Bamberger
Thinker
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2011
- Messages
- 220
Now that's interesting. A placebo meeting? Wouldn't the subjects know they were going to an AA meeting? Or would half go to an AA meeting and half go to one that looks exactly like an AA meeting?
How about half engage in other activities that do not claim the steps are the path to sobriety? Here are some suggestions:
- a cribbage group that meets 2x a week.
- enrollment in a night course, in conjunction with working a full-time day job.
- volunteer work at a pet shelter
Or we could just tell half of the people to go about their lives and try to make good choices. If after a year the control group has the same rate of recovery as the AA group then we see that attendance in AA was incidental to recovery.
Except there is one huge difference - you don't even have anecdotal evidence for your claims. AA has millions of members and thousands and thousands of meetings that provide exactly that. Your claims cannot be backed up with anything: Like I said - a huge difference
Not to mention more straw in your post since the world scarecrow convention.![]()
Well, now, if we want to go down anecdotal alley I'm sure I can find you a few million Catholics who claim that the Eucharist literally turns into the body and blood of Christ during communion. There, that proves it.
And as for the "millions" of members staying sober daily. Evidence, please.