Fair enough on "another", I should have put more emphasis on the "unannounced" word which was the one that really caught my eye.
Fair enough.
Fine with me. I have no ego about being wrong either.
The only reason I'm being so adamant about it is that I do believe it was changed without general announcement, otherwise I would have objected then.
But I also stand by my comments about it being a cop out. If you take that to mean you, then fine - if the shoe fits, as they say.
Heh. Okay, Alfie. I'm not sure how other to interpret you saying, "It seems to me Norseman that by taking these questions to another thread at this late stage is nothing more than a cop out" other than that it was directed specifically at me.
My point was and is that we have been asking for people to support their claims around other treatments for a long time, both on and off topic. And it is only now that you wish this change. You have been in a position to say something for some months.
I understand and I have been providing some evidence along the way. Not a huge amount, I'll admit, but I would dare say more than most. I was fine with the status the way it was until you pointed out the thread change, then I had come to a realization. This realization is that I was in error by not, as you point out, saying anything about it sooner. Can't go back and change it, so I'm pressing on with what I believe the subject of a new thread should be.
You seem to me to be if not against my starting a new thread, at least not for it either and that is somewhat surprising to me. I would think that a separate thread *specifically* about how effective treatment types *other than AA* are in in a separate thread would be beneficial for all involved. I will bring my evidence for other treatment types and I hope that others, including yourself, bring it as well.
Ther mods have done a great job with this thread imho.They have been firm when they needed to be, allowed the thread to take natural drift and accommodated accordingly to that organic evolution.
I'm not sure why you bring up the mods and their decisions regarding this thread; it seems a bit irrelevant. I agree with you, though, in that they've done a good job.
And to be fair, I can see your point on one hand. But on the other the cynical side of me says "cop out" when you could readily start another thread without moderator approval/intervention. In fact you should anyway; I too would like to see some more information from a science based perspective. It is certainly not forthcoming from those that make the claims here.
In the meantime you are potentially providing an out for some less than honest posters (I do not count you in that number) and other protagonists, meaning they are not called to account over their fast and loose claims.
I put in my request a day or two ago; I would like confirmation from a mod that it'd be okay. Maybe I'm just confusing me starting a new thread versus me starting a new thread that is similar to one that was locked and/or moderated.
Besides, if this thread continues, there is more than ample space here to call out me or others in providing evidence for or against AA specifically.