Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
When I discuss AA literature I am talking about, well, the literature, not the members. AA as an entity can be generalized as a religion based on its literature. Now if a particular group does not use the AA literature and abstains from praying then I would be apt to term that particular group as not religious. But realistically what percentage of groups world-wide meet such criteria? Wouldn't such groups be likely sooner or later to run afoul of AA as a whole? Isn't there something in the traditions to the effect that groups are autonomous except in matters that affect AA as a whole? I think the "God" question would qualify in this respect, don't you?

No this would not qualify under the fourth tradition because the authors and the first 100 dealt with this issue back in 1935-36. Remember the atheist were looking for sobriety also. We still are. So, No, we are not running afoul.
Bamberger, honestly there is more conversation going on here on this thread then actually goes on within AA on this subject. It is widely respected amongst us AA'ers that this subject is are own business.
The incident in Canada a couple of months ago was a "Inner Group" issue that should have never happened.
 
Experience may vary on an individual basis, but the AA literature does not.

Rubbish!

From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.
 
Rubbish!

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.

Again, you failed to capitalize the word "God" in your follow-up to the text you quoted from AA literature. The capitalization is important, as it stresses a monotheistic deity as is traditionally expressed in major religious traditions.

Has there been AA-approved literature published since the big book that expands upon the notion of the generic spiritualism you describe, and that serves to supersede the notion of "God" as expressed in the the original text? If not, why do you think this to be the case?
 
Again, you failed to capitalize the word "God" in your follow-up to the text you quoted from AA literature. The capitalization is important, as it stresses a monotheistic deity as is traditionally expressed in major religious traditions.

It can stress that idea; it need not, though.

Has there been AA-approved literature published since the big book that expands upon the notion of the generic spiritualism you describe, and that serves to supersede the notion of "God" as expressed in the the original text? If not, why do you think this to be the case?

The Big Book (or other approved literature) is not necessarily treated as received wisdom from on high. I personally know people of both persuasions: "Big Book thumpers" and "shopping cart AAs". The fact is that the approach to approved literature doesn't seem affect a person's ability to remain sober within AA, be they theistic, agnostic, or atheist.
 
It can stress that idea; it need not, though.

The Big Book (or other approved literature) is not necessarily treated as received wisdom from on high. I personally know people of both persuasions: "Big Book thumpers" and "shopping cart AAs". The fact is that the approach to approved literature doesn't seem affect a person's ability to remain sober within AA, be they theistic, agnostic, or atheist.

"Do what you feel like doing" is hardly a ringing endorsement of a program's effectiveness. Tell me -- how can a person who does not follow a specific plan for achieving and maintaining sobriety ever give honest credit to that program that they aren't following? In other words, what's the difference in doing what you feel like outside of AA as opposed to doing what you feel like inside of AA?

<sarcastic> Seriously! I'm a member of AA, though I currently don't attend meetings, work the steps, have a sponsor, or read the AA literature. I'm simply not putting many things into my shopping cart, but boy, has AA ever worked for me! I'm still sober! </sarcastic>

Besides, it is said over and over again that you must give yourself over fully to the program to succeed. The quotes that Alfie gives a few posts earlier are addressed specifically towards fence-sitters and is only said as a way to get the proverbial foot in the door for ultimate acceptance of God.
 
<sarcastic> Seriously! I'm a member of AA, though I currently don't attend meetings, work the steps, have a sponsor, or read the AA literature. I'm simply not putting many things into my shopping cart, but boy, has AA ever worked for me! I'm still sober! </sarcastic>
Hard to imagine how someone might consider themselves a member of AA without attending meetings, and if one thinks one is an alcoholic and needs help, closed discussion meetings. Of course if one is not an alcoholic, why one is interested in AA is a good question.

As to the rest, take what you like which means "works for you in assisting you to not drink".

Besides, it is said over and over again that you must give yourself over fully to the program to succeed. The quotes that Alfie gives a few posts earlier are addressed specifically towards fence-sitters and is only said as a way to get the proverbial foot in the door for ultimate acceptance of God.
Again, take what you like, meaning as I just described,
 
I first heard this little gem in a closed meeting:


"Let's look first at the case of the one who says he won't believe--the belligerent one. He's in a state of mind which can be described only as savage."

Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, pg 25
 
Rubbish!

From the chapter "We agonistics" of the Big Book (my bold):

"When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies too, to other spiritual expressions you find in his book."

and

"In our personal stories you will find a wide variation in the way each teller approaches and conceives of the Power which is greater than himself. Whether we agree with a particular approach or conception seems to make little difference. Experience has taught us that these are matters about which, for our purpose, we need not be worried. They are questions for each individual to settle for himself. "

So what we have is a god of your own understanding, of your own conception that can apply to any spiritual expression and that only the individual needs to settle for themself.

Thank You Alfie, for your tireless efforts to help folks here understand the concept of a higher power as AA sees it.
Your quotes from the Big Book should end any and all speculation about this subject.
AA is as religious as the religious want it to be.
 
Again, you failed to capitalize the word "God" in your follow-up to the text you quoted from AA literature. The capitalization is important, as it stresses a monotheistic deity as is traditionally expressed in major religious traditions.

Has there been AA-approved literature published since the big book that expands upon the notion of the generic spiritualism you describe, and that serves to supersede the notion of "God" as expressed in the the original text? If not, why do you think this to be the case?

Hang on, you have completely changed the subject and now make a poor argument around the capitalisation of the word God which was nothing more that the peculiarities of the language of the day and the writer.

Your incorrect point was that there is reference only to a "monotheistic entity called "God"". I have shown this to be untrue through the very literature you claim supports your arguement, so off you go on a tangent about proper nouns. :boggled:

The literature makes it very clear on a number of aoccasions that the religious or spiritual approach that one makes is up to them; anything is possible. Biill W in his chapter to the agnostics also goes on to explain how the laws of nature could readily work for someone.

How long have you been in AA Bamberger?
 
Besides, it is said over and over again that you must give yourself over fully to the program to succeed. The quotes that Alfie gives a few posts earlier are addressed specifically towards fence-sitters and is only said as a way to get the proverbial foot in the door for ultimate acceptance of God.

Nonsense. The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

You cannot simply deny what is written in there with a wave of the hand. The citation is specific and it works in both theory practice and disproves the claim of a monotheistic religion.
 
Nonsense. The evidence is the agnostics and atheists that remain in AA and stay sober of which there are, I would suggest, hundreds of thousands.

Yes, I'm sure that they are. And they remain by ignoring essential written tenets of AA. So again, when ignoring the program, why should the program get any credit at all?

After all, how do we know that these people wouldn't have gotten and remained sober without AA?

And I was wondering what kinds of certification program counselors go through in Australia. How about what we in the US call continuing education credits? The states that I'm familiar with require its chemical dependency professionals to maintain professional knowledge in their field. If this is true in Australia, then how come you don't know about current treatment modalities? Do you subscribe to specialty journals? How is it you don't have current knowledge of these things? You've said in this thread you recommend AA as well as other treatments for alcoholism. How did you come by your experience in making these recommendations?

You're constantly pestering other posters in this thread with demands of evidence of alcoholism treatments, yet you (and I believe Dancing David) are the only actual certified counselor(s) posting.



It really seems to me that the ones in this thread that are critical of AA's program of recovery are the only ones who want to know why it works or doesn't work. Those who are enamored with AA seem to say "do what you want and it's all good" so therefore it works.
 
Hang on, you have completely changed the subject and now make a poor argument around the capitalisation of the word God which was nothing more that the peculiarities of the language of the day and the writer.

The capitalization of pronouns to denote a deity is still very much in use today in religions. Read a Christian Church bulletin. And even if it wasn't then the retention of such a practice in the AA literature endorses such a practice.

Again, it is clear that AA supports the notion of a monotheistic entity referred to as "God".
 
What is the essential element? What must one do in order to be considered working the program?
As I said, attend meetings, and if one thinks one is an alcoholic and needs help, closed discussion meetings.

And as I also said take what you like which means "works for you in assisting you to not drink". Leave the rest.
 
I was hoping we could steer the discussion toward things upon which would agree.

Maybe Belz, Jack, Norseman, and others that disapprove of the AA structure could tell us of something positive about what many of find to be a readily availabe structure designed to help those suffering from addiction.

I find it hard to believe that even the most ardent of critics cannot acklowdge that it is helpful to some.

Can we agree on anything?
 
What is the essential element? What must one do in order to be considered working the program?

Be honest with self. All AA is offering is a guide out of destructive drinking and the life created because of this dilemma.
So the essential element would be self honesty.
 
I was hoping we could steer the discussion toward things upon which would agree.

Maybe Belz, Jack, Norseman, and others that disapprove of the AA structure could tell us of something positive about what many of find to be a readily availabe structure designed to help those suffering from addiction.

I find it hard to believe that even the most ardent of critics cannot acklowdge that it is helpful to some.

Can we agree on anything?

Meet everyone half way. Start coming up with a list of things that you find objectionable about AA first.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom