Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course it does. If a claim is made it needs to be supported. The claim was it is evidence based and progressive. What evidence? What progress?

He said he'd PM you with the name of the place. Have at it with the research.

What proof do you have that you're a (competent) addiction counselor? Have you attended a university? Evidence please.

While we're on the subject of evidence, you might want to ask Danny why he claimed there are non-prayer meetings in the northeast, yet won't provide the names.

The only thing I'm quite sure about is that a monotheistic entity called God is mentioned a few hundred times in the AA literature. The evidence for that is pretty clear.
 
Of course it does. If a claim is made it needs to be supported. The claim was it is evidence based and progressive. What evidence? What progress?

Again Alfie, I'm not interested in debating the merits and methodology of a particular treatment center. I gave you a link to their website which contains some information about their methods. If you, as an addictions professional, wish to inquire further, I'm sure they'd be able to give you additional information.

Just for the record, it's clear you're being intellectually dishonest here. Instead of inquiring for yourself, you're asking me to provide information that you know isn't available to any former patient at any former center in written form. Using the standard you're asking for, there's no evidence that western medicine is evidence based. My GP doesn't make the literature he reviews and incorporates into practice publicly available on a website, and I venture that very few, if any, do so. To find out if he uses evidence based medicine, I have to actually do a little research.

Also, from the "For Clinicians" tab of the link i sent you, "The determination to stay on the leading edge of new findings in the field of addiction treatment has resulted in the current development of new treatment services..." Look at that, straight from the horses mouth.
 
Emotive twaddle.
Evidence of "millions of lives" please.
It's a judgment call. This thread is full of evidence of ruined lives because of the cult that I have personally researched and posted. Such as the many women who have written articles for major papers and blogs on how AA ruined their marriage. It's on a grand scale. As has been pointed out many times, when you ask for evidence for a claim you need to stipulate the conditions. What would you need to see? What would disprove evolution? Rabbit fossil in the Cambrain. Word up.

The reality is that it is alcohol that is the problem for these people, not AA.
evidence please. ;)
 
Exactly and it is interesting, as one with a sister who belongs to another cult, to see how AA members are sucked into their cult. It is very enlightening to see the depth of the cognitive dissonance cult members wallow in to justify their participation.
A scientifically falsifiable and objective claim about human beings which should be taught to every child in school. Think of the trillions we'd save and the well-being we'd create if we had anti-cult training in place.

One of the best posts in this thread qayak, it's all there, flawless victory. THAT is what the cochrane reviewers wanted to say, i am sure.
 
But at some point the cognitive dissonance got too great and I couldn't keep lying or obfuscating the truth when I was in meetings ... For me, AA was a great way to meet people in the same boat, but at some point it simply made me feel like a fraud, and I wasn't willing to remain in an organization that made me feel that way.

This is very reasonable and cogent. I have been defending AA on this thread mainly because some posters see it as utterly pernicious, evil and deceptive. But I keep wondering, who benefits? If this is a fraud, what is the ulterior motive? If this is a cult, who is the leader? Even if the ultimate motive (primary purpose) is to convert agnostics into theists, who benefits?

Re: efficacy. I don't think the steps get you sober. You can't work them effectively while still drinking. Although 1, 2 and 3 might help you through detox you can't do a fourth step drunk, you need some distance from the chemicals, you need some clarity to see how you might have hurt someone, or, conversely, to stop blaming yourself for something that wasn't your fault.

However I do think meetings and the steps can help you stay sober, for the reason you stated above: You found a support system that you continue to utilize. Some people find relief from shame by working the steps. But if meetings "made you feel like a fraud" you were right to walk away; if AA participation fosters a sense of shame it is counterproductive.

The "cognitive dissonance" is apparently much lower in Australia, per Alfie, and as I am vaguely theistic I didn't run into that as much. In meetings I took everyone's statements with a grain of salt as I didn't believe any particular "old-timer" had the answer. It's not a given that if you stop going to meetings you will use again. However, the meetings - accessible, free support - are good resources for many people.
 
I am not surprised one bit that the AA oppositionists have gone rather silent, it confirms some things I have known and suspected all along about them and efficacy rates:
- their drive is not about alcohol recovery, but anti religion, anti AA etc. They wish to destroy, not assist. And ST is a hate group.
- alcoholism is a very very complex thing; there are no cures per se.
- individual recovery depends on the individual.
- finding actual and/or accurate data on any recovery methods is virtually impossible. It seems the best we have are questionable meta analyses or extremely prejudice (positive or negative) reports.
- Methods vary as do results.

My opinion is and always has been that if it works, use it. If it doesn't keep trying new (and old) things. Alcoholism and addiction is a chronic relapse condition and massive amounts of persistence are often (even usually) required.
 
He said he'd PM you with the name of the place. Have at it with the research.

What proof do you have that you're a (competent) addiction counselor? Have you attended a university? Evidence please.

While we're on the subject of evidence, you might want to ask Danny why he claimed there are non-prayer meetings in the northeast, yet won't provide the names.

The only thing I'm quite sure about is that a monotheistic entity called God is mentioned a few hundred times in the AA literature. The evidence for that is pretty clear.

Bamberger,
Would you please stop with all the evidence claims and efficacy statements. You and I have supplied none as of this date. I never said I would. What I am talking about here is anecdotal, as yours.
Once again I will not give you those names of groups no matter how much you scream.
Let it go.
 
He said he'd PM you with the name of the place. Have at it with the research.

Which he did, but it seems research and evidence free.
Your point however was that it didn't need to be supported, would you hold an AA member and their claims to the same lack of scrutiny?

What proof do you have that you're a (competent) addiction counselor? Have you attended a university? Evidence please.

Meh!
You might have missed it earlier when I said to someone else that "you can believe me or not, I really don't care". Moreover, I feel in no way obligated to prove anything to you. If my claims and statements do not make sense, ask me about them and I will do my best to clarify.

Again Alfie, I'm not interested in debating the merits and methodology of a particular treatment center. I gave you a link to their website which contains some information about their methods. If you, as an addictions professional, wish to inquire further, I'm sure they'd be able to give you additional information.

Fair enough, it's just that you did say they were "evidence based and progressive", I just figured you would have had a reason for saying so. I also figured that by stepoping into this debate you might have had something in terms of their efficacy results.

Just for the record, it's clear you're being intellectually dishonest here. Instead of inquiring for yourself, you're asking me to provide information that you know isn't available to any former patient at any former center in written form.

Maybe you are unaware of how it works around here, generally speaking if you make the claim, you need to support it.

Using the standard you're asking for, there's no evidence that western medicine is evidence based.

You may just have hit the nail on the head here. Interestingly, this thread for a long time was about AA and its efficacy and the AA oppositionists screamed "Results! Where are the results?". I have been gently pointing out in my own way that results are hard to find for any treatment and the same levels of scrutiny should be applied accross the industry, not just to AA.

Also, from the "For Clinicians" tab of the link i sent you, "The determination to stay on the leading edge of new findings in the field of addiction treatment has resulted in the current development of new treatment services..." Look at that, straight from the horses mouth.

Are you serious? I should just believe their advertisements?
 
It's a judgment call. This thread is full of evidence of ruined saved lives because of the cult fellowship that I have personally researched and posted slandered. Such as the many women who have written articles for major papers and blogs on how AA alcoholism ruined their marriage. It's on a grand scale. As has been pointed out many times, when you ask for evidence for a claim you say you need to stipulate the conditions actually see some.

ftfy
 
Alfie stated:
"You may just have hit the nail on the head here. Interestingly, this thread for a long time was about AA and its efficacy and the AA oppositionists screamed "Results! Where are the results?". I have been gently pointing out in my own way that results are hard to find for any treatment and the same levels of scrutiny should be applied accross the industry, not just to AA."

Thanks, I was beginning to wonder what the bejeezous was going on around here.
 
I am not surprised one bit that the AA oppositionists have gone rather silent, it confirms some things I have known and suspected all along about them and efficacy rates:
I got promoted and work too much to post.
- their drive is not about alcohol recovery, but anti religion, anti AA etc. They wish to destroy, not assist. And ST is a hate group.
They are such nice people. Here is an interview with the creators, I like these people a lot. You should too. I mean I challenge anyone to listen to that interview and then call them a hate group. Listen, seriously.
- alcoholism is a very very complex thing; there are no cures per se.
- individual recovery depends on the individual.
- finding actual and/or accurate data on any recovery methods is virtually impossible. It seems the best we have are questionable meta analyses or extremely prejudice (positive or negative) reports.
No. The twelve steps are falsifiable and they have been falsified. Oh you can't prove love either. You can't show the 12 steps is good technology and their entire skeptic community knows it now. Great thread. Look around this is a hot topic in skepticism right now.

My opinion is and always has been that if it works, use it. If it doesn't keep trying new (and old) things. Alcoholism and addiction is a chronic relapse condition and massive amounts of persistence are often (even usually) required.
That's common sense. This thread is about the cult of AA.
 
Are you serious? I should just believe their advertisements?

Evasion noted. I provided you with a link to that clearly states that the program in question uses new findings to improve the program (that's what we call "evidence based" and you dismiss it because it comes from the program itself? That's utterly ridiculous.

Again, I never stated that this particular treatment center or any other has a better success rate than AA. I stated that it was based on evidence, unlike AA, which is based on the highly suspect and possibly drug induced experience of one individual 75 years ago. I have given you a link that shows this to be the case. If you want to brush aside anything that might suggest that there are viable alternatives to AA, I can't stop you. But it's quite clear that the program I described is evidence based and I provided documentation. AA has a set dogma, and as the agnostics groups in Toronto found out, it isn't subject to change. This particular treatment center, and others, use science to develop treatment regimens. It is one hundred-percent evidence based, and if you don't think so, it's because you're twisting the notion of evidence to be so obscure to protect AA from well-leveled charges that it is not based on evidence.
 
Joey McGee says:
They are such nice people. Here is an interview with the creators, I like these people a lot. You should too. I mean I challenge anyone to listen to that interview and then call them a hate group. Listen, seriously.

Ok, you brought this up.
Read Marks posts (MA) on his blog, look at Elsa's (FTG) posts. They are hateful at times to the extreme. They purposely point out people by name and humiliate them.
OK enough about that.
AA is for some and not for others. The efficacy for AA is hard to come because AA is not a medical treatment it is a set of principles people choose to live by. One other caveat to go with that is the AA member has the independence to do as he pleases.
All I have seen here fro9m the anti is efforts to get AA put in a box as a one size fits all. AA is just not intended nor was it designed to be this way. IMO
 
Evasion noted. I provided you with a link to that clearly states that the program in question uses new findings to improve the program (that's what we call "evidence based" and you dismiss it because it comes from the program itself? That's utterly ridiculous.

No evasion. It is a simple fact. They make a claim about what they call "evidence based". But do not explain what their evidence is. I don't expect you to answer for them however I do expect that they be held to the same scrutiny as AA or any other facility that would make a claim.
 
I am not surprised one bit that the AA oppositionists have gone rather silent, it confirms some things I have known and suspected all along about them and efficacy rates:
- their drive is not about alcohol recovery, but anti religion, anti AA etc. They wish to destroy, not assist. And ST is a hate group.
- alcoholism is a very very complex thing; there are no cures per se.
- individual recovery depends on the individual.
- finding actual and/or accurate data on any recovery methods is virtually impossible. It seems the best we have are questionable meta analyses or extremely prejudice (positive or negative) reports.
- Methods vary as do results.

My opinion is and always has been that if it works, use it. If it doesn't keep trying new (and old) things. Alcoholism and addiction is a chronic relapse condition and massive amounts of persistence are often (even usually) required.

No. Some anti-AA people have left because they don't feel we're getting anywhere.

And I don't get why you are surprised that they focused on the religious aspect of AA since that was the point of the thread in the first place. I don't know why "efficacy" was added, rather than address the derails, but there you have it.
 
Your choice of words is interesting. Why not anti-spiritual?

No reason, call it an oversight.

Evidence please.

Have you ever been there? If so, being the AA member that you are ;), you would know the answer.

No. Some anti-AA people have left because they don't feel we're getting anywhere.

No argument from me on that one. Some people also stop going to their doctor because they feel they aren't getting anywhere. Same with their mechanic, their music teacher or their internet provider.

And I don't get why you are surprised that they focused on the religious aspect of AA since that was the point of the thread in the first place.

Did I say that somewhere? I must have forgotten. Could you show me context please, I am genuinely confused.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom