Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You most certainly did:
This post (I have snipped the non relevant bits) was the one I objected to. The entire post is about treatments, not my recovery.



Not a word about my personal journey in there and you want me to believe that is what you meant? Really? (my bold)

Yes. I did. I'm sorry you were confused.

What for? You either believe me or you don't. I couldn't care less either way.


But why not tell me what your qualifications are and how that makes you some sort of expert that can make recommendations?

No A.A. Alfie you've been making claims that you are a a professional Forensic Addiction Councillor for over a year now.

I've made no claim to being a expert within a relevant field to the discussion.

It happens all the time on the CT forum, someone makes a claim about their professional credentials that affords them expertise in a relevant field.

Like you have done.

They PM a mod to demonstrate they have accredited certification with a recognised school or institution.

Where's the harm?

So you keep saying. But I keep asking why you would make recommendations for something you actually have no idea about. It strikes me as both potentially dangerous and hypocritical.

It might strike you as such. I disagree.

Surely you don't make unqualified recommendations without some knowledge of their effectiveness. I assume you are not trained in the area of addiction, do you think lay people should be doing this?

Lay people make recommendations to a variety of alcohol treatments all the time. Certain Lay people will go into hospitals and prisons and make recommendations about certain treatment methods for hours at a time.

All I did was post some links.

You disagree to what? That the forum members here are unable to manage more than one online conversation at a time? Really? You think they are that stupid? Really? :jaw-dropp:boggled:

And again you're putting words into my mouth. I don't think people are stupid. And I resent you putting words in my mouth. I just think the thread would benefit from a discussion of the efficacy of AA, before we start talking about the efficacy of other treatments.

Indeed you did. And I would like to know why you would do such a thing unless you knew they worked? Do these secular alternatives work? How well? What sort of efficacy do they claim? What studies have been done?

Have you got this information or not?

Like I said, this strikes me as potentially dangerous and naive in the extreme.

Well I don't care how it strikes you. I've made no claims about their efficacy, you can stomp your foot all you want demanding I provide efficacy statistics for alternatives to AA. The thread is about the efficacy of AA.

Now anyway about your professional qualifications?
 
I can not argue your point with any authority because I really don't know. "My bad". The meetings I attended did not have prayers at all. This was purposely put into the by laws.
My wording of "some" denoted the wrong message, you are right Bamberger.
This also goes to you Ben. My apologies for accidentally misrepresenting my point.


You attended AA meetings that had no prayers? That's unique to say the least. Can you give us a clue where? This would be a new one on me.
 
You attended AA meetings that had no prayers? That's unique to say the least. Can you give us a clue where? This would be a new one on me.
Yes indeed. Every meeting I attended started with the Serenity Prayer (well, there was this ONE meeting where the chairman was getting married the next day, he accidentally started that one with the Lord's Prayer), and then ended with the Lord's Prayer, often just after the "Who you see here, what you hear here, when you leave here, let it stay here" statement and often prompted with "Whose father?"

I did hear about meetings "up north" or perhaps I read about it on the Fidonet Recovery echo - I heard they said the Serenity Prayer at both the start and the end of their meetings.
 
You attended AA meetings that had no prayers? That's unique to say the least. Can you give us a clue where? This would be a new one on me.

There are many (I know of at least 25 meetings and more are happening) in the Northeast (where I am originally from) but I was more familiar with these meeting in the southeast. I was a member of two and actually was part of a group that changed the by laws to accommodate people and myself that wanted no prayers in are meeting.
 
No A.A. Alfie you've been making claims that you are a a professional Forensic Addiction Councillor for over a year now.

Among other disciplines, yes I have.

I've made no claim to being a expert within a relevant field to the discussion.

Yet you feel to be in a position to make potentially dangerous recommendations for treatments?!?!

I am curious, just what do you do for work?

It happens all the time on the CT forum, someone makes a claim about their professional credentials that affords them expertise in a relevant field.

This isn't a CT forum. But like I said, I don't care one way or another whether you belive me.

Lay people make recommendations to a variety of alcohol treatments all the time. Certain Lay people will go into hospitals and prisons and make recommendations about certain treatment methods for hours at a time.

Indeed. Yet you don't see that you making recommendations are hypocritical, naive and potentially dangerous?

This is incredible: You have serious problems with lay AA members recommending treatment without evidence of efficacy because AA is dangerous. If I was to defend them, I would simply say that what they do is tell people what has worked for them.

To the best of our knowledge, you are not a member of have been treated by these other methods yet you will happily make unqualified and potentially dangerous recommendations yourself with no training whatsoever.

Unbelievable.

All I did was post some links.

Untrue, you posted links, referred readers to Stinkin' Thinkin; and said "I recommend"... the treatments.

Why would you "recommend" them unless you knew they worked?

And again you're putting words into my mouth. I don't think people are stupid. And I resent you putting words in my mouth. I just think the thread would benefit from a discussion of the efficacy of AA, before we start talking about the efficacy of other treatments.

Trust me, we can manage both - having both would even be beneficial to discussions don't you think?

So can you please provide the efiicacy results of the treatments you "recommend" please? If you can't, could you please explain why you can't and then explain why you would recommend anything in such a hypocritical, naive and potential dangerous way.
 
There are many (I know of at least 25 meetings and more are happening) in the Northeast (where I am originally from) but I was more familiar with these meeting in the southeast. I was a member of two and actually was part of a group that changed the by laws to accommodate people and myself that wanted no prayers in are meeting.

I have never been at a meeting that recited the Lord's prayer.
I have attended hundreds of different groups in every state and territory of Australia and thousands of meetings over nearly 15 years (12 years sober come October).

Certainly, every meeting finishes with the Serenity prayer, but my agnostic and atheist friends (and I) have no problem with the serenity prayer, it is very easy to change it into an affirmation.

Take what you need and leave the rest.
 
There are many (I know of at least 25 meetings and more are happening) in the Northeast (where I am originally from) but I was more familiar with these meeting in the southeast. I was a member of two and actually was part of a group that changed the by laws to accommodate people and myself that wanted no prayers in are meeting.

Please provide the northeast meeting names. I will personally visit the ones I can to confirm.
 
No Prayers at AA Meetings?

Nonsense!

I've never been to an AA meeting that didn't end with The Lord's Prayer, The Serenity Prayer, or both.

Alcoholics Anonymous is a religion dressed up to look like a treatment for alcoholism... It's a religious cult that uses peoples weaknesses as a recruiting tool.

AA is a casual religion in many ways, but it remains true to most of the Christian doctrine, in that AA requires members to confess their sins, surrender their will (as if such a thing were possible) repent from their sins, and evangelize the message of AA.
 
Nonsense!

I've never been to an AA meeting that didn't end with The Lord's Prayer, The Serenity Prayer, or both.

Alcoholics Anonymous is a religion dressed up to look like a treatment for alcoholism... It's a religious cult that uses peoples weaknesses as a recruiting tool.

AA is a casual religion in many ways, but it remains true to most of the Christian doctrine, in that AA requires members to confess their sins, surrender their will (as if such a thing were possible) repent from their sins, and evangelize the message of AA.

OK, those were the meetings you attended and I am not going to argue this.
As far as AA being a casual religion or any other religion, you won't get a argument from me there either. I believe AA can be as religious as you want it to be.
 
Please provide the northeast meeting names. I will personally visit the ones I can to confirm.

Sorry Bamberger, but I simply will not provide you with this information for obvious reasons. If you are truly that interested then a little checking around will serve you well.
 
Among other disciplines, yes I have.

And yet you made your job part of your first post about this thread.


You said:
I have been clean and sober now for 10 years and work as a forensic counsellor in AOD as well as other areas.
AA forms the basis for the maintenance of my sobrierty


I am curious, just what do you do for work?
My job/career isn't irrelevant.


I have been clean and sober now for 10 years and work as a forensic counsellor in AOD as well as other areas.
You made your sobriety, and your professional status part of your argument since your first post

I've never made made my personal experience and my professional background relevant to the discussion.

You've also said;

you said:
I am a professional counsellor and work in the fields of alcohol and other drugs (AOD)

You're a professional with experience in the relevant field of this discussion.

You said this yourself. Why are you trying to raise my career as part of the discussion?

This isn't a CT forum.
This is the James Randi Forum. If a poster these forums raises their professional background as relevant to this discussion as you have, it's not unreasonable for a member of this forum to ask for independent verification of your credentials.

I only mentioned the CT forum of Randi, as it's a forum that, apparently, we both post on.

But like I said, I don't care one way or another whether you belive me.
It's not whether I believe you or not.

You brought up your professional background in the exact field of this thread.

For the forum. Please, share with a Moderator. Not with me. But with everyone on this thread, your professional accreditation.


Indeed. Yet you don't see that you making recommendations are hypocritical, naive and potentially dangerous?
I posted two links I didn't say for for example

I have been clean and sober now for 10 years and work as a forensic counsellor in AOD as well as other areas.
AA forms the basis for the maintenance of my sobriey
Now that's a recommendation.

Yet here you are, not discussing the efficacy of AA, and here you are saying that despite the fact that it is the basis of your own decade of sobriety that you don't prefer it?

Now for example have I ever said "people can't say what is or isn't their personal preference"?






Unbelievable.
I know you are.

Untrue, you posted links, referred readers to Stinkin' Thinkin; and said "I recommend"... the treatments.

Why would you "recommend" them unless you knew they worked?
Unless I thought people should do some further reading?

Trust me,
Pass.

we can manage both - having both would even be beneficial to discussions don't you think?
I think the forum would benefit from you showing your professional credentials.



So can you please provide the efiicacy results of the treatments you "recommend" please?
If you think the discussion could benefit from the efficacy of these treatments. knock yourself out. Please provide efficacy results of these treatments. I've made no claims about their efficacy. So please put them on the table.

If you can't, could you please explain why you can't
I didn't say I can't. I just said said I made no claims about their efficacy. So I don't see why I should have to support their efficacy when I made no claims about their efficacy.

and then explain why you would recommend anything in such a hypocritical, naive and potential dangerous way.
Wow. Is recommending something with having supporting evidence naive and potentially dangerous in your personal opinion A.A Alife?

Or in your professional capacity?
 
I think this discussion of credentials is an excellent idea!

The President of SMART Recovery is Tom Horvath Ph.D., ABPP. Here are just some of his accomplishments and credentials, but the list really goes on and on and on. He earned a Ph.D. from the California School of Professional Psychology. He served as an active duty Navy Psychologist. He founded Practical Recovery, a self-empowering alternative to 12-step and disease-oriented addiction treatment. He became a board certified clinical psychologist of the American Board of Professional Psychology (ABPP) in 1990. He founded Pyrysys Psychology Group, Inc., which offers a wide range of services, and the Center for Cognitive Therapy La Jolla. Dr. Horvath has been active in professional psychology and behavioral health at the local, state, national and international levels. He is a Past President of the San Diego Psychological Association and a Past President of the San Diego Phobia Foundation. In 1992 he was appointed by Speaker Willie Brown to the California Controlled Substances Prescription Advisory Council. At the national level, he was the Secretary-Treasurer of the American Psychological Association's Division on Addictions, and served as President from 1999-2000. The Division has over 1200 members and is the world's largest organization of addictive behavior psychologists.

Bill Wilson was a failed stock swindler. In other words, was a lay person whose claim to being able to help alcoholics stemmed from a hallucination caused by Belladonna and Henbane treatment, which was the best treatment devised back the 1930’s. Oh, that and being indoctrinated into the religious cult, the Oxford Group.

SMART Recovery also uses REBT, which was developed by Albert Ellis, who held M.A. and Ph.D. degrees in clinical psychology from Columbia University, on the American Board of Professional Psychology, and was the president emeritus of the New York City-based Albert Ellis Institute. He is one of the originators of the cognitive revolutionary paradigm shift in psychotherapy and the founder of CBT therapies. In 1982, a professional survey of U.S. and Canadian psychologists, he was chosen as the second most influential psychotherapist in history. Before he died, Psychology Today named him as the “greatest living psychologist.

Dr. Bob was a Proctologist. In other words, he treated hemorrhoids. He was another lay person when it comes treating addiction.

SMART Recovery also uses AVRT which was created by Jack Trimpey, a California-licensed clinical social worker who is a recovered alcoholic that works in the field of treatment of alcoholism and other drug addictions.

But surely AA’s own Dr. Silkworth was an expert, right? Wrong. He was the one who called alcoholism an “allergy” and the one who, knowing full well that Bill had been tripping his brains out on hallucinogens, allowed Bill to think otherwise. Bill Wilson said of him: “If he had said, "hallucination," I might now be dead. To him I shall ever be eternally grateful.”

So, if credentials mean anything in this debate, on the one hand, you have a stock swindler, a proctologist and a another Dr. who was less than “rigorously honest.” Then there is the never ending generations of lay people, who are carrying on the AA tradition of the aforementioned lay people, all of whom think they are alcoholism and addictions experts just because they quit drinking/drugging. They also consider themselves to be on par with Drs, psychologists, clergy and soooo much more. In other words, AA is almost exclusively lay people.

On the other hand, you have real, actual PhDs who have actual education in this specific field that require far more than 40 hours and cost more than $160 to obtain. And there are many other PhDs that support SMART Recovery than those I mentioned.

By the way, Alfie, have you come up with any proof of the efficacy of AA yet? And what are your credentials again? Why is it that you "support" someone going to the lay people in AA, then incessantly criticize someone who suggests going to a program developed by Doctors?
 
I have never been at a meeting that recited the Lord's prayer.
I have attended hundreds of different groups in every state and territory of Australia and thousands of meetings over nearly 15 years (12 years sober come October).

Certainly, every meeting finishes with the Serenity prayer, but my agnostic and atheist friends (and I) have no problem with the serenity prayer, it is very easy to change it into an affirmation.

Take what you need and leave the rest.


Here's the remainder of the serenity prayer. It was written by a Christian for Christians:

Living one day at a time;
Enjoying one moment at a time;
Accepting hardships as the pathway to peace;
Taking, as He did, this sinful world
as it is, not as I would have it;
Trusting that He will make all things right
if I surrender to His Will;
That I may be reasonably happy in this life
and supremely happy with Him
Forever in the next.
Amen.


The "he" in there is Jesus I believe.
 
Sorry Bamberger, but I simply will not provide you with this information for obvious reasons. If you are truly that interested then a little checking around will serve you well.

Look, we're discussing whether not AA is religious. You claimed that all your years in AA were spent in meetings that had no prayer. This claim is so far-fetched (for anyone who has been to even a few AA meetings) that you really need to back it up. Again, I will gladly visit one of the said meetings and confirm your claim that there is no prayer involved there.
 
My job/career isn't irrelevant.

It is if you are making recommendations for treatment.

You said this yourself. Why are you trying to raise my career as part of the discussion?

To determine on what basis you make your recommendations.

It's not whether I believe you or not.

Great! Because I don't care either way.

You brought up your professional background in the exact field of this thread.

Yep.

For the forum. Please, share with a Moderator. Not with me. But with everyone on this thread, your professional accreditation.

Like I said, you either believe me or you don't; I don't care either way.

I posted two links I didn't say for for example

Untrue.
You made recommendations, here is exactly what you said:
For anyone reading this thread and having trouble with alcohol addiction I'd recommend
http://www.smartrecovery.org/
http://www.mywayout.org/

Why would you "recommend" them unless you know they work? It is both potentially dangerous and naive to do so.

Surely you wouldn't "recommend" things so firmly unless you knew they worked. Surely you wouldn't? Tell me it isn't so.

Yet here you are, not discussing the efficacy of AA,

I will happily discuss the efficacy of AA, where would you like to start? What have you got? I would love to see some results. :)

I didn't say I can't. I just said said I made no claims about their efficacy. So I don't see why I should have to support their efficacy when I made no claims about their efficacy.

Sigh...
Because you "recommend" them. And if you "recommend" them, surely you have good reason to do so, for the reasons I have already stated.

Wow. Is recommending something with having supporting evidence naive and potentially dangerous in your personal opinion A.A Alife?

Or in your professional capacity?[/

Both:
Absolutely, especially when we are talking about alcohol dependance. Perhaps you are not aware that people can die from withdrawal without adequate medical supervision. So it is certainly is potentially dangerous to recommend any treatment unless you can stand by it with some qualified reasons.

By the way, Alfie, have you come up with any proof of the efficacy of AA yet?

Why do I need to? Have I made some claims around the efficacy of AA somewhere?

Why is it that you "support" someone going to the lay people in AA,

You are only new here so I will give you some clues;
Firstly browse the thread, you will probably find the answer as I have outlined these before.
Second, do not accuse me of doing anything you cannot support with evidence. Third, if you are going to make claims, please ensure you provide the reasons for you making them.

Given that, please tell me where and how exactly and under what conditions I have supported people going to AA? I am not saying I wouldn't or didn't, but I would like to know precisely what it is you are trying to accuse me of.

then incessantly criticize someone who suggests going to a program developed by Doctors?

I have criiticised nothing. All I have asked for is some results. I also ask for results from AA, Have you got some so I can do some comparisons?

In the meantime, given these doctors have established this program that you advocate, perhaps you can provide us with some efficacy results for alcoholics?

Here's the remainder of the serenity prayer. It was written by a Christian for Christians:

Living one day at a time;
Enjoying one moment at a time;
Accepting hardships as the pathway to peace;
Taking, as He did, this sinful world
as it is, not as I would have it;
Trusting that He will make all things right
if I surrender to His Will;
That I may be reasonably happy in this life
and supremely happy with Him
Forever in the next.
Amen.


The "he" in there is Jesus I believe.

And I never heard those verses at a meeting, did you?
 
Here's the remainder of the serenity prayer. It was written by a Christian for Christians:

Living one day at a time;
Enjoying one moment at a time;
Accepting hardships as the pathway to peace;
Taking, as He did, this sinful world
as it is, not as I would have it;
Trusting that He will make all things right
if I surrender to His Will;
That I may be reasonably happy in this life
and supremely happy with Him
Forever in the next.
Amen.


The "he" in there is Jesus I believe.
In fact I've seen a version of the "long version" that spelled out Jesus.
 
AA is not only religious - AA is a religion

OK, those were the meetings you attended and I am not going to argue this.
As far as AA being a casual religion or any other religion, you won't get a argument from me there either. I believe AA can be as religious as you want it to be.

AA is inherently religious in nature.

Our real purpose is to fit ourselves to be of maximum service to God and the people about us.​
~Alcoholics Anonymous Big Book p.77, Into Action

I'd go as far as to say that AA is a stealth religion that rides the backs of other religions like a parasite.
 
According to AA's Big Book

AA members are just a group of folks who seek to play doctor, and treat alcoholism, as a hobby.

"We would like it understood that our alcoholic work is an avocation." ~Alcoholics Anonymous Big Book xiii, Foreword to First Edition
​
 
You are asking for a one-size-fits-all response and to answer in such a manner would be ridiculous, unprofessional and potentially dangerous.

So you are admitting that your preferred modalities are potentially dangerous. It seems that everybody who goes to AA should run it past you first. What happens if you make a mistake and make the wrong referral?
 
They differentiate between religious and spiritual.

This is not necessarily a differentiation. You are reading something into it that isn't there.

[QUOTE}Back to my work, I need to figure out how to help this person with their drinking issues - AA is not the answer for him.[/QUOTE]

I can see how this would be very confusing for you since AA is the only thing you know about. Perhaps you should refer this individual to someone else who knows about alternatives and can better assist him. It could be very dangerous for you to continue with this client considering your lack of knowledge and your unwillingness/inability to do your own research.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom