Hey all! I've been lurking this thread for a while and feel compelled to jump in with my two cents. I've been sober for going on 4 years now. I've been to hundreds of AA meetings, closed and open, and for the past year plus, I've had to walk away because the environment is extremely uncomfortable for me as an atheist. Thankfully I had attended a treatment center that focuses on evidence based treatment so I didn't walk away from what I thought was the only path to sobriety, but it's really frustrating to see AA members insist that the program is not religious, when the religiosity of the program is what forced me out the door. It also kept me out of the program when I could have used treatment. I remember attending my first AA meeting, totally unaware of the religious (or spiritual, I fail to see a substantive difference) component. I sat down in a dirty church basement, adorned with crosses, and listened to people talk about how God had changed their lives. I left absolutely stunned that that was the secret to AA, and it took another year before I found a better alternative. Once I had some time sober, I started going back to AA, got a sponsor, did a 90 in 90, did the steps, and the whole gig. I kept it up for as long as I could, but I simply couldn't take biting my tongue in meetings and hearing absurd stories about how God had personally saved people from an alcoholic death. This is just my experience with the program and perhaps there are regional differences, but the program made me feel like a total fraud. I didn't believe in God and couldn't no matter how hard I tried, all while hearing all the time that my Higher Power was the only thing between me and a drink. Thankfully, I've managed to build a good, rational support network of like-minded folks, but to see that people are arguing in good faith that AA is not religious is downright mind boggling to me.
Why exactly was "We Agnostics" written? It sure as heck wasn't to provide a rational, well-thought out justification of AA's principles to non-believers. The condescension and frankly stupidity contained in that chapter was a large part of why I left the program. I'm not going to break down the chapter in detail, but according to Bill in "We Agnostics", an alcoholic "may be suffering from an illness which only a spiritual experience will conquer." Translation: abandon your thoughts about spirituality (which for all Bill knows are well justified) and accept mine, or remaining a drunk. Classic false dichotomy. He literally says remaining an atheist or agnostic will doom us.
This particular paragraph on page 49 was what convinced me that Bill had no intention of being intellectually honest, nor did he actually respect someone who didn't believe in god. "Instead of regarding ourselves as intelligent agents, spearheads of God's ever advancing Creation, we agnostics and atheists chose to believe that our human intelligence was the last word, the alpha and the omega, the beginning and the end of all. Rather vain of us, wasn't it?" He conflates a perfectly justified belief (that God doesn't exist) with some absurdly narcissistic caricature, and mocks us at the end. This is straight from the book that the program takes its name from.
And to quote Doctor Bob, "If you think you are an atheist,an agnostic, or have any other form of intellectual pride which keeps you from accepting what is in this book, I feel sorry for you."
Now I think that AA is religious, and for good reason, but regardless, the discussion of disbelief in the text is offensive and childish. It is totally unwelcoming to anyone who doesn't share Bill's view about God, and the only way to get around this is to cherry pick from the book which above said has the key to saving your life. If saying that someone who doesn't believe in the organizations belief about God will quite literally doom them doesn't count as a religion, I don't know what does.