Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is very reasonable and cogent. I have been defending AA on this thread mainly because some posters see it as utterly pernicious, evil and deceptive.
I see it that way, even though I see where everyone involved in starting it may well have had "the best intentions."
But I keep wondering, who benefits? If this is a fraud, what is the ulterior motive? If this is a cult, who is the leader?
A cult doesn't necessarily need a single charismatic leader. What happened to Scientology when L. Ron Hubbard died? I was arguing with Rick Ross (presumably, it was "rrmoderator" on the Rick Ross forum) about that years ago, and he came up with a name I never heard of. Sure, it has a new leader, but does anyone outside of Scientology know his name? I wonder how many people even within Scientology know his name.

A group of dozens or hundreds of people, even thousands (megachurches such as the one Rick Warren runs) may directly depend on a charismatic leader, but not one of hundreds of thousands or millions. At that size the organization can pretty much move and grow on its own.

Read a lot of books in cults (I did). There ARE a lot of characteristics of cults, but not every cult has every characteristics, and just because a group doesn't have one of the characteristics doesn't mean it's not a cult.

From another angle, every person DOES have a leader in AA, it's YOUR SPONSOR. It's of course a hierarchy, and sponsors have sponsors, who also have sponsors.
Even if the ultimate motive (primary purpose) is to convert agnostics into theists, who benefits?
One could say the group benefits by growing, but I think that's anthropomorphizing the group. The members believe the group benefits by having more members, so they'll do what they've been taught to "recruit members," er, save these people from the horrible disease of alcoholism.

Members benefit by believing they have "saved another person from this horrible disease of alcoholism." And even if the newcomer doesn't get sober, they feel better having told another drunk about the program with the attitude that "we'll be here when you're ready."
...
The "cognitive dissonance" is apparently much lower in Australia, per Alfie, and as I am vaguely theistic I didn't run into that as much. In meetings I took everyone's statements with a grain of salt as I didn't believe any particular "old-timer" had the answer. It's not a given that if you stop going to meetings you will use again. However, the meetings - accessible, free support - are good resources for many people.
AA as a hardcore belief system is definitely a USA phenomenon (originating from the strong Christian beliefs of so many Americans), though of course AA members have been exporting "the right way" to do meetings to the rest of the world as best they can. I'm sure many of the AA members I knew in Atlanta would read your description of meetings and they would say they couldn't stay sober in those meetings.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
every person DOES have a leader in AA, it's YOUR SPONSOR

Every person? Every person in AA doesn't even have a sponsor. It's not required.

The members believe the group benefits by having more members ... Members benefit by believing they have "saved another person from this horrible disease of alcoholism."

If everyone has identical indoctrination as you suggest it would be inconsistent for members to believe they have saved another person from alcoholism. "No human power," remember? Any service I perform is more about maintaining my own well-being than someone else's. This concept that individual members believe they are saving other individuals from alcohol - it's quite foreign to me. I witnessed a sense of people feeling an obligation to keep a group going, in case someone saw a listed meeting and decided to show up. But the idea of personally saving someone else, I never ran across that.

of course AA members have been exporting "the right way" to do meetings to the rest of the world as best they can.

Evidence?

I'm sure many of the AA members I knew in Atlanta would read your description of meetings and they would say they couldn't stay sober in those meetings.

That would be their problem.

I defend AA as a free, accessible resource that people can freely choose. Apparently some anti-AA people do not believe potential members are competent to decide what they want. I have never been to a meeting in the Bible Belt so maybe it is different. I don't think people are such sheep that they can't attend a meeting and decided for themselves if it is helpful.

I post just to counter some of the anti-AA paranoia. I know this thread is a perpetual motion machine but I'll say it anyway: No one told me what to believe. No one told me "the rules." As far as I could tell no personal glory accrued to anyone at any level. Everyone had 3 minutes to speak if they chose (a stipulation of the meeting I attended most frequently; different groups have different policies.) Quite often a person would contradict what another person had just said. In fact AA grows partly through disagreements. I asked you, maybe you answered and I missed it, what prompted you to quit going and become an anti-AA advocate.
 
No. Some anti-AA people have left because they don't feel we're getting anywhere.

And I don't get why you are surprised that they focused on the religious aspect of AA since that was the point of the thread in the first place. I don't know why "efficacy" was added, rather than address the derails, but there you have it.

Oh Ok, so when you don't like the way the conversation goes (or we don't say exactly what you want us to say) the conversation is mute and baseless.
We definitely have gotten somewhere here. That AA is as religious as you make it, that atheist can and do succeed in AA, that prayers are not said in all meeting and that AA is not necessarily a medical option of itself but is part of a over all treatment plan.
Belz, please stick around because I believe more revealing nuggets will be forthcoming.
 
Originally Posted by benbradley View Post
I'm sure many of the AA members I knew in Atlanta would read your description of meetings and they would say they couldn't stay sober in those meetings.

I am from Atlanta, I have been to 8111 in Sandy Springs and the Triangle downtown, The How Place in Woodstock and the Club in Marietta. I have been to the "Rock" In Eatonton Ga. next to Madison ect......I know for a fact every single AA person I know in Georgia could stay sober with his accounts and mine.
Ya know you actually have had to really be a AA member before you can call out another Ben.
BTW how is Wayne K. on AW's.
Nice seeing you.
 
I am not surprised one bit that the AA oppositionists have gone rather silent . . .

This isn't a shouting match, Alfie. This oppositionist hasn't posted because everything AA supporters have claimed has been debunked and not much can be added without it just being a repeat of what has already been said. On top of that, AA supporters have been unable to address any of the points oppositionists have raised. They play word games and deny what exists in the literature, and practice, of the cult they are defending.

To go back to the OP, there is one thing both supporters and oppositionists agree on and that is that AA is religious. Your claim that it is merely spiritual has been destroyed by both sides and the very few supports who share your view is evidence that it is not the AA party line.

As to why some people claim AA isn't religious there are many reasons. From what I have observed from the few who claim it isn't in this thread, and in my talking to them, the main reason seems to be simply that the AA program is easier to swallow if that one lie is added to the many more that are a part of the program. It makes people believe they are inclusive, and enlightened, when in reality they are not. They are simply spouting the rantings of an especially intolerant group from a much less tolerant time in history.

No doubt though, there are as many reasons why people claim AA isn't religious as there are people who make the claim. There must be at least five reasons. :D
 
This isn't a shouting match, Alfie. This oppositionist hasn't posted because everything AA supporters have claimed has been debunked and not much can be added without it just being a repeat of what has already been said.

I agree, and will add that if this post is closed the debate will not end. The Internet assures us of that.

As to why some people claim AA isn't religious there are many reasons. From what I have observed from the few who claim it isn't in this thread, and in my talking to them, the main reason seems to be simply that the AA program is easier to swallow if that one lie is added to the many more that are a part of the program. It makes people believe they are inclusive, and enlightened, when in reality they are not.

So true. The biggest lie in fact is that AA promotes itself as a cure for alcoholism as a means to get people to accept jesus a monotheistic deity into their lives later on down the road. It's a bait and switch. Like when a car dealer claims 0% financing but just jacks up the selling price in order to recoup lost interest.
 
Oh Ok, so when you don't like the way the conversation goes (or we don't say exactly what you want us to say) the conversation is mute and baseless.

What ? How did you glean that from my post ?

We definitely have gotten somewhere here.

I didn't say we hadn't. Perhaps you should read my post more carefully.

That AA is as religious as you make it

That's something people have been claiming since the first page, and it's something that is still been argued against.

Belz, please stick around because I believe more revealing nuggets will be forthcoming.

I don't know why you have this adverserial attitude. I don't think it's helping the debate.
 
Every person? Every person in AA doesn't even have a sponsor. It's not required.

Perhaps. But it’s highly discouraged to not have a sponsor. If you don’t you’ll be pressured to get one and soon. I wish I had a dime for every time I heard, “You have to get a sponsor, read the big book and work the steps.” Sponsors are believed to be able to impart wisdom, although they quite frequently don’t really have any.

Actually there is a hierarchy of “charismatic” leaders, with Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob at the top, then there are the old timers, and under them are the sponsors.

"No human power," remember?

A quote from the BB brings us directly back to the monotheistic entity and the religiosity of the program itself.

But the idea of personally saving someone else, I never ran across that.

Again, that would be sponsorship, as well as proselytizing as laid out in step 12:
“Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.”

Apparently some anti-AA people do not believe potential members are competent to decide what they want.

You’re absolutely correct here. Long term abuse of alcohol or drugs causes a temporary decrease in cognitive capacity. These people’s lives are usually in shambles and they are desperate to stop drinking. They are encouraged to attend 90 in 90 but by then they have the fear instilled in them that the only alternatives to AA are jails, institutions or death, and that AA is the last house on the block. This is evident in Alfie’s incessantly hounding 8den about recommending alternatives and claiming it’s “dangerous” to do so. People stay in AA out of desperation, then, through the repetition of conversion narratives (drunkologues) they eventually take on the beliefs.

No one told me what to believe. No one told me "the rules."

Do they not have the 12 steps and 12 traditions where you live?

I know for a fact every single AA person I know in Georgia could stay sober with his accounts and mine.

Fact? Every single person, Danny? Evidence please.
 
This isn't a shouting match, Alfie. This oppositionist hasn't posted because everything AA supporters have claimed has been debunked and not much can be added without it just being a repeat of what has already been said. On top of that, AA supporters have been unable to address any of the points oppositionists have raised. They play word games and deny what exists in the literature, and practice, of the cult they are defending.

To go back to the OP, there is one thing both supporters and oppositionists agree on and that is that AA is religious. Your claim that it is merely spiritual has been destroyed by both sides and the very few supports who share your view is evidence that it is not the AA party line.

As to why some people claim AA isn't religious there are many reasons. From what I have observed from the few who claim it isn't in this thread, and in my talking to them, the main reason seems to be simply that the AA program is easier to swallow if that one lie is added to the many more that are a part of the program. It makes people believe they are inclusive, and enlightened, when in reality they are not. They are simply spouting the rantings of an especially intolerant group from a much less tolerant time in history.

No doubt though, there are as many reasons why people claim AA isn't religious as there are people who make the claim. There must be at least five reasons. :D

Now ya see gayak there ya go again trying to fit your idea of AA into a box and sell it as one size fits all. You can't seem to let the idea swim around your brain that AA literature may not be as literal as you think. Guys (Anti AA'ers) it would seriously help if any of you "really" were alcoholic and seriously went to AA for help with said problem. It is extremely difficult to discuss this personal subject with folks that have just read the Big Book and maybe haphazardly went to a few meetings.
Just saying.
 
DannyB II wrote:
Belz, please stick around because I believe more revealing nuggets will be forthcoming.

Belz wrote:
I don't know why you have this adverserial attitude. I don't think it's helping the debate.

Belz, I do apologize if you feel that this response was intended to be adversarial.
 
You can't seem to let the idea swim around your brain that AA literature may not be as literal as you think.

If that were the case, then the literature would literally not mention a monotheistic deity called God a few hundred times, would it? And how about the christian lord's/serenity prayers that are said at the overwhelming majority of meetings world-wide? Again, God would literally not be mentioned in these prayers if the intention of the prayers were literally not to mention Him.

Guys (Anti AA'ers) it would seriously help if any of you "really" were alcoholic and seriously went to AA for help with said problem. It is extremely difficult to discuss this personal subject with folks that have just read the Big Book and maybe haphazardly went to a few meetings.
Just saying.

Well I'm pretty sure that just about anyone with a passing knowledge of the meaning of the word God would not be overly challenged by its use and intent in the AA literature, regardless of their status as an AA member. And many anti/X AA'ers you are likely to meet have in fact been to many AA meetings, some over the course of decades.
 
DannyB II wrote:
I know for a fact every single AA person I know in Georgia could stay sober with his accounts and mine.

causeandeffect wrote:
Fact? Every single person, Danny? Evidence please.

I would really like to get you the evidence but I am not in Georgia at the moment. I asked several AA folks I know to post here but they won't. To be honest they don't get involved with this internet stuff anywhere.
C & E, I did say folks I know.
C & E, isn't it so much more pleasant here to post, no threats of attack and people respect one another.
Nice seeing you again. I did always like you...:)
 
I am from Atlanta, I have been to 8111 in Sandy Springs and the Triangle downtown, The How Place in Woodstock and the Club in Marietta. I have been to the "Rock" In Eatonton Ga. next to Madison ect......

The "Real Sobriety" was at Biscayne, especially the Sunday Morning meeting run by Maggie Harrison. My AA-friend Ken was always impressed by "how many years of sobriety" there was in that room with all the old folks with "double-digit sobriety" attending.

You remind me of a couple more people. There was Bill Sanders who was always an "eloquent" speaker when he led discussions at NABA, and I also saw him at 8111 (woops, I think I'm breaking a tradition - well I did say a clubhouse, not a meeting!). He ran (and promoted) the Atlanta Men's Workshop, some weekend-long AA retreat I never went to. Then there's Noel Burtonshaw (sp?), aka "Father Noel" and then just "Noel" but I thought of him as "Former Father Noel" when he resigned as a Catholic Priest and got married. Years later I recall seeing him in a TV commercial for Ridgeview where he was the "spiritual adviser" or some such title.

And Triangle was definitely a trip. One meeting (AA, they were all AA except for the obligatory Al-Anon meeting most clubhouses have) started off with "Welcome to the so-and-so meeting of Alcoholics Anonymous. My name is so-and-so, and I'm an addict." I looked around the room and no one blinked an eye, but if he had said that at NABA, Biscayne, or any of the many church-hall/basement meetings I attended, all hell would have erupted. Some of the 8111 meetings were "liberal" like that, and I recall several of the 8111 folks were into new-age stuff - massage therapists and attendees of Life Chiropractic College.
Ya know you actually have had to really be a AA member before you can call out another Ben.
Not that that's true any more than "only an alcoholic can help another alcoholic," but if you don't believe I was ever an AA member, there's nothing more I can say.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Now ya see gayak there ya go again trying to fit your idea of AA into a box and sell it as one size fits all.

No, it's not my idea of AA, it's AA's idea of AA as it comes straight from their literature and practice.

As for th eone size fits all, it is only the AA apologists that commit that error. They claim that AA fits anyone, no matter what their beliefs are. Alfie goes so far as to say it will fit even the most hardcore atheist. As a relatively hardcore atheist myself, I can say he has no idea what he speaks of.

You can't seem to let the idea swim around your brain that AA literature may not be as literal as you think.

This claim doesn't support your position on AA. If the AA literature doesn't mean what it says then it means exactly nothing. In that case, there is no such thing as AA. There are just collections of delusional people sitting in church basements, etc., drinking coffee and lying to each other.

Guys (Anti AA'ers) it would seriously help if any of you "really" were alcoholic and seriously went to AA for help with said problem.

This is wrong on so many levels. There are many in this thread who are "real" alcoholics who have stated that AA is indeed religious. The subject of the OP is a case in point. Tinyal is another.

Your statement also seems to say that one will become religious if only one is an alcoholic. Do you think people are that shallow? Do you think that their atheism is a sign of alcoholism or is alcoholism a sign of atheism? That doesn't hold water though because the majority of people in AA are believers.

In short: Alcoholism has nothing to do with religious beliefs and religious beliefs have nothing to do with alcoholism.

It is extremely difficult to discuss this personal subject with folks that have just read the Big Book and maybe haphazardly went to a few meetings.
Just saying.

I understand you're "just saying" that but it would have helped if you had thought about it first. It's known as a special pleading fallacy. You claim to have some knowledge that is unknown, even unknowable, to the rest of us and you base your argument upon it. You seem to think that alcoholism is in a class all by itself and unrelated to any other human condition. Sorry, it isn't.

Your argument is rebutted by your fellow alcoholics who have contradicted you in this thread. Or are you going to claim that because they contradict you they are not "real" alcoholics either? :rolleyes:

And having typed all this out, there isn't anything that I have written that hasn't been written many times in this thread. You are recycling the same fallacies that were used previously by other AA apologists and which have already been destroyed.
 
AA is not treatment any more than a peer support group for cancer survivors is chemotherapy. It's an adjunct.

Every single treatment admission and discharge is reported to my state and federal government, tons of data on each episode of care and its outcomes. A patient is tracked at the state and federal level for recidivism and other standard outcome measures.

We know that professional treatment works. People recover, though that does not mean treatment works for everyone, or that everyone does what they need to do to succeed.
 
The "Real Sobriety" was at Biscayne, especially the Sunday Morning meeting run by Maggie Harrison. My AA-friend Ken was always impressed by "how many years of sobriety" there was in that room with all the old folks with "double-digit sobriety" attending.

You remind me of a couple more people. There was Bill Sanders who was always an "eloquent" speaker when he led discussions at NABA, and I also saw him at 8111 (woops, I think I'm breaking a tradition - well I did say a clubhouse, not a meeting!). He ran (and promoted) the Atlanta Men's Workshop, some weekend-long AA retreat I never went to. Then there's Noel Burtonshaw (sp?), aka "Father Noel" and then just "Noel" but I thought of him as "Former Father Noel" when he resigned as a Catholic Priest and got married. Years later I recall seeing him in a TV commercial for Ridgeview where he was the "spiritual adviser" or some such title.

And Triangle was definitely a trip. One meeting (AA, they were all AA except for the obligatory Al-Anon meeting most clubhouses have) started off with "Welcome to the so-and-so meeting of Alcoholics Anonymous. My name is so-and-so, and I'm an addict." I looked around the room and no one blinked an eye, but if he had said that at NABA, Biscayne, or any of the many church-hall/basement meetings I attended, all hell would have erupted. Some of the 8111 meetings were "liberal" like that, and I recall several of the 8111 folks were into new-age stuff - massage therapists and attendees of Life Chiropractic College.

Not that that's true any more than "only an alcoholic can help another alcoholic," but if you don't believe I was ever an AA member, there's nothing more I can say.

I know Bill very well just spoke to him last week, I am sure you are familiar with many of my friends. I would rather speak of names in a email or private message, please.
That mens weekend was called the "Rock" in Eatonton, beautiful state park.
It was 8111 I was referring too, Ben concerning no prayers.
Ridgeview had a annual New Years Gala in Marietta.
The Triangle is a trip just as you said, I could take it for to long.
I do believe you were a Alcoholic but I also believe that you weren't into AA. I don't have a problem with this either, really I don't.
I will talk more later on this.
You blew me away with your knowledge of AA in Atlanta. I haven't thought about Atlanta in a while.
Thanks.
 
Perhaps. But it’s highly discouraged to not have a sponsor. If you don’t you’ll be pressured to get one and soon.

I heard people saying what had worked for them, or hadn't worked for them. Some people preached and some people made it a point not to.

Sponsors are believed to be able to impart wisdom, although they quite frequently don’t really have any.

"Are believed to be able to impart wisdom" by whom? You are speaking for some generalized mass of people, or else you're saying you believed.

Actually there is a hierarchy of “charismatic” leaders, with Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob at the top, then there are the old timers, and under them are the sponsors.

News to me. There wasn't an organizational chart.

A quote from the BB brings us directly back to the monotheistic entity and the religiosity of the program itself.

But a monotheist would never would have attributed someone's sobriety to another individual. That would be claiming godlike powers. I'm a drug fiend, but I would have spotted the inconsistency.

Again, that would be sponsorship, as well as proselytizing as laid out in step 12:
“Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.”

Proselytizing? Nowhere near. "Carrying the message" meant sharing in meetings, possibly taking meetings to prisons and perhaps being a speaker. No knocking on doors, billboard, telethons. Outside of AA meetings I've never heard of an AA member going up to someone and trying to convert them.

These people’s lives are usually in shambles and they are desperate to stop drinking. They are encouraged to attend 90 in 90 but by then they have the fear instilled in them that the only alternatives to AA are jails, institutions or death, and that AA is the last house on the block.

Again those generalizations and that passive construction. "They ... have the fear instilled in them." Do you mean that you experienced that fear? And, this is a serious question: Do you think such a person would be worse off sober and indoctrinated, or drinking and un-indoctrinated? Because I would tend to think, "better off sober and preached at." But I could be underestimating the intensity of your presumed indoctrination.

People stay in AA out of desperation, then, through the repetition of conversion narratives (drunkologues) they eventually take on the beliefs.

"People stay." Do you mean you stayed? You took on the beliefs through repetition? And that everybody always had the same point of view?

Do they not have the 12 steps and 12 traditions where you live?

Yeah, but they're considered "steps" and "traditions," as in "these steps are suggested as a program of recovery." Where I live, most people were pretty tolerant if you'd found something that worked for you.

I guess what I'm saying is - I realized everyone's fallible. I've said so in meetings. To me AA is a group of individuals who get together because it helps them get sober or stay sober. In general I've found people pretty accepting and nonjudgmental. You haven't, apparently.
 
Actually there is a hierarchy of “charismatic” leaders, with Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob at the top, then there are the old timers, and under them are the sponsors.

And they are creaming all the money off the top, huh?
You might not be aware, but Bill and Bob are dead.:rolleyes:

You’re absolutely correct here. Long term abuse of alcohol or drugs causes a temporary decrease in cognitive capacity. These people’s lives are usually in shambles and they are desperate to stop drinking.

Very good. And AA gives them an option that might just work.
Their lack of cognitive capacity is exactly the reason why many take a sponsor and why someone appropriate may even be a good idea.

They are encouraged to attend 90 in 90 but by then they have the fear instilled in them that the only alternatives to AA are jails, institutions or death, and that AA is the last house on the block.

Firsly I want to point out that I personally have never said AA is the "last house" on the block or AA is the "only alternative". The rest of what you say is sadly too often true.

To the best of our knowledge, alcoholism is an incurable chronic relapse condition. If people do not get recovery (in whatever form that takes for them) the reality is these things do happen (gaols, institutions or death): To suggest otherwise is ridiculous in the extreme.

This is evident in Alfie’s incessantly hounding 8den about recommending alternatives and claiming it’s “dangerous” to do so.

LOL
Whoosh!
That's quite a leap you have made there. And just so wrong it is hard to know how to respond.

People stay in AA out of desperation, then, through the repetition of conversion narratives (drunkologues) they eventually take on the beliefs.

Like it's the first drink?
That it's spiritual, not religious?
That the 12 steps are suggested?
That you can choose any path you like and it is a God (or not) of your own understanding?
That I can bee free of alcohol and live a happy life?
You can leave anytime you want and we don't do roll call?
Or that the 12 promises can (and do) come true?
(1) We are going to know a new freedom and a new happiness.
(2) We will not regret the past nor wish to shut the door on it.
(3) We will comprehend the word serenity and we will know peace.
(4) No matter how far down the scale we have gone, we will see how our experience can benefit others.
(5) That feeling of uselessness and self-pity will disappear.
(6) We will lose interest in selfish things and gain interest in our fellows.
(7) Self-seeking will slip away.
(8) Our whole attitude and outlook upon life will change.
(9) Fear of people and of economic insecurity will leave us.
(10) We will intuitively know how to handle situations which used to baffle us.
(11) We will suddenly realize that God is doing for us what we could not do for ourselves.
(12) Are these extravagant promises? We think not. They are being fulfilled among us—sometimes quickly, sometimes slowly. They will always materialize if we work for them.

You mean those types of beliefs?
 
Posted by Nutbag:

"I provided you with a link to that clearly states that the program in question uses new findings to improve the program (that's what we call "evidence based"..."

"The determination to stay on the leading edge of new findings in the field of addiction treatment has resulted in the current development of new treatment services..." Look at that, straight from the horses mouth. "

I looked up the intriguing statement Nutbag quoted and found it on the C____ clinician's page. They do appear to be a cut above the usual recovery businesses. But, since they are the answer to an evidence based recovery seeker's prayer, after much evidenced based thought, would they dare to make the foundation of their program the 12 steps? What would that say about the steps if they could find nothing better to offer?

Let's see what else this horse has to say. They seem to think more than only the 12 steps are needed for many, yet they want to ensure that any additions will be in tune with the basic concepts of the steps..."Twelve-step recovery instinctively addresses the issues of addiction interaction and attachment disorder, but for many, this process is not immediately effective because the layers of addiction are intertwined with coexisting psychiatric disorders. This calls for treatment services in tune with the 12-step concepts yet deeply skilled in dealing with the more complex issues today's addicts and family members present."

Since they are on the cutting edge of recovery therapies and are incorporating the newest ideas to supply patients with the best of all possible evidence based programs, they add to the steps of AA treatment services which will deal with the more complex issues beyond what they say is addressed by the 12 steps, such as having family members present.

Being at the forefront of modern recovery, leaving behind the musty past yet making sure they get their patients through the steps is an amazing leap forward.

Good thing they disgarded all that religious quackery.

Apparently in favor of Spirituality. "Spirituality is a vital component of all of C____’s treatment programs. Integrated spiritual care allows the recovering person to regain their dignity and form creative, life-giving, intimate relationships with self, others, the universe and a Higher Power.

Good they got the difference figured out, but it really isn't that hard when one is honest about the subject. Still, big kudos.

My opinion is that rehabs are a waste of time and money, but it's good that people have solidly evidenced based programs like C_____ if they choose to not give AA a try because they consider it religious and they don't want to take the 12 steps, or they have family with family issues.

This way they can go the spiritual route instead and have things added to the steps which are in tune with the concepts of the 12 steps, which these professionals seem to believe is important, judging by how they go on about it.

Nothing but the best for their patients.
 
AA is not treatment any more than a peer support group for cancer survivors is chemotherapy. It's an adjunct.

Every single treatment admission and discharge is reported to my state and federal government, tons of data on each episode of care and its outcomes. A patient is tracked at the state and federal level for recidivism and other standard outcome measures.

We know that professional treatment works. People recover, though that does not mean treatment works for everyone, or that everyone does what they need to do to succeed.
That page has a whole lot of statistics about people before and after treatment, but it doesn't have a word about what treatment is.

Do you know exactly what "professional treatment" is in the USA? Do you have any idea what percentage of people working as professionals in the alcohol-and-drug treatment field are members of Alcoholics Anonymous or another 12-step program?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom