Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Then we have the fact that despite the successful trials of naltrexone people are steered away from that in AA

Joey. Dude. Please. Do you have any evidence that people are steered away from naltrexone in AA?

Re: Stanton Peele. His article piles on the unsupported claims:

"Since the 12-step mantra is that substance use problems only grow worse without their intervention, AA members must deny this reality ("All the youthful drug users have died!")."

This isn't the 12-step mantra, and AA members don't insist all youthful drug users have died, and Peele knows better.

There doesn't have to be a conflict between harm reduction and abstinence. Some people have found that for themselves the only effective harm reduction is abstinence. Peele makes this point nicely by citing people who quit smoking. Many, probably most, do so after multiple efforts have proven that abstinence is easier than moderating.

Studies can be done on addicts/alcoholics who are not interested and never go to AA as a control group

Yes. But you have strongly suggested that AA should do the studies. And AA rather avoids seeking out people who are not interested. So, someone else should do studies. Suggestions below.

When some AA groups felt similarly, they decided to make a few alterations to the 12 steps and the AA World Organization decided that was no longer AA.

Two meetings in Toronto were left out of a meeting book by Toronto Intergroup. If you find it was a worldwide ruling let me know.

But at any rate, what's wrong with AA saying "That's not AA"? Do you see them trying to stop these folks from meeting and even using "agnosticaa" to describe themselves?

What you would hesitate to call AA - my scenario of a secular spirituality - is the way it works in practice for a lot of people, including atheists who don't hesitate to call it AA.

AA as such isn't the only game in town, true; but ~90% of all treatment agencies in the US are 12-step based which severely undercuts your argument.

Who is responsible for the treatment industry? The treatment industry. Who's responsible for government policy? The government. Who's responsible for peddling pharmaceutical treatments? The drug company. Etc.

Quoting from Scientific American, just for the heck of it:

In 2006 psychologist Rudolf H. Moos of the Department of Veterans Affairs and Stanford University and Bernice S. Moos published results from a 16-year study of problem drinkers who had tried to quit on their own or who had sought help from AA, professional therapists or, in some cases, both. Of those who attended at least 27 weeks of AA meetings during the first year, 67 percent were abstinent at the 16-year follow-up, compared with 34 percent of those who did not participate in AA.

http://http://www.clinmedres.org/cgi/content/full/4/3/163
 
All of those methods have science behind them, which anyone can look up for themselves. An old game is being played here which isn't fooling anyone.

How is naltrexone and the associated genetic test that shows it's chances of working on you not some of the best science?

Sometimes people defend things that they have no interest in actually learning about, like people who defend ear candling and obfuscate over meanings despite the overwhelming evidence it is total delusion.
 
Pharmacological treatment of alcohol dependence: a review of the evidence.

http://http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10208148


Naltrexone (grade A) reduces the risk of relapse to heavy drinking and the frequency of drinking compared with placebo but does not substantially enhance abstinence, ie, avoidance of any alcohol consumption.

Naltrexone does not enhance abstinence, which may be fine for some people. And not so fine for other people. In addition a Canadian study cited cost as a potential factor - $5 a day, plus the cost of liver function studies to before and after to make sure you're not getting poisoned. It's usually prescribed for three months.

If the cost in Canada is $5 a day what do you figure it is in the U.S.?

Another caveat: If you are on naltrexone and for some reason end up in a lot of physical pain, naltrexone will block the pain-killing effects of narcotics. So you might want to wear a little bracelet in case you end up with a compound fracture and the morphine isn't working.

And, it is not recommended to use naltrexone without psychosocial support. Which means you may end up in meetings. If cost and insurance coverage are not a barrier, you can probably do non-AA intensive outpatient for oh, $3,000 or so.
 
Yes. But you have strongly suggested that AA should do the studies. And AA rather avoids seeking out people who are not interested. So, someone else should do studies. Suggestions below.

I'm failing to see the problem here. AA -- or any researchers for that matter -- puts the word out that they're looking for volunteers.



Two meetings in Toronto were left out of a meeting book by Toronto Intergroup. If you find it was a worldwide ruling let me know.

How did the Toronto Intergroup get the authority then? It's written in the 12 traditions and I'm sure in the AA World Intergroup charter what exactly the hierarchy is and at which level these kinds of decisions have to be made.


But at any rate, what's wrong with AA saying "That's not AA"? Do you see them trying to stop these folks from meeting and even using "agnosticaa" to describe themselves?

There's nothing wrong with it. My argument is that the decision to de-list a group that makes changes to be more inclusive and (admittedly according to those groups' beliefs) more in accordance to the spirit of the AA method/movement, goes to the heart of when people say "take what you want and leave the rest" and all the other ways people make their own program, simply aren't doing AA.



What you would hesitate to call AA - my scenario of a secular spirituality - is the way it works in practice for a lot of people, including atheists who don't hesitate to call it AA.

I hesitate to call it AA is because it doesn't follow what AA says of itself. AA says, "this is what it means to be 'in AA' and here's what it takes to be able to call yourself an AA group." The de-listing is a very visible example that the organization still has sway in saying what goes on in that organization, just as all organizations do. It's just not quite the free-for-all that many members like to present.



Who is responsible for the treatment industry? The treatment industry. Who's responsible for government policy? The government. Who's responsible for peddling pharmaceutical treatments? The drug company. Etc.

I'm saying that the treatment industry, the government and so on have been heavily pressured and frankly lied to regarding AA's success numbers. Policies have been set, courts are actively involved in shuttling people off to AA, and so on, with no actual evidence that it works and this has been going on for at least fifty years.



Quoting from Scientific American, just for the heck of it:

In 2006 psychologist Rudolf H. Moos of the Department of Veterans Affairs and Stanford University and Bernice S. Moos published results from a 16-year study of problem drinkers who had tried to quit on their own or who had sought help from AA, professional therapists or, in some cases, both. Of those who attended at least 27 weeks of AA meetings during the first year, 67 percent were abstinent at the 16-year follow-up, compared with 34 percent of those who did not participate in AA.

http://http://www.clinmedres.org/cgi/content/full/4/3/163

That's a really great study! I'm very pleased you found it and posted it, thank you.

My only issues with it are that the study was measuring gender differences in treatment success rates and AA is not isolated (the terms 'self-help group' and 'AA' are conflated as used in the text). In other words, there are differences between AA and self-help groups, but the study only seemed to use AA.

My interpretation of this study is that the people who were more social (used more family, friends, and support groups) tended to fare much better. However, based on this study, we don't know if the deciding factor was the AA program itself versus development of a stronger sober social support network in general. This ties in with my previous paragraph; the study didn't seem to measure people seeking non-twelve-step meetings for drugs/alcohol such as SOS or Lifering or going to community centers or churches.

Though I will admit that one of the strengths of AA is that anyone can go into nearly any random town in America and find an AA group to attend.
 
This thread is off Moderated Status. Do not engage in the kinds of behavior that got it on Moderated Status to begin with or it will be placed back on Moderated or even closed.

Keep it on topic. Keep it civil and do not personalize the issue.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
All of those methods have science behind them, which anyone can look up for themselves. An old game is being played here which isn't fooling anyone.

Indeed!
The game where someone makes outrageous claims, doesn't or can't support them, and then tells others to look up the non existent information. :rolleyes:

Like you said, it's not fooling anyone.
 
Last edited:
This thread is off Moderated Status. Do not engage in the kinds of behavior that got it on Moderated Status to begin with or it will be placed back on Moderated or even closed.

Keep it on topic. Keep it civil and do not personalize the issue.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis

Open season!



Just kidding.



Sort of, :)
 
Joey. Dude. Please. Do you have any evidence that people are steered away from naltrexone in AA?
Off the top of my head there is an article shown in the Penn and Teller episode, timestamped here, which I paused to type this out. From Lennie S., a local AA spokeswoman,
"We just believe it's not necessary. AA is a program based on a power greater than ourselves."
Then they show the woman saying that it's a band-aid, (not treating the real problem, which is the four-fold disease, mental, physical, emotional, spiritual. Total woo) I was personally told by people in AA that naltrexone was a "band-aid." and googling that, I found some Bill Wilson follower saying, in response to a question about naltrexone
Why not try NA or AA for the cravings? We often run to medication too quicky. Sometimes there are no quick fixes. You have to right what's wrong with yourself before you can truly heal. Putting a band aid on it with another medication doesn't make much sense to me
Seems like they've got their slogans cult speech down pat.

You can surely find some rule or AA literature about telling it's members not to "play doctor" but this is the reality of what people are often told. The main point is that they don't offer a comprehensive approach because it is cult religion. They don't give you options, they tell you to follow the program. My point is that any organization should be offering people these options, or at least making them aware of them. AA isn't set up to help people with harm-reduction because it's shaped on sin/redemption because of the Oxford group, not because they know anything about "true alcoholics."

Re: Stanton Peele. His article piles on the unsupported claims:

"Since the 12-step mantra is that substance use problems only grow worse without their intervention, AA members must deny this reality ("All the youthful drug users have died!")."

This isn't the 12-step mantra, and AA members don't insist all youthful drug users have died, and Peele knows better.
I have heard hundreds of AA'ers talk about their addiction. They all repeat the mantra that "I tried to drink again, and it was worse, it's a progressive disease. A true alcoholic never gets better. " Just look up progressive disease AA, here's an example
I also learned that alcoholism is a chronic, progressive disease that manifests itself with symptoms that affect one physically, mentally, emotionally, spiritually and socially

Here's an addictions guy who was treated like garbage because he dared to drink socially again

About three years ago, I was attending a national conference on public health (American Public Health Association) and presenting my posters on the relationship between drug use and violence, and sexually transmitted infections and injecting drugs. As I walked the aisles I ran into a woman who runs a Florida addiction "treatment" facility. We talked for a bit about my work, her facility, and then we shared some of our personal stories. Mine included meth addiction, jail, recovery, and now graduate school studying addictions. Everything was great until I mentioned that I now drink alcohol socially... "We'll save a seat for you" she told me as she handed me her business card. Idiot.

So you are just splitting hairs over the idea of a "12-step mantra".

There doesn't have to be a conflict between harm reduction and abstinence. Some people have found that for themselves the only effective harm reduction is abstinence. Peele makes this point nicely by citing people who quit smoking. Many, probably most, do so after multiple efforts have proven that abstinence is easier than moderating.
That's the point, AA doesn't try and take care of everyone and address everyone's problem. They make up this crap about "if you can quit drinking on your own, or learn to moderate, you aren't a 'true alcoholic'"whatever that means." And the facts show (posted many, many times in this thread already) that most people quit on their own, without AA.

Despite this the cult carries on with their spiritual abuse.
 
...
Despite this the cult carries on with their spiritual abuse.

If you say so. I have experienced zero abuse at the hands of the folks at AA. I don't know why you choose to vilify a bunch of folks who, regardless of whatever woo they might be into, are trying to support each other. Yeah, they talk about god a lot, but that should come as no surprise since most folks seem to believe in god in one form or another. Maybe living in the bible belt has desensitised me to the god-talk, as I really couldn't care less about what they have to say about their religious beliefs. Hell, I hear just about as much god-talk when I go to the grocery store. Don't care about that, either-- But if folks hoping and praying and believing in magical thinking bothers you so much that you can't see that they're also actually supporting each other in the decision to remain sober, then tilt away. I guess we all have our windmills.
 
Is teaching children about hell child abuse? I say it is.

Is teaching people with addiction problems that they can't get their lives together because they aren't spiritual enough abuse? I say it is.

Spend some time googling aa deprogramming and tell me it's all positivity. Spend some time reading the letters from the Orange Papers and tell me it's a few bad apples. Actually go to a lot of different meetings and talk to a lot of people about these issues that keep coming up. Like I've said here before, there are lots of good people in AA and some groups are worse than others. But look at the core, look at the history of Dr. Bob getting people to get on their knees and "surrender.", look at what the Oxford group stood for and was at it's core.

Can't put lipstick on a pig, is what they say. Really I need to move on, most skeptical people know what's up by now, and really if you can watch the penn and teller episode and still not get it, well, you probably have worse problems than not understanding how 12-step operates in society.
 
Last edited:
This thread is off Moderated Status. Do not engage in the kinds of behavior that got it on Moderated Status to begin with or it will be placed back on Moderated or even closed.

Keep it on topic. Keep it civil and do not personalize the issue.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis

I think having this thread come off Moderation is a good thing.

We just need to remember that while we may differ in our beliefs, we can use rational arguments and cite pertinent facts without resorting to, well, you already know.
 
Off the top of my head there is an article shown in the Penn and Teller episode, timestamped here, which I paused to type this out. From Lennie S., a local AA spokeswoman,
Then they show .

Penn and Teller are scientists now? Seriously?

How about some of that science based evidence you said is available? Put up or shut up, as my dad used to say.
 
Last edited:
The question was "Do you have any evidence that people are steered away from naltrexone in AA?" I have provided that evidence. I used that article they showed, the woman they had on, plus some cult member out on the internet towing the same line about "band-aids". Your objection that they are not scientists make absolutely no sense.

Here is some evidence that even if I do try to explain these things to you, you will not read any of it anyway. Kind of like when we talked about the Cochrane review earlier. If anyone else really wants to ask me about that stuff, I'll work to provide it.

But I'll get you started with my list. Motivational Interviewing.
 
Last edited:
Joey, you really think saying "we'll save a seat for you" is treating someone like garbage? This man's entire article was based on those words.

Re the "Bill Wilson follower" who said, "Why not try NA or AA for the cravings? We often run to medication too quickly." Did you keep reading? Her later post said,
"When I got sober from alcohol and illegal drugs 5 years ago I never thought about taking another drug to fight the cravings but if you feel that is what you need, then God bless and good luck.

And when the original questioner cited research the "Bill Wilson follower said:

A lot of that I didn't know. Maybe if some people I know that have struggled severely in the past could have taken that, they would have remained clean.
If you choose to go that path, keep us updated and as always God bless and good luck!!


Cherry picking?

It bugs you that "AA doesn't try and take care of everyone and address everyone's problem. " No. Has it ever said it does? I'm not an expert on formal logic, but isn't there a phrase for rebutting a claim that was never made?

I hate to repeat that "no true alcoholic" thing, but many people in AA believe they are a certain kind of alcoholic - ones that have tried moderation and have concluded abstinence is the safest course. I don't think it's as bound up with Protestant sin as you believe. For some people abstinence is just better, and they learn it the hard way. This is why you'll see some "selection bias" if you Google "progressive disease AA." You'll get AA members saying this is a progressive disease. I repeat: Chances are they tried moderation more than once before arriving at this belief.

And guess what? AA members aren't there to save the world. They're there to save themselves.

Norseman, you've chosen not to elucidate how AA could conduct the sort of research you want AA to conduct, although you've implied repeatedly that AA really should do these studies.

You seem to think it's OK for AA to track down people who aren't interested in AA and make them promise not to attend meetings, and that it's OK for AA to require some attendees to pray and work the steps and some attendees not to pray and work the steps. Though you say that's not what you meant, you have not shown me what AA's involvement in the study would look like.

Now perhaps the Toronto situation will allow just that sort of laboratory.

You made the statement that AA's world organization made the decision to de-list the group, and I've failed to see you support that claim. It's moot, but it's also sloppy. Nice try on the save, Yeah but ... there are these traditions ... and where do they come from ... so really it was AA's world organization.

Here's something to gnaw on. If more people identify themselves as God-believers than as agnostics, than a group calling itself "agnostic AA" arguably could be less inclusive than a group where vague theists want to develop a relationship with a God of their understanding. Now, that's not a particularly strong argument. But it does go to this idea that AA should be all things to all people, or that it "should help everyone."

I totally get how AA at any level would sincerely believe changing the steps would hurt more than it would help.

Nah, that can't be right. They're just hung up on some stupid meme to keep their ratty little "cult" together. For the money, doncha know. And for the heady glamor of being anonymous. And the kick they get out of treating "sinners" like garbage.

I hope to be out of this thread soon. Lost health insurance, big motivator to get off the harm-reduction Rx, and away from threads that push my buttons as much as this one. I keep doing the same thing and expecting different results.

Insanity.
 
When people want to learn about Scientology, they often talk to Marty Rathburn or Mike Rinder. If you want to learn about the cult of AA, check out xsteppers or aa deprogramming, learn from people who were in it hardcore for +25 years.

Here's a good one, and fairly typical
 
Joey, you really think saying "we'll save a seat for you" is treating someone like garbage? This man's entire article was based on those words.
She immediately broke repore when he mentioned social drinking because people like that are treated as it they still have an active disease. He's treated like an outsider of the cult. It's a fake niceness, I know people just like her, they will talk behind your back and do nothing but try and wear you down until you admit you have the disease just like them and need the cult to cure it.

Re the "Bill Wilson follower" who said, "Why not try NA or AA for the cravings? We often run to medication too quickly." Did you keep reading? Her later post said,
"When I got sober from alcohol and illegal drugs 5 years ago I never thought about taking another drug to fight the cravings but if you feel that is what you need, then God bless and good luck.

And when the original questioner cited research the "Bill Wilson follower said:

A lot of that I didn't know. Maybe if some people I know that have struggled severely in the past could have taken that, they would have remained clean.
If you choose to go that path, keep us updated and as always God bless and good luck!!


Cherry picking?
Wow, the cult programming didn't completely destroy her humanity, but the point was made. No I didn't read the entire thread.

It bugs you that "AA doesn't try and take care of everyone and address everyone's problem. " No. Has it ever said it does? I'm not an expert on formal logic, but isn't there a phrase for rebutting a claim that was never made?
The treatment is the same for everyone. People leave the cult and drink normally for the rest of their lives all the time, having realized the disease and cure idea was complete nonsense. They have no way of figuring this out but "Well, Bob must not have been a 'true alcoholic'" while someone too weak to think for themselves go to a cult program for the rest of their lives, few times a week, and have no friends outside of the program, like that story I just posted.

I hate to repeat that "no true alcoholic" thing, but many people in AA believe they are a certain kind of alcoholic - ones that have tried moderation and have concluded abstinence is the safest course. I don't think it's as bound up with Protestant sin as you believe. For some people abstinence is just better, and they learn it the hard way. This is why you'll see some "selection bias" if you Google "progressive disease AA." You'll get AA members saying this is a progressive disease. I repeat: Chances are they tried moderation more than once before arriving at this belief.
I think you just need to go spend some time around the people who have been in the cult for a long time before leaving, find out what the "back to basics" groups are like. This is too complex an organism, you have to focus on the core situations and the total history of the program instead of the exceptions. People who defend this cult the make a lot of excuses for the bad stuff. If you pressure them they will say they fight against the 13th stepping and the delusional stuff. Well the reason that stuff exists is because of the structure of the program and wouldn't exist in a properly thought out system so it's completely delusional propaganda.

And guess what? AA members aren't there to save the world. They're there to save themselves.
I like science, in science, we are trying to work on every problem simultaneously and learn from each other and do it together. The psychologists work with the medical doctors, the physiotherapists work with the surgeons, the cult does it's own thing because it's the Oxford Group for booze. The Big Book IS the program, and will never change.


Nah, that can't be right. They're just hung up on some stupid meme to keep their ratty little "cult" together. For the money, doncha know. And for the heady glamor of being anonymous. And the kick they get out of treating "sinners" like garbage.
You really have a naive vision of why this group is rightly called a cult. Look up Clancy, he's a real hero.
 
It's a fake niceness, I know people just like her, they will talk behind your back and do nothing but try and wear you down until you admit you have the disease just like them and need the cult to cure it.

Fake niceness = being treated like garbage? And how did you know they were talking about you behind your back?

Wow, the cult programming didn't completely destroy her humanity, but the point was made. No I didn't read the entire thread.

A mild reply was offered and the discussion grew from there. But you'd already found the low-hanging fruit; why should you risk reading something that might contradict that?


The treatment is the same for everyone. People leave the cult and drink normally for the rest of their lives all the time, having realized the disease and cure idea was complete nonsense.

So this is not a disease and therefore not a medical issue?


I like science, in science, we are trying to work on every problem simultaneously and learn from each other and do it together. The psychologists work with the medical doctors, the physiotherapists work with the surgeons.

I like science too. AA isn't science. And since there's no disease there's not much of a medical issue.

You really have a naive vision of why this group is rightly called a cult. Look up Clancy, he's a real hero.

And you have a remarkable ability to discount anything positive said about AA if it contradicts your assertion of culthood.

Insanity. Mine not yours.
 
You said:

Wait, I thought we were talking about how AA is not interested in being studied scientifically and uninterested in in integrating the best that science has to teach us about addiction.

I asked

Please elaborate on "the best that science has to teach us about addiction" as well as the treatments we have from these teachings and the efficacy rates of same.

And I wait.

Here is some evidence that even if I do try to explain these things to you, you will not read any of it anyway. Kind of like when we talked about the Cochrane review earlier.

Rubbish.
And your evidence relates to another topic altogether and one I have limited knowledge and admitted so.

Do you really want to get started on previous or earlier discussions?

But I'll get you started with my list. Motivational Interviewing.

I'm willing to bet that I know a lot more about motivational interviewing than you.

That said, please show me the science on it as a treatment and its efficacy for alcoholism. That link you have provided would not appear to go close. Colour me unsurprised.

You said there was science based evidence. I want to see it, what it is and the efficacy for alcoholism.
 
Last edited:
Fake niceness = being treated like garbage
You just don't get it. They are only nice to you when you are an abstainer and you tow the disease line. You are obsessing over my use of "garbage", they treat them the same way Scientologists treat their "squirrels" or Christians treat their atheists, which is not with respect. You obviously have limited experience with this organization.
And how did you know they were talking about you behind your back?
My back? No. I have heard people talking **** about people who have left AA, they make fun of them for being out doing "research" where they will inevitably find out that indeed, they can't live without the cult. Go read the whole article that Jaffe wrote, calling ******** on the addiction bullies was it called? Again, you haven't been around long.
A mild reply was offered and the discussion grew from there. But you'd already found the low-hanging fruit; why should you risk reading something that might contradict that?
You didn't notice the two representatives steering people away from Naltrexone? One said "You don't need it." The other said "It's a band-aid." People whose only qualifications are being high up in the cult. You're the one going for low-hanging fruit with the third example. And it proved my point, she tried to steer someone away from the drug. And what an idiot, obviously that person knows AA and NA exist if they are sober and going for naltrexone, it's just the robot cult thing but you don't get it... yet.
So this is not a disease and therefore not a medical issue?
:boggled:
I like science too. AA isn't science.
:)
And since there's no disease there's not much of a medical issue.
:boggled:
And you have a remarkable ability to discount anything positive said about AA if it contradicts your assertion of culthood.
That's all the defenders ever finish with. It's the same as all religionists. "We do charity! We provide support! We focus on good stuff!" All stuff non-cult organizations do much better.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom