Joey McGee
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2011
- Messages
- 10,307
I would have thought it was obvious that I was paraphrasing, you don't win points for nitpicking, just sayin. You calling me "dishonest", "fabricated a quote" "make things up" when it doesn't change the meaning of what they said at all, is clearly trying to win points of some kind or the other.It's an easy fix, Joey. Don't put quote marks around things that are not quotes. Instead, paraphrase, or add a qualifier ... "the board basically said, 'It's not our responsibility.' " Signal that you are paraphrasing. Putting words in other people's mouths is dishonest.
You think they will take some kind of action? This was written years ago, nothing has happened, nothing will happen, because to them the structure of theHe's clearly saying they have a moral responsibility; he's implying they have a legal responsibility. Which is why I think the board will take some kind of action - there is legal exposure. In a lawsuit you're way better off saying,"No, it never occurred to us at all" than saying "We considered doing something about it and decided not to." There should be more literature put out than the one-page communique in 2001 that apparently applied only to the Central region.
From "Escape from the cult of AA"
DARE TO ASK YOURSELF 7 QUESTIONS:
1. Do you feel that A.A. is NOT the only road to Sobriety?
2. Do you take issue with being chided for questioning the “Program”?
3. Are you troubled by AA's Religious foundation?
4. Have you been greatly harmed by AA?
5. Do you ever wonder if AA is a cult?
6. Do you question being told that you cannot be angry?
7. Have you been forced to admit powerlessness over your life in a way that empowers other members while it diminishes you?
What's your mechanism for ensuring that "alcoholics only take the services of professionals" and outlawing peer support groups? That is what you just proposed doing, if I am I interpreting your words accurately
I have had to say this continually because I am regularly attacked with the idea of "You don't want support groups? You heartless monster!" No, I don't want cults operating freely in society. There is a difference.
What's the point? I'm against people with no qualifications other than drinking Bill Wilson's kool-aid being given authority toAnd, did you miss the part where I said I was in group therapy and briefly living under the same treatment center roof as a guy who was soon afterward arrested for first-degree murder? In a highly regarded professional setting?
He says "There is confusion about taking legal action against perpetrators because the victims think they will be breaking anomymity..." Where that is two mothers or one (do you really think that has ever only happened once?), or just one mother and multiple victims, there is a pattern of predators getting away with these crimes because vulnerable people are confused and thought-stopped with "anonymity" Why are you nitpicking over things like this? It doesn't win you any points, it doesn't make me look dishonest, this to me sounds like apologizing for a religious cult.One mother, Joey. Not "some mothers." Do you really not see how your language kicks everything bad about AA up a notch? I notice you pluralize "molestors" when, again, that bullet item cited one molester. Also the incident is 7 years old, no excuse I know but not necessarily an epidemic.
The thing is about vulnerable people and cults...Also, as soon as she ran it by Paul he told her to call the police? I don't know what you do about such clueless people having children. Unfortunately parents don't have to pass parenting tests to become parents.
The oldest AA canard "We have no leaders" (careful, that's not a direct quoteExcept for your insistence on "group leaders," I agree with that assessment. I can't swear there are no groups with an elected "leader," but I haven't seen any examples of this, on this forum or anywhere else.
It's very simple, if groups are not monitored and kept in line by a central authority, predators will rise to the top in some groups. It should be extremely easy, if you call yourself "alcoholics anonymous" this means there is monitoring and security enforced by people who know how these situations go bad. If you don't pass the test, if you don't do things properly, if you let someone be a sponsor who goes around giving anti-med advice, you lose your right to call yourself Alcoholics Anonymous. Of course, this is too much to ask, will never happen in a million years. Do you know any reformed cults that are now good for society? Nope, neither do I.I don't know any 15-year-olds in AA, but you've convinced me: Groups with minor members should act. They should elect someone to scan local sex offender databases, be on the lookout for these individuals, approach them if they are seen in a meeting and say, we'll be watching you. Or, they could post fliers in the window; it would be degrading to the offender, but survivable. If the meeting is within 300 feet of a school, such a person could be asked to leave on legal grounds. The board ought to use its voice to strongly suggest this policy but mandate it? No. There are groups that aren't on the books anywhere, groups where everyone's over 30, etc.
Here's something sad, a 15-year-old addict/alcoholic will be a predator magnet both inside & outside "the rooms." I wonder where they would be more at risk: on the streets and using, or clean in a group that has sober, responsible members.
There are better groups out there that could just take their place.
Last edited: