Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You don't think AA steers people away from other kinds of therapy. Ok, go to a meeting and ask all of the old-timers what they think of naltrexone. Bye

Joey, I doubt if most of them know what naltrexone is.
 
If you were offended that I didn't say you're welcome, I'll say it now: You're welcome.

I didn't want to start a back-and-forth about the study because essentially I agreed with you.

Ditto.
And apologies for any offence by my oversight in not giving a thanks to Norseman for finding the study.
 
Joey, I doubt if most of them know what naltrexone is.

I doubt Joey really understands it either; its limitations, short versus long term efficacy, side effects. Perhaps he could cite some studies for us? :rolleyes:
Sadly the Cochrane report (which he seems somewhat obsessed with) makes no mention of naltrexone for alcohol dependence that I could locate.
 
I could believe this........... maybe, except yo keep saying things like this:

So I am asking what evidence based medicine? Which treatments? And their efficacy?
So we're clear on the fact that AA is not interested in being a professional organization or even asking for panels of experts to consult on what happens inside the program? I'm pretty sure everyone is clear on that at this point.

The most important thing is recognizing the fact that not everyone should be told that they have a disease and that abstinence is the only way, or that the program is the only way that works. This is a major problem that the cult creates. Since it's been shown that most people get sober on their own, and a great deal of people learn to moderate their drinking, this needs to be reflected by the program. It is immoral and cultist to be going around convincing people that their very life depends on their attendance at meetings.

About 30% of Americans had experienced a disorder, the research showed, but about 70% of those quit drinking or cut back to safe consumption patterns without treatment after four years or less.

Only 1% of those surveyed fit the stereotypical image of someone with severe, recurring alcohol addiction who has hit the skids.

"It can be a chronic, relapsing disease. But it isn't usually that," Willenbring (NIAAA says.

+ + +

In the national survey, about half of the people who'd had an alcohol-use disorder recovered, enabling them to drink at low-risk levels without symptoms of dependence. "Some people are uncomfortable with that," Prescott says. "It's a safer prescription to tell someone to quit. But the studies suggest that a large proportion of people are able to cut down and aren't out-of-control."

LA Times

I am still waiting on you to expand on exactly what you think the Cochrane review says.
This was your technique last time, and I'll reply the same thing. These are the author's conclusions. It's inappropriate to "interpret" them for your own purposes...

People considering attending AA or TSF programmes should be
made aware that there is a lack of experimental evidence on the
effectiveness of such programmes.

So... :confused:

You must also have noted it addresses many other treatments, perhaps you could outline which of the "science based" ones you think best?
For the purpose of this conversation I understand it is your flawed technique to try and suggest that AA is just as good as anything else. I think that people in AA should learn about CBT and relationship counselling, science-based methods of health and wellness, that type of thing, instead of the cult. I'm not interested in that conversation right now, although it is worth having. My sole point, the point of this thread, is to point out that AA is a cult, point out the history of people whose stories are contained in the archives of AA deprogramming and the like.

So :confused:
 
I'm talking about the knowledge that you purport to have that gives you keener insight into the AA experience than that possessed by those actively involved in going to meetings and living a sober life. You "get it". You see the malevolence that is AA, while those in AA don't.

I find this interesting.
Actually it would be more appropriate to say that I have been in hundreds of meetings, have several hardcore followers in my family, and know several people who have been in it a long time, plus I have spent a good deal of time talking with and reading from people who have been in the cult for many, many years before finally escaping and deprogramming.

You find it interesting that the people in the cult don't see the harm, don't see it as a cult?

"I was in a cult for 34 years. Everyone else could see it. I don't know why I couldn't." - Paul Haggis

Yes, I'm familiar with it. Folks like a good label, though I don't much go in for them myself. Each to his own-- The whole idea behind encouraging folks to continue to attend meetings is to keep them in an environment that's conducive to and supportive of a sober life-style.
Duh. They all start out with the right idea don't they! But what happens in practice is quite different isn't it.
People, however, are still people. We're going to engage in the same stupidity that everybody else in the world does: plays for power, petty bickering, attempts to achieve physical and/or intellectual dominance, struggles for power and control, etc. That's just the kind of apes we are. So, the fact that we strive to live a sober life-style in no way means that we're somehow above all the foibles associated with the human condition. It just means that today we're sober, we want to stay that way, and we want to help others who want the same thing. It's really not nearly as evil as you make it out to be.
:confused: In no way are you addressing how the "dry drunks" are treated by their former "friends" in AA when they leave or start to social drink. If this doesn't happen where you live, I'm amazed, and happy for you all. This is the experience of many others, documented extensively.

I suspect that, were I to tell you that I've been in the program for 30 years, you'd say that I was brainwashed, completely indoctrinated, and incapable of see the truth. On the other hand, were I to tell you that I've been in the program for a couple of years, you'd (obviously) say that I haven't been around long enough to understand what you're saying. Consequently, the amount of time I've spent in AA has very little to do with how well you think I understand you. With this in mind, I submit that I completely understand what you're saying and have come to the conclusion that, while you make some good points about possible alternatives to AA, you are largely trapped in your preconceived notions, and are prone to summarily dismissing any notion that doesn't support them.
Actually it would be more accurate to say that instead of acknowledging there are serious problems with AA (think Clancy, Midtown, people quitting AA over too many people committing suicide after going off their meds on the advice of a sponsor, then that sponsor continuing to be a sponsor..., people's marriages breaking up etc etc) you somehow find other places to put the blame instead of on the cult structure. Well, some people just know better.

Perhaps. But sober babbling, cult idiots...
Actually they are not well known for helping people to get sober, says the data. They are well known for getting people to believe that's true. This is the kind of apologia that just makes me ill.

I mean, the people I'm close to, they will even admit that this is one seriously screwed up organization, but they accept it because they believe it helps them stay sober! It's unbelievable what they will accept and go through just because they honestly believe it's jails, institutions or death!
 
So we're clear on the fact that AA is not interested in being a professional organization or even asking for panels of experts to consult on what happens inside the program? I'm pretty sure everyone is clear on that at this point.

Their traditions largely cover the reasons why.

The most important thing is recognizing the fact that not everyone should be told that they have a disease and that abstinence is the only way, or that the program is the only way that works.

That doesn't happen quote the way you portray it. You may not be aware but people are free to come and go as they like. Since the fellowship is for people with a desire to stop drinking (tradition three), why would they be interested in teaching moderation; that does not work for many alcoholics.

Since it's been shown that most people get sober on their own,

I don't believe:
a. this has been shown nor
b. it to be true

Ecidence please.

and a great deal of people learn to moderate their drinking, this needs to be reflected by the program.

These people are not alcoholics, so I would agree.

These are the author's conclusions. It's inappropriate to "interpret" them for your own purposes...

Frantic backpedal

That aside, what are his conclusions?

For the purpose of this conversation I understand it is your flawed technique to try and suggest that AA is just as good as anything else. I think that people in AA should learn about CBT and relationship counselling, science-based methods of health and wellness, that type of thing, instead of the cult.

And there is nothing stopping them getting any of that.

Now (my bold) what are these science based methods you speak of? What are the treatments and what is their efficacy?

I'm not interested in that conversation right now, although it is worth having. My sole point, the point of this thread, is to point out that AA is a cult, point out the history of people whose stories are contained in the archives of AA deprogramming and the like.

The you are off topic and will be reported as such from now on. Start your own thread on AA is a cult; that is not the point of this thread as you claim here, this is about the efficacy of AA and other treatments.

I find it interesting that you pop up as soon as we are off moderated, coincidence? I doubt it.
 
Last edited:
Their traditions largely cover the reasons why.
Please explain why the ideal recovery group is not a professionally run organization with professional accountability and data tracking.
That doesn't happen quote the way you portray it. You may not be aware but people are free to come and go as they like. Since the fellowship is for people with a desire to stop drinking (tradition three), why would they be interested in teaching moderation; that does not work for many alcoholics.
Maybe where you are from, maybe in some other people's groups, but that is what happens to a lot of people. And if you don't agree, you're a denier who has not bothered to research the experiences of people who have left the cult after many years. AA should integrate this knowledge immediately. This is why I call it apologia, you admit that this is true, but you apologize for the fact that many people get caught up in the lie about jails, institutions and death.
I don't believe:
a. this has been shown nor
b. it to be true

Ecidence please.
That's what the study detailed in the LA times shows. You've been shown it so many times in this thread already.
These people are not alcoholics, so I would agree.
Not "true alcoholics" lol. They get stuck in the program cult all the time though because of this sick recruiting drive (which the big book is a manual) Dr. Bob says get on your knees!
Frantic backpedal

That aside, what are his conclusions?
:confused: I just posted them!
And there is nothing stopping them getting any of that.
In your dreamworld where none of the cultist aspects of AA poison what actually happens! People say it all the time in meetings nowadays "it's ok to get outside help!" Why do they have to say that? Because it's such a sick problem of woos in AA professing to have all the answers!


The you are off topic and will be reported as such from now on. Start your own thread on AA is a cult; that is not the point of this thread as you claim here, this is about the efficacy of AA and other treatments.
That's hilarious... the title of this thread is "Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs" the answer to the first question is "because it is a cult". Nice try though!
I find it interesting that you pop up as soon as we are off moderated, coincidence? I doubt it.
Anyone can see that you are wrong, I have been posting here consistently before they turned it off...

What is true is that this is waste of time. I don't think anyone wants to read our conversations anym ore so I'll be bowing out from here. Good luck
 
:boggled: We've been over this before. If he is caught but no one has any authority to make sure he's never a football coach for anyone ever again, (like making sure predators or people who coach people off of meds are never sponsors again) then you have a ****** organization on your hands with no accountability. This analogy has nothing to do with anything.
AA claims it can help people, that it knows the answers, since they suck at this, and also refuse to catch up to evidence-based medicine, everyone should know about it before they choose to devote their life to the cult.



Yes we have been over this before and you're still having trouble finding an answer. You are once again showing you either don't know how AA groups function or are feigning ignorance because if you admitted AA doesn't work the way you believe it does, your argument falls flat on its face

One more time in hopes you'll get it, AA is a loose collection of self-groups and has as much authority over me as the people I play ball hockey with in an empty parking lot every week. In fact it's one of the things that attracted me to AA in the first place, I was tired of being lectured to by people who had no clue how I felt, it was nice to be able to talk with people fighting the same battle as I was.

Now back to the weekly ball hockey game. I think one guy is a jerk, he's rude and obnoxious, I wish he'd just quit, but it's not up to me whether he is allowed to play or not. It's an empty parking lot, different guys show up to play from week to week, I nor anyone else control who gets to play. If someone commits a criminal act I'll call the police, besides that not much I can do, except avoid the louse or find another game somewhere else.

I know in some far off Utopian paradise, everyone has Ghandi like personas and society functions without a flutter, back here in the real world most of us are far from perfect, especially those of us who suffer from addiction.

The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.

Getting it yet?




:boggled: If they don't ban him from ever being a part of WW again, and if WW doesn't use science (it most certainly does more of science stuff than AA!) yeah I'd say they were a stupid cult too.


Ban him for what? :boggled: Being an over-aggressive cad?

Last time I checked that wasn't against any laws, you can't go around banning people willy nilly just because you don't like them. Is your last name Stalin?

Who gets to decide who joins and who doesn't? Who makes the rules?


AA claims it can help people, that it knows the answers, since they suck at this, and also refuse to catch up to evidence-based medicine, everyone should know about it before they choose to devote their life to the cult.


Proof? Oh that's right you don't have any because as your friend Orange tells us, there's a:


"scarcity of good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous"



and




Until the last decade, alcoholism treatment research lagged behind standard medical and behavioral treatment research. Randomized controlled trials, the most objective type of treatment research methodology, were rarely used by alcohol treatment researchers.

Instead, much of the early research suffered from lack of comparison groups, high rates of attrition, and reliance solely on self-reports of alcohol consumption, all of which may have biased, or skewed, the results.




As well as this from the same page:


"The highly regarded approach to alcoholism, Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), has proved difficult to evaluate. Part of the problem stems from the difficulty of studying AA under natural conditions and the inability to randomize patient samples due to the AA tradition of member anonymity (4). A popular treatment approach, the inpatient "Minnesota Model," uses a philosophy of self-help similar to that of AA (5). The program combines referral to AA both during inpatient treatment and as part of an aftercare program. The model relies heavily on counseling (both personal and family). Few controlled studies have been conducted on the model's effectiveness (6,7); however, two recent studies, one in the United States (8) and one in Finland (9), support its effectiveness."


You're boring me now.



Highlighting the core of the program is religion and saying that they don't use science to improve their success rates because they are an arrogant cult is just the facts. Saying that there are many problems because of it's structure and belief system is just the facts, Bill Wison was the worst 13th stepper, it's his cult, it's built right into the system! No accountability.


That would make sense if it contained a shred of truth, your ignorance is showing again.



Jails, institutions or death.


No thankfully AA helped steer me clear of that, when all medical help available at the time (psychiatrists, psychotherapists and family physicians) turned out to be an abysmal failure. Certainly glad you weren't giving me advice, I might not be here at all.


Your experience is contradicted by the people who have written on aadeprogramming and xsteppers. Those people that were in the program for decades know a lot more about this than you, and didn't have the luxary of an AA agnostics meeting (from the article, a dude actually was balling his eyes out over the fact they'd been delisted, seems even the people in your beloved agnostics group care about what the intergroup does)



Yeah you might have a point, except I know many people who have been in AA a long time too, many more than you and none of them seem to agree with anything you've said, nor exhibit any of the behaviors you've attributed to AA.

Am I supposed to believe my own eyes and ears or your unsupported assertions?

I guess I'm just a guy who lucked into the best AA membership in the world, that or your active imagination belongs in the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum, instead of this one.



Anyway arguing about this religion is the same as arguing about all religions, the apologia lines and pseudoargument tactics are all the same. It's a huge cult with all sorts of different groups and people in it, you have to look at the overall trends and the general patterns of what happens. Just apologize for your idealized version and ignore the fundamental problems


Yes it's a massive cult, in fact we have plans to take over the world.
Right now AA groups all over the planet are organizing a membership drive.
We will be camping out at bars, restaurants and liquor outlets. Any drunks we find walking the streets will be kidnapped and reprogrammed using our state of the art brainwashing techniques. NO ONE IS SAFE FROM THE CLUTCHES OF AA!

Well not really, but I figured this would go well with your delusions.
 
Last edited:
I'm talking about the knowledge that you purport to have that gives you keener insight into the AA experience than that possessed by those actively involved in going to meetings and living a sober life. You "get it". You see the malevolence that is AA, while those in AA don't.

This is the same behavior exhibited by truthers. They believe they are the only ones capable of "figuring" out 9/11 and we are just "sheeple."

When you ask for proof, you get personal incredulity and opinion, never evidence.

You can cite the NCSEA and some truther will say "yeah well I know a guy who used to work there, he said they all take drugs so I wouldn't trust them"

It's worth noting, Joey is doing the same thing.
 
Sadly the Cochrane report ... makes no mention of naltrexone for alcohol dependence that I could locate.

I just Googled a bunch of words. I ended up with a Canadian study and can't find it now. New England Journal of Medicine abstract cited it as no better than placebo. The Canadian health service had a very even-handed treatment and it does appear to reduce cravings.

It's a fairly expensive Rx to be used in conjunction with liver-function studies and is considered a three-month course of treatment.
 
You find it interesting that the people in the cult don't see the harm, don't see it as a cult?
Please.

If, after reading my post, you arrived at the conclusion that I find it interesting that "the people in the cult don't see the harm, don't see it as a cult", then I suggest you read the post again. I wouldn't want you to give the impression that you are being disingenuous.

"I was in a cult for 34 years. Everyone else could see it. I don't know why I couldn't." - Paul Haggis

Is there some reason that I should give a rat's ass about what Paul Haggis has to say about Scientology?

Duh. They all start out with the right idea don't they! But what happens in practice is quite different isn't it.

What happens is what happens. I'm beginning to wonder if you didn't have an idealistic expectation that the folks in AA were somehow going to be possessed of superhuman self-control, honesty, integrity, compassion, and what-not, and that when this proved not to be any more the the case than it is with the rest of the population, you became bitterly disenchanted.

:confused: In no way are you addressing how the "dry drunks" are treated by their former "friends" in AA when they leave or start to social drink. If this doesn't happen where you live, I'm amazed, and happy for you all. This is the experience of many others, documented extensively.

Sure this happens, if by "this" you mean that folks who leave, or attempt to drink "socially", are spoken to as if their lives may be in danger. When some folks drink, their lives are in danger. You're aware of this, right? You've met the type, right? If by "this" you mean that folks talk badly about them behind their backs, then, yeah, this happens too, primarily because sometimes some folks are asshats who can't seem to keep from investing a whole lot of energy in nonsense. You run into this type everywhere, not just at AA meetings, though at AA meetings they're generally called on it. It certainly doesn't happen across the board.

Actually it would be more accurate to say that instead of acknowledging there are serious problems with AA (think Clancy, Midtown, people quitting AA over too many people committing suicide after going off their meds on the advice of a sponsor, then that sponsor continuing to be a sponsor..., people's marriages breaking up etc etc) you somehow find other places to put the blame instead of on the cult structure. Well, some people just know better.

Omniscience must be nice.

My heart goes out to foks who suffer through tragic events.

Has anyone ever accused you of cherry-picking? I mean, seriously. I could find all manner of isolated horrible, tragic events that have occured within all kinds of organizations. That you would use such tragedies because you think it supports you position is more than just a little sad.


Actually they are not well known for helping people to get sober, says the data. They are well known for getting people to believe that's true. This is the kind of apologia that just makes me ill.

There are a lot of folks living a sober lifestyle that might disagree with you. But what do they know, right?

I mean, the people I'm close to, they will even admit that this is one seriously screwed up organization, but they accept it because they believe it helps them stay sober!

Which you dismiss because it doesnt support your preconceived notions--

It's unbelievable what they will accept and go through just because they honestly believe it's jails, institutions or death!

Do you tell alcoholics that if they decide to drink they don't have to worry about jail or dying?
 
Last edited:
In looking up the infamous Clancy - due to a probably unhealthy degree of interest in Joey's worldview - I found an article by Clancy Martin, a philosophy prof at the University of Missouri.

The drunk's club: A.A., the cult that cures

http://hivdatf.files.wordpress.com/2010/12/harpersmagazine-2011-01-0083250.pdf

It touches on a lot of stuff mentioned here including various psych meds, anonymity, entrenched attitudes, multigenerational AA - it's really well done.
 
What is true is that this is waste of time. I don't think anyone wants to read our conversations anym ore so I'll be bowing out from here. Good luck

Thanks.

Goodbye again.

But you've said that before, sadly something tell me you will be back.
 
I'm beginning to wonder if you didn't have an idealistic expectation that the folks in AA were somehow going to be possessed of superhuman self-control, honesty, integrity, compassion, and what-not, and that when this proved not to be any more the the case than it is with the rest of the population, you became bitterly disenchanted.

The above was addressed to Joey, and I don't want to make this post about him - so if you're still reading, Joey, note that I'm applying this remark to the x-steppers meme and not to you personally.

There are folks out there with a very sincere and personal sense of grievance against AA. I read a few of their stories, and it does seem they were genuinely hurt (emotionally) that AA turned out to be not what they hoped. The sense of grievance shines through even when their remarks are contradictory. They seem to have found purpose in being against AA. A common characteristic appears to be this selective vision that magnifies the pitfalls of amateur self-help while discounting whatever positive aspects they admittedly encountered. If someone kills themselves or gets divorced in AA, it's because of AA, not because they had emotional difficulties to begin with.

Joey has expressed support for the following model:

Everyone will be screened by a panel of experts who will do genetic testing, provide a thorough overview of pharmacological interventions and stand by the addict/alcoholic as they sort out what package of options will optimize outcomes for the patient. That will include a complete physical workup, one-on-one counseling, nutritional advice and thorough oversight to make sure no one ever feels an undue sense of pressure to conform or to adopt an abstinence-based model. This should be run by professionals, the patient's data should be tracked and it should all be free of charge. Presumably, should the data indicate the need for a Plan B, or C, or D, this system will step in and tinker, until everyone's on just the right meds, drinking just right amount of booze and insulated from any human frailty that might pop up in an unmoderated peer-support group.

And this isn't reality, in the U.S., and therefore ... AA is an evil cult. If you can't see that, it proves AA is an evil cult.
 
The above was addressed to Joey, and I don't want to make this post about him - so if you're still reading, Joey, note that I'm applying this remark to the x-steppers meme and not to you personally.

There are folks out there with a very sincere and personal sense of grievance against AA. I read a few of their stories, and it does seem they were genuinely hurt (emotionally) that AA turned out to be not what they hoped. The sense of grievance shines through even when their remarks are contradictory. They seem to have found purpose in being against AA. A common characteristic appears to be this selective vision that magnifies the pitfalls of amateur self-help while discounting whatever positive aspects they admittedly encountered. If someone kills themselves or gets divorced in AA, it's because of AA, not because they had emotional difficulties to begin with.

Joey has expressed support for the following model:

Everyone will be screened by a panel of experts who will do genetic testing, provide a thorough overview of pharmacological interventions and stand by the addict/alcoholic as they sort out what package of options will optimize outcomes for the patient. That will include a complete physical workup, one-on-one counseling, nutritional advice and thorough oversight to make sure no one ever feels an undue sense of pressure to conform or to adopt an abstinence-based model. This should be run by professionals, the patient's data should be tracked and it should all be free of charge. Presumably, should the data indicate the need for a Plan B, or C, or D, this system will step in and tinker, until everyone's on just the right meds, drinking just right amount of booze and insulated from any human frailty that might pop up in an unmoderated peer-support group.

And this isn't reality, in the U.S., and therefore ... AA is an evil cult. If you can't see that, it proves AA is an evil cult.

Excellent summary. There are just two things you omitted: Joey says

1. There is better science based treatments around; just find them for me and that will prove it to you.
2. AA is an evil cult! :)
 
I for one hope Joey McGee stays, and told him so.

While I disagree with many of his conclusions, I enjoyed his posts and found them informative. There is value in simply discussing different viewpoints. Would you rather have no one here? Yes someone probably will come along, and the Norseman is still here, but why not simply engage Joey?

AA/Addiction is almost the perfect storm of skepticism. Religion, politics, medicine, psychology, evidence, money, entertainment. It effects all demographics. And it can kill you.

To everyone who has posted here, thank you. But keep in mind that this thread has been admonished once for posters not being civil. Both sides, by the way. I'm reminded of Phil Plaits Don't be a dick speech at TAM 8. What I got from it was that someone can make a point without the baggage of being rude. I've been guilty of that, but I also don't like it when I see it.
 
Last edited:
There are just two things you omitted: Joey says

1. There is better science based treatments around; just find them for me and that will prove it to you.
2. AA is an evil cult! :)


What this thread is driving home to me is what a bitch addiction is. Which is why, along with the science-based treatment, I stick up for calling in the spiritual cavalry. In my felt experience there is such a thing as soul-sickness and I'm not averse to using religious language to describe it. It's my belief that most people interpret the steps, some in exactly the sort of secular language used in "Agnostic AA." And without calling it faith-healing I'll admit, there is a leap of faith involved. Not trusting in God, but trusting the process, perhaps. Part of the process is internalizing what those steps mean to you, whether they involve supernatural agency or not.

Which absolutely doesn't rule out antidepressants or cognitive therapy or even Valium, as in the link to the PDF I posted. That's the part of AA bashing that puzzles me most - the blanket assertion that in AA people are "steered away" from outside help. Has it ever happened? In some era, in some groups, or by some individuals, of course. In my neck of the woods, not so much: appropriate medical care is encouraged, a sort of amends to your battered body, mind and maybe soul. Self-care is always indicated. One of my "mantras." I've seen more people steered toward outside help than away from it.
 
The above was addressed to Joey, and I don't want to make this post about him - so if you're still reading, Joey, note that I'm applying this remark to the x-steppers meme and not to you personally.

There are folks out there with a very sincere and personal sense of grievance against AA. I read a few of their stories, and it does seem they were genuinely hurt (emotionally) that AA turned out to be not what they hoped. The sense of grievance shines through even when their remarks are contradictory. They seem to have found purpose in being against AA. A common characteristic appears to be this selective vision that magnifies the pitfalls of amateur self-help while discounting whatever positive aspects they admittedly encountered. If someone kills themselves or gets divorced in AA, it's because of AA, not because they had emotional difficulties to begin with.

Joey has expressed support for the following model:

Everyone will be screened by a panel of experts who will do genetic testing, provide a thorough overview of pharmacological interventions and stand by the addict/alcoholic as they sort out what package of options will optimize outcomes for the patient. That will include a complete physical workup, one-on-one counseling, nutritional advice and thorough oversight to make sure no one ever feels an undue sense of pressure to conform or to adopt an abstinence-based model. This should be run by professionals, the patient's data should be tracked and it should all be free of charge. Presumably, should the data indicate the need for a Plan B, or C, or D, this system will step in and tinker, until everyone's on just the right meds, drinking just right amount of booze and insulated from any human frailty that might pop up in an unmoderated peer-support group.

And this isn't reality, in the U.S., and therefore ... AA is an evil cult. If you can't see that, it proves AA is an evil cult.

:bigclap

/end thread

Not to mention if AA was moulded to Joey's specifications it's membership would dwindle rapidly and probably cease to exist.
 
I spend a lot of time educating people both in and out of AA. I shared a story in this thread some time ago about a sponsee who came to me asking when I thought his anxiety might leave him. I asked him if he was compliant with his prescription medication (antidepressants). He was not. When I ask "why", he said he'd heard the pills are for dills from somewhere and thought that meant his meds. I explained that AA stands for Alcoholics Anonymous, not Anxiety Anonymous and he needs outside help for outside issues.
 
:bigclap

/end thread

Not to mention if AA was moulded to Joey's specifications it's membership would dwindle rapidly and probably cease to exist.

I am pretty certain that would suit him just fine. The result of that would be that millions of people would suddenly be without their disorganised and imperfect support system.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom