Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, I'm sure that they are. And they remain by ignoring essential written tenets of AA. So again, when ignoring the program, why should the program get any credit at all?

"Ignoring the program" is a bit of a loaded phrase, but I'll respond anyway, hoping that the penny will drop. I give AA credit because I receive support from people who have something of an understanding of the problems I struggled and struggle with. Had I gone it alone, or gone to my buddies for support in my decision to get and stay sober, there is little doubt in my mind that I would have continued to drink.

After all, how do we know that these people wouldn't have gotten and remained sober without AA?

We don't. For my part, it's a matter of likelihood. When I initially decided to stop drinking, I was shocked to realize that I had much more a serious problem than I'd originally thought. Admitting to myself that I needed help was a very difficult thing to do. I found help that has enabled me to remain sober at AA. I, quite literally, took what I needed and dismissed the rest. Some may say, "Well, then you're not doing AA," or "You're not a real alcoholic!" I don't care. I'm sober. I might be packing around a sack of rocks that could crush a semi, but I'm sober. I can tell you that it is very unlikely that I would have, or could have, done it completely and totally by myself. Luckily, I found some support. I give credit where credit is due.

I know, I know... Anecdotal evidence... Experience may vary on an individual basis and there's no reason to think that my personal experience is in any way representative of the vast majority of those who go to AA. But there it is.


It really seems to me that the ones in this thread that are critical of AA's program of recovery are the only ones who want to know why it works or doesn't work.

There are probably as many answers to that question as there are people for whom it did and did not work. You have mine.

Those who are enamored with AA seem to say "do what you want and it's all good" so therefore it works.

Not quite. "Those who are enamored with AA" is a bit loaded as well, but I'll try to respond, regardless. It works because it provides constant, unwavering support in the decision to remain sober. My $0.02.
 
I was hoping we could steer the discussion toward things upon which would agree.

Maybe Belz, Jack, Norseman, and others that disapprove of the AA structure could tell us of something positive about what many of find to be a readily availabe structure designed to help those suffering from addiction.

Why would you want me to do that ? The OP asks if AA is religious. I say yes.

It's been pointed out that AA isn't more successful than other methods, sure. Other than that I have nothing to say about that organisation.
 
Yes, I'm sure that they are. And they remain by ignoring essential written tenets of AA. So again, when ignoring the program, why should the program get any credit at all?

Norseman, read the Big Book again, please. No one is ignoring the essential tenets of AA. Bill W. and the first 100 gave great latitude so they could reach out to the non-religious. They also made the steps suggestive in their nature, meaning if one had to make changes in order to accomplish getting sober they could. One essential in any personal journey as this is honesty, if you lack this essential virtue well then all is lost.

After all, how do we know that these people wouldn't have gotten and remained sober without AA?

and if cows could fly. I am not trying to be a smart ass but who cares. If they did get sober well that is great...right!!

It really seems to me that the ones in this thread that are critical of AA's program of recovery are the only ones who want to know why it works or doesn't work. Those who are enamored with AA seem to say "do what you want and it's all good" so therefore it works.

The folks who are grateful for AA have no need to question, it worked, works and is still working for them.
 
As I said, attend meetings, and if one thinks one is an alcoholic and needs help, closed discussion meetings.

And as I also said take what you like which means "works for you in assisting you to not drink". Leave the rest.

But what makes it AA as compared to say SMART or just a general alcolism support group? You say AA works. That is fine, but what would one specifically have to do to make sure they are doing what works? Let's say I think I am an alcoholic and need help. What will I do in this closed discussion meeting that makes it AA?
 
Maybe Belz, Jack, Norseman, and others that disapprove of the AA structure could tell us of something positive about what many of find to be a readily availabe structure designed to help those suffering from addiction.

I find it hard to believe that even the most ardent of critics cannot acklowdge that it is helpful to some.

Define "helpful." What matters is if it helps people quit drinking. Not whether people think it does. But whether it really does. We know it doesn't.

Does it help people gain status who are otherwise losers in other aspects of their life? Sure. Time in AA insures guru status.

Does it help felons hide from the law because they bastardize the anonymity tradition to protect each other from accountability? Yes, as this article from Sunday describes.

Does it help people escape reality? Does it delude them in the same way homeopathy does for people? Sure.

Does it help the economy? Tough call. It does feed lots of people in and out of treatment centres, and that employees people; but it costs a lot of tax money since it is used as a dumping ground for criminals.

Does it help people find God? Sure. Is that helpful?

I can't honestly think of one thing that AA does right. Even things like support and service, they ruin. Support means getting advice from someone trying to talk you into giving your live over to God or a toaster (depending on your brand of AA). Service means recruiting new sheep into the program. It's all so far-out crazy, I don't see any good.
 
I was hoping we could steer the discussion toward things upon which would agree.

Maybe Belz, Jack, Norseman, and others that disapprove of the AA structure could tell us of something positive about what many of find to be a readily availabe structure designed to help those suffering from addiction.

I find it hard to believe that even the most ardent of critics cannot acklowdge that it is helpful to some.

Can we agree on anything?

Positive things about AA:

- It provides people access to a support group in which abstinence is encouraged.
- It helps people to disengage from less healthy social environments (bars, drinking buddies, etc)
- It promotes the betterment of one's moral character (via the steps).
 
Let's say I think I am an alcoholic and need help. What will I do in this closed discussion meeting that makes it AA?
Assuming you are an alcoholic looking for help to stop drinking, in your first (and maybe a few) closed discussion meeting(s) listening more than talking might be a good idea, and perhaps you might hear something, or several things, that will be of help to you.

Or you may decide there is nothing there for you, and go have a few drinks, or find SMART or some other rehab effort available to you that you can afford.
 
Meet everyone half way. Start coming up with a list of things that you find objectionable about AA first.

Oh good 8den, you're back on deck.

Any chance you could respond to my post 4926, I am still waiting on some answers.

Cheers

So there IS no program, then. Is that what you are saying ?

No. Try again.

But what makes it AA as compared to say SMART or just a general alcolism support group? You say AA works. That is fine, but what would one specifically have to do to make sure they are doing what works? Let's say I think I am an alcoholic and need help. What will I do in this closed discussion meeting that makes it AA?

AA is a many faceted diamond.
We can all take different things that work for us from the same program outline, what works for me might not work for you and vice versa. Some things that are in the program include:
- spirituality
- religion (if one cares for it)
- society
- fellowship
- responsibility
- honesty and integrity
- making amends.
- self improvement and self actualisation.
- lifeskills
- CBT
- relapse prevention techniques.

and they are just off the top of my head.


Can you tekll me how the Sinclair method works,what makes effective and what sort of efficacy they get for alcoholics please? I have been unable to locate the information you tell me is on the internet.
 
But what makes it AA as compared to say SMART or just a general alcoholism support group? You say AA works. That is fine, but what would one specifically have to do to make sure they are doing what works? Let's say I think I am an alcoholic and need help. What will I do in this closed discussion meeting that makes it AA?

What makes it AA is 75 years of hard work many anonymous people have put into their communities helping a fellow alcoholic.

What would one do to specifically make sure they are doing what works? "Not Drink"!!!

What would one do if they were seeking help at a "closed meeting" that would make it a AA meeting for them? Ask for help, try to see if they are a Alcoholic.

Ya know, I think we all assumed Jack that you already knew all this because you were a member of AA. That you have a Blog that purposely focuses on AA and that you have vast amounts of evidence and experience concerning AA.
So I guess the real question here is what is your point and where are you going with this line of questioning, seriously.
I think this thread gets lost frequently because sometimes questions are misleading or loaded with more questions. Why can't we just say what we want to say and let it fall as it may.
 
Any chance you could respond to my post 4926, I am still waiting on some answers.

A.A. The part of post that you truncated contains my answer.

Because that was what you did. You "recommended" a number of other treatments. Why? Because some people (and I know this might blow your mind away as a addiction councillor) might not like AA.

They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives.

As I mentioned my recommendations were based on the fact that they werent AA?.

You are apparently a qualified addiction councillor, and you want me to explain which treatments are more effective or less effective than AA?

Is that correct.
 
Rubbish!

From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):


That'd be the same big book you claimed wasn't really relevant in modern AA a few weeks ago?

And the same big book dictated to Bill W by a 15th century monk called boniface?
 
I was hoping we could steer the discussion toward things upon which would agree.

Maybe Belz, Jack, Norseman, and others that disapprove of the AA structure could tell us of something positive about what many of find to be a readily availabe structure designed to help those suffering from addiction.

I find it hard to believe that even the most ardent of critics cannot acklowdge that it is helpful to some.

Can we agree on anything?

Sure, it's helpful for some. What I want to know is why it works or doesn't work, so that what works can be emphasized and improved upon and the rest, discarded as being not useful for alcoholism and recovery. Something which AA proponents seem not to really care about.

"Ignoring the program" is a bit of a loaded phrase, but I'll respond anyway, hoping that the penny will drop. I give AA credit because I receive support from people who have something of an understanding of the problems I struggled and struggle with. Had I gone it alone, or gone to my buddies for support in my decision to get and stay sober, there is little doubt in my mind that I would have continued to drink.

I understand this. I used the term "ignoring the program" because that's what in effect is being promoted here in this thread. Take what you want and leave the rest is ignoring what was written down, time after time after time, about not doing precisely that. The Take What You Want saying, as I understand, applied originally to personal testimonies said during the meetings and not to the big book itself.

In effect, the big book says, "look, you did it your way and see how your life is messed up because of it? If you're wanting relief, be prepared to give yourself over fully to this program."



We don't. For my part, it's a matter of likelihood. When I initially decided to stop drinking, I was shocked to realize that I had much more a serious problem than I'd originally thought. Admitting to myself that I needed help was a very difficult thing to do. I found help that has enabled me to remain sober at AA. I, quite literally, took what I needed and dismissed the rest. Some may say, "Well, then you're not doing AA," or "You're not a real alcoholic!" I don't care. I'm sober. I might be packing around a sack of rocks that could crush a semi, but I'm sober. I can tell you that it is very unlikely that I would have, or could have, done it completely and totally by myself. Luckily, I found some support. I give credit where credit is due.

Ultimately, it is my belief that you did all the hard work, all by yourself, though having sober friends or people who are going through similar issues is certainly a benefit.



Not quite. "Those who are enamored with AA" is a bit loaded as well, but I'll try to respond, regardless. It works because it provides constant, unwavering support in the decision to remain sober. My $0.02.

If the success of AA is simply because it provides a constant, unwavering support in the decision to remain sober, then a supportive spouse or family would do the same thing and as many alcoholics are acutely aware, it takes far more than that.



Positive things about AA:

- It provides people access to a support group in which abstinence is encouraged.
- It helps people to disengage from less healthy social environments (bars, drinking buddies, etc)
- It promotes the betterment of one's moral character (via the steps).

I would agree with this, except for the last where I'd qualify it and say "via some of the steps."
 
No. Try again.

Well it's not really up to me to guess what you're trying to say, is it ? I mean, you basically say that AAers can basically do whatever works, which is the same as saying there is no program, because if there were a program they'd have to follow at least part of it in order to, you know, do AA.

And on the other hand you say the program works, which certainly implies there's a program.

Certainly you can clarify this for me far better than I can guess your own thoughts on this matter, no ?
 
Assuming you are an alcoholic looking for help to stop drinking, in your first (and maybe a few) closed discussion meeting(s) listening more than talking might be a good idea, and perhaps you might hear something, or several things, that will be of help to you.

I understand the "listening more than talking" thing. Or the "take the cotton our of your ears and put it in your mouth" thing. But it does not answer the question, and that is: What essential component makes it AA? What is it the differentiates it?
 
That'd be the same big book you claimed wasn't really relevant in modern AA a few weeks ago?

No, it wouldn't, because he never claimed that the Big Book wasn't relevant to today, just that every word need not be taken literally in order for one to benefit from AA.

And the same big book dictated to Bill W by a 15th century monk called boniface?

You see, the sentiment expressed above is really a problem. No-one in this thread has ever claimed that the Big Book is divinely inspired and inerrant literature. In fact, all the members of AA who are explaining that AA is not religious have said that one can take only the parts that one finds helpful to staying sober and leave the rest. Strangely, only those participants in this thread who insist that AA must be religious for whatever reason are the one who portray the Big Book as having a place in AA akin to the place that the Bible has in fundamentalist Christian denominations, that is, the ultimate, inerrant arbiter of reality.
 
AA is a many faceted diamond.
We can all take different things that work for us from the same program outline, what works for me might not work for you and vice versa. Some things that are in the program include:
- spirituality
- religion (if one cares for it)
- society
- fellowship
- responsibility
- honesty and integrity
- making amends.
- self improvement and self actualisation.
- lifeskills
- CBT
- relapse prevention techniques.

and they are just off the top of my head.


Can you tekll me how the Sinclair method works,what makes effective and what sort of efficacy they get for alcoholics please? I have been unable to locate the information you tell me is on the internet.

Do you really, honestly not know anything about the Sinclair Method? Have honestly not read the data? And if this is the case, and I actually link them to you, will it matter?

Your inclusion of CBT, life skills and relapse prevention techniques are made up. They are definitely not part of AA. "Honesty and Integrity" is wishful thinking. The other things don't answer the question of what is essential for AA. If you believe one can take or leave anything, then that would mean one could leave out everything. So, suppose I am an alcoholic, join AA and decide to leave out all of those things. What am I doing that is AA?
 
That'd be the same big book you claimed wasn't really relevant in modern AA a few weeks ago?

And the same big book dictated to Bill W by a 15th century monk called boniface?

No, the ghost of the 15th century monk dictated to Bill Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, not the 'Big Book':

“One turned up the other day calling himself Boniface. Said he was a Benedictine missionary and English. Had been a man of learning, knew missionary work and a lot about structures. I think he said this all the more modestly but that was the gist of it. I’d never heard of this gentleman but he checked out pretty well in the Encyclopedia. If this one is who he says he is—and of course there is no way of knowing—would this be licit contact in your book?” - Bill Wilson in a letter to Father Ed Dowling

The 'Big Book' program of gaining a 'spiritual awakening' was inspired from Bill's hallucinogenic belladonna trip, when God hooked up with Bill on top of a Mountain.
 
No, the ghost of the 15th century monk dictated to Bill Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, not the 'Big Book':

“One turned up the other day calling himself Boniface. Said he was a Benedictine missionary and English. Had been a man of learning, knew missionary work and a lot about structures. I think he said this all the more modestly but that was the gist of it. I’d never heard of this gentleman but he checked out pretty well in the Encyclopedia. If this one is who he says he is—and of course there is no way of knowing—would this be licit contact in your book?” - Bill Wilson in a letter to Father Ed Dowling

The 'Big Book' program of gaining a 'spiritual awakening' was inspired from Bill's hallucinogenic belladonna trip, when God hooked up with Bill on top of a Mountain.

You obviously have not read "Bill's Story" in the Big Book. There is no account of hallucinations induced by belladonna. In fact, Bill did not have his "spiritual experience" until several months after he was released from the hospital and it only came after talking to another recovered alcoholic and not the use of psychoactive substances.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom