8den
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2006
- Messages
- 1,293
It is if you are making recommendations for treatment.
Was a recommending something in my professional capacity? No. So why do you think my career is relevant
This is a amazing piece of "whataboutery".
You arrived on this thread, and with your first post, announced that not only had you personal experience of the topic, but a relevant professional qualification, And that you could speak with authority on the subject. However, the moment someone questions your qualifications, you immediately snap back at them "Well what do you do"?
To answer your question A.A Alfie my career does not provide me with any relevant professional experience for the discussion. So what I do isn't relevant.
What you do is however relevant. And you yourself made it relevant from the start.
I recommended them as as secular alternatives to AA. That was the basis of my recommendation. That is basis on which I've always maintained is the reason I recommended them.To determine on what basis you make your recommendations.
A.A. Alfie you have brought your status as aGreat! Because I don't care either way.
Like I said, you either believe me or you don't; I don't care either way.
A.A.Alfie said:(I) work as a forensic counsellor
Why bring up your professional status in a relevant field into this debate, and then announce "Meh I don't care if you believe me if I am or not"?I am a professional counsellor and work in the fields of alcohol and other drugs
I recommended them as secular alternatives to AA.Untrue.
You made recommendations, here is exactly what you said:
Why would you "recommend" them unless you know they work? It is both potentially dangerous and naive to do so.
You can call that naive or dangerous, I couldn't care less.
You're just repeating yourself now AA Alfie.Surely you wouldn't "recommend" things so firmly unless you knew they worked. Surely you wouldn't? Tell me it isn't so.
See here's the thing. I'm a layman. I have no relevant professional experience in this field. I just said "if you're having trouble with alcohol addiction try and look at these links".
I didn't say "These methods really work" and here's the efficacy statistics to back them up.
Frankly you've been banging on for at least three pages now trying to get me to provide efficacy statistics, for programs that I've made no claims about their efficiency.
Wow again. You're a professional addiction counselorI will happily discuss the efficacy of AA, where would you like to start? What have you got? I would love to see some results.![]()
You feel you can discuss the issue of Alcohol Addiction and AA "with some level of authority". You've been clean for 10 years have studied addiction for how many years and "you'd love to see some results" as to the efficacy of AA? Where did you go to school, Delta Tau Chi?
Now You want Other Posters to provide You with Efficacy statistics for AA and other Treatment Methods?
I "recommended" them because they were Secular Alternatives to A.A. Honestly at this point I feel like I'm having a conversation with Leonard Shelby.Sigh...
Because you "recommend" them. And if you "recommend" them, surely you have good reason to do so, for the reasons I have already stated.
Both:
Absolutely, especially when we are talking about alcohol dependance. Perhaps you are not aware that people can die from withdrawal without adequate medical supervision.
I posted links to two websites. I didn't say "stop drinking this instance and read these links and you'll be cured".So it is certainly is potentially dangerous to recommend any treatment unless you can stand by it with some qualified reasons.
You're engaging in absurd hyperbole
I'm going to finish this post, as I will finish all posts addressed to you in future.
You have told this thread that you are a Professional Forensic Addiction Counselor in the field of Alcohol and Other Drugs. I'm asking you kindly to present to a moderator of this forum, verification that you hold professional accreditation with a recognized national body, or evidence of certification or qualification with a nationally recognized institution or school.
Thank you.