DannyB II
Thinker
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2011
- Messages
- 245
Sure, it's helpful for some. What I want to know is why it works or doesn't work, so that what works can be emphasized and improved upon and the rest, discarded as being not useful for alcoholism and recovery. Something which AA proponents seem not to really care about.
You already know this answer, Norseman. Why else would you be here debating.
I understand this. I used the term "ignoring the program" because that's what in effect is being promoted here in this thread. Take what you want and leave the rest is ignoring what was written down, time after time after time, about not doing precisely that. The Take What You Want saying, as I understand, applied originally to personal testimonies said during the meetings and not to the big book itself.
No, no one is ignoring anything. We have read the Book and came away with what we felt would work for us to stay sober. Part of the process of coming to the conclusions of what we will use and what we won't was carefully deliberated with others important to us.
In effect, the big book says, "look, you did it your way and see how your life is messed up because of it? If you're wanting relief, be prepared to give yourself over fully to this program."
That can be your interpretation if you want.
Ultimately, it is my belief that you did all the hard work, all by yourself, though having sober friends or people who are going through similar issues is certainly a benefit.
You would be wrong in that belief (IMO). We all had help and it was instrumental in our sobriety.
If the success of AA is simply because it provides a constant, unwavering support in the decision to remain sober, then a supportive spouse or family would do the same thing and as many alcoholics are acutely aware, it takes far more than that.
I firmly agree with this.
I would agree with this, except for the last where I'd qualify it and say "via some of the steps."
OK!