Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's an easy fix, Joey. Don't put quote marks around things that are not quotes. Instead, paraphrase, or add a qualifier ... "the board basically said, 'It's not our responsibility.' " Signal that you are paraphrasing. Putting words in other people's mouths is dishonest.
I would have thought it was obvious that I was paraphrasing, you don't win points for nitpicking, just sayin. You calling me "dishonest", "fabricated a quote" "make things up" when it doesn't change the meaning of what they said at all, is clearly trying to win points of some kind or the other.

He's clearly saying they have a moral responsibility; he's implying they have a legal responsibility. Which is why I think the board will take some kind of action - there is legal exposure. In a lawsuit you're way better off saying,"No, it never occurred to us at all" than saying "We considered doing something about it and decided not to." There should be more literature put out than the one-page communique in 2001 that apparently applied only to the Central region.
You think they will take some kind of action? This was written years ago, nothing has happened, nothing will happen, because to them the structure of the system cult is more important than doing the right thing and changing how the entire program cult operates. The only way they could do it properly is have all people in authority or influence (leaders, sponsors, don't bother making the argument there are no authority figures in AA that's the oldest canard they have) subject to the same rules of professionalism as anyone else. The cult is structured the way it is, to give authority to people who don't deserve it, because that's who created it, woos who wanted to feel better about themselves for having the power to help other people, power over other people. Bill Wilson was the worst. He even enlisted the help of imaginary spirit guides to help him write the 12 and 12, such was his addiction to the feeling of importance.

From "Escape from the cult of AA"

DARE TO ASK YOURSELF 7 QUESTIONS:
1. Do you feel that A.A. is NOT the only road to Sobriety?
2. Do you take issue with being chided for questioning the “Program”?
3. Are you troubled by AA's Religious foundation?
4. Have you been greatly harmed by AA?
5. Do you ever wonder if AA is a cult?
6. Do you question being told that you cannot be angry?
7. Have you been forced to admit powerlessness over your life in a way that empowers other members while it diminishes you?

What's your mechanism for ensuring that "alcoholics only take the services of professionals" and outlawing peer support groups? That is what you just proposed doing, if I am I interpreting your words accurately
:rolleyes: I have said many times in this thread that I fully support support groups, but when you start giving advice or forming other people's belief systems about alcohol or alcoholism and recovery this is not peer support, this is medical advice. Peer support groups overseen and guided by professionals is the model others have wisely used.

I have had to say this continually because I am regularly attacked with the idea of "You don't want support groups? You heartless monster!" No, I don't want cults operating freely in society. There is a difference.

And, did you miss the part where I said I was in group therapy and briefly living under the same treatment center roof as a guy who was soon afterward arrested for first-degree murder? In a highly regarded professional setting?
What's the point? I'm against people with no qualifications other than drinking Bill Wilson's kool-aid being given authority to help indoctrinate (infect) newcomers to achieve sobriety with their belief system (cult memetics)

One mother, Joey. Not "some mothers." Do you really not see how your language kicks everything bad about AA up a notch? I notice you pluralize "molestors" when, again, that bullet item cited one molester. Also the incident is 7 years old, no excuse I know but not necessarily an epidemic.
He says "There is confusion about taking legal action against perpetrators because the victims think they will be breaking anomymity..." Where that is two mothers or one (do you really think that has ever only happened once?), or just one mother and multiple victims, there is a pattern of predators getting away with these crimes because vulnerable people are confused and thought-stopped with "anonymity" Why are you nitpicking over things like this? It doesn't win you any points, it doesn't make me look dishonest, this to me sounds like apologizing for a religious cult.

Also, as soon as she ran it by Paul he told her to call the police? I don't know what you do about such clueless people having children. Unfortunately parents don't have to pass parenting tests to become parents.
The thing is about vulnerable people and cults... :( sorry I can't continue this much longer it takes too much time.

Except for your insistence on "group leaders," I agree with that assessment. I can't swear there are no groups with an elected "leader," but I haven't seen any examples of this, on this forum or anywhere else.
The oldest AA canard "We have no leaders" (careful, that's not a direct quote ;):rolleyes:) is BS. The sponsees do what their sponsor says "listen to your sponsor" is something you hear all the time. People gain authority naturally. Look up Midtown, look up Clancy, those are cults, that is how it works.

I don't know any 15-year-olds in AA, but you've convinced me: Groups with minor members should act. They should elect someone to scan local sex offender databases, be on the lookout for these individuals, approach them if they are seen in a meeting and say, we'll be watching you. Or, they could post fliers in the window; it would be degrading to the offender, but survivable. If the meeting is within 300 feet of a school, such a person could be asked to leave on legal grounds. The board ought to use its voice to strongly suggest this policy but mandate it? No. There are groups that aren't on the books anywhere, groups where everyone's over 30, etc.

Here's something sad, a 15-year-old addict/alcoholic will be a predator magnet both inside & outside "the rooms." I wonder where they would be more at risk: on the streets and using, or clean in a group that has sober, responsible members.
It's very simple, if groups are not monitored and kept in line by a central authority, predators will rise to the top in some groups. It should be extremely easy, if you call yourself "alcoholics anonymous" this means there is monitoring and security enforced by people who know how these situations go bad. If you don't pass the test, if you don't do things properly, if you let someone be a sponsor who goes around giving anti-med advice, you lose your right to call yourself Alcoholics Anonymous. Of course, this is too much to ask, will never happen in a million years. Do you know any reformed cults that are now good for society? Nope, neither do I.

There are better groups out there that could just take their place.
 
Last edited:
Stinkin' Thinkin', "Muckracking the 12-Step Industry", members of this forum (ilsita for one) friends of mine, and many in this thread, have closed their blog. It will go back up with comments off in good time. You can read their goodbye letter here. The comments on that are quite something. I hope no one goes there from here to start something, that would be disrespectful in light of the circumstances.

Some of the craziest cult member trolls I have ever seen were featured there and posted in their comments. For a long time I was worried about them. Then on the 19th they reveal that someone has sent them a threatening email with ilse's home address in it, and then called them early the next morning, demanding that references to themselves be removed from the comments of the blog. (The comments described them as predators or delusional cult leaders or something along those lines, you know, the usual)

The next blog post in my RSS was "AA member threatens to cut off my head". They contacted the FBI.

So while this alone didn't cause them to shut down the blog, spending all of this time just dealing with these kinds of situations has been very taxing to them and they are moving on to be more effective in other ways. Death threats are not fun to deal with. This is not the first and will not be the last anti-AA group to suffer this kind of treatment and fate.

That was the best AA blog of all time. It helped many, many people get out of the cult and live much better lives. These were good, smart people. Not a hate group at all as some have tried to say. Go ahead and listen to an interview with them and see for yourself.

So, this turn of events is what has been behind my lack of interest in engaging in the same old arguments we had 6 months ago and the same old blatant caricatures of my arguments. I'm going to actually go do something about these problems.

So if you feel the need to bash ST for some strange reason, please remember that ilse is a member of this forum so the rules apply.

Thanks for everything ST crew, your efforts will be multiplied by the skeptic community a million times over.

That reminds me, ilse made a good point, the skeptic community is largely blind to the true nature of the cult, just how bad it is. It has done a good job blending into society. She wrote to Ed Brayton about this and he featured it on his widely read blog. A good point.

They also told me that this thread is just way too crazy for them to engage in, also that it was sad the way things were going, especially since it's James Randi's forum. At first I was in denial about this, but I have come around to their position.

James Randi "created" Penn and Teller, who created BS the 12-step episode (the best anti-AA video ever produced, fantastic television, a great intro to the cult of AA), which no doubt inspired the South Park 12-step epsiode (those guys are all best buds) So that's heartening.
 
Last edited:
Still waiting for the studies that demonstrate 'science-based medicine' actually helps anyone, ever. :( ;)
 
Nutbag wrote:

The real harm is that people go to AA thinking it's an effective program largely because AA touts itself as a cure-all for alcoholics,

"Rarely have we seen a person fail who has throughly followed our path."
That doesn't sound like a "cure all" statement to me.


but there isn't a shred of evidence that it does bumpkis for them.

Was there supposed to be Doctors reports , longitudinal studies ect....
Nutt your inability to be totally honest here is a bummer. You know AA and what it offers. Stop trying to act like it is something else just so you can criticize it.


And many of these people ******* die.

Oh!!! There is the drama.
Can you cite anything but your own anecdotal evidence?
I didn't think so.

Anyone who has been to AA meetings for long enough sees these people. They're the chronic relapsers who keep showing up in the rooms and then go get drunk. And instead of pointing them to science-based medicine, AA tells them that they didn't work the steps properly, didn't do their 90 in 90, didn't do enough service.

Nutt, is that what you did while you were in AA. Because you are right there are some folks who do say those things. Most members I know do not. If I had a friend who was struggling I would suggest he go to detox and then get some in house treatment. If AA was not working then the suggestions become slim frankly, depending upon where you live. Most addicts and alcoholics I know are down and out so having a computer isn't always handy. But if they can get to a library, college ect...they can probably hook up with a online group other then AA.
Please stop acting like all these other possibilities aside from AA are tested, studied and have been science based proven. if you had a problem with alcohol then you know damn well all the solutions out there are not providing great results.


That's a load of bull.

They went to a program that claims to help alcoholics, but can't provide a shred of evidence that it does so, and they get desperate. They get desperate because they're involved in a treatment that simply doesn't have the answer for the condition they have, and that actively dissuades them from seeking out more effective programs.

Was this your story Nutt. Is this what you perceived to have happened to you.
People in AA are conspiring together to prevent people from getting the help they need. That we hold down alcoholics that want to move on and see if another program works.
That we are so threaten by other avenues that we would participate in the killing (through suicide) of members just to see them not leave.
What in gods name is wrong with you.


Through this whole thread, not a single AA supporter has given even the slightest shred of evidence that AA does a damn thing for anyone.

I guess we as members don't count. I have been clean and sober for almost 26 years with the help of AA/NA. I have moved on but I still practice the valuable principles I learned.

I'm highly suspicious of an organization that won't conduct a study to see if it's effective when it is literally a matter of life and death for many folks walking in it's doors.

Do all the other programs have such studies done on there effectiveness.
Since you are so brilliant and you seem to have immense experience in working with alcoholics, please do share your current plan of helping people who abuse alcohol. Also would you be able to stop working at your job today and show us how effective your plan would work.
Everyone here I have noticed that knocks AA have all these bright ideas but not one of you work with or support people who are struggling with alcohol or drugs. It just sounds like you are telling us your story but embellishing it bit to include more members.
Just wondering???
 
Last edited:
Stinkin' Thinkin', "Muckracking the 12-Step Industry", members of this forum (ilsita for one) friends of mine, and many in this thread, have closed their blog. It will go back up with comments off in good time. You can read their goodbye letter here. The comments on that are quite something. I hope no one goes there from here to start something, that would be disrespectful in light of the circumstances.

Some of the craziest cult member trolls I have ever seen were featured there and posted in their comments. For a long time I was worried about them. Then on the 19th they reveal that someone has sent them a threatening email with ilse's home address in it, and then called them early the next morning, demanding that references to themselves be removed from the comments of the blog. (The comments described them as predators or delusional cult leaders or something along those lines, you know, the usual)

The next blog post in my RSS was "AA member threatens to cut off my head". They contacted the FBI.

So while this alone didn't cause them to shut down the blog, spending all of this time just dealing with these kinds of situations has been very taxing to them and they are moving on to be more effective in other ways. Death threats are not fun to deal with. This is not the first and will not be the last anti-AA group to suffer this kind of treatment and fate.

That was the best AA blog of all time. It helped many, many people get out of the cult and live much better lives. These were good, smart people. Not a hate group at all as some have tried to say. Go ahead and listen to an interview with them and see for yourself.

So, this turn of events is what has been behind my lack of interest in engaging in the same old arguments we had 6 months ago and the same old blatant caricatures of my arguments. I'm going to actually go do something about these problems.

So if you feel the need to bash ST for some strange reason, please remember that ilse is a member of this forum so the rules apply.

Thanks for everything ST crew, your efforts will be multiplied by the skeptic community a million times over.

That reminds me, ilse made a good point, the skeptic community is largely blind to the true nature of the cult, just how bad it is. It has done a good job blending into society. She wrote to Ed Brayton about this and he featured it on his widely read blog. A good point.

They also told me that this thread is just way too crazy for them to engage in, also that it was sad the way things were going, especially since it's James Randi's forum. At first I was in denial about this, but I have come around to their position.

James Randi "created" Penn and Teller, who created BS the 12-step episode (the best anti-AA video ever produced, fantastic television, a great intro to the cult of AA), which no doubt inspired the South Park 12-step epsiode (those guys are all best buds) So that's heartening.

Listen lets get something straight right here and now Stinkin Thinkibn was not a great blog. It attacked, stalked, abused, harassed and outright dehumanized people all across this country.
Mark and Illse were the most vindictive hateful people I have ever met.
Though I don't agree with death threats or anything like that. I do know it was a matter of time. You can only publish people's names, addresses, pictures, ISP addresses ect... for so long and not get retaliation. They put so many people in danger by posting their personal information I can't count.
So please take your whoa is me for those two disgusting people and run it on soem other blog.
Many members know Mark and Ellse here and have been the subject of their ridicule.
Like I said I in no way condone nor am I happy to know Ellse and her family were subjected to this kind of abuse.
But they went after people using their blog and in a very cruel way and abused and attacked them.
I say good riddance.
I am not bashing I am telling the truth, what I said are facts. Plus she was owner of a blog so don't tell me the same rules apply.
You brought it up, you opened the door and you wanted to say something positive without letting the other side say anything. Nice try.
 
And instead of pointing them to science-based medicine,

Which science based medicines?

For the record, I will regularly refer people to other therapies; people need some serious counselling for PTSD, sexual abuse etc; psychiatry; etc

I would have thought it was obvious that I was paraphrasing, you don't win points for nitpicking, just sayin. You calling me "dishonest", "fabricated a quote" "make things up" when it doesn't change the meaning of what they said at all, is clearly trying to win points of some kind or the other.

I think it is dishonest in the extreme

There are better groups out there that could just take their place.

Which ones?
How do they work and what efficacy rates do they have?
Are they science based?

Stinkin' Thinkin', "Muckracking the 12-Step Industry",

Stinkin Thinkin is a hate group.
 
Still waiting for the studies that demonstrate 'science-based medicine' actually helps anyone, ever. :( ;)
That's off-topic for this thread. Go make a new one under SMT and then you can get more specific information, though I think you probably won't get many useful answers to the question, "so guys, demonstrate 'science-based medicine' actually helps anyone, ever!"
 
Which science based medicines?
How do they work and what efficacy rates do they have?
Are they science based?

This is off-topic. The topic pertains specifically to AA.



Stinkin Thinkin is a hate group.

So what?

The null hypothesis is that AA works no better than doing nothing at all.

Where's your evidence disproving the null hypothesis?
 
That's off-topic for this thread. Go make a new one under SMT and then you can get more specific information, though I think you probably won't get many useful answers to the question, "so guys, demonstrate 'science-based medicine' actually helps anyone, ever!"

Actually it is totally on topic.

We are seeking (and have been for some time) the efficacy of other treatments; they would include the science based ones that some continually refer to. The ones that some say AA (and elsewhere) should be referring people with alcohol issues.

If AA doesn't work (as some claim) what does? How? And what are the efficacy rates?
 
Yup, you're right that was my mistake. I don't know when it was changed, but I see that it now has been.

I retract my statements.
I hadn't noticed this either. I think this needs an explanation. Who petitioned for this and what was the rationale behind accepting it? As everyone can see, it is the technique of some to try and talk about "efficacy" instead of the problems stemming from the religious/cult nature of the program, as if that somehow excuses the iatrogenic problems with the program cult. These problems wouldn't occur (as often, or without a way to report/seek justice) in a secular, evidence-based, professionally run program. Thanks Paul Cleary wherever you are. (oh wait he's at Yale?) is that the same guy? Sheesh. If there was a way to show that SMART and AA had the exact same efficacy results (see this post for how I think it treatment should happen in real life) , you'd still have all your work ahead of you apologizing for the harm that goes on because of the structure of AA!

It's pretty obvious to everyone that there is a perfectly rational explanation why there is not a Cochrane review for SMART yet. AA started in the 30s and has crept into the court system and beyond. It doesn't matter, we are talking about "What's the harm?" here, in light of the OP.
 
Last edited:
Stinkin Thinkin is a hate group.
What is your rationale for stating this? Can you give any evidence and reason for this assessment or is your hatred of their purpose the main factor? They exist purely to help eliminate delusion and pseudoscience in medicine, a goal the JREF shares. They don't pull punches, they don't excuse wish thinking. Good on them. Without completely distorting their words or actions, I know absolutely nothing they have done to hurt or hate on any innocent person. Some people are just protective of their namesake, I understand, but "hate group" is just provably wrong.
 
Last edited:
The real harm is that people go to AA thinking it's an effective program largely because AA touts itself as a cure-all for alcoholics

It doesn't.

, but there isn't a shred of evidence that it does bumpkis for them... And many of these people ******* die.

It's simply untrue that no one has given a shred of evidence that AA helps some people. You can deny the 1 million in the U.S. have been helped by AA, but they believe they have, and I don't think they're all delusional. At any rate as we discussed before: If they think AA has helped, hasn't AA helped? If you don't like anecdotal evidence click on some of the posted links to studies.

And many of these people ******* die. I Anyone who has been to AA meetings for long enough sees these people. They're the chronic relapsers who keep showing up in the rooms and then go get drunk.

Chronic relapsers die in and out of AA. There is no treatment that reliably "has the answers for the condition they have." except maybe handcuffing them to a gurney or keeping them perpetually unconscious. Many have used up any health coverage that would supply alternative or supplemental options for these "more effective programs" you allude to. Most people in AA don't want people to die of alcoholism, don't you get that? If any medical help's available we'll summon it. Just because some of them are theist doesn't mean they take great joy subjugating and condemning people. Jesus, if that's been your experience of AA, I'm sorry. It hasn't been mine.

And instead of pointing them to science-based medicine, AA tells them that they didn't work the steps properly, didn't do their 90 in 90, didn't do enough service. ... They get desperate because they're involved in a treatment that simply doesn't have the answer for the condition they have, and that actively dissuades them from seeking out more effective programs.

They get desperate because they're in a desperate situation. Many have used up any health coverage that would supply options for these "more effective programs" you allude to. There's no tradition in AA doctrine of beating up on individuals and isolating them from care. If anyone tells them those things, it's most definitely not 'AA.'

...not a single AA supporter has given even the slightest shred of evidence that AA does a damn thing for anyone.

You repeat the claim, I'll repeat the response. It's untrue that no one has given a shred of evidence that AA helps some people. You can deny the 1 million in the U.S. have been helped by AA, but they believe they have, and I don't think they're all delusional. Do you? At any rate as we discussed before: If they think AA has helped, hasn't AA helped? If you don't like anecdotal evidence click on some of the posted links to scientific studies.

I'm highly suspicious of an organization that won't conduct a study to see if it's effective when it is literally a matter of life and death for many folks walking in it's doors.

AA conducts membership surveys; but it's been pointed out numerous times that AA isn't going to seek out people that have never been to AA and make them promise not to go to AA. The General Service Board has no power to make that directive. There's a charter, it's binding. When people talk about bottom-up structure it's not a metaphor. I suppose groups could start pushing for it - but if detractors blame even neutral studies, they 're certainly not going to believe one "run by" AA, so really what is the point?
 
Last edited:
You calling me "dishonest", "fabricated a quote" "make things up" when it doesn't change the meaning of what they said at all, is clearly trying to win points of some kind or the other.

Of course I'm trying to win points, Joey. Sheez.

You think they will take some kind of action? This was written years ago, nothing has happened,

The board's answer was 2 years ago. Things do trickle up. Do you not think people in AA look out for one another? They do. Your default attribution is malevolence.

The cult is structured the way it is, to give authority to people who don't deserve it, because that's who created it, woos who wanted to feel better about themselves for having the power to help other people, power over other people.

I can see that you really believe this. This has affected you personally, you spoke of close family members involved in AA. Further attacks on Bill Wilson irrelevant; he was colorful, so what?

From "Escape from the cult of AA"

DARE TO ASK YOURSELF 7 QUESTIONS:

Uh, selection bias?

I fully support support groups, but when you start giving advice or forming other people's belief systems about alcohol or alcoholism ...

When you start giving advice? That is when a groups rights of assembly should end?

And how does a support group form other people's belief systems? You think addicts/alcoholics don't arrive at some beliefs themselves? Like, *I can't drink because last time I launched a 3,000-pound missile down city streets at 60 mph? *People know what they've done! Here, try these steps OK? No? Oh, OK, well, if you change your mind ... Such indoctrination.

I don't want cults operating freely in society.

It's called freedom of assembly. There is a difference.

He says "There is confusion about taking legal action against perpetrators because the victims think they will be breaking anomymity...

And I can't account for people that dense. That woman sounds like she was actually looking for a cult. If you look for a cult in AA maybe you'll find one.

The thing is about vulnerable people and cults... :( sorry I can't continue this much longer it takes too much time.

Tell me about it

... if groups are not monitored and kept in line by a central authority, predators will rise to the top.

You're in your own world Joey

If you don't pass the test, if you don't do things properly, if you let someone be a sponsor who goes around giving anti-med advice, you lose your right to call yourself Alcoholics Anonymous.

Ah, Joey. What was it that happened?

There are better groups out there that could just take their place.

Maybe they will. And they'll be professionally moderated just like you say? By volunteer professionals, correct?
You have an interesting mind.
 
Last edited:
I'm going to ask that you refrain from personalizing this topic any more than you have since starting, okay? I don't really like the idea of this thread being closed.

I might also recommend you edit out your personal attack against another forum member.

What are you talking about, Norseman. I am lost, really.
 
I'm going to ask that you refrain from personalizing this topic any more than you have since starting, okay? I don't really like the idea of this thread being closed.

I might also recommend you edit out your personal attack against another forum member.

I am going to ask you to please be fair. Just because you happen to like Stinkin Thinkin and refuse to see the harm they brought to many, that is not my problem. It was a hate group.
Nut was very direct and so was I.
Norseman knock it off. Every time you don't like a post it is attacking. Let the members I am conversing with comment.
AA is personal for us maybe you can cavalierly talk about it but at times when you folks are being dramatic it can be a bit much.
People lives are at stake here at times.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom