8den
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2006
- Messages
- 1,293
You most certainly did:
This post (I have snipped the non relevant bits) was the one I objected to. The entire post is about treatments, not my recovery.
Not a word about my personal journey in there and you want me to believe that is what you meant? Really? (my bold)
Yes. I did. I'm sorry you were confused.
What for? You either believe me or you don't. I couldn't care less either way.
But why not tell me what your qualifications are and how that makes you some sort of expert that can make recommendations?
No A.A. Alfie you've been making claims that you are a a professional Forensic Addiction Councillor for over a year now.
I've made no claim to being a expert within a relevant field to the discussion.
It happens all the time on the CT forum, someone makes a claim about their professional credentials that affords them expertise in a relevant field.
Like you have done.
They PM a mod to demonstrate they have accredited certification with a recognised school or institution.
Where's the harm?
So you keep saying. But I keep asking why you would make recommendations for something you actually have no idea about. It strikes me as both potentially dangerous and hypocritical.
It might strike you as such. I disagree.
Surely you don't make unqualified recommendations without some knowledge of their effectiveness. I assume you are not trained in the area of addiction, do you think lay people should be doing this?
Lay people make recommendations to a variety of alcohol treatments all the time. Certain Lay people will go into hospitals and prisons and make recommendations about certain treatment methods for hours at a time.
All I did was post some links.
You disagree to what? That the forum members here are unable to manage more than one online conversation at a time? Really? You think they are that stupid? Really?![]()
And again you're putting words into my mouth. I don't think people are stupid. And I resent you putting words in my mouth. I just think the thread would benefit from a discussion of the efficacy of AA, before we start talking about the efficacy of other treatments.
Indeed you did. And I would like to know why you would do such a thing unless you knew they worked? Do these secular alternatives work? How well? What sort of efficacy do they claim? What studies have been done?
Have you got this information or not?
Like I said, this strikes me as potentially dangerous and naive in the extreme.
Well I don't care how it strikes you. I've made no claims about their efficacy, you can stomp your foot all you want demanding I provide efficacy statistics for alternatives to AA. The thread is about the efficacy of AA.
Now anyway about your professional qualifications?
