Minoosh
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 15, 2011
- Messages
- 12,906
Gayak, you make reasonable arguments that suffer from over-generalization. The "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" analogy is creative and thought-provoking. It's more effective than constructions that start with "Everyone in AA ...," "AA makes everyone ..."
Poster Nutbag, you asked a really interesting question: 'If you think AA works, do you think it works in the way in which AA's official position says it does? Does god really fix a spiritual deficiency and miraculously remove the desire to drink if you perform the 12-steps? Or is it the social aspect that helps?'
My experience: The craving was suddenly gone. I had heard about the desire being removed, but I thought that meant, "You'll feel so good you won't want to use." In contrast - that day I felt so bad, I didn't think using would help. I also thought, "Why bother using, I'll just want more." That was pretty much a first step - "powerlessness" meant that if I used I couldn't count on controlling the outcome. I'd been going to AA when this happened but I didn't have a sponsor and wasn't really trying to do a first step.
Nutbag, I'm not trying to be obtuse when I question the use of "AA's official position." Bill Wilson had a "white light" experience that might have been helped along by belladonna, he and his buddies came up with the wording of the steps and it hasn't changed. The 12 steps in agnostic AA would, in my opinion, work just as well. Both use words to model an internal shift that words can only approximate.
It's impossible for me to sort out what "worked" - cognitive, behavioral, social, spiritual. I include "spiritual" because that word has a meaning for me distinct from the first three. "Religious" does not mean the same thing to me. I realize many atheists/agnostics don't make this distinction.
Poster Nutbag, you asked a really interesting question: 'If you think AA works, do you think it works in the way in which AA's official position says it does? Does god really fix a spiritual deficiency and miraculously remove the desire to drink if you perform the 12-steps? Or is it the social aspect that helps?'
My experience: The craving was suddenly gone. I had heard about the desire being removed, but I thought that meant, "You'll feel so good you won't want to use." In contrast - that day I felt so bad, I didn't think using would help. I also thought, "Why bother using, I'll just want more." That was pretty much a first step - "powerlessness" meant that if I used I couldn't count on controlling the outcome. I'd been going to AA when this happened but I didn't have a sponsor and wasn't really trying to do a first step.
Nutbag, I'm not trying to be obtuse when I question the use of "AA's official position." Bill Wilson had a "white light" experience that might have been helped along by belladonna, he and his buddies came up with the wording of the steps and it hasn't changed. The 12 steps in agnostic AA would, in my opinion, work just as well. Both use words to model an internal shift that words can only approximate.
It's impossible for me to sort out what "worked" - cognitive, behavioral, social, spiritual. I include "spiritual" because that word has a meaning for me distinct from the first three. "Religious" does not mean the same thing to me. I realize many atheists/agnostics don't make this distinction.