Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Gayak, you make reasonable arguments that suffer from over-generalization. The "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" analogy is creative and thought-provoking. It's more effective than constructions that start with "Everyone in AA ...," "AA makes everyone ..."

Poster Nutbag, you asked a really interesting question: 'If you think AA works, do you think it works in the way in which AA's official position says it does? Does god really fix a spiritual deficiency and miraculously remove the desire to drink if you perform the 12-steps? Or is it the social aspect that helps?'

My experience: The craving was suddenly gone. I had heard about the desire being removed, but I thought that meant, "You'll feel so good you won't want to use." In contrast - that day I felt so bad, I didn't think using would help. I also thought, "Why bother using, I'll just want more." That was pretty much a first step - "powerlessness" meant that if I used I couldn't count on controlling the outcome. I'd been going to AA when this happened but I didn't have a sponsor and wasn't really trying to do a first step.

Nutbag, I'm not trying to be obtuse when I question the use of "AA's official position." Bill Wilson had a "white light" experience that might have been helped along by belladonna, he and his buddies came up with the wording of the steps and it hasn't changed. The 12 steps in agnostic AA would, in my opinion, work just as well. Both use words to model an internal shift that words can only approximate.

It's impossible for me to sort out what "worked" - cognitive, behavioral, social, spiritual. I include "spiritual" because that word has a meaning for me distinct from the first three. "Religious" does not mean the same thing to me. I realize many atheists/agnostics don't make this distinction.
 
The "out" that AA has here is in those last words, "provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation." A group calling itself an atheist group would be considered an affiliation other than alcoholism, as would a Christian group (never mind AA's own Christian roots), but a "spiritual" group would be okay, since AA claims itself to be "spiritual." I recall one group named "The Spiritual progress rather than spiritual perfection group" (many or most groups are named after some slogan or phrase from the big book or other AA literature).

There ARE "AA" meetings that aren't listed in local meeting lists, and the attendees like it that way - these are usually "special interest" meetings, often of professionals such as doctors. I attended one such meeting, started by one of the old timers at the clubhouse. He didn't want to hear all those "young people," those in their teens and twenties who say "ya know" and "like" two or thee times in every sentence.

In the Atlanta meeting list there are "Gay and Lesbian" groups, but immediately after the words Gay and Lesbian are the words "All Alcoholics Welcome." This is how one has a "special interest" group in AA, by specifically not excluding those outside the group. But even then, I'll bet having the statement "All Alcoholics Welcome" still would get those Toronto atheist groups/meetings listed in their local AA meeting list.

Those who compile the meeting lists are of course the ones who get to decide what's an "affiliation" and what's not. The inevitably have several years if not decades of AA membership and are in the "mainstream" of AA belief.


Ben I hate to say this but you are playing games here. You know for a fact AA/GSO had nothing to do with this delisting. It was a intergroup rep that can act on their own if so deemed. IMO it was a knuckhead who decided I don't want this group.
For everybodies information this slight was corrected and the group is listed.
My goodness, so many folks want to get as much play out of this isolated incident as they can.
Enough already.
 
They were zeros before AA but are now the finest people I know. If you're reasonably up to date on the world scene you already know of a few of them.

Hmmmmmm....Mel Gibson? Charlie Sheen? Patrick Kennedy?

I've found a direct correlation to the amount of time someone has spent droning on in AA, and degree of crazy.

There's an inverse correlation between how much one professes to be serenity good person as a result of AA, and what they are actually like to others outside of the AA bubble. AA is really the only place that can accept the domineering, sociopathic types; and turn them into gurus. Part of the reason is the anonymity thing. Another is that anyone with even a slight degree of lucidity leaves quickly. Another is because the bottom rung of AA is screwed up, these types look good in comparison.

Most of the AA gurus I've met aren't really world leader types, but more along the lines of used car salesmen and assistant managers of Taco Bell. That is, if they aren't milking the system by living on their "disability," but somehow can make it to three meetings a day, and lording over their flock of sponsees. We've got a guru here who goes to a morning, noon and night meeting; multiple times a week. Yet, he can't keep a job; and is known locally as someone who can't be trusted. Twenty years in AA, and he's only been convicted of cheque fraud a few times in that period. (Hey, he's gotta pay for his nicotine addiction somehow).

It's nice these people stopped being such lowlifes, although I suspect your view them is an "inside view," in which case it is likely skewed. To a worm in a horse radish, the world is a horse radish. It's difficult to get a lucid, real-world point of reference if one has surrounded oneself by crazy for thirty plus years.
 
Gayak, you make reasonable arguments that suffer from over-generalization. The "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" analogy is creative and thought-provoking. It's more effective than constructions that start with "Everyone in AA ...," "AA makes everyone ..."

Nimoosh, it would seem to me that if what you say about my arguments were true it would be easy to refute them and yet you, and the other AA apologists, have been unable to.

Here's where we stand:

1) It has been shown that there is no evidence that AA attendance improves success rates.

2) It has been shown that by all definitions AA is a religious organization.

3) It has been demonstrated that people claim AA is not religious for several reasons including ignorance, cognitive dissonance, fraud, among others.

It has been an entertaining thread though. Thanks for the input.
 
'You did duck the crux of it however. Again, if AA works, does it work because of divine intervention? If the answer is yes, then it's not even worthy of consideration as a serious treatment option unless AA can provide even a shred of evidence that there is a god and that god is interested in and capable of treating alcoholics. If it works for another reason, why keep such an inflammatory, exclusive, and unnecessary concept in the steps if the real purpose of the program is to provide effective treatment to all who seek it?'

Great that you mentioned that you've already seen the results of AAs doing a few things that work. Instead of telling the drunk to try really, really, really hard to not drink this time unlike all those other times he tried just really really hard, the steps offer a path of specific actions leading to the altered approach to many areas and aspects of life alcoholics need in order to achieve and maintain lifelong abstinence. It even works for those who have failed at the usual methods we commonly try and experience at best minor successes with-as our condition worsens.

One fellow I know would tell you that God powers the needed changes, another friend would say the steps are elementary behaviour modification leading to a wide variety of continual and constantly changing positive reinforcements. Among AAs there are as many theories as members as to exactly why AA works so adding my opinion here couldn't be more meaningless. In keeping with that reality I never discuss the specifics of my spiritual beliefs with anyone.

It's not likely that AA's material will ever be altered to accommodate the sensitivities and beliefs of newcomers or outsiders. In acknowleging he is insufficient to overcome alcoholism and must seek some source of additional power to effect permanent change regarding his drinking the new person is receptive to trying what continues to work well for the sober people as he comes to understand
what all the various objectionable terms found in the literature can personally mean to him and why what they may mean to others is unimportant to him.

If he goes no further than the term God in AA must absolutely mean 'God' and blows out because of that, what commonly happens is he then thereafter believes in an error he has made when his perceptions and thinking were at their sickest point.

Commonly for the rest of his life he would continue to believe and even argue that this incredibly sick and ignorant perception is correct. Despite the worldwide reality that he knows at some level daily and continually contradicts him. After a while it becomes a 'thing' for some to devote a lot of work and time to.

I know it sounds absurd, but it happens. And meanwhile, those who had the ability (or desperation) to look a bit deeper get well.

Some smartass might say the literature is best continuing to be worded as it is in order to sift out the unwilling early instead of later on. Saves everyone's time, ultimately. And some like myself who find ourselves a bit more openminded after some additional elbow bending show up down the road yet again with the same old fears but are fortunate enough to finally hear what the AAs in this thread have repeated in different ways for about a year.

We do some stuff to live better than we did drinking. If the new person wants to do the same and asks directly for help, we help them because someone helped us when we were willing to get out of our own way.

Odd that something so good and simple so greatly irks a few who are not the least involved. For example, I'd not be interested in remaining constantly 'werry furrious' at wabbit hunters, having given up hunting the wascals long ago...
 
Thanks for answering Mondo. I just want to clarify that while I do know a substantial number of sober and well-adjusted people in AA, I have not seen any evidence that it was AA's program that helped them reach that point. If we take the internal triennial surveys at face value, then AA is simply not effective. That doesn't mean that there aren't individuals that benefit, but that as a whole, AA is no more effective than no treatment at all. But again, until serious research is done on AA, I'm not particularly interested in arguing outcomes because of the paucity of data.

I have no trouble admitting that I could not get sober on my own, and so if that was all that AA required, I'd likely still be in the program. However, it is quite clear from the literature that a god who is capable of producing a change in an alcoholic is the mechanism of action. There is no evidence such an entity exists. If I went to the doctor because I had cancer and he told me that the recommended course of action is to do a series of steps to invoke the intervention of a god to fix the spiritual part of my illness, I'd be perfectly justified in being both pissed off that this was being shilled as legitimate treatment, and getting out of there as fast as possible. This is literally what AA says will treat alcoholism. If AA is really CBT or some other behavioral treatment as Alfie or your friend claim, then why not drop the god/spiritual bit and focus on refining the behavioral treatment to be as effective as possible?

I really have to take issue with you claiming that an alcoholic in need of treatment who walks out of AA because of the god crap is in error because he is at his sickest. I haven't believed in god since I was 13 or so, and when I first got to the rooms at 19/20ish, I walked out immediately because my BS detector was off the charts. I'm of sound mind now, and I still find AA to be an absolute joke, quite literally barely worthy of any serious consideration as a legitimate treatment program. This trend in AA to dismiss objections to the religious aspect of the program as the result of "sick" or "alcoholic" thinking is nothing more than a crass way to shoot down important criticism of the program. It marginalizes people who have legitimate concerns about the implausibility (closer to impossibility) of AAs effectiveness, and makes them feel as if treatment isn't available to them. I was a mess when I first got to the rooms, but my inability not stop drinking/using had zero to do with my understanding of modern science and medicine, which even when I was at such a terrible point, is clearly better than those who believe that faith healing is a good treatment for anything. Being an active alcoholic does not mean that a newcomer is wrong about everything, nor does it mean that sober individuals are somehow better judges of what constitutes good treatment. Belief in god and recovery from any disorder are not in any way linked, and for AA to insist that it is is literally killing people. I wanted to get treatment when I first went to AA, saw what passed as treatment, and stayed out for another year plus because I didn't know that there were any legitimate alternatives available because of the domination that AA enjoys in the field.
 
Nimoosh, it would seem to me that if what you say about my arguments were true it would be easy to refute them and yet you, and the other AA apologists, have been unable to.

Here's where we stand:

1) It has been shown that there is no evidence that AA attendance improves success rates.

2) It has been shown that by all definitions AA is a religious organization.

3) It has been demonstrated that people claim AA is not religious for several reasons including ignorance, cognitive dissonance, fraud, among others.

It has been an entertaining thread though. Thanks for the input.


Sorry about the typo qayak.

Overgeneralization doesn't make all your posts wrong; it just makes them easier to pick apart. Example: "It has been shown that by all definitions AA is a religious organization." No it hasn't. You may think the "spiritual vs. religious" distinction is hooey, but quite a few people make a distinction.

"It has been shown by six dictionary definitions" would be more effective.

You say, "It has been shown that there is no evidence that AA attendance improves success rates." Actually, no. The lack of evidence on this forum does not prove there's no evidence. "No quantitative evidence has been presented" would be more defensible. No quantitative evidence has been presented for any method.

Maybe you see a distinction, maybe not.

Nutbag, if people were being steered away from proven treatments and toward AA, the cancer analogy would hold up better. I haven't seen any evidence this is happening. If I heard someone at a meeting telling a depressive to give up Prozac I'd certainly speak up. I agree it's rubbish to assume a newcomer is wrong about everything and that doubting woo is a sign of sickness. But I never thought AA "insisted" that a belief in God is necessary for recovery. I disagreed with individuals all the time but figured their beliefs were their problem, not mine.

Is it a solipsism to say that if people think AA works for them, AA does work for them?
 
PN, see how well that worked?

You came in and left quickly. The sober people were then able to use their time more effectively by helping the willing.

Changing the wording in the literature as you suggest would have screwed all that up. It might have taken some time for you to find other sufficient reasons to drink, so as it stands the entire process is streamlined for maximum effectiveness.

I wasn't looking for verification of the points in my last post, but your experience mirrors them perfectly. Don't you just love coincidence?
 
Overgeneralization doesn't make all your posts wrong; it just makes them easier to pick apart. Example: "It has been shown that by all definitions AA is a religious organization." No it hasn't. You may think the "spiritual vs. religious" distinction is hooey, but quite a few people make a distinction.

"It has been shown by six dictionary definitions" would be more effective.

In order to pick my posts apart you would have to show they are wrong which you have not been able to do. The "over" generalization in your example is not. It isn't even a generalization. It is a simple fact. In order to make the claim "AA is spiritual not religious" apologists have had to ignore the actual definitions of those words and create ones of their own.

You say, "It has been shown that there is no evidence that AA attendance improves success rates." Actually, no. The lack of evidence on this forum does not prove there's no evidence. "No quantitative evidence has been presented" would be more defensible. No quantitative evidence has been presented for any method.

Was it Richard Feynman or Carl Sagan who said something to the effect that when you start arguing the words you want your opponent to use instead of the actual words they used to express a simple idea, you have conceded the argument? Which ever, I accept your surrender.

Maybe you see a distinction, maybe not.

There is a difference but I stand behind what I said simply because not a single person in this thread has been able to provide evidence that AA has any effect. I think with the number of participants and how easy it is to access information these days, if there were evidence it would have been presented by now. And the fact is, the pro-AAers are responsible for presenting it. They have been completely unable to.

That I choose to call a fact a fact and not coddle apologists' feelings by allowing them some wiggle room is just the way I am. If you think I am wrong, put up the evidence.
 
PN, see how well that worked?

You came in and left quickly. The sober people were then able to use their time more effectively by helping the willing.

Changing the wording in the literature as you suggest would have screwed all that up. It might have taken some time for you to find other sufficient reasons to drink, so as it stands the entire process is streamlined for maximum effectiveness.

I wasn't looking for verification of the points in my last post, but your experience mirrors them perfectly. Don't you just love coincidence?

BS Mondo. The whole "willingness" theme in AA is used, as you just did, as a convenient excuse to explain why the vast majority of people who end up in AA don't get any benefit. I wanted help, but it was clear that to me then that AA didn't have the tools necessary. The only reason I ever went to AA after that is because it was highly recommended by my treatment center, and as soon as the cognitive dissonance of pretending to believe in AA's methods while knowing they didn't work was too much, I left. Your post is a great example of why posters on this thread have been arguing that AA is a cult. Instead of critically examining the program and refining it to provide the best possible treatment to alcoholics, those who are capable of seeing how ridiculous AA is are swept aside as unwilling, stubborn, sick, or hopeless. I'll make this clear: I didn't fail AA, AA failed me. It failed me because it is more concerned with a dogmatic adherence to a set of religious principles than it is with actually helping people who are struggling. The process isn't "streamlined". It's designed to stifle contrary opinions and brand those who hold them as outcasts who aren't good enough for the program. What kind of treatment does that?

Minoosh, I don't really know if people are being steered from more effective treatments. What I do know is that there are effective treatment methods (CBT, REBT, opiate replacement, etc.) that have failed to take hold in a major way, at least in the US, because of the dominance of AA. I don't wish to see AA disappear, but I do think that it has such a prominent position in the recovery industry that it has crowded out more effective and inclusive treatment options that should be much more common than they are. I only found a non-12 step treatment program through dumb luck, and from the little bit of research Ive done, they're relatively few and far between. From my experience, while AA doesn't claim to insist upon anything, the social pressure to conform is quite strong. I left the program primarily because of the reaction I received when discussing my atheism both at meetings and with AAs outside of meetings. One of many anecdotes related to this: I distinctly remember having a conversation with a guy I deeply respected and who had been a great support for me. He was recounting a story of how a speaker had said that newcomers shouldn't worry about finding god because it had no bearing on sobriety. This friend of mine literally told him in the meeting that he was pushing them away from the "solution" and killing newcomers, and that the entire meeting tore the speaker to shreds. I've witnessed similar things as well, but to hear it from someone who I had previously thought to be such a reasonable person really changed the way I viewed the "recommended" parts of AA.

As to your last point, I've thought a lot about that and I'm really not sure. Even if AA doesn't help anyone recover at all, but makes their lives more fulfilled, then I don't want to see it gone. There's no doubt that strong social support can be really comforting when getting sober, and that's one thing that AA tends to do a pretty good job at.
 
It isn't even a generalization. It is a simple fact.

The word "all" is the tip-off. When you are confident you have mustered "all" definitions, you will be in a position to make your case.

Was it Richard Feynman or Carl Sagan who said something to the effect that when you start arguing the words you want your opponent to use instead of the actual words they used to express a simple idea, you have conceded the argument?

I used your words.

Would you agree that the Declaration of Independence is a religious document?

I think with the number of participants and how easy it is to access information these days, if there were evidence it would have been presented by now. And the fact is, the pro-AAers are responsible for presenting it. They have been completely unable to.

Anecdotal evidence has been presented in favor of AA. Anecdotal evidence in favor of other modalities has been lacking. AA itself is never going to do the kind of study you want: It's not going to require one group to stay and another group to stay away. It would have no way of tracking and controlling the study. It's an interesting question, what a longitudinal or double-blind study would show; but it is specious to hold AA or AA supporters responsible for the lack of such a study.

NB, re CBT, etc. I believe treatment programs overall are trying to broaden their approaches. As it happens no one has presented quantitative evidence here that anything works. But: Just going to a meeting instead of a bar is behavior modification. Going 24 hours without using is a cognitive revelation, if you've long believed you couldn't go 24 hours without using. Opiate replacement therapy may be underutilized; unfortunately the clinics have a financial interest in keeping people on drugs.

When I went to AA I benefited from a certain skepticism about authority figures. I seem to be well-insulated against putting too much stock in individual opinions. The official literature's disclaimers allowed me to take it at face value: Belief in God is optional.

I hope this thread helps someone.
 
I understand these were not directed at me, but I finally had to jump in again to this thread after getting a bit tired of it.


"It has been shown by six dictionary definitions" would be more effective.

"...and by the 9th circuit court of appeals in the US." Would be even more accurate (and thus effective).


You say, "It has been shown that there is no evidence that AA attendance improves success rates." Actually, no. The lack of evidence on this forum does not prove there's no evidence. "No quantitative evidence has been presented" would be more defensible. No quantitative evidence has been presented for any method.

Wrong.


Anecdotal evidence has been presented in favor of AA. Anecdotal evidence in favor of other modalities has been lacking.

Wrong.


AA itself is never going to do the kind of study you want: It's not going to require one group to stay and another group to stay away.

Gee, I wonder why AA would never do a proper study.


It would have no way of tracking and controlling the study. It's an interesting question, what a longitudinal or double-blind study would show; but it is specious to hold AA or AA supporters responsible for the lack of such a study.

Who then is responsible if not the organization's head nor the organization's members?


NB, re CBT, etc. I believe treatment programs overall are trying to broaden their approaches. As it happens no one has presented quantitative evidence here that anything works.

Wrong.


But: Just going to a meeting instead of a bar is behavior modification. Going 24 hours without using is a cognitive revelation, if you've long believed you couldn't go 24 hours without using. Opiate replacement therapy may be underutilized; unfortunately the clinics have a financial interest in keeping people on drugs.

I agree with this, save for the last part which I'm unsure that's true.


The official literature's disclaimers allowed me to take it at face value: Belief in God is optional.

I don't ever remember the official literature saying belief in a Higher Power is optional.


I hope this thread helps someone.

As do I. :)
 
gayak:

'That I choose to call a fact a fact and not coddle apologists' feelings by allowing them some wiggle room is just the way I am.'

Since that's the way gayak rolls, may I ask what was it that pleased you so much regarding the methodology of the scientific research studies on ibogaine treatment that despite their ficticious existence you still found so satisfactory?

Was it the way the non-existent scientists were careful to keep the non-existent protocol intact throughout the non-existent study of the widely representative and tremendously vague number of imaginary patients that participated?

Something must have pleased you about these studies that you say completely satisfy your standards for scientific study methodology without having actually taken place. Without wiggling too much, could you give us some idea of what those items are?

Or did you mean the opposite of your plainly worded statement again?
 
PN:

You took the long way to say it, the time-honored and far too-common belief that AA, by foolishly not doing away with what you found objectionable in the literature and validating the things you believed regarding the nature of alcoholism and what it takes to recover (in which were naturally sound and correct, given that you were sure they were) that AA failed you and should be very sorry they lost your support. AA should change what has worked very well for millions to line up more with what you and people who see things the way you see them believe at the point where they are shaking it out in meetings, because they are so much more fully informed than anyone else has been or will ever be.

Those beliefs are almost universal among new people, and after a while no one with sense even hears it when they lay it all out yet again.

Regarding what your friend told you, another member could say the opposite and have no more weight than your friend or than the speaker he dressed down. Interesting that he made such an impression on you and those who say the opposite apparently made none.

He was obviously bad, very bad. And wrong, very wrong. There's more like him out there and who knows what else you may hear someone say that will radically alter your life, as happened in your example?

You can surely see how vulnerable your direction in life is at all times, subject to any asinine comment you happen to overhear. Be careful on all public transportation.

Or, you could become the kind of fellow who accepts responsibilty for your decisions, such as your decision to leave AA and how you spent your time afterward without placing it on this guy or what you heard some other bozo say in a parking lot, or the things in the AA material that offended you way back when.

Go forward with whatever you've got now. Figuring out what or who's to blame for wronging you so grieviously in your last run at AA is a dead end. No one other than yourself cares in the least, truth be told.

And another truth, one I experienced is that it all may strike you completely differently at some point years later. That's also and unfortunately too-common among us.
 
PN:

You took the long way to say it, the time-honored and far too-common belief that AA, by foolishly not doing away with what you found objectionable in the literature and validating the things you believed regarding the nature of alcoholism and what it takes to recover (in which were naturally sound and correct, given that you were sure they were) that AA failed you and should be very sorry they lost your support. AA should change what has worked very well for millions to line up more with what you and people who see things the way you see them believe at the point where they are shaking it out in meetings, because they are so much more fully informed than anyone else has been or will ever be.

Those beliefs are almost universal among new people, and after a while no one with sense even hears it when they lay it all out yet again.

Regarding what your friend told you, another member could say the opposite and have no more weight than your friend or than the speaker he dressed down. Interesting that he made such an impression on you and those who say the opposite apparently made none.

He was obviously bad, very bad. And wrong, very wrong. There's more like him out there and who knows what else you may hear someone say that will radically alter your life, as happened in your example?

You can surely see how vulnerable your direction in life is at all times, subject to any asinine comment you happen to overhear. Be careful on all public transportation.

Or, you could become the kind of fellow who accepts responsibilty for your decisions, such as your decision to leave AA and how you spent your time afterward without placing it on this guy or what you heard some other bozo say in a parking lot, or the things in the AA material that offended you way back when.

Go forward with whatever you've got now. Figuring out what or who's to blame for wronging you so grieviously in your last run at AA is a dead end. No one other than yourself cares in the least, truth be told.

And another truth, one I experienced is that it all may strike you completely differently at some point years later. That's also and unfortunately too-common among us.

I'm not blaming anyone about me leaving AA. My life is pretty awesome right now and has been for a while. With the exception of this thread and the occasional talk with some other sober people, I really don't give AA much thought.

You're twisting my words again though. I didn't leave AA because it offended me or I thought I was better informed, or because of one comment a friend made. I stayed in the program for more than a year after that comment and only offered it as an example of how AA stifles criticism. I left AA because it's a faith-healing organization and faith healing is not effective nor plausible. That should be the end of the discussion. Anything else is superfluous. In order to believe that AA is a reasonable treatment, you have to believe that there is divine intervention. This, of course, is antithetical to everything we know about modern medicine. My problem with AA is not my experience, because I'm doing absolutely fine. My issue is that there are people who need actual treatment who aren't getting it because of the undeserved primacy of 12-step based treatment options. People are literally dying because of this.

Please don't claim AA has worked for millions. This is a bald assertion and you can't back it up. AA shouldn't change to fit my opinions. It should embrace modern medicine and scientific data regarding addiction/alcoholism. The way you frame this as me having a problem with the program, instead of the program being woefully inadequate, is a perfect example of how AA avoids criticism and demands conformity.

Your ad homs are also noticed. You can't substantively respond to any of the points I've made, so you result to insults. Classy!
 
Gee, I wonder why AA would never do a proper study.

Sarcasm noted. As explained, AA isn't going to do a study that requires one group to come and requires another group to stay away. It is not going to do random sobriety checks. Ironically, and antithetically to some posters' beliefs, AA is not controlling enough to do a controlled study.

Who then is responsible if not the organization's head nor the organization's members?

Odd question. If you wanted an unbiased study of an organization, why would you want that organization to do the study? And why does anyone have to be "responsible"?

I don't believe that a nonprofit organization that doesn't charge, advertise or force anyone to do anything has stopped the pursuit of science-based addiction treatment in its tracks. (I say that just in case you think AA is evil, as opposed to merely useless.)

I don't ever remember the official literature saying belief in a Higher Power is optional.

Just about everything in AA is optional. The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking and as a practical matter that still doesn't bar attendance, since members can't read your mind.

Atheists and agnostics on this thread provide better evidence than I could that belief in God is optional. As for belief in a higher power, almost by definition alcoholics already have one - alcohol.

If you can quit or moderate without AA, then you don't need AA. If you think it might help, do the skeptical thing: Check it out.
 
I take the posters who have had bad experiences with AA at their word. AA members are fallible human beings. They can be jerks. They can be wonderful.

But please be wary of claims that begin with:

"AA makes you ..." or "In AA you have to ..." or "In AA everyone ..."

AA has no coercive power.

You don't have to be "religious."

Don't write off a potentially lifesaving resource based solely on the negative comments here.
 
The word "all" is the tip-off. When you are confident you have mustered "all" definitions, you will be in a position to make your case.

I have. Look in any dictionary, all the applicable definitions show AA is religious.

I used your words.

No, you told me I didn't mean what I said and then went on to tell me what I really meant. You were, and are, mistaken.

Would you agree that the Declaration of Independence is a religious document?

Haven't thought about it, nor does it interest me at this point in time. Sorry.

Anecdotal evidence has been presented in favor of AA.

Not so much. Many claims have been made but no real evidence. Someone saying "AA done cured me" isn't evidence, anecdotal or otherwise.

AA itself is never going to do the kind of study you want: It's not going to require one group to stay and another group to stay away. It would have no way of tracking and controlling the study. It's an interesting question, what a longitudinal or double-blind study would show; but it is specious to hold AA or AA supporters responsible for the lack of such a study.

Not if AA and its members make claims about it being effective.

Opiate replacement therapy may be underutilized; unfortunately the clinics have a financial interest in keeping people on drugs.

Why? There are more than enough addicts to replace any that are cured.

When I went to AA I benefited from a certain skepticism about authority figures. I seem to be well-insulated against putting too much stock in individual opinions. The official literature's disclaimers allowed me to take it at face value: Belief in God is optional.

I am also skeptical of authority figures, mostly from my experiences with them but I don't see where AA gives anyone the option of believing when the program is based on that belief.
 
Sarcasm noted. As explained, AA isn't going to do a study that requires one group to come and requires another group to stay away. It is not going to do random sobriety checks. Ironically, and antithetically to some posters' beliefs, AA is not controlling enough to do a controlled study.
Two problems with what you posted:
  • you are only describing one sort of study and claiming therefore that no studies can be done with AA
  • and why wouldn't AA wish to do studies?


Odd question. If you wanted an unbiased study of an organization, why would you want that organization to do the study? And why does anyone have to be "responsible"?
You stated, "...but it is specious to hold AA or AA supporters responsible for the lack of such a study" so why then did you not ask yourself first why anyone has to be responsible? However, my point is that I find it strange that the organization which purports amazing success with "millions of people" wouldn't want to be responsible for finding out exactly why.


I don't believe that a nonprofit organization that doesn't charge, advertise or force anyone to do anything has stopped the pursuit of science-based addiction treatment in its tracks. (I say that just in case you think AA is evil, as opposed to merely useless.)
Thank you for your clarification.


Just about everything in AA is optional. The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking and as a practical matter that still doesn't bar attendance, since members can't read your mind.
Sounds to me like some disheartening parallels between AA and homeopathy: "take what you want and leave the rest" (notwithstanding that that is nowhere in the official literature) and homeopathy's individuized treatment; writings and philosophies of treatment which have not changed since their inception; vague statements of each methods' inability to be scientifically tested and validated; and so on.

As has been shown by links in this thread (which you've denied being linked), one of the biggest studies into AA was done by an enthusiastic AA member who wanted to prove to everyone the incredible effectiveness which he himself had experienced only to find that it really wasn't the case.


Atheists and agnostics on this thread provide better evidence than I could that belief in God is optional. As for belief in a higher power, almost by definition alcoholics already have one - alcohol.
Only if you believe in the AA doctrine.


If you can quit or moderate without AA, then you don't need AA. If you think it might help, do the skeptical thing: Check it out.
What we're trying to do here is do far more than 'think it might help' and find out if it actually does help.

You'll also find out that most who question AA in this thread have already checked it out; there are only a few who have not gone to a meeting to check it out either, but I would hazard a guess and say that they have checked out AA in other ways which, in this case, could be more productive towards the goal of forming an unbiased (or, worst case, contra-biased) viewpoint for others to examine.
 
I have. Look in any dictionary, all the applicable definitions show AA is religious.

Ha! The first one I bothered to try, Dictionary.com:

Alcoholics Anonymous 
noun
an organization of alcoholics whose purpose is to stay sober and help others recover from the disease of alcoholism. Abbreviation: AA, A.A.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom