Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know Bill very well just spoke to him last week, I am sure you are familiar with many of my friends. I would rather speak of names in a email or private message, please.
That mens weekend was called the "Rock" in Eatonton, beautiful state park.
It was 8111 I was referring too, Ben concerning no prayers.
Ridgeview had a annual New Years Gala in Marietta.
The Triangle is a trip just as you said, I could take it for to long.
I do believe you were a Alcoholic but I also believe that you weren't into AA. I don't have a problem with this either, really I don't.
I will talk more later on this.
You blew me away with your knowledge of AA in Atlanta. I haven't thought about Atlanta in a while.
Thanks.
I really did go to 7 to 10 AA meetings my first two years, mostly the Peachtree Corners group (met Monday and Friday) which was the first AA meeting I ever went to, and NABA much of the rest of the week, and also some other meetings in and around Norcross. So yes, I WAS into AA during my first two years. I then spent many more years slowly questioning the program, and I eventually became a "heretic" in meetings, and many people wouldn't talk to me because of it. I've been wanting to write a memoir about my experiences in and related to AA.

In later years I attended the Oakland Group in Lawrenceville, which finally became a club but disbanded when the church wanted to use (and presumably renovate!) the house the groups/club was renting from them. During that time I also went to a lot of other groups and meetings (including Al-Anon, Coda and OA) - some were with an Oakland friend, going to different clubs around, attending a meeting and then interviewing an officer of the club about how they ran things for research on forming the Oakland Club. I vaguely remember the one in Woodstock being in a double-wide trailer or similar building. We also went to the REBOS (that's SOBER backwards) club in the Marietta/Smyrna area.

Two really interesting people I met, but not in AA, were Al and his wife Kay, both I think in their '70's, at the Atlanta SOS meeting circa early-mid 1990's. I recall that Al died during that time and I didn't hear about it until later (I sometimes went months between SOS meetings). But he was an outspoken atheist and he talked about getting sober in NABA decades earlier and raising hell about the God stuff there, then in 1963 he and two other people started the Triangle Club. It was interesting to see how the club's tradition of being "liberal AA" survived. In fact it was known as the place the big stars in AA went to a meeting when their tours brought them to Atlanta.

Triangle was in an "interesting" area of Atlanta, in an area famous for strip clubs, a liquor store on the corner of the main street where you turn in to get to it, and across from that the infamous Gold Club.

Meetings at both Triangle and 8111 did the usual Serenity Prayer to start a meeting and Lord's Prayer to close when I attended (early-mid 1990's). I can believe there was a time when they didn't, and I can see where AA members from other groups would show up and demand the prayers or else "it's not a real AA meeting and it won't keep me sober."
 
I really did go to 7 to 10 AA meetings my first two years, mostly the Peachtree Corners group (met Monday and Friday) which was the first AA meeting I ever went to, and NABA much of the rest of the week, and also some other meetings in and around Norcross. So yes, I WAS into AA during my first two years. I then spent many more years slowly questioning the program, and I eventually became a "heretic" in meetings, and many people wouldn't talk to me because of it. I've been wanting to write a memoir about my experiences in and related to AA.

In later years I attended the Oakland Group in Lawrenceville, which finally became a club but disbanded when the church wanted to use (and presumably renovate!) the house the groups/club was renting from them. During that time I also went to a lot of other groups and meetings (including Al-Anon, Coda and OA) - some were with an Oakland friend, going to different clubs around, attending a meeting and then interviewing an officer of the club about how they ran things for research on forming the Oakland Club. I vaguely remember the one in Woodstock being in a double-wide trailer or similar building. We also went to the REBOS (that's SOBER backwards) club in the Marietta/Smyrna area.

Two really interesting people I met, but not in AA, were Al and his wife Kay, both I think in their '70's, at the Atlanta SOS meeting circa early-mid 1990's. I recall that Al died during that time and I didn't hear about it until later (I sometimes went months between SOS meetings). But he was an outspoken atheist and he talked about getting sober in NABA decades earlier and raising hell about the God stuff there, then in 1963 he and two other people started the Triangle Club. It was interesting to see how the club's tradition of being "liberal AA" survived. In fact it was known as the place the big stars in AA went to a meeting when their tours brought them to Atlanta.

Triangle was in an "interesting" area of Atlanta, in an area famous for strip clubs, a liquor store on the corner of the main street where you turn in to get to it, and across from that the infamous Gold Club.

Meetings at both Triangle and 8111 did the usual Serenity Prayer to start a meeting and Lord's Prayer to close when I attended (early-mid 1990's). I can believe there was a time when they didn't, and I can see where AA members from other groups would show up and demand the prayers or else "it's not a real AA meeting and it won't keep me sober."

Ben I stayed up north of you (575) primarily. HOW Place, several other meeting around Woodstock, Acworth, Kennesaw and Canton. I had many friends around Sandy Springs and the surrounding cities (I can't remember right now) downtown ATL was not one of my favorite places to go to meetings.
8111, The How Place and a meeting in Canton did have a meeting with no prayers. Was a big deal made of this no, it was actually kept low key.
 
From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.
 
From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

I thought the 'Big Book' was nothing more than a historical document. Now you're quoting it like it means something.

Note the capitalization of "God." Not a god, but the God. It's specific, and it performs specific acts. People conceptualize the same God in many ways. Some see Him in nature, some in what they perceive as a miracle, some feel His spirit. Either way, it's a specific god. The chapter simply advocates that someone be willing to be converted, and if they are willing and subject themselves to the dogma, the conversion will happen. This from the same chapter explains how whatever conception you use, it's still the same deity:

"Yes, we of agnostic temperament have had these thoughts and experiences. Let us make haste to reassure you. We found that as soon as we were able to lay aside prejudice and express even a willingness to believe in a Power greater than ourselves, we commenced to get results, even though it was impossible for any of us to fully define or comprehend that Power, which is God."

Whatever higher power you choose to use, it's the same god manifesting itself. The chapter is very clear. It does advocate proxy gods, but only until one comes to believe in God. It's standard religious conversion.

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.

Not true. Nowhere in the book does it read "god of your understanding." It does, however, read "God as you understand Him." The "god of your understanding" concept drives the AA fundies nuts, which is why there is such a divide between them and the new age AAs who try and re-write the program to make it all-inclusive.

Nothing is more entertaining than seeing an old-school AA fundy argue with an AA hippie about the absurdity of turning a person's life over to a doorknob or a chia pet. It's almost worth suffering through the hour or so of crazy, just to be able to watch two serenity hornets battle it out. Almost, but not quite.
 
This post kinda sums up what I have been saying here for a while now. Hope you like it.

"By Marya Hornbacher, Special to CNN

(CNN) - Kicked back with his boots on the table at the head of the smoke-dense room, the meeting's leader banged his fist and bellowed, “By the grace of this program and the blood of Jesus Christ, I’m sober today!”

I blinked.

This was not an auspicious beginning for the project of getting my vaguely atheistic, very alcoholic self off the sauce.

I wondered if perhaps I’d wandered into the wrong room. I thought maybe I’d wound up in Alcoholics Anonymous for crown-of-thorn Christians, and in the next room might find AA for lapsed Catholics, and downstairs a group for AA Hare Krishnas and one for AA Ukrainian Jews.

...

http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2011/08/28/

Edited by LashL: 
Snipped for compliance with Rule 4 and added link to source.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."
 
Jack Astor:

"Note the capitalization of "God." Not a god, but the God. It's specific, and it performs specific acts. People conceptualize the same God in many ways. Some see Him in nature, some in what they perceive as a miracle, some feel His spirit. Either way, it's a specific god. The chapter simply advocates that someone be willing to be converted, and if they are willing and subject themselves to the dogma, the conversion will happen. This from the same chapter explains how whatever conception you use, it's still the same deity:"

Surely without intending to, your statement would be greatly offensive to many AA members who subscribe to Wiccan beliefs which include hundreds of gods, living out their lives in direct violation of your announcement.

"Whatever higher power you choose to use, it's the same god manifesting itself."

Through the centuries, some have pointed out the many simiarities in the wide range of belief systems humans have practiced and come up with the answer that it's the same god throughout them all. It looks as if you buy that line. Most don't.


"Nothing is more entertaining than seeing an old-school AA fundy argue with an AA hippie about the absurdity of turning a person's life over to a doorknob or a chia pet."

I guess our standards for entertainment differ. Not that your's are bad, and let me be quick to say that if nothing is more entertaining than seeing this, then it's a fine and good thing. For you.

I personally haven't been a witness to this kind of event in 36 years of attending meetings, but as long as you're finding what you want to find often enough to meet your highest standard for entertainment, then that's a very good thing. For you.
 
From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

You are making the same basic mistake that Bill W. made in his ignorance of agnostics and atheists. You think this chapter applies to atheists when it is specifically directed at agnostics.

Bill W. makes the ridiculous mistake of thinking that people are only agnostic because they haven't thought about god enough and that if they think about god they will, of course, embrace Bill W.'s version of the christian god.

He makes his ignorance clear with statements like:

As soon as we admitted the possible existence of a Creative Intelligence, a Spirit of the Universe . . .

Alfie, you must know that this passage excludes atheists from AA. Atheists do not admit the possibility of a creative intelligence. They expressly reject it. It's the only thing all atheists agree on.

We found that as soon as we were able to lay aside prejudice . . .

Bill thinks agnosticism and atheism are mere prejudices? How very condescending of him and of anyone who thinks the same way. And this from a man who claims to have been an agnostic, even an atheist. :rolleyes:

When however, the perfectly logical assumption is made that underneath the material world and life as we see it, there is an All Powerful, Guiding, Creative Intelligence, right there our perverse streak comes to the surface and we laboriously set out to convince ourselves it isn't so. We read wordy books and indulge in windy arguments, thinking the universe needs no God to explain it. Were our contentions true, it would follow that life came from nothing, means nothing, and proceeds nowhere.

So, Alfie, can you explain how anything but a god can be the intelligent creator of the universe? Can the door knob do that? The AA group? How about a higher ideal? Or is Bill really talking about a God in the full christian sense and not in the weak "spirituality" sense that you claim?



and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.

And having posted this you still claim atheists fit into AA. Like Bill, you don't have the foggiest notion of what being an atheist means. It doesn't mean you have a god of your own conception, it means you reject the existence of any god whether it takes the shape of Allah, Vishnu, Odin, or a door knob.

You have consistently claimed that AA has room for atheists and just as consistently failed to support that claim with evidence from any AA literature or practice.

I think you have provided enough evidence for us to answer the OP in your case. I think we can safely say that the reason you claim AA is not religious is because you have made a grave error in logic.
 
From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.

Odd how there is no chapter called "we atheists" is it not?

Almost as if there were no choice but to believe in a "God".
 
Note the capitalization of "God." Not a god, but the God. It's specific, and it performs specific acts.

Yes, and the use of the upper-case follows the Judeo-Christian convention commonly used when referring to a monotheistic deity. If I am not mistaken, the original draft of the Big Book was run by the Roman Catholic diocese of New York for review and approval before going to print. Would a lower-case god have passed muster?
 
I personally haven't been a witness to this kind of event in 36 years of attending meetings, but as long as you're finding what you want to find often enough to meet your highest standard for entertainment, then that's a very good thing. For you.

I suspect since you have been in AA for 36 years that you're keenly aware of the divide between the treatment centre AAs, and the AA fundies.

Alfie's view of the program is not well-liked by these old-school fundamentalists.

Edited by LashL: 
Edited for moderated thread
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Odd how there is no chapter called "we atheists" is it not?

Almost as if there were no choice but to believe in a "God".

If you chose to actually read the chapter you would see that the laws of physics/the universe (loosely speaking) are used as an example of god/God/GOD. There is plenty of choice to believe or not:

"This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

And the door is left wide open for any other "spiritual expressions".

Yes, and the use of the upper-case follows the Judeo-Christian convention commonly used when referring to a monotheistic deity. If I am not mistaken, the original draft of the Big Book was run by the Roman Catholic diocese of New York for review and approval before going to print. Would a lower-case god have passed muster?

Who cares? The man wrote what he wrote in the language of the day according to is understanding.

It is n surprise, nor mystery that Bill was a Christian (is it ok if I uppper case the C there?:rolleyes:). No mystery either that he wrote from his knowledge base. What he did do was his best to be all inclusive and like I said above, the door is wide open for any form of spiritual belief and expression.
 
Which view exactly?

The take what you want and leave the rest thing. Picking any sort of thing like a tree or toaster oven as a higher power to pray to; turn your life over to; run your life. Adding stuff to the program that isn't in the 'Big Book.' That sort of thing.

Both groups are equally delusional, just in different ways. The fundies are more cultish, and the "professionals" are more into the pseudoscience woo. Then you get your crossovers who mix and match the two brands of crazy. Neither is effective in fixing addiction, because toaster ovens chia plants don't fix addiction; and there is no invisible alkie god waiting for people to walk into a meeting and start praying to him.
 
Alfie:

Clearly, that would be the views you hold which are disliked by the fundamentalists that Jack is channelling for.

According to Jack, his fundamentalists would take you to task in an incredibly entertaining way for well over the span of an hour for the views you hold.

So watch out.
 
Who cares? The man wrote what he wrote in the language of the day according to is understanding.

I care, and so do a lot of other skeptics. And the language of the day hasn't changed all that much. The use of the word God is common in Christian denominations.

It is n surprise, nor mystery that Bill was a Christian (is it ok if I uppper case the C there?:rolleyes:). No mystery either that he wrote from his knowledge base. What he did do was his best to be all inclusive and like I said above, the door is wide open for any form of spiritual belief and expression.

The door is wide open so long as long as such beliefs and expressions lead one to the acceptance of a monotheistic deity called God. BTW mysticism, Ouija boards, seances and the like were by no means unheard of in Wilson's day. Why weren't they included as viable paths to a Higher Power? I believe it has something to do with the clerical oversight that was involved during the writing of the big book.
 
If you chose to actually read the chapter you would see that the laws of physics/the universe (loosely speaking) are used as an example of god/God/GOD.

Are you talking about all the mistakes Bill made regarding science and scientific discovery? Seems kind of strange that in one breath Bill claims science agrees with him and yet in another says that it doesn't because scientists are obstinate and deny the spirit world. :rolleyes:

And for as accurate as Bill was, his claims could just as easily be examples of satan/Satan/SATAN.

Who cares? The man wrote what he wrote in the language of the day according to is understanding.

You seem to. So much so that you re-interpret Bill's words in ways he could not have possibly meant them in order to hold onto the position that AA is not religious.

What he did do was his best to be all inclusive and like I said above, the door is wide open for any form of spiritual belief and expression.

And yet you have failed once again to address the fact that AA cannot be inclusive of atheists. So, in fact, AA is not all inclusive.
 
Both groups are equally delusional, just in different ways. The fundies are more cultish, and the "professionals" are more into the pseudoscience woo. Then you get your crossovers who mix and match the two brands of crazy. Neither is effective in fixing addiction, because toaster ovens chia plants don't fix addiction; and there is no invisible alkie god waiting for people to walk into a meeting and start praying to him.

I wouldn't so much label these groups delusional as I would lax. AA's so-called flexible approach to spirituality is due more to theological laziness than ecumenical inclusiveness. I do agree with the "pseudoscience woo" label. AA, like other new-agey philosophies, is based on junk science at best.

Bill W. got the ball rolling decades before Oprah and Choprah came on the scene. What a deal.
 
I care, and so do a lot of other skeptics.

Why?

The door is wide open so long as long as such beliefs and expressions lead one to the acceptance of a monotheistic deity called God. BTW mysticism, Ouija boards, seances and the like were by no means unheard of in Wilson's day. Why weren't they included as viable paths to a Higher Power? I believe it has something to do with the clerical oversight that was involved during the writing of the big book.

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom