Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe you should have a talk with 8den, Jack Astor, Poster Nutbag, Joey McGee and their friends from Stinkin Thinkin, they were the first people to mention those other treatments and when they were asked to back up their claims, they ran away.

And that makes a difference how? It has been the pro-AAers making the claim that AA is effective because other programs might not be.

If you haven't noticed, this isn't Stinkin Thinkin, its the JREF forum.
 
And that makes a difference how? It has been the pro-AAers making the claim that AA is effective because other programs might not be.

Go ask them, they were the ones claiming these other programs were better than AA.

If you haven't noticed, this isn't Stinkin Thinkin, its the JREF forum.

Yes and thankfully so.
 
Qayak is on ignore so I don't read his posts. Going by the above comment he seems to assert that the AAers are making the claims. In fact it is the other way around, it is the non AAers that have been claiming "science" and/or "evidence based" therapies work better (owtte).

In line with the usual protocols of this forum, they are being called to provide evidence.

The problem is that they have produced nothing, and so we wait... and wait....and wait.
 
Last edited:
Before anyone gets too invested in AA's 5 percent success rate, do some research on where that number came from. Same with any other statistic you cite. Extra credit for citing professional journals or the studies themselves vs. relying on the popular press. It's possible the statistic originated with AA itself and was based on misreading a frequency distribution.

Bill Wilson early on estimated that 4 in 5 drunks (though exposed to fledgling AA) didn't want anything to do with a stop-drinking program. Of the 20 percent that remained he thought half got sober immediately. That's 10 percent. Half of those had some slips, then got sober. That's 15 percent. As years went by it emerged that some tried AA, didn't stick around long but came back later and got sober. The claim that AA says it's a cure-all is so easy to debunk I wonder why anyone would bother posting it.

What worked for me was motivation and a lot of structure. Having my days scheduled down to the minute took away dangerous downtime. The meetings were a big help. AA is not a moderation program, which doesn't mean moderation never works; it means if moderation isn't working for you, you might check out AA. If you're one of the 90 percent that believes in some kind of God, it might be helpful and even if you're not, agnostics and atheists have found a path through the steps. It's not some Puritan scheme; it's a way to make peace with the past and learn to live more usefully in the present. If it's not helpful don't go. If you think it might help, give it more than a token try. If possible try a few groups to help find a good fit.
 
Last edited:
And that makes a difference how? ...

If you haven't noticed, this isn't Stinkin Thinkin, its the JREF forum.

qayak's been around, he didn't sign up to trash AA. Some folks did seem to register primarily to post on this topic, and a couple of them were sarcastic, belittling, etc.

The arguments were varied and some deserved to be seriously addressed. These I believe are legit:

1. AA, at the group and national level, needs to raise awareness about the potential for abuse, particularly when it involves underage members. Nationally, additions should be made to literature and a broader conversation held.

2. Within the current structure, responsible AA members should speak up if they hear reckless medical advice, or blanket statements that imply that AA alone is needed to cure mental disorders. AA literature already reflects that stance.

These are the two main ones I can think of. The attacks on Bill Wilson are irrelevant, spewing contempt for anything that claims a "spiritual" component is ineffective, saying "I know someone in AA who killed himself" is inconclusive.

My 2 cents.
 
Last edited:
Maybe you should have a talk with 8den, Jack Astor, Poster Nutbag, Joey McGee and their friends from Stinkin Thinkin, they were the first people to mention those other treatments and when they were asked to back up their claims, they ran away.

For the record, I only learned of Stinkin' Thinkin' through this thread and have perused it for all of 5 minutes. As I said before, I bear no animosity towards AA members in general and don't care to engage in character assassination of the whole program for the behavior of a small portion of the members. I also never made efficacy claims about any other program. What I did claim, and this has still not been addressed by the apologist crowd, is that AA does not operate within the modern medical framework, while there are at least a handful of treatments that do. Setting aside any claims of efficacy, I prefer treatments for physical conditions that operate within the modern medical tradition of experimentation, extensive study, and constant improvement, because this is the only proven way to improve treatment of any condition. AA doesn't engage in this, and there is not a good reason why. Every successful medical treatment to date has been developed and studied in a particular way, and improved upon as needed. Why should AA be exempt from this?
 
..respectful snip .. Why should AA be exempt from this?

Because AA is not medical treatment - it is a self help organisation.

I have mentioned a number of times that I would hope people in AA direct prospective members to their doctor for detox treatments. I would also hope people are diirected to outside specialists where necessary for other issues.

AA is a self-help maintenance program, not a medical program. And if it was the latter it would be subject to medical board type regulations.
 
Last edited:
Setting aside any claims of efficacy, I prefer treatments for physical conditions that operate within the modern medical tradition of experimentation, extensive study, and constant improvement, because this is the only proven way to improve treatment of any condition.

You probably won't like this, but AA identifies it as a spiritual program. You have to rely on anecdote for this since it's hard to measure in a lab (though not impossible if suitable algorithms are developed).

AA doesn't conduct experiment with drunks. It's not going to offer one group "treatment" and exclude another group. Show me the study AA could conduct that wouldn't require it to forbid people from attending. I've been puzzling over this one for a while, and no one's stepped up.

Plenty of science has found its way into AA and research has concluded it's effective, especially when supplemented by appropriate counseling etc. AA is not exempt from hard research; AA attendance has factored into various studies.

It would be a lot harder to measure success if working the AA program were included, since the spiritual dimension, which you may ridicule but most Americans don't, is a separate issue than meeting attendance and not readily quantifiable.
 
When people state that AA doesn't work I believe it's perfectly legitimate to address whether anything works in the same forum. I want the evidence for other treatments put forth, not to defend AA but so that any random person happening on this thread will see evidence about these other programs.

Grandiose of me.

The efficacy of medical treatment programs for addiction should be in the Science, Mathematics, Medicine and Technology subforum because, irrespective of whether or not AA treats addiction as a spiritual disease, it simply isn't.
 
Norseman,
Please read above. My answer to your post is within the lines above.


No. You made a specific claim that every time I don't like a post, I complain. That's what evidence you need to present (which you did nothing of the sort in the post you referenced) otherwise retract your statement.
 
Maybe you should have a talk with 8den, Jack Astor, Poster Nutbag, Joey McGee and their friends from Stinkin Thinkin, they were the first people to mention those other treatments and when they were asked to back up their claims, they ran away.

How about maybe you should have a talk with the *first* people to bring up AAs incredible success numbers -- like AA Alfie who claimed a 15% success rate -- and when asked to back it up, they ran away.
 
I'm not sure if this makes a difference to anyone, but the thread title was changed 13th August 2011.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7471665#post7471665

It seems to have taken a long time for people to come up with this reason not to support their claims doesn't it? I hope that means all excuses are now exhausted. ;)

Yes, it was originally changed as I already stated and it was apparently not just me who noticed yet another, unannounced, change to the thread title.

I've already PMed a mod in order to get permission to start a new thread where discussions of efficacies of differing treatment methods can be discussed in the SMMT subforum where perhaps it will get more professional attention from those who know more than I about studies and proper ways of conducting them and interpreting them. I would like to learn more at least.

The Religion and Philosophy subforum is not the appropriate place for this.



Oh and by the way, it was AlBell who once complained about my and others' concerns and criticisms of AA saying that he felt that, by saying these things, we were potentially driving people away from AA. I would think that the smug condescension shown by many pro-AAs would do more damage in the long run as they seem extremely sensitive to criticism -- appropriate or otherwise.
 
Last edited:
You probably won't like this, but AA identifies it as a spiritual program. You have to rely on anecdote for this since it's hard to measure in a lab (though not impossible if suitable algorithms are developed).


Yes, it does as I and others have said for quite a few months now and that is the root of the issue for me, at least. There is no evidence that addiction is in fact a spiritual disease which requires a spiritual solution.



AA doesn't conduct experiment with drunks. It's not going to offer one group "treatment" and exclude another group. Show me the study AA could conduct that wouldn't require it to forbid people from attending. I've been puzzling over this one for a while, and no one's stepped up.

It seems my answers to you weren't clear enough for you to understand, and I apologize. I thought I was specific enough and provided links to educate you further. Please do not be disingenuous by claiming that "no one's stepped up."

Plenty of science has found its way into AA and research has concluded it's effective, especially when supplemented by appropriate counseling etc. AA is not exempt from hard research; AA attendance has factored into various studies.

It would be a lot harder to measure success if working the AA program were included, since the spiritual dimension, which you may ridicule but most Americans don't, is a separate issue than meeting attendance and not readily quantifiable.

"Plenty of science has found it's way into AA"? Are you serious? That's the whole bloody problem -- where is all of this "plenty of science" then? Do you really think no one AT ALL has tried to find this science for those who are looking?

I try not to ridicule spirituality, but sometimes I end up doing so anyway. I don't think I did in this thread; I know others have done. But it is irrelevant whether or not some ridicule spirituality and it's a fallacy (argumentum ad populum) to think that just because lots of Americans believe in spirituality that spirituality is a meaningful proposition especially concerning addictions.
 
Yes, it was originally changed as I already stated and it was apparently not just me who noticed yet another, unannounced, change to the thread title.

Another?
Unannounced?

There is nothing stopping you from starting another thread on addiction treatments and their efficacies elsewhere.

It seems to me Norseman that by taking these questions to another thread at this late stage is nothing more than a cop out. The questions have been asked and asked for a long time. My cynical side says people are running from the discussion.
 
Another?
Unannounced?

There is nothing stopping you from starting another thread on addiction treatments and their efficacies elsewhere.

It seems to me Norseman that by taking these questions to another thread at this late stage is nothing more than a cop out. The questions have been asked and asked for a long time. My cynical side says people are running from the discussion.

Yes, another change, as I've already stated.

First: Why do people insist AA is not religious?

Second: Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA

Newest: Why do people insist AA is not religous?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs.



The original topic of efficacy of AA was off-topic; I know I participated in the derail of that. So, it was changed to include discussion of the efficacy of AA. Sometime after that change, it was changed again and I only noticed when you pointed it out. I try to be very precise when I make claims and though I can be wrong, it seems I was not in this case. Maybe a mod will come forward to verify whether or not I'm mistaken. I have no ego involved in being wrong. It is very unfortunate that many others cannot also make this claim in good conscience.

You may view my desiring a thread in the appropriate subforum as a cop-out or as running away. I couldn't care less. You and the other pro-AAs can all do congratulatory back-slapping all night long. I put in a request to a mod simply because I didn't want to be infracted by posting what could be considered a duplicate thread; I also stand by my reasons I just stated. I don't know if it would be an offense so I sent a PM to make certain. I do hope that's alright with you.
 
Yes, another change, as I've already stated.

Fair enough on "another", I should have put more emphasis on the "unannounced" word which was the one that really caught my eye.

You may view my desiring a thread in the appropriate subforum as a cop-out or as running away. I couldn't care less. You and the other pro-AAs can all do congratulatory back-slapping all night long. I put in a request to a mod simply because I didn't want to be infracted by posting what could be considered a duplicate thread; I also stand by my reasons I just stated. I don't know if it would be an offense so I sent a PM to make certain. I do hope that's alright with you.

Fine with me. I have no ego about being wrong either.

But I also stand by my comments about it being a cop out. If you take that to mean you, then fine - if the shoe fits, as they say.

My point was and is that we have been asking for people to support their claims around other treatments for a long time, both on and off topic. And it is only now that you wish this change. You have been in a position to say something for some months.

Ther mods have done a great job with this thread imho.They have been firm when they needed to be, allowed the thread to take natural drift and accommodated accordingly to that organic evolution.

And to be fair, I can see your point on one hand. But on the other the cynical side of me says "cop out" when you could readily start another thread without moderator approval/intervention. In fact you should anyway; I too would like to see some more information from a science based perspective. It is certainly not forthcoming from those that make the claims here. :rolleyes:

In the meantime you are potentially providing an out for some less than honest posters (I do not count you in that number) and other protagonists, meaning they are not called to account over their fast and loose claims.
 
For the record, I only learned of Stinkin' Thinkin' through this thread and have perused it for all of 5 minutes. As I said before, I bear no animosity towards AA members in general and don't care to engage in character assassination of the whole program for the behavior of a small portion of the members. I also never made efficacy claims about any other program. What I did claim, and this has still not been addressed by the apologist crowd, is that AA does not operate within the modern medical framework, while there are at least a handful of treatments that do. Setting aside any claims of efficacy, I prefer treatments for physical conditions that operate within the modern medical tradition of experimentation, extensive study, and constant improvement, because this is the only proven way to improve treatment of any condition. AA doesn't engage in this, and there is not a good reason why. Every successful medical treatment to date has been developed and studied in a particular way, and improved upon as needed. Why should AA be exempt from this?

I agree with much of what you're saying and understand where you're coming from. Trust me, if I could've taken some medication twice a day for a month and been cured of drinking I would've jumped at the chance.

The problem is, at the moment there really isn't any: "treatments for physical conditions that operate within the modern medical tradition of experimentation, extensive study, and constant improvement"

Most doctors believe there is no treatment currently available:

http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/285913-treatment

Many physicians believe no effective treatment is available for alcoholism; therefore, these physicians do not refer their patients for treatment.

As for AA members being studied we've had this discussion many times in this thread already. I guess one more won't hurt.

The dilemma stems from how AA is structured. It's a loosely connected network of thousands of self-groups that are based on their members anonymity and a lack of rigid rules. That's what makes it attractive for people like me.

I remember missing appointments with my counselours and I was late for my group therapy meetings quite often( I was still drinking at the time), I was told I would be dropped if it continued and eventually I was. That can't happen to me in AA.

I don't think asking AA members to fill out reports would go over too well, the info might not be realible either.
The best way to study addicts is in a tightly controlled enviroment
with strict parameters.

Maybe one day a government somewhere will offer an AA program to people in need, they could offer room & board in return the subjects will have to participate in a lenghty study. I'm not sure how that would work though or who would oversee it.
 
Fair enough on "another", I should have put more emphasis on the "unannounced" word which was the one that really caught my eye.

Fair enough.


Fine with me. I have no ego about being wrong either.

The only reason I'm being so adamant about it is that I do believe it was changed without general announcement, otherwise I would have objected then.


But I also stand by my comments about it being a cop out. If you take that to mean you, then fine - if the shoe fits, as they say.

Heh. Okay, Alfie. I'm not sure how other to interpret you saying, "It seems to me Norseman that by taking these questions to another thread at this late stage is nothing more than a cop out" other than that it was directed specifically at me.


My point was and is that we have been asking for people to support their claims around other treatments for a long time, both on and off topic. And it is only now that you wish this change. You have been in a position to say something for some months.

I understand and I have been providing some evidence along the way. Not a huge amount, I'll admit, but I would dare say more than most. I was fine with the status the way it was until you pointed out the thread change, then I had come to a realization. This realization is that I was in error by not, as you point out, saying anything about it sooner. Can't go back and change it, so I'm pressing on with what I believe the subject of a new thread should be.

You seem to me to be if not against my starting a new thread, at least not for it either and that is somewhat surprising to me. I would think that a separate thread *specifically* about how effective treatment types *other than AA* are in in a separate thread would be beneficial for all involved. I will bring my evidence for other treatment types and I hope that others, including yourself, bring it as well.



Ther mods have done a great job with this thread imho.They have been firm when they needed to be, allowed the thread to take natural drift and accommodated accordingly to that organic evolution.

I'm not sure why you bring up the mods and their decisions regarding this thread; it seems a bit irrelevant. I agree with you, though, in that they've done a good job.




And to be fair, I can see your point on one hand. But on the other the cynical side of me says "cop out" when you could readily start another thread without moderator approval/intervention. In fact you should anyway; I too would like to see some more information from a science based perspective. It is certainly not forthcoming from those that make the claims here. :rolleyes:

In the meantime you are potentially providing an out for some less than honest posters (I do not count you in that number) and other protagonists, meaning they are not called to account over their fast and loose claims.

I put in my request a day or two ago; I would like confirmation from a mod that it'd be okay. Maybe I'm just confusing me starting a new thread versus me starting a new thread that is similar to one that was locked and/or moderated.

Besides, if this thread continues, there is more than ample space here to call out me or others in providing evidence for or against AA specifically.
 
The only reason I'm being so adamant about it is that I do believe it was changed without general announcement, otherwise I would have objected then.

There was a general announcement on the 13th August as Ketyk outlined a few posts ago.

Can't go back and change it, so I'm pressing on with what I believe the subject of a new thread should be.

I might owe you an apology; are you saying you want to start a new thread, or change the topic of this one? Or both?

You seem to me to be if not against my starting a new thread, at least not for it either and that is somewhat surprising to me. I would think that a separate thread *specifically* about how effective treatment types *other than AA* are in in a separate thread would be beneficial for all involved. I will bring my evidence for other treatment types and I hope that others, including yourself, bring it as well.

I am all for the new thread and will be a willing participant. I am against changing this thread back.

Have I misunderstood you somehow? If so; my mistake and I apologise. I have no personal beef with you. :cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom