Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh my Dog ... the rants against AA never cease to amaze me. I've been to a few hundred meetings, and no one ever tried to coerce me into believing anything. The fact that courts order people to go to AA does not mean AA itself orders anyone to go. The issues are unrelated. If your beef is with the court system, take on the court system. Better yet, contrive to avoid circumstances that get you into the court system to begin with.

Perhaps you can go back in this thread and read the links to AA's instruction manuals on working with the court systems. AA does indeed troll for new recruits in the courts. Most new members are suckered in this way. It's AA's life blood.
 
Oh, and part 3. My dad did die that night. In the morning I found myself flushing his morphine down the toilet, arguably a miracle in itself.

Despite its Oxford Movement roots, the religion I associate most with AA is not Christianity - it's Islam. A wonderfully idiosyncratic Islam.

The anger I'm seeing on this thread mostly comes from posters who think that AA, with its emphasis on God, harmed or at least failed to help people they loved. There are judgmental, dogmatic people in AA; however I find them to be in the minority. No one should abuse the trust of a vulnerable person who comes to them for help. I don't doubt that has happened. It's wrong.

Attacking AA because it supposedly purports to be secular is what I'd call a straw-man argument, in that I've never thought it purported to be secular. Look at the walls, the word "God" is all over the place. Prayer is practiced, freely alluded to and frankly encouraged. Some people may be turned off by the God bit but it's not like AA tries to keep it a secret. What I do think Bill Wilson and the others did is try to keep the concept of God as generic as possible. If it really, really turns you off, don't go. Or, if you are sentenced to go, either wear earplugs or enjoy the meeting for its entertainment or educational value. Or, a third option, just as an exercise in (spiritual? mental?) discipline, try focusing on what you might have in common with whoever is speaking instead of what's different. Or, if all else fails, remind yourself it's punishment, you're not supposed to like it.

I would have been turned off by something overtly Christian. Even though the Lord's Prayer is in the Gospels, it doesn't strike me as particularly Christian. It doesn't invoke Jesus as Savior, for example. I usually say it facing east. Tongue in cheek, hedging my bets, whatever.
 
Part 2 - I accidentally posted something I wasn't finished; can't get it back because thread is moderated. The point was just that the program was useful for me, did not offend me and AA itself did not compel me to go and that I don't understand why so much anger is directed at the program.



Let me help clarify the bolded part of your sentence above: The anger (or disagreement, plus a variety of feelings in-between) comes from several facts, which I will summarize as:

1. AA is presented/presents itself as a quit-drinking program. Combining my very extensive experience in AA - some of it at near the highest levels with access to material not available to the public or members themselves - with the research & experience of hundreds of others has led us to conclude that AA is not a quit-anything program, certainly not primarily a quit-drinking program. It is a religion/spiritual gaining program who's side effect (one of several) is claimed to nearly assure anyone 'who thoroughly follows our path' of freedom from alcoholism. AA's primary purpose (note specifically I am not referring to the 'groups primary purpose' as stated in the traditions) is for members to gain a religious or spiritual life where they can be 'of maximum service to God and to other human beings'. At least the 2nd goal is generally considered good - however the first is clearly religious, strongly suggests (if not actually proves) the program is one of 'gaining religion/gaining a relationship with 'He who is our Father', becoming 'God-Conscious', etc. Quitting drinking is considered a side effect of living the program.
2. What studies have been done (including by AA itself - see my posts towards the beginning of this thread) seem to suggest that attendance at AA increases binge drinking and is no more effective than doing nothing - perhaps a 5% success rate (call it a 95% failure rate). More studies would be quite helpful, however AA actively does whatever it can to prevent such studies.
3. The massive money-making scheme called 'treatment centers', as well as other for-profit 12 step based businesses, collect 100's of millions if not billions of dollars that could be used to research & deploy actual drinking cessation programs that work. The program and associated business's take scarce funds from a limited pool of money, assuring that these funds are unavailable for actual medical use.
4. AA meets many of the definitions of a cult, if not all of the definitions commonly used. In our view, cults are not good things. For a well researched view of how AA meets every definition of a Cult, see the following link: http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-cult.html

There are many other reasons for my disagreement with the AA approach, but those are a good start to give you some idea of what we disagree with.
 
Oh, and part 3. My dad did die that night.
My condolences on your father's death.
In the morning I found myself flushing his morphine down the toilet, arguably a miracle in itself.
If you can successfully argue how that's a miracle, "you're in the right place." One aspect of this site is James Randi's Million Dollar Challenge, and if you can show that a practicing alcoholic and/or drug addict throwing away alcohol or drugs is a miracle (check the Challenge FAQ for the exact wording), you can win a million dollars. Click on the "$1 MILLION PARANORMAL CHALLENGE" right in the middle of the thin red line at the very top of this webpage.
 
AA's primary purpose (note specifically I am not referring to the 'groups primary purpose' as stated in the traditions)

This is an important point that has not been sufficiently emphasized in this thread: Distinguishing AA as an organisation from individual groups or members.
 
The anger I'm seeing on this thread mostly comes from posters who think that AA, with its emphasis on God, harmed or at least failed to help people they loved. There are judgmental, dogmatic people in AA; however I find them to be in the minority. No one should abuse the trust of a vulnerable person who comes to them for help. I don't doubt that has happened. It's wrong.

A couple of points on this. The term "anger" is not really accepted as a pejorative outside of AA, where it is used as such. AA's seem use this term about anyone who questions the program, but it doesn't really have the same impact on those who don't understand the subtext.

The judgmental and dogmatic people in AA are the minority, simply because most people leave AA as soon as they see it for what it is. Most of AA is "new people". But it is most definitely the vast majority of those who stick around and become sponsors and old-timers and such.

As for the abuse, it's not that it happens. It's that it happens and is swept under the rug and ignored. There is no accountablility like there is in the real world. "You just keep your side of the street clean," or, "don't keep another person's inventory." That type of thing. Abusers of all stripes thrive in this environment.
 
How about this:

"Both you and the new man must walk day by day in the path of spiritual progress. If you persist, remarkable things will happen. When we look back, we realize that the things which came to us when we put ourselves in God’s hands were better than anything we could have planned. Follow the dictates of a Higher Power and you will presently live in a new and wonderful world, no matter what your present circumstances!" BB pg. 100

That sure looks like a monotheistic God is being touted to me.

What am I missing?

What you are missing is what AA offers. You are just insistent on making your point that any other is irrelevant.
AA does offer this monotheistic God if this is what you want. As you have said countless times God is mentioned and references to God are there to interpret. AA leaves these matters to the individual.
 
A.A. Alfie.
You said;

Where did I say AA was my preferred method? You and Jack put a lot of words and claims in my mouth that I never uttered.
You've also said;




To the OP (et al).

I can only comment on AA meetings I have attended here and abroad and cannot therefor speak of the groups in (say) the US.
I have been clean and sober now for 10 years and work as a forensic counsellor in AOD as well as other areas.
AA forms the basis for the maintenance of my sobriey and I feel I can discuss this with some level of authority. So much for credentials.


Keep coming back - it will get better and easier.

The "belief" in a higher power is part of the step work that allow us to stop being perfect, to cease trying to control the things we cannot, and/or to accept that we are powerless over alcohol (or our addiction, in whatever form it takes) when we take the first drink.
It is part of the necessary ego deflation that so many of us desperately need.

You are correct that the word God is used time and again, however you seem to ignore the fact that as early as step three, it is clearly expressed in the terms "as we understood Him". This is the common theme relating to God, or a higher power. Those that wrote the steps outline that that is their preferred term for their higher power - if one doesn't like the term they can use something (or nothing else). No one cares, I'm surprised you do.
Remember also that these steps were created some 75 years ago and the language of the day was slightly different.

You call it BS, I call it life saving (and I consider myself agnostic) and I have seen hundreds (thousands probably) that have recovered using 12 step principles.


:biggrin:

I found my wife in AA - but I would hardly consider myself a predator.

No problem here: clearly AA does work for many or there would be no AA. For many it has been AA or death (myself included) - and I have buried hundreds. I prefer to live.

AA is a benign fellowship that promotes healthy behaviours, if some consider spirituality unhealthy, that's just too bad.

I consider myself agnostic and unreligious, yet see no problem with having a spiritual side.

For some that try AA, it sticks and works. Not so for others. But AA can work if you put in some effort.

I assume you are pointing to the 'G' word.

I made it simple for myself: Everytime the 'G' word was mentioned, in my mind, I followed with "as we understood Him/It".

"As we understood Him" is clearly expressed in step three.

The word cured is an interesting one. Where I live (I can't speak for elsewhere), the vast majority of us do not believe we are cured. We are given a daily reprieve from the disease. Through fellowship and personal growth we remain sober.
If one has a 'bust' or relapse it is usually a very short time (if not immediately) that the alcoholic returns right back to where they previously were.
I proved this to myself some years ago: After a period of abstinence, I stopped AA meetings and at a work function I had three "social drinks". On the way home I brought a slab of beer and a bottle of scotch to celebrate my newfound success in my ability to drink responsibly. They were both gone by morning. It took me to deaths door again (literally), I found myself in hospital after my body broke down - I was 35. I went into rehab afterwards and then commiitted myself to recovery.


In that sense, it works and religion has nothing to do with recovery.
Can I prove it? Not really, but I don't need to: the thousands that I personally know that get assistance from one another are proof enough for me.


If you're going to be so disingenuous, as to have said all of the above, and plenty more, and a year advocating and defending AA, and then claim

Where did I say AA is my preferred method

Then yes I am going to point out the part of AA, (y'know the program that you say has provided the maintenance of your sobriety) that says

[FONT=Arial, Arial, Helvetica] Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.
[/FONT]

Simply because you've never written the words the exact sentence "AA is my preferred method" does not discount the years worth of posting on this thread.
 
This is an important point that has not been sufficiently emphasized in this thread: Distinguishing AA as an organisation from individual groups or members.

This is where I was heading with the efficacy issue. The case can be made I believe that AA exists primarily for the purpose of one's finding a God of their understanding. Sobriety becomes more than mere abstinence when the God benchmark is applied. Much, much more.
 
Yep.
As I say you make unqualified and unsupported recommendations to alternative treatments without having a clue as to whether they work or not.

So? I linked to two pages.

Even without the references to god or spirituality, what makes them worthy of your high recommendations?
They're secular alternatives to AA.

Please provide efficacy results for your recommended treatments. They are not anonymous are they? Therefore it should be a fairly simple matter to obtain them, shouldn't it?
Off you go so. I'm not your monkey. You're not the organ grinder.

I recommended them as they were secular alternatives to AA. I gave a list of reasons why people might not like AA.

They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives.
Indeed you did. Now why would you recommend them unless they work? Do they work? How do you know? What are the efficacy rates for alcoholics?
Again my reasoning

[QUOTEThey might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives. QUOTE]


Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread. Please don't bring arguments from other websites.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How about this:

"Both you and the new man must walk day by day in the path of spiritual progress. If you persist, remarkable things will happen. When we look back, we realize that the things which came to us when we put ourselves in God’s hands were better than anything we could have planned. Follow the dictates of a Higher Power and you will presently live in a new and wonderful world, no matter what your present circumstances!" BB pg. 100

That sure looks like a monotheistic God is being touted to me.

What am I missing?

The fact that spirituality and religious are different.
The fact that it is a God of your understanding (and redundant repetition is ... well, redundant)
The fact that Bill explains this in the agnostics chapter, specifically:

From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

These are some of the things you mssed. ;)

Perhaps you can go back in this thread and read the links to AA's instruction manuals on working with the court systems. AA does indeed troll for new recruits in the courts. Most new members are suckered in this way. It's AA's life blood.

Your problem is with the court systems, not AA.

Jack, I'm still waiting oin the efficacy results for Sincalir and naltrexone for alcoholics. Any chance of anything soon?

This is an important point that has not been sufficiently emphasized in this thread: Distinguishing AA as an organisation from individual groups or members.

Yep. So what is their primary purpose and where is it outlined? Oh that's right, Tinyal said so. :boggled:
 
The moderator just rejected my rant - evidence that a Higher Power is working in my life ;)

On topic: "Why do people insist AA is not religious." Answer: they don't.

On topic: "The efficacy of AA." Nothing works against alcoholism without sufficient motivation. If you have motivation, AA is usually the most affordable and readily available community resource. Pick up its tools or don't, it's up to the individual.
 
Oh and A.A. Alfie while you jump up and down and insist I provide efficacy statistics you've made a very specific claim

A.A. Alife said:
Nonsense. The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

Please provide supporting evidence.
 
The fact that spirituality and religious are different.
The fact that it is a God of your understanding (and redundant repetition is ... well, redundant)
The fact that Bill explains this in the agnostics chapter, specifically:

From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

These are some of the things you mssed. ;)

I think you need to look at the big picture here. Have you read "AA Comes of Age"? That book provides an historical account of why Wilson tempered his speech in the big book regarding the religious nature of AA. An objective observer would readily see why AA is religious, not only because of the use of the word "God" hundreds of times in the basic literature, but also by reading "AA Comes of Age". It's there in B&W.

Add to this the common practices found in most AA meetings. These involve prayer - typically the Lord's Prayer or the Serenity Prayer, both of which have roots in Christianity. Additionally, the AA 12 steps resemble the redemptive path found in some Gospel stories, and most of them involve "God". A catholic might see similarities with some of their sacraments (e.g. confession, confirmation).

What's not religious about all that?
 
You said;

You've also said;

Simply because you've never written the words the exact sentence "AA is my preferred method" does not discount the years worth of posting on this thread.

Like I said before, you put a lot of words in my mouth that I never said. And then you have the good grace to prove it for everyone too.
I thank you. ;)

This is where I was heading with the efficacy issue. The case can be made I believe that AA exists primarily for the purpose of one's finding a God of their understanding. Sobriety becomes more than mere abstinence when the God benchmark is applied. Much, much more.

You keep making these assertions, they appear to be your opinion only and I am happy for you to have them, but in the absence of evidence of anything they mean very little. :)

So? I linked to two pages.

Yes and I was very entertained. ROFL actually. :D

They're secular alternatives to AA. [/.quote]

So you said, but do they work, and how do you know? :confused:
 
The moderator just rejected my rant - evidence that a Higher Power is working in my life ;)

I would not have been offended in the least. These "serenity rants" are common when someone puts someone in AA out of their comfort zone and into a double bind. This is real psychological dilemma. There are two ways to react when someone points out the reality which you have been conditioned to believe is simply false. Acceptance of it is one, but that is difficult. The normal reaction is anger and denial (and rationalization is a form of denial). It happens with any religion when someone is shown evidence that is contradictory to their beliefs. You should see my (fundamentalist Christian) family's heads explode when we discuss evolution.

So don't get angry when I point this out:

On topic: "Why do people insist AA is not religious." Answer: they don't..[/QUOTE]

Of course they do. One example is Hazelden, by far the biggest purchaser and distributor of all AA literature and promoter of 12-step dogma, who wrote this: Twelve Steps are Spiritual Principles, Not Religious. Google "spiritual not religious," and you'll get thousands of pages of AA denial on this. You could also read the denials throughout this thread. Maybe you could ask this question in any meeting, because you'll get the same answer.

One way to deny the obvious is for steppers to mind-bend us into believing that there is a difference in AA between religion and spirituality, when their very scripture says differently. They're exactly the same thing, of course. From the 'Big Book':

"The terms “spiritual experience” and “spiritual awakening” are used many times in this book which, upon careful reading, shows that the personality change sufficient to bring about recovery from alcoholism has manifested itself among us in many different forms.

Yet it is true that our first printing gave many readers the impression that these personality changes, or religious experiences, must be in the nature of sudden and spectacular upheavals. Happily for everyone, this conclusion is erroneous."


The "spiritual not religious" nonsense is just part of the bait and switch con game. Repeating is a result of gaslighting one receives in AA, and which we have in kind received from the AAs in this thread. Telling us nobody says AA is not religious is an example of this gaslighting. What you will get here, is someone pointing out the obvious lie, so gaslighting doesn't work here. In AA, one will be shut down by pointing out the contradictions, and the lies simply get repeated until those who stick around really believe it.
 
On topic: "The efficacy of AA." Nothing works against alcoholism without sufficient motivation. If you have motivation, AA is usually the most affordable and readily available community resource. Pick up its tools or don't, it's up to the individual.

QFT

Oh and A.A. Alfie while you jump up and down and insist I provide efficacy statistics you've made a very specific claim

The clearly stated words I have included there - as in " I would suggest" make this obvious to virtually anyone that this is simply my opinion. I simply base that on my experience and some simple maths; I would call it an educated guess, nothing more.
There is no "very specific claim" there at all, is there? :)

Now where is the evidence for the efficacy of your recommended treatments? Do you have anything or not?

I think you need to look at the big picture here. Have you read "AA Comes of Age"? That book provides an historical account of why Wilson tempered his speech in the big book regarding the religious nature of AA.

How and where exactly?

What's not religious about all that?

No religion nor god is required. Duh! :boggled:
 
Yep. So what is their primary purpose and where is it outlined? Oh that's right, Tinyal said so. :boggled:

No. The primary purpose is discussed in the big book and AA litterature. That's AA as an organisation, and it is clearly religious in nature.

AA as individual groups and people, as discussed ad nauseam in this thread, varies from one place to the next, but how they deal with members seems greatly influenced by religious beliefs. "You need to find god to get sober" should be discouraged, as this is not (supposedly) the point of AA.

So although _some_ members are not religious, it doesn't change the conclusion about AA as an organisation, and AA members as a whole.
 
Are the word interchangeable to you either in connotation or denotation?

You said that nobody is saying AA is not religious, and I'm pointing out to you an example of how this is patently false.

To me these words are the same thing, so I agree with what is written in the 'Big Book'. Regardless of what I believe about the terms, all one has to do is read the program or spend ten minutes at a meeting to determine it is religious.

Economists refer to the printing of new money out of thin air and putting into the money supply "monetary easing." Doctors call adult onset diabetes "type II diabetes." Retailers call fat clothes "plus sizes." It doesn't change what these things are. Calling AA "spiritual" is just a way to con people joining a program that is overtly religious. It's also a flat-out wacky religion, even by religious standards.

Hey, do ghosts of dead monks speak to you like they did Bill Wilson? And if so, is that a religious or a spiritual experience?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom