Minoosh, what you are describing is simply the natural process of healing after prolonged excessive alcohol abuse .... There’s no mystery to that.
There was a big mystery, which was largely, why didn't I tap into that natural process sooner? I'd been doing insane things for a long time. There are a host of non-mystical reasons that light finally dawned, but there was also a definite inner shift. The biggest was probably, in very early recovery my 39-year-old brother died. I saw what it did to my parents.
I had always thought my life was my own. I had a right to run it into the ground. It came to me that I did not have sovereign control of my life. "I" had no right to kill "me."
My life was not my own. Then whose was it?
At that time I was around AA, but that wasn't in any of the slogans. The first three steps kind of worked me rather than vice versa. I had a treatment assignment on "powerlessness," but it wasn't those earnest questions that sold me, it was another epiphany. I realized if I did use, I'd just want more, and there wouldn't be enough. I learned that indulging the craving made the craving worse. After using the old reward circuits would kick into gear and my judgment would falter. A real, internal experience of Step 1.
At another time in this early period I tried prayer, and I wasn't asking a sky daddy for miracles. I was trying to stop obsessing about something really scary that I couldn't fix. The prayer wrought changes in me, not the world at large. My fear lessened. It was kind of "doing the footwork" and letting go of the results.
Conveniently I had an actual higher power running my life, the county adult probation department. So turning my life and will over so it could restore me to sanity made perfect sense. I heard other people bitch about being on probation; I was actually relieved, grateful. I wasn't fighting circumstances.
All this to stay that the first 3 steps worked on me from within, independent of the Big Book or slogans. I wasn't going through contortions to make the words mean what I wanted them to; I just (fairly) suddenly grasped the truth beyond the words. Life was better if I didn't use, came to meetings and quit fighting this "ego" or whatever that for so long had been in the driver's seat. It didn't depend on supernatural agency; yet it depended on activating the "natural process of healing" and that was not something I willed to happen. I didn't wake up in the morning and say, "I've decided to activate the natural process of healing." I just sort of opened up to it.
Unfortunately, in AA during that repairing process you are told to “leave your brain at the door,” “your best thinking got you here,” and that “feelings aren’t fact,” which is essentially telling you to not trust you rational mind or your “gut instincts.”
C&E, I think you're not aware that those slogans, in context, support the "natural healing process," and also don't mean abdicating responsibility for yourself.
First of all, I rarely heard them, but when I did they made a certain amount of sense. "Feelings aren't fact," for example often refers to feeling like you need a drink and you are being told, you're not going to explode if you don't have one; the feeling will pass. "Leave your brain at the door" (which BTW I
never heard) says, don't overthink this. Experience, listen, absorb. Switch off your running analysis of everybody and everything, be still and listen.
I don't think most people arrive at AA as blank slates unable to resist catchy slogans. Maybe some do. Most, I would wager, already have some experience of how distorted their thinking can be. People spout slogans that have helped
them, it's not really a bid for mind control, it's people reminding
themselves of what the slogan means to them. You can pick them apart, most people probably do and some fall out of favor. My theory is that 1940s "Mad Men" turned their newly sober brains to formulating slogans and ran amok.
As stated in the big book, and as many AAs would say, his close friend said “Why don’t you go try some controlled drinking?”
The book doesn't say "why don't you try some controlled drinking." It says "You can quickly diagnose yourself, step over to the nearest barroom and try some controlled drinking. Try it more than once ..." It's a last measure for breaking through denial of our "true condition." I shudder with revulsion when I hear it (at least I do clean; the somatic connection is tamped down at present) and I'll wager that those early AA cases did too. It's repulsive.
I don't know how your "true believer" friend managed to persuade himself that routine drinking to a blackout state was no longer adequate to diagnose his alcoholism, but despite the suggestion someone else planted - that blackouts were part of normal drinking - your friend convinced
himself.
It sounds like he wanted an "out" from being a "real alcoholic," and was receptive to believing his blackout drinking was normal. I don't know why
his "friend" floated that notion, then suggested he try some controlled drinking. To me it sounds absolutely vile.
Demonic if you want to hear some religious language.
Your friend is being played with, but it sounds like he really, really wants an excuse to try some controlled drinking.
I was merely pointing out one of many, many myths perpetuated in AA.
The "myths" change. The people change. Some myths die, others reveal themselves as quite creditable.
BTW, what you said about being uninsurable is true. Keep in mind almost all those rehabs use 12 step facilitation.
OK, serious challenge here: What does the second sentence have to do with anything? The insurance form asks if you've ever been treated for substance abuse, period. Twelve-step facilitation is irrelevant. AA isn't "treatment" in medical underwriting lingo - it doesn't generate financial claims.
Best of luck getting “clean”, but why do you feel you’re not “clean” when you are taking a prescribed medication as prescribed by a physician? Oh wait…
Thank you. I'm not sure what the "Oh wait" refers to. That I'm the victim of a myth? No.
I feel not clean because I don't feel clean. I don't mean filthy dirty, I'm not lying to get scripts or driving in blackouts. More like "tarnished": I was bright shiny silver and now a patina is obstructing that light. It shows on my face.
Someone else on my medication regimen might consider themselves clean and I wouldn't try to talk them out of it. Never. Ever.
I know which Rx's are doing this. From experience. Hint: It's not the antidepressant. It's 2 controlled substances to manage cravings. This is better than conning docs for scripts or committing five felonies before breakfast, but
for me it is not clean, I don't want to spend the rest of my life addicted to these substances.