Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nonsense. Twelve-Step Facilitation is AA is AA. Like all woo, they shine it up a little, but it is definitely AA.
Are you suggesting 12-step facilitation is a comprehensive definition of professional treatment? Because it isn't.

And once the insurance runs out, AA serves as the dumping ground and used as "aftercare."
My facility never dumps people on AA as a substitute for aftercare. Maybe you meant to say "sometimes".

That is, until the person relapses, which they do at the same rate as those with no treatment at all.
Do you have statistics on this?

AA and treatment facilities work symbiotically.
AA and some treatment facilities work symbiotically.
/fixed that for you

"Two-hatters" (steppers who found the AA religion and became addiction counselors) permeate the industry
True, in my experience.

But not much different than any human services professions. Lots of religious types or "I was in their shoes so I want to give back" types. This is unprofessional and ineffective unless it's managed properly. I've seen that in action many times. Where I work we are really strict about therapeutic boundaries.

and the education requirements are pathetically low.
Agreed, but again only in some states.

My state has medium requirements when compared with others, and it requires a few years of classes and education, followed by a written and oral exam. When I took it 75% of candidates failed, so I can't say it has totally bogus entrance criteria.

But certainly compared with similar professions (i.e., mental health counselor) it is out of whack (Master's Degree + experience). Mental health counseling is more complex (treating lots of diseases instead of one, some diseases entirely organic in origin, lots of screening to determine if patients have neurological issues, etc.) so it should require more, but that much more? I think it's a disservice to chemically dependent people. But there is a labor shortage in this field so it would be a really hard sell to increase the education requirements at this time.

In fact, AA attendance in itself is enough in many places to meet the criteria.

It's sad, really.
If that is true then it's sad. We have much higher requirements than that, and I've never worked at or with any facility that operates that way, so I can't speak to the veracity of that statement. I can only say the ones I've been in touch with (~100) have never indicated AA attendance is the only requirement to get a job. In fact in my state all programs operating that way would lose their operating certificates and be closed down due to violating operating regulations.
 
All very good points, taking the term "non-pejoratively" (or substituting "sect"), one has to wonder - even if AA is one, can't it be a positive one?

I mean, if believing in Barny the purple dinosaur enables you to not abuse alcohol and to be a contributing member of society, that's still OK isn't it? I know some people feel the (understandable) need/impulse to confront all irrational beliefs but sometimes IMHO, it's OK to let sleeping dogs lie.
You're quite right, if AA were a benign organization, it would be "OK." Marc Galanter saw AA in this way in his book "Cults: Faith, Healing and Coercion."

Unfortunately Galanter didn't write about the underside of AA, but rather he whitewashed it as a "healing cult" and compared it to the violent offshoot organization/drug treatment program Synanon. He claimed AA's traditions prevent it from becoming such a dangerous group. Actually, the AA traditions protect AA by claiming no one can represent or speak for AA, and by hiding the memberships of AA members, including those who do detrimental and criminal actions.

You might check out the accusations against AA at these sites and see if they might be true and whether AA is truly a benign organization:

http://orange-papers.org
http://morerevealed.com
http://stinkin-thinkin.com
http://peele.net

As far as "the C word" itself I don't think it's a very useful word. Calling a group a cult may be a convenient shorthand (a short definition might be like the Supreme Court Justice's definition of pornography, "I know it when I see it"), but it can cause unnecessary ire in proponents of the group.

These proponents might not be members themselves, but rather friends or relatives of members who have seen them "turned their lives around" since joining, yet they have little clue of what goes on in 12 step groups (such as how much meeting discussions revolve around prayer and God, or how many of the steps mention God), much less have any knowledge of the negative parts.
 
A.A. Alfie;7537640The original question was why you care about whether the word God is in upper or lower case. What possible difference could it make to you or anyone else? :confused:[/QUOTE said:
That's not true, Alfie. The original statement by Bamberger was:

Originally Posted by Bamberger
Because religion posing as medicine is both ludicrous and shameful.

To which you responded:

My question is why do you care?

Which makes your last statement rather misleading.

In the case of what is the importance in the way "god" is spelled: Christians, which Bill W. was, always insist their god be referred to as God to separate him from the lesser gods of the other faiths. If Bill was discussing anything other than the christian god, the one he believed in, he would have spelled it god, not God.
 
No it's not, especially because AA has never been proven scientifically to cure addiction any better than doing nothing. Why not just have addicts stand on their heads and gargle lemonade while trying to hum the opening stanzas to the Benny Hill show? In my mind that would be equally as effective as AA, as well as much more fun to watch.

Here we go again...
Tell me, exactly what scientific treatment have you got that works? And even more importantly, can you prove it?

I thought we had fleshed out that there is nothing on the table that can show any treatments' efficacy rates that outdo any other.

When you say "science", I say "show me" and guess what is produced? Zippo!
 
Are you suggesting 12-step facilitation is a comprehensive definition of professional treatment? Because it isn't.

The Minnesota Model certainly is, and it's shamelessly AA. All of these AA-based treatment modalities toss in additional woo, but the 12-step faith healing is the basis of the programs.

AA and some treatment facilities work symbiotically.
/fixed that for you

Well over 90% of treatment centres in North America use AA based treatment, and you won't find a single one of them who doesn't use AA as their aftercare dumping ground.
Where I work we are really strict about therapeutic boundaries.

I've never seen this, although I have seen many deny that their little corner of the 12-step world is somehow different.

Agreed, but again only in some states.

My state has medium requirements when compared with others, and it requires a few years of classes and education, followed by a written and oral exam. When I took it 75% of candidates failed, so I can't say it has totally bogus entrance criteria.

But certainly compared with similar professions (i.e., mental health counselor) it is out of whack (Master's Degree + experience). Mental health counseling is more complex (treating lots of diseases instead of one, some diseases entirely organic in origin, lots of screening to determine if patients have neurological issues, etc.) so it should require more, but that much more? I think it's a disservice to chemically dependent people. But there is a labor shortage in this field so it would be a really hard sell to increase the education requirements at this time.

If by "some" states, you mean "most" states, then yes, this is true. In half of the states, no formal education is required.

The education itself is also laughable. It all has its nexus in the same place: a deluded religious fanatic and his religiously fanatical brethren, who re-worked a steps and a program from the Oxford group religious cult. I can dress in a lab coat and lecture all I want about creationist junk science, and it's still junk science. Dressing religious faith-healing up as education doesn't make it an academic endeavor. It makes it woo.

Do you have statistics on this?

Studies of both AA and AA-based treatment have been posted multiple times here in this thread, and have been ignored by the AA faithful. I'm not going to re-post them.

Having said that, it's not my job to show it doesn't work. It's your job to show it does. I'll save you some time on this. Nothing shows either AA or AA-based treatment is more effective at getting people to quit drinking than doing nothing at all. Some show a negative correlation, in fact. Steppers are more likely to fall off the wagon, and steppers binge drink at five times the normal rate.
 
In the case of what is the importance in the way "god" is spelled: Christians, which Bill W. was, always insist their god be referred to as God to separate him from the lesser gods of the other faiths. If Bill was discussing anything other than the christian god, the one he believed in, he would have spelled it god, not God.

The spelling is very important as it shows intent. Until the AA literature is updated to change the spelling of God to god (or replace it altogether with another word) it has to be assumed that a monotheistic deity in line with the Judeo-Christian tradition is being referred to in the writing. Hence, AA will remain religious by nature until reforms are made.

The same goes for the prayers said at the vast majority of AA meetings worldwide. Both the Lord's prayer and the Serenity prayer are Christian prayers, and specifically make reference to a monotheistic deity. The lesser known stanzas of the latter prayer make reference to Jesus indirectly via a personal pronoun (He).
 
I can understand how you, as an atheist, feel that way.
It would be more accurate to say that Atheism is not open to AA. Individual Atheists could, if they desired, consider the non-religious components as beneficial, while finding the 'God' stuff as archaic.

Then again, I understand how ANY references to non-Atheistic points of view could be a deal breaker.

The evidence suggests otherwise. It was AA, not atheists, that de-certified the two Toronto atheist groups.

AA members are told they can "take what they want and leave the rest," or "AA is not religious and inclusive of all beliefs," and yet when an atheist group removes the religious references from a group that claims it isn't religious, they are removed by the organization itself.

The AA defenders in this thread repeat all the lofty rhetoric they learn from AA here on the list but ignore all the evidence that shows it is not true.
 
The spelling is very important as it shows intent. Until the AA literature is updated to change the spelling of God to god (or replace it altogether with another word) it has to be assumed that a monotheistic deity in line with the Judeo-Christian tradition is being referred to in the writing. Hence, AA will remain religious by nature until reforms are made.

In your estimation perhaps. Reality is somewhat different.

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

What do you think "other spiritual expressions" means?
 
Here we go again...
Tell me, exactly what scientific treatment have you got that works? And even more importantly, can you prove it?

I didn't claim anything worked. Read my post again. I hypothesize however that standing on one's head gargling lemonade and humming Benny Hill songs works just as well as AA.

I thought we had fleshed out that there is nothing on the table that can show any treatments' efficacy rates that outdo any other.

When you say "science", I say "show me" and guess what is produced? Zippo!

I agree. So what's the issue?
 
The evidence suggests otherwise. It was AA, not atheists, that de-certified the two Toronto atheist groups.

AA members are told they can "take what they want and leave the rest," or "AA is not religious and inclusive of all beliefs," and yet when an atheist group removes the religious references from a group that claims it isn't religious, they are removed by the organization itself.

The AA defenders in this thread repeat all the lofty rhetoric they learn from AA here on the list but ignore all the evidence that shows it is not true.

I think it was a mistake to de-certify the groups in Toronto. If I had a say in either group, I would would simply continue doing whatever we wanted to do. I would love to attend one of those meetings.

I don't much care about the "organisation". I don't care if it's G or g. I don't care that it is often read that "seldom have we seen someone fail that has followed these steps". I don't care that so many people attribute years of sobriety to gGod. I don't care if Bill W wanted to convert people to cChristianity. I don't care if the person next to me smells of booze (though I'd help them if I could). I don't care if people pray at the beginning, middle, or end.

I do care about me and those close to me. And yes, strangers too I suppose. If going to AA meetings helps me and others, that's a good thing. I would hope those that are opposed to AA and its practices would be happy for me at least.
 
The spelling is very important as it shows intent. Until the AA literature is updated to change the spelling of God to god (or replace it altogether with another word) it has to be assumed that a monotheistic deity in line with the Judeo-Christian tradition is being referred to in the writing. Hence, AA will remain religious by nature until reforms are made.

The same goes for the prayers said at the vast majority of AA meetings worldwide. Both the Lord's prayer and the Serenity prayer are Christian prayers, and specifically make reference to a monotheistic deity. The lesser known stanzas of the latter prayer make reference to Jesus indirectly via a personal pronoun (He).

Agreed and it is exactly what the Girl Guides of Canada found when they changed references to God to read "higher power," and "God as you understand him."

It was only after the GG of C took a poll of the public to see why the changes had no effect on image and enrollment that they learned the public wasn't stupid enough to believe that those changes meant anything but the original religious words they replaced.

The GG of C then removed all references to god and religion in the organization literature, and practices, and their image improved and enrollment has been climbing steadily.

Not only did the change mean agnostics and atheists were included but they don't have apologists trying to explain away what is completely obvious to everyone else.
 
I didn't claim anything worked. Read my post again. I hypothesize however that standing on one's head gargling lemonade and humming Benny Hill songs works just as well as AA.

You brought a 'scientific proof' requirement in. I am asking you what does work in line with this standard - is there anything?
 
You brought a 'scientific proof' requirement in. I am asking you what does work in line with this standard - is there anything?

I said that there is no proof. Why would you ask me for any if I said there was none? I hypothesize however that having an addict stick their finger in their ear and sing ting-a-ling-a-loo would be equally effective as AA, seeing as the latter has never been proven to be any better than doing nothing. Can you refute this statement?
 
I guess there's people on here who would be fine with 12-step programs, provided somebody changed the steps. I don't think that's going to happen.

The elected governance of AA is within its rights to say that altering the steps pushes the "autonomy" envelope enough to conclude that the Toronto group is no longer AA. Each group is presumed to be autonomous except in matters affecting "other groups or AA as a whole."

But not having the AA imprimatur does not preclude a group from starting its own self-help tradition and it might well attract people that AA doesn't, or draw some "converts" from AA.

AA doesn't run treatment centers. I keep wanting to clarify this because some people seem to be confused.

On another note I've been thinking about the difference between "spirituality" and "religion" and have concluded that there might well be a secular spirituality. I realize many people would see that as a contradiction in terms. Perhaps I'm using "spirituality" as shorthand for a suite of cognitive and behavioral tools that, potentially, could change a person's life for the better by keeping destructive compulsions in check.
 
The Minnesota Model certainly is, and it's shamelessly AA. All of these AA-based treatment modalities toss in additional woo, but the 12-step faith healing is the basis of the programs.
I work at a facility that uses 12-step stuff in its treatment modalities, but the 12-step program is 1 hour per day out of 13 total hours of therapy (psychotherapy, relapse prevention, health education, etc.).

There is no faith healing. All our therapies are focused on behavior change.

Well over 90% of treatment centres in North America use AA based treatment, and you won't find a single one of them who doesn't use AA as their aftercare dumping ground.

As I pointed out I work at one. You seem to be making a lot of generalizations.

I've never seen this, although I have seen many deny that their little corner of the 12-step world is somehow different.

I’ve worked at other places that do so and in one of my jobs I traveled around to over 100 programs, so I've seen that.

My current employer is different. It’s because it’s managed properly, by a qualified licensed clinician and a team that does not allow for violation of therapeutic boundaries. I'm surprised you believe it's impossible for clinicians to behave appropriately and effectively?

I’m not a proponent of the 12 step model BTW. I can’t ignore the fact that it works for a lot of people but it would never work for me, if I found myself in need of something like that.

The education itself is also laughable. It all has its nexus in the same place: a deluded religious fanatic and his religiously fanatical brethren, who re-worked a steps and a program from the Oxford group religious cult. I can dress in a lab coat and lecture all I want about creationist junk science, and it's still junk science. Dressing religious faith-healing up as education doesn't make it an academic endeavor. It makes it woo.

Thanks for calling my education laughable….hmm….I took my courses in a well-respected college, one of many offering similar curricula. My courses taught evidence-based strategies--so drummed into our heads the groans became audible when the professor said "evidence-based". There was no religious fanatic and no one ever talked about religion in my classes.

Again, I’m no fan of the Oxfords or 12-step groups myself, but I know the difference between real education and fake. Again, I'm surprised you believe there is no such thing as quality counselor education programs?
 
I said that there is no proof. Why would you ask me for any if I said there was none? I hypothesize however that having an addict stick their finger in their ear and sing ting-a-ling-a-loo would be equally effective as AA, seeing as the latter has never been proven to be any better than doing nothing.

So AA doesn't work by the scientific methodology you would like - we get it. My question to you is: Does anything meet your standards?
 
I work at a facility that uses 12-step stuff in its treatment modalities, but the 12-step program is 1 hour per day out of 13 total hours of therapy (psychotherapy, relapse prevention, health education, etc.).

There is no faith healing. All our therapies are focused on behavior change.

You just wrote in consecutive paragraphs that you incorporate 12-step treatment, which involves turning over ones life to God, praying to god to remove the shortcomings which cause alcoholism, etc.; and that you have no faith healing in your program. If you can explain how the following is not faith healing, and is evidence based, I would appreciate it:

- Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
- Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
- Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

As I pointed out I work at one. You seem to be making a lot of generalizations.

I would never ask you disclose where you work, but if you could link one treatment center anywhere in North America that uses the 12-step model, and does not use AA as its aftercare dumping ground, I would appreciate it.

As for the treatment where you work, I have nothing to say about it, as you haven't stated what it entails. Just that it works, and it's evidence based. I'm not sure what you mean by "evidence based." You also said AA works for some people, although you didn't cite any supporting evidence. Truthiness doesn't doesn't count.
 
I guess there's people on here who would be fine with 12-step programs, provided somebody changed the steps. I don't think that's going to happen.

I would be fine if the steps remained the same and AA, and its membership, simply stopped lying about them.

The elected governance of AA is within its rights to say that altering the steps pushes the "autonomy" envelope enough to conclude that the Toronto group is no longer AA. Each group is presumed to be autonomous except in matters affecting "other groups or AA as a whole."

How does an atheist AA group affect other groups anymore than AA group that uses the lords prayer affects those that don't?

Once again, if AA were to stop lying and just admit it is a religious organization instead of claiming to be all inclusive, most probably wouldn't have a problem. We expect bigotry against outside groups from religious organization, we don't expect it from groups that claim to be all inclusive.
 
So AA doesn't work by the scientific methodology you would like - we get it. My question to you is: Does anything meet your standards?

I'm not saying it doesn't work - just that it has not been statistically proven to work any better than placebo (e.g. singing ting-a-ling-a-loo, gargling upside-down, doing nothing).

My personal standard is a carefully controlled long-term study that utilizes control groups consisting of a large, diverse population, conducted by an objective scientific, non-affiliated organization.

Do you know of any such studies? I don't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom