, and I can't believe you are actually advocating that, particularly on a skeptics forum.
I'm saying that it is sometimes useful to do so. You "give in" to magical thinking every time you watch a movie or read a work of fiction -- or don't, and are thereby unable to derive any pleasure from those activities.
 
Last edited:
I'm saying that it is sometimes useful to do so.

No...in the real world it just makes you a patsy for all kinds of paranormal/supernatural beliefs. Why would you think advocating such idiocy a good thing??

You "give in" to magical thinking every time you watch a movie or read a work of fiction -- or don't, and are thereby unable to derive any pleasure from those activities.

No that is a complete mischaracterization of what I posted. It's called "suspension of belief" for a reason, and at no time do I forget I'm watching a movie. "Giving in" to magical thinking is exactly as stated...believing things real that are not real...it has nothing to do with suspending belief while watching a movie.

What kind of drugs are you on??
 
Last edited:
No...in the real world it just makes you a patsy for all kinds of paranormal/supernatural beliefs.
Sometimes it still works. If you don't drink from the poisoned water hole, it doesn't matter so much that the reason you don't is because you believe it to be haunted by evil spirits.

No that is a complete mischaracterization of what I posted.
It's not any kind of a characterization of what you posted.

It's called "suspension of belief" for a reason, and at no time do I forget I'm watching a movie.
Part of you does, though; that's just the thing. It's nothing but patterns of flickering light on the surface of a two-dimensional screen, and you know that, but it doesn't prevent you from becoming completely immersed in a particularly gripping drama -- and when that happens, there are measurable physiological responses. You (whatever that is) may be able to exert some control over this, but what you're really doing in the case of watching a movie is exploiting it.

Giving in" to magical thinking is exactly as stated...believing things real that are not real...it has nothing to do with suspending belief while watching a movie.
I disagree. I submit that suspending disbelief while watching a movie is a prime example of such a "giving in". Your brain and (say) your adrenal glands may not always agree on what is "real", and the makers of movies and designers of theme parks are just a couple of examples of people who earn a living from this phenomenon.

What kind of drugs are you on??
I get asked that question all the time -- usually by pre-exam nurses. It's a long enough list that I'm proud of my ability to rattle it off from memory, but the only thing of likely interest here is that none of them are known for producing psychotropic effects.
 
I've never been into rock climbing myself, so I can't speak from personal experience on that -- but if I were hanging by my fingertips to a cliff, hundreds of feet above a grisly death by blunt trauma, I can see how it might be helpful to pretend that I wasn't, even though I'd be lying to myself . . . Sometimes it's more about what works than what's real.

Well, I have done a fair amount of rock climbing and this is completely insane logic. If there is a danger, the worst thing you can do is turn and hide from it. In order to best protect yourself you need to turn and face it.

If you are being stabbed by a mugger, it doesn't help to pretend it isn't happening. If your brakes fail as you head for a cliff, it doesn't help to pretend that the brakes are still good or the cliff isn't there, and . . . it doesn't help to pretend you aren't hanging from a cliff by your fingertips when you are.

A realistic assessment of the situation is your best bet for dealing with it. Fake it until you make it doesn't work, it is just a trite adage that does more harm than good.
 
So now you "criticize" spelling errors? You realize that is the last dying gasp of someone promoting a "lame" argument.

Why do people insist that AA isn't religious? is the question that started this thread...the only answer I can come up with is that there must be something to FEAR in admitting AA is religious...

What are you afraid of, alfie???

Drinking.

But I was not so much pointing out your errors but ensuring you knew what I was responding to. A little touchy aren't we? :)

No, it is more than that. It spelled out the aspects of AA process which are still used today and which you defend.

You speak then of the steps and traditions then, which, while in the big book are slightly different. I was responding to the big book comment.

I have made my postion on the steps and traditions patently clear, I would have thought.

But back to the big book. Wht do you want the language changed to be more inclusive if you think AA doesn't work anyway?
 
Last edited:
I think the problem for me is that an atheist only has two choices, believe in something that goes against everything they believe or make up a lie about what a higher power is.

Both positions are dishonest and it is morally wrong to force someone to choose one just to belong. And it is still morally wrong even if other atheists make the choice.[/QUOTE]

A higher power is not compulsory, it is suggested.

.. big snip of BS .. and I also don’t want people to wait forever for me to come up with figures (as I just don’t have the research time – I may very will do so in the future, but cannot predict how long that might take – certainly more than a week) – due to these factors I retract my assertion that alcohol isn’t addictive.[/B]

Interestingly you can come up with reference after reference on religious determinations in the courts but not some simple references from experts as to why alcohol isn't addictive. :rolleyes::boggled:

But I thank you for your retraction.

Indeed. What if I don't want a higher power ? Does that mean I can't get sober ? Ridiculous.

Don't have one then. It is only suggested after all. :rolleyes:

A realistic assessment of the situation is your best bet for dealing with it. Fake it until you make it doesn't work, it is just a trite adage that does more harm than good.

There's that word "harm" again.
Could someone please explain to me exactly what harm can be done?
 
Last edited:
Well, I have done a fair amount of rock climbing and this is completely insane logic. If there is a danger, the worst thing you can do is turn and hide from it. In order to best protect yourself you need to turn and face it.
If there's a completely sane logic to rock climbing, I probably wouldn't understand it even if you could explain it (especially if it involves climbing backwards, as you seem to suggest). My preferred approach is to avoid that particular danger altogether. If it were for some reason unavoidable, I still think my best bet at staying focused on what I needed to do would be to act as if grisly death wasn't waiting below. But, as my words were carefully chosen to indicate, that's just me. For all I know, there are maniacs out there whose whole reason for rock climbing is that they like staring grisly death in the face. If that's a buzz for you, knock yourself out.

A realistic assessment of the situation is your best bet for dealing with it.
If that were true, there wouldn't be any movies, because there wouldn't be any actors. No rock and roll stars either. Or artists. Damn few small businesses. A realistic assessment of the situation is your best bet for doing science, but when it comes to what it takes to inspire humans, or anything else under the general heading of "figuring out what makes humans tick" -- well, to coin a phrase, "Science may one day accomplish this, but it hasn't done so yet".
 
Then what you are doing is not AA....and you're only fooling yourself if you think so.

What makes you think that?
The steps themselves are "suggested", there is nothing that is compulsory: "the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".

Please explain and provide evidence.

As for not doing AA, you will need to tell the many friends, hundreds of meetings and my sobriety that I am not doing AA, and that my step work was and is just my imagination. The you can tell me why I am so happy in my life and with AA and why I haven't had a drink or drug since 1999.
 
Then what you are doing is not AA....and you're only fooling yourself if you think so.
If you think that, then what you're doing is not critical thinking. What, you question my authority to make that declaration?
 
As far as the danger of delusion or denial:

I'd think that some people suffering from addiction may already be used to coping by using those mechanisms. "One more won't hurt..." "I can quit tomorrow..." "I don't really drink that much more than other people..." "I'm not really an alcoholic because..."

That doesn't apply to every alcoholic, of course, and even those it does apply to may be able to separate one kind of denial from another, so they can reject "I'm not really an alcoholic despite all the evidence," for example, while accepting "There's a higher power in control despite the lack of evidence."

But if it's good for an alcoholic to face the truth without flinching, even if the evidence points to an uncomfortable conclusion, it seems contradictory to suggest at the same time that sometimes fooling oneself on important topics is okay.
 
What makes you think that?
The steps themselves are "suggested", there is nothing that is compulsory: "the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".

Please explain and provide evidence.

As for not doing AA, you will need to tell the many friends, hundreds of meetings and my sobriety that I am not doing AA, and that my step work was and is just my imagination. The you can tell me why I am so happy in my life and with AA and why I haven't had a drink or drug since 1999.

What we need to tell them is that you are living proof that AA doesn't work.
 
What we need to tell them is that you are living proof that AA doesn't work.

How so? Unless you're claiming that he's lying about not drinking?

One can certainly say that Alfie isn't proof that AA does work: just because he credits AA with his abstinence doesn't mean he's right. But how do you get to claim that he's proof it doesn't work?
 
As far as the danger of delusion or denial:

I'd think that some people suffering from addiction may already be used to coping by using those mechanisms. "One more won't hurt..." "I can quit tomorrow..." "I don't really drink that much more than other people..." "I'm not really an alcoholic because..."

That doesn't apply to every alcoholic, of course, and even those it does apply to may be able to separate one kind of denial from another, so they can reject "I'm not really an alcoholic despite all the evidence," for example, while accepting "There's a higher power in control despite the lack of evidence."

But if it's good for an alcoholic to face the truth without flinching, even if the evidence points to an uncomfortable conclusion, it seems contradictory to suggest at the same time that sometimes fooling oneself on important topics is okay.
Nice. That's one of the most reasonable arguments I've seen in this thread.

I would answer that where human thinking is concerned, contradiction is arguably more often the rule than the exception. Recovery-cliche references to the internal "committee" resonate with (preliminary) findings from the modern science of neurology: the function of the human brain is largely characterized by modularity.

At various times in my life I have found myself "torn" over even trivial decisions, and, occasionally, deeply conflicted over important ones. I wish I could say that I was always successful at applying the solution you've just suggested: go with what works for you (even if it amounts to some form of denial) and reject what works against you -- but at those points where I made some of my worst mistakes, I knew they were mistakes; they felt like mistakes even as I was making them. If my internal dialogue was dominated by the sort of denial-speak you describe, it was probably not a legitimate or important part of an ongoing decision-making process; it was, just as you say, a coping mechanism. The decision had essentially already been made, and what I was trying to cope with was the conflict that arose out of my deeply felt awareness that I was not acting in my own best interests. (I'm obviously not talking only about drinking here).

Whether the "disease" model of alcoholism is scientifically defensible or not, I find it useful as a metaphor. Call it a cognitive submodule, or a cluster of submodules. If I view internal denial-speak as among the potential outputs of such a module, I may be in a better position to ignore those outputs (which is another way of saying that other modules may be in a better position to override those outputs -- within this admitedly ambitious framework). Whereas, "There's a higher power at work here" may be viewed as among the potential inputs, though precisely what modules might receive and utilize them I haven't a clue. And I don't need to. No more than I need to concern myself with the details of how my stomach deals with the tuna sandwich I had for lunch.

One thing I feel certain of (though I would be hard-pressed to prove) is that cognitive submodules love symbols -- and the nature of symbols is that they stand for something else; they are a (hopefully benign) form of "fooling yourself" by substituting one thing for another. It is no more necessary that every person employ the same symbols in communicating with their own cognitive submodules than it is that every person eat the same thing for lunch.
 
What we need to tell them is that you are living proof that AA doesn't work.

How so?
I go to AA and I have been sober for a long time now. I credit AA with (at least part, maybe a large part) of my sobriety; the fellowship helped me in ways that other interventions didn't and couldn't.

As far as the danger of delusion or denial:

I'd think that some people suffering from addiction may already be used to coping by using those mechanisms. "One more won't hurt..." "I can quit tomorrow..." "I don't really drink that much more than other people..." "I'm not really an alcoholic because..."

That doesn't apply to every alcoholic, of course, and even those it does apply to may be able to separate one kind of denial from another, so they can reject "I'm not really an alcoholic despite all the evidence," for example, while accepting "There's a higher power in control despite the lack of evidence."

But if it's good for an alcoholic to face the truth without flinching, even if the evidence points to an uncomfortable conclusion, it seems contradictory to suggest at the same time that sometimes fooling oneself on important topics is okay.

Dynamic said this was "nice".

I have to agree, I read this about four hours ago and have been musing on it since (I actually went shopping with the hot Mrs Alfie). It is the first time someone has actually, and really challenged my thinking in this thread.

My automatic reaction was to say something like; "but not everyone has a higher power", or more specifically a "traditional deity". But while that is true, it is also true that I have seen many 'critical thinkers' reject their atheism in AA and love a God (as they understood him). Whilst I have no problem with that personally, what you say makes some sense. Right now I have no idea to be frank, except to say that perhaps they were desperate enough to "go to any lengths".

Many talk also of a spiritual awakening, some even talk of Gods intervention.

I loved Dynamics response but I now need time to digest that too. :)

I hope I can formulate a solid response/addition to both (I will sleep on them). But in the meantime I thought I would simply say "bravo" to you both.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
After much ado and verbiage, he did reluctantly retract it... er, sort of: Citing time constraints as to why he was unable to proivide supporting evidence.

But it does give us an indication of where he is at.
 
As far as the danger of delusion or denial:

I'd think that some people suffering from addiction may already be used to coping by using those mechanisms. "One more won't hurt..." "I can quit tomorrow..." "I don't really drink that much more than other people..." "I'm not really an alcoholic because..."

That doesn't apply to every alcoholic, of course, and even those it does apply to may be able to separate one kind of denial from another, so they can reject "I'm not really an alcoholic despite all the evidence," for example, while accepting "There's a higher power in control despite the lack of evidence."

But if it's good for an alcoholic to face the truth without flinching, even if the evidence points to an uncomfortable conclusion, it seems contradictory to suggest at the same time that sometimes fooling oneself on important topics is okay.
I agree with Dynamic. A thoughtful and well reasoned post and a reasonable question. When I got sober I needed coping skills. Alcohol and drugs had been my coping skills. I can not explain how it works but by mentally being able to relieve some of the internal pressure by "turning it over to a power greater than myself" was very liberating. I have always been a very self sufficient person and would never ask for help for anything. The AA literature says "Alcohol is but a symptom of our problem" and that our real problem is "self will run riot". This part really spoke to me. Like I have said before, if I was not at an "alcoholic bottom" the program probably would not have had the same effect on me. There were psychological effects at work inside of me that I can not explain and I certainly understand how someone that has not "been there, done that" would be dubious about the basic tenants of AA. All I can tell you is that from day one I was told that my atheism would not be an impediment to seeking help through AA. Most people that come to AA, like most people in the US, don't have a problem with god belief. For the 10 or 15% of us that are atheists, we are encouraged to find our own path (take what you need and leave the rest philosophy). I hope this addresses your question.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom