benbradley
Scholar
- Joined
- Jun 20, 2011
- Messages
- 71
I see it that way, even though I see where everyone involved in starting it may well have had "the best intentions."This is very reasonable and cogent. I have been defending AA on this thread mainly because some posters see it as utterly pernicious, evil and deceptive.
A cult doesn't necessarily need a single charismatic leader. What happened to Scientology when L. Ron Hubbard died? I was arguing with Rick Ross (presumably, it was "rrmoderator" on the Rick Ross forum) about that years ago, and he came up with a name I never heard of. Sure, it has a new leader, but does anyone outside of Scientology know his name? I wonder how many people even within Scientology know his name.But I keep wondering, who benefits? If this is a fraud, what is the ulterior motive? If this is a cult, who is the leader?
A group of dozens or hundreds of people, even thousands (megachurches such as the one Rick Warren runs) may directly depend on a charismatic leader, but not one of hundreds of thousands or millions. At that size the organization can pretty much move and grow on its own.
Read a lot of books in cults (I did). There ARE a lot of characteristics of cults, but not every cult has every characteristics, and just because a group doesn't have one of the characteristics doesn't mean it's not a cult.
From another angle, every person DOES have a leader in AA, it's YOUR SPONSOR. It's of course a hierarchy, and sponsors have sponsors, who also have sponsors.
One could say the group benefits by growing, but I think that's anthropomorphizing the group. The members believe the group benefits by having more members, so they'll do what they've been taught to "recruit members," er, save these people from the horrible disease of alcoholism.Even if the ultimate motive (primary purpose) is to convert agnostics into theists, who benefits?
Members benefit by believing they have "saved another person from this horrible disease of alcoholism." And even if the newcomer doesn't get sober, they feel better having told another drunk about the program with the attitude that "we'll be here when you're ready."
AA as a hardcore belief system is definitely a USA phenomenon (originating from the strong Christian beliefs of so many Americans), though of course AA members have been exporting "the right way" to do meetings to the rest of the world as best they can. I'm sure many of the AA members I knew in Atlanta would read your description of meetings and they would say they couldn't stay sober in those meetings....
The "cognitive dissonance" is apparently much lower in Australia, per Alfie, and as I am vaguely theistic I didn't run into that as much. In meetings I took everyone's statements with a grain of salt as I didn't believe any particular "old-timer" had the answer. It's not a given that if you stop going to meetings you will use again. However, the meetings - accessible, free support - are good resources for many people.
Last edited by a moderator: