Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You said that nobody is saying AA is not religious, and I'm pointing out to you an example of how this is patently false.
Indeed. I don't find AA religious. Some who use the program are theists or deists.

Hey, do ghosts of dead monks speak to you like they did Bill Wilson? And if so, is that a religious or a spiritual experience?
That is a hallucination. Perhaps that person needs help with a drinking problem.
 
You said that nobody is saying AA is not religious, and I'm pointing out to you an example of how this is patently false.

To me these words are the same thing, so I agree with what is written in the 'Big Book'. Regardless of what I believe about the terms, all one has to do is read the program or spend ten minutes at a meeting to determine it is religious.

Economists refer to the printing of new money out of thin air and putting into the money supply "monetary easing." Doctors call adult onset diabetes "type II diabetes." Retailers call fat clothes "plus sizes." It doesn't change what these things are. Calling AA "spiritual" is just a way to con people joining a program that is overtly religious.

If ouija boards actually worked, I would conjure george orwell's spirit. He would have a field day with this topic.
 
No. The primary purpose is discussed in the big book and AA litterature. That's AA as an organisation, and it is clearly religious in nature.

We were discussing the difference between the individual groups and the fact that their primary purpose is about sobriety. The unsupported assertion is the Central Office/organisation has a different primary purpose.

I have called for evidence as to what this so called other primary purpose is; so far we only have unqualified opinions.

To me these words are the same thing,

And this is the problem, others see them as quite separate and different things. I would suggest you will find it difficult to convince others they are the same when they are demonstrably not.

I agree with what is written in the 'Big Book'.

Great, try this one again:

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "
 
8den, the supporting evidence would be in the rooms of AA. Since you don't go and AA does not supply evidence of peoples personal faith this could only happen by you going to meetings.
So what do you say, you want to go to some meeting and commiserate with these hundred of thousands of agnostics and atheists. You won't be disappointed.
 
To me these words are the same thing ... Calling AA "spiritual" is just a way to con people joining a program that is overtly religious.

I don't see the "con." You walk in, there's signs with God all over them.

Many people do make a distinction between "spiritual" and "religious," but if you don't, whatever.
 
I am meandering through my (hard) copy of 'Treatment for Alcohol Problems" at work just now, looking for something unrelated for one of my clients and I came across this. The handbook is issued by our state government and is a very handy tool in many ways:

A common misconception concerning AA is that members need to be religious to benefit from the program. In a large-scale study, people involved with AA demonstrated improved outcomes whether or not they identified with a particular religious or spiritual belief system.

Bottom of page 109 under "Self help groups".

Two points:
People do not need religion and
They differentiate between religious and spiritual.

They also mention SMART recovery, sadly they are the only two self help groups we have here that are mentioned.

Back to my work, I need to figure out how to help this person with their drinking issues - AA is not the answer for him.

Maybe my friends might find the info they need on Sinclair, Naltrexone, et al in support of their high recommendations.

Cheers.
 
A.A. Alfie, as an addictions professional, what modality do you recommend to your clients? This is a simple question to answer but you have been evasive with this. Why are you not forthcoming with this information? You seem very interested in efficacy, so what is the efficacy of your preferred method? I think if you have knowledge of something that really works, you should share that with the world instead of withholding this extremely valuable information. Please share it with us and share with us the efficacy.
 
We were discussing the difference between the individual groups and the fact that their primary purpose is about sobriety. The unsupported assertion is the Central Office/organisation has a different primary purpose.

No, we were discussing the organization as a whole compared to parts of it. I know, I emphasized it.

I have called for evidence as to what this so called other primary purpose is; so far we only have unqualified opinions.

I don't know why you keep saying that. The AA litterature still in use should be sufficient evidence of AA's general objectives, no matter what the objectives of individual groups or individuals are. That was my point.
 
A.A. Alfie, as an addictions professional, what modality do you recommend to your clients? This is a simple question to answer but you have been evasive with this. Why are you not forthcoming with this information? You seem very interested in efficacy, so what is the efficacy of your preferred method? I think if you have knowledge of something that really works, you should share that with the world instead of withholding this extremely valuable information. Please share it with us and share with us the efficacy.

You are asking for a one-size-fits-all response and to answer in such a manner would be ridiculous, unprofessional and potentially dangerous.

Some things I might consider at an assessment would include.

Is the person an alcoholic, alcohol dependent, a binge drinker, problem drinker, other?
Are there comorbidity issues? Cross addictions? Other mental health issues?
What are their social supports like, do they have dependants and what are their belief systems?
What is their financial situation, can they access time off work, do they have private health care?
What are their immediate and urgent needs with regard to health, housing and legal issues?
Is there brain impairment?
Where are they in the stages of change?
But most importantly, what is it they think will work for them? What do they want to do with their problem and where they want to take it? It would - for example - be pointless directing someone to abstinence type treatment if they wanted to continue drinking.

So at the risk of sounding evasive - which I am not; I am just stating fact - I have no preferred treatment type, it depends on the circumstances and the individual entirely, and often it will take some time (a few sessions at least) before a client makes or can make any decision, or me any recommendations.

I know that does not answer your question, however your question is not simple at all; it is impossible without a full assessment and taking into consideration a clients unique circumstances. That said, I do hope that I have at least given you some insight into the vaguaries around assessing clients as individuals prior to recommending anything.
 
I know that does not answer your question, however your question is not simple at all; it is impossible without a full assessment and taking into consideration a clients unique circumstances. That said, I do hope that I have at least given you some insight into the vaguaries around assessing clients as individuals prior to recommending anything.

If anyone has $160 and a printer, they can get their counseling certificate here: Forensics Addictions Counselor.
 
A.A. Alfie, as an addictions professional, what modality do you recommend to your clients? This is a simple question to answer but you have been evasive with this. Why are you not forthcoming with this information? You seem very interested in efficacy, so what is the efficacy of your preferred method? I think if you have knowledge of something that really works, you should share that with the world instead of withholding this extremely valuable information. Please share it with us and share with us the efficacy.

I would think that this would be a very personal question to ask a professional in the addiction field. Alfie might make the mistake of being biased to one particular treatment plan if he elaborated on your question.
People need to be directed towards what best serves them and AA may not be the answer.
Just my opinion.
 
I would think that this would be a very personal question to ask a professional in the addiction field. Alfie might make the mistake of being biased to one particular treatment plan if he elaborated on your question.
People need to be directed towards what best serves them and AA may not be the answer.
Just my opinion.

Sure, but why does every AA meeting end with the lords prayer?

And then wheel out the claim to not be religious?

Does this not seem strange to you?
 
Like I said before, you put a lot of words in my mouth that I never said. And then you have the good grace to prove it for everyone too.
I thank you. ;)

There is a certain desperation, when shown reams of posts detailing your year long championing of AA, and then to announce triumphantly "Woa Woa woa, where exactly did I say specifically those words?"


They're secular alternatives to AA. [/.quote]

So you said, but do they work, and how do you know? :confused:

And I made no claim as to their efficacy just that they were secular alternatives to AA.

You're going round and round on this point.


The clearly stated words I have included there - as in " I would suggest" make this obvious to virtually anyone that this is simply my opinion. I simply base that on my experience and some simple maths; I would call it an educated guess, nothing more.
There is no "very specific claim" there at all, is there?

Lets look at what you said

The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

And you really think this is a credible way to conduct a argument?

Now where is the evidence for the efficacy of your recommended treatments? Do you have anything or not?

I made no claims about their efficacy. I'm not quite clear how many
times I can say this.
I made no attempt or
 
8den, the supporting evidence would be in the rooms of AA. Since you don't go and AA does not supply evidence of peoples personal faith this could only happen by you going to meetings.

Ah the "there's loads of evidence" you just go off and find it for me argument.
 
If anyone has $160 and a printer, they can get their counseling certificate here: Forensics Addictions Counselor.

Ad hom, much.
Could you please tell me with what qualifications you make your recommendations?

Once you have done that, perhaps you could finally provide the information on the efficacy of your recommendations for alcoholics. So far all you have provided is laughter.

Thanks in advance.
 
Sure, but why does every AA meeting end with the lords prayer?

Untrue.
I have never - and I stress never, been to an AA meeting that has uttered the Lord's prayer.

There is a certain desperation, when shown reams of posts detailing your year long championing of AA, and then to announce triumphantly "Woa Woa woa, where exactly did I say specifically those words?"

What is desperate is you trying to pin things on me I never actually said. You even quoted the big book at me as evidence of something I supposedly said, which I found hilarious by the way. :)

And I made no claim as to their efficacy just that they were secular alternatives to AA.

You "recommended" them, and I would still like to know why.

Do you not think it somewhat hypocritical to recommend something without being fully apprised of them or their treatment methods?
Do you think it not a ittle silly to recommend something to people yet have no idea whether or not it actually has a chance of working?
Frankly it is potentially dangerous.

Do you still stand by your recommendations? If so, why?

You're going round and round on this point.

Actually I'm simply following you.
Can you answer me or not? What are the efficacy results for these other treatments with regard to alcoholics?

I made no claims about their efficacy. I'm not quite clear how many times I can say this.

I am simply holding you to the same standards you wish to hold AA.
Can you answer me or not?

That's odd. I go to the website http://www.aa.org and I don't see the word God even one time.

Which meetings do you attend, and how long have you been sober?
 
Sure, but why does every AA meeting end with the lords prayer?

And then wheel out the claim to not be religious?

Does this not seem strange to you?

Yes. But when its very survival (revenue via literature sales) depends on a steady stream of new members this begins to make more sense. Court and doctor referrals would all but dry up if the organization got more honest about being a religion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom