DannyB II
Thinker
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2011
- Messages
- 245
When I discuss AA literature I am talking about, well, the literature, not the members. AA as an entity can be generalized as a religion based on its literature. Now if a particular group does not use the AA literature and abstains from praying then I would be apt to term that particular group as not religious. But realistically what percentage of groups world-wide meet such criteria? Wouldn't such groups be likely sooner or later to run afoul of AA as a whole? Isn't there something in the traditions to the effect that groups are autonomous except in matters that affect AA as a whole? I think the "God" question would qualify in this respect, don't you?
No this would not qualify under the fourth tradition because the authors and the first 100 dealt with this issue back in 1935-36. Remember the atheist were looking for sobriety also. We still are. So, No, we are not running afoul.
Bamberger, honestly there is more conversation going on here on this thread then actually goes on within AA on this subject. It is widely respected amongst us AA'ers that this subject is are own business.
The incident in Canada a couple of months ago was a "Inner Group" issue that should have never happened.
