Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes. But when its very survival (revenue via literature sales) depends on a steady stream of new members this begins to make more sense. Court and doctor referrals would all but dry up if the organization got more honest about being a religion.
Even in areas where court cases have ruled AA is religious and courts cannot force offenders to attend, such coercion still goes on. This shows the influence of AA and its members within courts and corrections, all the while believing (whether as AA members or misinformed "civilians") that they're only trying to help people.
 
What is desperate is you trying to pin things on me I never actually said. You even quoted the big book at me as evidence of something I supposedly said, which I found hilarious by the way. :)

No. No it's not. You've spent so long on this thread supporting and defending AA, and detailing how important it was for your own personal sobriety, how through AA you recovered and indeed met your spouse, and yet when someone says "AA is your preferred method" you jump up and down and said "I NEVER EVER SAID THOSE EXACT WORDS" and seem to think you've made some kind of majesty win here.

All I did is link back to this section of the AA "how it works"

[FONT=Arial, Arial, Helvetica]Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.
[/FONT]

I've never claimed you said this.

I've merely pointed out this part of the "how it works" (of y'know the philosophy you credit as part of your recovery.


You "recommended" them, and I would still like to know why.

I've never put the word "recommended" in inverted commas.

As I've pointed out I recommended them as secular alternatives to AA.

Do you not think it somewhat hypocritical to recommend something without being fully apprised of them or their treatment methods?
Do you think it not a ittle silly to recommend something to people yet have no idea whether or not it actually has a chance of working?
Frankly it is potentially dangerous.

This thread is about AA and it's efficacy.

It's not about alternatives to AA and their efficacy.

Do you still stand by your recommendations? If so, why?

I recommended them as secular alternatives to AA.

Actually I'm simply following you.
Can you answer me or not? What are the efficacy results for these other treatments with regard to alcoholics?

Well why don't we seem some efficacy statistics for AA, before we start to worry about the efficacy ratings about alternatives to AA?

I am simply holding you to the same standards you wish to hold AA.
Can you answer me or not?

No see thats not the way it works.

The thread is about the efficacy of AA, not about the efficacy of everything else aside from AA.

I mean you've made the claim

Nonsense. The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

And now you seem eager to crawl away from your claims.
 
Untrue.
I have never - and I stress never, been to an AA meeting that has uttered the Lord's prayer.


Evidence please.

Ad hom, much.
Could you please tell me with what qualifications you make your recommendations?

Yeah AA Ailfie you've cited your qualifications as a Forensic Addiction Councillor several times on this thread.

I'd like you to share your credentials with a mod on this forum. To verify you have the correct qualifications from a accredited college.
 
Yes. But when its very survival (revenue via literature sales) depends on a steady stream of new members this begins to make more sense. Court and doctor referrals would all but dry up if the organization got more honest about being a religion.

It is a bit frustrating. I went as moral support to maybe 4 or five meetings, and I had to bite my tongue.

I really wanted to scream this is utter BS, but out of respect and hope for my mate, I held my peace. Go figure.
 
No. No it's not. You've spent so long on this thread supporting and defending AA, and detailing how important it was for your own personal sobriety, how through AA you recovered and indeed met your spouse, and yet when someone says "AA is your preferred method" you jump up and down and said "I NEVER EVER SAID THOSE EXACT WORDS" and seem to think you've made some kind of majesty win here.

See now you are getting closer to the truth, I have said "it works for me" (or similar), that I support AA and continue to attend. I have never said it is my preferred method for others.

I've never put the word "recommended" in inverted commas.

No you didn't. I did. And the reason is simple, I have put the inverted commas around the word as it is a direct quote from you, that's what inverted commas are for, to show you are quoting someone.

You made the recommendation, hence the word "recommend" appears as it does.

As I've pointed out I recommended them as secular alternatives to AA.

Of course. But do they work?
Surely you wouldn't you recommend something if it doesn't work? Surely not. :eek:
This is potentially dangerous.

This thread is about AA and it's efficacy.

Indeed.
But let's not forget it was you that brought these in, it was you.


As a footnote here, I am still waiting for Jack to support his recommendations around the Sinclair method too. Hopefully he is still reading the thread.

Well why don't we seem some efficacy statistics for AA, before we start to worry about the efficacy ratings about alternatives to AA?

Great!
But I think we can handle both sets of info at the same time, don't you?

So what have you got?
 
Sure, but why does every AA meeting end with the lords prayer?

And then wheel out the claim to not be religious?

Does this not seem strange to you?

No not strange just not accurate. The lords prayer is not said at every AA meeting, though I will agree it is said at some.
Who is saying AA is not religious, it is for some (very religious), for others spiritual and even others not either spiritual or religious.
Your trying to lump AA into one box.
 
Ah the "there's loads of evidence" you just go off and find it for me argument.

Well how else would you find it. I am speaking from over two decades of experience. This is how I gathered my evidence.
I just didn't grab the AA book off the book shelf and start reading it and then stumble upon a web site that was discussing the pros and cons of AA. Then begin to debate the topic out of a motivation that came from a long lost relative or friend that went to AA and didn't like it.
I am sincerely invested in this topic (not to say you are not) and I respond from a conviction that is based in rational thoughts about AA. These thoughts and beliefs came from daily interactions with fellow members, witnessing their daily struggles and watching them rebuild shattered lives, practicing the principles AA offers.
 
No not strange just not accurate. The lords prayer is not said at every AA meeting, though I will agree it is said at some.

Uh, probably a bit more than some, if by some you mean a plurality rather than a majority of meetings. And for those meetings it is not said I would wager that the serenity prayer fills the void. Or do you know of some meetings that do not use either of the two?
 
No not strange just not accurate. The lords prayer is not said at every AA meeting, though I will agree it is said at some.
Who is saying AA is not religious, it is for some (very religious), for others spiritual and even others not either spiritual or religious.
Your trying to lump AA into one box.

The Lord's Prayer was said at the end of every meeting I attended, and that's at least a thousand meetings.
 
See now you are getting closer to the truth, I have said "it works for me" (or similar), that I support AA and continue to attend. I have never said it is my preferred method for others.

And I never said that you did either. I said it was your preferred method.

You seem eager to stuff words into my mouth.

And if it is your preferred method you've spend two pages saying "I've said no such thing" Hardly rigorous honest there Alife.

Of course. But do they work?
Surely you wouldn't you recommend something if it doesn't work? Surely not. :eek:
This is potentially dangerous.

As is saying something like "the evidence is hundreds of thousands of atheists and agnostics are helped by AA, I Would Suggest"

I could say "tens of thousands of Atheists and Agnostics are helped via SMART recovery, at a guess"

And then try and claim I was making a educated guess based on the number of the users on the site, and comments on the web, but that would be a fantastically dishonest way of discussing the issue. So I won't.


Indeed.
But let's not forget it was you that brought these in, it was you.

Actually I'm fairly certain SMART recovery has been discussed on this thread before I came on board.



Great!
But I think we can handle both sets of info at the same time, don't you?

No. Sorry I don't. I think it would be much better to discuss the efficacy of AA before we start talking about the efficacy of alternatives. I think it'd confuse the issue.

So what have you got?

As I've been saying ad nausem for several pages now, I've made no claims as to the efficacy of the sites I mentioned since the start.

A.A. Ailfe You're the qualified forensic addiction councillor. You think the thread could benefit from the efficacy statistics of alternatives to AA.

If you want to bring them into the debate off you go.

Toodle Pip.
 
Well how else would you find it. I am speaking from over two decades of experience. This is how I gathered my evidence.
I just didn't grab the AA book off the book shelf and start reading it and then stumble upon a web site that was discussing the pros and cons of AA. Then begin to debate the topic out of a motivation that came from a long lost relative or friend that went to AA and didn't like it.

Wow. Transfer Much?

You've no idea if an the above narrative is anything to do with my experience with AA.

I am sincerely invested in this topic (not to say you are not) and I respond from a conviction that is based in rational thoughts about AA. These thoughts and beliefs came from daily interactions with fellow members, witnessing their daily struggles and watching them rebuild shattered lives, practicing the principles AA offers.

Which is great. Doesn't show me that there's hundreds of thousands of sober Agnostics and Atheists in AA.

It doesn't matter A.A. Alife cheerfully added a little qualifier to that statement, to avoid having to prove it.

Other hilarious ways that sentence could be use

The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

"Theres plenty of evidence that crack and heroin addicts remain addicted to their drugs, and remain productive members of society, I would suggest hundreds and thousands of them do."
 
http://www.thestar.com/news/article/1002750--fight-over-god-splits-toronto-aa-groups

On Tuesday, Toronto’s two secular AA groups, known as Beyond Belief and We Agnostics, were removed or “delisted” from the roster of local meetings. They’ve disappeared from the Toronto AA website and will not be in the next printed edition of the Toronto directory.
The dispute started when Beyond Belief posted an adapted version of AA’s hallowed “Twelve Steps” on the Toronto website. They removed the word “God” from the steps, which are used as a kind of road map to help drinkers achieve sobriety.
“They took issue with a public display of secular AA,” says Joe C., who founded Beyond Belief, Toronto’s first agnostic AA group, 18 months ago. (In keeping with AA’s tradition of anonymity, members are identified by first names only.)
It proved popular enough that a second group started up last fall; it took its name from a chapter in the AA bible entitled Alcoholics Anonymous, commonly known as the Big Book. The group, We Agnostics, had only recently completed the paperwork to be part of AA before being booted out.
“What is unusual is that this didn’t happen in some backwater, but that it happened in a liberal, democratic, pluralistic place like Toronto,” says Joe.
The name of God appears four times in the Twelve Steps and echoes the period in which they were written — the 1930s. It invites those seeking sobriety to turn themselves over to God, who will remove their “defects of character.” They go on to speak of God’s will for the recovering alcoholic.
“They (the altered Twelve Steps) are not our Twelve Steps,” says an AA member who was at Tuesday’s meeting of the coordinating body known as the Greater Toronto Area Intergroup. “They’ve changed them to their own personal needs. They should never have been listed in the first place.”
He says that in the early days of AA, meetings ended with the Lord’s Prayer. “That has obviously stopped in all but hard-core groups. We welcome people with open arms. In our group we still say the Lord’s Prayer. One guy was uncomfortable with that. I told him to just step back when we pray. He does. He’s doing what he needs to do for him.”
The issue of AA’s use of God has come up frequently over the past 50 years. For the most part, the organization — which claims 113,000 groups around the world — permits other agencies to imitate its program, but not to call themselves Alcoholics Anonymous.
Other secular organizations, including Save our Selves (or Secular Organizations for Sobriety), offer addiction help similar to AA. But with some 100,000 members in 2005, SOS is far less popular than AA, which reports a membership of about two million. In Toronto alone, there are 500 AA meetings a week.
“This is not the first we’ve gone up against bigotry,” says Larry of We Agnostics. “This has been an ongoing struggle in North America.”
 
Nothing wrong with booze, otherwise Jesus wouldn't have turned 120 gallons (repeat 120 gallons) of water to wine; and it was also served at the last supper where Jesus told his mates-"the next time we drink this, we'll drink it together in heaven".
That's me out then, I don't drink (sniffle).

As for drugs, the bible says we can use everything (animals and plants) for food and medicine.

Sadly of course the heavy boozers and out-of-control junkies abuse it get it a bad name..
 
Uh, probably a bit more than some, if by some you mean a plurality rather than a majority of meetings. And for those meetings it is not said I would wager that the serenity prayer fills the void. Or do you know of some meetings that do not use either of the two?

I can not argue your point with any authority because I really don't know. "My bad". The meetings I attended did not have prayers at all. This was purposely put into the by laws.
My wording of "some" denoted the wrong message, you are right Bamberger.
This also goes to you Ben. My apologies for accidentally misrepresenting my point.
 
And I never said that you did either. I said it was your preferred method.

So you are now saying that you were relating to me as an individual and my approach to recovery, rather than a professional approach for my clients?

I could say "tens of thousands of Atheists and Agnostics are helped via SMART recovery, at a guess"]/quote]

Yep. No problem, you are clearly stating and opinion (as was I). You might be called to explain, which I have.

Actually I'm fairly certain SMART recovery has been discussed on this thread before I came on board.

LOL. So someone else brought it up first a year ago.

Have you got some evidence on the efficacy of the recommended treatments or not?

No. Sorry I don't. I think it would be much better to discuss the efficacy of AA before we start talking about the efficacy of alternatives. I think it'd confuse the issue.

Others in this forum will cope, trust me on this; most of us are bright enough to manage.

As I've been saying ad nausem for several pages now, I've made no claims as to the efficacy of the sites I mentioned since the start.

True, but in the absense of evidence why, how would you recommend them? I could not for a moment think that you - someone who cares about the suffering alcoholic and their families, friend etc - would make potentially dangerous recommendations.

Tell me it isn't so.

A.A. Ailfe You're the qualified forensic addiction councillor. You think the thread could benefit from the efficacy statistics of alternatives to AA.

Sure. Where are they?

If you want to bring them into the debate off you go.

But it was you that brought them in, and it was you that gave an unqualified recommendation. Why? :boggled:
 
So you are now saying that you were relating to me as an individual and my approach to recovery, rather than a professional approach for my clients?

Did I give the impression that I was doing anything other than relating to you as a individual?

Speaking as to your "professional approach" to your "clients", any more thought as to giving us some evidence of your qualifications?



LOL. So someone else brought it up first a year ago.

Have you got some evidence on the efficacy of the recommended treatments or not?

I made no claim to their efficacy.

Others in this forum will cope, trust me on this; most of us are bright enough to manage.

Okay. I disagree. I think we should focus on the efficacy of AA before we look at other options.

True, but in the absense of evidence why, how would you recommend them? I could not for a moment think that you - someone who cares about the suffering alcoholic and their families, friend etc - would make potentially dangerous recommendations.

Tell me it isn't so.

As has been mentioned on this thread before alot of people of serious issues with AA, I suggested some secular alternatives.
 
Did I give the impression that I was doing anything other than relating to you as a individual?

You most certainly did:
This post (I have snipped the non relevant bits) was the one I objected to. The entire post is about treatments, not my recovery.

How do we know AA works?
How precisely do we know how AA works and it's efficacy.

Because I've read a reasonable amount on the variety of methods tried in SMART or Sinclair and they don't include piscan based violence.

They also don't include references to God, 75 year old manuals, dogma and the steps, hence why I recommended them.

You want me to find figures for Naltraxtone or Baclofen, or Sinclair, and shot them down by saying "well as you can see X project hasn't had a long term feasibility study"

However your preferred method of Addiction curing has no qualms about hiding it's "efficacy" so I'm not inclined to play with football match on a uneven playing field.

Whats the point about picking apart the efficacy of alternatives when AA does it's best to obfuscate it's own success rates.


Not a word about my personal journey in there and you want me to believe that is what you meant? Really? (my bold)

Speaking as to your "professional approach" to your "clients", any more thought as to giving us some evidence of your qualifications?

What for? You either believe me or you don't. I couldn't care less either way.

But why not tell me what your qualifications are and how that makes you some sort of expert that can make recommendations?

I made no claim to their efficacy.

So you keep saying. But I keep asking why you would make recommendations for something you actually have no idea about. It strikes me as both potentially dangerous and hypocritical.

Surely you don't make unqualified recommendations without some knowledge of their effectiveness. I assume you are not trained in the area of addiction, do you think lay people should be doing this?

Okay. I disagree. I think we should focus on the efficacy of AA before we look at other options.

You disagree to what? That the forum members here are unable to manage more than one online conversation at a time? Really? You think they are that stupid? Really? :jaw-dropp:boggled:

As has been mentioned on this thread before alot of people of serious issues with AA, I suggested some secular alternatives.

Indeed you did. And I would like to know why you would do such a thing unless you knew they worked? Do these secular alternatives work? How well? What sort of efficacy do they claim? What studies have been done?

Have you got this information or not?

Like I said, this strikes me as potentially dangerous and naive in the extreme.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom