Hi Forum members!
I'm unsure of whether chiming in on this thread is a prudent move...but I've spent hours reading this thread and I felt compelled to join.
As I indicate below, it's a cantankerous thread, basically an ongoing debate about AA.
As
I've written at this page and elsewhere, There's not enough skeptical "coverage" of AA compared to that with Scientology and its Narconon program, or of the many myriad groups and ideas discussed by skeptics on, for example, Tim Farley's site
http://whatstheharm.net.
I stopped believing in God quite naturally when I was about 12 years old and have described myself as an atheist my entire adult life.
I am also participating in AA. I am a reluctant participant (but to be fair, so is everyone, it seems--I haven't seen anyone come into AA skipping).
I first attended AA in the 1980's as a "weak atheist." My parents took me to church but I went reluctantly as I never did believe in God (though I didn't feel safe telling thhem or anyone that). I supposed God COULD exist, but I didn't see actual evidence, only people who believed. In college I read Isaac Asimov (famous for being an out atheist, among other things) say "The burden of proof for God should be on the positive, just as it is for anything else." I held on to that, but when I started attending AA I was literally SURROUNDED by believers at every meeting. After finally beginning daily attendance I "converted" and believed strongly (in God and that AA's steps would help me if I took them) for a couple of years. It took many more years, including reading every book on cults I could find (this was years before the Internet became ubiquitous), for me to deprogram myself. When I did get online I found sites such as Ken Ragge's, and SOS email list and other non-12-step resources. I didn't need these to stay sober/abstinent by then, but I was still in a way deprogramming myself.
Being on forums such as this is a way for me to "give away" the info that was so hard for me to find when I was trying to dig my way out of AA.
I think the Big Book is pretty terrible--I'm trying not to judge it on its literary merits, but it's still corny, contradictory, and sexist (the chapter "To Wives" is absolutely vile). I am reading it anyway because I am trying to be open-minded and teachable. I am trying not to be cynical around the Program because I am desperate to change my habits and get my life back on track, and the clinicians I've spoken to all say that AA what I should do.
Ask each clinician "are you a friend of Bill W.?" and watch them smile and their eyes light up. They'll be happy you know AA's "secret handshake." Most are, of course, 12-step members or are believers that people can only recover by attending 12-step groups and taking the 12 steps.
If you like the Big Book, you should pick up the 12&12 or "Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions," written about 10-15 years later but still filled with the same language, incluging the phrase
"lustful enough to rape."
In other areas it would be a clear conflict of interest. Imagine a counselor telling you you should attend Catholic mass, and later finding out he's a Catholic priest, something he didn't tell you about. That's what most AA members do as counselors, hiding behind their AA membership with the anonymity "traditions" (AA's codeword for rules).
I'm in a very vulnerable position right now and I'm scared to death, frankly. I am trying to do what my sponsor and the people in AA tell me to do, but at the same time, all this Higher Power stuff strikes me as an affront to my human dignity. I have thought about "faking it," much the same way that I still go to mass on Christmas Day with my Mother because it comforts her, but lying is insulting to everyone involved as well.
I've found an agnostics' AA fellowship here in NYC and I'm going to start attending those meetings. I will report back on what I find there. I would link to their website but I'm new to the forum, so I do not have the privilege. Anyone can find info about them if they google agnostics nyc aa. Looks like it could be just the place for me, I hope I hope!
As you may know, there are true non-12-step groups such as LSR, SOS, WFS/MFS, though they're much rarer than AA. I haven't been to any support group in a decade, but like the alternative groups if for no other reason than I don't hear of alternative-group members committing suicide (as I discussed when I first started posting in this thread). And that's yet another reason why I finally stopped attending AA. If the verbal and emotional abuse weren't bad enough, it can only be hurtful psychically to go where you regularly see people once a week and never know when one will decide to, as it's described in AA, "take a permanent solution to a temporary problem."
In the meantime, I'm going to meetings in my neighborhood--I have one this afternoon, in fact. The frequency of meetings is one thing about the Program that doesn't alarm me, actually. Going to meetings every single day probably sounds extreme to some people, but we are talking about individuals who wanted to get blackout drunk every...single...day.
I didn't drink every day of my last few years of drinking, but I managed to go to 8 to 10 AA meetings per week in my first two years in AA. I felt a bit like I was chasing a carrot, and if I went to enough meetings I'd finally get it. What I got was brainwashed, despite the joke in the Ham On Wry section of the AA Grapevine where the old timer said "No, it's more like a dry cleaning operation."
But yes, the frequency of meetings isn't a "problem," it's just an indication of how popular AA is. Where I live there's a Baptist church almost literally on every corner, but despite my heritage I'm far from a Christian and I don't attend.
To find out more about the problems with AA. check out these websites:
http://orange-papers,org
http://morerevealed.com
http://peele.net
If you mention to an AA meber or at a meeting that you're reading this thread or reading "alternative to AA" readings, you'll see how alarmed they get - AA members see this as "playing with fire" and it being a life-or-death thing, and that you should ONLY go to AA and not read any of "that other stuff" on the Internet.
This is a fascinating thread. I will keep catching up on it till I read it through. Thank you all.
You'll notice my posts don't show up until posts numbered in the 4,000's. I honestly didn't read many of the earlier posts, just enough to see there are pro-AA posters as well as those of us one would expect on a skeptic forum.