Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You just wrote in consecutive paragraphs that you incorporate 12-step treatment, which involves turning over ones life to God, praying to god to remove the shortcomings which cause alcoholism, etc.; and that you have no faith healing in your program. If you can explain how the following is not faith healing, and is evidence based, I would appreciate it:

- Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
- Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
- Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.



I would never ask you disclose where you work, but if you could link one treatment center anywhere in North America that uses the 12-step model, and does not use AA as its aftercare dumping ground, I would appreciate it.

As for the treatment where you work, I have nothing to say about it, as you haven't stated what it entails. Just that it works, and it's evidence based. I'm not sure what you mean by "evidence based." You also said AA works for some people, although you didn't cite any supporting evidence. Truthiness doesn't doesn't count.

Jack, I've pretty much agreed with everything that you've posted in this thread. I will say, however, that I've had experience with a scientifically-based treatment center that avoids using the 12-step model in it's own methodology, but does encourage patients who are comfortable with the 12 steps to seek out AA/NA. I personally found this to be a silly strategy, but unfortunately many newly recovering people in treatment centers have already been convinced that AA is the best solution for alcoholism and want a center to be at least compatible with a 12-step program. The center I'm familiar with never, under any circumstance, would ask a patient to do any of the woo-ish steps, but did incorporate some of the "principles" of AA like honesty, etc. in their program. So there certainly is at least one center in the US that picks and chooses some of the more reasonable AA practices and combines them with actual science based treatment.

The thing I find even more disturbing than most centers using AA as their dumping ground is the lack of experience that most counselors have with any treatment modality other than the 12-steps. Even this relatively good and forward thinking center was comprised of a substantial number of counselors who were 12-step believers, and while they couldn't officially endorse AA during their treatment sessions, it was clear that they were approaching 12-step programs with an uncritical eye. Most centers I know of are far worse, run almost entirely by AAers who aren't willing to critically examine AA and it's ridiculously implausible mechanism of action, and use their position of authority to try to convert unbelievers to believe in AA's God crap.
 
I'm not saying it doesn't work

So it does work?

My personal standard is a carefully controlled long-term study that utilizes control groups consisting of a large, diverse population, conducted by an objective scientific, non-affiliated organization.

Do you know of any such studies? I don't.

So where would you recommend a sick, struggling and desperate alcoholic go? To a Benny Hill convention or a rehab? What course (in general type terms) would you recommend?
 
...
Where I work we are really strict about therapeutic boundaries.
The "theraputic boundaries" I knew of was that counselors at a treatment center were not allowed to go to the same 12-step meetings as current patients of the center. This is pretty easily done, as there are limited places patients can go to meetings - one on the premises run by outside AA members, and "outside meetings," regular meetings in clubhouses that the patients get taken to on a bus. With maybe a thousand meetings a week in any large metropolitan area, that one's pretty easy to adhere to.
 
I'm not saying it doesn't work - just that it has not been statistically proven to work any better than placebo (e.g. singing ting-a-ling-a-loo, gargling upside-down, doing nothing).

My personal standard is a carefully controlled long-term study that utilizes control groups consisting of a large, diverse population, conducted by an objective scientific, non-affiliated organization.

Do you know of any such studies? I don't.

LOL, OK then.

I am going to bow out of this. IMHO (albeit limited) AA is flat out bonkers.
 
benbradley:

"With maybe a thousand meetings a week in any large metropolitan area, that one's pretty easy to adhere to."

No argument at all with that statement. If their bosses require them to hit different meetings they surely find minimal difficulty in doing so. Even a medium sized town with only half as many meetings to choose from it would still be easy.

It may be a problem if at some point in the future any rehabs decide to base their program on SOS for example, and were able to find and hire counsellors who had stayed sober a couple of years or more by following that program to staff their operation. Only a few large metropolitan areas have a meeting or two each week, and the employees would then be faced with driving several states away to attend the next available meeting.

I wonder how they would work that out?
 
So it does work?



So where would you recommend a sick, struggling and desperate alcoholic go? To a Benny Hill convention or a rehab? What course (in general type terms) would you recommend?

So your position is go to AA because there is nothing else?

Actually, Benny Hill has the same success rate as AA, or better.
 
So your position is go to AA because there is nothing else?

Nope.
But I will wait for Bambe to answer as it is he who has these high standards.

In the meantime, perhaps you could outline what treatments you would recommend.
 
So it does work?

There's no way of knowing if it works any better than placebo until sound statistical studies show otherwise.

So where would you recommend a sick, struggling and desperate alcoholic go? To a Benny Hill convention or a rehab? What course (in general type terms) would you recommend?

I would suggest they dry out and not drink again. A rehab might help with the drying out part, assuming there are controls in place to keep substances away from patients. The not drinking again phase (post-rehab) gets more tricky. Again, AA has not been shown to be any more effective in this regard as placebo, so I have no idea what to suggest.

Longitudinal studies that show how/why people stopped/moderated drinking after having abused alcohol might help to give clues to what works. Do you know of any?
 
Actually, Benny Hill has the same success rate as AA, or better.

People would be better off do all kinds of things in lieu of going to AA: Benny Hill, ice skating, playing dominoes, jogging in place, whatever. These things won't do anything to get an alkie off the sauce, either -- but at least with these things, unlike AA, there isn't any religious brainwashing. They wouldn't be subjected to nutbag old-timers who couldn't gain employment at a porn shop, but somehow think they're a spiritual guru and addiction experts because they've studied the 'Big Book' for twenty years. And maybe they could actually learn to think for themselves, outside of the confines of aphorisms and slogans.

Yep. Benny Hill is a better choice.
 
Jack, I've pretty much agreed with everything that you've posted in this thread. I will say, however, that I've had experience with a scientifically-based treatment center that avoids using the 12-step model in it's own methodology, but does encourage patients who are comfortable with the 12 steps to seek out AA/NA. I personally found this to be a silly strategy, but unfortunately many newly recovering people in treatment centers have already been convinced that AA is the best solution for alcoholism and want a center to be at least compatible with a 12-step program. The center I'm familiar with never, under any circumstance, would ask a patient to do any of the woo-ish steps, but did incorporate some of the "principles" of AA like honesty, etc. in their program. So there certainly is at least one center in the US that picks and chooses some of the more reasonable AA practices and combines them with actual science based treatment.

The thing I find even more disturbing than most centers using AA as their dumping ground is the lack of experience that most counselors have with any treatment modality other than the 12-steps. Even this relatively good and forward thinking center was comprised of a substantial number of counselors who were 12-step believers, and while they couldn't officially endorse AA during their treatment sessions, it was clear that they were approaching 12-step programs with an uncritical eye. Most centers I know of are far worse, run almost entirely by AAers who aren't willing to critically examine AA and it's ridiculously implausible mechanism of action, and use their position of authority to try to convert unbelievers to believe in AA's God crap.

Nutbag,
Can you or "ANYONE" show us JREF members where in pray-tale you get this misinformation from, please. If it is just your opinion then please say so either at the beginning or end of your post.
There are so many generalizations and inept comments made in those two paragraphs it would take me to long to debate them all.
One thing I will say here though, at any point in time you want to roll up your sleeves and jump in to help the addicted, please do. IMO!!! :)
 
There's no way of knowing if it works any better than placebo until sound statistical studies show otherwise.

I would suggest they dry out and not drink again. A rehab might help with the drying out part, assuming there are controls in place to keep substances away from patients. The not drinking again phase (post-rehab) gets more tricky. Again, AA has not been shown to be any more effective in this regard as placebo, so I have no idea what to suggest.

Longitudinal studies that show how/why people stopped/moderated drinking after having abused alcohol might help to give clues to what works. Do you know of any?

People would be better off do all kinds of things in lieu of going to AA: Benny Hill, ice skating, playing dominoes, jogging in place, whatever. These things won't do anything to get an alkie off the sauce, either -- but at least with these things, unlike AA, there isn't any religious brainwashing. They wouldn't be subjected to nutbag old-timers who couldn't gain employment at a porn shop, but somehow think they're a spiritual guru and addiction experts because they've studied the 'Big Book' for twenty years. And maybe they could actually learn to think for themselves, outside of the confines of aphorisms and slogans.

Yep. Benny Hill is a better choice.

Thanks for your help gents. :rolleyes:
It is patently clear that like so many in the wider community, you have little understanding of the complexities around treatment and recovery.
In my opinion your ideas, suggestions and opinions are not just ignorant, but dangerous in the extreme.
 
benbradley:

"With maybe a thousand meetings a week in any large metropolitan area, that one's pretty easy to adhere to."

No argument at all with that statement. If their bosses require them to hit different meetings they surely find minimal difficulty in doing so. Even a medium sized town with only half as many meetings to choose from it would still be easy.

It may be a problem if at some point in the future any rehabs decide to base their program on SOS for example, and were able to find and hire counsellors who had stayed sober a couple of years or more by following that program to staff their operation. Only a few large metropolitan areas have a meeting or two each week, and the employees would then be faced with driving several states away to attend the next available meeting.

I wonder how they would work that out?
An aspect of the scenario you describe is it assumes some other model of recovery would require continued lifetime meeting attendance in order to maintain abstinence, just as AA claims. The SOS meetings I attended in the 1990's didn't assume that a person needed to continue to attend meetings for a lifetime or a certain period of tome to maintain abstinence. People sometimes went months or years between attending meetings without anyone there assuming they had been drinking. I have the impression that the more recent LSR (a spinoff of SOS with mostly similar ideas - it was actually an online self-proclaimed "unofficial" SOS site circa 1995-1999) does promote this "suggestion," much like AA.

The idea that one must go to some sort of meeting to maintain "sobriety" is a false one that AA promotes, and it has become such a strong and "obvious" idea in many people's minds who have attended AA (even if they disagree with much of the rest of AA dogma) that it's not surprising that this idea (and others) would get carried into secular groups.
 
Thanks for your help gents. :rolleyes:
It is patently clear that like so many in the wider community, you have little understanding of the complexities around treatment and recovery.
In my opinion your ideas, suggestions and opinions are not just ignorant, but dangerous in the extreme.

How in Zeus' name you can make those assertions based on my post you quoted above is beyond me. As for my ideas being dangerous: evidence please.
 
Thanks for your help gents. :rolleyes:
It is patently clear that like so many in the wider community, you have little understanding of the complexities around treatment and recovery.
In my opinion your ideas, suggestions and opinions are not just ignorant, but dangerous in the extreme.
I agree wholeheartedly with the texts of the posts you quoted, so I suppose I'm also dangerous in the extreme. So you can go ahead and tell me I'm "killing alcoholics." It wouldn't be the first time I've been accused of that.

It's also interesting how you say "you have little understanding of the complexities around treatment and recovery." Everything I was told in AA meetings was "this is a simple program, but it's not easy," "keep it simple, stupid/sweetheart" sand that the whole program is in the first 164 pages of the big book of Alcoholics Anonymous. It's interesting how people spend years studying and re-reading those 164 pages, as if their lives depended on it. And yes, many of them DO believe their lives depend on it. I once believed so myself.
 
The idea that one must go to some sort of meeting to maintain "sobriety" is a false one that AA promotes, and it has become such a strong and "obvious" idea in many people's minds who have attended AA (even if they disagree with much of the rest of AA dogma) that it's not surprising that this idea (and others) would get carried into secular groups.

Ya gotta have a lifetime of servitude to qualify as a cult. Well, one of the qualifications, at least. AA certainly meets this criteria. There is no exit strategy in AA. AA God™ not only gives reprieves for just 24-hour stretches, but he drops you like a bad habit once you stop attending the meetings and doing all that praying and such. Remember these inane AA slogans: your disease is doing push-ups in the parking lot; you're a day away from your next drink; and meeting makers make it!
 
benbradley:

"...lifetime meeting attendance in order to maintain abstinence, just as AA claims."

I'm unfamiliar with this claim of AA that you mention. May I ask for a link where AA claims that to be so?

If AA doesn't actually claim that lifetime meeting attendance is necessary in order to maintain abstinence, how could you alter your statement in order to make it true instead of false?

You also say "the more recent LSR (a spinoff of SOS with mostly similar ideas - it was actually an online self-proclaimed "unofficial" SOS site circa 1995-1999) does promote this "suggestion," much like AA."

I've not seen lifetime meeting attendence suggested to maintain sobriety in any LifeRing materials either. A quote from their material saying this would be helpful, or you may wish to restate this in some way to make it true instead of false.

Probably not worthwhile for you to get too worked up about AA or LifeRing promoting these false ideas. Without reference or links to the claims you mention these organizations are making it appears that you are the one with false ideas.

I'm new to JREF, but I'll try to help out with this kind of thing as we go along.
 
It is patently clear that like so many in the wider community, you have little understanding of the complexities around treatment and recovery.

And yet, with all your much bragged about knowledge and experience, you have hitched your cart to a horse that has the same success rate as doing nothing.

In my opinion your ideas, suggestions and opinions are not just ignorant, but dangerous in the extreme.

I understand this is just your opinion but do you have any evidence to support it? Are people going to die because these two have pointed out that AA doesn't work? In my opinion, falsely claiming AA works is far more dangerous than pointing out the fact that it doesn't.
 
I would be fine if the steps remained the same and AA, and its membership, simply stopped lying about them.

"They" don't see it the way you do, can you grasp that? It's the attribution of malice that baffles me, like there's some sort of cover-up going on. I never encountered this orchestrated, monolithic "lying" that you and others attribute to "AA, and its membership."

If they simply stopped lying, you'd be OK with it.

A lot of this thread revolves around the definition of "religious." It wouldn't be hard to find AA members who'd say, "Yeah, it's religious." There would be others who counter, "No, it's not religious." It will not matter how many times someone points this out, someone else will rear up and announce, "Yeah, but they're lying."

People seem to be talking past each other here. I suppose the tread became "moderated" for a reason.

AA is a support group, for crying out loud don't attend it if you don't find it supportive. But to go away nursing your wounds and holding a grudge just doesn't seem rational to me. The language on this thread bears that out. The characterization of AA as a "dumping ground" for treatment centers makes me wonder, what do such posters envision? That alcoholics and addicts will keep paying for treatment for the rest of their lives? Typically treatment programs offer aftercare, perhaps for a year, on a weekly basis. After that, you either become a paying customer again or you're referred to free community resources. If you want to start a group that makes no mention of God, nobody is stopping you.

Some guys started something in 1935 that many people believe has helped them. Frankly, even though I tend toward a belief in God, the steps themselves were not for me the Holy Grail that some people claimed them to be. But I never developed this belief that they were a bunch of scum-sucking liars, either.

Edited by LashL: 
Moderated thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
When I go back and read the thread this seems overlooked: Being part of a community can be healing in itself. For me that was probably more important than what's codified in the steps. I made friends. It was interesting, more interesting than getting loaded. There was always a chance someone would say something I really needed to hear, or vice versa. The willingness to show up brought its own rewards.

Bits of the steps come in handy all the time. For example, if people's rude posts are pushing my buttons, I'm somewhat conditioned to examine my buttons rather than blaming the poster. As in, why do I feel a need to persuade people who are going to be hostile no matter what I say?

If you leave out the friendships formed in AA you leave out a significant aspect of the program. Somebody has probably made that point. I believe there are studies that reinforce the importance of community in staying relatively healthy, un-depressed, etc. AA can be that community. These forums can be that community, to a certain extent.

What AA has that other programs don't (that I know of) is critical mass. It's free and it's all over the place. You want to use and instead you go to a meeting. Voila, you've put off getting loaded for another hour, in the company of people who know how you feel.

OK I'll leave this thread for a few days.

Edited by LashL: 
Moderated thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wow. 133 pages.
In my opinion, falsely claiming AA works is far more dangerous than pointing out the fact that it doesn't.
It works for some people (my agnostic to atheist cousin, still sober 28 years later, being one of them) but it doesn't work for everybody. I don't think it dangerous to point out that it works for some people. There's more than one tool in the tool kit for solving some problems. Use whichever works for you, and leave the options open.


Choice is a good thing, don't you think?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom