Poster Nutbag
Student
- Joined
- Aug 8, 2011
- Messages
- 46
You just wrote in consecutive paragraphs that you incorporate 12-step treatment, which involves turning over ones life to God, praying to god to remove the shortcomings which cause alcoholism, etc.; and that you have no faith healing in your program. If you can explain how the following is not faith healing, and is evidence based, I would appreciate it:
- Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
- Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
- Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
I would never ask you disclose where you work, but if you could link one treatment center anywhere in North America that uses the 12-step model, and does not use AA as its aftercare dumping ground, I would appreciate it.
As for the treatment where you work, I have nothing to say about it, as you haven't stated what it entails. Just that it works, and it's evidence based. I'm not sure what you mean by "evidence based." You also said AA works for some people, although you didn't cite any supporting evidence. Truthiness doesn't doesn't count.
Jack, I've pretty much agreed with everything that you've posted in this thread. I will say, however, that I've had experience with a scientifically-based treatment center that avoids using the 12-step model in it's own methodology, but does encourage patients who are comfortable with the 12 steps to seek out AA/NA. I personally found this to be a silly strategy, but unfortunately many newly recovering people in treatment centers have already been convinced that AA is the best solution for alcoholism and want a center to be at least compatible with a 12-step program. The center I'm familiar with never, under any circumstance, would ask a patient to do any of the woo-ish steps, but did incorporate some of the "principles" of AA like honesty, etc. in their program. So there certainly is at least one center in the US that picks and chooses some of the more reasonable AA practices and combines them with actual science based treatment.
The thing I find even more disturbing than most centers using AA as their dumping ground is the lack of experience that most counselors have with any treatment modality other than the 12-steps. Even this relatively good and forward thinking center was comprised of a substantial number of counselors who were 12-step believers, and while they couldn't officially endorse AA during their treatment sessions, it was clear that they were approaching 12-step programs with an uncritical eye. Most centers I know of are far worse, run almost entirely by AAers who aren't willing to critically examine AA and it's ridiculously implausible mechanism of action, and use their position of authority to try to convert unbelievers to believe in AA's God crap.