Part 2 - I accidentally posted something I wasn't finished; can't get it back because thread is moderated. The point was just that the program was useful for me, did not offend me and AA itself did not compel me to go and that I don't understand why so much anger is directed at the program.
Let me help clarify the bolded part of your sentence above: The anger (or disagreement, plus a variety of feelings in-between) comes from several facts, which I will summarize as:
1. AA is presented/presents itself as a quit-drinking program. Combining my very extensive experience in AA - some of it at near the highest levels with access to material not available to the public or members themselves - with the research & experience of hundreds of others has led us to conclude that
AA is not a quit-anything program, certainly not
primarily a quit-drinking program.
It is a religion/spiritual gaining program who's side effect (one of several) is claimed to nearly assure anyone 'who thoroughly follows our path' of freedom from alcoholism. AA's
primary purpose (note specifically I am not referring to the 'groups primary purpose' as stated in the traditions) is for
members to gain a religious or spiritual life where they can be 'of maximum service to God and to other human beings'. At least the 2nd goal is generally considered good - however the first is
clearly religious,
strongly suggests (if not actually proves) the program is one of 'gaining religion/gaining a relationship with 'He who is our Father', becoming 'God-Conscious', etc. Quitting drinking is considered a side effect of
living the program.
2. What studies
have been done (including by AA itself - see my posts towards the beginning of this thread) seem to suggest that attendance at AA increases binge drinking and is no more effective than doing nothing - perhaps a 5% success rate (call it a 95% failure rate). More studies would be quite helpful, however AA actively does whatever it can to
prevent such studies.
3. The massive money-making scheme called 'treatment centers', as well as other for-profit 12 step based businesses, collect 100's of millions if not billions of dollars that could be used to research & deploy actual drinking cessation programs that work. The program and associated business's take scarce funds from a limited pool of money, assuring that these funds are unavailable for
actual medical use.
4. AA meets many of the definitions of a
cult, if not all of the definitions commonly used. In our view, cults are
not good things. For a well researched view of how AA meets every definition of a Cult, see the following link:
http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-cult.html
There are many other reasons for my disagreement with the AA approach, but those are a good start to give you some idea of what we disagree with.