Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
And yet, with all your much bragged about knowledge and experience, you have hitched your cart to a horse that has the same success rate as doing nothing.

I'm a bit skeptical of that knowledge and experience myself. What exactly is a forensic addictions counselor qualified to do? And how does one go about becoming one? Is it a degree at the bachelors or masters level? Is is from an accredited agency that is recognized by other standards bodies? Does one get training in basic statistics so that they can understand the results presented in scientific studies?

Or does one just not drink, go to meetings, and pay the certification fee?

Just asking.
 
benbradley:

"...lifetime meeting attendance in order to maintain abstinence, just as AA claims."

I'm unfamiliar with this claim of AA that you mention. May I ask for a link where AA claims that to be so?
Part of it is semantics. AA doesn't actually call itself "lifetime" program, it's called a "one day at a time" program. For anyone who uses one's mind, lifetime attendance logically follows.

One more thing when in doubt go to a meeting or there are two times to go to a meeting, when you want to and when you don't want to!!
It's clear from logical deduction that one should ALWAYS go to an AA meeting.

That's from the third post here:
http://www.stayingcyber.org/scarchive/dm042901.htm

The first post is also instructive - the OP asks:
For a topic I'd like to here some input on "Meeting Makers Make It?". How many Meeting are needed a week to maintain ones Sobriety, 2,4,7? Does this number change the longer we are sober?
I notice he didn't ask if zero was acceptable. I doubt it would have crossed his mind, but if it had he knew better than to ask.

You seem to want some "official" stance on this. I could email AAWS and ask when it's acceptable for a recovering alcoholic to stop attending AA meetings, and report the response.
 
Nutbag,
Can you or "ANYONE" show us JREF members where in pray-tale you get this misinformation from, please. If it is just your opinion then please say so either at the beginning or end of your post.
There are so many generalizations and inept comments made in those two paragraphs it would take me to long to debate them all.
One thing I will say here though, at any point in time you want to roll up your sleeves and jump in to help the addicted, please do. IMO!!! :)

Danny, anyone with even the slightest experience with the major treatment centers in the US knows that almost all of the counselors are AA or NA members. I know this because I've been to several large centers and now that I've been sober for a while I am friends with quite a few addiction counselors. Before I got clean, I went to several independent counselors as well. It's not misinformation. Google any treatment center you've heard of in the United States and I can almost guarantee you that they use a 12 step model, highly recommend AA as aftercare, and are staffed primarily by AA members. Hazelden, Betty Ford, Caron, etc. are all 12 step programs and intimately tied to AA as an organization. Again, there are exceptions and I was lucky enough to find one, but the state of addiction treatment in this country is deplorable, and AA's dominance in the field is a large reason why.

Here's Betty Ford's model: http://www.bettyfordcenter.org/treatment-programs/inpatient-treatment/index.php

And Caron: http://www.caron.org/caron-treatment-services.html

Hazelden sells 12-step material through their website: http://www.hazelden.org/OA_HTML/ibeCCtpItmDspRte.jsp?item=1120&sitex=10020:22372:US

Again, if you're a treatment center using a 12 step model, who better to employ but members of a 12 step organization? This is the basic model for treatment in the US. 12-step based inpatient treatment, AA as aftercare, and addictions counselors who are 12 step believers.


BTW, I do quite a bit to help people who are struggling, but that doesn't include recommending they try faith healing. There are places in the US, few and far between as they may be, that use science instead of revelation as the basis for their methodology. I understand the desire to help others, but sending them to a program that has such an implausible mechanism of action as to be absurd isn't the way to do it. Instead, if we really care about helping other addicts, we should by trying to break the dominance of AA and other outdated treatments so that more resources can be funneled to expanding science based approaches.
 
I would be fine if the steps remained the same and AA, and its membership, simply stopped lying about them.

It's possible they simply don't agree with your definition of "religious" and are not maliciously trying to deceive you.

What AA has that other self-help movements don't is critical mass. If I'm craving booze or drugs there is probably a meeting within reasonable distance that can help me stay clean for an hour or two. There are other alternatives (like eating a hot fudge sundae) but a meeting is usually the most interesting one, not as fattening, etc. There are people there who know what I'm feeling. Maybe they can help me, or I can help them. At that point the issue isn't really whether it will cure me; it's whether I can not use today.

Somewhat lost in this discussion is the healing benefit of community. If you go to a meeting regularly people get to know you, you get to know them, and, as so many others have said on this thread, I have encountered far more tolerance than bigotry. Having sober friends may be just as useful as the steps. There's a synergy though. For example, when I get angry I often pause to ask myself, why am I so angry? Why did this post get a rise out of me? Why do I feel compelled to persuade? That's part of step 4 and it's useful in relationships.

BTW when I tried to do a fourth step in Bill Wilson's format, I was stymied. So I used a different format. It's flexible.

Step 3 in practice, for me, often means letting go when I've done my best to solve a problem and the result is out of my hands. Less worry, healing benefit. I've sometimes used the word "reality" to substitute for the"God." I don't feel any need to adopt Bill Wilson's concept of God even though he clearly had one. I'm not allergic to the word. To me it's code for something that can't really be described in words. If someone used the word "Jesus" instead though, I'd be annoyed. Maybe there is a good analogy there: I would then say AA is "Christian" and would resent AA saying, "We're not Christian!" The Lord's Prayer has never struck me as particularly Christian. Jesus supposedly said it but I don't find it objectionable. I do have to stop myself from saying "Keep coming back!" at funerals, though.

There is sign on a wall in my neck of the woods: "Happiness is submission to God." I had a friend who didn't like it. I said, "How about, Peace is acceptance of the inevitable?" She liked that fine. In my internal experience these statements are more alike than different. You may believe I'm wrong to equate the two statements but it doesn't change my felt experience.

If someone tells you AA is not religious, bear in mind the possibility that you and that person may have divergent definitions of "religious." Just saying, don't rule it out.
 
Wow. 133 pages.

It works for some people (my agnostic to atheist cousin, still sober 28 years later, being one of them) but it doesn't work for everybody. I don't think it dangerous to point out that it works for some people. There's more than one tool in the tool kit for solving some problems. Use whichever works for you, and leave the options open.


Choice is a good thing, don't you think?

Claiming AA helped someone, or someone claiming AA helped them, does not mean AA did help. There has been no evidence provided to show that AA helped anybody . . . ever.

The claim that "choice is a good thing" just like the claim that "there are no dumb questions" isn't always true. In this case, the implications of what you suggest are absurd. "It's a good thing Bill has a choice between shamanism and voodoo, what, with his cancer diagnosis and all!" :boggled:
 
It works for some people (my agnostic to atheist cousin, still sober 28 years later, being one of them) but it doesn't work for everybody. I don't think it dangerous to point out that it works for some people. There's more than one tool in the tool kit for solving some problems. Use whichever works for you, and leave the options open.


Choice is a good thing, don't you think?

There are people who've had cancer go into remission who used homeopathic therapy, too. It doesn't mean it's the therapy that did it. Five percent of problem drinkers quit every year. The five percent of AA members who quit are simply part of that group. If AA wasn't such a joke, their numbers would be higher, because that is where people who want to quit drinking congregate. But because it's such a loony bin, they can't even improve upon a control group that includes even those alkies not planning on quitting. Trust me, faith healing doesn't work. Really.

AA always takes credit for their members who quit, even though it's the same percentage who would quit on their own anyway. But they blame the failures on the person, not the group or program.

Sadly, there are large pockets of the population with no choice besides AA. Like where I live. Steppers aren't real big on creating awareness, either. AA is their world. To a worm in a horseradish, the world's a horseradish.
 
"They" don't see it the way you do, can you grasp that? It's the attribution of malice that baffles me, like there's some sort of cover-up going on. I never encountered this orchestrated, monolithic "lying" that you and others attribute to "AA, and its membership."

But you have encountered it, you just choose to ignore it. How do you justify the de-certifying of the atheist groups in Toronto if AA is all inclusive and there is no religious requirement to the program?

It is really that simple. Why didn't all those claiming AA is all inclusive speak out for the atheist groups? They didn't though. They said that if the atheists want to belong they would have to change. That is the very definition of non-inclusive.

If they simply stopped lying, you'd be OK with it.

Yes.

A lot of this thread revolves around the definition of "religious." It wouldn't be hard to find AA members who'd say, "Yeah, it's religious." There would be others who counter, "No, it's not religious." It will not matter how many times someone points this out, someone else will rear up and announce, "Yeah, but they're lying."

Agreed so instead of listening to opinion, read the literature and look at the practices. It's religious, and as I pointed out on numerous occasions, the Girl Guides of Canada ran into the same issue when they made the claim that they were all inclusive after changing wording in their literature to read "God as you understand Him" and "Higher Power" instead of the traditional "God."

Nobody was fooled except a few religious people inside the organization who really believed those changes made a difference. They didn't to anyone else and certainly not to the agnostics and atheists they were trying to include.

People seem to be talking past each other here. I suppose the tread became "moderated" for a reason.

No, the claim was made that AA was not religious but spiritual. Unfortunately the people making, and supporting, that claim haven't show it to be true. All evidence is to the contrary.

So, just because AA isn't "religious enough" to meet the definition of a believer doesn't mean it isn't religious. Fundamentalists seldom see other believers as being devout enough.

AA is a support group, for crying out loud don't attend it if you don't find it supportive.

Perhaps but that still doesn't answer the OP.

If you want to start a group that makes no mention of God, nobody is stopping you.

Perhaps you didn't read that part of the thread. Somebody did stop them.

Some guys started something in 1935 that many people believe has helped them. Frankly, even though I tend toward a belief in God, the steps themselves were not for me the Holy Grail that some people claimed them to be. But I never developed this belief that they were a bunch of scum-sucking liars, either.

Known errors that are not corrected become lies. Known lies that are repeated become fraud. At some point the errors of Bill W's program became frauds. I don't know where or when but it happened a long time ago and they continue. There is nothing wrong with exposing fraud, pointing out the lies and correcting the errors.

In this thread, when a believer tells me, an atheist, that a religious organization is inclusive of my beliefs and yet when I see that they are not, I am assumed to be the one in error. That is as absurd as a man telling a woman she has nothing to fear in walking down alleys in the dark because he does it and has never been raped.

Religious people have made the error here and when they keep repeating the error even when it has been explained to them, it becomes a lie. When that error becomes the basic claim of the organization, it is a fraud.

I think it is ironic that it is religious believers in this thread trying to convince atheists that we don't know what we believe and that AA is inclusive of us. As an atheist, I know for a fact that it is not.

From your religious perspective you might see AA as being inclusive but from an atheist perspective it just isn't.
 
benbradley:

When first you said AA and LifeRing make the claim that lifetime meeting attendence is necessary to maintain sobriety, what you meant to say was 2 posters on this thread think so and you interpret a common saying as indicative of that if one were to follow the line of reasoning that you suggest.

I see a difference. Can you see a difference?
 
What AA has that other programs don't (that I know of) is critical mass. It's free and it's all over the place. You want to use and instead you go to a meeting. Voila, you've put off getting loaded for another hour, in the company of people who know how you feel.

Edited by LashL: 
Moderated thread.

Other programs had critical mass in the past too. Think Catholicism before the Reformation or slavery before the cotton gin. The existence of a movement or institution does not ipso facto justify its existence, especially if one believes that progress and innovation are constants.
 
Where? Names please. And details of the methodology.

Again Alfie, I already sent you a link to one, which you just swept under the rug even though it included a location, name, and methodology. That's a fairly common treatment model in Florida, and most of the treatment centers in South Florida operate similarly, though some also incorporate 12-step programs into treatment. Admittedly most treatment centers are 12-step based, but that doesn't mean they're effective.

Would it kill you to google at all? This is the first non-12 step center that pops up on google and while I have no idea about the quality of their care, the way they approach addiction as being treatable by evidence based methods is night and day from AA. http://www.malibuhorizon.com/non-12-step-program.aspx

Here's their clinical philosophy: http://www.malibuhorizon.com/our_philosophy.aspx

As an addictions counselor, shouldn't you be aware of non-12 step alternatives? I'd imagine that if you were genuinely curious about these programs you could call/email them as a practitioner and they would be more than happy to provide you with a more detailed account of their methodology and philosophy.
 
gayak:

"How do you justify the de-certifying of the atheist groups in Toronto if AA is all inclusive and there is no religious requirement to the program?...Why didn't all those claiming AA is all inclusive speak out for the atheist groups?...They said that if the atheists want to belong they would have to change. That is the very definition of non-inclusive."

Do you think there aren't atheist AA groups? There are lots. The Godless Heathens AA Group in El Cerrito comes to mind. In Berkeley they even have their own fellowship hall. In almost every state there are plenty of atheist AA meetings. Your claim that AA is not inclusive is refuted by their existence.

Do you believe the Toronto groups were 'decertified'? They weren't. Do you think NY can certify or decertify groups? They can't. Do you have faith that the Toronto groups were taken off the meeting listings because they were atheists and AA doesn't want any stinking atheists? Not so.

You may disagree with the actual reasons for delisting the 2 groups, and as an outside observer you've every right to hold forth on subjects you're not involved with if you stick to the facts. The group reworded the steps to match up better with their beliefs and thus became something other than AA. Continuing to list them with the AA groups didn't make sense.

If an entirely Christian AA group did the same thing, they could expect the same treatment. That would not mean that AA doesn't like Christians, or that Christians can't be AA members, but you can bet somewhere on the Net some nut would go on about that being the case.

The sensitivities of dedicated believers being as tender as they so often are.
 
Hi Forum members!

I'm unsure of whether chiming in on this thread is a prudent move...but I've spent hours reading this thread and I felt compelled to join.

I stopped believing in God quite naturally when I was about 12 years old and have described myself as an atheist my entire adult life.

I am also participating in AA. I am a reluctant participant (but to be fair, so is everyone, it seems--I haven't seen anyone come into AA skipping). I think the Big Book is pretty terrible--I'm trying not to judge it on its literary merits, but it's still corny, contradictory, and sexist (the chapter "To Wives" is absolutely vile). I am reading it anyway because I am trying to be open-minded and teachable. I am trying not to be cynical around the Program because I am desperate to change my habits and get my life back on track, and the clinicians I've spoken to all say that AA what I should do.

I'm in a very vulnerable position right now and I'm scared to death, frankly. I am trying to do what my sponsor and the people in AA tell me to do, but at the same time, all this Higher Power stuff strikes me as an affront to my human dignity. I have thought about "faking it," much the same way that I still go to mass on Christmas Day with my Mother because it comforts her, but lying is insulting to everyone involved as well.

I've found an agnostics' AA fellowship here in NYC and I'm going to start attending those meetings. I will report back on what I find there. I would link to their website but I'm new to the forum, so I do not have the privilege. Anyone can find info about them if they google agnostics nyc aa. Looks like it could be just the place for me, I hope I hope!

In the meantime, I'm going to meetings in my neighborhood--I have one this afternoon, in fact. The frequency of meetings is one thing about the Program that doesn't alarm me, actually. Going to meetings every single day probably sounds extreme to some people, but we are talking about individuals who wanted to get blackout drunk every...single...day.

This is a fascinating thread. I will keep catching up on it till I read it through. Thank you all.
 
gayak:

"How do you justify the de-certifying of the atheist groups in Toronto if AA is all inclusive and there is no religious requirement to the program?...Why didn't all those claiming AA is all inclusive speak out for the atheist groups?...They said that if the atheists want to belong they would have to change. That is the very definition of non-inclusive."

Do you think there aren't atheist AA groups? There are lots. The Godless Heathens AA Group in El Cerrito comes to mind. In Berkeley they even have their own fellowship hall. In almost every state there are plenty of atheist AA meetings. Your claim that AA is not inclusive is refuted by their existence.

Do you believe the Toronto groups were 'decertified'? They weren't. Do you think NY can certify or decertify groups? They can't. Do you have faith that the Toronto groups were taken off the meeting listings because they were atheists and AA doesn't want any stinking atheists? Not so.

You may disagree with the actual reasons for delisting the 2 groups, and as an outside observer you've every right to hold forth on subjects you're not involved with if you stick to the facts. The group reworded the steps to match up better with their beliefs and thus became something other than AA. Continuing to list them with the AA groups didn't make sense.

If an entirely Christian AA group did the same thing, they could expect the same treatment. That would not mean that AA doesn't like Christians, or that Christians can't be AA members, but you can bet somewhere on the Net some nut would go on about that being the case.

The sensitivities of dedicated believers being as tender as they so often are.

Mondotuna, you're right that AA as a whole can't remove a group. But whatever organization prints the meeting lists, be it an intergroup office or an area or district office can. They simply do this by removing the groups in question from the meeting list, so anyone looking at official AA material that lists what is supposed to be an exhaustive list of meetings in an area will not find them. And no where in AA's literature does it say you can't modify the steps. IIRC, it says any group of two or more alcoholics with a desire to quit drinking may call themselves a group. They were delisted because they didn't buy into the faith healing aspect of AA and didn't follow AA dogma.

Anecdotally, even in areas where agnostic/atheist groups exist, they're the subject of much derision from members of other groups. I've heard some pretty unflattering things said in meetings and the parking lot about a specific group in S. Florida that dropped the whole "god" thing and was open to anyone of any religious persuasion. Even when these groups exist, there is enormous social pressure from other groups not to get involved with them.
 
Claiming AA helped someone, or someone claiming AA helped them, does not mean AA did help. There has been no evidence provided to show that AA helped anybody . . . ever.

I see. This is logical to an atheist. I agree that I cannot scientifically prove that AA helped me.

And it points out the schism between atheists and non-atheists. If I say going to church helped me, it would be equally as illogical, because I cannot prove it. Never mind that to me it helped; to you I was being self-delusional. Does that make sense?

...If AA wasn't such a joke, ...

It was inconsiderate comments such as this that the thread became moderated, not the debate itself.

AA always takes credit for their members who quit, even though it's the same percentage who would quit on their own anyway. But they blame the failures on the person, not the group or program.

True, and I don't like that aspect. Maybe I should stop going? The standard response here is that I should go to a non-12 step alternative or suck-it-up and stop on my own. The thing is I have done both, all three really. I stopped on my own, with the help of AA, Smart Recovery, and at times various medications. BTW, I must give a sincere and honest thanks to all the critics of AA. You guys have given me resources I never would have found within AA. It's been very educational, and while I disagree with many opinions expressed, I think for the most part you've done a great service to this thread and skepticism as a whole.

People seem to be talking past each other here. I suppose the tread became "moderated" for a reason.

No, the claim was made that AA was not religious but spiritual. Unfortunately the people making, and supporting, that claim haven't show it to be true. All evidence is to the contrary.

Not tired of playing the word definition game yet? I am. Lot's of people have claimed lots of things, with evidence to back up every claim made.

Perhaps but that still doesn't answer the OP.

I did, many times, and AA is in my opinion religious. And I can see how that would be a problem for some people. Would you agree that for the vast majority of people in the United States, AA being a religious organization is not only not a problem, but a comfort? Please try not to insult those people that do believe in a god.

Known errors that are not corrected become lies. Known lies that are repeated become fraud. At some point the errors of Bill W's program became frauds. I don't know where or when but it happened a long time ago and they continue. There is nothing wrong with exposing fraud, pointing out the lies and correcting the errors….

To you, the statement “There is a god” is a lie, is it not? If the response here is that the lie is the statement that AA is not inclusive, that’s more word games.

I can go to a synagogue and ask a Rabbi for help, while not being Jewish. I never have, but I could. Would the rabbi turn me away? Ask me to convert first? If he told me to read the Torah, should I mock him? Should we shut down the synagogues because I am not included?

To rap up, I think I understand why atheist are anti-AA. Seeing vulnerable people getting support from a faith-based organization could be very worrying to an atheist, I suppose. Rest assured, though, there are plenty of people within AA that if not seeing that dilemma, at least acknowledge that it's there.
 
Mondotuna, you are completely off base with your claims. How much experience do you actually have with AA at the Regional, Area, and National level? I've spent decades of my life at all 3, including time at the NY headquarters at nearly the highest levels (just below trustee) - the nonsense that AA isn't organized, and that the groups are really in charge and NY just sorta keeps the history and publishes books is Orwellian BS.

Have you read many of the (publically closed - even to / expescially to legimate researches & scientists) AA archives? I have had access to them myself, before they pulled my privledges. I've had decades of experience, gone to 1000's of meetings, created entire districts from scratch. I've spoken to 10's of thousands of AA's - by invitation. I've made the statement 'Neither god, nor any higher power, is necessary to get or maintain sobriety' in front of 1000's of AA members - a big risk. Although I am sure there are people with more internal experience on AA, they are few and far between.
As for your fallicious claim that there are many atheists groups in AA, this is false based on both my experience, as well as the fact that the AA program itself actively fights against atheism, makes the statement that anyone who's agnostic or atheist (the big book doesn't even understand what an atheist is) is 'dishonest' or 'prejudiced' - if you know your big book as well as I do, you will agree with what I just stated.
There are indeed agnostic, somewhat non-theist 'meetings' that use the AA name, but these exist because the groups they belong too allow it to occur - and if NY finds out about them, they will get decertified/delisted from the national directories.

Lastly (as I 've stated innumable times since the very beginning of this thread, have you bothered to read the whole thing? I have) - lastly, I'll make it clear once again there is a big, big difference between the AA program, and the meetings themselves. Meetings, on occasion, alter and change, some even adapt with the latest information in treatment - but the AA program hasn't changed in 75 years. I myself have tried for over 20 years to get the chapter 'We Agnostics' removed from the big book, completely removed from any AA material. Not just me, but hundreds of us have tried to do this at the annunal Conferences as well as via Area/GSRs - we've been voted down more times than I can count, with the majority opinion being 'it's worked so well we don't want to change it' sort of nonsense....

In summary, I see the arguments by the pro-AA crowd here haven't changed since the beginning of the thead - no surprise there.
 
This is the first non-12 step center that pops up on google and while I have no idea about the quality of their care, the way they approach addiction as being treatable by evidence based methods is night and day from AA. -

Here's my problem. You cite "science based" models yet you have "no idea" of their efficacy, their quality of care nor their treatment. You say they are science based, yet you cannot tell us what their science is based on.

It seems to me like you have simply read a pamphlet and believed it.

What is their model based upon?
How does it work?
What are their efficacy rates?

You brought them in, you get to support them. That's how it works around here.
 
Do you think there aren't atheist AA groups? There are lots. The Godless Heathens AA Group in El Cerrito comes to mind. In Berkeley they even have their own fellowship hall. In almost every state there are plenty of atheist AA meetings. Your claim that AA is not inclusive is refuted by their existence.

Do you believe the Toronto groups were 'decertified'? They weren't. Do you think NY can certify or decertify groups? They can't. Do you have faith that the Toronto groups were taken off the meeting listings because they were atheists and AA doesn't want any stinking atheists? Not so.

You may disagree with the actual reasons for delisting the 2 groups, and as an outside observer you've every right to hold forth on subjects you're not involved with if you stick to the facts. The group reworded the steps to match up better with their beliefs and thus became something other than AA. Continuing to list them with the AA groups didn't make sense.

So as long they leave God in the program, then atheists groups are allowed in AA.

Awesome.

Hey, Mondo. Why not elaborate further on your opinions of LifeRing. What is your experience with that program?
 
But you have encountered it, you just choose to ignore it.

You say I have encountered it, I say I haven't. One of us was there.

I said, if you want to start a support group that makes no mention of God no one is stopping you. You reply yes, AA stopped them.

Let's see if you can spot the difficulty with that line of reasoning.

And as for "critical mass": I say AA has it and there are meetings all over the place. Someone responds, "Catholicism before the Reformation or slavery before the cotton gin" also had critical mass.

"I like McDonalds. I can always find a McDonalds. It has critical mass."

And at one time slavery had critical mass, so that proves ... I'm sorry, what does that prove?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom