"They" don't see it the way you do, can you grasp that? It's the attribution of malice that baffles me, like there's some sort of cover-up going on. I never encountered this orchestrated, monolithic "lying" that you and others attribute to "AA, and its membership."
But you have encountered it, you just choose to ignore it. How do you justify the de-certifying of the atheist groups in Toronto if AA is all inclusive and there is no religious requirement to the program?
It is really that simple. Why didn't all those claiming AA is all inclusive speak out for the atheist groups? They didn't though. They said that if the atheists want to belong they would have to change. That is the very definition of non-inclusive.
If they simply stopped lying, you'd be OK with it.
Yes.
A lot of this thread revolves around the definition of "religious." It wouldn't be hard to find AA members who'd say, "Yeah, it's religious." There would be others who counter, "No, it's not religious." It will not matter how many times someone points this out, someone else will rear up and announce, "Yeah, but they're lying."
Agreed so instead of listening to opinion, read the literature and look at the practices. It's religious, and as I pointed out on numerous occasions, the Girl Guides of Canada ran into the same issue when they made the claim that they were all inclusive after changing wording in their literature to read "God as you understand Him" and "Higher Power" instead of the traditional "God."
Nobody was fooled except a few religious people inside the organization who really believed those changes made a difference. They didn't to anyone else and certainly not to the agnostics and atheists they were trying to include.
People seem to be talking past each other here. I suppose the tread became "moderated" for a reason.
No, the claim was made that AA was not religious but spiritual. Unfortunately the people making, and supporting, that claim haven't show it to be true. All evidence is to the contrary.
So, just because AA isn't "religious enough" to meet the definition of a believer doesn't mean it isn't religious. Fundamentalists seldom see other believers as being devout enough.
AA is a support group, for crying out loud don't attend it if you don't find it supportive.
Perhaps but that still doesn't answer the OP.
If you want to start a group that makes no mention of God, nobody is stopping you.
Perhaps you didn't read that part of the thread. Somebody did stop them.
Some guys started something in 1935 that many people believe has helped them. Frankly, even though I tend toward a belief in God, the steps themselves were not for me the Holy Grail that some people claimed them to be. But I never developed this belief that they were a bunch of scum-sucking liars, either.
Known errors that are not corrected become lies. Known lies that are repeated become fraud. At some point the errors of Bill W's program became frauds. I don't know where or when but it happened a long time ago and they continue. There is nothing wrong with exposing fraud, pointing out the lies and correcting the errors.
In this thread, when a believer tells me, an atheist, that a religious organization is inclusive of my beliefs and yet when I see that they are not, I am assumed to be the one in error. That is as absurd as a man telling a woman she has nothing to fear in walking down alleys in the dark because he does it and has never been raped.
Religious people have made the error here and when they keep repeating the error even when it has been explained to them, it becomes a lie. When that error becomes the basic claim of the organization, it is a fraud.
I think it is ironic that it is religious believers in this thread trying to convince atheists that we don't know what we believe and that AA is inclusive of us. As an atheist, I know for a fact that it is not.
From your religious perspective you might see AA as being inclusive but from an atheist perspective it just isn't.