Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe.

But thanks, you have shown Tinyal to be incorrect via the definitions provided in that alcohol/alcohol is an addiction/addictive.

The term disease is another topic entirely.

Oh, yeah! I thought you put me on ignore . . . perhaps you were just being less than honest so you could avoid answering the tough questions. :p
 
That well poisoned enough for you? Have you had response from your appeal to authority yet?

There are people in this thread who are AA veterans who say it is.

They also say alcohol is not addictive. So much for that expert.

Why? Why can the Big Book be so obviously wrong on so many things and yet people like you, Alfie and godofpie (Geez, ilk would fit nicely in there!) still defend it?

I have not defended it at all, except to say it an historical record of one mans journey and opinion (largely). And that if there is changes to be made, they will be made by the membership.
 
You sir, are incredibly uninformed and seem to twist the facts to suit your own world view of AA and addiction and alcoholism. And my mom smokes 3 cigs a day and has for 40 years. I have known literally an ass-load of people that can put down cocaine and not look back. I couldn't. Do you know anything about brain chemistry? It would appear that you don't.

As much as I'd like Tinyal to bring up some evidence of his/her claim, you're just throwing random testimonies. That's not evidence.
 
As much as I'd like Tinyal to bring up some evidence of his/her claim, you're just throwing random testimonies. That's not evidence.

So do you think alcohol is not addictive, and/or not a drug?

Can you still believe his testimonies regarding AA when he clearly has such a tainted view of the issue, science and the problems of those facing recovery?

No wonder he is no longer asked to speak and is ostracised; I dare say it has nothing to do with his atheism, but his radical (ridiculous) claims and views.

Can you imagine anyone telling an alcoholic that alcohol is not addictive? you might as well tell them they can drink in safety; nothing could possibly go wrong? :boggled:

Incredible!
It would be hilarious if the results might not be so tragic.
 
Last edited:
The Big Book is based on the wishful thinking of a group of people.
True enough, though "hopeful thinking" is probably how a lot of them would put it. Hopeful thinking may be no less dubious a tool for scientific inquiry than wishful thinking, but in preserving one's sanity in the face of the risks and uncertainties life presents, I would argue that a measured amount of it is indispensible. For me, recovery began with wishing that I could be free from the torment my life had become -- but the things one wishes for are the things one cannot have; hope implies real possibility. What AA did for me was to give me hope. Not very scientific -- but then, neither is the OP's question.

There is so much of it that can, and has, been proved wrong that it is a wonder anyone would use it.
Anyone in their right mind, that is.

But it is still the bible of AA and AA zealots defend it and AA tooth and nail.
They probably would, if they ever spent enough time outside of AA meetings that they had occasion to do so, but AA zealots tend not to do that. I've made it clear a number of times now that I'm not here advocating AA. If I wanted to defend the Big Book, I don't believe I'd begin by dredging up what I consider to be one its most comically absurd passages. What is interesting is how quick you are to equate questioning AA's so-called religious nature with defending AA.

"Is it valid?" and "Is it religious?" are two separate questions.

It is like you have this switch that, as soon as the subject of AA comes up, your brain gets shut off and your fingers start typing BS.
Perhaps by following your excellent example of methodical and unemotional reasoning, I will eventually learn to overcome this disability.
 
By the way, your means belonging to you, you're means you are. I assumed you meant the former.

So now you "criticize" spelling errors? You realize that is the last dying gasp of someone promoting a "lame" argument.

Why do people insist that AA isn't religious? is the question that started this thread...the only answer I can come up with is that there must be something to FEAR in admitting AA is religious...

What are you afraid of, alfie???
 
Qayak, take a breath. I just typed a q without a u, learn to spell.

Damn the rules . . . embrace free-spelling! :D

Kayak, qayak, qajak, qjak, qyak . . . are all correct. It just depends on which early book on Innuit culture you read.
 
I have not defended it at all, except to say it an historical record of one mans journey and opinion (largely). And that if there is changes to be made, they will be made by the membership.

No, it is more than that. It spelled out the aspects of AA process which are still used today and which you defend.
 
What is interesting is how quick you are to equate questioning AA's so-called religious nature with defending AA.

Interesting. You pick one medical error out of the AA bible and that is evidence that it is not the medical authority that people claim and yet there are hundreds of religious references, religious claims, and religious demands but that isn't evidence that it is religious.

With that amount of cognative dissonance I doubt your mind could be changed.
 
Not for those atheists and others who choose something other than a deity as their higher power. :rolleyes:
Why do you have such a problem with this?

I think the problem for me is that an atheist only has two choices, believe in something that goes against everything they believe or make up a lie about what a higher power is.

Both positions are dishonest and it is morally wrong to force someone to choose one just to belong. And it is still morally wrong even if other atheists make the choice.
 
In reference to my assertion that alcohol isn't addictive

The chemical itself is only as addictive as food, and just as dangerous - consume too much, you'll do stupid & dangerous things, as well as damage portions of the body. Out of the 100's of millions of people who use alcohol, only a small fraction - perhaps 4% - move into alcohol abuse. The other 96% deal with alcohol just fine, no addiction, no abuse - heavy drinkers can put it down, moderate, or give up altogether.
Aaalfie is putting words in my mouth (my what a surprise:?) when he claims I said alcohol isn’t a drug – of course it’s a drug!! It’s also a drug with a potential for abuse. What I am speaking of is it’s safety in comparison to other things typically considered addictive (opiates, for instance) as well as any number of things that have an abuse potential (such as Food or Sex).
In terms of substance abuse potential, alcohol is safer than sex - according to the most recent studies summarized here, Sex is addictive to 6% human beings:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/health/emotional_health/addictions/sex_addiction.shtml
The study referenced here (about half way down the page) gives a figure of 10.7 million alcohol abusing/dependent persons in the USA (using 1989 data), a rate that works out to around 3.6%.
http://www.dulwichcentre.com.au/alcohol-many-dimensions.html
So you're calling a drug that has a 4% problem rate (specifically, a 4% abuse potential) an addictive drug?
The disease model of alcoholism promoted solely by AA has taken over the web, and it’s near impossible to get to the facts with the time I have available. What’s clear however is that the vast majority of human beings use alcohol safely, it’s also clear that large numbers of people can use it heavily without becoming dependent.
The same cannot be said of opiates, or coco derived drugs – in those cases, the potential for abuse is, in a sense, built in to the drug itself (ie: the drug is addictive).
Due to the fact that I want the conversation to move forward, and I also don’t want people to wait forever for me to come up with figures (as I just don’t have the research time – I may very will do so in the future, but cannot predict how long that might take – certainly more than a week) – due to these factors I retract my assertion that alcohol isn’t addictive.
I think it has been instructive to some people in this thread what I meant – now back to our regularly scheduled ‘aaalfie attacks the messenger not the message’ thread.
 
I think the problem for me is that an atheist only has two choices, believe in something that goes against everything they believe or make up a lie about what a higher power is.

Both positions are dishonest and it is morally wrong to force someone to choose one just to belong. And it is still morally wrong even if other atheists make the choice.

Indeed. What if I don't want a higher power ? Does that mean I can't get sober ? Ridiculous.
 
The chemical itself is only as addictive as food, and just as dangerous - consume too much, you'll do stupid & dangerous things, as well as damage portions of the body. Out of the 100's of millions of people who use alcohol, only a small fraction - perhaps 4% - move into alcohol abuse. The other 96% deal with alcohol just fine, no addiction, no abuse - heavy drinkers can put it down, moderate, or give up altogether.
Aaalfie is putting words in my mouth (my what a surprise:?) when he claims I said alcohol isn’t a drug – of course it’s a drug!! It’s also a drug with a potential for abuse. What I am speaking of is it’s safety in comparison to other things typically considered addictive (opiates, for instance) as well as any number of things that have an abuse potential (such as Food or Sex).
In terms of substance abuse potential, alcohol is safer than sex - according to the most recent studies summarized here, Sex is addictive to 6% human beings:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/health/emotional_health/addictions/sex_addiction.shtml
The study referenced here (about half way down the page) gives a figure of 10.7 million alcohol abusing/dependent persons in the USA (using 1989 data), a rate that works out to around 3.6%.
http://www.dulwichcentre.com.au/alcohol-many-dimensions.html
So you're calling a drug that has a 4% problem rate (specifically, a 4% abuse potential) an addictive drug?
The disease model of alcoholism promoted solely by AA has taken over the web, and it’s near impossible to get to the facts with the time I have available. What’s clear however is that the vast majority of human beings use alcohol safely, it’s also clear that large numbers of people can use it heavily without becoming dependent.
The same cannot be said of opiates, or coco derived drugs – in those cases, the potential for abuse is, in a sense, built in to the drug itself (ie: the drug is addictive).
Due to the fact that I want the conversation to move forward, and I also don’t want people to wait forever for me to come up with figures (as I just don’t have the research time – I may very will do so in the future, but cannot predict how long that might take – certainly more than a week) – due to these factors I retract my assertion that alcohol isn’t addictive.
I think it has been instructive to some people in this thread what I meant – now back to our regularly scheduled ‘aaalfie attacks the messenger not the message’ thread.

Perhaps you should start another thread, then, and ask for some help from other forum members in conducting said research. No matter what the conclusion is I'm sure it would be interesting.

*And I'd also like to have a link to the post where yrreg said what he says in your signature.
 
I think the problem for me is that an atheist only has two choices, believe in something that goes against everything they believe or make up a lie about what a higher power is.

If I may be so bold...the only thing I would change is that 2nd "believe"...in other words I would read it as, "The atheist only has two choices, believe in something that goes against everything they know from evidence, and the application of the scientific method, or make up a lie about what a higher power is."

Both positions are dishonest and it is morally wrong to force someone to choose one just to belong. And it is still morally wrong even if other atheists make the choice.

It actually is much worse than that. The whole idea of "fake it till you make it" encourages those who do not believe to lie to themselves.

How that can possibly be "helpful", I do not know...seems like it would have just the opposite effect to me.
 
If I may be so bold...the only thing I would change is that 2nd "believe"...in other words I would read it as, "The atheist only has two choices, believe in something that goes against everything they know from evidence, and the application of the scientific method, or make up a lie about what a higher power is."

I don't disagree with this. I was just using wording that would prevent the "can't disprove god" crowd from derailing the point as so often happens in this thread.

It actually is much worse than that. The whole idea of "fake it till you make it" encourages those who do not believe to lie to themselves.

How that can possibly be "helpful", I do not know...seems like it would have just the opposite effect to me.

Yes, I whole heartedly agree.
 
The whole idea of "fake it till you make it" encourages those who do not believe to lie to themselves.

How that can possibly be "helpful", I do not know...seems like it would have just the opposite effect to me.
I've never been into rock climbing myself, so I can't speak from personal experience on that -- but if I were hanging by my fingertips to a cliff, hundreds of feet above a grisly death by blunt trauma, I can see how it might be helpful to pretend that I wasn't, even though I'd be lying to myself. Life isn't science. Science isn't life. Sometimes it's more about what works than what's real.

We're born magical thinkers. If you're embarrassed about being included in that -- or convinced that it can never work for you but only against you -- then you can try to compensate by pretending to be all strictly-logic-and-evidence based, but you're swimming upstream against millions of years of evolution. If you can step back enough to see how easily you're sucked in by (say) a clever optical illusion, you may be able to see that it's just a different kind of fantasy; you've simply tried to recreate yourself as a superhero in your own little comic book: "Reality Man".

Of course, if you find that "helpful"...
 
I've never been into rock climbing myself, so I can't speak from personal experience on that -- but if I were hanging by my fingertips to a cliff, hundreds of feet above a grisly death by blunt trauma, I can see how it might be helpful to pretend that I wasn't, even though I'd be lying to myself.

How could that be useful ? If you _weren't_ in that situation you could just let go, so obviously you need to be quite aware of that fact.
 
Sometimes it's more about what works than what's real.

Exactly my point...how can something "work" if it is not real? Relying on something unreal to "work" is foolish, and can only lead to failure.

We're born magical thinkers.

This may be true, but there is no reason to remain that way...just "giving in" to magical thinking because it is "easier" is flat out stupid, and I can't believe you are actually advocating that, particularly on a skeptics forum.

Talk about bad advice.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom