Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I suspect since you have been in AA for 36 years that you're keenly aware of the divide between the treatment centre AAs, and the AA fundies.

Alfie's view of the program is not well-liked by these old-school fundamentalists.

Edited by LashL: 
Edited for moderated thread

What is hilarious is your attempt to create two groups in AA. Jack this is your view of AA. as you said on the radio program you were on, you have a very limited education and or experience when it comes to AA. This is a fact, your words.
There is not a treatment center AA, there are treatment centers impersonating AA. Their are not fundamentalists in AA there are just members in AA.
See Jack, AA does not separate, it unifies. AA doesn't have a caste system nor does it have AA'ers that are ignorant and AA members that are in the know.
People are not coming to AA to be persecuted and judged, they would leave.
I am really sorry that the prejudice you feel towards AA clouds your ability to actually present AA realistically.

Very nice to see you mondotuna.
 
Jack Astor;7524638]I thought the 'Big Book' was nothing more than a historical document. Now you're quoting it like it means something.

"Note the capitalization of "God." Not a god, but the God."

"Not true. Nowhere in the book does it read "god of your understanding." It does, however, read "God as you understand Him."

Sounds like semantics to me, Jack.
 
"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

Why do you keep quoting the big book after you said it was nothing more than a historical document?

Anyway, the book is clear. It is a specific god, although you are free to conceptualize it however you wish. It is prayed to in exactly the same way, and performs the exact same mystical, magical powers.

And remember the instructions in the book. They are very clear. You may pick anything you wish to be your god, and as long as you're willing to believe, you soon be converted; and you'll realize what you thought was was your toothbrush performing those miracles, was AA God the whole time.
 
"Cult" is a subjective and pejorative term. Football fans might be a "cult" but not in a negative way as implied by the term.

Well, except for Raider fans...
 
Anyway, the book is clear. It is a specific god, although you are free to conceptualize it however you wish. It is prayed to in exactly the same way, and performs the exact same mystical, magical powers.

Um ... what?

So I have to choose one god, but I can conceptualise it any way I like as long as it is the one way?

At any rate, you can choose any god, any gods, no gods, or something else. Whatever works for you is just fine.

And remember the instructions in the book. They are very clear.

Indeed they are:

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

What do you suppose these "other spiritual expressions" are exactly?

Because religion posing as medicine is both ludicrous and shameful.

My question is why do you care?

They're still speaking of God. The spiritual stuff is just a side dish to the main course.

Nope!
The feast is sobriety. One of the many optional sidedishes is God. :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What is hilarious is your attempt to create two groups in AA. Jack this is your view of AA. as you said on the radio program you were on, you have a very limited education and or experience when it comes to AA. This is a fact, your words.
There is not a treatment center AA, there are treatment centers impersonating AA. Their are not fundamentalists in AA there are just members in AA.

Sounds like semantics to me, Danny.

See Jack, AA does not separate, it unifies. AA doesn't have a caste system nor does it have AA'ers that are ignorant and AA members that are in the know.

AA unifies by separating the god believers from the non-believers and making the non-believers uncomfortable enough to leave. In a very short time AA is a group of united believers.

No AA member here has been able to reconcile the actions of AA head office in de-certifying the atheist AA groups in Toronto with their own claims that AA is all inclusive or that members are free to "take what they want and leave the rest."





People are not coming to AA to be persecuted and judged, they would leave.
I am really sorry that the prejudice you feel towards AA clouds your ability to actually present AA realistically.

Sounds like semantics to me, Danny.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I care, and so do a lot of other skeptics. And the language of the day hasn't changed all that much. The use of the word God is common in Christian denominations.



The door is wide open so long as long as such beliefs and expressions lead one to the acceptance of a monotheistic deity called God. BTW mysticism, Ouija boards, seances and the like were by no means unheard of in Wilson's day. Why weren't they included as viable paths to a Higher Power? I believe it has something to do with the clerical oversight that was involved during the writing of the big book.

Bamberger, this is your understanding and you are entitled to it. The door to AA is wide open whether it leads to God or not. I am one who can and will attest to this.
 
"Cult" is a subjective and pejorative term. Football fans might be a "cult" but not in a negative way as implied by the term.

Well, except for Raider fans...
Actually, a "cult following" such as sports fans or (especially) Grateful Dead fans who followed the band to concerts across the country, is a different meaning of the word. These followers do so completely voluntarily, and aren't in any way misled by the people or objects they follow.

But as used for "coercive, high-demand" groups, yes it's definitely subjective and almost always pejorative. Calling something a cult does get the ire of its defenders or (especially a group with as good PR as AA) even the uninformed general public who may be offended at calling it a cult, but AA does enough cult-like stuff for me to think of it as a cult (also, read Charles Bufe's "AA: Cult or Cure?").

This website (saved on archive.org) is an interesting resource. It describes every religious group I've ever heard of, including mainstream churches such as Catholicism and the major Protestant denominations, but also Alcoholics Anonymous and even non-religious business groups (multilevel marketing organizations):
http://web.archive.org/web/20060902...ments.lib.virginia.edu/profiles/listalpha.htm
It doesn't rank groups as "cult" or "not cult" but it discusses any controversies surrounding each group.
I found the essays here on "cult" and "sect" interesting (the word cult didn't originally have a pejorative meaning any more than sect did or does now):
http://web.archive.org/web/20060901...ments.lib.virginia.edu//cultsect/cultsect.htm
 
That page has a whole lot of statistics about people before and after treatment, but it doesn't have a word about what treatment is.
Good, because I was responding to a post asking if there were statistics proving treatment outcomes.

Do you know exactly what "professional treatment" is in the USA?
Yes. Why do you ask?

Do you have any idea what percentage of people working as professionals in the alcohol-and-drug treatment field are members of Alcoholics Anonymous or another 12-step program?
I don't care what my colleagues do in their free time.
 
AA is not treatment any more than a peer support group for cancer survivors is chemotherapy. It's an adjunct.

Nonsense. Twelve-Step Facilitation is AA is AA. Like all woo, they shine it up a little, but it is definitely AA. And once the insurance runs out, AA serves as the dumping ground and used as "aftercare." That is, until the person relapses, which they do at the same rate as those with no treatment at all.

AA and treatment facilities work symbiotically. "Two-hatters" (steppers who found the AA religion and became addiction counselors) permeate the industry, and the education requirements are pathetically low. In fact, AA attendance in itself is enough in many places to meet the criteria.

It's sad, really.
 
Actually, a "cult following" such as sports fans or (especially) Grateful Dead fans who followed the band to concerts across the country, is a different meaning of the word. These followers do so completely voluntarily, and aren't in any way misled by the people or objects they follow.

But as used for "coercive, high-demand" groups, yes it's definitely subjective and almost always pejorative. Calling something a cult does get the ire of its defenders or (especially a group with as good PR as AA) even the uninformed general public who may be offended at calling it a cult, but AA does enough cult-like stuff for me to think of it as a cult (also, read Charles Bufe's "AA: Cult or Cure?").

This website (saved on archive.org) is an interesting resource. It describes every religious group I've ever heard of, including mainstream churches such as Catholicism and the major Protestant denominations, but also Alcoholics Anonymous and even non-religious business groups (multilevel marketing organizations):
http://web.archive.org/web/20060902...ments.lib.virginia.edu/profiles/listalpha.htm
It doesn't rank groups as "cult" or "not cult" but it discusses any controversies surrounding each group.
I found the essays here on "cult" and "sect" interesting (the word cult didn't originally have a pejorative meaning any more than sect did or does now):
http://web.archive.org/web/20060901...ments.lib.virginia.edu//cultsect/cultsect.htm
All very good points, taking the term "non-pejoratively" (or substituting "sect"), one has to wonder - even if AA is one, can't it be a positive one?

I mean, if believing in Barny the purple dinosaur enables you to not abuse alcohol and to be a contributing member of society, that's still OK isn't it? I know some people feel the (understandable) need/impulse to confront all irrational beliefs but sometimes IMHO, it's OK to let sleeping dogs lie.
 
I already took intro to gaslighting. Let's not go there. My previous response to you is your answer.

Actually it isn't. You answered a question I didn't ask. :rolleyes:

The original question was why you care about whether the word God is in upper or lower case. What possible difference could it make to you or anyone else? :confused:

btw: what gaslighting has to do with any of this is completely beyond me. :boggled:
 
All very good points, taking the term "non-pejoratively" (or substituting "sect"), one has to wonder - even if AA is one, can't it be a positive one?

No, because it is not addressing addiction in a progressive, scientific manner. Look, we could also stick alcohol abusers behind barbed wire and call that recovery but that wouldn't be too humane. Likewise, sending them to a program that requires belief in a Higher Power, aka God, is equally irrational. Hell, why not just eliminate the middleman and give them lobotomies? That might prove 100% effective.

I mean, if believing in Barny the purple dinosaur enables you to not abuse alcohol and to be a contributing member of society, that's still OK isn't it? I know some people feel the (understandable) need/impulse to confront all irrational beliefs but sometimes IMHO, it's OK to let sleeping dogs lie.

No it's not, especially because AA has never been proven scientifically to cure addiction any better than doing nothing. Why not just have addicts stand on their heads and gargle lemonade while trying to hum the opening stanzas to the Benny Hill show? In my mind that would be equally as effective as AA, as well as much more fun to watch.
 
You are mistaken. AA is not open to atheists.
I can understand how you, as an atheist, feel that way.
It would be more accurate to say that Atheism is not open to AA. Individual Atheists could, if they desired, consider the non-religious components as beneficial, while finding the 'God' stuff as archaic.

Then again, I understand how ANY references to non-Atheistic points of view could be a deal breaker.
 
Jack Astor;7536559]Nonsense. Twelve-Step Facilitation is AA is AA. Like all woo, they shine it up a little, but it is definitely AA. And once the insurance runs out, AA serves as the dumping ground and used as "aftercare." That is, until the person relapses, which they do at the same rate as those with no treatment at all.

Jack the nonsense is you have nothing (including personal experience) to back up what you just stated.
AA/GSO is not a treatment plan and no AA member would say it is. AA Treatment Centers do at times ask members of AA to come in and supply a AA meeting. But to infer or state that Treatment Facilities that impersonate AA into their Treatment Plan to help patients in there care does in fact make it AA is ludicrous. This is not AA it is a parody and it is hurting more then it helps.

AA and treatment facilities work symbiotically. "Two-hatters" (steppers who found the AA religion and became addiction counselors) permeate the industry, and the education requirements are pathetically low. In fact, AA attendance in itself is enough in many places to meet the criteria.

It's sad, really.

Does this include the friends and members on your blog that advertise for their treatment specialty in solving the riddle to alcoholism and drug addiction too, Jack.
Actually I did a study on this to see how many actual alcoholics and drug addicts that are active in AA, NA or CA work in the treatment industry in the Atlanta Metro area and it is about 25%. If you doubt this do the survey yourself. You have actual members on your blog from Atlanta.
Now I am referring to employees working right now in the treatment industry that are active members in AA, NA or CA.
Oh and the education requirements to work as a case worker (one on one) in these Treatment facilities was at least a Bachelors, check it out. I am not saying students of colleges are not working in these facilities but like a para-legal they are not solely responsible for any one client, resident or patient however you may call them.
Jack anything else you might have trouble stating on this site as pertains to AA, please just ask for help. It works better that way for all.
 
I do. Step twelve dictates these steppers "carry the message to the still suffering alcoholic." When the "message" is nothing more than faith-healing, that is important.

What is truly sad, Jack, is the possibility you believe what you write. :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom