You're moving the goalposts.
I'm fine with moving the goalposts. I'm trying to get them back to where they belong; notably, AA has made claims of success in dealing with addiction and alcoholism. That is undeniable.
The problem I see is that AA wants to eat it's cake and have it too -- it's protagonists want it to be successful and valuable for suffering addicts, yet steadfastly refuse to actually test the claims or try to improve the program in any way. They just come up with non-program stuff as a work around. Why would that be, I wonder?
I just don't get it. An AAer, for example, doesn't really like the sixth step and so doesn't do it. They use a saying that was never part of the original program ("take what you want and leave the rest") to justify not doing it, yet feel proud that they're 'working the steps'.
AA has obviously helped someone at some time.
If you were drinking regularly and the only thing in your life that changed was the fact you began AA meetings it had to of have some effect.
The point is that we really don't know that AA has any positive effect at all; if there is a positive effect, is it realistic to attribute it to AA rather than the efforts of the person themselves outside of any self-help group attendance? We don't know yet.
Again, as I said in an earlier post, I will be the first one to say to others, "hey, go to AA. I don't like it because of it's religious orientation, but I've read all the studies that confirm that it's really helpful for coping with addiction."
The problem is that there are no studies that show what I just said. And to forestall any criticism of CBT or related therapy, a new thread should be started so that that program can be discussed with more thoroughness than can be done in this thread.
Personally I had tried various other methods to quit drinking, they didn't work.
One included psychotherapy, can I now claim it doesn't work?
Sure, based on one survey's conclusions. But 'psychotherapy' is a HUGE FIELD that covers quite a wide area of differing treatment modalities; one does not even have to have any professional degrees or training to call oneself a psychotherapist. Usually the studies will define what they mean by using certain terminology which can lead a meta-analyst into making a more fair comparison.
The fact is measuring to what degree AA helps will be always be difficult, by the very nature of the program and even it's detractors admit there haven't been any good studies on it's effectiveness, so throwing out the 5% canard is a little dishonest.
It's not a canard. It's a baseline that every study that I've seen, reports. In any population of alcoholics studied, ~5% of them recover without doing anything. (In this case, I sure wish Linda were still around because she can explain in greater detail since that's her profession.)
It'd be like trying to find out if local Drop-In centers made teenagers better students. You have kids coming and going for various lengths of time, but if they spent 5 minutes at the center reading I'm sure it helped their studies if only in a small way.
And why are you sure of this? There are many things that happen which are counter-intuitive yet remain true. One example that I can think of is that some children were studied on the amount of homework they had versus scores on standardized tests. Before a certain age (twelve, I think), it was found that homework was useless in producing long-term improvement in scores. They just weren't developed enough to take advantage of long hours of studying at home.
So in other words, we can certainly study these kinds of things and more. Alcoholics are no different in that regard, as I've said many times now.
If we look at self-help groups in the areas of cancer, arthritis, depression,etc.
no they don't cure the disease, but they help cope with it. Most any medical professional will tell you that.
Great examples, PBS! Yes, they can be effective for many people in coping with their disease. Do these cancer self-help groups work the 12-steps? Do arthritis sufferers proclaim their powerlessness over arthritis every day? How does a person with major depression 'relapse'? Does a woman with cancer need to take her own inventory or caused her family and friends emotional distress due to her trips to chemotherapy that she should make amends for?
If these people find comfort, solace, and a new outlet for living with these difficult conditions, what is it that helps them? Is it the 12 steps? If not, why not?