Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Per the paper, the 5 percent figure appears to stem from the "1990 summary report of 1977-1989 triennial membership surveys." If anyone can cite a substantially different source for that figure, please do, because I'm trying to look at apples vs. apples.

Please be aware that this survey was looking at retention rates, not recovery rates.

I'm going with a hypothetical 100 people to make the percentages readily apparent. Of 100 people answering the survey, 19 were in their first month. 5 were in their 12th month. Extrapolating you could maybe say that only 5 in 19 newcomers stays a full year. So: Only 26 percent of first-month attendees stay a full year.

However, back to quoting the study, the statistics indicate 56 percent who stay active for 3 months are still active after a year.

Strangely the erroneous 5 percent has been adopted by some people in AA to prove that AA worked better in the old days.
 
Minoosh,

Thank you for thanking me earlier. I didn't want to act all butt-hurt; I was wanting to point out that being polite to one another has been much more of a benefit than the long and tedious sniping that got the thread moderated in the first place.

I was surprised to read that you agreed with my criticisms of the report you linked to. I made the assumption that since you didn't specifically comment on them, you disagreed and didn't want to 'fight' over it.



Re: the 5 percent rate, here is a report explaining the apparent origins and issues with both that low-end mark and high-end marks flush with AA euphoria:

AA Recovery Outcome Rates: Contemporary Myth and Misinterpretation
http://hindsfoot.org/recout01.pdf


Let's assume, despite the problem with those statistics, that the oft-cited 5 percent AA success rate and 5 percent do-nothing success rate are accurate.

The 5 percent who experience spontaneous remission by definition have not been to AA or any other treatment. Bully for them.

One in 20 stays home and voila, they're cured. The other 19 go out and try something. Maybe they, their spouses, their employers, the legal system or all of the above have grown impatient with waiting for spontaneous remission.

If, of that 19, any succeed in quitting drink, you have a success rate greater than 1 in 20. If they all stay home, you have a success rate of 1 in 20.

I may be making some specific error here, but that's what I come up with.

Here's another interesting link: http://http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=does-alcoholics-anonymous-work


I will read the links later, but for now I want to clarify what I believe is the process for the 5% rate and if I'm mistaken, it's a good thing that I get corrected.

I think the 5% baseline comes from the fact that there are (to simplify) two groups: alcoholics who take no action to achieving sobriety and those alcoholics who choose to attend AA.

The first group (non-attendance) have a spontaneous rate of ~5%.

The second group (AA attendance) have a reported success rate of ~5%.

This is how the numbers have panned out so far with the studies that have been done which means that more studies need to be done to help ferret out why.

Who knows. Maybe AA is truly useless as a treatment modality and it's just a cultural myth a this point that will die hard.
 
What I do think is that AA can accidentally teach a few valuable coping mechanisms that are lacking in many addicted people.

Just a little aside

I don't think this is any accident. My experience of stepwork, open and honest discussion with experienced people, fellowship and community, etc all assist with coping skills. The program has a design and many facets from which to choose, ultimately they all lead to education of self which leads to coping skills.
 
Last edited:
What Alfie said: the good stuff you learn is not an accident. Well, sometimes I suppose it could be, but I'd say it comes along with learning new behaviors and new ways of thinking.

And, Norseman, one of those point-by-point responses, which are tiresome but fulfill my need to fiddle with words:

The problem I see is that AA wants to eat it's cake and have it too -- it's protagonists want it to be successful and valuable for suffering addicts, yet steadfastly refuse to actually test the claims or try to improve the program in any way. They just come up with non-program stuff as a work around. Why would that be, I wonder?

Disingenuous. You've been told "why that would be." The insinuation is AA has something to hide. Whether it does or not, you've been given numerous valid reasons there's no concerted push to "improve" the program.

You've already been told why AA isn't going to open a psychotherapy center (or a gym, a vegetable garden, bowling alley or social club). Of course qualified therapists, regular exercise, good nutrition and sober recreation could help in recovery. Should AA incorporate them all?

"They just come up with non-program stuff" not as a workaround but as a supplement, because AA can't be all things to all people. It's minimalist by design. It is an organism. It changes all the time based on its habitat. You've provided an example: The desire to help suffering "addicts" is pretty widely accepted now. Bill W. distinguished between alcoholics and addicts; the distinction has almost disappeared some places. That's a change wrought by reality.

The point is that we really don't know that AA has any positive effect at all; if there is a positive effect, is it realistic to attribute it to AA rather than the efforts of the person themselves outside of any self-help group attendance?

Is it realistic to conclude attendance had nothing to do with it? All of those people who think it helped are wrong? You hear that your deepest, darkest secrets aren't unique. It fills up an hour and you're not drinking during that hour. You laugh, maybe get some of those endorphin things going, make some friends. For a lot of us that's an improvement over staying home.

Has it come around again to the implication that AA should go out of its way to stop people from coming, so AA can study people who don't go to AA?

Again, as I said in an earlier post, I will be the first one to say to others, "hey, go to AA. I don't like it because of it's religious orientation, but I've read all the studies that confirm that it's really helpful for coping with addiction." The problem is that there are no studies that show what I just said.

Personally I avoid saying, "Hey, go to AA."

You're good at finding reasons to discount the studies that have been posted. I'd say it's been demonstrated that AA is helpful for coping with addiction. Whether that's because it gets you out of the house, helps you make new friends, helps you find God or has really primo coffee ;), isn't clear. It's a stretch to arrive at "there are no studies showing AA is helpful for coping with addiction." Yes, there are. Some people benefit from support groups. AA is a support group for alcoholics. Maybe the benefits are all in their head (which would be where mental health resides, after all).

Granted the non-AA support group model might also work, but in practice AA is by far the most accessible. Someone can do a study in Toronto, perhaps. But even that's a 12-step program.

Over time AA itself has probably gotten more secular and though I doubt it will happen, it's possible one day the membership will push for rewording the steps. The Step 3 disclaimer satisfies a lot of members, and it was a major concession at the time, given AA's origins. The point is AA started out by attempting to be inclusive, that's the language that was developed and a lot of people love the steps as written.

Yes, they can be effective for many people in coping with their disease. Do these cancer self-help groups work the 12-steps? Do arthritis sufferers proclaim their powerlessness over arthritis every day?

If a disease is purely or primarily physical, working the steps may or may not help someone. Alcoholism is not a purely physical disease. The "powerlessness" is for people who believe themselves to be powerless after the first drink. It's a cognitive shift from "I can moderate" to "No I can't." That's what AA is for. Please believe that for many people this is extremely hard-won knowledge - not something AA can drop into their heads by power of suggestion.

Note the behavioral component: after drinking. There's no analogy in arthritis or cancer. You can't behave your way out of cancer. With diabetes you can learn new behaviors that might help your overall condition; with alcoholism you must learn new behaviors in order to avoid drinking. Is it a given that first drink would be disastrous? Maybe not. But if you don't use you can't get strung out. Pretty simple. Other principles give other steps their oomph.
 
I'm fine with moving the goalposts. I'm trying to get them back to where they belong; notably, AA has made claims of success in dealing with addiction and alcoholism. That is undeniable.

The problem I see is that AA wants to eat it's cake and have it too -- it's protagonists want it to be successful and valuable for suffering addicts, yet steadfastly refuse to actually test the claims or try to improve the program in any way. They just come up with non-program stuff as a work around. Why would that be, I wonder?

I just don't get it. An AAer, for example, doesn't really like the sixth step and so doesn't do it. They use a saying that was never part of the original program ("take what you want and leave the rest") to justify not doing it, yet feel proud that they're 'working the steps'.

I see what you're saying and your view is completely understandable. I'm just not sure AA would function/work if members weren't allowed to remain anonymous. It's hard to "spill your guts" when you're ashamed of what you've done to yourself and others, being able to do it behind closed doors with anonymity makes it easier.

As for "take what you want, leave the rest" and doing certain things, while not others. I think those of us in AA would just like people who are suffering to come to some meetings and not drink as a starting point for sobriety. I was told by my best friend who entered AA 18 months before I did "there are no rules in AA", it helped convince me to show up at my first meeting because I was very, VERY apprehensive about going. In fact AA had been suggested to me many times and I always laughed it off. By not "preaching" to newcomers and making them adhere to a strict set of rules we make it easier for them to stay in the program and remain sober.

Picture someone going to weight watchers and being told they have to cut out sugar, salt, fat, carbs and do some exercise. They come back a week later and say " I was able to stick to my diet, but I didn't exercise, I really hate to exercise, I especially dislike running". We wouldn't say, well if you're not going to run, you might as well get lost.


The point is that we really don't know that AA has any positive effect at all; if there is a positive effect, is it realistic to attribute it to AA rather than the efforts of the person themselves outside of any self-help group attendance? We don't know yet.

Again, as I said in an earlier post, I will be the first one to say to others, "hey, go to AA. I don't like it because of it's religious orientation, but I've read all the studies that confirm that it's really helpful for coping with addiction."

The problem is that there are no studies that show what I just said. And to forestall any criticism of CBT or related therapy, a new thread should be started so that that program can be discussed with more thoroughness than can be done in this thread.

I have to disagree I think it helps alcoholics, I've seen too many people come to meetings after trying various other remedies and stay sober. I think those people along with myself would still be drinking today without AA. How effective is it? I agree it remains to be seen and more studies done, though I don't know how one would work out the logistics.

You're right though, this thread should probably be split and moved to the sub-forum dealing with medicine.,

Sure, based on one survey's conclusions. But 'psychotherapy' is a HUGE FIELD that covers quite a wide area of differing treatment modalities; one does not even have to have any professional degrees or training to call oneself a psychotherapist. Usually the studies will define what they mean by using certain terminology which can lead a meta-analyst into making a more fair comparison.

My psychotherapist was my former family doctor who decided to switch fields.

I don't think he knew very much about alcohol, but that didn't stop my current family physician from referring me to him. I learned much more from my fellow alcoholics than I ever did from him.

It's not a canard. It's a baseline that every study that I've seen, reports. In any population of alcoholics studied, ~5% of them recover without doing anything. (In this case, I sure wish Linda were still around because she can explain in greater detail since that's her profession.)

I think we're misunderstanding each other, I was refering to the AA success rate often cited in this thread. That number is based on an old study with questionable controls.

And why are you sure of this? There are many things that happen which are counter-intuitive yet remain true. One example that I can think of is that some children were studied on the amount of homework they had versus scores on standardized tests. Before a certain age (twelve, I think), it was found that homework was useless in producing long-term improvement in scores. They just weren't developed enough to take advantage of long hours of studying at home.

I'm sure because it's been studied, reading helps brain function. A better functioning brain makes for a better student.


So in other words, we can certainly study these kinds of things and more. Alcoholics are no different in that regard, as I've said many times now.

I agree if strict perimeters are set. As I said a few pages ago, still practicing or newly recovered alcoholics and addicts are notorious liars and very unreliable. Any study would need tight controls. Relying on questionnaires or phone interviews is spurious at best.

Great examples, PBS! Yes, they can be effective for many people in coping with their disease. Do these cancer self-help groups work the 12-steps? Do arthritis sufferers proclaim their powerlessness over arthritis every day? How does a person with major depression 'relapse'? Does a woman with cancer need to take her own inventory or caused her family and friends emotional distress due to her trips to chemotherapy that she should make amends for?

If these people find comfort, solace, and a new outlet for living with these difficult conditions, what is it that helps them? Is it the 12 steps? If not, why not?

Obviously every disease is different and requires varying methods of treatment. I was making the comparison to show that people suffering from the same affliction can benefit from sharing their experience, strength and hope with each other.
The twelve steps are used as a form of mental therapy for alcoholics who have unique traits. I don't think cancer victims were ever blamed for ruining the lives of others. I don't think arthritis sufferers deny they have a problem for years on end, even when they've been told over and over they have a problem.
Alcoholics have these problems and the myriad of things in the program as well as the twelve steps help to alleviate them.
 
Wow, ProBonoShill said things a lot more efficiently than I did.

I wonder if critics on this thread would be less anti-AA if official literature added a pamphlet giving perspectives about AA success/failure rates and a summary of other treatments that replace or complement AA. The 5 percent failure rate could be debunked; so also could be overly high success rates.

This could be an appendix or chapter in the Big Book as well as a pamphlet. Groups could hold discussion meetings on such topics. Another potential topic could be pitfalls people have found in AA. Topic: "I've been wondering about these bad things people say. I'd like hear about responsibility of members who see serious mistakes being made."

I'd agree with putting this in a medicine forum except that AA isn't medicine or even treatment. It's a free, voluntary, accessible behavioral intervention with no fixed course.

I've looked at the evidence for harm AA does, but after reading some stories about deprogramming etc. I grew less impressed. Claims were indignant it tone but lacking in specifics. For example one woman complained because she was urged to see a psychologist. This offended her greatly.

Another said, "I have worked the steps twice had three sponsors, the last one a real sicko who has thirteen years ''sobriety'' he is over in my country from the middle east recruiting like an insane lunatic!!" The poster does not describe the presumably offensive behavior. I belief a subgroup is primed for anger against AA.

Someone on this board said AA ruined countless marriages. Googling "AA destroyed my marriage" yielded one hit. A good read, but it turned out the marriage had always has problems. Other allegations on this forum - of massive lawsuits, for example - have not proved readily verified.

Evidence of so-called harm is heavily outweighed by counterclaims of so-called help. I'm not discounting the ugliness, I read about it and think it over. My opinion evolves.
 
Last edited:
As I said a few pages ago, still practicing or newly recovered alcoholics and addicts are notorious liars and very unreliable…. The twelve steps are used as a form of mental therapy for alcoholics who have unique traits.


According to Handbook of Alcoholism Treatment Approaches-Effective Alternatives

“Another factor that contributed to the shift away from a character-trait view of motivation was the consistent finding that alcoholics do not manifest a characteristic type of personality. Fifty years of both psychological (Miller,1976) and longitudinal studies (Jones, 1968, Vaillant, 1983) have failed to reveal a consistent “alcoholic personality.” Attempts to derive a set of alcoholic psychometric personality subtypes have yielded profiles similar to those found when subtyping a general population (e.g., Loberg & Miler, 1986). That is, alcoholics appear to be as variable in personality as are nonalcoholics. Studies of character defense mechanisms among alcoholics have yielded a similar picture. Denial and other defense mechanisms have been found to be nor more or less frequent among alcoholics than among people in general (Chess, Neuringer, & Goldstein, 1971; Donovan, Rohsenow, Schau, & O’Leary, 1977; Skinner & Allen, 1983). There was simply no supports for the view that alcoholics in general come into treatment with a consistent set of personality traits and defenses.”


I’m fully aware that AA members will repeat the erroneous belief that alcoholics are notorious liars, and even claim it’s true of them. But that’s merely conforming to a belief system which they believe that there will be dire consequences if they don’t adopt. These things they claim may or may not be true of them at all.

Doesn’t that make you wonder what other myths you’ve been lead to believe in?
 
In my felt experience there is such a thing as soul-sickness and I'm not averse to using religious language to describe it.

What exactly is a "soul sickness"? How do you define it? Feel free to use religious language. How do you diagnose it? Does it cough, sneeze, run a fever, or what? Is it communicable? If I wash my soul hands frequently do you think I can avoid it or is it air-born? How do you even know a soul exists? How do you know it’s a soul sickness as opposed to a very real human lack of coping skills (please don’t confuse coping skills with personality)? And what about this “spiritual malady” the big book refers to? How do you know it exists? What evidence do you have for it, other than what's written in a book of superstitious faith healing?
 
What exactly is a "soul sickness"? How do you define it? Feel free to use religious language. How do you diagnose it? Does it cough, sneeze, run a fever, or what? Is it communicable? If I wash my soul hands frequently do you think I can avoid it or is it air-born? How do you even know a soul exists? How do you know it’s a soul sickness as opposed to a very real human lack of coping skills (please don’t confuse coping skills with personality)? And what about this “spiritual malady” the big book refers to? How do you know it exists? What evidence do you have for it, other than what's written in a book of superstitious faith healing?

Start with low self esteem coupled with (maybe) some mental health issues and unresolved grief and loss and you probably have a fair starting point.
 
What exactly is a "soul sickness"? How do you define it? Feel free to use religious language. How do you diagnose it? Does it cough, sneeze, run a fever, or what? Is it communicable? If I wash my soul hands frequently do you think I can avoid it or is it air-born? How do you even know a soul exists? How do you know it’s a soul sickness as opposed to a very real human lack of coping skills (please don’t confuse coping skills with personality)? And what about this “spiritual malady” the big book refers to? How do you know it exists? What evidence do you have for it, other than what's written in a book of superstitious faith healing?

Why don't you try this C&E explain to us why these things are not true.
Oh and coping skills are a part of your personality. They are not separate.
Your coping skills will define your personality and visa versa.
See what I mean.
 
What exactly is a "soul sickness"? How do you define it?

When you have this compulsion ... and you try to stop some incredibly destructive behavior and you can't?

My DOC left body and reasoning relatively intact. It was like a neutron bomb. The infrastructure, the machine, was evident but something else was in eclipse. I call that my soul.

Clean or in withdrawal I gain access to a different level of awareness. I know it's there because I'm aware of it. I realize my internal experience has zero probative value for you, you needn't labor to point that out. However I didn't coin the phrases "mind, body and soul" or "I went with my gut instead of my brain." They are distinct internal experiences for some people; if they weren't we would not have developed words to make the distinction.

I didn't know what "heartache" meant until I got clean. "Gut feelings," "chills down the spine" - those described thoughts to me but I didn't feel them. Clean I feel them in my body. I can't live with "burning shame" or something that "turns my stomach."

"Mind" and "body" integrated are more powerful than either alone. Unchecked they vie for primacy. But there is an interface that yearns for integration; it is nurtured by prayer, meditation, yoga and I would imagine a variety of martial-arts practices.

If you're perfectly rational you'll never have "compulsions." You'll reason yourself into moderating. But when that fails, and generally when it fails repeatedly - you may conclude your mind or "unaided will" isn't working properly. Your "enough" button is broken. Certain of your cells are shouting "more ETOH!" while others are hemorrhaging.

So at the least, allow space for your mind and body to work together, and the space is what I call spirituality. In time maybe you feel that your "spiritual" gears engage with something larger than you, but it's not required. Your drive for health, wholeness, integrated mind/body are still more powerful than your unaided will.

The repair kit of the 12 steps enable this sort of integration, where "deep, dark" secrets come to the light; where "nagging guilt feelings" stop nagging; where your raging id meets your "still small voice" and settles down. To start, you need to refrain as far as safely possible from using "mood-altering" drugs (detox protocols fully in force; booze withdrawal is life-threatening).

The secular version looks fine to me, but I have no problem with the traditional language. If you accept the steps but not God, find kindred spirits and start a meeting. I'm curious about crossover potential.

I'm now in harm reduction mode, taking prescribed substances as prescribed and I want to be clean. This isn't some Protestant, puritanical "meme," it's experiential - I want to feel more alive. I've been in a lot of different belief states, though I've never been a belligerent atheist demanding proof of the unprovable. "Clean" I'd find these discussions a bit hard to take, so if I post less it means I'm getting better - "coming to my senses" :)

BTW in the U.S. be aware that any documented treatment for substance abuse may make you uninsurable. That's not necessarily an argument for AA; just an unfortunate reality.
 
Last edited:
Doesn’t that make you wonder what other myths you’ve been lead to believe in?

Sweetie, alcoholics in AA by and large aren't "led to believe" they can't safely drink. Generally we've conducted our own longitudinal studies and arrived at our own conclusions. You are not the only skeptic on this forum.
 
Minoosh, what you are describing is simply the natural process of healing after prolonged excessive alcohol abuse. The mind and body start to heal and start to feel again. People want to reclaim their lives and that’s not exclusive to AA. There’s no mystery to that. Unfortunately, in AA during that repairing process you are told to “leave your brain at the door,” “your best thinking got you here,” and that “feelings aren’t fact,” which is essentially telling you to not trust you rational mind or your “gut instincts.”

And I would never, ever suggest that you, or anybody else who has had a problem, can safely drink, although some have actually found they can. It’s a complete diversion from the point I was making about myths, but I’m glad you brought it up.

I know this guy from around the web. He’s a real true believer in every single bit of AA, and a staunch defender of his faith. He makes a big deal of the distinction between “real alcoholics” and heavy drinkers on his blog. He recently encountered another true believer on the web who told him that blackouts are a natural consequence of drinking too much and can happen to anybody—that “real alcoholics” experience a phenomenon called “struck drunk.” He actually was thrown into an identity crisis, questioning whether or not he “qualifies” as a “real alcoholic.” I asked him what exactly it meant and he said he didn’t even know, but said that he’d only experienced blackouts almost every time he drank, but he’d never been “struck drunk.” When I visited his blog, what do you think was the very first comment from his long time follower and good friend? As stated in the big book, and as many AAs would say, his close friend said “Why don’t you go try some controlled drinking?” I really feel for the guy. I sincerely hope he didn’t take that suggestion.

I was merely pointing out one of many, many myths perpetuated in AA.

BTW, what you said about being uninsurable is true. Keep in mind almost all those rehabs use 12 step facilitation.

Best of luck getting “clean”, but why do you feel you’re not “clean” when you are taking a prescribed medication as prescribed by a physician? Oh wait…
 
According to Handbook of Alcoholism Treatment Approaches-Effective Alternatives

“Another factor that contributed to the shift away from a character-trait view of motivation was the consistent finding that alcoholics do not manifest a characteristic type of personality. Fifty years of both psychological (Miller,1976) and longitudinal studies (Jones, 1968, Vaillant, 1983) have failed to reveal a consistent “alcoholic personality.” Attempts to derive a set of alcoholic psychometric personality subtypes have yielded profiles similar to those found when subtyping a general population (e.g., Loberg & Miler, 1986). That is, alcoholics appear to be as variable in personality as are nonalcoholics. Studies of character defense mechanisms among alcoholics have yielded a similar picture. Denial and other defense mechanisms have been found to be nor more or less frequent among alcoholics than among people in general (Chess, Neuringer, & Goldstein, 1971; Donovan, Rohsenow, Schau, & O’Leary, 1977; Skinner & Allen, 1983). There was simply no supports for the view that alcoholics in general come into treatment with a consistent set of personality traits and defenses.”


I’m fully aware that AA members will repeat the erroneous belief that alcoholics are notorious liars, and even claim it’s true of them. But that’s merely conforming to a belief system which they believe that there will be dire consequences if they don’t adopt. These things they claim may or may not be true of them at all.

Doesn’t that make you wonder what other myths you’ve been lead to believe in?

Hmmm, nowhere in the post you quoted did I mention anything about personality.

I was referring to traits we have due to our lengthy abuse of alcohol, it's effect on us and others such as guilt, denial, shame, low self esteem, etc.

http://books.google.ca/books?hl=en&...uxjODn-01qaZ2uck0IwtM2l4c#v=onepage&q&f=false

See the top of page 2



http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/4031595.stm


Nearly a quarter of adults or 12 million people use alcohol to fill the 'hole in the soul' created by low self esteem and depression, experts warn.



As for alcoholics lying:



http://alcoholism.about.com/cs/info2/a/aa050797.htm

One of the most frustrating factors in dealing with alcoholism, as a relative, friend or professional, is it is almost always accompanied by a phenomenon known as "denial."
In the long path the alcoholic takes toward mental, physical and moral decline, usually the first thing to go is honesty. He simply lies about his drinking. Little lies at first.



But these simple acts of denial, lying about his drinking or refusing to discuss it, are clues that the alcoholic himself deep down inside knows that he has a problem. If it's not a problem, why lie about it to anyone?

http://stroke.ahajournals.org/content/31/8/1851.full

In most prospective studies, the assessment of the alcohol drinking has been based on self-reporting, which may be unreliable.


http://alcoholism.about.com/od/about/a/diagnosis.htm

Diagnosing alcoholism can be tricky, since the diagnosis depends on the drinker being willing to honestly answer a series of questions about his or her drinking patterns and attitudes.

This is a problem because a common symptom of alcoholism is denial. An old adage about alcoholism is it's "the only disease that denies it exists and resists treatment." If someone is not willing to be honest about their drinking habits, it is difficult, if not impossible, to accurately diagnose alcohol abuse or alcohol dependence.

http://www.amsciepub.com/doi/abs/10.2466/pr0.1980.46.3.999

Some studies have supported the conclusion that the self-reports from alcoholics are unreliable.
 
Start with low self esteem coupled with (maybe) some mental health issues and unresolved grief and loss and you probably have a fair starting point.

Which pretty much covers everyone in the world.

The issue is: why is it that AA members "believe" AA is effective but absolutely refuse to find out if it actually is. We have seen this taken to the extreme in this thread.

What makes it all the more puzzling is that the discussion is happening on a skeptics list where you would expect people to follow the evidence and not allow themselves to get so emotionally tied to the outcome.

Humans are crazy aren't we?
 
Minoosh, what you are describing is simply the natural process of healing after prolonged excessive alcohol abuse .... There’s no mystery to that.

There was a big mystery, which was largely, why didn't I tap into that natural process sooner? I'd been doing insane things for a long time. There are a host of non-mystical reasons that light finally dawned, but there was also a definite inner shift. The biggest was probably, in very early recovery my 39-year-old brother died. I saw what it did to my parents.

I had always thought my life was my own. I had a right to run it into the ground. It came to me that I did not have sovereign control of my life. "I" had no right to kill "me." My life was not my own. Then whose was it?

At that time I was around AA, but that wasn't in any of the slogans. The first three steps kind of worked me rather than vice versa. I had a treatment assignment on "powerlessness," but it wasn't those earnest questions that sold me, it was another epiphany. I realized if I did use, I'd just want more, and there wouldn't be enough. I learned that indulging the craving made the craving worse. After using the old reward circuits would kick into gear and my judgment would falter. A real, internal experience of Step 1.

At another time in this early period I tried prayer, and I wasn't asking a sky daddy for miracles. I was trying to stop obsessing about something really scary that I couldn't fix. The prayer wrought changes in me, not the world at large. My fear lessened. It was kind of "doing the footwork" and letting go of the results.

Conveniently I had an actual higher power running my life, the county adult probation department. So turning my life and will over so it could restore me to sanity made perfect sense. I heard other people bitch about being on probation; I was actually relieved, grateful. I wasn't fighting circumstances.

All this to stay that the first 3 steps worked on me from within, independent of the Big Book or slogans. I wasn't going through contortions to make the words mean what I wanted them to; I just (fairly) suddenly grasped the truth beyond the words. Life was better if I didn't use, came to meetings and quit fighting this "ego" or whatever that for so long had been in the driver's seat. It didn't depend on supernatural agency; yet it depended on activating the "natural process of healing" and that was not something I willed to happen. I didn't wake up in the morning and say, "I've decided to activate the natural process of healing." I just sort of opened up to it.

Unfortunately, in AA during that repairing process you are told to “leave your brain at the door,” “your best thinking got you here,” and that “feelings aren’t fact,” which is essentially telling you to not trust you rational mind or your “gut instincts.”

C&E, I think you're not aware that those slogans, in context, support the "natural healing process," and also don't mean abdicating responsibility for yourself.

First of all, I rarely heard them, but when I did they made a certain amount of sense. "Feelings aren't fact," for example often refers to feeling like you need a drink and you are being told, you're not going to explode if you don't have one; the feeling will pass. "Leave your brain at the door" (which BTW I never heard) says, don't overthink this. Experience, listen, absorb. Switch off your running analysis of everybody and everything, be still and listen.

I don't think most people arrive at AA as blank slates unable to resist catchy slogans. Maybe some do. Most, I would wager, already have some experience of how distorted their thinking can be. People spout slogans that have helped them, it's not really a bid for mind control, it's people reminding themselves of what the slogan means to them. You can pick them apart, most people probably do and some fall out of favor. My theory is that 1940s "Mad Men" turned their newly sober brains to formulating slogans and ran amok.

As stated in the big book, and as many AAs would say, his close friend said “Why don’t you go try some controlled drinking?”

The book doesn't say "why don't you try some controlled drinking." It says "You can quickly diagnose yourself, step over to the nearest barroom and try some controlled drinking. Try it more than once ..." It's a last measure for breaking through denial of our "true condition." I shudder with revulsion when I hear it (at least I do clean; the somatic connection is tamped down at present) and I'll wager that those early AA cases did too. It's repulsive.

I don't know how your "true believer" friend managed to persuade himself that routine drinking to a blackout state was no longer adequate to diagnose his alcoholism, but despite the suggestion someone else planted - that blackouts were part of normal drinking - your friend convinced himself.

It sounds like he wanted an "out" from being a "real alcoholic," and was receptive to believing his blackout drinking was normal. I don't know why his "friend" floated that notion, then suggested he try some controlled drinking. To me it sounds absolutely vile. Demonic if you want to hear some religious language. Your friend is being played with, but it sounds like he really, really wants an excuse to try some controlled drinking.

I was merely pointing out one of many, many myths perpetuated in AA.

The "myths" change. The people change. Some myths die, others reveal themselves as quite creditable.


BTW, what you said about being uninsurable is true. Keep in mind almost all those rehabs use 12 step facilitation.

OK, serious challenge here: What does the second sentence have to do with anything? The insurance form asks if you've ever been treated for substance abuse, period. Twelve-step facilitation is irrelevant. AA isn't "treatment" in medical underwriting lingo - it doesn't generate financial claims.

Best of luck getting “clean”, but why do you feel you’re not “clean” when you are taking a prescribed medication as prescribed by a physician? Oh wait…

Thank you. I'm not sure what the "Oh wait" refers to. That I'm the victim of a myth? No.

I feel not clean because I don't feel clean. I don't mean filthy dirty, I'm not lying to get scripts or driving in blackouts. More like "tarnished": I was bright shiny silver and now a patina is obstructing that light. It shows on my face.

Someone else on my medication regimen might consider themselves clean and I wouldn't try to talk them out of it. Never. Ever.

I know which Rx's are doing this. From experience. Hint: It's not the antidepressant. It's 2 controlled substances to manage cravings. This is better than conning docs for scripts or committing five felonies before breakfast, but for me it is not clean, I don't want to spend the rest of my life addicted to these substances.
 
Last edited:
The issue is: why is it that AA members "believe" AA is effective but absolutely refuse to find out if it actually is. We have seen this taken to the extreme in this thread.

This is absurd. When my brother took his own life, I attended a suicide support group, it made me feel better. I didn't go home after the meetings and wonder to myself "hmmm I wonder if this works, maybe I should investigate it. :boggled:
 
I didn't go home after the meetings and wonder to myself "hmmm I wonder if this works, maybe I should investigate it. :boggled:

In fact you would be literally unable to investigate it properly. Having attended, you couldn't un-attend in order to observe the effects of non-attendance.

Back to AA: Was my slide caused by not going to meetings? I can't say for sure. There was a correlation.

I'm sorry you lost your brother and I hope you have found some peace around his memory.
 
Minoosh, what you are describing is simply the natural process of healing after prolonged excessive alcohol abuse. The mind and body start to heal and start to feel again. People want to reclaim their lives and that’s not exclusive to AA. There’s no mystery to that. Unfortunately, in AA during that repairing process you are told to “leave your brain at the door,” “your best thinking got you here,” and that “feelings aren’t fact,” which is essentially telling you to not trust you rational mind or your “gut instincts.”

And I would never, ever suggest that you, or anybody else who has had a problem, can safely drink, although some have actually found they can. It’s a complete diversion from the point I was making about myths, but I’m glad you brought it up.

I know this guy from around the web. He’s a real true believer in every single bit of AA, and a staunch defender of his faith. He makes a big deal of the distinction between “real alcoholics” and heavy drinkers on his blog. He recently encountered another true believer on the web who told him that blackouts are a natural consequence of drinking too much and can happen to anybody—that “real alcoholics” experience a phenomenon called “struck drunk.” He actually was thrown into an identity crisis, questioning whether or not he “qualifies” as a “real alcoholic.” I asked him what exactly it meant and he said he didn’t even know, but said that he’d only experienced blackouts almost every time he drank, but he’d never been “struck drunk.” When I visited his blog, what do you think was the very first comment from his long time follower and good friend? As stated in the big book, and as many AAs would say, his close friend said “Why don’t you go try some controlled drinking?” I really feel for the guy. I sincerely hope he didn’t take that suggestion.

I was merely pointing out one of many, many myths perpetuated in AA.

BTW, what you said about being uninsurable is true. Keep in mind almost all those rehabs use 12 step facilitation.

Best of luck getting “clean”, but why do you feel you’re not “clean” when you are taking a prescribed medication as prescribed by a physician? Oh wait…

C&E, I believe you have totally misunderstood what Mcgow (he posts here) was saying about Danny S (he posts here, also) comments on his blog concerning blackouts and being struck drunk. Mcgow wasn't legitimately questioning whether he was a alcoholic. He was a bit confounded by a post Danny S. put up and questioned it. I will tell ya many of us question Danny S's comments from time to time.
I can say this with much confidence Mcdog does not believe AA has myths.
What he does believe as I is your need C&E to circumvent posts for your own agenda. Tsk Tsk!!!!
 
Last edited:
<Slightly OT>

Been reading this thread off and on for a while - When did the
Thread topic change to add the "Efficacy ..." part?

Shouldn't that topic be split off into the Science or Social Issues forum?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom