Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So why use the term "God" at all, if individuals can have ANY "spiritual entity" they want? And what's with all this "we" crap? "Alcoholics Anonymous" was NOT written by a committee! It was written by Bill Wilson, and whatever narcissistic, pluralized, mentally-masturbatory delusion, HE had! The web-site "Orange-Papers.org" shows the research on that-all from AA's own primary sources no less!
 
In a 2000 Episode of "20/20" called, "Drinking-Are You In Control?", one of the "experts" being interviewed states that "revising the 12-Steps would be like revising the 10 Commandments or something". Shows how INSANELY dogmatic, this particular alcohol-oriented philosophy is!
 
So they do NOT apply to the present then? Its about what HAD been done! That means that they CANNOT be "worked" in the present. They are "ending points" NOT beginning ones, and the 12-Step groups that do "Step Studies" do them because? After all, its ALL past behavior never to be repeated again, right? But that is in direct contradiction with the membership criteria of: "Desire to stop drinking" (vs. the act of actually stopping!), which is FUTURE based! I guess for an allegedly "simple program", nothing occurs in the present then, right?
 
istj, it's difficult to enter into an ongoing discussion and you have my sympathies for that. Just a few pages back the Toronto issue was given a good airing out and although this is a very long thread you'd be doing yourself a favor to read through it all and thus get yourself somewhat up to date, and then ask about anything that still remains unclear to you to be clarified.
 
The steps describe what "we" - the few dozen who had coalesced by that point into AA - "had done" to recover. "This is what we did," past tense plural, "and what we suggest you try." Can't see how that precludes anything, tense-wise. This was addressed recently in this thread. As has every insult/label one could apply to Bill Wilson, as has the program's flexibility in practice when it comes to "God as we understood Him." There was plenty of lively discussion amongst those early AA members about how to word the steps and the bulk of "Alcoholics Anonymous" is devoted to individuals' stories, in the first person, and certainly not all written by Bill Wilson. "The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking" is a statement aimed at those still drinking. It doesn't mean they throw you out once you quit but I see your point.

Also recently results of studies have been posted. Both of these articles are good. I have very minor quibbles with the "Wired" article, when it comes to statements that begin "AA requires ..."

http://http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/06/ff_alcoholics_anonymous/all/1

http://http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=does-alcoholics-anonymous-work

Welcome to the thread.
 
Be advised neither link works. :(

ps: thanks for fixing. :)
 
Last edited:
Find out of your new therapist is a member of AA himself! If so, file an ethics complaint against him! AA's first tradition DEMANDS that "the GROUP comes first"! This is in direct violation of ANY helping profession's violations, where the CLIENT comes first! See how the therapist maintains his support of AA after that! I would recommend finding a new therapist in the meantime!

Actually, I did take him to another therapist, a cognitive behavioral specialist. Working with him, we found out that my husband was behaving oddly for a reason--he has brain cancer. It's a massive tumor on both sides of the frontal lobes.

Yes, he is dying. No, there is no treatment possible. Now he is in hospice and the kicker to all of this is that he gets to have a glass of brandy every night before bed, which he quietly enjoys.

His last days will be spent as comfortably as possible. --Nanny Ogg
 
Yes, he is dying. No, there is no treatment

Nancy, I am so sorry.

I don't know how you view this thread now, if you're sorry you got the ball rolling or not. Probably not a big concern for you one way or the other.

Whatever else comes out of this thread: Is there something people should be on the lookout for, is there a clear sign about when to stop shopping for therapists and get a referral for an MRI or other appropriate procedure?

As one of the AA "apologists" I stand by my opinion that AA does more good than harm, by a long chalk. But, I'm really horrified if you or your husband got the impression that checking out AA precluded taking appropriate steps to determine if bizarre behavior had an "organic" root, e.g. brain tumor.

If someone without reservation (or credentials) told you, "You don't need a doctor, you just need AA," then ... I'd like to personally throttle them.

I hope your husband goes peacefully, I hope that you find peace, or that you already have.
 
Nanny, I'm so very sorry to hear this. I hope he will be very comfortable. Hospice does a wonderful service. My condolences.
 
Here's a stab at answering though I'm not an AA historian.

Per Wikipedia, AA conducts surveys that attempt to determine how many people are staying in or dropping out. (Also possibly to see how many times they'd tried AA before deciding to stay) The most recent was in 2007. These are strictly voluntary, on the honor system and in some cases seem to address program retention rates rather than effectiveness.

From 1970 to 1990 these surveys were supplemented with analysis. In 1990 AA dropped the analysis but continued with the surveys. Members reported on how long they'd been continuously sober. It's worth noting that although they believed AA had worked for them, they might simply have been kidding themselves, as suggested by numerous posters.

In 1990 AA dropped its concurrent analysis that had accompanied the surveys. I'm not sure why. Is that what you meant by "studies" that AA stopped doing? Do you know of any controlled and rigorous quantitative analysis done by AA that is no longer done?

My take on that would be: to facilitate a network where alcoholics can help other alcoholics get sober and/or stay sober.

AA will not do study that requires one group to attend and another group not to attend.

AA will not implement a mandatory reporting system that requires participation in surveys.

AA will not require anyone to take a sobriety test.

AA doesn't know who's not in AA. It cannot track down non-attendees who are trying a different method than AA.

AA will not divide attendees into groups and require each group to try a supplementary option.

AA will not (and cannot) track down people who have left to see if they're staying sober. First, it won't have their names; second, AA's priority is to keep the program going for people who want it. It's not going to seek out people who don't want it. (Although I think they tried that early on, it can backfire.)

Seriously, Norseman, after having named these, I'm curious what kind of study you picture. So I'm asking - what kind of study do you picture? I'm not an expert on study designs so I may have missed a plausible protocol.

I looked at the two studies you mentioned. Both involved court-probated alcoholics. They didn't have a choice about attending meetings; they were ordered there. So even if participation in the study was voluntary, the choice to attend wasn't.

The anonymity they were granted by authorities has nothing to do with the anonymity tradition in AA. Authorities had all the vital data they needed; AA would not have collected it to begin with. The AA tradition does not bind outside agencies, it binds AA. You started by asking why AA couldn't have done the studies, then cited studies AA didn't do in order to prove AA could have done the studies?

Neither was conducted by AA, nor could either have been conducted by AA; it has no power over probationers; no ability to order them into treatment and no interest in pushing the program to people who don't want it.

The studies seemed to indicate that AA doesn't work well if you a) don't want to be there or b) don't attend at all.

Finally, bear with me as a cite a telling paragraph (also Wikipedia):

That's certainly possible but I ran through some scenarios above. I'd love to see an example of a study that could be done by AA. The links you cited don't do that.

Thanks for being civil.

Thank you for saying so! :)


Allow me to cut to the chase.

The point in providing those two studies is to demonstrate that the rather liberal interpretation of the 11th tradition is being used as an obfuscatory measure rather than what it was intended. Bill W. himself spoke about precisely what all of the traditions meant, and pretending that one could not participate in a double-blind medical study due to anonymity is not one of those reasons.

To anyone who cares to test this: how about presenting the names of all the participants in those studies. How about providing the names of people who participate in any proper medical study, whatsoever. Anonymity of subjects who take part in medical trials, psychological studies or whatever, has already been addressed at length. In fact, there are groups called Institutional Review Boards (IRB) that examine research proposals for potentially harmful impacts on research participants (such as remaining anonymous) and make recommendations regarding changes that may be needed. All kinds of efforts are taken to treat participants ethically and fairly.

So again, my point in bringing up those two surveys was merely to demonstrate that proper studies can be made of AA and the possible effects. The results of those studies certainly can be analyzed and I'm not really arguing for one or the other at this point.

Oh, and to address the other issues brought up about those two studies, I will say that the participants were allowed no choice in attending some sort of treatment due to court and legal requirements, but there was no corresponding requirement for these people to participate in this study. There is still the element of choice in all of these studies. In other words, non-court mandated AA attendees can volunteer to take part in a study. I'm rather surprised in a way that there aren't AAers lining up around the block to help out. I would guarantee that there'd be thousands of volunteers if AA officially put the word out. Two thousand volunteers out of a reported two million members? Heck, AA or any other organization can put the call out to non-alcoholic volunteers to help establish a baseline. AA corporate has the money; they can even pay people twenty bucks per month to fill out their survey for example. These types of inducements are fairly common and not per se unethical.

Please read the ethics and methods of sociological research and then tell me how AAs are prevented from joining ANY research program.

For the love of FSM, it's not like AAs are extra special in this regard. We have studies being done on men and women who were raped as children or molested. If delicate topics like this can be thoughtfully studied with full respect and care given to the participants, then what have a 'group of drunks' got to worry about?




Since ethical and proper studies can and have been done with AA, let's continue to look at AA and it's possible benefits in a more scientific light.

The null hypothesis in this case is "AA has no effect on alcoholism recovery rates better than mere chance."

Now it's up to the pro-AAers to disprove the null hypothesis. So let's get some studies or re-link the studies that have been presented in this thread already and see what aspects of AA are useful and which are not. First, however, the studies should show that they have statistically significant results and that these results cannot be reasonably demonstrated through other means.
 
Dear Nanny Ogg,
I sincerely send my condolences to you and your family.
May peace come to your life.

DannyB
 
Please read the ethics and methods of sociological research and then tell me how AAs are prevented from joining ANY research program.

Tradition six probably covers that:

6. An A.A. group ought never endorse, finance
or lend the A.A. name to any related facility or outside enterprise, lest problems of money, property and prestige divert us from our primary purpose.


It could be argued that it is an endorsement of an enterprise. Add to that with:

10. Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy.

namely the potential for public controversy and you probably have the answer.

And finally, asking members to potentially give away their anonymity - while perhaps as innocent as you explain - is not something that I could see AA doing; it basically contravenes the very basis on which the "anonymous" part of the group was founded.
 


First off NANNY sorry for misspelling your user name.


Bill W. himself spoke about precisely what all of the traditions meant, and pretending that one could not participate in a double-blind medical study due to anonymity is not one of those reasons.

I'm not saying "one" could not participate. I'm saying AA is not a good candidate to do the study. I'm also not sure how a "double blind" protocol would work.

I'm rather surprised in a way that there aren't AAers lining up around the block to help out. I would guarantee that there'd be thousands of volunteers if AA officially put the word out.

OK. AA picks 2,000 of those people. Why are they "lining up around the block"? Do you not see the possibility of selection bias? Are half of them going to be told to quit coming? AA isn't going to tell them that, or track the progress of those who leave. And if x percent say it worked for them, maybe they're wrong, it was just a coincidence.

AA or any other organization can put the call out to non-alcoholic volunteers to help establish a baseline.

That image makes me wonder what people think AA is.

AA corporate has the money; they can even pay people twenty bucks per month to fill out their survey for example. These types of inducements are fairly common and not per se unethical.

Has anyone said such inducements are unethical?

So you have 2,000 people already in AA, before the study began; and a baseline group of non-alcoholics - say, 2,000 of them. That's $1 million a year, without other expenses added. What's a reasonable amount for AA to spend for a survey that doesn't prove anything? And wouldn't it be better to have 2,000 alcoholics who promise they won't go to AA? Understand, AA won't take their names and won't turn them away.

tell me how AAs are prevented from joining ANY research program.

Anyone in AA can join any research program.

it's not like AAs are extra special in this regard.

You've gone from saying AA could conduct the study to saying AA members could participate in the study. Those aren't trivial differences.

let's get some studies or re-link the studies that have been presented in this thread already and see what aspects of AA are useful and which are not.

Folks: Google "Does AA work" for a Scientific American link that has been posted at least twice, and for opinions of people who don't like AA. Re: to see what aspects of AA are useful and which are not. Show me what that would look like. Some people could attend but not work the steps? Some people would not be allowed to socialize? Some people would not be allowed to pray and others would be required to pray?
 
I don't want to keep repeating myself or beat this into the ground ... and I can't retrieve the last post to find out if I made the point.

AA is decentralized to a degree that outsiders may not realize. It's not an efficient top-down research organization dedicated to funding studies, discovering the best cutting-edge methods of treating alcoholism then regularly handing out format directives from on high. That's not part of its DNA as the cliche goes.

And some other key point, which I've forgotten.
 
Tradition six probably covers that:

6. An A.A. group ought never endorse, finance
or lend the A.A. name to any related facility or outside enterprise, lest problems of money, property and prestige divert us from our primary purpose.


It could be argued that it is an endorsement of an enterprise. Add to that with:

10. Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy.

namely the potential for public controversy and you probably have the answer.

And finally, asking members to potentially give away their anonymity - while perhaps as innocent as you explain - is not something that I could see AA doing; it basically contravenes the very basis on which the "anonymous" part of the group was founded.

AA's sixth tradition in it's entirety:

"Problems of money, property, and authority may easily divert us from our primary spiritual aim. We think, therefore, that any considerable property of genuine use to A.A. should be separately incorporated and managed, thus dividing the material from the spiritual. An A.A. group, as such, should never go into business. Secondary aids to A.A., such as clubs or hospitals which require much property or administration, ought to be incorporated and so set apart that, if necessary, they can be freely discarded by the groups. Hence such facilities ought not to use the A.A. name. Their management should be the sole responsibility of those people who financially support them. For clubs, A.A. managers are usually preferred. But hospitals, as well as other places of recuperation, ought to be well outside A.A.—and medically supervised. While an A.A. group may cooperate with anyone, such cooperation ought never go so far as affiliation or endorsement, actual or implied. An A.A. group can bind itself to no one."

A proper anonymous study is hardly an outside enterprise. Also, where in the sixth tradition, specifically, does it say that people cannot participate in studies of alcohol?

Also, if you read what I had written, I never asked anyone to give up their anonymity. I asked if anyone could get the names of the participants in those studies that were already done. But because no one can, it simply illustrates my point all along that the traditions are being mis-used by some in order to avoid taking part in legitimate studies; the anonymity of participants has already been covered, and has been covered for decades.
 
I'm not saying "one" could not participate. I'm saying AA is not a good candidate to do the study. I'm also not sure how a "double blind" protocol would work.

The AA organization certainly could be the funder for a study such as this, as I already explained. As to a double-blind study, you have a point there. :)



OK. AA picks 2,000 of those people. Why are they "lining up around the block"? Do you not see the possibility of selection bias? Are half of them going to be told to quit coming? AA isn't going to tell them that, or track the progress of those who leave. And if x percent say it worked for them, maybe they're wrong, it was just a coincidence.

Sure, there's always the potential for bias; a proper study takes as much of that into consideration as possible. It's not like sociology is breaking new ground here when it comes to studying the effects of alcoholism.

With a large enough sample size, many of these issues are also controlled for.

With a survey-type study, you have the participants take a survey every month asking specific questions about what their treatment is like or not like; what their attendance is, what their other activities are, whether or not they had a drink, and similar. A study doesn't need to have to tell participants to not attend. And they most certainly can track people who stop attending AA for whatever reason. They are still a part of the study after all. If a study group chooses to use inducements (like paying the participants for filling out the surveys) then they are still eligible as long as they truthfully report what's going on.

Studies also take into consideration a certain amount of people dropping out of the survey over time. The larger the number of participants, the more accurate the results are which can be more accurately extrapolated to the larger group.


Has anyone said such inducements are unethical?

No; just anticipating a possible objection.



So you have 2,000 people already in AA, before the study began; and a baseline group of non-alcoholics - say, 2,000 of them. That's $1 million a year, without other expenses added. What's a reasonable amount for AA to spend for a survey that doesn't prove anything? And wouldn't it be better to have 2,000 alcoholics who promise they won't go to AA? Understand, AA won't take their names and won't turn them away.

Doesn't prove anything? Maybe to you it won't or doesn't. To people who want to study if AA works and how it works, then it's of a great deal of importance.



Anyone in AA can join any research program.

Yup. That's exactly my point and has been for quite a while now, 11th tradition (and now the sixth apparently) notwithstanding.



You've gone from saying AA could conduct the study to saying AA members could participate in the study. Those aren't trivial differences.

The original complaint as I've understood it is that AA as an organization couldn't possibly perform a study. I've shown evidence that it certainly can. I've also shown that AAers themselves can participate in alcoholism studies and remain safely anonymous without disemboweling the 12 Traditions in the process.



Folks: Google "Does AA work" for a Scientific American link that has been posted at least twice, and for opinions of people who don't like AA. Re: to see what aspects of AA are useful and which are not. Show me what that would look like. Some people could attend but not work the steps? Some people would not be allowed to socialize? Some people would not be allowed to pray and others would be required to pray?

Sure. All that can be included in a survey questionnaire, and more. Again, depending on the type of research you're doing, there doesn't have to be a "you can pray, but you over there, you can't" thing going on. You said you read the studies I linked to earlier about the court-ordered guys, yes? In that study, they make it quite clear that they measured four groups -- one group went to AA, another group went to group therapy, a third group went to professional therapists and a fourth group didn't go to any of those. It's part of the scientific process Formulate an hypothesis, measure the data and see if the hypothesis has any predictive value.



I don't want to keep repeating myself or beat this into the ground ... and I can't retrieve the last post to find out if I made the point.

AA is decentralized to a degree that outsiders may not realize. It's not an efficient top-down research organization dedicated to funding studies, discovering the best cutting-edge methods of treating alcoholism then regularly handing out format directives from on high. That's not part of its DNA as the cliche goes.

And some other key point, which I've forgotten.

I would argue that AA is centralized to a larger degree that most people -- especially in AA -- aren't aware of.

Until TinyAl (I apologize if it wasn't him... this has been a very long thread!) posted the reported salaries of the top people in the AA World Group, I had no idea. And I've been around AA for the past twenty-odd years with my active participation for several years. I was frankly surprised to find out that the meetings that passed a few dollars in here and there, bowl out every half-time during a meeting that I was familiar with, could translate to hundred thousand dollars plus salaries for multiple people.

When 90% of treatment agencies in the US are 12-step based, for example, and with courts across the country mandating AA treatment, why is it such a hard thing to ask for some actual proof of it's success?

So.

Any evidence towards disproving the null hypothesis yet?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom