Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now that's interesting. A placebo meeting? Wouldn't the subjects know they were going to an AA meeting? Or would half go to an AA meeting and half go to one that looks exactly like an AA meeting?

How about half engage in other activities that do not claim the steps are the path to sobriety? Here are some suggestions:

- a cribbage group that meets 2x a week.
- enrollment in a night course, in conjunction with working a full-time day job.
- volunteer work at a pet shelter

Or we could just tell half of the people to go about their lives and try to make good choices. If after a year the control group has the same rate of recovery as the AA group then we see that attendance in AA was incidental to recovery.


Except there is one huge difference - you don't even have anecdotal evidence for your claims. AA has millions of members and thousands and thousands of meetings that provide exactly that. Your claims cannot be backed up with anything: Like I said - a huge difference

Not to mention more straw in your post since the world scarecrow convention. :rolleyes:

Well, now, if we want to go down anecdotal alley I'm sure I can find you a few million Catholics who claim that the Eucharist literally turns into the body and blood of Christ during communion. There, that proves it.

And as for the "millions" of members staying sober daily. Evidence, please.
 
Have you read many of the (publically closed - even to / expescially to legimate researches & scientists) AA archives? I have had access to them myself, before they pulled my privledges. I've had decades of experience, gone to 1000's of meetings, created entire districts from scratch. I've spoken to 10's of thousands of AA's - by invitation. I've made the statement 'Neither god, nor any higher power, is necessary to get or maintain sobriety' in front of 1000's of AA members - a big risk.

A big risk of what? Losing "privileges" from an organization you despise? Did you start despising it before or after your privileges were pulled?

I'm curious by what process your privileges were removed. You had - courageously, I'll add - given numerous by-invitation talks counter to the beliefs of any members (and kept getting invited back). You were voted down numerous times in arguing for the removal of "We Agnostics." It sounds like you were in a democratic forum. Did you attend as an elected GSR? Did you lose an election? Did that have anything to do with privileges being revoked?

You say AA archives are closed to the general public, especially legitimate researchers and scientists. How does AA create the extra level of scrutiny needed to close archives "especially" to scientists?

It sounds like you were not only tolerated for quite a long time, but embraced and encouraged. How does that square with broad assertions that AA doesn't tolerate atheists?

A final observation, and you may be able to enlighten me: I know there's a general service structure but I never joined the process at the regional level. Since the group was self-supporting and made its own internal policies, how does the meddling from on high really effect individual groups? Sincere question, I don't know.

So someone noted on here that any two or three people can call themselves an AA group, per AA literature. Does that mean AA has to call it an AA group? Also someone on the thread said that a group that branded itself Christian, and peddled Jesus Christ instead of "God as you understand him," would never be left off meeting lists. The person didn't provide any evidence.

I'd consider it pretty likely a group identifying itself as Christian would be removed from the general meeting list where I live, based on voting by representatives of various groups. Note that Christian AA could still call itself AA (as the New York "Agnostics AA" does). There are meetings not listed on the group meeting list. I knew a Mormon that went to Mormon 12-step meetings. Can't speak for other parts of the country.

Seems like with the rise of the Internet such spin-offs have gained the ability to let their presence be known. It's a good thing. If someone wanted agnostic aa I'm glad it comes up in a search.
 
Now that's interesting. A placebo meeting? Wouldn't the subjects know they were going to an AA meeting? Or would half go to an AA meeting and half go to one that looks exactly like an AA meeting?

According to what steppers have written here, an AA meeting can be anything. You could have a group that slaughters goats, and ignores everything else ('cuz you can "take what you want and leave the rest" ya know). How about a meeting where everyone reads the 'Big Book' backwards? Or one where everyone's higher power is Bozo the Clown, and everyone sits around and sprays seltzer on each other.

Half a meeting actually qualifies as AA (again, take what you want and leave the rest). So does 1/3 of a meeting. You tell us what an AA meeting looks like.
 
Show me.

The why are people upset that AA doesn't/ Shouldn't the standards be the same? If one of us made this claim for AA, they would be ridiculed unmercilessly.



Correct, CBT does assist.
Incorrect 12 steps assist in doing exactly this (CBT).

A definition of CBT

Definition: CBT or Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy refers to any treatment based on the idea that psychological problems arise as a result of the way in which people interpret or evaluate situations, thoughts, and feelings, as well as our the behaviors stem from these evaluations. Cognitive-behavioral therapy has been found to be effective in treating a number of psychological conditions such as the anxiety disorders, depression, eating disorders, borderline personality disorder, and problems with alcohol and drug use.

Short of transporting myself through the computer and forcing you to read the links I've sent, I don't know what you want me to do. I sent you links to 2 different treatment centers whose methodology is based on actual research and changes when new evidence becomes available. If you don't want to accept that, then simply admit that you aren't interested in alternatives to AA.

I never made a claim about AA's success rate. However, other posters have noted that AA used to make the information from their triennial survey public, and that information gleaned from that showed a 5 percent success rate. So there is some info, albeit limited, about AA's success rate that they themselves have provided, while I'm unaware of any private treatment center that releases or has ever released such info. Again, I've never claimed that AA is less effective than anything else (though I think that's likely the case), only that their methodology is so implausible as to not be worthy of consideration. If AA does work, it certainly doesn't work because of divine intervention, in which case there's absolutely no need to keep peddling the god crap.

Why does AA need to incorporate god as a necessary component if it's just CBT? Secular CBT programs (ie. all of them unless you count AA as CBT) work without invoking woo. Why must AA do this if it's truly not a religious program?

To Alfie, Danny, and any other AA members: If you think AA works, do you think it works in the way in which AA's official position says it does? Does god really fix a spiritual deficiency and miraculously remove the desire to drink if you perform the 12-steps? Or is it the social aspect that helps?
I genuinely don't understand how people can believe that faith-healing can be used to treat alcoholism but not any other condition and I'd love to have an explanation as to why people think this.
 
Originally Posted by Tinyal View Post
Have you read many of the (publically closed - even to / expescially to legimate researches & scientists) AA archives? I have had access to them myself, before they pulled my privledges. I've had decades of experience, gone to 1000's of meetings, created entire districts from scratch. I've spoken to 10's of thousands of AA's - by invitation. I've made the statement 'Neither god, nor any higher power, is necessary to get or maintain sobriety' in front of 1000's of AA members - a big risk.

Tinyal, Tinyal, Tinyal you come on here with such bravado about your experiences in AA like they are unique and we can not relate. You are not special my friend. Taking risks is the engine that drives AA, controversy thrives in AA, drama is loved in AA and people with huge ego's are despised and loved in AA.
Don't drink to much of yourself you might just get drunk, have to pick up a chip and start over the proper way with some humility.
I am not impressed that you went to the far right with your passions while in AA, because then you had to swing back and totally miss the good stuff that sits in the center.
AA is about meeting another alcoholic and asking for help, getting the help and then giving the gift to another. That's it.
Have a great day Tinyal.
 
A.A. Alfie;7566833 Incorrect 12 steps assist in doing exactly this (CBT).[/QUOTE said:
It seems that what you are trying to say is that 12 steps are some form of CBT. LOL!Have you ever even been exposed to CBT? Evidence please.


I've heard anti-atheist sentiments expressed both in meetings and outside meetings. I'm going to repost this quote from the 12x12 since you AA apologists seem to have ignored it before.

"Let's look first at the case of the one who says he won't believe--the belligerent one. He's in a state of mind which can be described only as savage."

Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, pg 25
 
I am bumping this to the top to give Bondotuna, who may have missed it, an opportunity to respond. This is exactly the point I have been trying to make since the beginning of the thread and I think Poster put it brilliantly.

Mondotuna, I already posted about how an intergroup/area/district office that prints meetings lists can delist a meeting. This is what happened in Toronto. Any reply to this? According to AA's third tradition, “Our membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Hence we may refuse none who wish to recover. Nor ought AA membership ever depend upon money or conformity. Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group, provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation.”

The atheist/agnostic group in Toronto met the criteria. Why were they delisted other than the desire of AA to keep meetings religious in nature? The membership/group requirements says nothing about keeping the steps the same or believing in god.
 
Well, now, if we want to go down anecdotal alley I'm sure I can find you a few million Catholics who claim that the Eucharist literally turns into the body and blood of Christ during communion. There, that proves it.

This isn't the comparison sought. There is anecdotal evidence from alcoholics who report that AA helped them stay sober. Do you have anecdotal evidence from alcoholics who report that twice-weekly cribbage has helped them stay sober? The study, strictly speaking, should follow up with sobriety checks, rather than relying on credulous souls who feel better but have been cruelly deluded.

You compare the efficacy of two treatments. The relevant question is, "Does AA work as well as playing cribbage?" A properly designed study likely would not concern itself with Catholic beliefs on transubstantiation; they would be considered outside the core research mission.
 
Well, now, if we want to go down anecdotal alley I'm sure I can find you a few million Catholics who claim that the Eucharist literally turns into the body and blood of Christ during communion. There, that proves it.

Straw extraordinaire.
Your argument was that a Benny Hill convention would be as effective as AA.
Have you proof of this?

And as for the "millions" of members staying sober daily. Evidence, please.

http://www.aa.org/subpage.cfm?page=74

By this estimate there are 100k plus meetings worldwide. How many members per meeting on average do you reckon? two, five, ten, twenty?

The "millions" is my educated estimate - how many do you think?
 
gayak:

'Why address this to me, I've never made such a claim?...nor have I ever said there were no atheists in AA.'

Ok, I think I see a way to make some sense of our disagreement regarding what you actually said vs. what you want people to think you said. Given that we usually take people to mean what they actually say it's a little tough to follow the necessary line of reasoning so bear with me.

You don't then feel that AA is not open to atheists as when you said 'You are mistaken. AA is not open to atheists.' as you did say earlier. You don't want people to construe from that statement that you believe that AA excludes atheists as when you told Alfie 'You must know that this passage excludes atheists from AA', but instead want people to think you believe that atheists are not excluded in AA and that AA is open to atheists, or perhaps your currently stated position du jour that AA is open to some atheists but not all atheists.

This is plainly my error in not properly interpreting your plain statements to in fact mean their opposite. I see now that by saying 'I've never made such a claim' you actually in your own special way are stating you have claimed that AA is not open to atheists and that atheists are excluded from AA, and your statements which state that then should be interpreted by people to understand that you mean the opposite of those sentiments.

This is going to make reading your past and future posts very difficult to decypher, you understand.
 
It seems that what you are trying to say is that 12 steps are some form of CBT.

Yep.
And if you had ever had a close look at the 12 steps, you would see how this happens.

I've heard anti-atheist sentiments expressed both in meetings and outside meetings. I'm going to repost this quote from the 12x12 since you AA apologists seem to have ignored it before.

"Let's look first at the case of the one who says he won't believe--the belligerent one. He's in a state of mind which can be described only as savage."

Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, pg 25

And? This does not necessarily mean that person won't believe in a specifgic god per se, this means one who can't grasp the concept of spuritual growth or higher power.

As per the big book (page 43 if memory serves):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."
 
Ok, I think I see a way to make some sense of our disagreement regarding what you actually said vs. what you want people to think you said. Given that we usually take people to mean what they actually say it's a little tough to follow the necessary line of reasoning so bear with me.

How ironic it is that you would passive-aggressively scold someone for not being literal, while at the same time explaining away how in your AA program isn't what it says it is. God doesn't mean God, prayer doesn't mean prayer, "only requirement" doesn't mean only requirement, and on and on and on....

Priceless.
 
According to what steppers have written here, an AA meeting can be anything. You could have a group that slaughters goats, and ignores everything else ('cuz you can "take what you want and leave the rest" ya know). How about a meeting where everyone reads the 'Big Book' backwards? Or one where everyone's higher power is Bozo the Clown, and everyone sits around and sprays seltzer on each other.

Half a meeting actually qualifies as AA (again, take what you want and leave the rest). So does 1/3 of a meeting. You tell us what an AA meeting looks like.

OK. The format will depend on what the group has chosen. This is typical: People join in serenity prayer, moment of silence or both. Often the AA preamble will be read. The format of the meeting will be read. It may be a discussion; a speaker meeting or a "study" meeting dedicated to the steps and traditions. In discussion meetings that day's chairman usually solicits topic ideas and attempts to define them in AA language. A basket will be passed. After an hour the meeting closes, often with a prayer, but not always; there are secular alternatives.

I believe most groups in the U.S. would eschew goat slaughter because format changes are voted on and traditions are strong. In this country, goat slaughter is not widely associated with spiritual practice. However in some cultures it is. For all I know there are goat sacrifice meetings.

Similarly, the meetings in which every person's higher power is Bozo the Clown would face format challenges from mainstream members who are serious about preserving inclusive traditions. Individuals would be free to choose Bozo the Clown as a higher power, but requiring Bozo the Clown would rankle many members. Eventually Central Office might even delist those clowns.

Reading the book backward might also be a hard sell. Some people would probably vote against it, believing it is easier to read frontward. I once saw a woman reading an upside down Big Book. At first I thought she might be illiterate, but it turned out she was dyslexic; she read everything upside down. If enough people had similar reading issues perhaps a new group might for dyslexic alcoholics might form.
 
Poster Nutbag wrote:
To Alfie, Danny, and any other AA members: If you think AA works, do you think it
works in the way in which AA's official position says it does? Does god really fix a spiritual deficiency and miraculously remove the desire to drink if you perform the 12-steps? Or is it the social aspect that helps?

First question, "What is AA's official position".
Second question, I don't know if God does any of this because I am a Atheist.
Third question, the social aspect helps with any negative condition if you allow it.

I genuinely don't understand how people can believe that faith-healing can be used to treat alcoholism but not any other condition and I'd love to have an explanation as to why people think this.

I can't help with this answer. Just ask yourself Nutbag, do you believe in a God and if you do does he help you.
 
Ok, I think I see a way to make some sense of our disagreement regarding what you actually said vs. what you want people to think you said.

The easiest way to make sense of what I say is to attribute to me only those things that I have actually said. Your problem is that you think I have said something that someone else said in the case of 'critical mass.'

You don't then feel that AA is not open to atheists as when you said 'You are mistaken. AA is not open to atheists.' as you did say earlier. You don't want people to construe from that statement that you believe that AA excludes atheists as when you told Alfie 'You must know that this passage excludes atheists from AA', but instead want people to think you believe that atheists are not excluded in AA and that AA is open to atheists, or perhaps your currently stated position du jour that AA is open to some atheists but not all atheists.

This is plainly my error in not properly interpreting your plain statements to in fact mean their opposite. I see now that by saying 'I've never made such a claim' you actually in your own special way are stating you have claimed that AA is not open to atheists and that atheists are excluded from AA, and your statements which state that then should be interpreted by people to understand that you mean the opposite of those sentiments.

This is going to make reading your past and future posts very difficult to decypher, you understand.

The difficulty is in your thinking, not in what I said. "AA is not inclusive of atheists" =/= "There are no atheists in AA."

Let em explain why you are in error:

For years the US military had a "don't ask, don't tell" policy when it came to gays. That means they are not inclusive of gays but there are still gays in the US military. The problem only arises if someone lives the lifestyle they choose or someone finds out about them being gay.

This is very similar to AA in that AA claims to be all inclusive but it delists atheist groups and it doesn't allow people to openly be atheists. They must pretend there is a "Higher Power," a "God As We Know Him," and a "Power Greater Than Themselves."

All atheists believe that is ********, which is what makes them atheists but they aren't allowed to say that in an AA meeting.

It is much the same as civil rights in the South in the early part of the 20th century where one group of people (Blacks if you haven't figured it out) were allowed to exist but not allowed to fully participate in society.

If you ask the military brass, they actually think they are inclusive of gays. If you listen to White Southerners they actually believed Blacks were being included. And if you ask the AA old guard they actually think AA is inclusive of atheists.

Everybody else knows it isn't true but these people continue to delude themselves.
 
Poster Nutbag:

'If you think AA works, do you think it
works in the way in which AA's official position says it does? Does god really fix a spiritual deficiency and miraculously remove the desire to drink if you perform the 12-steps? Or is it the social aspect that helps?'

Yes it works very well, and since your question seems sincere I'll tell you why I say that. There were about 200 +- people in my AA 'family tree' who had a 1-20 years when I came in. Our deal started when a Chicago Tribune editor took a psychiatrist/con man through the steps while the con was locked up in Cook County jail during the '50s. He settled in Los Angeles and formed the group I later became part of in another town. Of those +-200 members 3 of the LA people got drunk. None in my group drank. Outside of the 3 I mentioned the remainder of those people are still sober or have died of natural cause while still sober during my 29 years.

They don't all believe the same things or do the same things in the same way with the same regularity so I don't believe there is one right way to take the 12 steps. All on occasion fail spectacularly at trying to live by the principles in AA but still keep trying, so they are good examples for imperfect people like myself to follow.

For 6 years earlier I was, modestly speaking, far more creatively viscious than the current anti-AA crowd which I find uniformly disappointing, repetitious, and unimaginative. But, the '70s was a more creative time in some respects.

During my first sober years real experience trumped my earlier fantasies of the reality in AA, as it always does. I have had the benefit and pleasure of knowing these people for nearly 30 years, seeing them a few times each year and keeping track of their lives. Outsiders are denied that experience and have little to go on other than believing what their imaginary fundies whisper in their ears is so.

If you ask the 20-50 year people about their 'desire to drink' you'd get a chuckle in return. Their sobriety is diamond hard. That quality doesn't have anything at all to do with the social aspect of AA.

Did God fix them? Was it instead the understanding they gained of themselves and the nature and degree of their problem, making peace with their past and doing unselfish and unpaid service to others, and gaining a overriding purpose in their lives and limiting the choices they might make that would harm them if carried out?

You can bet your ass it was something. People don't ordinarily change much, and these did, in many cases their drinking lives before and after sobriety are poles apart, and though I won't go into specifics I assure you that is the biggest understatment you'll read this year. They were zeros before AA but are now the finest people I know. If you're reasonably up to date on the world scene you already know of a few of them.

My group is not the least unusual. Because I travel a lot I've had the pleasure of seeing the same successes in solid AA groups in many parts of the world. If you are ever faced with choosing between lame or solid AA, I suggest you go with the solid group. Otherwise, you could wind up not knowing what you could have known and suffering from honestly and adamantly believing that you do actually know.

I'm sure you know the type.
 
Just recently Jack posted an example of my progress (maybe evolution would be a better word) from feeling confined to spirituality/religious doctrines to going into agnostic thoughts and then finally admitting that I really do not believe in the concept of a God as described by the theologians of today.
I guess he found it very odd that someone that was involved in AA as much as I once was could progress away from a God of Jacks understanding.
This is the independence and strength that AA gave me through practicing their principles. I was given the right to choose for myself and still feel comfortable there.
 
http://www.thefix.com/content/dvm-5-definition-addiction9110

Excerp from the article:
The DSM functions as the bible not only for the mental health establishment—the manual is written by the American Psychiatric Association (APA)—but for the insurance and pharmaceutical industries. Although this bible does not have a monopoly on the idea of addiction—the Twelve-Step disease model retains tremendous influence—the redefinition is certain to have a significant, if hard to predict, impact on addicts, recovering or otherwise.Will the "Efficacy of AA"be challenged by all of this?
I don't think so because as has been pointed out here many times AA in and of itself is not a treatment plan but part of one. (IMO) AA's place will be more clear and solidified as a suitable tool for educating an maintaining ones sobriety.
One other note though for all those naysayers concerning addiction not being a disease I guess we were wrong according to the professionals. Your self will seems to have little to do with keeping you sober.
 
Mondotuna, I already posted about how an intergroup/area/district office that prints meetings lists can delist a meeting. This is what happened in Toronto. Any reply to this? According to AA's third tradition, “Our membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Hence we may refuse none who wish to recover. Nor ought AA membership ever depend upon money or conformity. Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group, provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation.”

The atheist/agnostic group in Toronto met the criteria. Why were they delisted other than the desire of AA to keep meetings religious in nature? The membership/group requirements says nothing about keeping the steps the same or believing in god.
The "out" that AA has here is in those last words, "provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation." A group calling itself an atheist group would be considered an affiliation other than alcoholism, as would a Christian group (never mind AA's own Christian roots), but a "spiritual" group would be okay, since AA claims itself to be "spiritual." I recall one group named "The Spiritual progress rather than spiritual perfection group" (many or most groups are named after some slogan or phrase from the big book or other AA literature).

There ARE "AA" meetings that aren't listed in local meeting lists, and the attendees like it that way - these are usually "special interest" meetings, often of professionals such as doctors. I attended one such meeting, started by one of the old timers at the clubhouse. He didn't want to hear all those "young people," those in their teens and twenties who say "ya know" and "like" two or thee times in every sentence.

In the Atlanta meeting list there are "Gay and Lesbian" groups, but immediately after the words Gay and Lesbian are the words "All Alcoholics Welcome." This is how one has a "special interest" group in AA, by specifically not excluding those outside the group. But even then, I'll bet having the statement "All Alcoholics Welcome" still would get those Toronto atheist groups/meetings listed in their local AA meeting list.

Those who compile the meeting lists are of course the ones who get to decide what's an "affiliation" and what's not. The inevitably have several years if not decades of AA membership and are in the "mainstream" of AA belief.
 
Last edited:
The "out" that AA has here is in those last words, "provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation." A group calling itself an atheist group would be considered an affiliation other than alcoholism, as would a Christian group (never mind AA's own Christian roots), but a "spiritual" group would be okay, since AA claims itself to be "spiritual." I recall one group named "The Spiritual progress rather than spiritual perfection group" (many or most groups are named after some slogan or phrase from the big book or other AA literature).

There ARE "AA" meetings that aren't listed in local meeting lists, and the attendees like it that way - these are usually "special interest" meetings, often of professionals such as doctors. I attended one such meeting, started by one of the old timers at the clubhouse. He didn't want to hear all those "young people," those in their teens and twenties who say "ya know" and "like" two or thee times in every sentence.

In the Atlanta meeting list there are "Gay and Lesbian" groups, but immediately after the words Gay and Lesbian are the words "All Alcoholics Welcome." This is how one has a "special interest" group in AA, by specifically not excluding those outside the group. But even then, I'll bet having the statement "All Alcoholics Welcome" still would get those Toronto atheist groups/meetings listed in their local AA meeting list.

Those who compile the meeting lists are of course the ones who get to decide what's an "affiliation" and what's not. The inevitably have several years if not decades of AA membership and are in the "mainstream" of AA belief.

I think that's spot on Ben. My issue, however, is that failure to believe in god is in no way an affiliation. The office (area, district, intergroup depending on how it works in the region) printed the meeting lists had to really bend the concept of affiliation in order to de-list the atheist group. There are of course regions where AA allows atheist groups to be listed, along with the other specialty groups like LGBT, women only, HIV, etc. And you're exactly write that those who are in a position to print the lists are the backbone of AA in the region and set the tone for the "mainstream" beliefs. There's obviously some diversity depending on where you go (as I've attended a listed agnostic meeting in Florida), but it's very obvious that there's a constant undercurrent of anti-atheist sentiment in the hierarchy of AA.

Mondo: Thanks for taking a stab at answering my question! You did duck the crux of it however. Again, if AA works, does it work because of divine intervention? If the answer is yes, then it's not even worthy of consideration as a serious treatment option unless AA can provide even a shred of evidence that there is a god and that god is interested in and capable of treating alcoholics. If it works for another reason, why keep such an inflammatory, exclusive, and unnecessary concept in the steps if the real purpose of the program is to provide effective treatment to all who seek it?

I definitely do know people who got significantly better in AA like you pointed out. Further, I strongly suspect the social aspect of AA can be useful to lots of people who need help. I'm well aware of the AA success stories and I'm friends with quite a few of them. But simply getting sober within the framework of AA does not mean that there was divine intervention, or that their suffering from a spiritual malady, or any of the other woo claims that AA makes as official policy. My problem with AA is that they have fundamentally misdiagnosed the problem as a spiritual one and proscribed a treatment that would be laughable if applied to any other condition (and should be treated as such in the context of alcoholism). The cognitive dissonance I experienced over this in AA is what drove me out. I desperately wanted to believe it worked, saw that there were loads of people in the program with significant sober time, and yet knew that the claims of how it worked were utter crap. And questioning this in meetings was taboo. Why does AA need to be like this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom