Minoosh
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 15, 2011
- Messages
- 12,906
Then we have the fact that despite the successful trials of naltrexone people are steered away from that in AA
Joey. Dude. Please. Do you have any evidence that people are steered away from naltrexone in AA?
Re: Stanton Peele. His article piles on the unsupported claims:
"Since the 12-step mantra is that substance use problems only grow worse without their intervention, AA members must deny this reality ("All the youthful drug users have died!")."
This isn't the 12-step mantra, and AA members don't insist all youthful drug users have died, and Peele knows better.
There doesn't have to be a conflict between harm reduction and abstinence. Some people have found that for themselves the only effective harm reduction is abstinence. Peele makes this point nicely by citing people who quit smoking. Many, probably most, do so after multiple efforts have proven that abstinence is easier than moderating.
Studies can be done on addicts/alcoholics who are not interested and never go to AA as a control group
Yes. But you have strongly suggested that AA should do the studies. And AA rather avoids seeking out people who are not interested. So, someone else should do studies. Suggestions below.
When some AA groups felt similarly, they decided to make a few alterations to the 12 steps and the AA World Organization decided that was no longer AA.
Two meetings in Toronto were left out of a meeting book by Toronto Intergroup. If you find it was a worldwide ruling let me know.
But at any rate, what's wrong with AA saying "That's not AA"? Do you see them trying to stop these folks from meeting and even using "agnosticaa" to describe themselves?
What you would hesitate to call AA - my scenario of a secular spirituality - is the way it works in practice for a lot of people, including atheists who don't hesitate to call it AA.
AA as such isn't the only game in town, true; but ~90% of all treatment agencies in the US are 12-step based which severely undercuts your argument.
Who is responsible for the treatment industry? The treatment industry. Who's responsible for government policy? The government. Who's responsible for peddling pharmaceutical treatments? The drug company. Etc.
Quoting from Scientific American, just for the heck of it:
In 2006 psychologist Rudolf H. Moos of the Department of Veterans Affairs and Stanford University and Bernice S. Moos published results from a 16-year study of problem drinkers who had tried to quit on their own or who had sought help from AA, professional therapists or, in some cases, both. Of those who attended at least 27 weeks of AA meetings during the first year, 67 percent were abstinent at the 16-year follow-up, compared with 34 percent of those who did not participate in AA.
http://http://www.clinmedres.org/cgi/content/full/4/3/163
