Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The group reworded the steps to match up better with their beliefs and thus became something other than AA.

And this proves several points that I have been making in this thread and disproves several of the points made by AA apologists:

1) AA religious claims are NOT in line with atheist beliefs. You yourself claim they were when the fact that atheists needed to change the wording to suit their beliefs proves you wrong.

2) AA is not all inclusive and specifically targets atheists. They do not remove the meetings that are very religious only the ones that are non-religious.

3) You cannot "take what you want and leave the rest" and still belong to AA. At least not if you're an atheist.

4) AA members do insist atheists change their beliefs even though they claim that doesn't happen.

There are more, those are the main ones.

If an entirely Christian AA group did the same thing, they could expect the same treatment.

Except that that will never happen because the program was set up by religious people for religious people and so christian beliefs will always fit into the program. The "G" in God, the "H" in He and Him, and the "H" and "P" in Higher Power ensure that.

Your explanation is disingenuous.
 
And at one time slavery had critical mass, so that proves ... I'm sorry, what does that prove?

It proves that the mere existence of an institution does not justify its existence.

So what if AA meetings are ubiquitous? This in no way means that they help with addiction. AA might claim to be effective, but that does not mean it is. Until a valid statistical study proves that AA helps one to achieve sobriety better than placebo such claims need to be treated as anecdotal only. Along this same vein, I can claim that the following treatments are equally as valid as AA:

- sticking my finger in my ear and singing ting-a-ling-loo.
- slapping a short bald headed guy on the top of his head while a sax plays in the background.
- standing on my head gargling lemonade while trying to hum the opening stanzas to the Benny Hill show.

All of the above are equally valid when using the benchmark for outcomes analysis that AA employs. In other words, no benchmark.
 
gayak:

Alcoholics Anonymous
The Godless Heathens
SUNDAY - 9:00 AM
El Cerrito Fellowship
2426 Church Lane
EL CERRITO,
Details: Format:
Language: English

Atheist & Agnostic
Berkeley Fellowship
2108 McGee Ave.
Tuesday 7:00 p.m.


Athiest/Agnostic
530 Lake Park Ave
Grand Lake Neighborhood Center
Wednesday 7:00 pm


Atheists Agnostics and others
Alano Club
1748 Market St. (near Octavia Blvd.)
Saturday 11:00 a.m.

Using one area as an example, AA members who are atheist in the bay area can go to different atheist AA groups on Sunday, Tues, Wednesday, and Saturdays.

Hopefully you'll find these specific listings of what you repeatedly deny exists less disingenuous. I don't want to work any harder.

How 'bout we now move on to whatever your next point is, so we can have some fun with that?
 
Here's my problem. You cite "science based" models yet you have "no idea" of their efficacy, their quality of care nor their treatment. You say they are science based, yet you cannot tell us what their science is based on.

It seems to me like you have simply read a pamphlet and believed it.

What is their model based upon?
How does it work?
What are their efficacy rates?

You brought them in, you get to support them. That's how it works around here.

It's clear that you don't even bother reading the links I've provided. Your obfuscation is borderline ridiculous. Both of the centers that I've linked you to make their methodology clear. You know full well that treatment centers don't make their "success" rates public, so that information isn't available. If you read the last link, you'd see "Evidence-based cognitive behavioral therapy illuminates how thinking influences the way we feel and behave." Again, it's clear that centers like this use evidence to create a treatment program based on what the evidence shows is effective. AA and 12-step centers do no such thing.

Again, you're the addictions "professional" here. You should be familiar with methodologies like CBT, REBT, etc. Because centers don't make success rates public, it's impossible to determine which are the most effective. However, the 12-step model is based on the revelation of a man in 1935 and has an entrenched dogma that has not changed since then. Other methods, like the two I've linked to, use modern science to create a regimen that can and does change when the evidence points to more effective methods. Only one of these is evidence based.

I cannot believe that you really want me to explain how these treatments work. Again, think about the supposed mechanism of action of 12-step groups. Alcoholics have a spiritual disease. They must ask the god who allowed the disease to take root to remove it. This same god also allows cancer, HIV, etc., but chooses not to help those who suffer from those diseases. Instead, he only helps alcoholics, and only if they follow a specific routine that he revealed to a random alcoholic in 1935. It's a joke. The mechanism of action in AA is so highly implausible as to not even warrant serious consideration. They've both misdiagnosed the problem (as a spiritual one), and introduced a treatment program that only makes sense if their is a deeply involved god who chooses to treat alcoholism but not other medical issues. Simply ridiculous. This sharply contrasts with these centers which look at contemporary addictions research and use it to guide their treatments. You're not going to win this one Alfie. AA's mechanism of action is so ridiculous that just about anything else is significantly more likely to work, and centers that use actual evidence and modern medicine are far ahead of the faith-healing mindset of AA.
 
gayak:

Using one area as an example, AA members who are atheist in the bay area can go to different atheist AA groups on Sunday, Tues, Wednesday, and Saturdays.

Hopefully you'll find these specific listings of what you repeatedly deny exists less disingenuous. I don't want to work any harder.

How 'bout we now move on to whatever your next point is, so we can have some fun with that?

Thanks for the information. Ok, so a tiny minority of AA groups world-wide claim to be agnostic/atheist. I, as a life-long Catholic, can also introduce you to church-goers who do not believe the Eucharist is transformed into the body and blood of Christ during communion. Heck, I can find some priests who don't believe that. But their very participation in the Mass implicitly supports an institution that is very much based on such dogma.

Likewise, I find it interesting that a group of atheists would congregate under the auspices of AA, knowing full well that the program literature and vast majority of groups world-wide utilize the word God. I would naturally be interested to know if these atheist/agnostic groups send money to AAWS. The degree of cognitive dissonance required to pull that rabbit out of the hat staggers me.
 
Bombotuna:

If they are praying to God, asking for His help. and generally sucking up to a Higher Power, they are still practicing religion.

gayak:

Alcoholics Anonymous
The Godless Heathens
SUNDAY - 9:00 AM
El Cerrito Fellowship
2426 Church Lane
EL CERRITO,
Details: Format:
Language: English

Atheist & Agnostic
Berkeley Fellowship
2108 McGee Ave.
Tuesday 7:00 p.m.


Athiest/Agnostic
530 Lake Park Ave
Grand Lake Neighborhood Center
Wednesday 7:00 pm


Atheists Agnostics and others
Alano Club
1748 Market St. (near Octavia Blvd.)
Saturday 11:00 a.m.

Using one area as an example, AA members who are atheist in the bay area can go to different atheist AA groups on Sunday, Tues, Wednesday, and Saturdays.

Hopefully you'll find these specific listings of what you repeatedly deny exists less disingenuous. I don't want to work any harder.

How 'bout we now move on to whatever your next point is, so we can have some fun with that?
 
gayak:

Using one area as an example, AA members who are atheist in the bay area can go to different atheist AA groups on Sunday, Tues, Wednesday, and Saturdays.

Hopefully you'll find these specific listings of what you repeatedly deny exists less disingenuous. I don't want to work any harder.

How 'bout we now move on to whatever your next point is, so we can have some fun with that?

Mondotuna, I already posted about how an intergroup/area/district office that prints meetings lists can delist a meeting. This is what happened in Toronto. Any reply to this? According to AA's third tradition, “Our membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Hence we may refuse none who wish to recover. Nor ought AA membership ever depend upon money or conformity. Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group, provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation.”

The atheist/agnostic group in Toronto met the criteria. Why were they delisted other than the desire of AA to keep meetings religious in nature? The membership/group requirements says nothing about keeping the steps the same or believing in god.
 
Hi Forum members!

I'm unsure of whether chiming in on this thread is a prudent move...but I've spent hours reading this thread and I felt compelled to join.
As I indicate below, it's a cantankerous thread, basically an ongoing debate about AA.

As I've written at this page and elsewhere, There's not enough skeptical "coverage" of AA compared to that with Scientology and its Narconon program, or of the many myriad groups and ideas discussed by skeptics on, for example, Tim Farley's site http://whatstheharm.net.

I stopped believing in God quite naturally when I was about 12 years old and have described myself as an atheist my entire adult life.

I am also participating in AA. I am a reluctant participant (but to be fair, so is everyone, it seems--I haven't seen anyone come into AA skipping).
I first attended AA in the 1980's as a "weak atheist." My parents took me to church but I went reluctantly as I never did believe in God (though I didn't feel safe telling thhem or anyone that). I supposed God COULD exist, but I didn't see actual evidence, only people who believed. In college I read Isaac Asimov (famous for being an out atheist, among other things) say "The burden of proof for God should be on the positive, just as it is for anything else." I held on to that, but when I started attending AA I was literally SURROUNDED by believers at every meeting. After finally beginning daily attendance I "converted" and believed strongly (in God and that AA's steps would help me if I took them) for a couple of years. It took many more years, including reading every book on cults I could find (this was years before the Internet became ubiquitous), for me to deprogram myself. When I did get online I found sites such as Ken Ragge's, and SOS email list and other non-12-step resources. I didn't need these to stay sober/abstinent by then, but I was still in a way deprogramming myself.

Being on forums such as this is a way for me to "give away" the info that was so hard for me to find when I was trying to dig my way out of AA.
I think the Big Book is pretty terrible--I'm trying not to judge it on its literary merits, but it's still corny, contradictory, and sexist (the chapter "To Wives" is absolutely vile). I am reading it anyway because I am trying to be open-minded and teachable. I am trying not to be cynical around the Program because I am desperate to change my habits and get my life back on track, and the clinicians I've spoken to all say that AA what I should do.
Ask each clinician "are you a friend of Bill W.?" and watch them smile and their eyes light up. They'll be happy you know AA's "secret handshake." Most are, of course, 12-step members or are believers that people can only recover by attending 12-step groups and taking the 12 steps.

If you like the Big Book, you should pick up the 12&12 or "Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions," written about 10-15 years later but still filled with the same language, incluging the phrase "lustful enough to rape."
In other areas it would be a clear conflict of interest. Imagine a counselor telling you you should attend Catholic mass, and later finding out he's a Catholic priest, something he didn't tell you about. That's what most AA members do as counselors, hiding behind their AA membership with the anonymity "traditions" (AA's codeword for rules).

I'm in a very vulnerable position right now and I'm scared to death, frankly. I am trying to do what my sponsor and the people in AA tell me to do, but at the same time, all this Higher Power stuff strikes me as an affront to my human dignity. I have thought about "faking it," much the same way that I still go to mass on Christmas Day with my Mother because it comforts her, but lying is insulting to everyone involved as well.

I've found an agnostics' AA fellowship here in NYC and I'm going to start attending those meetings. I will report back on what I find there. I would link to their website but I'm new to the forum, so I do not have the privilege. Anyone can find info about them if they google agnostics nyc aa. Looks like it could be just the place for me, I hope I hope!
As you may know, there are true non-12-step groups such as LSR, SOS, WFS/MFS, though they're much rarer than AA. I haven't been to any support group in a decade, but like the alternative groups if for no other reason than I don't hear of alternative-group members committing suicide (as I discussed when I first started posting in this thread). And that's yet another reason why I finally stopped attending AA. If the verbal and emotional abuse weren't bad enough, it can only be hurtful psychically to go where you regularly see people once a week and never know when one will decide to, as it's described in AA, "take a permanent solution to a temporary problem."

In the meantime, I'm going to meetings in my neighborhood--I have one this afternoon, in fact. The frequency of meetings is one thing about the Program that doesn't alarm me, actually. Going to meetings every single day probably sounds extreme to some people, but we are talking about individuals who wanted to get blackout drunk every...single...day.
I didn't drink every day of my last few years of drinking, but I managed to go to 8 to 10 AA meetings per week in my first two years in AA. I felt a bit like I was chasing a carrot, and if I went to enough meetings I'd finally get it. What I got was brainwashed, despite the joke in the Ham On Wry section of the AA Grapevine where the old timer said "No, it's more like a dry cleaning operation."

But yes, the frequency of meetings isn't a "problem," it's just an indication of how popular AA is. Where I live there's a Baptist church almost literally on every corner, but despite my heritage I'm far from a Christian and I don't attend.

To find out more about the problems with AA. check out these websites:
http://orange-papers,org
http://morerevealed.com
http://peele.net

If you mention to an AA meber or at a meeting that you're reading this thread or reading "alternative to AA" readings, you'll see how alarmed they get - AA members see this as "playing with fire" and it being a life-or-death thing, and that you should ONLY go to AA and not read any of "that other stuff" on the Internet.
This is a fascinating thread. I will keep catching up on it till I read it through. Thank you all.
You'll notice my posts don't show up until posts numbered in the 4,000's. I honestly didn't read many of the earlier posts, just enough to see there are pro-AA posters as well as those of us one would expect on a skeptic forum.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Of course there are groups of "Atheists" in AA. If you look long enough, you can find a group that worships cans of cat food. AA casts a giant net of crazy, and they will take anyone in who is "willing to believe."

They still must accept a higher power that performs magic faith healing. It's interesting to hear the mind-bending rationalizations of what they use as their magical god. And it's more fun to hear one explain exactly how that magical god, whether it be a house plant, dog, the moon or whatever object they assign the task of ridding them of their spiritual deficiencies (yeah, I know, how does an atheist believe in a spirit. you can't get too logical or you'll wind up in a logical sinkhole).

If they are working the AA program, they are practicing religion.

If they are not working the program, they are not doing AA. Well, that's not exactly true. They me be doing the crazy slogans and gaslighting and such, but that isn't the program. That's just the culture.

AA allows for these "atheist" groups, but only if they use the dogma, because they are sure, as the 'Big Book' instructs, that if they fake their way through it, they'll be converted. Catholics, Hindus, Jews, and just about any religion I can think of also welcomes atheists who are willing to listen to the dogma. It's a conversion thing.

And the thing that gets lost is, AA is not religious. It is in itself a religion. So someone who is suckered into the faith healing nonsense, and comes to believe, is part of the religion. Or a cult, whichever one wishes to call it.
 
Until a valid statistical study proves that AA helps one to achieve sobriety better than placebo

Now that's interesting. A placebo meeting? Wouldn't the subjects know they were going to an AA meeting? Or would half go to an AA meeting and half go to one that looks exactly like an AA meeting?

I'm not being facetious, I'm really curious what this would look like. In a double blind study neither the subject nor the researcher knows which is the placebo and which is the real deal. The experiences are designed to be identical: Researcher hands subject a pill, subject swallows it.

If you're saying one group would go to a meeting and one group would take a pill, wouldn't their experiences be radically different? How would you correct for those differences? If it doesn't matter that the experiences are so different, why is the double-blind element so critical in clinical trials?
 
It's clear that you don't even bother reading the links I've provided. Your obfuscation is borderline ridiculous. Both of the centers that I've linked you to make their methodology clear.

Show me.

You know full well that treatment centers don't make their "success" rates public, so that information isn't available.

The why are people upset that AA doesn't/ Shouldn't the standards be the same? If one of us made this claim for AA, they would be ridiculed unmercilessly.

If you read the last link, you'd see "Evidence-based cognitive behavioral therapy illuminates how thinking influences the way we feel and behave." Again, it's clear that centers like this use evidence to create a treatment program based on what the evidence shows is effective. AA and 12-step centers do no such thing.

Correct, CBT does assist.
Incorrect 12 steps assist in doing exactly this (CBT).

A definition of CBT

Definition: CBT or Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy refers to any treatment based on the idea that psychological problems arise as a result of the way in which people interpret or evaluate situations, thoughts, and feelings, as well as our the behaviors stem from these evaluations. Cognitive-behavioral therapy has been found to be effective in treating a number of psychological conditions such as the anxiety disorders, depression, eating disorders, borderline personality disorder, and problems with alcohol and drug use.

So what if AA meetings are ubiquitous? This in no way means that they help with addiction. AA might claim to be effective, but that does not mean it is. Until a valid statistical study proves that AA helps one to achieve sobriety better than placebo such claims need to be treated as anecdotal only. Along this same vein, I can claim that the following treatments are equally as valid as AA:

- sticking my finger in my ear and singing ting-a-ling-loo.
- slapping a short bald headed guy on the top of his head while a sax plays in the background.
- standing on my head gargling lemonade while trying to hum the opening stanzas to the Benny Hill show.

Except there is one huge difference - you don't even have anecdotal evidence for your claims. AA has millions of members and thousands and thousands of meetings that provide exactly that. Your claims cannot be backed up with anything: Like I said - a huge difference

Not to mention more straw in your post since the world scarecrow convention. :rolleyes:
 
Hi Forum members!

I'm unsure of whether chiming in on this thread is a prudent move

Hi, Swanhilde.

I think the Big Book is pretty terrible--I'm trying not to judge it on its literary merits, but it's still corny, contradictory, and sexist (the chapter "To Wives" is absolutely vile).

I agree it's overrated. Bill Wilson was full of himself. My favorite part was always the stories. "Doctor, Addict, Alcoholic especially. The "allergy" part was probably poor science even for 1939, but as an analogy it can be useful.

I am trying to do what my sponsor and the people in AA tell me to do, but at the same time, all this Higher Power stuff strikes me as an affront to my human dignity.

If your sponsor makes you feel worse it's not a good fit. Be true to yourself. I found room to clear the God bar with the underlined disclaimer in Step 3 - without feeling like a hypocrite. I can't speak for your meeting but people don't move in lockstep in my part of the country. If your crap detector detects crap - there's a decent chance you're right.

I've found an agnostics' AA fellowship here in NYC and I'm going to start attending those meetings. I will report back on what I find there. I would link to their website but I'm new to the forum, so I do not have the privilege. Anyone can find info about them if they google agnostics nyc aa. Looks like it could be just the place for me, I hope I hope!

So do I.

Going to meetings every single day probably sounds extreme to some people, but we are talking about individuals who wanted to get blackout drunk every...single...day.

I liked going every day. I do better with lots of structure.

This is a fascinating thread. I will keep catching up on it till I read it through. Thank you all.

I find it fascinating, and annoying - so annoying I keep coming back :;

Whatever works for you. Best wishes from across the Internet. No matter what happens.
 
gayak:

Alcoholics Anonymous
The Godless Heathens
SUNDAY - 9:00 AM
El Cerrito Fellowship
2426 Church Lane
EL CERRITO,
Details: Format:
Language: English

Atheist & Agnostic
Berkeley Fellowship
2108 McGee Ave.
Tuesday 7:00 p.m.


Athiest/Agnostic
530 Lake Park Ave
Grand Lake Neighborhood Center
Wednesday 7:00 pm


Atheists Agnostics and others
Alano Club
1748 Market St. (near Octavia Blvd.)
Saturday 11:00 a.m.

Using one area as an example, AA members who are atheist in the bay area can go to different atheist AA groups on Sunday, Tues, Wednesday, and Saturdays.

Hopefully you'll find these specific listings of what you repeatedly deny exists less disingenuous. I don't want to work any harder.

How 'bout we now move on to whatever your next point is, so we can have some fun with that?

Damn Mondo you nailed it. I was always a tad leery to post these types of groups in my area of the country because of traditions of anonymity and the fact I find it hard to believe many members here have ever been to AA.
Plus I would not forgive myself if someone from Jack's Blog Site should get this information and disrupt a AA meeting.
 
And this proves several points that I have been making in this thread and disproves several of the points made by AA apologists:
1) AA religious claims are NOT in line with atheist beliefs. You yourself claim they were when the fact that atheists needed to change the wording to suit their beliefs proves you wrong.

Nobody ever said they were, NOBODY!!! AA has enough room to accommodate Atheist.

2) AA is not all inclusive and specifically targets atheists. They do not remove the meetings that are very religious only the ones that are non-religious.

Yes AA is all inclusive and it always has been. You would know this if you went at all to AA. Please actually do some footwork.

3) You cannot "take what you want and leave the rest" and still belong to AA. At least not if you're an atheist.

Once again, YES YOU CAN!!! Thanks to all the beings in the universe that you are not in charge of AA. Because your idea of AA would border on abusive.
4) AA members do insist atheists change their beliefs even though they claim that doesn't happen.

This is total ignorance of AA, to say something as inept as this. You have just shown here that you really have no knowledge of AA and the inner working at all.

There are more, those are the main ones.

No, there really are not any more. What there is my friend is rambling from someone just having fun with this thread.

Except that that will never happen because the program was set up by religious people for religious people and so christian beliefs will always fit into the program. The "G" in God, the "H" in He and Him, and the "H" and "P" in Higher Power ensure that.

Who is arguing this point, no one. You really think you are the first to understand this info.
So I am happy you have figured this out. Now please kind of grasp onto this thought process. Even though Bill W. wanted a religious domain many others did not so they opened it up to everyone as much as they could in 1934. We get it (atheists) and we exist just fine within AA.

Your explanation is disingenuous.

No Mondo is not being disingenuous. I think Mondo thought he was conversing with someone who understood AA or at least would take this conversation serious.
 
Of course there are groups of "Atheists" in AA. If you look long enough, you can find a group that worships cans of cat food. AA casts a giant net of crazy, and they will take anyone in who is "willing to believe."

They still must accept a higher power that performs magic faith healing. It's interesting to hear the mind-bending rationalizations of what they use as their magical god. And it's more fun to hear one explain exactly how that magical god, whether it be a house plant, dog, the moon or whatever object they assign the task of ridding them of their spiritual deficiencies (yeah, I know, how does an atheist believe in a spirit. you can't get too logical or you'll wind up in a logical sinkhole).

If they are working the AA program, they are practicing religion.

If they are not working the program, they are not doing AA. Well, that's not exactly true. They me be doing the crazy slogans and gaslighting and such, but that isn't the program. That's just the culture.

AA allows for these "atheist" groups, but only if they use the dogma, because they are sure, as the 'Big Book' instructs, that if they fake their way through it, they'll be converted. Catholics, Hindus, Jews, and just about any religion I can think of also welcomes atheists who are willing to listen to the dogma. It's a conversion thing.

And the thing that gets lost is, AA is not religious. It is in itself a religion. So someone who is suckered into the faith healing nonsense, and comes to believe, is part of the religion. Or a cult, whichever one wishes to call it.

Jack, I thought you and I had already covered this topic before. Why you are acting like you are a authority on AA is beyond most of us here. On a radio program you sat in on you stated that you had never really been a member, you said this. That you lacked real experience, you had no real interpersonal relationships with AA or it's members.
So I am finding it very hard to understand and believe that you would even know what a atheist is going through in AA. I mean you can intellectualize about it or we can along with you. But that really doesn't pass the acid test does it.
Your careless characterizations of AA as a cult is naive at best, you have no proof of this. This statement shows your ignorance of AA, "AA allows for these "atheist" groups, but only if they use the dogma".
AA does not order people to do anything, my my!! as I told Qauy, I am so happy the AA you write about does not exist because it would be horrible.
Jack many of us have offered our help to you. With hopes of bringing you up to speed on the inner working of AA.
Ask us, buddy.
 
gayak:

'Bombotuna:

If they are praying to God, asking for His help. and generally sucking up to a Higher Power, they are still practicing religion.'

Instead of continuing to maintain that there are no atheists in AA or atheist meetings allowed to exist because AA doesn't want atheists around, you now want to go with the proposition that the atheist AAs who attend these groups haven't the kind of atheism you feel they should have.

Good for you. That's the first turning toward a more reasoned direction I've seen on this thread. By leaving behind your old false assertions and going on to new ones you've surrendered in a very small measure to the truth of things. All progress is good.

I'm fine with how you're imagining these members see things, but have no interest in reading exactly how you know what this vast group of individuals who reject all religion are thinking. Please don't go into that as it quickly becomes painful to read.
 
Originally Posted by A.A. Alfie
'So AA doesn't work by the scientific methodology you would like - we get it. My question to you is: Does anything meet your standards?'

gayak: post #5279

Ibogain research and treatment.

We shouldn't ignore examining this treatment for alcoholism suggested by gayak since it meets his standards for scientific methology.

MAPS (Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies) is still taking donations for the first scientific study conducted on the longterm efficacy of ibogaine for treatment of drug addiction, as they have been collecting from any willing source since 2004.

This first scientific study ever will be examining data obtained from the 6 room treatment house located in the Playas de Tijuana bordertown and also the treatment program run in an upscale condo apartment on the 8th floor of a Vancouver condo association building.

By studying the data provided by these operations and later adding in a New Zealand program despite their statement that only a few people had ever signed up for it, the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies plans to at sometime in the future issue the results of their tightly controlled scientific study.

If the donations keep coming in.

Some people's standards for scientific methodology and research aren't all that hard to meet, it seems.
 
Instead of continuing to maintain that there are no atheists in AA...

Why address this to me, I've never made such a claim?

You will also note that I ignored your claim about my statements regarding critical mass. If you were paying attention you would know that I never made a single statement about critical mass nor have I ever said there were no atheists in AA.

Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread.


...or atheist meetings allowed to exist because AA doesn't want atheists around...
Instead of? Have you not been reading? :confused:

...you now want to go with the proposition that the atheist AAs who attend these groups haven't the kind of atheism you feel they should have.
No, not at all. That is just the interpretation you get when you filter my writing through your theist mind.

In fact, the error is yours in thinking that all atheists are the same and that if one atheist can ignore their beliefs and pretend imaginary skydaddies will cure their alcoholism then all atheists can. You need only read this thread to know otherwise.

What I have been saying, and what is evidenced by people in this thread, is that not all atheists are able to suspend their beliefs, or tolerate religious muddle headed rantings, in order to attend AA meetings. That AA insists these people continue using the religious mumbo jumbo guarantees the vast majority of atheists will shy away from AA.

And that's okay, too, but if that is what AA wants then could they should stop lying about how they are all inclusive and not religious.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom