While I appreciate the snarky tone of your post, you still have yet to actually provide evidence that AA works. As the Norseman said, the null hypothesis is that AA provides no better outcome than no treatment at all, and the organization has not conducted such a study. The few studies available show outcomes identical to no treatment, and until better studies are done, we should not attribute any effect to AA.
As I said earlier, my experience in AA was actually relatively positive. There were some nutters here and there but most of the people were decent human beings attempting to improve themselves, and I totally respect that. I still speak to my old sponsor on a near daily basis and have tremendous respect for him as a person. I dont think AA members conspire to drown out other options, but there is no doubt that the organization as a whole is inadequately self critical and so dominant in the field of treatment as to crowd out funding of other methods and awareness of other programs that at least operate within the framework of good medical practice. The idea that the 12-steps work as they claim to work is simply laughable, and since there's been no evidence produced that they do work, it's best to make no assumptions about the efficacy. The fact that millions of people worldwide think that AA helped them simply doesn't matter. Far more believe that they have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ, or that homeopathic remedies helped an ailment, or any other whacky claim. The fact that someone believes a treatment was effective is in no way indicative that the treatment actually had any effect. I'm only criticizing AA because I see it failing people, and some of these people have died because they did not have access to effective treatment. As someone who realizes how the modern scientific method has revolutionized medicine, I find it simply inexcusable that the largest alcohol treatment program has failed to incorporate these advances into the program.
I was lucky and was able to attend a program in addition to AA that was self critical and constantly reviewed its practices. Whether it was my own motivation, that program, or AA that ultimately made the difference is a question I simply cannot answer, but I feel much more comfortable operating within a rational framework than one founded quite literally upon revelation. If you don't, that's fine, but the idea that such an organization has dominated the treatment field for so long should be disturbing to anyone who really wants to provide good treatment to alcoholics.
One thing I have noticed the anti-AA'ers never seem to see their snarkyness.
If your experience was so positive and you are still talking with your sponsor daily then why would you say AA is killing people. If I had been with a organization that I knew was killing people then I would not want anything to do with anybody there. Nutt, these are your words I am using.
My problem is when you start throwing around statements like "AA is killing people and many at that". Then you say "but ya I had really a positive time while I was there".
It is confusing.
I went through a residential treatment program in Maine back in 1975. There model for treating young adults was so barbaric, dehumanizing ect...that many committed suicide during and after they left. So I know what it is like to have someone try to brainwash me and be in a cult with no way out. I have nothing to do with any of the staff that abused us.
You keep pounding away at this efficacy point like it really is supposed to mean something. AA should have longitudinal studies, be tested and they should go out and make AA'ers submit to random tests.
I just laugh my butt off because AA has worked for 70 years and is still working, I don't why and you don't know why and Nutt it is just killing you that this is a fact. You can not deny 1 million people (which is a conservative number in the USA) and call them all dummies.
AA is simple, the steps appeal to ones good self and asks if you want to become a better person, if so this is how we did it. Not this is the only way but "This Is How We Did It".
There are at least 7 members of JREF's right here that are AA folks posting on this thread and about the same number Anti-AA posting. So what does that tell you Nutt. You and I are not alone and we both matter, equally.

Concerning critical thinking, I didn't need a program to teach me this or guide me I had plenty of good healthy friends in AA and out that were critical thinkers. Still have the same friends. AA people have been some of the most critical thinkers I have known. This is why according to my experiences many go on to have successful lives. We demanded excellence from one another.
As far as showing you evidence that AA does help people look at you and I. We are clean and sober today. Yes your time in AA did have something to do with that. Remember AA is only part of the treatment plan.