Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
In looking up the infamous Clancy - due to a probably unhealthy degree of interest in Joey's worldview - I found an article by Clancy Martin, a philosophy prof at the University of Missouri.

The drunk's club: A.A., the cult that cures

http://hivdatf.files.wordpress.com/2010/12/harpersmagazine-2011-01-0083250.pdf

It touches on a lot of stuff mentioned here including various psych meds, anonymity, entrenched attitudes, multigenerational AA - it's really well done.

Bill W. describing his own
first couple of drinks at a party in
1917, at age twenty-two:
Well, my self-consciousness was such
that I simply had to take that drink. So
I took it, and another, and then, lo, the
miracle! That strange barrier that had
existed between me and all men and
women seemed to instantly go down. I
felt that I belonged where I was, belonged
to life; I belonged to the universe;
I was a part of things at last. Oh,
the magic of those first three or four
drinks! I became the life of the party. I
actually could please the guests; I could
talk freely, volubly; I could talk well.

Resonates for me; I suspect it means nothing to social drinkers, that is, non-alcoholics who are apparently 'born-that-way'.
 
Last edited:
As quoted by Al Bell:

"I was a part of things at last. Oh,
the magic of those first three or four
drinks! I became the life of the party. I
actually could please the guests; I could
talk freely, volubly; I could talk well."
- Bill Wilson

The problem with that kind of overwhelming pleasure is that as long as the substance-based "fix" works, there's little motivation to cultivate life's smaller pleasures.

To battle cravings, science can develop drugs without highs, but the complementary practice - developing highs without drugs - is a more individual process that for me required letting go of the instant fix. Otherwise my brain couldn't effectively recalibrate itself.

I've got mixed feelings about where antidepressants fit in all of this. They don't seem to do much for me. Being honest with a doctor and taking drugs as prescribed can be absolutely compatible with a 12-step process. But if you start trying to manipulate the doc, or doubling up on the anti-anxiety meds, you're back in the shame spiral, or at least I would be.
 
Claiming AA helped someone, or someone claiming AA helped them, does not mean AA did help. There has been no evidence provided to show that AA helped anybody . . . ever.
I don't understand willful ignorance of the sort you display here.

My cousin was helped by that program. This he told me. He is still sober. He has no motive to lie. You, however, seem to have a motive to attempt to insinuate and lie about my cousin.

I don't understand why you try to play this game.

Pay attention. It can help, and it can also NOT help. Go back to my post and read, particularly digesting the concept of having more than one tool in your kit to fix problems.

Why would you limit your options? Is that a companion to your demonstration of willful ignorance? Do you believe you can min max your way out of substance abuse and addiction?
 
I don't understand willful ignorance of the sort you display here.

This should be good.

My cousin was helped by that program.

What's your evidence?

This he told me.

Oh, just like people will tell you homeopathy cured them. Pretty weak evidence.

He is still sober. He has no motive to lie.

One does not need to lie in order to be wrong.

You, however, seem to have a motive to attempt to insinuate and lie about my cousin.

I lied about your cousin? Sorry, you lost me. I didn't even know your cousin was an alcoholic, how could I lie about them?

I don't understand why you try to play this game.

What game is that, the "Do you have any evidence to back up your claims" game?

Pay attention. It can help, and it can also NOT help.

Evidence please. And the opposite of help is not "not help." The opposite would be "harm." We have seen the evidence showing AA harms people, we haven't seem any to suggest it helps people recover from alcohol addiction.

Go back to my post and read, particularly digesting the concept of having more than one tool in your kit to fix problems.

Speaking as someone who works with tools everyday and has $40,000.00 worth sitting in a toolbox at work, I can tell you that having a tool that doesn't work will not fix any problems.

Why would you limit your options? Is that a companion to your demonstration of willful ignorance? Do you believe you can min max your way out of substance abuse and addiction?

There is no evidence to show that AA is an option. Your argument is simply a variation of Pascal's Wager.
 
This should be good.


Yes it should.



What's your evidence?


Where's yours?



Oh, just like people will tell you homeopathy cured them. Pretty weak evidence.


Well I guess these groups might as well close their doors too.



One does not need to lie in order to be wrong.


No kidding.



I lied about your cousin? Sorry, you lost me. I didn't even know your cousin was an alcoholic, how could I lie about them?


His cousin drank alcoholically, went to AA and professes it helps him stay sober, you claim that isn't true, so is he lying?


What game is that, the "Do you have any evidence to back up your claims" game?


Well since you haven't presented any yourself, I reckon it would be a pretty short game.


Evidence please. And the opposite of help is not "not help." The opposite would be "harm." We have seen the evidence showing AA harms people, we haven't seem any to suggest it helps people recover from alcohol addiction.


Nonsense. Using that criteria, we should ban policing, teaching and medicine because some people in those fields have been caught abusing someone.


Speaking as someone who works with tools everyday and has $40,000.00 worth sitting in a toolbox at work, I can tell you that having a tool that doesn't work will not fix any problems.


Well when you can prove it has never helped anyone you might have a point.

Go find some evidence I'll wait.


There is no evidence to show that AA is an option. Your argument is simply a variation of Pascal's Wager


I guess the people in this thread claiming AA has helped them must be mistaken. :rolleyes:

These people too:

http://blogs.suntimes.com/ebert/2009/08/my_name_is_roger_and_im_an_alc.html

http://www.lapbc.com/successstories.htm

http://www.e-aa.org/forum/viewforum.php?f=36&sid=9e724cb3996bb9658b8c5aa417e03d28

There's tons more, but why bother, it seems you've already made-up your mind, I guess we should just send out a memo to all self help groups around the world, that until they can prove to qayak they help people, they might as well close down. :rolleyes:
 
One argument on here, in a nutshell:

If someone believes they have been helped by AA, their belief is meaningless.

If someone believes they've been harmed by AA, their belief is proof.

Being unhappy with AA because it's not a moderation program is understandable I suppose but why would you think it was? Some people are better off abstaining, and a lot of them figure that out by trying to moderate.
 
One argument on here, in a nutshell:

If someone believes they have been helped by AA, their belief is meaningless.

If someone believes they've been harmed by AA, their belief is proof

Not quite. A better summation would be: The evidence for AA suggests that it has little, or no, benefit and is actually capable of having a detrimental impact on people.

The claim that AA has little, or no, benefit is supported by the fact that attendance has the same success ratio as non-attendance.

The claim that it is detrimental is born out by the fact that AA uses methods that are known to be detrimental to people no matter what organization uses them.
 
His cousin drank alcoholically, went to AA and professes it helps him stay sober, you claim that isn't true, so is he lying?

He could be but I never said that. I simply said there are other more likely explanations but, based on the success rate of AA, he is most likely in error.

Well when you can prove it has never helped anyone you might have a point.

Negative proof fallacy. How about you prove it has helped someone.

I guess the people in this thread claiming AA has helped them must be mistaken. :rolleyes:

These people too:


There's tons more, but why bother, it seems you've already made-up your mind, I guess we should just send out a memo to all self help groups around the world, that until they can prove to qayak they help people, they might as well close down. :rolleyes:

One would think that on a skeptic list you would be able to recognize simple logical fallacies. For instance the one you commit above. I'll give you a hint, millions upon millions of Chinese people believed Chinese traditional medicine was effective. However, Chinese traditional medicine has failed every time it has been put to the test. It has failed so badly that millions upon millions of Chinese people now go to doctors practicing Western medicine. Why? Because Western medicine has proven to be very effective against disease.

(Unless you honestly think that CTM was effective until people stopped believing in it.) :rolleyes:

That a lot of people believe something to be true doesn't make it so. The evidence supports Western medicine not CTM just like it supports AA having no effect on alcoholism.
 
Last edited:
He could be but I never said that. I simply said there are other more likely explanations but, based on the success rate of AA, he is most likely in error.



Negative proof fallacy. How about you prove it has helped someone.



One would think that on a skeptic list you would be able to recognize simple logical fallacies. For instance the one you commit above. I'll give you a hint, millions upon millions of Chinese people believed Chinese traditional medicine was effective. However, Chinese traditional medicine has failed every time it has been put to the test. It has failed so badly that millions upon millions of Chinese people now go to doctors practicing Western medicine. Why? Because Western medicine has proven to be very effective against disease.

(Unless you honestly think that CTM was effective until people stopped believing in it.) :rolleyes:

That a lot of people believe something to be true doesn't make it so. The evidence supports Western medicine not CTM just like it supports AA having no effect on alcoholism.

I guess you have no evidence then?

As for mine, if I use the same criteria you do to claim AA harms people, I have boatloads. Your hypocrisy is showing.

Do you think "Western medicine" believes self-help groups don't help anyone?
 
I guess you have no evidence then?

As for mine, if I use the same criteria you do to claim AA harms people, I have boatloads. Your hypocrisy is showing.

Do you think "Western medicine" believes self-help groups don't help anyone?

Oh, sigh. That's not how it works.

AA has made claims of (sometimes) great efficacy since day one. The null hypothesis is that AA is no more effective than chance; because this is the case as it stands, please present evidence which disproves the null hypothesis and we can go from there.
 
5% get well using AA
5% get well by just stopping.
x% get well using psychology
x% get well using other self help groups.
x% via the sinclair method
x% here, x% there.

We need every one of them because they all work for those they work for.
 
5% get well using AA
5% get well by just stopping.
x% get well using psychology
x% get well using other self help groups.
x% via the sinclair method
x% here, x% there.

We need every one of them because they all work for those they work for.

Me thinks you don't understand statistics. If there is a five percent spontaneous remission in a population, the fact that there is a 5% remission in AA members means AA has no effect. All the people who stop drinking in AA would have stopped without it.
 
i guess you have no evidence then?

As for mine, if i use the same criteria you do to claim aa harms people, i have boatloads. Your hypocrisy is showing.

Do you think "western medicine" believes self-help groups don't help anyone?

the norseman said:
oh, sigh. That's not how it works.

Aa has made claims of (sometimes) great efficacy since day one. The null hypothesis is that aa is no more effective than chance; because this is the case as it stands, please present evidence which disproves the null hypothesis and we can go from there.

^^^this^^^
 
5% get well using AA
5% get well by just stopping.
x% get well using psychology
x% get well using other self help groups.
x% via the sinclair method
x% here, x% there.

We need every one of them because they all work for those they work for.

Me thinks you don't understand statistics. If there is a five percent spontaneous remission in a population, the fact that there is a 5% remission in AA members means AA has no effect. All the people who stop drinking in AA would have stopped without it.

I admit I don't understand statistics very well. But it seems to me that all those options don't have to add up to 100%, nor are they mutually exclusive. Are you saying that, statistically speaking, since both AA and just stopping have a 5% chance of working, I should just hope I'm in the lucky spontaneous group, and I shouldn't go to AA because it doesn't better my odds at recovery?
 
Last edited:
Oh, sigh. That's not how it works.

AA has made claims of (sometimes) great efficacy since day one. The null hypothesis is that AA is no more effective than chance; because this is the case as it stands, please present evidence which disproves the null hypothesis and we can go from there.

You're moving the goalposts.

I'm addressing these claims:


qayak said:
There has been no evidence provided to show that AA helped anybody . . . ever.


AA has obviously helped someone at some time.

If you were drinking regularly and the only thing in your life that changed was the fact you began AA meetings it had to of have some effect.

Personally I had tried various other methods to quit drinking, they didn't work.

One included psychotherapy, can I now claim it doesn't work?

The fact is measuring to what degree AA helps will be always be difficult, by the very nature of the program and even it's detractors admit there haven't been any good studies on it's effectiveness, so throwing out the 5% canard is a little dishonest.

It'd be like trying to find out if local Drop-In centers made teenagers better students. You have kids coming and going for various lengths of time, but if they spent 5 minutes at the center reading I'm sure it helped their studies if only in a small way.

If we look at self-help groups in the areas of cancer, arthritis, depression,etc.
no they don't cure the disease, but they help cope with it. Most any medical professional will tell you that.
 
I admit I don't understand statistics very well. But it seems to me that all those options don't have to add up to 100%, nor are they mutually exclusive. Are you saying that, statistically speaking, since both AA and just stopping have a 5% chance of working, I should just hope I'm in the lucky spontaneous group, and I shouldn't go to AA because it doesn't better my odds at recovery?

Think about it. If you have a population of say, for the sake of argument, 1000 people who are all alcoholics and the spontaneous remission rate is 5%.

50% of those people attend AA and 50% don't.

Of the people who do not go to AA, 25 people will be cured.

Of the people who do go, 25% will be cured.

The point is, 25% of the AA attendees would have been cured without going. If AA had a say a 10% success rate, you could be pretty sure that AA had some effect. It would be responsible for the difference between the spontaneous remission rate and its own success rate.

Because the rates are the same, we know there is no effect. The 5% who claim to be cured by AA are mistaken. They are the ones who would have been cured regardless.

That AA members 'feel' AA helped them doesn't mean it did. It is very easy for people to be mistaken about cause and effect. Many people eat something and feel it made them sick simply because they ate the food before getting sick. That doesn't mean the one caused the other it only means one happened after the other.

This fallacy is very common in 'alternative' medicine. Most people will recover from a cold in a few days but if they take a herbal remedy and get better in a few days they will credit the remedy. People want to believe.

It is the same with AA members. They want to believe the therapy they chose works and so they give AA credit even though it most likely doesn't deserve the credit.
 
I admit I don't understand statistics very well. But it seems to me that all those options don't have to add up to 100%, nor are they mutually exclusive. Are you saying that, statistically speaking, since both AA and just stopping have a 5% chance of working, I should just hope I'm in the lucky spontaneous group, and I shouldn't go to AA because it doesn't better my odds at recovery?

Technically, at this point, I'd say yes, BUT... nobody really knows yet what would help the most number of people with the most positive outcome. As I pointed out in a previous post, it could be just showing up and doing *something* social other than drinking (or being in situations which have supported drinking) is what is the most effective for people and the AA program itself is just packaging.

In other words, it could be that it's the dedication that AAers show in going to meetings that if they showed the same dedication towards going bowling or attending book club meetings they could get exactly the same benefit.

I don't think that's true however. I am throwing that out for a comparison. One of the points I'm trying to make is we just don't know yet and it's disingenuous of the pro-AAs who make claims of success, all attributable to the AA program/lifestyle.

What I do think is that AA can accidentally teach a few valuable coping mechanisms that are lacking in many addicted people. What my goal is, is to recognize these useful and valuable coping skills and strip them from the religious aspects that AA couches them in and continue to add to this body of knowledge so that many, many more people can benefit from them.

It also can serve a benefit by separating the useful fundamentals of a self-help or self-directed plan of sobriety while simultaneously dropping the -- let's face it -- huge amount of baggage that the AA concept has developed over the past seventy years.
 
Re: the 5 percent rate, here is a report explaining the apparent origins and issues with both that low-end mark and high-end marks flush with AA euphoria:

AA Recovery Outcome Rates: Contemporary Myth and Misinterpretation
http://hindsfoot.org/recout01.pdf


Let's assume, despite the problem with those statistics, that the oft-cited 5 percent AA success rate and 5 percent do-nothing success rate are accurate.

The 5 percent who experience spontaneous remission by definition have not been to AA or any other treatment. Bully for them.

One in 20 stays home and voila, they're cured. The other 19 go out and try something. Maybe they, their spouses, their employers, the legal system or all of the above have grown impatient with waiting for spontaneous remission.

If, of that 19, any succeed in quitting drink, you have a success rate greater than 1 in 20. If they all stay home, you have a success rate of 1 in 20.

I may be making some specific error here, but that's what I come up with.

Here's another interesting link: http://http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=does-alcoholics-anonymous-work
 
Last edited:
You're moving the goalposts.

I'm fine with moving the goalposts. I'm trying to get them back to where they belong; notably, AA has made claims of success in dealing with addiction and alcoholism. That is undeniable.

The problem I see is that AA wants to eat it's cake and have it too -- it's protagonists want it to be successful and valuable for suffering addicts, yet steadfastly refuse to actually test the claims or try to improve the program in any way. They just come up with non-program stuff as a work around. Why would that be, I wonder?

I just don't get it. An AAer, for example, doesn't really like the sixth step and so doesn't do it. They use a saying that was never part of the original program ("take what you want and leave the rest") to justify not doing it, yet feel proud that they're 'working the steps'.


AA has obviously helped someone at some time.

If you were drinking regularly and the only thing in your life that changed was the fact you began AA meetings it had to of have some effect.

The point is that we really don't know that AA has any positive effect at all; if there is a positive effect, is it realistic to attribute it to AA rather than the efforts of the person themselves outside of any self-help group attendance? We don't know yet.

Again, as I said in an earlier post, I will be the first one to say to others, "hey, go to AA. I don't like it because of it's religious orientation, but I've read all the studies that confirm that it's really helpful for coping with addiction."

The problem is that there are no studies that show what I just said. And to forestall any criticism of CBT or related therapy, a new thread should be started so that that program can be discussed with more thoroughness than can be done in this thread.


Personally I had tried various other methods to quit drinking, they didn't work.

One included psychotherapy, can I now claim it doesn't work?

Sure, based on one survey's conclusions. But 'psychotherapy' is a HUGE FIELD that covers quite a wide area of differing treatment modalities; one does not even have to have any professional degrees or training to call oneself a psychotherapist. Usually the studies will define what they mean by using certain terminology which can lead a meta-analyst into making a more fair comparison.


The fact is measuring to what degree AA helps will be always be difficult, by the very nature of the program and even it's detractors admit there haven't been any good studies on it's effectiveness, so throwing out the 5% canard is a little dishonest.

It's not a canard. It's a baseline that every study that I've seen, reports. In any population of alcoholics studied, ~5% of them recover without doing anything. (In this case, I sure wish Linda were still around because she can explain in greater detail since that's her profession.)


It'd be like trying to find out if local Drop-In centers made teenagers better students. You have kids coming and going for various lengths of time, but if they spent 5 minutes at the center reading I'm sure it helped their studies if only in a small way.
And why are you sure of this? There are many things that happen which are counter-intuitive yet remain true. One example that I can think of is that some children were studied on the amount of homework they had versus scores on standardized tests. Before a certain age (twelve, I think), it was found that homework was useless in producing long-term improvement in scores. They just weren't developed enough to take advantage of long hours of studying at home.

So in other words, we can certainly study these kinds of things and more. Alcoholics are no different in that regard, as I've said many times now.


If we look at self-help groups in the areas of cancer, arthritis, depression,etc.
no they don't cure the disease, but they help cope with it. Most any medical professional will tell you that.

Great examples, PBS! Yes, they can be effective for many people in coping with their disease. Do these cancer self-help groups work the 12-steps? Do arthritis sufferers proclaim their powerlessness over arthritis every day? How does a person with major depression 'relapse'? Does a woman with cancer need to take her own inventory or caused her family and friends emotional distress due to her trips to chemotherapy that she should make amends for?

If these people find comfort, solace, and a new outlet for living with these difficult conditions, what is it that helps them? Is it the 12 steps? If not, why not?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom