MatildaGage
Muse
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2010
- Messages
- 799
Are you suggesting 12-step facilitation is a comprehensive definition of professional treatment? Because it isn't.Nonsense. Twelve-Step Facilitation is AA is AA. Like all woo, they shine it up a little, but it is definitely AA.
My facility never dumps people on AA as a substitute for aftercare. Maybe you meant to say "sometimes".And once the insurance runs out, AA serves as the dumping ground and used as "aftercare."
Do you have statistics on this?That is, until the person relapses, which they do at the same rate as those with no treatment at all.
AA and some treatment facilities work symbiotically.AA and treatment facilities work symbiotically.
/fixed that for you
True, in my experience."Two-hatters" (steppers who found the AA religion and became addiction counselors) permeate the industry
But not much different than any human services professions. Lots of religious types or "I was in their shoes so I want to give back" types. This is unprofessional and ineffective unless it's managed properly. I've seen that in action many times. Where I work we are really strict about therapeutic boundaries.
Agreed, but again only in some states.and the education requirements are pathetically low.
My state has medium requirements when compared with others, and it requires a few years of classes and education, followed by a written and oral exam. When I took it 75% of candidates failed, so I can't say it has totally bogus entrance criteria.
But certainly compared with similar professions (i.e., mental health counselor) it is out of whack (Master's Degree + experience). Mental health counseling is more complex (treating lots of diseases instead of one, some diseases entirely organic in origin, lots of screening to determine if patients have neurological issues, etc.) so it should require more, but that much more? I think it's a disservice to chemically dependent people. But there is a labor shortage in this field so it would be a really hard sell to increase the education requirements at this time.
If that is true then it's sad. We have much higher requirements than that, and I've never worked at or with any facility that operates that way, so I can't speak to the veracity of that statement. I can only say the ones I've been in touch with (~100) have never indicated AA attendance is the only requirement to get a job. In fact in my state all programs operating that way would lose their operating certificates and be closed down due to violating operating regulations.In fact, AA attendance in itself is enough in many places to meet the criteria.
It's sad, really.