Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Am I correct in saying you are not willing ever to discuss your own claims with me?
They are your claims mate, you get to clarify and support. You are failing. Not only that, you steadfastly refuse to hold yourself to your own standards, the very ones you demand of AA.

I made no claims A.A. Alfie I merely suggested some alternatives to A.A.

No. I simply want to know why you would recommend them in front of other treatments.

Other treatments like.....

That said, it sounds like your recommendations have holes even before you present your proof.

That might be your opinion.

Are your recommendations worth anything? Why would you recommend them unless you knew they worked?

Why do you recommend A.A. to people, can you show it works?

Who said AA was my preferred method? You and Jack put a lot of words and claims in my mouth that I never uttered.

Thats a profoundly dishonest statement, for well over a year now you've been arguing a profoundly pro AA message.

I am happy to support or explain any claims I make - just show me where I made them first ok?

Start on your first post here and work on back.

Are you prepared to do the same?

Am I prepared to do the same as what? lets remember what I said?

They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives.

Neither you nor Jack can support your recommendations. Very telling.

It's not "can't" It's indifference to getting into that argument with you.

Indeed it is, so why would you make off topic recommendations about other treatments and then be unable to support them?

Because I was referring to a quote from AlBell.

The point is that you have made unreserved, unqualified claims about other treatments; you brought these into play no-one else. It was you who made recommendations, no-one else.

I think these treatments have been mentioned already on this thread before I brought them up.

Can you or can you not support your recommendations with efficacy rates for alcoholics or not?

Again I never said I was going to.

Hang on: You said it wasn't in the literature. This is untrue and proved above. You are moving goalposts and dodging.

There are lots of meetings worldwide that do not say the Lords prayer, do not care for religion and do not mention this monotheistic god you speak insist upon. The meeting through its' group conscience determine what they do in that meeting, that might make that meeting (somewhat) religious, but not AA as a whole.
/quote]

Source?
 
A.A. Alfie, your claim as to the efficacy of AA is implied in your name; A.A. Alfie.

Your claim as to the efficacy of AA is implied in your year long defense of AA in this thread. I’m sure you wouldn’t defend it unless you thought it was effective, or would you?

Your claim as to the efficacy of AA is implied in your attacks on alternatives and your personal attacks on those who mention that they even exist. Why would you attack alternatives without even looking at them, unless you feel your way is, has been and always will be superior? Please explain why you won’t even acknowledge that this information has been provided to you repeatedly. You have demonstrated a total lack of knowledge about CBT by stating that AA can provide it, when in fact, they aren’t even remotely similar. As an addictions professional, why don’t you know what CBT actually is and how it works?

As an addictions professional, do you ever recommend AA? Why? What studies can you provide that show an efficacy beyond that of spontaneous remission? As an addictions professional, the onus of proof is on you, not others. Why do you keep dodging the question of AA’s efficacy? This thread’s title has recently been changed to include “The efficacy of AA.” It’s beyond time for you to answer this question openly and honestly.
Beyond anecdotal evidence, what definitive, irrefutable evidence do you have that proves AA works? It has been in existence for 75 years, surely there’s something you can point to.


As for the God question, you can go to the recovery emporium website and the concordances on the right side of the page for both the big book and 12x12 will tell you exactly how many times the word God is used in each book.

In the big book:

GOD.......................300
GOD'......................1 (don’t know what this one is referring to)
GOD'S.....................23
GOD-CONSCIOUS.............1
GOD-CONSCIOUSNESS.........3
GOD-GIVEN.................1
GOD-GUIDED................1
GOD-SUFFICIENCY...........1
GOD-THING.................1
GODLY.....................1
GODS......................1

In the Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions the word God appears:

GOD...................142
GOD'S.................29
GOD-GIVEN.............2

That’s 507 times. That’s a lot to be claiming it’s not religious. The word pray is used frequently as well.

In the big book:
PRAY......................12
PRAYED....................9
PRAYER....................28
PRAYING...................4


In the 12x12
PRAY..................5
PRAYER................38
PRAYERS...............1
PRAYING...............2

That’s a total of 99 times.

Albell, I have attended numerous closed meetings and have found the dogma to be exactly the same as in the open meetings. Since I’ll be unable to attend your favorite closed meetings, what exactly is the esoteric knowledge that one would find there? Why would this special knowledge not be shared with the open meetings if the members truly wanted to help suffering alcoholics?

My last question is: what proof do you have that there are hundreds of thousands of agnostics and atheists in AA?
 
Great, now what do you actually thinbk they say? Are they effective in treating alcoholism? What are the success rates?

What do you think of this line in the opening of your first link?

Although all found benefits from naltrexone with the coping therapy, none of them found any significant benefit of naltrexone over placebo when combined with support for abstinence

So, nothing in terms of ongoing treatement and effectiveness. In my observations the problem is that most alcoholics do relapse, detox alone rarely works.

You obviously didn't read or understand the this. "Coping Therapy" is referencing CBT; "support for abstinence" is referencing AA or TSF. What the study determined was support groups provided zero benefit. But CBT actually does. I can't educate on this stuff, and you shouldn't comment on these things if you don't understand it. It doesn't look good on you. Really.

As for the link to the kleptomania study, that was inadvertent. It was supposed be a Naltrexone study on alcohol addiction from the same journal. But since you won't even read these things, I'm not humoring you any more. You asked for citations, I gave them to you. You didn't read them or understand them, because the answers to your follow-up questions are contained in the studies.
 
A.A Alfie said:
Who said AA was my preferred method? You and Jack put a lot of words and claims in my mouth that I never uttered.

I can't think why but this springs to mind.

[FONT=Arial, Arial, Helvetica]Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.[/FONT]
 
I made no claims A.A. Alfie I merely suggested some alternatives to A.A.

Here is what you said:

For anyone reading this thread and having trouble with alcohol addiction I'd recommend

http://www.smartrecovery.org/
http://www.mywayout.org/

and the blogroll on the side of the page of stinkin thinkin has a list of alternatives available

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/

Why do you recommend them to people having trouble with alcohol addiction? What are the efficacy rates? If I was to make an unqualified unsupportable recommendation for AA like you did, you would justifiably demand proof. I am asking the same of you.

It's time to stump up mate.

And can you explain why ST recommends their list?

Your claim as to the efficacy of AA is implied in your attacks on alternatives and your personal attacks on those who mention that they even exist.

Any objections I have on alternatives are based on the lack of evidence provided. Evidence which seems strangely elusively to those who make their recommendations.

As to "implied", what I am doing here is ensuring that the many lies and misunderstandings about AA are not spread further; I do not believe I have made any claims one way or the other on AAs overall efficacy.

You named yourself "AA Alfie" for Christ's sake.

You wouldn't believe it even if I told you. But I was named 'A A Alfie' by some mates long before I was in alcohol recovery: Think Derek and Clive.

You obviously didn't read or understand the this. "Coping Therapy" is referencing CBT; "support for abstinence" is referencing AA or TSF.

So what are the efficacy rates for the treatment(s) for alcoholism? That was and remains the unanswered question. Can you provide this information or not? Surely the efficacy of these treatments are the cornerstone of your recommendations? :confused:

As for the link to the kleptomania study, that was inadvertent.

LOL. Was the link to the "spiritual site" inadvertent too? :D

It was supposed be a Naltrexone study on alcohol addiction from the same journal.

Let's have it then.

But since you won't even read these things, I'm not humoring you any more. You asked for citations, I gave them to you.

Incorrect, I asked for efficacy. You have yet to provide anything to support your claims and recommendations in this regard.
And obviously I read them, if not I would be unable to LOL at the so called evidence you have provided. :D
 
Here is what you said:

Yes thats right

8den said:
For anyone reading this thread and having trouble with alcohol addiction I'd recommend

http://www.smartrecovery.org/
http://www.mywayout.org/

and the blogroll on the side of the page of stinkin thinkin has a list of alternatives available

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/

And here's what I said it in response to

Al Bell said:
I'd say science is at the stage of blind men examining an elephant re alcoholism.

It's seems a witches brew of pscho-dynamic interplays, perhaps at times coupled with possible physical maladies.

And Bill W and AA noted the behaviors are what needs fixing. On a case by case basis one can argue about the relative roles of symptoms that can be ameliorated by various pscho-active medicines vs the the problems related to drinking alcoholically. AA worries about the latter.

I respond for, in particular, untreated alcoholics who may have the misfortune to be reading the mish-mash we now have here.

Al Bell was making a clear plea for people to attend AA, I was making a counter claim to explore alternatives.

Al Bell doesn't seem the need to back up his claims about AA, and it's efficacy, so why should I about the alternatives?

And A.A. Alfie remember why I recommended the alternatives?



Why do you recommend them to people having trouble with alcohol addiction? What are the efficacy rates? If I was to make an unqualified unsupportable recommendation for AA like you did, you would justifiably demand proof. I am asking the same of you.

It's time to stump up mate.

And once again you ignore the reasoning for my suggestion.

They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives.

So you see Al Bell recommended AA, I recommended some alternatives.

Yo admitted that I never said they were more effective than AA, but you're still demanding efficacy statistics from me.

And can you explain why ST recommends their list?

Perhaps you should ask stinkin thinkin, though I imagine that would be difficult for you.

Any objections I have on alternatives are based on the lack of evidence provided. Evidence which seems strangely elusively to those who make their recommendations.

I'm sorry. What? Alternatives? "Alternatives" Hang on didn't you just say

Who said AA was my preferred method?

Now you're describing other treatment methods as "alternatives".

As to "implied", what I am doing here is ensuring that the many lies and misunderstandings about AA are not spread further; I do not believe I have made any claims one way or the other on AAs overall efficacy.

Em Lets see post 4791

A Al Ailfe said:
Nonsense. The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

You claimed hundreds and thousands of agnostics and atheists stay sober because of AA.
 
And A.A. Alfie remember why I recommended the alternatives?

Yep.
As I say you make unqualified and unsupported recommendations to alternative treatments without having a clue as to whether they work or not.

This strikes me not only as potentially dangerous but ignorant in the extreme.

Even without the references to god or spirituality, what makes them worthy of your high recommendations?

Please provide efficacy results for your recommended treatments. They are not anonymous are they? Therefore it should be a fairly simple matter to obtain them, shouldn't it?

And once again you ignore the reasoning for my suggestion.

Not at all. I question the validity and logic of your reasoning. not to mention the fact that you fall well short of your own standards of evidence.

So you see Al Bell recommended AA, I recommended some alternatives.

Indeed you did. Now why would you recommend them unless they work? Do they work? How do you know? What are the efficacy rates for alcoholics?

Yo admitted that I never said they were more effective than AA, but you're still demanding efficacy statistics from me.

I most certainly am.

Perhaps you should ask stinkin thinkin, though I imagine that would be difficult for you.

I asked the people there many many times. They had no answers either and refused to respond to me .
Edited by LashL: 
Moderated thread

I no longer post there and ask questions, I know when I am banging my head against a brick wall.

I'm sorry. What? Alternatives? "Alternatives" Hang on didn't you just say

And... yes....? Just what is it that you think I said?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've shied away from the efficacy discussion so far because my experience is that recovery rates for AA have not been sufficiently studied in a scientific way as to draw a definite conclusion. I'd like however to explore the term "efficacy" from other perspectives.

My belief, based on my reading of AA literature, is that AA's secondary purpose is to help the alcoholic find a God of their understanding, specifically a monotheistic God as found in the traditional major religions. So it follows, in my mind, that efficacy studies of AA should also focus on the program's success regarding its members attaining a belief in a God of their understanding.

An additional efficacy study could measure morals. Steps 4 - 10 pretty much deal with one's moral conduct before entering AA and how one betters their morals through the use of prayer to a God of their understanding. It would therefore be interesting to do studies that measure for instance the rate of recidivism of convicts who integrate AA into their lives.

Comments are welcome.
 
I've shied away from the efficacy discussion so far because my experience is that recovery rates for AA have not been sufficiently studied in a scientific way as to draw a definite conclusion. I'd like however to explore the term "efficacy" from other perspectives.

My belief, based on my reading of AA literature, is that AA's secondary purpose is to help the alcoholic find a God of their understanding, specifically a monotheistic God as found in the traditional major religions. So it follows, in my mind, that efficacy studies of AA should also focus on the program's success regarding its members attaining a belief in a God of their understanding.
Actually, that is the PRIMARY purpose of AA. The AA belief is that an alcoholic CANNOT stop drinking AND STAY STOPPED without finding God. The following quotes should adequately demonstrate this:

This is the lasr paragraph of Chapter 3 of the Big Book:
http://www.aa.org/bigbookonline/en_bigbook_chapt3.pdf
Once more: THe alcoholic at certain times has no
effective mental defense against the first drink. Except
in a few rare cases, neither he nor any other
human being can provide such a defense. His defense
must come from a Higher Power.

This is reiterated in first few pages of Chapter 5 that are read in virtually all AA meetings:
http://www.aa.org/bigbookonline/en_bigbook_chapt5.pdf
...
(a) That we were alcoholic and could not manage our own lives.
(b) That probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism.
(c) That God could and would if He were sought.
 
I've shied away from the efficacy discussion so far because my experience is that recovery rates for AA have not been sufficiently studied in a scientific way as to draw a definite conclusion. I'd like however to explore the term "efficacy" from other perspectives.

Which is true for virtually every treatment.

My belief, based on my reading of AA literature, is that AA's secondary purpose is to help the alcoholic find a God of their understanding, specifically a monotheistic God as found in the traditional major religions.

This belief of yours would be incorrect and you have been shown why. That said; given the language of the day and the author, the oft repeated point that it is a God of your understanding, and bearing in mind redundant repetition on "as we understood him" is unnecessary: what evidence do you have that makes you believe AAs secondary purpose is a monotheistic God?

So it follows, in my mind, that efficacy studies of AA should also focus on the program's success regarding its members attaining a belief in a God of their understanding.

Given that each AA group has only one purpose which is to help (or carry the message to) the suffering alcoholic, I find it hard to follow your line of thinking here to be honest.

That aside what have you got along these lines?

An additional efficacy study could measure morals. Steps 4 - 10 pretty much deal with one's moral conduct before entering AA and how one betters their morals through the use of prayer to a God of their understanding. It would therefore be interesting to do studies that measure for instance the rate of recidivism of convicts who integrate AA into their lives.

What have you got? Or are you JAQing off?

To be honest, I do not think that sending convicts (is that the correct word to use?) should be sent in the first instance. Your (The US) government is abdicating its responsibility to both punishment and/or rehabilitation for the public and individual via this line of action.

Again, what information do you have?

Comments are welcome.

I assume questions to you are acceptable as well as comments? So...
What evidence have you got that AAs secondary purpose is a monotheistic God? This is merely your belief, and to be honest, so far what you believe AA to be has been gravely mistaken.

How often and how many meetings have you actually attended?
How long have you been sober in AA?
 
I've shied away from the efficacy discussion so far because my experience is that recovery rates for AA have not been sufficiently studied in a scientific way as to draw a definite conclusion. I'd like however to explore the term "efficacy" from other perspectives.

This has probably been a good idea on your part.
My belief, based on my reading of AA literature, is that AA's secondary purpose is to help the alcoholic find a God of their understanding, specifically a monotheistic God as found in the traditional major religions. So it follows, in my mind, that efficacy studies of AA should also focus on the program's success regarding its members attaining a belief in a God of their understanding.

Well since AA is not making their members believe in a traditional monotheistic God found in major religions this debate your asking for is rather mute.
Keep reading though I believe you are on the right path towards understanding what AA has to offer religiously, spiritually and agnostically.

An additional efficacy study could measure morals. Steps 4 - 10 pretty much deal with one's moral conduct before entering AA and how one betters their morals through the use of prayer to a God of their understanding. It would therefore be interesting to do studies that measure for instance the rate of recidivism of convicts who integrate AA into their lives.

Please refer to my comments above.

Comments are welcome.

Bamberger, it would help if you had any personal experience with AA.
Just say'in.
 
Oh my Dog ... the rants against AA never cease to amaze me. I've been to a few hundred meetings, and no one ever tried to coerce me into believing anything. The fact that courts order people to go to AA does not mean AA itself orders anyone to go. The issues are unrelated. If your beef is with the court system, take on the court system. Better yet, contrive to avoid circumstances that get you into the court system to begin with.

If you have a drinking or drug problem and can quit or moderate on your own, good for you. If you find it helpful to attend group support meetings, go ahead. If you don't want to attend support meetings, AA won't force you to.

I have often thought of it as somewhat religious, but it is not allied with any particular religion. A lot of atheists and agnostics find workarounds on the God thing because the program works for them in other ways, as have been spelled out: social, behavioral, whatever.

One of the fantastic things about it is the sheer amount of humor - again, in my experience only. I've gotten a lot of laughter out of meetings. There are tears too.

Here is a small example of how it worked in my life:

After going to meetings for a couple of years, I got off probation and got my drivers license back. That happened just in time because my father was dying and I was driving 120 miles to my parents house a couple of times a week. The day after I got back from one visit, I got a call from my mom and knew my dad would probably die that night. I packed a dress, got in the car and stopped at my regular meeting on the way out of town.

There I found 10 or 15 people who knew me, knew the situation and were quietly supportive. No one told me Dad was going to be with Jesus, no one offered up any special prayers. They just listened, and that became a topic - about how nice it was to have a support system in such times. I didn't even stay for the whole meeting.
 
Part 2 - I accidentally posted something I wasn't finished; can't get it back because thread is moderated. The point was just that the program was useful for me, did not offend me and AA itself did not compel me to go and that I don't understand why so much anger is directed at the program.
 
Which is true for virtually every treatment.

This belief of yours would be incorrect and you have been shown why. That said; given the language of the day and the author, the oft repeated point that it is a God of your understanding, and bearing in mind redundant repetition on "as we understood him" is unnecessary: what evidence do you have that makes you believe AAs secondary purpose is a monotheistic God?

How about this:

"Both you and the new man must walk day by day in the path of spiritual progress. If you persist, remarkable things will happen. When we look back, we realize that the things which came to us when we put ourselves in God’s hands were better than anything we could have planned. Follow the dictates of a Higher Power and you will presently live in a new and wonderful world, no matter what your present circumstances!" BB pg. 100

That sure looks like a monotheistic God is being touted to me.

What am I missing?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom