Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
AA's sixth tradition in it's entirety:

"Problems of money, property, and authority may easily divert us from our primary spiritual aim. We think, therefore, that any considerable property of genuine use to A.A. should be separately incorporated and managed, thus dividing the material from the spiritual. An A.A. group, as such, should never go into business. Secondary aids to A.A., such as clubs or hospitals which require much property or administration, ought to be incorporated and so set apart that, if necessary, they can be freely discarded by the groups. Hence such facilities ought not to use the A.A. name. Their management should be the sole responsibility of those people who financially support them. For clubs, A.A. managers are usually preferred. But hospitals, as well as other places of recuperation, ought to be well outside A.A.—and medically supervised. While an A.A. group may cooperate with anyone, such cooperation ought never go so far as affiliation or endorsement, actual or implied. An A.A. group can bind itself to no one."

A proper anonymous study is hardly an outside enterprise. Also, where in the sixth tradition, specifically, does it say that people cannot participate in studies of alcohol?

It doesn't, nor did I claim it did.

What you have done however is use only one of the three points I made around why AA may not wish to pursue the studies. There were three I coupled together and needed to be considered as a whole. One needs to take an overall perspective of the traditions and practices here, not just one item in isolation.

Do not think I am vehemently defending AA on this either, I would love it of there were more studies and science done. I simply do not see that AA would be able to - in good faith - based on my understanding.
 
Norseman,
AA is made up of genuine caring people, not automatons, robots, lab rats or special study groups that could satisfy your overwhelming desire for scientific research.
If you want to know go an ingratiate yourself with a community of alcoholics in AA. Tell them who you are and what you would like to do.
Then we could dispense with all these questions, scenarios, abstract study inquires ect.
I know that you will gain a significant understanding from the community you ask, for this study. Better then we could ever explain here.
 
Does this sound like a group that is interested in helping people get better or a group interested in protecting it's memetic structure?

You hear the same thing over and over "You just don't get it. You'd understand if you were a part of it. It's a special thing that is exempt from the normal expectations of accountability, accuracy, and meaning."

It's apologia for delusion and nothing more.
 
It doesn't, nor did I claim it did.

What you have done however is use only one of the three points I made around why AA may not wish to pursue the studies. There were three I coupled together and needed to be considered as a whole. One needs to take an overall perspective of the traditions and practices here, not just one item in isolation.

Do not think I am vehemently defending AA on this either, I would love it of there were more studies and science done. I simply do not see that AA would be able to - in good faith - based on my understanding.

Alright, that's fair enough. I think I made the points I wished to make regarding use of the Traditions as a bar to conducting proper studies of the efficacies of AA.

Whether or not AA conducts these studies, I submit that there is no reason that they could not, save for simply not wanting to; and that's fine.
 
Norseman,
AA is made up of genuine caring people, not automatons, robots, lab rats or special study groups that could satisfy your overwhelming desire for scientific research.
If you want to know go an ingratiate yourself with a community of alcoholics in AA. Tell them who you are and what you would like to do.
Then we could dispense with all these questions, scenarios, abstract study inquires ect.
I know that you will gain a significant understanding from the community you ask, for this study. Better then we could ever explain here.

I'm not a scientist nor a professional researcher. Any results I would find could hardly be used either for or against the efficacy of AA and why.

I find it also rather disheartening that you would think that I view AAers as not genuine, nor caring or any of the other negative things you said. People want to find out these things. Many people already volunteer their time and effort and energy in helping researchers find these things out. I know that there are many, many caring people in AA who would be more than happy to participate in a study.

Maybe there is something to the spirituality of AA that works wonders on a huge percentage of people who attend AA. Only one way to really find out though, isn't there?
 
Does this sound like a group that is interested in helping people get better or a group interested in protecting it's memetic structure?

You hear the same thing over and over "You just don't get it. You'd understand if you were a part of it. It's a special thing that is exempt from the normal expectations of accountability, accuracy, and meaning."

It's apologia for delusion and nothing more.

:bigclap Game, set, and match, Joey McGee.
 
Maybe there is something to the spirituality of AA that works wonders on a huge percentage of people who attend AA. Only one way to really find out though, isn't there?

And I still don't know what that "one way" is, without dividing the program into components and allowing some people to practice certain components and not others. I'm really not trying to bust your chops, but if you say there's "only one way to really find out," then I think it's fair to ask you to spell out the details.

If it's just AA handing out a bunch of voluntary questionnaires to ask people which aspects of AA helps them, fine - but is that what you're talking about?

Also, off the subject a little, I've done some thinking about "spirituality" and why I don't consider it a synonym for religious. Plenty of people do, fine. But here are some aspects I see as potentially fairly secular: humility, empathy, mindfulness, a sense of connection with other people or with the natural world. That great feeling when I'm mired in my own crap and suddenly find myself being useful to another human being, my own "problems" for a time displaced - I call such things spiritual; no one else has to.

AA members want to protect AA structure, no doubt about it. They do want to preserve what (they believe) worked for them. But AA is not the only game in town. Treatment centers, counselors, pharmaceutical companies and other recovery groups offer other options and people are free to choose those, or to handle things on their own. Personally I'm very glad that the AA niche is there for those who want it.
 
Does this sound like a group that is interested in helping people get better or a group interested in protecting it's memetic structure?

You hear the same thing over and over "You just don't get it. You'd understand if you were a part of it. It's a special thing that is exempt from the normal expectations of accountability, accuracy, and meaning."

It's apologia for delusion and nothing more.

Have you ever climbed to the top of Everest? No? Me either. I could only imagine what it must really be like. I'm told it's wonderful and something only those who have experienced could truly understand.

No doubt you understand exactly how the mountaineers feel. :rolleyes:
 
I'm not a scientist nor a professional researcher. Any results I would find could hardly be used either for or against the efficacy of AA and why.

I find it also rather disheartening that you would think that I view AAers as not genuine, nor caring or any of the other negative things you said. People want to find out these things. Many people already volunteer their time and effort and energy in helping researchers find these things out. I know that there are many, many caring people in AA who would be more than happy to participate in a study.

Maybe there is something to the spirituality of AA that works wonders on a huge percentage of people who attend AA. Only one way to really find out though, isn't there?

I apologize for inferring you held such negative characterizations of AA folks.

I am and was genuine when I suggested you do a "STUDY" yourself. You seem to have a scientific grasp of the subtleties of AA (the pros and the cons) and you are a intellect to boot.
Your questions and opinions concerning AA not being religious vs. being religious and the efficacy of AA have been broad and educational, at least for me.

So yeah, I think you could handle a anecdotal study with a bit of intellect as well as the next guy.
I am asking you to do this so you will understand why a professional scientific study would or could never happen within AA.
Maybe you find out I am in error.
 
Alright, that's fair enough. I think I made the points I wished to make regarding use of the Traditions as a bar to conducting proper studies of the efficacies of AA.

Whether or not AA conducts these studies, I submit that there is no reason that they could not, save for simply not wanting to; and that's fine.

Norseman,
I hilited the quote I want to try and understand where it is you are coming from.
You keep saying AA can do this and AA can do that.
Can you explain in more detail what it is you mean when you make this statement? What is your thinking?
You also referred to AA doing studies in the past and I must split hairs with you here because AA as a whole never actually did a study. Some people who participate in the political and organizational working of AA participated in the Triennial Studies. I was around AA when these questionnaires were handed out from AA/GSO and went down through the structure to the homegroups. Such a small percentage had anything to do with these questions. Part of the reason was AA members felt a infringed upon.
 
Have you ever climbed to the top of Everest? No? Me either. I could only imagine what it must really be like. I'm told it's wonderful and something only those who have experienced could truly understand.

No doubt you understand exactly how the mountaineers feel. :rolleyes:

So, now AA is like climbing Everest? :rolleyes:

The thing is, almost everyone has experienced something exactly like AA. It's called "religion". Zealots are zealots whether it be religion or a 12 Step program.

As well, there have been several people who have attended, or do attend, AA regularly who have countered all the rosey red claims made about AA through this entire thread.

The claim that only those who go to AA can understand is both a special pleading fallacy and a plea to ignorance fallacy.
 
gayak:

'So, now AA is like climbing Everest?...The claim that only those who go to AA can understand is both a special pleading fallacy and a plea to ignorance fallacy.'

Then without having done so you can tell me how it feels to climb Buzzard's Roost. What you would see by putting forth that effort, and what one experiences along the way to the top. I promise to let you know if you can guess even remotely close to the experience while still being wrong in all important aspects.

Obviously, anyone who has also made the climb would know what you don't know.

Waiting...and also still waiting for the details regarding your best-loved imaginary ibogaine study.
 
Wait, I thought we were talking about how AA is not interested in being studied scientifically and uninterested in in integrating the best that science has to teach us about addiction. Now we're talking about climbing Mt. Everest for some bizarre reason.

Instead of using facts and figures and studies to make their case, they give you emotionalized stories that are the same as any other religious apologia in order to sell you on the program. We don't accept testimonials and the beliefs of ear candling adherents for the same reason.

It's sad, it's old, and it's annoying.

AA is Ruining the World by Stanton Peele

AA rules out other, often more effective, approaches. AA is a jealous lover. A body of research has grown that investigates the efficacy of alcoholism and addiction therapies with names like motivational interviewing, life skills training, community reinforcement, brief interventions, harm reduction, etc. These therapies share a number of general characteristics relative to AA and its 12 steps: They are more pragmatic and impact addicts' functioning and life situations, they often permit reduced or less unhealthy use in addition to abstinence, they tap into users' personal value systems rather than imposing their own, and they don't rely on a "higher power." And they generally demonstrate greater success than AA (no clinical study of AA has ever found it superior to any alternative offered to randomly selected alcoholics). And how do AA-ers feel about such alternatives? Disinterest is probably too positive a way to describe their reaction.

AA makes testable claims without testing them. AA refuse to integrate claims that have been tested and proven. This would annihilate their cult structure and they are addicted their religion which is the only reason it won't happen.

"90 meetings in 90 days!" Good grief...
 
Wait, I thought we were talking about how AA is not interested in being studied scientifically and uninterested in in integrating the best that science has to teach us about addiction.

Please elaborate on "the best that science has to teach us about addiction" as well as the treatments we have from these teachings and the efficacy rates of same.
 
Then without having done so you can tell me how it feels to climb Buzzard's Roost. What you would see by putting forth that effort, and what one experiences along the way to the top. I promise to let you know if you can guess even remotely close to the experience while still being wrong in all important aspects.

Bondotuna: I would imagine that the feeling I get climbing Buzzard's Roost in California is pretty much the same as any other of the hikes/climbs I have done in British Columbia, Alberta, Montana, Idaho, Yukon Territory, etc.

In fact, it is exactly the same and I know that because I have done Buzzard's Roost. (Of all the ones you could pick what are the chances? I've only done two in California. :D)

What I get out of such hikes is certainly not what you get out of them. Somethings will likely be similar, others not. And that is the same with AA. Everyone will get something different out of it as evidenced by the many people who belong to AA and have posted in this thread.

And, as evidenced by this thread, the differences within the AA group will be wider than the experiences of non-AA members who have experiences with similar organizations just like the differences between what you feel climbing Buzzard Roost and what I feel climbing it will be greater than the difference I feel between Mount Robson, or Lacket Lookout, and Buzzards Roost.

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?f...0831909550455.739890.754560454&type=3&theater

You are caught up on this special pleading fallacy which isn't helping your case. You pooh pooh the experience of all contradictory AA members and then make the false claim that anyone who doesn't belong can't know. In short, you claim you are somehow special and only you, and those who agree with you, can ever know.

Sorry, human experience is human experience. One's Everest experience in another's drag racing rush, is another's base jumping experience, is another's scrap booking passion. AA and AA members are only special in the fact that they think they are so special.

Waiting...and also still waiting for the details regarding your best-loved imaginary ibogaine study.

Read through the thread. That was gone through long ago. There is a large one taking place in British Columbia, Canada at this time. Ibogain studies are not being done in the US because the US has a war on drugs. :rolleyes: Well, except alcohol . . . tobacco . . . caffeine . . . You know, the ones that cause major societal/health problems.
 
Please elaborate on "the best that science has to teach us about addiction" as well as the treatments we have from these teachings and the efficacy rates of same.
The only thing that the cult has left to do is try and obfuscate over the alternative approaches because they are trying to insinuate that "they are no better, AA is free, and you can 'take what you want and leave the rest' so it should stay on top." Hogwash. Blatant apologia.

A good place to start would be the quote from Stanton Peele from my last post, I'll repeat it

A body of research has grown that investigates the efficacy of alcoholism and addiction therapies with names like motivational interviewing, life skills training, community reinforcement, brief interventions, harm reduction, etc.

Then we have the fact that despite the successful trials of naltrexone people are steered away from that in AA, as well as baclofen or any of the others. For the last time I'll say that there is a genetic test that can show if naltrexone has a high chance of working for you, and AA has absolutely zero interest in promoting this small miracle.

We use comprehensive approaches in medicine. We upgrade. AA attempts to treat a medical problem with cult religion, it's simple. Obfuscate all you want, try and belittle the science all you want, it's just apologia.

Just the same as religious apologists claim "Hey, we're the sophisticated theists! We know evolution happened, we just know that God had a hand in it!" you'll get AA members trying to make it seem like all is well in their ranks and none of this godbothering anti-psychiatry stuff goes on anymore. Baloney.

Anyone who actually wants to investigate this for themselves instead of argue about religion will find all that they need.
 
And I still don't know what that "one way" is, without dividing the program into components and allowing some people to practice certain components and not others. I'm really not trying to bust your chops, but if you say there's "only one way to really find out," then I think it's fair to ask you to spell out the details.

If it's just AA handing out a bunch of voluntary questionnaires to ask people which aspects of AA helps them, fine - but is that what you're talking about?

The one way to which I was referring was simply 'do more studies' and not rely solely on vague anecdotal claims of efficacy.

A questionnaire can be a very effective method of conducting a study, yes. It's why I keep mentioning it. Studies can be done on addicts/alcoholics who are not interested and never go to AA as a control group; the same study can ask for non-addict volunteers as well. Since the DSM makes a distinction between an addict and an abuser (which AA does in a very clumsy, off-handed manner), abusers can be included as well.

I'm not even close to being an expert or professional in this instance. I've taken statistics classes in college as well as research methodologies (my paper was done on the first amendment as it concerns internet anonymity :)).

All I'm saying is that legit studies have been done. So far, the numbers don't show much benefit, if any, for AA's method of achieving and maintaining sobriety.


Also, off the subject a little, I've done some thinking about "spirituality" and why I don't consider it a synonym for religious. Plenty of people do, fine. But here are some aspects I see as potentially fairly secular: humility, empathy, mindfulness, a sense of connection with other people or with the natural world. That great feeling when I'm mired in my own crap and suddenly find myself being useful to another human being, my own "problems" for a time displaced - I call such things spiritual; no one else has to.

Yup, I wholeheartedly agree. When some AA groups felt similarly, they decided to make a few alterations to the 12 steps and the AA World Organization decided that was no longer AA. So keep doing what you're doing! I admire you for it. I just hesitate in calling it 'AA'.


AA members want to protect AA structure, no doubt about it. They do want to preserve what (they believe) worked for them. But AA is not the only game in town. Treatment centers, counselors, pharmaceutical companies and other recovery groups offer other options and people are free to choose those, or to handle things on their own. Personally I'm very glad that the AA niche is there for those who want it.

AA as such isn't the only game in town, true; but ~90% of all treatment agencies in the US are 12-step based which severely undercuts your argument.
 
I apologize for inferring you held such negative characterizations of AA folks.

Thank you. I'm thinking that maybe I have come across as such in this thread.


I am and was genuine when I suggested you do a "STUDY" yourself. You seem to have a scientific grasp of the subtleties of AA (the pros and the cons) and you are a intellect to boot.
Your questions and opinions concerning AA not being religious vs. being religious and the efficacy of AA have been broad and educational, at least for me.

So yeah, I think you could handle a anecdotal study with a bit of intellect as well as the next guy.
I am asking you to do this so you will understand why a professional scientific study would or could never happen within AA.
Maybe you find out I am in error.

As I said in the last post, I'm not an expert, nor do I have the money or time to give to a study which I would feel would do the question justice. Heck, if I saw multiple studies which fairly demonstrate that AA is effective at achieving sobriety, I'd be one of the first to say to everyone, "no, I don't care much for the program because I feel the religious elements are too strong, but I've seen the numbers and it's really effective for people, so if I were you, I'd give it a try." I'd do this because I value the most success for the most number of people.


Norseman,
I hilited the quote I want to try and understand where it is you are coming from.
You keep saying AA can do this and AA can do that.
Can you explain in more detail what it is you mean when you make this statement? What is your thinking?

Well, I can try. I'm saying that the AA organization could, if it wished, perform these studies. There is no barrier of money, people, or volunteers, nor are there any issues with anonymity. There are ethics boards designed specifically to make sure study participants are treated well and fairly. The field of sociology has dealt with all these issues and probably much more than I know of.

I don't really care ultimately if AA does a study or not. I'm saying that it can and yet does not. I read this as a lack of desire to find out if it's really effective; in the Preface to the Big Book, they even spell it out quite clearly. I've quoted it before in this thread, but I'll do so again to make my point:

"Because this book has become the basic text for our Society and has helped such large numbers of alcoholic men and women to recovery, there exists strong sentiment against any radical changes being made in it."

There ya go. No interest whatsoever to see if there could be anything to improve upon to make those numbers even higher (whatever 'such large numbers' really means).


You also referred to AA doing studies in the past and I must split hairs with you here because AA as a whole never actually did a study. Some people who participate in the political and organizational working of AA participated in the Triennial Studies. I was around AA when these questionnaires were handed out from AA/GSO and went down through the structure to the homegroups. Such a small percentage had anything to do with these questions. Part of the reason was AA members felt a infringed upon.

Yes, they'd do triennial studies and then collate the data which demonstrates that they are at least superficially interested in getting some numbers on some aspects of the AA organization.

As I said in my previous post, I don't care if AA does the research or not, ultimately.
 
A good place to start would be the quote from Stanton Peele from my last post,

That doesn't really seem all that "scientific" now does it?

How about some of this best science you say is available, the treatment methods and their efficacy. Do you have something or not?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom