A.A. Alfie, as an addictions professional, what modality do you recommend to your clients? This is a simple question to answer but you have been evasive with this. Why are you not forthcoming with this information? You seem very interested in efficacy, so what is the efficacy of your preferred method? I think if you have knowledge of something that really works, you should share that with the world instead of withholding this extremely valuable information. Please share it with us and share with us the efficacy.
You are asking for a one-size-fits-all response and to answer in such a manner would be ridiculous, unprofessional and potentially dangerous.
Some things I might consider at an assessment would include.
Is the person an alcoholic, alcohol dependent, a binge drinker, problem drinker, other?
Are there comorbidity issues? Cross addictions? Other mental health issues?
What are their social supports like, do they have dependants and what are their belief systems?
What is their financial situation, can they access time off work, do they have private health care?
What are their immediate and urgent needs with regard to health, housing and legal issues?
Is there brain impairment?
Where are they in the stages of change?
But most importantly, what is it they think will work for them? What do they want to do with their problem and where they want to take it? It would - for example - be pointless directing someone to abstinence type treatment if they wanted to continue drinking.
So at the risk of sounding evasive - which I am not; I am just stating fact - I have no preferred treatment type, it depends on the circumstances and the individual entirely, and often it will take some time (a few sessions at least) before a client makes or can make any decision, or me any recommendations.
I know that does not answer your question, however your question is not simple at all; it is impossible without a full assessment and taking into consideration a clients unique circumstances. That said, I do hope that I have at least given you some insight into the vaguaries around assessing clients as individuals prior to recommending anything.