gentlehorse
Master Poster
- Joined
- Aug 25, 2001
- Messages
- 2,605
Yes, I'm sure that they are. And they remain by ignoring essential written tenets of AA. So again, when ignoring the program, why should the program get any credit at all?
"Ignoring the program" is a bit of a loaded phrase, but I'll respond anyway, hoping that the penny will drop. I give AA credit because I receive support from people who have something of an understanding of the problems I struggled and struggle with. Had I gone it alone, or gone to my buddies for support in my decision to get and stay sober, there is little doubt in my mind that I would have continued to drink.
After all, how do we know that these people wouldn't have gotten and remained sober without AA?
We don't. For my part, it's a matter of likelihood. When I initially decided to stop drinking, I was shocked to realize that I had much more a serious problem than I'd originally thought. Admitting to myself that I needed help was a very difficult thing to do. I found help that has enabled me to remain sober at AA. I, quite literally, took what I needed and dismissed the rest. Some may say, "Well, then you're not doing AA," or "You're not a real alcoholic!" I don't care. I'm sober. I might be packing around a sack of rocks that could crush a semi, but I'm sober. I can tell you that it is very unlikely that I would have, or could have, done it completely and totally by myself. Luckily, I found some support. I give credit where credit is due.
I know, I know... Anecdotal evidence... Experience may vary on an individual basis and there's no reason to think that my personal experience is in any way representative of the vast majority of those who go to AA. But there it is.
It really seems to me that the ones in this thread that are critical of AA's program of recovery are the only ones who want to know why it works or doesn't work.
There are probably as many answers to that question as there are people for whom it did and did not work. You have mine.
Those who are enamored with AA seem to say "do what you want and it's all good" so therefore it works.
Not quite. "Those who are enamored with AA" is a bit loaded as well, but I'll try to respond, regardless. It works because it provides constant, unwavering support in the decision to remain sober. My $0.02.