Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I take the posters who have had bad experiences with AA at their word. AA members are fallible human beings. They can be jerks. They can be wonderful.

But please be wary of claims that begin with:

"AA makes you ..." or "In AA you have to ..." or "In AA everyone ..."

AA has no coercive power.

You don't have to be "religious."

Don't write off a potentially lifesaving resource based solely on the negative comments here.

qft
 
You told me I didn't mean what I said

The opposite: I told you that you didn't say what you meant. My point was petty, though.

Haven't thought about it, nor does it interest me at this point in time. Sorry.

No need to apologize. Since the Declaration mentions a Creator it could be construed as a religious document and it might follow that the U.S. is a religious nation.

Someone saying "AA done cured me" isn't evidence, anecdotal or otherwise.

Mocking the diction of imaginary posters, how incisive.

Anecdotal evidence has weak probative value but if thousands of people say it helped - or are so thoroughly convinced it helped that it, in effect, helped - how is that not anecdotal evidence?

Not if AA and its members make claims about it being effective.

So if someone says "this program worked for me" they're obligated to perform a study?

This summary in Scientific American sounds about right:

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=does-alcoholics-anonymous-work

If someone desperate not to drink or use asked me for help I wouldn't tell them to wait for more studies. If they were in or headed toward life-threatening withdrawal I'd call an ambulance. If they were willing I'd take them to a meeting.

I'd also recommend regular exercise, adequate sleep, a multivitamin and plenty of water. If they were in a position to go to in-patient treatment I'd tell them to consider it. Ditto any appropriate outpatient therapy. If they had any belief in God, I'd recommend prayer. All this depends on being asked.

And, partly as a result of reading (most of) this thread: If they were particularly vulnerable to exploitation or malign influence I'd do what I could to protect them predators.

Compulsions are beastly things. You need all the "effective" you can muster on as many different fronts. Minute by minute. If the meeting buys you just one hour, hey, the hour passed and you didn't drink. It was effective - adequate to accomplish the purpose.

Why? There are more than enough addicts to replace any that are cured.

Some clinics are for-profit. More customers=more money. Fixed costs don't change much.

I don't see where AA gives anyone the option of believing when the program is based on that belief.

AA doesn't have to give you the option. You own the option.

It's a boundary issue. AA can't make you believe in God. I can't make you change your mind. There are atheists in AA. Perhaps you could argue there are no true atheists in AA.

Can't argue with that logic.
 
Ha! The first one I bothered to try, Dictionary.com:

Alcoholics Anonymous 
noun
an organization of alcoholics whose purpose is to stay sober and help others recover from the disease of alcoholism. Abbreviation: AA, A.A.

You must have misread the thread. The word under discussion is "religion" not "Alcoholics Anonymous."
 
The opposite: I told you that you didn't say what you meant. My point was petty, though.

Either way, you are wrong. I said exactly what I meant.

No need to apologize. Since the Declaration mentions a Creator it could be construed as a religious document and it might follow that the U.S. is a religious nation.

No it doesn't follow. You are grasping at straws. Your analogy doesn't work because in practice the US government does not insist on anyone believing in a god.

Anecdotal evidence has weak probative value but if thousands of people say it helped - or are so thoroughly convinced it helped that it, in effect, helped - how is that not anecdotal evidence?

Millions of people say that water mixed with bat guano and diluted 10,000 cured what ails them, does that mean it did?

So if someone says "this program worked for me" they're obligated to perform a study?

No but when AA makes claims about its effectiveness like they always have they should be able to support it. Drug companies have been held liable for making unsupported claims about cures and the effectiveness of their product. If you are telling people the program is effective in order to get them in, there is nothing wrong with people asking for evidence.

Posting on a skeptics list, you should know that.

If someone desperate not to drink or use asked me for help I wouldn't tell them to wait for more studies. If they were in or headed toward life-threatening withdrawal I'd call an ambulance. If they were willing I'd take them to a meeting.

Why haven't the studies been done? AA has been around for a long time making a lot of claims about its effectiveness and yet you still can't give someone an honest answer.

Some clinics are for-profit. More customers=more money. Fixed costs don't change much.

I guess you are saying anyone who makes a profit is unscrupulous and immoral. That hasn't been my experience.

AA doesn't have to give you the option. You own the option.

I think you miss the point. The option is an illusion.

It's a boundary issue. AA can't make you believe in God. I can't make you change your mind.

No, but it can force you out when you don't believe which, as we have seen, happens in AA.

There are atheists in AA. Perhaps you could argue there are no true atheists in AA.

There are gays in the military too, perhaps you can argue their are no true gays in the military. :rolleyes:
 
You are grasping at straws. Your analogy doesn't work because in practice the US government does not insist on anyone believing in a god.

Now you're getting it. Even though the founding document of the US refers prominently to God, and even though its currency bears reference to "trusting" in God, in practice the US government does not insist that you believe in God.

When AA makes claims about its effectiveness like they always have they should be able to support it.

Think on whether AA is a they or an it. It might be relevant.

If you are telling people the program is effective in order to get them in, there is nothing wrong with people asking for evidence.

Agreed which is why I posted the link right above your post.

Why haven't the studies been done? AA has been around for a long time making a lot of claims about its effectiveness and yet you still can't give someone an honest answer.

Asked. Answered. Above.

I guess you are saying anyone who makes a profit is unscrupulous and immoral. That hasn't been my experience.

Logical phallacy # 1: Straw man. Logical phallacy # 2: Per you, your experience is not evidence.[/QUOTE]


No, but it can force you out when you don't believe, which, as we've seen, happens in AA

No, we haven't seen. I accept that you think so.
 
Meaning what they say and saying what they mean?

Ok, so if the "12-Steps" are somehow "not religious", then 6 of them are completely meaningless, since obviously they are somehow "not religious", and don't mean what they say, or say what they mean! But on the other hand, if they DO mean what they say, AND say what they mean, then two things become obvious: a.) They do not apply what to any individual because they are all written in the PLURAL tense, and b.) cannot be "worked" in the present, because they are all written in the PAST tense! So, which is it? Relgious or not? Applicable or not? Current or not? Let's see a "stepper" (if on this board), double-speak their way out of these contradictions. It is because OF their wording that the 12-Steps are, and remain, the most worthless words written into the English language!
 
Ok, so if the "12-Steps" are somehow "not religious", then 6 of them are completely meaningless, since obviously they are somehow "not religious", and don't mean what they say, or say what they mean! But on the other hand, if they DO mean what they say, AND say what they mean, then two things become obvious: a.) They do not apply what to any individual because they are all written in the PLURAL tense, and b.) cannot be "worked" in the present, because they are all written in the PAST tense! So, which is it? Relgious or not? Applicable or not? Current or not? Let's see a "stepper" (if on this board), double-speak their way out of these contradictions. It is because OF their wording that the 12-Steps are, and remain, the most worthless words written into the English language!

Straight out of the Big Book. Page 47.

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."
 
istj:

'Ok, so if the "12-Steps" are somehow "not religious", then 6 of them are completely meaningless, since obviously they are somehow "not religious", and don't mean what they say, or say what they mean! But on the other hand, if they DO mean what they say, AND say what they mean, then two things become obvious: a.) They do not apply what to any individual because they are all written in the PLURAL tense, and b.) cannot be "worked" in the present, because they are all written in the PAST tense! So, which is it? Relgious or not? Applicable or not? Current or not?'

Perhaps I can help with this difficulty, istj.

Regarding your points a&b. The steps are written in the plural tense because they describe what some guys did to never have to drink again, for the pleasure and enlightenment of those who might also want to achieve that result by doing the same actions in the present.

To make it easier for you, picture yourself wanting to enjoy a nice cool swim on a terribly hot Summer day. You see some guys relaxing on a porch who are wet and cool and obviously refreshed. When you ask how they got that way they say 'we went down that road to the ol' swimmin' hole and we dove right in from the bank next to the rusted plow where the water is nice and deep.'

Speaking from their experience in the plural perspective, with information you could use to your benefit in the present. Is it all better and clearer now?

You could of course ignore their suggestions and walk the opposite way down the street and stay all stunk-up, or you could take just part of their suggestions and go to the pond but then for reasons of your own choose to dive headfirst into the shallow and rocky part.

That's sure easy enough to picture.

Was that about it, or can we clear anything else up for you?
 
As explained, AA isn't going to do a study that requires one group to come and requires another group to stay away. It is not going to do random sobriety checks. Ironically, and antithetically to some posters' beliefs, AA is not controlling enough to do a controlled study.

This is not even close to the truth. The truth of the matter is that AAs do participate in studies all the time, and they do so with outside control groups. What AA will not do is a study on how well it works in getting people to quit drinking. At least, they won't do it anymore. They did, but since every one of them showed it in fact is worthless, they stopped doing that.

What they will do are studies on other things which look favorable to AA, but proves nothing. Like studies to determine if there is a correlation between AA attendance and continued abstinence. Or a study on spirituality. Lots of things. But they avoid studies on effectiveness of AA like the plague.
 
Now you're getting it. Even though the founding document of the US refers prominently to God, and even though its currency bears reference to "trusting" in God, in practice the US government does not insist that you believe in God.

Not getting it at all. There is no correlation between the DoI and what AA does. The BB isn't a "founding" document. It is the current go to document on how AA is run. It states AA's must believe in god if they want any chance of recovery and that policy is enforced. All other AA literature is equal to the BB in religiosity.

Think on whether AA is a they or an it. It might be relevant.

Its the apologists who need to think. When we say AA is an it, apologists say it is a collection of people, a they. When we say AA is a they, those same apologists claim it is an it.

It is a word dance which is what all their claims amount to.

Logical phallacy # 1: Straw man. Logical phallacy # 2: Per you, your experience is not evidence.

How did your conspiracy theory become my logical fallacy. I think you should take a moment and re-read those portions of the thread that you appear to have skipped. A refresher on what a straw man fallacy would also be a good idea.
 
I am bumping this to the top to give Bondotuna, who may have missed it, an opportunity to respond. This is exactly the point I have been trying to make since the beginning of the thread and I think Poster put it brilliantly.

It seems both groups are alive and well, I will be joining one of them very shortly:

http://aatorontoagnostics.org/

Also I think this would be a good read for those interested in the history of agnosticism in AA,:

http://aatorontoagnostics.org/2011/09/27/a-history-of-agnostic-groups-in-aa/

Apparently the battle started long before this thread :)

From the link:

The action taken by the GTA Intergroup was extreme. But there has always been tension between agnostics and the Christian members of Alcoholics Anonymous. What happened at the Intergroup meeting in that church basement in Toronto merely exposed a long-festering wound in AA
 
This is not even close to the truth. The truth of the matter is that AAs do participate in studies all the time, and they do so with outside control groups. What AA will not do is a study on how well it works in getting people to quit drinking. At least, they won't do it anymore. They did, but since every one of them showed it in fact is worthless, they stopped doing that.

What they will do are studies on other things which look favorable to AA, but proves nothing. Like studies to determine if there is a correlation between AA attendance and continued abstinence. Or a study on spirituality. Lots of things. But they avoid studies on effectiveness of AA like the plague.

Is there anything that you are quoting from, are you citing something. I noticed you have no links or a plausible explanation.
Just as usual writing your opinions which as you stated on your radio program that you are limited in. Your words.
 
I don't know what people are picturing when they complain AA doesn't do studies. I'm assuming some people are asking sincerely.

There is no study structure I can think of that wouldn't conflict with AA's reason for being. It's not going to require one group to stay and one to stay away. It's not even going to ask you for your name, let alone follow you around and track how you're doing if you stop showing up. It's not going to ask you if you're sober, or how long you've been sober. It doesn't ask attendees anything, let alone poke around for non-attendees who are trying some other option. People are free to come and go as they please and do whatever they want.

That might not be a very satisfying answer for some of you, but given the diffuse nature of the organization, the relative autonomy of specific groups and the flexibility of AA practice, the parent organization has no way to enforce the parameters of a study. The Scientific American article explains that fairly well.
 
I don't know what people are picturing when they complain AA doesn't do studies. I'm assuming some people are asking sincerely.

Part of the issue is that AA used to do studies, and do so no longer. The question is why?



There is no study structure I can think of that wouldn't conflict with AA's reason for being.

What is 'AA's reason for being' and what study structures can you name specifically that would conflict with 'AA's reason for being'?



It's not going to require one group to stay and one to stay away. It's not even going to ask you for your name, let alone follow you around and track how you're doing if you stop showing up. It's not going to ask you if you're sober, or how long you've been sober. It doesn't ask attendees anything, let alone poke around for non-attendees who are trying some other option. People are free to come and go as they please and do whatever they want.

This seems like you are not understanding the methodologies of the different types of studies.


That might not be a very satisfying answer for some of you, but given the diffuse nature of the organization, the relative autonomy of specific groups and the flexibility of AA practice, the parent organization has no way to enforce the parameters of a study. The Scientific American article explains that fairly well.

Sounds to me like special pleading.

For example, how about these two studies here:

http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/abstract/124/2/160

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1360-0443.1977.tb03961.x/abstract

Huh. Controlled studies done on the efficacies of AA compared with other treatment modalities. Hopefully, this demonstrates once and for all that the misuse of the 11th tradition is no barrier to effective controlled studies. All the participants volunteer for the study and remain anonymous as well.
 
Part of the issue is that AA used to do studies, and do so no longer. The question is why?

Here's a stab at answering though I'm not an AA historian.

Per Wikipedia, AA conducts surveys that attempt to determine how many people are staying in or dropping out. (Also possibly to see how many times they'd tried AA before deciding to stay) The most recent was in 2007. These are strictly voluntary, on the honor system and in some cases seem to address program retention rates rather than effectiveness.

From 1970 to 1990 these surveys were supplemented with analysis. In 1990 AA dropped the analysis but continued with the surveys. Members reported on how long they'd been continuously sober. It's worth noting that although they believed AA had worked for them, they might simply have been kidding themselves, as suggested by numerous posters.

In 1990 AA dropped its concurrent analysis that had accompanied the surveys. I'm not sure why. Is that what you meant by "studies" that AA stopped doing? Do you know of any controlled and rigorous quantitative analysis done by AA that is no longer done?


What is 'AA's reason for being'

My take on that would be: to facilitate a network where alcoholics can help other alcoholics get sober and/or stay sober.

and what study structures can you name specifically that would conflict with 'AA's reason for being'?

AA will not do study that requires one group to attend and another group not to attend.

AA will not implement a mandatory reporting system that requires participation in surveys.

AA will not require anyone to take a sobriety test.

AA doesn't know who's not in AA. It cannot track down non-attendees who are trying a different method than AA.

AA will not divide attendees into groups and require each group to try a supplementary option.

AA will not (and cannot) track down people who have left to see if they're staying sober. First, it won't have their names; second, AA's priority is to keep the program going for people who want it. It's not going to seek out people who don't want it. (Although I think they tried that early on, it can backfire.)

Seriously, Norseman, after having named these, I'm curious what kind of study you picture. So I'm asking - what kind of study do you picture? I'm not an expert on study designs so I may have missed a plausible protocol.

Huh. Controlled studies done on the efficacies of AA compared with other treatment modalities. Hopefully, this demonstrates once and for all that the misuse of the 11th tradition is no barrier to effective controlled studies. All the participants volunteer for the study and remain anonymous as well.

I looked at the two studies you mentioned. Both involved court-probated alcoholics. They didn't have a choice about attending meetings; they were ordered there. So even if participation in the study was voluntary, the choice to attend wasn't.

The anonymity they were granted by authorities has nothing to do with the anonymity tradition in AA. Authorities had all the vital data they needed; AA would not have collected it to begin with. The AA tradition does not bind outside agencies, it binds AA. You started by asking why AA couldn't have done the studies, then cited studies AA didn't do in order to prove AA could have done the studies?

Neither was conducted by AA, nor could either have been conducted by AA; it has no power over probationers; no ability to order them into treatment and no interest in pushing the program to people who don't want it.

The studies seemed to indicate that AA doesn't work well if you a) don't want to be there or b) don't attend at all.

Finally, bear with me as a cite a telling paragraph (also Wikipedia):

A randomized study of AA is difficult: AA members are not randomly selected from the population of chronic alcoholics, with the possible exception of those who are mandated by courts to attend AA meetings; they are instead self-selected.[56] There are two opposing types of self-selection bias: (1) drinkers may be motivated to stop drinking before they participate in AA (2) AA may attract the more severe and difficult cases.[57] Controlled experiments with AA versus non-AA subjects are also difficult because AA is so easily accessible.


This seems like you are not understanding the methodologies of the different types of studies.

That's certainly possible but I ran through some scenarios above. I'd love to see an example of a study that could be done by AA. The links you cited don't do that.

Thanks for being civil.
 
AA is MORE then religious!

Ever hear of what happened to the AA group in Canada that "modified" the 12-Steps, and "secularized" them? WHY would an allegedly "non-religious" program, go to the extent of "ex-communicating" a local group, that "modifies" the words of AA's core doctrine? SIX of the 12-Steps explicitly, or implicitly mention a "God" (but NOT a "Higher Power"!). They certainly are NOT decorations of atheism, secularity, or freedom FROM religious cult-dogma!

While the original 12 step program was a religious program, there are individual AA groups who don't include religion in their version. Find another group.

AA is a useful tool for many people trying to maintain sobriety. Not everyone needs this kind of support. People are successful in their abstinence via different means and it isn't clear why one method works for some and another method works best for someone else.

The success of AA groups depend on the quality of the group, the quality of the leadership and whether the particular group one attends 'fits' with that individual. I used to work in the substance abuse field and I've seen many different AA groups in action. Some are not very supportive and people show up high, many attending because they had a DUI and the court has ordered them to go.

Other groups are very religiously oriented.

But there are also many AA groups which just leave out the 'turn your life over to a higher power' step. They mouth the words in the "give me the power" mantra but it isn't really part of the program. They support each other effectively, religion is just left up to the individual.

Someone really should revise the 12 steps and develop a non-religious program, but for some mysterious reason it hasn't happened yet.
 
I'm dealing with a spouse who has alcohol issues. His first therapist (social worker) told him to go to a Beginner's AA meeting, and to "Keep An Open Mind."

He went, and was instantly uncomfortable. Not only was Jesus Christ mentioned constantly as the Savior, but the meeting ended with, "The Lord's Prayer."

He related this to the social worker, who berated him for not going to a Beginner's meeting. (Which it WAS listed as.) And then told him that, "The Lord's Prayer" is not really religious, anyway.

My husband now sees a psychologist who specializes in cognitive behavior and doesn't push AA.

Now I'm furious that MY new therapist is telling me that AA would be a good resource for my husband. "It's not religious, it's spiritual," and "Your higher power can be anything at all, the ocean, even yourself."

I'm not confrontational, and I tried to remember some of the advice I've received here about debating. I told her that I had done research on AA, that it had a 5% success rate, and that the Supreme Court had ruled that it was religious. Then I started to get emotional and told her that it was all based on a Buchmanite group designed to get people to accept Christ as the Savior, and that the Higher Power stuff was nonsense, since sure, it starts out as, "the ocean," but ends up referring to God. And the "higher power" definitely CANNOT be yourself, since it has to be some outside force. As Henry Ford said of his cars, you can have any color you want so long as it's black. Well, you can have any Higher Power you want so long as it's God.

As former Catholics, my husband and I tend to get a bit touchy when religion is sold to us. It is very difficult to get away from, "Magical Thinking," and I've been working so hard to restructure my thoughts, to think more critically, to learn about logic, and to question things. And it took a lot for me to "talk back" to my therapist about this, and I still feel guilty, like I should just accept it as good advice. Such is the mark that being a good little Catholic girl leaves on person.

I feel so angry that the majority of people don't question AA at all.:mad:
Find out of your new therapist is a member of AA himself! If so, file an ethics complaint against him! AA's first tradition DEMANDS that "the GROUP comes first"! This is in direct violation of ANY helping profession's violations, where the CLIENT comes first! See how the therapist maintains his support of AA after that! I would recommend finding a new therapist in the meantime!
 
For those interested in a non-religious alternative to AA -- Check out --
Rational Recovery, and Jack Trimpy. Also Secular Organizations for Sobriety.

SMART Recovery (which stands for Self-Managment and Recovery Training) is another option.
Rational Recovery is VERY "anti-self-help group", regardless of the flavor of the group. Trimpey is a bit arrogant in that he thinks HE has "the answer" to recovery from addiction. He has ZERO objective information backing up his methodology, or "success" though. In that respect his "Rational Recovery" is no different then any other method of "addiction treatment".
 
I know someone reasonably high up in AA and he suggested their success rate is closer to 13% I would suggest no other programs are doing significantly better. My AA contact said it often takes at least 3 tries before a person does manage to get and stay sober

I'm also a little suprised at the outrage over the religious side of the program, it was started by a religious group back in the 30's. On Wiki they show you the original 12 steps and what they use today. Only two of the steps have any real religious relevence anymore.
Its the EXACT SAME! Penn and Teller discuss AA's "success rate" of FIVE per cent, based on AA's own 1989 "Triennial Survey" (and they haven't released the results of one since!). It proves that the "5% success rate" of AA is NO DIFFERENT THEN, the FIVE per cent success rate of. . . just quitting on your own! 5-5=0, so the statistical significance is. . . . ZERO!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom