Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
An aside, and it's not said in defense of AA:

In the U.S. any documented treatment for substance abuse can make you uninsurable.

Obama care sort of fixes this, if it lasts.

It's not just that they won't insure you for substance abuse; they won't insure you for anything.
 
Nutbag wrote:



"Rarely have we seen a person fail who has throughly followed our path."
That doesn't sound like a "cure all" statement to me.




Was there supposed to be Doctors reports , longitudinal studies ect....
Nutt your inability to be totally honest here is a bummer. You know AA and what it offers. Stop trying to act like it is something else just so you can criticize it.




Oh!!! There is the drama.
Can you cite anything but your own anecdotal evidence?
I didn't think so.



Nutt, is that what you did while you were in AA. Because you are right there are some folks who do say those things. Most members I know do not. If I had a friend who was struggling I would suggest he go to detox and then get some in house treatment. If AA was not working then the suggestions become slim frankly, depending upon where you live. Most addicts and alcoholics I know are down and out so having a computer isn't always handy. But if they can get to a library, college ect...they can probably hook up with a online group other then AA.
Please stop acting like all these other possibilities aside from AA are tested, studied and have been science based proven. if you had a problem with alcohol then you know damn well all the solutions out there are not providing great results.


That's a load of bull.



Was this your story Nutt. Is this what you perceived to have happened to you.
People in AA are conspiring together to prevent people from getting the help they need. That we hold down alcoholics that want to move on and see if another program works.
That we are so threaten by other avenues that we would participate in the killing (through suicide) of members just to see them not leave.
What in gods name is wrong with you.




I guess we as members don't count. I have been clean and sober for almost 26 years with the help of AA/NA. I have moved on but I still practice the valuable principles I learned.



Do all the other programs have such studies done on there effectiveness.
Since you are so brilliant and you seem to have immense experience in working with alcoholics, please do share your current plan of helping people who abuse alcohol. Also would you be able to stop working at your job today and show us how effective your plan would work.
Everyone here I have noticed that knocks AA have all these bright ideas but not one of you work with or support people who are struggling with alcohol or drugs. It just sounds like you are telling us your story but embellishing it bit to include more members.
Just wondering???

While I appreciate the snarky tone of your post, you still have yet to actually provide evidence that AA works. As the Norseman said, the null hypothesis is that AA provides no better outcome than no treatment at all, and the organization has not conducted such a study. The few studies available show outcomes identical to no treatment, and until better studies are done, we should not attribute any effect to AA.

As I said earlier, my experience in AA was actually relatively positive. There were some nutters here and there but most of the people were decent human beings attempting to improve themselves, and I totally respect that. I still speak to my old sponsor on a near daily basis and have tremendous respect for him as a person. I dont think AA members conspire to drown out other options, but there is no doubt that the organization as a whole is inadequately self critical and so dominant in the field of treatment as to crowd out funding of other methods and awareness of other programs that at least operate within the framework of good medical practice. The idea that the 12-steps work as they claim to work is simply laughable, and since there's been no evidence produced that they do work, it's best to make no assumptions about the efficacy. The fact that millions of people worldwide think that AA helped them simply doesn't matter. Far more believe that they have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ, or that homeopathic remedies helped an ailment, or any other whacky claim. The fact that someone believes a treatment was effective is in no way indicative that the treatment actually had any effect. I'm only criticizing AA because I see it failing people, and some of these people have died because they did not have access to effective treatment. As someone who realizes how the modern scientific method has revolutionized medicine, I find it simply inexcusable that the largest alcohol treatment program has failed to incorporate these advances into the program.

I was lucky and was able to attend a program in addition to AA that was self critical and constantly reviewed its practices. Whether it was my own motivation, that program, or AA that ultimately made the difference is a question I simply cannot answer, but I feel much more comfortable operating within a rational framework than one founded quite literally upon revelation. If you don't, that's fine, but the idea that such an organization has dominated the treatment field for so long should be disturbing to anyone who really wants to provide good treatment to alcoholics.
 
And a quick follow-up to my last post. AA can conduct a study about its efficacy any time it pleases. If it were truly concerned (as an organization) about providing the best possible treatment, it would do so. The traditions are simply that, and if they prevent such a study as currently written (though I don't think they do), they should be scrapped. If the real goal is helping as many people as possible, then there is no excusable reason for failing to see how they are performing as an organization and making any necessary adjustments to improve the program.
 
AA meetings often hold socials/dances and because the people attending the events are dry which means underage kids can get in. That is exactly how my former sister-in-law met her 34yo husband when she was 15 ... She was pregnant by 16 and married to the abusive asshat before turning 17.

Agreed, these cases occur in all kinds of social situations. Especially in the home.

The most common place for sexual violence to occur is in a person's home and
Alcohol or drugs increase a person's vulnerability to sexual assault
http://http://www.ywcabergencounty.org/programs/rape_crisis.html

You'd like to think a 15-year-old would be safer at home but you'd be wrong. She's also safer sober BTW.

The clubs probably ought to have age restrictions; I imagine a lot of them do. Shall we research that or just make it up?


The fact is, AA makes it easy because of the pecking order involved. Adults are superior to children

And you believe this. Good God. Please provide evidence.

I wouldn't turn my 15-year-old daughter loose at an AA dance, but she'd apparently be safer from Daddy there.

Thank you, you're motivating me to go back to AA and keep an eye on people like your brother-in-law.

My brother-in-law comes home from his weekly Saturday meeting and tells me all about any new woman who attends and the number of old timers who are all over her.

He sounds like a real champ. Definitely I'd trust whatever he said.
 
And a quick follow-up to my last post. AA can conduct a study about its efficacy any time it pleases. If it were truly concerned (as an organization) about providing the best possible treatment, it would do so.

It's concerned about serving a network of loosely connected, largely autonomous groups and staying as accessible as possible. The "best possible treatment" would probably be more along the lines of what Joey suggests and it would cost thousands of dollars per patient. Please show me what you think AA's study should look like. No one's been able to do it yet.

... If the real goal is helping as many people as possible...

That's not the real goal. Bill tried that at first, 4 out of 5 "rummies" weren't terribly interested. It's about being there for people who want it. You obviously don't.

Did it help you at all, do you think?
 
The idea that the 12-steps work as they claim to work is simply laughable, and since there's been no evidence produced that they do work, it's best to make no assumptions about the efficacy.

I get it what you're saying, that there's no evidence AA helps anyone, and that's inaccurate. If you want to attack the steps have at it and I assume you'd include the secular version. Can you think of any way to do it except to require some people to work the steps and forbid others from doing so? AA's there for every alcoholic who wants it. It's not going to forbid people from working the steps. So, design away, you claim it can easily be done.

The fact that millions of people worldwide think that AA helped them simply doesn't matter.

Those poor deluded fools. But I wasn't talking about anecdotes.

I find it simply inexcusable that the largest alcohol treatment program has failed to incorporate these advances into the program.

Which advances? And what would that look like?

The fact that the U.S. relies on a free program that takes no government money to be its "largest alcohol treatment program" is unnerving, I admit. I mean, all they do is read a little bit, drink coffee and sit around talking. Shouldn't the largest program be run by NIH, or Kaiser or something? A big teaching hospital? A foundation? I wonder why they haven't stepped up.

I was lucky and was able to attend a program in addition to AA that was self critical and constantly reviewed its practices.

I'd like to hear more about this program, its success rate and how it constantly improved its practices.

The sincere people in AA are - ideally - also are self-critical and constantly reviewing their practices. It's part of the program. AA is the people in it, not the general service board. Some if most have been involved in treatment facilities or groups.

Take the smoking example, as second-hand worries grew most meetings became nonsmoking. The AA organism changed to meet conditions on the ground. It will keep doing so.

But a drop-in center where you put a buck in a basket is not responsible for transforming the U.S. behavioral health care system.

but the idea that such an organization has dominated the treatment field for so long should be disturbing to anyone who really wants to provide good treatment to alcoholics.

Cost nothing, doesn't charge, doesn't advertise and has somehow hopelessly damaged all those other proven treatments out there.

Someone ought to step up to fix this. Congress, maybe.
 
I hadn't noticed this either. I think this needs an explanation. Who petitioned for this and what was the rationale behind accepting it? As everyone can see, it is the technique of some to try and talk about "efficacy" instead of the problems stemming from the religious/cult nature of the program, as if that somehow excuses the iatrogenic problems with the program cult. These problems wouldn't occur (as often, or without a way to report/seek justice) in a secular, evidence-based, professionally run program. Thanks Paul Cleary wherever you are. (oh wait he's at Yale?) is that the same guy? Sheesh. If there was a way to show that SMART and AA had the exact same efficacy results (see this post for how I think it treatment should happen in real life) , you'd still have all your work ahead of you apologizing for the harm that goes on because of the structure of AA!

It's pretty obvious to everyone that there is a perfectly rational explanation why there is not a Cochrane review for SMART yet. AA started in the 30s and has crept into the court system and beyond. It doesn't matter, we are talking about "What's the harm?" here, in light of the OP.

Yes, I didn't have time earlier to mention this part, but I agree; I think combining evidence for and against AA as well as evidence for and against other treatments in this thread is going to kill it. It's already a muddled mess trying to keep on topic as it is. At this point, it's become too easy for AA proponents to obfuscate and dodge the issue of AA's own inefficacies by trying to drag into the mix other (perhaps) more effective treatment modalities.
 
Yes, I didn't have time earlier to mention this part, but I agree; I think combining evidence for and against AA as well as evidence for and against other treatments in this thread is going to kill it. It's already a muddled mess trying to keep on topic as it is. At this point, it's become too easy for AA proponents to obfuscate and dodge the issue of AA's own inefficacies by trying to drag into the mix other (perhaps) more effective treatment modalities.

I may be wrong but I seem to recall the "addition" being made about the time we went to moderation (maybe before we did). That was some time ago and compaining about it now seems a little strange to say the least.

There is ample room for discussion on a number of fronts here.

Many of us would love to learn of these "science" or "evidence based" systems that work; but as yet actual evidence has been lacking despite the screams of their existence.
 
I may be wrong but I seem to recall the "addition" being made about the time we went to moderation (maybe before we did). That was some time ago and compaining about it now seems a little strange to say the least.


No. The change was to "Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA"

The "...& other treatment programs" is a more recent addition and will still be a mistake conflating them all here in this thread, especially in the Religion and Philosophy subforum. Medical science as pertaining to addiction more properly belongs in MST.


Many of us would love to learn of these "science" or "evidence based" systems that work; but as yet actual evidence has been lacking despite the screams of their existence.

Screams? Oh, please.

Any 'insightful', specific, thoughtful comments you'd like to make regarding the studies that have been presented? Have you found any for the edification of the rest of us?
 
I am going to ask you to please be fair. Just because you happen to like Stinkin Thinkin and refuse to see the harm they brought to many, that is not my problem. It was a hate group.
Nut was very direct and so was I.
Norseman knock it off. Every time you don't like a post it is attacking. Let the members I am conversing with comment.
AA is personal for us maybe you can cavalierly talk about it but at times when you folks are being dramatic it can be a bit much.
People lives are at stake here at times.

I am fair, Danny. Instead of just reporting it to the mods, I thought I'd remind you that you made what appeared to be a personal attack against another forum member.

Also you are personalizing this discussion by bringing in a (in this case) completely mistaken and irrelevant item by stating that I "like Stinkin' Thinkin'" website when I've never made any comment about it in my life that I can remember. I am not the only one you do this with, either. Ultimately, it doesn't matter excepting the fact that it detracts from what I believe you wish to say.



Every time you don't like a post it is attacking.

You are mistaken. So if this is the case, evidence please?
 
Still waiting for the studies that demonstrate 'science-based medicine' actually helps anyone, ever. :( ;)

Don't hold your breath. :)


Listen lets get something straight right here and now Stinkin Thinkibn was not a great blog. It attacked, stalked, abused, harassed and outright dehumanized people all across this country.
Mark and Illse were the most vindictive hateful people I have ever met.
Though I don't agree with death threats or anything like that. I do know it was a matter of time. You can only publish people's names, addresses, pictures, ISP addresses ect... for so long and not get retaliation. They put so many people in danger by posting their personal information I can't count.
So please take your whoa is me for those two disgusting people and run it on soem other blog.
Many members know Mark and Ellse here and have been the subject of their ridicule.
Like I said I in no way condone nor am I happy to know Ellse and her family were subjected to this kind of abuse.
But they went after people using their blog and in a very cruel way and abused and attacked them.
I say good riddance.
I am not bashing I am telling the truth, what I said are facts. Plus she was owner of a blog so don't tell me the same rules apply.
You brought it up, you opened the door and you wanted to say something positive without letting the other side say anything. Nice try.

No kidding that site was infested with raging hypocrites.

Stinkin Thinkin is a hate group.

Yep, I'm glad the cowards that attacked you no longer have a forum to spew their hate. Unfortunately it seems a few have made their way here. At least they won't be allowed to get away with same sort of nonsense on this site.

What are you talking about, Norseman. I am lost, really.

Me too.

Then why are you reading it???:boggled:

What do they call people who just put random negative comments into forums? I forget.

You mean people whose sole purpose for signing up at JREF is to fabricate nonsense about AA?

They used to congregate at another forum, can you guess which one? ;)
 
Don't hold your breath. :)

I've been here a while now, I'd be long dead if I had been. ;)

Yep, I'm glad the cowards that attacked you no longer have a forum to spew their hate.

I didn't mind, after all they gave me a great nickname: Iron Man Alfie. Ta da!
But you are right about cowardice, when I responded with better than they could give, they had to shut me down.

Unfortunately it seems a few have made their way here. At least they won't be allowed to get away with same sort of nonsense on this site.

Bring it on I say; they are at the grown ups table here. :)

That said, if true, I do not condone any threats made against them. However they played a very hard and insulting game - one with all the hallmarks of a hate group; it could be argued that they brought much of what they got on themselves.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I didn't have time earlier to mention this part, but I agree; I think combining evidence for and against AA as well as evidence for and against other treatments in this thread is going to kill it. It's already a muddled mess trying to keep on topic as it is. At this point, it's become too easy for AA proponents to obfuscate and dodge the issue of AA's own inefficacies by trying to drag into the mix other (perhaps) more effective treatment modalities.
Agreed that the null hypothesis for AA, or any other, treatment modality should be 'does not help'; stats just don't support help over and above doing nothing (other than getting older, and perhaps, wiser).

I think this thread is the perfect place to provide any study that demonstrates some modality actually working.


No. The change was to "Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA"

The "...& other treatment programs" is a more recent addition and will still be a mistake conflating them all here in this thread, especially in the Religion and Philosophy subforum. Medical science as pertaining to addiction more properly belongs in MST.
Perhaps, although any evidence medical science has actually helped would be nice, and so far, not forthcoming.
 
Last edited:
At this point, it's become too easy for AA proponents to obfuscate and dodge the issue of AA's own inefficacies by trying to drag into the mix other (perhaps) more effective treatment modalities.

When people state that AA doesn't work I believe it's perfectly legitimate to address whether anything works in the same forum. I want the evidence for other treatments put forth, not to defend AA but so that any random person happening on this thread will see evidence about these other programs.

Grandiose of me.
 
While I appreciate the snarky tone of your post, you still have yet to actually provide evidence that AA works. As the Norseman said, the null hypothesis is that AA provides no better outcome than no treatment at all, and the organization has not conducted such a study. The few studies available show outcomes identical to no treatment, and until better studies are done, we should not attribute any effect to AA.

As I said earlier, my experience in AA was actually relatively positive. There were some nutters here and there but most of the people were decent human beings attempting to improve themselves, and I totally respect that. I still speak to my old sponsor on a near daily basis and have tremendous respect for him as a person. I dont think AA members conspire to drown out other options, but there is no doubt that the organization as a whole is inadequately self critical and so dominant in the field of treatment as to crowd out funding of other methods and awareness of other programs that at least operate within the framework of good medical practice. The idea that the 12-steps work as they claim to work is simply laughable, and since there's been no evidence produced that they do work, it's best to make no assumptions about the efficacy. The fact that millions of people worldwide think that AA helped them simply doesn't matter. Far more believe that they have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ, or that homeopathic remedies helped an ailment, or any other whacky claim. The fact that someone believes a treatment was effective is in no way indicative that the treatment actually had any effect. I'm only criticizing AA because I see it failing people, and some of these people have died because they did not have access to effective treatment. As someone who realizes how the modern scientific method has revolutionized medicine, I find it simply inexcusable that the largest alcohol treatment program has failed to incorporate these advances into the program.

I was lucky and was able to attend a program in addition to AA that was self critical and constantly reviewed its practices. Whether it was my own motivation, that program, or AA that ultimately made the difference is a question I simply cannot answer, but I feel much more comfortable operating within a rational framework than one founded quite literally upon revelation. If you don't, that's fine, but the idea that such an organization has dominated the treatment field for so long should be disturbing to anyone who really wants to provide good treatment to alcoholics.

One thing I have noticed the anti-AA'ers never seem to see their snarkyness.
If your experience was so positive and you are still talking with your sponsor daily then why would you say AA is killing people. If I had been with a organization that I knew was killing people then I would not want anything to do with anybody there. Nutt, these are your words I am using.
My problem is when you start throwing around statements like "AA is killing people and many at that". Then you say "but ya I had really a positive time while I was there".
It is confusing.
I went through a residential treatment program in Maine back in 1975. There model for treating young adults was so barbaric, dehumanizing ect...that many committed suicide during and after they left. So I know what it is like to have someone try to brainwash me and be in a cult with no way out. I have nothing to do with any of the staff that abused us.
You keep pounding away at this efficacy point like it really is supposed to mean something. AA should have longitudinal studies, be tested and they should go out and make AA'ers submit to random tests.
I just laugh my butt off because AA has worked for 70 years and is still working, I don't why and you don't know why and Nutt it is just killing you that this is a fact. You can not deny 1 million people (which is a conservative number in the USA) and call them all dummies.
AA is simple, the steps appeal to ones good self and asks if you want to become a better person, if so this is how we did it. Not this is the only way but "This Is How We Did It".
There are at least 7 members of JREF's right here that are AA folks posting on this thread and about the same number Anti-AA posting. So what does that tell you Nutt. You and I are not alone and we both matter, equally. :)
Concerning critical thinking, I didn't need a program to teach me this or guide me I had plenty of good healthy friends in AA and out that were critical thinkers. Still have the same friends. AA people have been some of the most critical thinkers I have known. This is why according to my experiences many go on to have successful lives. We demanded excellence from one another.
As far as showing you evidence that AA does help people look at you and I. We are clean and sober today. Yes your time in AA did have something to do with that. Remember AA is only part of the treatment plan.
 
Last edited:
I am fair, Danny. Instead of just reporting it to the mods, I thought I'd remind you that you made what appeared to be a personal attack against another forum member.

Also you are personalizing this discussion by bringing in a (in this case) completely mistaken and irrelevant item by stating that I "like Stinkin' Thinkin'" website when I've never made any comment about it in my life that I can remember. I am not the only one you do this with, either. Ultimately, it doesn't matter excepting the fact that it detracts from what I believe you wish to say.

You are mistaken. So if this is the case, evidence please?

Norseman,
Please read above. My answer to your post is within the lines above.
 
Last edited:
When people state that AA doesn't work I believe it's perfectly legitimate to address whether anything works in the same forum.

How is it legitimate? How does the effectiveness of another program make any difference to the effectiveness of AA? Discussion of other methods has zero bearing on whether AA is effective or not and it is a logical fallacy to say "Well, you might as well go to AA because none of the others work either."
 
The "...& other treatment programs" is a more recent addition and will still be a mistake conflating them all here in this thread, especially in the Religion and Philosophy subforum. Medical science as pertaining to addiction more properly belongs in MST.


How is it legitimate? How does the effectiveness of another program make any difference to the effectiveness of AA? Discussion of other methods has zero bearing on whether AA is effective or not and it is a logical fallacy to say "Well, you might as well go to AA because none of the others work either."

Maybe you should have a talk with 8den, Jack Astor, Poster Nutbag, Joey McGee and their friends from Stinkin Thinkin, they were the first people to mention those other treatments and when they were asked to back up their claims, they ran away.
 
Maybe you should have a talk with 8den, Jack Astor, Poster Nutbag, Joey McGee and their friends from Stinkin Thinkin, they were the first people to mention those other treatments and when they were asked to back up their claims, they ran away.

Indeed. Even in the forum's home page they actually made claims about science and/or medically based therapies. When questioned on this and further challenged they had nothing except bile and hate. Sadly for them, it is their lack of critical thinking and exploration that was exposed.

Stinkin thinkin was no more than a hate group that served little purpose except for sick people to vent their common spleens.


In order to compare apples with apples, I would ask all the ST ex forum members (and others) to support their claims and show us which treatments they think work, what methodologies are used and what the efficacy rates are.

I don't think it too much to ask and time to stump up methinks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom