Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
When did the
Thread topic change to add the "Efficacy ..." part?

Shouldn't that topic be split off into the Science or Social Issues forum?

I first saw the thread over the summer; "efficacy" was already added. My guess is that the "it's religious" claim got conflated with the idea that AA "faith healing" has suppressed effective research-based treatments.

Just a guess, but I can see why "efficacy" would be added - to acknowledge & accommodate thread drift.
 
Minoosh, thanks for your thoughtful response. I’m sorry to hear you have been dealing with cravings. Keep in mind they are time limited and will subside with time, as you said, providing you don’t give in to them. You’ve done it before, I know you can do it again. I wish you all the best.

ProBonoShill, regarding your first link to the book, acknowledgement was given to Ernest Kurtz who writes from the AA perspective. I’m not going to read the whole thing, but what I read of it didn’t support your assertion that alcoholics are “notorious liars.”

The second link used a quotation marked phrase in a title. It’s just a figure of speech.

Both of your links from About.com were written by Buddy T. He is an Al-Anon and will naturally repeat the same old myths which pervade 12 step groups. I can’t post links yet, but if you click on his name you’ll see:

“Buddy T. is in recovery from the experience of living with an alcoholic. Because he is a member of a support group that stresses the importance of anonymity at the public level, he does not use his photograph or his real name on the web site.”

As for the forth link from stoke.ahajounals.org, the study was regarding whether or not stroke was associated with excessive alcohol use, not whether or not self-report was accurate. It did have this to say:

Although the reliability and validity of self-reported alcohol drinking habits, ie, the extent to which accurate information is provided by the respondent, has often been debated,4 5 most studies on the relation of alcohol to stroke risk have relied on self-reported alcohol drinking.2 6 7 It is known, however, that respondents may overestimate or underestimate the amount of alcohol consumed, and it has been noted that excessive alcohol drinking is often negated by alcoholics.”

Apparently it wasn’t negated enough to prevent drawing a correlation between stroke and alcohol abuse.

And regarding your last link, I’m quite sure you didn’t mean to include it since it doesn’t support your assertion that all alcoholics are notorious liars at all:


“Four data sources were used: the subject, his spouse if any (133 were married), his therapist, and his work supervisor. The results indicated high agreement among all four sources on the subjects drinking behavior, suggesting that any one of the four sources could provide adequate data for program evaluation.”

(snip)


“Ryback (7) found that impairment of short-term and possibly long-term memory is concomittant of prolonged excessive drinking, a factor which may affect the validity of self-reports of drinking history as well as their test-retest reliability.”

(snip)

Other studies have suggested that validity and reliability of self-reporters of drinking are high. Smart (9) reviewed several studies on the validity-reliability issue and concluded that test-retest reliability is high and that validity is high when recent information is requested.

Let me say one more time, 50 years of research found:

”Denial and other defense mechanisms have been found to be nor more or less frequent among alcoholics than among people in general.”
 
Let me say one more time, 50 years of research found:

”Denial and other defense mechanisms have been found to be nor more or less frequent among alcoholics than among people in general.”

I can believe this, but...

Perhaps you could clarify what I understand to be true:

Denial (in therapeutic terms) relates to the issue in question - in this case alcoholism. The same would be true for any issue such as; obesity, other eating disorders, drug addiction, gambling, domestic violence, anger etc.

But I think the discussion you were having was around lying; denial is a sort of lying, but not all of lying.
 
I'm sorry you lost your brother and I hope you have found some peace around his memory.

Thanks Minoosh



ProBonoShill, regarding your first link to the book, acknowledgement was given to Ernest Kurtz who writes from the AA perspective. I’m not going to read the whole thing, but what I read of it didn’t support your assertion that alcoholics are “notorious liars.”

The second link used a quotation marked phrase in a title. It’s just a figure of speech.

I'm not sure what the problem is, but this is the second time you've become confused in recent days. The first two links in my last post were in response to this post you directed at me.

Both of your links from About.com were written by Buddy T. He is an Al-Anon and will naturally repeat the same old myths which pervade 12 step groups. I can’t post links yet, but if you click on his name you’ll see:

“Buddy T. is in recovery from the experience of living with an alcoholic. Because he is a member of a support group that stresses the importance of anonymity at the public level, he does not use his photograph or his real name on the web site.”

Here's a link to Buddy's profile, why did you forget the rest?:


Experience:

Buddy has been in recovery since July, 1989 and has been the Alcoholism Guide since February, 1997. Despite years of research and experience, he's still asking questions and discovering surprising answers concerning this cunning, baffling, and powerful disease called alcoholism.

Education:

Buddy has a Bachelor of Science degree in Psychology.

From Buddy T:

After years of recovery, I'm still trying to find all the information I can. Although my own recovery experiences have been through a 12-step program, I know there are many other approaches that work

Gee that bolded part sure doesn't sound the way you've been portraying AA members. Also the content on those pages is reviewed by this medical board: http://www.about.com/health/review.htm

As for the forth link from stoke.ahajounals.org, the study was regarding whether or not stroke was associated with excessive alcohol use, not whether or not self-report was accurate. It did have this to say:

Although the reliability and validity of self-reported alcohol drinking habits, ie, the extent to which accurate information is provided by the respondent, has often been debated,4 5 most studies on the relation of alcohol to stroke risk have relied on self-reported alcohol drinking.2 6 7 It is known, however, that respondents may overestimate or underestimate the amount of alcohol consumed, and it has been noted that excessive alcohol drinking is often negated by alcoholics.”Apparently it wasn’t negated enough to prevent drawing a correlation between stroke and alcohol abuse.

I know what the study was for, it doesn't change the info I've highlighted.

How many times do I have to show you this?


And regarding your last link, I’m quite sure you didn’t mean to include it since it doesn’t support your assertion that all alcoholics are notorious liars at all:

What about this quote from my link do you not understand?:

Some studies have supported the conclusion that the self-reports from alcoholics are unreliable.


As for this :

“Four data sources were used: the subject, his spouse if any (133 were married), his therapist, and his work supervisor. The results indicated high agreement among all four sources on the subjects drinking behavior, suggesting that any one of the four sources could provide adequate data for program evaluation.”

It says the will be using reports from people other than the subject alcoholic, why do you think they would need to do this? Think hard.







“Ryback (7) found that impairment of short-term and possibly long-term memory is concomittant of prolonged excessive drinking, a factor which may affect the validity of self-reports of drinking history as well as their test-retest reliability.”


Okay and??? It doesn't indicate anything about the truthfulness of alcoholics.


Other studies have suggested that validity and reliability of self-reporters of drinking are high. Smart (9) reviewed several studies on the validity-reliability issue and concluded that test-retest reliability is high and that validity is high when recent information is requested.

Let me say one more time, 50 years of research found:

”Denial and other defense mechanisms have been found to be nor more or less frequent among alcoholics than among people in general.”



Some studies suggest it's high, others do not, there definitely isn't a consensus.

Here's more:

http://alcalc.oxfordjournals.org/content/37/3/282.full

However, the self-reported alcohol consumption was similar in the two regions. These results suggest that alcohol consumption especially in Russia may not be reliably estimated by self-reporting, and that alcohol consumption is relatively high, especially among men, in RUS

When self-reports of alcohol drinking are used as the indicator, the respondents may underestimate or overestimate the amount of alcohol they have consumed, and it has been noted that alcoholics frequently deny that they drink very much. Therefore, it is beneficial to use biological markers of alcohol drinking to determine the alcohol-associated risk

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0847/is_n3_v14/ai_11129867/

Physicians need a reliable screening marker of alcoholism to identify patients who are chronic heavy consumers of alcohol. This marker would assist with diagnosis of alcoholism, especially in patients who fail to provide an accurate history of their alcohol consumption.


http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/Assesing Alcohol/selfreport.htm

Although some researchers and clinicians have argued that information from self–reports on alcohol–related variables is suspect (e.g., alcohol abusers will deny they have problems), many others believe these reports can be valid and useful in the screening as well as assessment and treatment of alcohol abusers. This controversy over self–reports has been discussed in greater detail by Babor et al. (1987), Maisto et al. (1990), and Sobell and Sobell (1990).

I can quote many more if you'd like.

So there's controversy on the validity of self reports, but that's due to what controls they place on them. Clearly alcoholics left to their own devices are prone to not telling the whole truth about their consumption and other things related to their addiction. Otherwise there wouldn't be a problem.

I'm not sure why you are debating this point. Alcoholics and addicts are liars by nature otherwise they would've ceased using long ago.

I'm willing to bet people in this thread who are in any type of recovery will freely admit they've lied concerning the subject of drugs and alcohol. I know I did it often to my wife, kids, medical practitioners and therapists.
 
Last edited:
This is absurd. When my brother took his own life, I attended a suicide support group, it made me feel better. I didn't go home after the meetings and wonder to myself "hmmm I wonder if this works, maybe I should investigate it. :boggled:

Did the suicide support group claim to be able to cure you of suicide? Did it claim that your only choices are it, jail, or death?

That's the difference. AA claims to cure people, suicide support groups claim they can make you feel better. So, if you feel better in a suicide support group it has done everything it claimed, no need to investigate further. AA makes plenty of claims that any rational person would want to know the truth about. Further investigation is required.
 
<Slightly OT>

Been reading this thread off and on for a while - When did the
Thread topic change to add the "Efficacy ..." part?

Shouldn't that topic be split off into the Science or Social Issues forum?
I agree. I've said many times, it's the desire of some to talk about efficacy instead of the original topic. All cults/woomeisters say the same thing, "Who cares at long as it works?" That's what I get hit with whenever I bring up the negative aspects and it's frankly a little sad that this has taken the course it has.

People insist AA is not religious because it is a cult. Viruses embed themselves in your body and hide from your immune system, this the the same phenomenon.
 
Predators in A.A. written by Paul Cleary, General Service Trustee, General Service Board of Alcoholics Anonymous Inc.

Direct PDF

Google Docs Viewer Link

Paul is extremely upset.

Some outside agencies are unwilling to refer their clients to us because they being told by other clients of what's happening in regard to sexual abuse in AA.

There is confusion about taking legal action against perpetrators because the victims think they will be breaking anomymity...

Although we do not like to be involved in the controversy these actions may initiate, the problem has become such that we need to take steps immediately...
A few years ago a woman with many years of sobriety asked me for guidance upon discovering that her daughter had been molested by a man in A.A. I encouraged her to contact the police. I was stunned when she expressed concern about breaking the molester's AA. anonymity.
For a host of moral, ethical and legal reasons, it is time for the General Service Board to provide leadership in addressing the issue of child sexual abuse in A.A.

It goes on for several pages. Cleary even references the Catholic Church abuse scandals. At the end you will find the GSB's reply. Can you guess what they are going to say? "It's not our responsibility, groups are autonomous. They should work it out themselves." Gee, do you think that Paul didn't already realize they would say that? This is sick. How the hell is that going to happen when predators are running groups? This is a very disturbing document indeed.

Apologia over this type of thing is the worst kind and the hardest to watch.
 
Last edited:
”Denial and other defense mechanisms have been found to be nor more or less frequent among alcoholics than among people in general.”

Anecdotal, but: I was in denial about being in denial. I wasn't denying the amount of my usage or the insanity of my behavior or the seriousness of the consequences. Yet I couldn't see how badly I was treating myself.

I think efficacy came up in pages 40-50. Reading the long report about the history of AA self-reporting statistics (link to PDF is in a recent posts) was eye-opening. There were two kind of cherry-picking early on that were kind of contradictory. Bill W. was trying to "save" only the worst cases; but he limited the success statistics to those who had "stuck around" or "really tried." In Cleveland you were pre-screened at times to an absurd degree. At its most restrictive Cleveland was taking only people with substantial clean time (up to 3 months) who had already worked the steps.

If Bill included people with only cursory contact with AA in the figures, his low-end estimation for remission (not cure) would be 15 percent and his high end 45 percent. Under the "thoroughly followed our path" group he claimed 75 percent. In context I believe he justified "rarely" because there were people who stuck around but were too sick to recover. Now, Bill was a hustler, but I do believe he knew that and tried to compensate. If AA had 96 people when the BB was written, he'd grant himself license to say "more than 100," but probably had a ready rationalization. At the beginning he was dealing with some high-rollers and I believe he wanted his data to be honest. In later years he reiterated those figures, and by then it was apparent that some people had cursory contact, kept drinking and at some point, perhaps years later, came back, stuck around and got sober.

BTW to someone, AA doesn't claim it can cure alcoholism. It claims to offer a conditional daily reprieve. The differences with cancer or arthritis support are obvious; alcoholism/addiction remission depends on the sufferer's not picking up. So there is a degree of agency on behalf of the sufferer that is not in play in cancer, etc.

And besides, ProBonoShill was saying simply that he believes the suicide support group helped him cope with suicide. Similarly many in AA say that meetings help them cope with alcoholism. In context he was saying nothing about "curing suicide," but that's exactly where the next post went - "yeah but" suicide support groups don't claim they cure suicide, so the analogy is invalid.

The responder was rebutting a claim PBS hadn't made.
 
Probonoshill, I was responding to this statement.

As I said a few pages ago, still practicing or newly recovered alcoholics and addicts are notorious liars and very unreliable.


I supplied evidence that 50 years worth of studies have shown that denial and other defense mechanisms are the same as in the general population. That would include lying.


“Four data sources were used: the subject, his spouse if any (133 were married), his therapist, and his work supervisor. The results indicated high agreement among all four sources on the subjects drinking behavior, suggesting that any one of the four sources could provide adequate data for program evaluation.”

It says the will be using reports from people other than the subject alcoholic, why do you think they would need to do this? Think hard.

Allow me to break this down. The four sources are:

1. The subject (the alcoholic)
2. The spouse
3. The therapist
4. The work supervisor

There was high agreement from all four sources. Any one of the four, including the subject (the alcoholic) could provide adequate data. In other words, when they compared all these reports, they found they can rely on the self report as much as the other sources. The study was specific as to whether or not self-report is reliable, and it was stated in the very first paragraph that self-report was, in fact, reliable. The other studies you sited were not. They were regarding other issues and some made assumptions based on a long standing myth. Hard thinking is not required here.


Some studies have supported the conclusion that the self-reports from alcoholics are unreliable.


No need to shout. Other studies have found self-reports to be reliable. It simply doesn’t support you assertion that alcoholics are notorious liars. Otherwise they would all be in agreement. Long standing beliefs which have permeated society due to 75 years worth of AA are being challenged and found to be untrue.


I'm not sure why you are debating this point.


I’m debating this point because it’s pertinent to as whether the issue can be studied.


Alcoholics and addicts are liars by nature otherwise they would've ceased using long ago.


That’s a logical fallacy. Alcoholics and addicts can be very truthful and continue to use. They can also be terrible liars and remain abstinent.

Danny, I didn’t bring up McGow’s name out of respect to him.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Joey for posting that. It was very interesting reading. I have a hunch that the General Service Board will revisit this issue.

Not surprisingly I come to somewhat different conclusions than you. For one thing I note that you fabricated a quote. The General Service Board didn't say, "It's not our responsibility." It does say, "The General Service Board has no authority, legal or otherwise, to control or direct the behavior of AA members and groups." I wasn't surprised that the damning thing you put in quote marks wasn't a quote. I check for that kind of stuff. It's ironic because I agree the response was not satisfactory. My point is, you make up things about AA. You undermine your own credibility.

Unlike you I have generally high confidence in the ability of meetings to police themselves. Predators run the groups? How many people on here have told you no one runs the group? That won't stop self-appointed gurus from developing. And yeah, some of them are probably attracted to teenagers.

Ironically it was in a "professional" setting that I lived side by side with a young man who soon after was arrested for first-degree murder of a woman about my age.

You believe AA should be professionally run. Well, it's not professionally run and there's no mechanism for a hostile takeover, so it will stay an amateur outfit. The subject will get more attention, at the group level. If groups want to make a safety announcement, they can incorporate that in the meeting format. Change will happen in the groups but it might not be done on your timetable. Anything that involves minor children should of course be treated as a criminal matter.

But adults will hook up, Joey. That's not a crime.
 
Did the suicide support group claim to be able to cure you of suicide? Did it claim that your only choices are it, jail, or death?

That's the difference. AA claims to cure people, suicide support groups claim they can make you feel better. So, if you feel better in a suicide support group it has done everything it claimed, no need to investigate further. AA makes plenty of claims that any rational person would want to know the truth about. Further investigation is required.

No one in AA ever claimed I'd be cured, I was told they could help me abstain from drinking, they were right. Just as I was told the Suicide support group would help me, they were right too.

What claims do they make?

Claims like this, that they run away from?

qayak said:
There has been no evidence provided to show that AA helped anybody . . . ever.
 
I supplied evidence that 50 years worth of studies have shown that denial and other defense mechanisms are the same as in the general population. That would include lying.


No, you've shown some alcoholics aren't living in denial, you haven't shown they don't lie. Now I'm sure there area few completely honest users out there, but many alcoholics and addicts lie.
Do I need to quote millions of parents, spouses, children and bosses who've been lied to as proof?


Allow me to break this down. The four sources are:

1. The subject (the alcoholic)
2. The spouse
3. The therapist
4. The work supervisor

There was high agreement from all four sources. Any one of the four, including the subject (the alcoholic) could provide adequate data. In other words, when they compared all these reports, they found they can rely on the self report as much as the other sources. The study was specific as to whether or not self-report is reliable, and it was stated in the very first paragraph that self-report was, in fact, reliable.



Okay.

Why did they need reports from four people? Why didn't they just rely on the alcoholic?


The other studies you sited were not. They were regarding other issues and some made assumptions based on a long standing myth. Hard thinking is not required here.


I'm sorry this is a critical thinking forum, you can't just wave away facts if you don't like them.


No need to shout. Other studies have found self-reports to be reliable. It simply doesn’t support you assertion that alcoholics are notorious liars. Otherwise they would all be in agreement. Long standing beliefs which have permeated society due to 75 years worth of AA are being challenged and found to be untrue.


I've shown many cases where people conducting studies of alcoholics say their self-reporting is unreliable which backs up my claim that figures derived from those type of reports are questionable. I lied on mine all the time.


I’m debating this point because it’s pertinent to as whether the issue can be studied.


Well clearly there's a problem, would you like some more links?


That’s a logical fallacy. Alcoholics and addicts can be very truthful and continue to use. They can also be terrible liars and remain abstinent.


While that could be true, I'd say it isn't the norm, in fact drug addicts in most cases are breaking the law. Last time I checked they weren't lining up at police stations to be arrested.
 
I find it funny that the conspiracy theorists in this thread deem anecdotes about AA helping people unreliable, while anecdotes about the "harm" AA has done go unquestioned.
Not to mention there are many more of one than the other.
 
I find it funny that the conspiracy theorists in this thread deem anecdotes about AA helping people unreliable, while anecdotes about the "harm" AA has done go unquestioned.
Not to mention there are many more of one than the other.

No kidding. I guess it just has to be that way. :p
 
Thanks Joey for posting that. It was very interesting reading. I have a hunch that the General Service Board will revisit this issue.

Not surprisingly I come to somewhat different conclusions than you. For one thing I note that you fabricated a quote. The General Service Board didn't say, "It's not our responsibility." It does say, "The General Service Board has no authority, legal or otherwise, to control or direct the behavior of AA members and groups." I wasn't surprised that the damning thing you put in quote marks wasn't a quote. I check for that kind of stuff. It's ironic because I agree the response was not satisfactory. My point is, you make up things about AA. You undermine your own credibility.
They have a responsibility under law using the arguments that Paul laid out. You cannot undermine the value of the evidence I have provided by trying to slander me as a liar over interpretation when I have provided the evidence in full in context. Paul is quite clearly saying they have a legal responsibility, they are quite clearly saying they do not, if you read the document.


Unlike you I have generally high confidence in the ability of meetings to police themselves. Predators run the groups? How many people on here have told you no one runs the group? That won't stop self-appointed gurus from developing. And yeah, some of them are probably attracted to teenagers.
So isn't it more appropriate that alcoholics only take the services of professionals who are tracked held accountable to the same standards as other medical professionals using the best information we have available by law. Some mothers are worried about breaking the anonymity of their daugther's child molestors, and people still want AA to remain unprofessional, and unaccountable to anyone but the group leaders. Paul Cleary is no slouch you look him up.

Taxi cab drivers who have had sex with a minor are banned from driving taxis in my city but that same guy could go be a sponsor in AA.

To the rest of your post, no comment.
 
You cannot undermine the value of the evidence I have provided by trying to slander me as a liar over interpretation when I have provided the evidence in full in context.

It's an easy fix, Joey. Don't put quote marks around things that are not quotes. Instead, paraphrase, or add a qualifier ... "the board basically said, 'It's not our responsibility.' " Signal that you are paraphrasing. Putting words in other people's mouths is dishonest.

Paul is quite clearly saying they have a legal responsibility, they are quite clearly saying they do not, if you read the document.

He's clearly saying they have a moral responsibility; he's implying they have a legal responsibility. Which is why I think the board will take some kind of action - there is legal exposure. In a lawsuit you're way better off saying,"No, it never occurred to us at all" than saying "We considered doing something about it and decided not to." There should be more literature put out than the one-page communique in 2001 that apparently applied only to the Central region.

So isn't it more appropriate that alcoholics only take the services of professionals who are tracked held accountable to the same standards as other medical professionals . . .

What's your mechanism for ensuring that "alcoholics only take the services of professionals" and outlawing peer support groups? That is what you just proposed doing, if I am I interpreting your words accurately

And, did you miss the part where I said I was in group therapy and briefly living under the same treatment center roof as a guy who was soon afterward arrested for first-degree murder? In a highly regarded professional setting?

Some mothers are worried about breaking the anonymity of their daugther's child molestors,

One mother, Joey. Not "some mothers." Do you really not see how your language kicks everything bad about AA up a notch? I notice you pluralize "molestors" when, again, that bullet item cited one molester. Also the incident is 7 years old, no excuse I know but not necessarily an epidemic.

Also, as soon as she ran it by Paul he told her to call the police? I don't know what you do about such clueless people having children. Unfortunately parents don't have to pass parenting tests to become parents.

... People still want want AA to remain unprofessional, and unaccountable to anyone but the group leaders.

Except for your insistence on "group leaders," I agree with that assessment. I can't swear there are no groups with an elected "leader," but I haven't seen any examples of this, on this forum or anywhere else.

Paul Cleary is no slouch you look him up.

Thanks, Casey. I didn't say he was a slouch.

Taxi cab drivers who have had sex with a minor are banned from driving taxis in my city but that same guy could go be a sponsor in AA.

Are you saying hypothetically, or do you have a specific situation in mind?

I don't know any 15-year-olds in AA, but you've convinced me: Groups with minor members should act. They should elect someone to scan local sex offender databases, be on the lookout for these individuals, approach them if they are seen in a meeting and say, we'll be watching you. Or, they could post fliers in the window; it would be degrading to the offender, but survivable. If the meeting is within 300 feet of a school, such a person could be asked to leave on legal grounds. The board ought to use its voice to strongly suggest this policy but mandate it? No. There are groups that aren't on the books anywhere, groups where everyone's over 30, etc.

Here's something sad, a 15-year-old addict/alcoholic will be a predator magnet both inside & outside "the rooms." I wonder where they would be more at risk: on the streets and using, or clean in a group that has sober, responsible members.
 
Last edited:
I don't know any 15-year-olds in AA, but you've convinced me: Groups with minor members should act.

It isn't just inside AA. AA meetings often hold socials/dances and because the people attending the events are dry which means underage kids can get in. That is exactly how my former sister-in-law met her 34yo husband when she was 15. She was pregnant by 16 and married to the abusive asshat before turning 17.

And there are many of these cases

Here's something sad, a 15-year-old addict/alcoholic will be a predator magnet both inside & outside "the rooms." I wonder where they would be more at risk: on the streets and using, or clean in a group that has sober, responsible members.

That is a sorry attitude. The fact is, AA makes it easy because of the pecking order involved. Adults are superior to children. Long timers superior to newbees, etc. My brother-in-law comes home from his weekly Saturday meeting and tells me all about any new woman who attends and the number of old timers who are all over her. What he describes is typical predatory behaviour and he thinks it is a joke because it has gone on the entire time he has been there. Then, when the women stop attending, he claims they hadn't "hit bottom yet."

Ironically, the company he works for hired several women to work on the loading dock, a traditionally all male job. When old timers tried the same thing with the new women as the AA old timers did, they were reprimanded, and some disciplined, immediately by the company and yet he still doesn't see why that type of behaviour isn't okay. His feeling is that if it's fine at AA it's fine everywhere.
 
Wow, ProBonoShill said things a lot more efficiently than I did.

I've looked at the evidence for harm AA does, but after reading some stories about deprogramming etc. I grew less impressed. Claims were indignant it tone but lacking in specifics. For example one woman complained because she was urged to see a psychologist. This offended her greatly.

Another said, "I have worked the steps twice had three sponsors, the last one a real sicko who has thirteen years ''sobriety'' he is over in my country from the middle east recruiting like an insane lunatic!!" The poster does not describe the presumably offensive behavior. I belief a subgroup is primed for anger against AA.

Someone on this board said AA ruined countless marriages. Googling "AA destroyed my marriage" yielded one hit. A good read, but it turned out the marriage had always has problems. Other allegations on this forum - of massive lawsuits, for example - have not proved readily verified.

Evidence of so-called harm is heavily outweighed by counterclaims of so-called help. I'm not discounting the ugliness, I read about it and think it over. My opinion evolves.

I'm sorry Minoosh but I've got to call BS on this. Undoubtedly people make some claims like "AA made my husband do this or that and it ruined my marriage" or "my sponsor was a weirdo", and that these may not be convincing. That may be harmful, but it's not the real harm that AA causes. The real harm is that people go to AA thinking it's an effective program largely because AA touts itself as a cure-all for alcoholics, but there isn't a shred of evidence that it does bumpkis for them. And many of these people ******* die. Anyone who has been to AA meetings for long enough sees these people. They're the chronic relapsers who keep showing up in the rooms and then go get drunk. And instead of pointing them to science-based medicine, AA tells them that they didn't work the steps properly, didn't do their 90 in 90, didn't do enough service. That's a load of bull. They went to a program that claims to help alcoholics, but can't provide a shred of evidence that it does so, and they get desperate. They get desperate because they're involved in a treatment that simply doesn't have the answer for the condition they have, and that actively dissuades them from seeking out more effective programs. Through this whole thread, not a single AA supporter has given even the slightest shred of evidence that AA does a damn thing for anyone. I'm highly suspicious of an organization that won't conduct a study to see if it's effective when it is literally a matter of life and death for many folks walking in it's doors.
 
.... They're the chronic relapsers who keep showing up in the rooms and then go get drunk. And instead of pointing them to science-based medicine, AA tells them that they didn't work the steps properly, didn't do their 90 in 90, didn't do enough service. ....
Many here await the studies that demonstrate 'science-based medicine' actually helps anyone, ever.

Many of us AAers tried that 'science-based medicine' and found no help whatsoever, as opposed to AA which did assist (some of) us to stop drinking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom