Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sure, it's helpful for some. What I want to know is why it works or doesn't work, so that what works can be emphasized and improved upon and the rest, discarded as being not useful for alcoholism and recovery. Something which AA proponents seem not to really care about.

You already know this answer, Norseman. Why else would you be here debating.

I understand this. I used the term "ignoring the program" because that's what in effect is being promoted here in this thread. Take what you want and leave the rest is ignoring what was written down, time after time after time, about not doing precisely that. The Take What You Want saying, as I understand, applied originally to personal testimonies said during the meetings and not to the big book itself.

No, no one is ignoring anything. We have read the Book and came away with what we felt would work for us to stay sober. Part of the process of coming to the conclusions of what we will use and what we won't was carefully deliberated with others important to us.
In effect, the big book says, "look, you did it your way and see how your life is messed up because of it? If you're wanting relief, be prepared to give yourself over fully to this program."

That can be your interpretation if you want.

Ultimately, it is my belief that you did all the hard work, all by yourself, though having sober friends or people who are going through similar issues is certainly a benefit.

You would be wrong in that belief (IMO). We all had help and it was instrumental in our sobriety.

If the success of AA is simply because it provides a constant, unwavering support in the decision to remain sober, then a supportive spouse or family would do the same thing and as many alcoholics are acutely aware, it takes far more than that.

I firmly agree with this.

I would agree with this, except for the last where I'd qualify it and say "via some of the steps."

OK!
 
No, it wouldn't, because he never claimed that the Big Book wasn't relevant to today, just that every word need not be taken literally in order for one to benefit from AA.

No, please, let here's his exact words

"The big book is an historical document with some good ideas and many that have outgrown their usefulness."
You see, the sentiment expressed above is really a problem. No-one in this thread has ever claimed that the Big Book is divinely inspired and inerrant literature.
No just the founder of AA did just that.

In fact, all the members of AA who are explaining that AA is not religious
Aside from the member DannyB who said

Of course AA is religious
have said that one can take only the parts that one finds helpful to staying sober and leave the rest. Strangely, only those participants in this thread who insist that AA must be religious
You mean aside from the AA members on this thread who said AA is religious


Jack Astor said:
The 'Big Book' program of gaining a 'spiritual awakening' was inspired from Bill's hallucinogenic belladonna trip, when God hooked up with Bill on top of a Mountain.

My mistake thank you for the correction.
 
Last edited:
No, it wouldn't, because he never claimed that the Big Book wasn't relevant to today, just that every word need not be taken literally in order for one to benefit from AA.

Alfie claimed the the big book of AA was in essence a history book and merely one man's story to be taken or left as one wishes. How could one not reasonably conclude that his statements, when combined, provide evidence that he believes that the big book is not relevant today?
 
As I mentioned my recommendations were based on the fact that they werent AA?.

So do you know whether they work?
What do you know about these treatments precisely and their efficacy?
Why would you recommend thenm just because they aren't AA?
How do you know they do not slap fish over their heads to cure alcoholism? :rolleyes:

Anyone could recommend anything on the basis that it is not something else, but if that is the extent of the knowledge it is both potentially dangerous and intellectually negligent.

You are apparently a qualified addiction councillor,

Among other disciplines, yes I am

and you want me to explain which treatments are more effective or less effective than AA?

Is that correct.

No.
I want you to support with evidence why you would recommend any treatment. The AA part is actually irrelevant to me here, it is totally about the efficacy of these other treatments you recommend.

: What essential component makes it AA? What is it the differentiates it?

Which aspect of the diamond makes it the most beautiful? Which one makes it a diamond?

I don't know if anyone is aware of this blog... A skeptical look at 12 step programs. Just thought I would share.... http://stinkin-thinkin.com/

A hate group.

Do you really, honestly not know anything about the Sinclair Method? Have honestly not read the data? And if this is the case, and I actually link them to you, will it matter?

I know of the Sinclair method, what do you know of it?
Why would you recommend it?
On what basis do you recommend it?
What is the efficacy for alcoholics?
Can you stand by your recommendations on the basis of evidence or not?

What am I doing that is AA?

Going to meetings and not picking up the first drink is a good start.
What would you like to do after that? See? you get to choose.
 
Alfie claimed the the big book of AA was in essence a history book and merely one man's story to be taken or left as one wishes. How could one not reasonably conclude that his statements, when combined, provide evidence that he believes that the big book is not relevant today?

Context.
 
You obviously have not read "Bill's Story" in the Big Book. There is no account of hallucinations induced by belladonna. In fact, Bill did not have his "spiritual experience" until several months after he was released from the hospital and it only came after talking to another recovered alcoholic and not the use of psychoactive substances.

Of course I've read Bill's story in the 'Big Book'. This is an example of rigorous honesty (tm), which is like regular honesty, without the truth.

Bill's belladonna induced white light experience isn't disputed. Even the most ardent AA defending historians don't deny it. But much like LSD experimentation, his talking to ghosts and claims that he had dead monk dictate books to him, his womanizing - none of which are in dispute - it is simply glossed over. The 'Big Book' account is simply, to put it charitably, an embellishment. To put honestly, it's a lie.

You can read more about Bill's crazy drug trip/meeting with God here at Silkworth.net. They quote Dick B., AA historian extraordinaire:

"What is not known is on what day of this eleven-day stay at Towns Hospital the now famous “white light transformation” occurred. Most believe it occurred on the third day of his belladonna treatment and also after possible use of Phenobarbital. While lying in bed, suicidal, depressed, and hopeless, Wilson would accept anything to help him quit drinking. He had tried everything he knew. He had reached a bottom that he had never experienced. Just prior to his experience with “the veritable sea of living spirit” Wilson often later talked about, he chastised God and said to himself “I’ll do anything at all. If there be a Great Physician, I’ll call on him!” again referring to his prior discussions with Silkworth. Then, according to Wilson, he cried out, “If there be a God, let him show himself.” . . . Suddenly the room lit up with a great white light. . . . All about me and through me there was a wonderful feeling of Presence, and I thought to myself, ‘So this is the God of the preachers!’ A great peace stole over me and I thought, ‘No matter how wrong things seem to be, they are all right. Things are all right with God and His world.’” Mitchel, Silkworth, supra, p. 47.

Pretty cool a whole movement would be started on this, huh? AA is most definitely a whackadoodle grab-bag of religious delusion. You don't have to dig in too deeply, either.
 
What essential element makes it AA?

Going to meetings and not picking up the first drink is a good start.
What would you like to do after that? See? you get to choose.

OK. After that I'll choose to make the coffee, and leave the rest. So, if I go to meetings and make coffee, then I'm doing AA and I get sober? How is that different than a SMART meeting, or a meeting at work, or meeting with my lawyer, or a community meeting?

All that really matters that you call it AA, and after that you do whatever. Pull out a ouija board, shoot pool, sing songs, play pin the tail on the donkey, string popcorn, whatever. As long as it's a meeting and you don't drink. By your criteria, anyone in meeting today who chose not to drink there, was in AA.

How does this fix addiction?
 
8den quotes:
Quote:
In fact, all the members of AA who are explaining that AA is not religious
Aside from the member DannyB who said

Quote:
Of course AA is religious

You are being ticky tack and playing games 8den, come on my friend. Number one this is my opinion/experience probably not shared by all. Number two I don't speak for AA I speak for myself. Last my intent with this statement was to explain the origins of AA's religious background and the fact that AA can be religious if this is the experience you want to have.
Btw I don't choose to have a religious experience in AA.
 
Alfie claimed the the big book of AA was in essence a history book and merely one man's story to be taken or left as one wishes. How could one not reasonably conclude that his statements, when combined, provide evidence that he believes that the big book is not relevant today?

Why is it so important to you to hang onto this notion that AA is set up like a military automaton program and/or some religious cult where no one can deviate from the covenants/tenants of the Big Book. That we must take every word literally or else be characterized as irrelevant.
AA can be religious, that's it.
 
Alfie claimed the the big book of AA was in essence a history book and merely one man's story to be taken or left as one wishes. How could one not reasonably conclude that his statements, when combined, provide evidence that he believes that the big book is not relevant today?

I should hasten to add, that I was also simply responding to a claim that the literature speaks only of a monotheistic god. This is untrue and my citation proves this point.

Moreover, it also proves that the spiritual nature of AA is has always been encouraged and accepted as opposed to any requirement to adhere to religious religious beliefs: There is and always has been plenty of room for the agnostic and atheist to enter the rooms of AA without adopting a belief in a traditional (or even Christian) God.

Here endeth the lesson. :)
 
So do you know whether they work?

How do we know AA works?

What do you know about these treatments precisely and their efficacy?

How precisely do we know how AA works and it's efficacy.

Why would you recommend thenm just because they aren't AA?

Because they're not AA, and the part of my post that you keep truncating.

They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives.

How do you know they do not slap fish over their heads to cure alcoholism? :rolleyes:

Because I've read a reasonable amount on the variety of methods tried in SMART or Sinclair and they don't include piscan based violence.

They also don't include references to God, 75 year old manuals, dogma and the steps, hence why I recommended them.

Anyone could recommend anything on the basis that it is not something else, but if that is the extent of the knowledge it is both potentially dangerous and intellectually negligent.

It is not the extent of my knowledge, it's just the extent of what I'm will to argue with you.

You want me to find figures for Naltraxtone or Baclofen, or Sinclair, and shot them down by saying "well as you can see X project hasn't had a long term feasibility study"

However your preferred method of Addiction curing has no qualms about hiding it's "efficacy" so I'm not inclined to play with football match on a uneven playing field.

The Thread Title is "[Moderated] Why do people insist AA is not religious? / The efficacy of AA" Not "Never mind about the efficacy of AA, lets look at the efficacy of everything that is NOT AA

Among other disciplines, yes I am



No.
I want you to support with evidence why you would recommend any treatment. The AA part is actually irrelevant to me here, it is totally about the efficacy of these other treatments you recommend.

The A.A. part is not "irrelevant" here it's the thread title you're steadfastly ignore.

Whats the point about picking apart the efficacy of alternatives when AA does it's best to obfuscate it's own success rates.
 
The evidence for the religiosity of AA is found not only in AA approved literature, where the word "God" is extensively used, but also in the closing rituals found in the majority of AA groups in the USA. These rituals typically consist of either the Christian Lord's Prayer or the so-called Serenity Prayer, which was written by a 20th century Christian theologian.
 
OK. After that I'll choose to make the coffee, and leave the rest. So, if I go to meetings and make coffee, then I'm doing AA and I get sober?

If you want to call that doing AA, that's fine with me; it's your program after all and who am I to interfere with whatever works for you?

How does this fix addiction?

Where did I ever say it did?

But on another point, I find it a little laughable that you would ask me questions on claims I have never made, yet refuse to support your own unqualified assertions.

Where are the results for the Sinclair method? Why do you recommend it? What results make it so attractive as a viable option for alcoholics?
 
I understand the "listening more than talking" thing. Or the "take the cotton our of your ears and put it in your mouth" thing. But it does not answer the question, and that is: What essential component makes it AA? What is it the differentiates it?
I don't know if what I call 'my program' would work for anyone else, and in any case don't find it germane.

You'll have to attend those closed discussion meetings to find out what, if anything there, works for you. If you continue to drink alcoholically, obviously the program didn't offer what you needed.
 
If you want to call that doing AA, that's fine with me; it's your program after all and who am I to interfere with whatever works for you?

I guess AA is simply a brand name. You're promoting a logo. Logos don't help people quit drinking.

But on another point, I find it a little laughable that you would ask me questions on claims I have never made, yet refuse to support your own unqualified assertions.

Where are the results for the Sinclair method? Why do you recommend it? What results make it so attractive as a viable option for alcoholics?

I seriously doubt you even care, but...

If you would like to review the data you can find a copy of the randomized, double-blinded, placebo controlled trial is located at here, from the Oxford Journal of Medicine.

Other studies are linked below:


The Sinclair Method works very well. I'm certainly not married to it, and I would happily see another treatment render this obsolete. It is not a religion to me, so I don't really care if there is another treatment modality that is more effective. There is definitely room for improvement.

A number of other studies are being done, and similar drugs are tested, as well. I'm going to spoon feed everything to you. All of the participants are anonymous, by the way. Just as they are in any other study. Anonymity is not an issue.

Unlike other treatments, AA doesn't really care about studies. Those that have been done on AA - ALL of them - have shown it does not help people quit drinking; and there is zero interest in refining or improving the program, just as there is not with any religion.

If you would like to learn more, you may start a thread on the Sinclair Method and Naltrexone. Since the subject of this thread is religious nature and efficacy of AA, it's not really the place to discuss it. I'll happily discuss it in an appropriate thread.
 
Here's a hypothetical. Let's say we have a program called "Workers United". Its basic text is "The Communist Manifesto" and most of its meetings end with the chant "..workers of the world unite!". The majority of members in this program also happen to identify themselves as socialists, although as individuals they express their socialism in different ways (e.g. politically, socially, economically, or a combination of such ways). There are also non-socialists in the movement, but they are in the minority.

Could I then call Workers United a socialist movement?
 
It's your quote you find the post and contextualise it.

Done - see post 5010.

It is not the extent of my knowledge, it's just the extent of what I'm will to argue with you.

Am I correct in saying you are not willing ever to discuss your own claims with me?
They are your claims mate, you get to clarify and support. You are failing. Not only that, you steadfastly refuse to hold yourself to your own standards, the very ones you demand of AA.

You want me to find figures for Naltraxtone or Baclofen, or Sinclair, and shot them down by saying "well as you can see X project hasn't had a long term feasibility study"

No. I simply want to know why you would recommend them in front of other treatments.

That said, it sounds like your recommendations have holes even before you present your proof.

Are your recommendations worth anything? Why would you recommend them unless you knew they worked?

However your preferred method of Addiction curing has no qualms about hiding it's "efficacy" so I'm not inclined to play with football match on a uneven playing field.

Who said AA was my preferred method? You and Jack put a lot of words and claims in my mouth that I never uttered.

I am happy to support or explain any claims I make - just show me where I made them first ok?

Are you prepared to do the same?

Neither you nor Jack can support your recommendations. Very telling.

The Thread Title is "[Moderated] Why do people insist AA is not religious? / The efficacy of AA" Not "Never mind about the efficacy of AA, lets look at the efficacy of everything that is NOT AA

Indeed it is, so why would you make off topic recommendations about other treatments and then be unable to support them?

Whats the point about picking apart the efficacy of alternatives when AA does it's best to obfuscate it's own success rates.

The point is that you have made unreserved, unqualified claims about other treatments; you brought these into play no-one else. It was you who made recommendations, no-one else.

Can you or can you not support your recommendations with efficacy rates for alcoholics or not?

The evidence for the religiosity of AA is found not only in AA approved literature, where the word "God" is extensively used, but also in the closing rituals found in the majority of AA groups in the USA. These rituals typically consist of either the Christian Lord's Prayer or the so-called Serenity Prayer, which was written by a 20th century Christian theologian.

Hang on: You said it wasn't in the literature. This is untrue and proved above. You are moving goalposts and dodging.

There are lots of meetings worldwide that do not say the Lords prayer, do not care for religion and do not mention this monotheistic god you speak insist upon. The meeting through its' group conscience determine what they do in that meeting, that might make that meeting (somewhat) religious, but not AA as a whole.

Anyone who had done AA would know these things.
 
I seriously doubt you even care, but...

If you would like to review the data you can find a copy of the randomized, double-blinded, placebo controlled trial is located at here, from the Oxford Journal of Medicine.

Other studies are linked below:


Great, now what do you actually thinbk they say? Are they effective in treating alcoholism? What are the success rates?

What do you think of this line in the opening of your first link?

Although all found benefits from naltrexone with the coping therapy, none of them found any significant benefit of naltrexone over placebo when combined with support for abstinence

So, nothing in terms of ongoing treatement and effectiveness. In my observations the problem is that most alcoholics do relapse, detox alone rarely works.

And do you not find just a little irony in that the second link has a whole section based on mind and spirit and:
Spiritual & Ritual Use of Psychoactives: with pages on
Journal Articles on the Spiritual Use of Entheogens
Books on the Spiritual Use of Entheogens

LOL :rolleyes:

I thought you didn't like woo as a treatment. :) Perhaps they suggest that Naltrexone in conjunction with spirituality (like AA) works? What are your thoughts? Perhaps you could expand on this for us, it is your evidence after all? ;)

But I was unable to find the conclusions for this, have you access to them or can you show me where they are exactly? What was the efficacy rates for alcoholism?

And the last link was a study for naltrexone on kleptomania. Hilarious!

So tell me, you base your recommendations on:
- something that has zero ongoing effectiveness for alcoholics after (basically) detox?
- a spiritualist website
- a study for kleptomania.

I must say I am totally sold. Very compelling. :rolleyes:

The Sinclair Method works very well.

LOL! Based on what? The info you just provided? You must be kidding.

If you would like to learn more, you may start a thread on the Sinclair Method and Naltrexone. Since the subject of this thread is religious nature and efficacy of AA, it's not really the place to discuss it. I'll happily discuss it in an appropriate thread.

This is the appropriate thread. You brought it up and now you are running from it. Not only have you "recommended" something that has no ongoing effectiveness for alcoholics, you blindly claim "it works very well".

Here's a hypothetical. Let's say we have a program called "Workers United". Its basic text is "The Communist Manifesto" and most of its meetings end with the chant "..workers of the world unite!". The majority of members in this program also happen to identify themselves as socialists, although as individuals they express their socialism in different ways (e.g. politically, socially, economically, or a combination of such ways). There are also non-socialists in the movement, but they are in the minority.

Could I then call Workers United a socialist movement?

You can call it what you want, I call it straw.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom