Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is if you are making recommendations for treatment.

Was a recommending something in my professional capacity? No. So why do you think my career is relevant

This is a amazing piece of "whataboutery".

You arrived on this thread, and with your first post, announced that not only had you personal experience of the topic, but a relevant professional qualification, And that you could speak with authority on the subject. However, the moment someone questions your qualifications, you immediately snap back at them "Well what do you do"?

To answer your question A.A Alfie my career does not provide me with any relevant professional experience for the discussion. So what I do isn't relevant.

What you do is however relevant. And you yourself made it relevant from the start.


To determine on what basis you make your recommendations.
I recommended them as as secular alternatives to AA. That was the basis of my recommendation. That is basis on which I've always maintained is the reason I recommended them.

Great! Because I don't care either way.





Like I said, you either believe me or you don't; I don't care either way.
A.A. Alfie you have brought your status as a

A.A.Alfie said:
(I) work as a forensic counsellor

I am a professional counsellor and work in the fields of alcohol and other drugs
Why bring up your professional status in a relevant field into this debate, and then announce "Meh I don't care if you believe me if I am or not"?


Untrue.
You made recommendations, here is exactly what you said:


Why would you "recommend" them unless you know they work? It is both potentially dangerous and naive to do so.
I recommended them as secular alternatives to AA.

You can call that naive or dangerous, I couldn't care less.

Surely you wouldn't "recommend" things so firmly unless you knew they worked. Surely you wouldn't? Tell me it isn't so.
You're just repeating yourself now AA Alfie.

See here's the thing. I'm a layman. I have no relevant professional experience in this field. I just said "if you're having trouble with alcohol addiction try and look at these links".

I didn't say "These methods really work" and here's the efficacy statistics to back them up.

Frankly you've been banging on for at least three pages now trying to get me to provide efficacy statistics, for programs that I've made no claims about their efficiency.




I will happily discuss the efficacy of AA, where would you like to start? What have you got? I would love to see some results. :)
Wow again. You're a professional addiction counselor


You feel you can discuss the issue of Alcohol Addiction and AA "with some level of authority". You've been clean for 10 years have studied addiction for how many years and "you'd love to see some results" as to the efficacy of AA? Where did you go to school, Delta Tau Chi?

Now You want Other Posters to provide You with Efficacy statistics for AA and other Treatment Methods?

Sigh...
Because you "recommend" them. And if you "recommend" them, surely you have good reason to do so, for the reasons I have already stated.
I "recommended" them because they were Secular Alternatives to A.A. Honestly at this point I feel like I'm having a conversation with Leonard Shelby.


Both:
Absolutely, especially when we are talking about alcohol dependance. Perhaps you are not aware that people can die from withdrawal without adequate medical supervision.
So it is certainly is potentially dangerous to recommend any treatment unless you can stand by it with some qualified reasons.
I posted links to two websites. I didn't say "stop drinking this instance and read these links and you'll be cured".

You're engaging in absurd hyperbole


I'm going to finish this post, as I will finish all posts addressed to you in future.

You have told this thread that you are a Professional Forensic Addiction Counselor in the field of Alcohol and Other Drugs. I'm asking you kindly to present to a moderator of this forum, verification that you hold professional accreditation with a recognized national body, or evidence of certification or qualification with a nationally recognized institution or school.

Thank you.
 
Look, we're discussing whether not AA is religious. You claimed that all your years in AA were spent in meetings that had no prayer. This claim is so far-fetched (for anyone who has been to even a few AA meetings) that you really need to back it up. Again, I will gladly visit one of the said meetings and confirm your claim that there is no prayer involved there.

Well that is not going to happen. I made my claim and my experience and integrity should be enough.
Most people chatting on this blog know my real name, so there fore how long would it take for some crazy to walk into a group I handed out here and locate my home or whatever else they are looking for. No I will not.
These groups are out there find them if you are truly interested.
 
I think this discussion of credentials is an excellent idea!

The President of SMART Recovery is Tom Horvath Ph.D., ABPP. Here are just some of his accomplishments and credentials, but the list really goes on and on and on. He earned a Ph.D. from the California School of Professional Psychology. He served as an active duty Navy Psychologist. He founded Practical Recovery, a self-empowering alternative to 12-step and disease-oriented addiction treatment. He became a board certified clinical psychologist of the American Board of Professional Psychology (ABPP) in 1990. He founded Pyrysys Psychology Group, Inc., which offers a wide range of services, and the Center for Cognitive Therapy La Jolla. Dr. Horvath has been active in professional psychology and behavioral health at the local, state, national and international levels. He is a Past President of the San Diego Psychological Association and a Past President of the San Diego Phobia Foundation. In 1992 he was appointed by Speaker Willie Brown to the California Controlled Substances Prescription Advisory Council. At the national level, he was the Secretary-Treasurer of the American Psychological Association's Division on Addictions, and served as President from 1999-2000. The Division has over 1200 members and is the world's largest organization of addictive behavior psychologists.

Bill Wilson was a failed stock swindler. In other words, was a lay person whose claim to being able to help alcoholics stemmed from a hallucination caused by Belladonna and Henbane treatment, which was the best treatment devised back the 1930’s. Oh, that and being indoctrinated into the religious cult, the Oxford Group.

SMART Recovery also uses REBT, which was developed by Albert Ellis, who held M.A. and Ph.D. degrees in clinical psychology from Columbia University, on the American Board of Professional Psychology, and was the president emeritus of the New York City-based Albert Ellis Institute. He is one of the originators of the cognitive revolutionary paradigm shift in psychotherapy and the founder of CBT therapies. In 1982, a professional survey of U.S. and Canadian psychologists, he was chosen as the second most influential psychotherapist in history. Before he died, Psychology Today named him as the “greatest living psychologist.

Dr. Bob was a Proctologist. In other words, he treated hemorrhoids. He was another lay person when it comes treating addiction.

SMART Recovery also uses AVRT which was created by Jack Trimpey, a California-licensed clinical social worker who is a recovered alcoholic that works in the field of treatment of alcoholism and other drug addictions.

But surely AA’s own Dr. Silkworth was an expert, right? Wrong. He was the one who called alcoholism an “allergy” and the one who, knowing full well that Bill had been tripping his brains out on hallucinogens, allowed Bill to think otherwise. Bill Wilson said of him: “If he had said, "hallucination," I might now be dead. To him I shall ever be eternally grateful.”

So, if credentials mean anything in this debate, on the one hand, you have a stock swindler, a proctologist and a another Dr. who was less than “rigorously honest.” Then there is the never ending generations of lay people, who are carrying on the AA tradition of the aforementioned lay people, all of whom think they are alcoholism and addictions experts just because they quit drinking/drugging. They also consider themselves to be on par with Drs, psychologists, clergy and soooo much more. In other words, AA is almost exclusively lay people.

On the other hand, you have real, actual PhDs who have actual education in this specific field that require far more than 40 hours and cost more than $160 to obtain. And there are many other PhDs that support SMART Recovery than those I mentioned.

By the way, Alfie, have you come up with any proof of the efficacy of AA yet? And what are your credentials again? Why is it that you "support" someone going to the lay people in AA, then incessantly criticize someone who suggests going to a program developed by Doctors?

BTW, Cause n Effect, have you come up with any proof of the efficacy of what you just printed. Do you really know what the credentials of Tom Horvath really means or are you just stumping the soap box with what you think they mean. Seriously, do you really think Tom has made a dent in the addiction circles, that Smart has really lived up to all its hype.
One alcoholic talking to another, the phenomena seems to still be working. I'll take a alcoholic working with me over any Dr/PHD any day, Drs/Phds want money and have no answers.
Whether this happens with a God of your understanding or not the rare experience of a alcoholic who once suffered working with one who is suffering is a awesome event.
Sorry many of you here missed this part and spent more time worrying about your own lot in life.
 
AA is inherently religious in nature.

I don't believe you would get a argument out of anyone here, Gunthar. We all know this already.

I'd go as far as to say that AA is a stealth religion that rides the backs of other religions like a parasite.

Nah, no stealth. The religious aspect of AA is right out there. Remember Oxford group, Lois holding meeting with the Bible before the BB and the mention of God t/o the writings of AA.
No stealth!!!
 
And I never heard those verses at a meeting, did you?

In fact I have. More than once. But even if you have not the prayer still remains a christian one.

Heck, I could take excerpts out of Mein Kampf and claim they are not fascist. But one could rightly question my veracity (and motives) in doing so.

Both the lord's prayer and the serenity prayer are christian, religious prayers. I challenge you to find me a meeting that uses neither of the two. If one exists, it is one of only a handful world-wide I would guess.
 
Underlying Motive

Nah, no stealth. The religious aspect of AA is right out there. Remember Oxford group, Lois holding meeting with the Bible before the BB and the mention of God t/o the writings of AA.
No stealth!!!

Then why do so many AA members insist that AA is "spiritual" and NOT "religious"?
 
Well that is not going to happen. I made my claim and my experience and integrity should be enough.
Most people chatting on this blog know my real name, so there fore how long would it take for some crazy to walk into a group I handed out here and locate my home or whatever else they are looking for. No I will not.
These groups are out there find them if you are truly interested.

You said there are 25 meetings in the northeast that do not use prayer. Give me the names of the ones you don't attend. Or do you go to all 25? I'm finding it hard to believe you.
 
Our real purpose is to fit ourselves to be of maximum service to God and the people about us.​
~Alcoholics Anonymous Big Book p.77, Into Action

Except that earlier in the book it states:

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

And unless you are into redundant repetition, that kinda covers it, huh?

So you are admitting that your preferred modalities are potentially dangerous.

LOL
Not even close.

Was a recommending something in my professional capacity? No. So why do you think my career is relevant

Because you made a recommendation. Duh!

To answer your question A.A Alfie my career does not provide me with any relevant professional experience for the discussion. So what I do isn't relevant.

Sure it is. I am wondering under what basis you would actually make these recommendations; you aren't a medical professional, you aren't a clinician, therapist or counsellor, you aren't anything relevant by your own admission. So on what possible basis can you make a recommendations unless you know they work? Surely you have some insight into the effectivenes of the modalities from either a first hand perspective or via clinical results.

And even if you didn't have some data on the effectiveness, surely it should be simple enough to get some. After all, they have doctors and professionals running them don't they?

What you do is however relevant. And you yourself made it relevant from the start.

Yep.

I recommended them as as secular alternatives to AA. That was the basis of my recommendation. That is basis on which I've always maintained is the reason I recommended them.

OK. So am I to understand that you know nothing of these other modalities except that they are secular. That's it? Just because they are secular?
That would be akin to one recommending something just because something was religious, wouldn't it?

So your recommendations are based on no reason whatsoever except for a religious belief or lack of it?

Wow! Just wow!

See here's the thing. I'm a layman. I have no relevant professional experience in this field. I just said "if you're having trouble with alcohol addiction try and look at these links".

If that had been what you actually did, I would have no problem. But you made rather stentorious recommendations based on nothing.

I didn't say "These methods really work" and here's the efficacy statistics to back them up.

If I had said, "I recommend AA", you would have jumped all over me and with some justification, wouldn't you?

You feel you can discuss the issue of Alcohol Addiction and AA "with some level of authority". You've been clean for 10 years have studied addiction for how many years and "you'd love to see some results" as to the efficacy of AA?

Well it was you that wanted to discuss them after all, I just figured you would actually have something to table to get the discussion under way. So what have you got? :boggled:

I posted links to two websites. I didn't say "stop drinking this instance and read these links and you'll be cured".

No but you did make recommendations.
If you recommended a mechanic to your mates, would you know whether they were any good? If you recommended a restaurant to colleagues, would you have dined there?
Or would you base your recommendations on the basis of whether or not they were secular. What if the mechanic was useless, the food inedible?

Your recommendations may be different to mine, but when I recommend something it actually carries some valid reasons and/or first hand experience.

Then why do so many AA members insist that AA is "spiritual" and NOT "religious"?

It has been pointed out many times already that religion is most certainly spiritual, but spiritual does not have to be religious. That's why.:)
 
Except that earlier in the book it states:

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

And unless you are into redundant repetition, that kinda covers it, huh?


So I can choose any God I want, and my God doesn't have to be a God at all, and at the end of meetings we say Christian prayers, but this is not a religion?

Right... Got it.
 
Religious? Why not? The CIA says that the United States is 78.5% christian. it should come as no suprise that a christian based option is popular.

Hi folks.

I've been on this thread for quite awhile, and wanted to ask a favor.

Can we get to more productive discussions?

The thing is I agree with almost everyone, because it is not a zero sum game. 8den says that a secular approach to stopping addiction is valuable. I agree. Alfie says that statistics regarding such methods are important. I agree.

We need to move on, past this unnecessarily distraction. At least I do.

I wonder what the benefit of this thread might be to those watching. Surely not bickering about who is from where, how or why. This forum is open to everone, and I give everyone equal consideration. Surely we can drop the past animosities stirred up by the words written here, and try to accept that we have differences of interpretation.

In all honesty, I'd like some folks here to take a few days off. See where this thread might go. I don't like where it is. (I'm going to write something at the top that will hopefully let this post pass)
 
Except that earlier in the book it states:

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

Again, you are failing to acknowledge the full mosaic that is AA. The main pieces of this mosaic that make the program religious are:

- the program's history [evangelical/moralistic Oxford Group, relationship with clergy]
- the program's texts [heavy use of a monotheistic deity]
- the program's common practices [christian prayer, God-oriented 12 steps]
- the programs demographics [most AA groups employ prayer, thereby signifying tacit approval of most members for supplication to a deity]

Each of these pieces are in and of themselves religious in nature, and when put together they create a very cohesive pattern of religiosity in the program as a whole.
 
Then why do so many AA members insist that AA is "spiritual" and NOT "religious"?

Marketing.

They might think the term "religious" may have negative connotations to whomever they are speaking to, so they use "spiritual", a more "generic" term, to make AA seem more inviting.

Like "I'm not a pessimist ! I'm a realist !"
 
Each of these pieces are in and of themselves religious in nature, and when put together they create a very cohesive pattern of religiosity in the program as a whole.

I might agree except for the fact that religion is unnecessary in both theory and practice.

Marketing.

They might think the term "religious" may have negative connotations to whomever they are speaking to, so they use "spiritual", a more "generic" term, to make AA seem more inviting.

Like "I'm not a pessimist ! I'm a realist !"

Or another and more likely alternative is that people truly know this to be the case for themselves (i.e. spiritual not religious), because of their understanding of their own spiritual foundations and how they use them within AA itself.
 
Religious? Why not? The CIA says that the United States is 78.5% christian. it should come as no suprise that a christian based option is popular.
Then why isn't a Christian based option to treat cancer more popular? Even most devout Christians choose the most modern medical treatment offered, which is based on secular, scientific study of cancer and how to most effectively treat it.

What is it about alcoholism that makes it a "Christian disease?" For that manner how is compulsive gambling and being messy Christian diseases, or even diseases at all?
Hi folks.

I've been on this thread for quite awhile, and wanted to ask a favor.

Can we get to more productive discussions?

The thing is I agree with almost everyone, because it is not a zero sum game. 8den says that a secular approach to stopping addiction is valuable. I agree. Alfie says that statistics regarding such methods are important. I agree.

We need to move on, past this unnecessarily distraction. At least I do.

I wonder what the benefit of this thread might be to those watching.
I think it's showing the true colors of AA and its proponents, and that is a Good Thing.
 
Marketing.

They might think the term "religious" may have negative connotations to whomever they are speaking to, so they use "spiritual", a more "generic" term, to make AA seem more inviting.

Like "I'm not a pessimist ! I'm a realist !"

Exactly. The real deal comes later on down the road.

Higher Power > God > evangelize.....repeat cycle.
 
I might agree except for the fact that religion is unnecessary in both theory and practice.

The fact that I am an atheist means I understand this very well. You on the other hand make the claim while being a practicing christian. Seems rather odd.

Or another and more likely alternative is that people truly know this to be the case for themselves (i.e. spiritual not religious), because of their understanding of their own spiritual foundations and how they use them within AA itself.

Yeah, no. This thread is filled with AA members who completely disagree with you. They state that the organization and the meetings are every bit as religious as AA detractors have claimed.
 
Or another and more likely alternative is that people truly know this to be the case for themselves (i.e. spiritual not religious), because of their understanding of their own spiritual foundations and how they use them within AA itself.

That seems unlikely since we're talking about a religious organization, not individual.
 
That seems unlikely since we're talking about a religious organization, not individual.

Except that it is the individuals that make up the organisation. The freedom of spiritual expressions flows both up and down.

If AA is predominantly Christian in the USA it is because the entire population is predominantly Christian. No surprise there.
In Australia we are far more relaxed and secular than our USA friends and as a result AA too is basically secular.

I wonder what sort of spiritual basis is evident in (say) China, Indonesia or other non Chritian countries.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom