Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact that I am an atheist means I understand this very well. You on the other hand make the claim while being a practicing christian. Seems rather odd.

LOL.

Evidence please.

Yeah, no. This thread is filled with AA members who completely disagree with you. They state that the organization and the meetings are every bit as religious as AA detractors have claimed.

Names please.

Once you've done that, please explain how their evidence trumps mine and the others that see that AA is spiritual and not religious, especially in the context of a world organisation.
 
The most interesting thing to me about Alcoholics Anonymous is that it's a classically perfect example of an ideal specimen to learn from scientifically. That is, the hijacking of numerous other memetic viruses to create one super virus from hell that has ruined millions of lives, you could learn a lot from that kind of thing to prevent further suffering.

I mean the entire theme of this thread is about how a cult can completely screw up the minds of millions of people with almost no one noticing based on the delusions of a creeper named Bill Wilson. I mean, the dude wrote the 12 and 12 with the help of a 15th century monk named Boniface and NO ONE notices or knows about this in AA. Christ, no one even knows that Bill wrote Chapter 8! Cryin' shame. See in you in the movies.
 
Then why isn't a Christian based option to treat cancer more popular? Even most devout Christians choose the most modern medical treatment offered, which is based on secular, scientific study of cancer and how to most effectively treat it.
AA is not medical treatment. That’s why I go to doctors, many of whom are Christian. Why would a doctor be Christian, BTW? With their knowledge of the physical body, and brain function, surely being spiritual would be counter-intuitive. I’ll ask next time.

If someone is already Christian, and goes to AA for support, are they deceived in anyway? (Besides being told that AA is the only way, which I have disagreed with from the start.)
I think it's showing the true colors of AA and its proponents, and that is a Good Thing.
We disagree on what their true colors are, obviously. You see it as somehow sinister, with a hidden agenda. You have every right to do so, and can easily back it up with facts and quotes. To me, it is a fellowship of men and woman, yadayada. Dogmatic but true. I don’t seek god or medical advice or a date (well not usually a date ;) ), but instead stories of people that have been in similar situations and made a better life for themselves.
 
Except that it is the individuals that make up the organisation. The freedom of spiritual expressions flows both up and down.

If AA is predominantly Christian in the USA it is because the entire population is predominantly Christian. No surprise there.
In Australia we are far more relaxed and secular than our USA friends and as a result AA too is basically secular.

I wonder what sort of spiritual basis is evident in (say) China, Indonesia or other non Chritian countries.

Again, you are not looking at the overall picture, which consists of the history, published literature, common practices and (majority) demographics of the AA program. Together these show the organization to be religious in nature.

The program might be a lazy religion, but it is one all the same.
 
The thread title has been changed to reflect the fact that treatments other than AA are being discussed. Please consider posts on such subjects to be on-topic.
Posted By: Loss Leader
 
The most interesting thing to me about Alcoholics Anonymous is that it's a classically perfect example of an ideal specimen to learn from scientifically. That is, the hijacking of numerous other memetic viruses to create one super virus from hell that has ruined millions of lives, you could learn a lot from that kind of thing to prevent further suffering.

Emotive twaddle.
Evidence of "millions of lives" please.

The reality is that it is alcohol that is the problem for these people, not AA.

Again, you are not looking at the overall picture, which consists of the history, published literature, common practices and (majority) demographics of the AA program. Together these show the organization to be religious in nature. ]/quote]

Um,.. No.
Spiritual in nature; absolutely. Religious; no.

The thread title has been changed to reflect the fact that treatments other than AA are being discussed. Please consider posts on such subjects to be on-topic.
Posted By: Loss Leader

Great!

Can Jack and 8den please come out and provide the evidence for their recommendations now please?
 
We disagree on what their true colors are, obviously. You see it as somehow sinister, with a hidden agenda. You have every right to do so, and can easily back it up with facts and quotes. To me, it is a fellowship of men and woman, yadayada. Dogmatic but true. I don’t seek god or medical advice or a date (well not usually a date ;) ), but instead stories of people that have been in similar situations and made a better life for themselves.

I don't think most AA skeptics view the program so much as sinister as they do insincere. The common practices of program participants, together with the published program literature, indicate a religiously oriented program. The AA preamble however emphasizes none of this religiosity. Moreover, the AA.org website makes no mention of God on its home page. This is misleading.

If AA were to get more honest at the public level about its emphasis on worship of a monotheistic deity called God then it would rightly take its place as a new-age type of religion that employs faith healing as its primary method of choice. A better informed public could then make better informed choices about whether the program is right for them. The benefit for AA is that while its overall membership would decline those remaining would be true-believers, possibly leading to better long-term sobriety for those choosing a God-centered approach to treating addiction.
 
Again, you are not looking at the overall picture, which consists of the history, published literature, common practices and (majority) demographics of the AA program. Together these show the organization to be religious in nature.

The program might be a lazy religion, but it is one all the same.

Oh!! OK, now it is a lazy religion. Why is it alright for you to come up with your definition but not for us.
 
So I can choose any God I want, and my God doesn't have to be a God at all, and at the end of meetings we say Christian prayers, but this is not a religion?

Right... Got it.

"We"/"You" don't have to say Christian Prayers. It is your choice. Many AA people leave just before prayers or just don't say them.
AA is as religious as you want it to be.
 
That seems unlikely since we're talking about a religious organization, not individual.

You would really like to believe this because it would further your argument. Simple fact this statement is false, AA as a organization or people is as religious as you want to make it. Several links were brought to every ones attention by Alfie (quotes from the BB) explaining AA's take on religion, spirituality and the lack of.
 
Again, you are not looking at the overall picture, which consists of the history, published literature, common practices and (majority) demographics of the AA program. Together these show the organization to be religious in nature.

The program might be a lazy religion, but it is one all the same.

Spiritual son; spiritual. :)
 
Oh!! OK, now it is a lazy religion. Why is it alright for you to come up with your definition but not for us.

You can't even provide me the name of one meeting in the USA that does not close with a prayer. And I'm going to trust your definition of religion?
 
Great!

Can Jack and 8den please come out and provide the evidence for their recommendations now please?

Loss Leader's notice doesn't mean we MUST discuss alternatives, either.

You would really like to believe this because it would further your argument.

Doesn't this apply to everyone in every debate, ever ?

AA as a organization or people is as religious as you want to make it.

Yes, and objects are as "fast" as you want to make them. It doesn't change the fact that photons are fast.
 
I don't think most AA skeptics view the program so much as sinister as they do insincere. The common practices of program participants, together with the published program literature, indicate a religiously oriented program. The AA preamble however emphasizes none of this religiosity. Moreover, the AA.org website makes no mention of God on its home page. This is misleading.

If AA were to get more honest at the public level about its emphasis on worship of a monotheistic deity called God then it would rightly take its place as a new-age type of religion that employs faith healing as its primary method of choice. A better informed public could then make better informed choices about whether the program is right for them. The benefit for AA is that while its overall membership would decline those remaining would be true-believers, possibly leading to better long-term sobriety for those choosing a God-centered approach to treating addiction.

Gawd, Bamberger, come on now. You really think people can not figure out what AA is or is not within 15 mins. of being there. A "better informed public", trust me the public in America knows all about AA. They are informed and can make their own decisions.
Do you really think that you are the first person to bring this subject up, potential AA members have been with this decision since AA started. Read the history of AA.
It seems you don't like AA because it can be religious for some. I'm sorry.
 
Loss Leader's notice doesn't mean we MUST discuss alternatives, either.

Then we should spell hypocrisy with a capital H, and throw it back in their faces.

If they were honest they would simply state that these other methods have either similar results as AA and/or there have been no studies done - or released, at any rate.
 
Have no fear, I'm still lurking in the background on this thread, mostly to see if any of the AA defenders have come up with any new information.

Haven't seen any yet - but what I have seen, repeatedly, is a claim such as DannyB's such as 'AA can be religious for some', or 'AA is only as religious as one wants it to be'.

I'm sorry DannyB, you are not entitled to your own set of facts. The AA program (as distinguished from a minority of individual AA meetings, specifically so) is fully & completely a monotheistic, faith-based program who's 'healing' techniques are based on getting & maintaining a personal relationship with a 'higher power' - one who's qualities include listening & responding to prayer, as well as solidly described by the use of identifiers such as 'He who watches over us all', 'He who has All Power', 'He is the Father, we are his children' etc - typically christian & monotheistic descriptions.
I'm going to repeat this until it sinks in - the primary goal of AA is to develop and maintain a personal relationship with 'God as one understands Him', a side-effect of which (it is claimed by the program itself) a daily reprieve from alcoholism, one contingent upon working the 12 steps . The primary goal of the AA program is to make the member 'Of maximum service to God and his fellow human beings'.
Various groups practice this process differently - but I am not (in this particular post) at all concerned with what individual groups or members do, but what the program itself claims in it's materials (primiarly the big book, the 12x12, and to a smaller extent, the grapevine magazine).

As to why members continue to claim (as they have for 70 some odd years) that 'AA is spiritual, not religious' - the answer is found in Bill W's writings in the big book itself - I'll leave you to find those, for the moment.

Have a great day!!
 
You can't even provide me the name of one meeting in the USA that does not close with a prayer. And I'm going to trust your definition of religion?

I am sorry you can not accept the answer, NO!!!
I gave my reasons.

Belz says: Yes, and objects are as "fast" as you want to make them. It doesn't change the fact that photons are fast.

You can't be serious. :rolleyes:
 
I mean the entire theme of this thread is about how a cult can completely screw up the minds of millions of people with almost no one noticing based on the delusions of a creeper named Bill Wilson.

Exactly and it is interesting, as one with a sister who belongs to another cult, to see how AA members are sucked into their cult. It is very enlightening to see the depth of the cognitive dissonance cult members wallow in to justify their participation.

http://www.nytimes.com/1982/03/15/style/the-psychology-of-the-cult-experience.html?pagewanted=2

Dr. Cath defined a cult as a group of people joined together by a common ideological system fostered by a charismatic leader, where, he said, ''the expectation is that they can transcend the imperfections and finitude of life.''

He said: ''Often they set up a we-they philosophy: We have the truth and you do not.''

A typical manipulated conversion, Dr. Clark said, involves a vulnerable person - a student leaving home, or at exam time, or someone who has lost a friend or lover - who is enticed by some reward: companionship, peace of mind, a place to stay or an implied sexual offering. (Alcoholic = Vulnerable person)

''Then they narrow the attention of the recruit, in controlled social situations,''

(AA meeting = Controlled social situation)

Dr. Clark said. ''He or she is invited to attend a special function, or series of classes.

(AA meetings again)

Cult members are assigned to attend the prospect constantly.

(AA sponsors)

Eventually they keep the mark involved in group-ecstatic activities, or use meditation, obsessive praying, constant lecturing or preaching or lack of sleep to maintain the mind in a constantly debilitated state.'' A Crisis Is Manufactured

At some point during the experience, he said, ''the mark is placed in a panicky, disoriented state, and an emotional crisis is manufactured by the recruiters.''

(All the fear mongering AA does where they claim the only result of alcoholism is death = Manufactured emotional crisis.)

(Bolding mine)
 
Have no fear, I'm still lurking in the background on this thread, mostly to see if any of the AA defenders have come up with any new information.

Haven't seen any yet - but what I have seen, repeatedly, is a claim such as DannyB's such as 'AA can be religious for some', or 'AA is only as religious as one wants it to be'.

I'm sorry DannyB, you are not entitled to your own set of facts. The AA program (as distinguished from a minority of individual AA meetings, specifically so) is fully & completely a monotheistic, faith-based program who's 'healing' techniques are based on getting & maintaining a personal relationship with a 'higher power' - one who's qualities include listening & responding to prayer, as well as solidly described by the use of identifiers such as 'He who watches over us all', 'He who has All Power', 'He is the Father, we are his children' etc - typically christian & monotheistic descriptions.
I'm going to repeat this until it sinks in - the primary goal of AA is to develop and maintain a personal relationship with 'God as one understands Him', a side-effect of which (it is claimed by the program itself) a daily reprieve from alcoholism, one contingent upon working the 12 steps . The primary goal of the AA program is to make the member 'Of maximum service to God and his fellow human beings'.
Various groups practice this process differently - but I am not (in this particular post) at all concerned with what individual groups or members do, but what the program itself claims in it's materials (primiarly the big book, the 12x12, and to a smaller extent, the grapevine magazine).

As to why members continue to claim (as they have for 70 some odd years) that 'AA is spiritual, not religious' - the answer is found in Bill W's writings in the big book itself - I'll leave you to find those, for the moment.

Have a great day!!

Tinyal, they are not just my set of facts (from practical experience) but they are facts for many in AA. I find it hard to believe that in all your years being in AA Tinyal that you have not met the over whelming numbers of people that are opposed to any type of religion. They can barely accept the spiritual approach.
Yes the book mentions God and the need to have a God but it also states exactly what Alfie posted if you were reading the posts as you said.
Many of us approach AA in a manner that God is not a issue, doesn't exist.
Since it seems you have no problem with religion being in your AA program I can understand you opinions.
But do know these members accept the premise that "AA can be as religious as you want to be".
Oh!! Tinyal, Bill was one man speaking from his own experiences, with loud authority I will give you that. But he was not speaking for everyone.
Claiming that we AA'ers are nothing but automatons that kowtow to the will of one is ludicrous. We know exactly why "We Agnostics" was written, even though Bill tried not to have it written at all.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom