Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
From DSM-IV



Those DSM-IV criteria have imo no relevance to the alcoholics AA is set up to help. Picking and choosing any three, then discussing the ameliorating effects of a drug (measured by self-reporting) is laughable when discussing what would be considered an alcoholic in any AA closed discussion meeting group I've ever been a member of.

The last two are where 'AA alcoholism' is at least a possibility.

Attempting to compare efficacy of the studies with respect to AA success (or failure) rate is comparing fluffy little kittens to wild tigers.

Funny AlBell!

So first off where is this an Official Sanctioned AA policy?

Then let us look at the first five shall we:
Tolerance
Withdrawal symptoms or clinically defined Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome
Use in larger amounts or for longer periods than intended
Persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down on alcohol use
Time is spent obtaining alcohol or recovering from effects


So AA while it supposedly helps people with a drinking propblemss does not help with:

tolerance-seriously a person abstinent from alcohol is going to have the exact same tolerance for alcohol?

W/D-ditto

Use in larger amounts or for longer periods than intended ; so if some one relapses you just say that the AA programs is worthless? have you really thought about this. I thought if you relapsed the goal was to get and stay sober ASAP? One would hope this would be a visible metric from AA attendance over time, that the individual used less and spent more time sober, duh especially if they 'period of use' is zero.

Persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down on alcohol use :same as above shortening the amount of time in a relapse would be crucial.

Time is spent obtaining alcohol or recovering from effects: double ditto.

I am sure that you meant something else but if the goal of AA is to help people stop drinking who are problem drinkers, then everyone of those criteria would show an impact.

So what the Fred did you mean to say? Your statement borders on the absurd on its face value, so what did you mean to say?


As to the final two criteria you say AA is meant for a life skills based program with CBT and relapse prevention planning leading to abstinence would be more effective.
 
I am sure that you meant something else but if the goal of AA is to help people stop drinking who are problem drinkers, then everyone of those criteria would show an impact.

So what the Fred did you mean to say? Your statement borders on the absurd on its face value, so what did you mean to say?
I said exactly what I meant. The goal of AA is 'Stop Drinking', so none of the 7 remain a problem.

As to the final two criteria you say AA is meant for, a life skills based program with CBT and relapse prevention planning leading to abstinence would be more effective.
Er, yes, effective AA is exactly the bolded phrase.

And also yes, if the final two criteria are not The Problem, I'd agree AA is not for that person.
 
That seems like a bold claim, considering how many AAers have said the exact opposite in this thread.

...and considering AA literature explicitly states that recovery from both alcoholism and moral defects is directly tied to fostering a relationship with a monotheistic deity specifically referred to as "God".
 
I just came across this webpage titled "That Ain't In The Book!"

http://www.irecovered.com/

It's rather amusing to see so many common slogans countered by quotes from the Big Book, but it also shows some subtle changes in AA since the book was written.
 
So Tinyal and the others who have actually been in AA or around it don't know what they're talking about ?

Tinyal is actually tacit proof that God isn't required. He says is an atheist that is 20+ years sober in AA. He obtained and maintained sobriety without (presumably) a God.
 
How is that info on the naltrexone Sinclair mix coming?
I have yet to locate anything myself, could you please furnish us with the information that supports your claims?

So, are you unaware of the studies supporting the Sinclair Method? If you are not, then you not very informed as a self-certified expert. If you are, you could provide the links themselves.

I told you to go ahead and look at the very links you ignored in this thread. They have been given to you before, without a hint of acknowledgment.
 
So Tinyal and the others who have actually been in AA or around it don't know what they're talking about ?

If they are not fully aware of the very broad spiritual latitude that is given, then that is exactly what I would say, unless, of course, I had reason to believe that the AA they experienced is completely and totally different from anything I've experienced. Always a possibility, I suppose-- I've only ever experienced AA in a small handful of states in the US, over a period of eight or so years. Taking my personal experience into consideration, I have to admit to taking what they have to say with a grain of salt.
 
Tinyal is actually tacit proof that God isn't required. He says is an atheist that is 20+ years sober in AA. He obtained and maintained sobriety without (presumably) a God.

He may have done it, but my comment, as you well know, was about AA being a religious organisation.

Here's a quote:

I feel relatively qualified to comment on this subject: I've attended 1000's of AA & 100's of NA meetings over more than 21 years of soberiety. I've spoken at large AA conventions, medium sized Area functions, as well as many hundreds of smaller meetings - there was a period of nearly 12 years where I attended at least 6 and as many as 10 AA meetings every single week. I've long ago lost count of the number of people I've spoken to, with many in-depth conversations stretching over weeks, months, and years.
I still attend about once a week, at a small meeting where most of the members know I'm non-theist (and frequently outspoken whenever someone mentions something stupid like 'it's impossible to get sober without a higher power' , or 'there are no coincidences, only god at work', or tries to close a meeting with the lords prayer, or some such nonsense.) My reasons for still going? Primarily, they are to associate with friends I've known for decades, and to demonstrate to anyone willing to listen that they don't have to buy the AA higher power package to get - and stay - sober.
So much for my experience in AA - back to on topic:

In my view, AA is not only a religious organization, but fully meets the qualifications of a religious cult.
 
If they are not fully aware of the very broad spiritual latitude that is given, then that is exactly what I would say, unless, of course, I had reason to believe that the AA they experienced is completely and totally different from anything I've experienced. Always a possibility, I suppose-- I've only ever experienced AA in a small handful of states in the US, over a period of eight or so years. Taking my personal experience into consideration, I have to admit to taking what they have to say with a grain of salt.

Experience may vary on an individual basis, but the AA literature does not. Any meeting that uses the approved AA literature or that displays pamphlets, posters or banners that make mention of the 12 steps are religious in nature because such material make specific reference to a monotheistic entity called "God".
 
I said exactly what I meant. The goal of AA is 'Stop Drinking', so none of the 7 remain a problem.


Er, yes, effective AA is exactly the bolded phrase.

And also yes, if the final two criteria are not The Problem, I'd agree AA is not for that person.

I don't think that you understand the diagnostic criteria, usually you will not have just three of the criteria and usuallty they will not just be the first three either. In practice in assesment and diagnosis people usually focus on teh behavioral impacts , so functioning in th tree life domains is the biggest criteria to look at.

But if it helps you to have such strict black and white thinking , more power to you.
 
I don't think that you understand the diagnostic criteria, usually you will not have just three of the criteria and usuallty they will not just be the first three either. In practice in assesment and diagnosis people usually focus on teh behavioral impacts , so functioning in th tree life domains is the biggest criteria to look at.
I don't think you read the studies, because they tend to mention "any" 3 of the 7 and are not forthcoming as to which 3 (or more, perhaps) they were using as the criteria.

We seem to agree behavior is the real key. And sure some of that occurs in the private behavior area; the AA definition of stinkin thinkin and HALT.

But if it helps you to have such strict black and white thinking , more power to you.
Indeed I find alcoholism, as AA attempts to alleviate, to be just that without middle ground. It appears that middle ground of 'problem drinkers' is the only thing researchers study.

PDA and DDD greater than zero puts every alcoholic back in full-blown problems.
 
Experience may vary on an individual basis, but the AA literature does not. Any meeting that uses the approved AA literature or that displays pamphlets, posters or banners that make mention of the 12 steps are religious in nature because such material make specific reference to a monotheistic entity called "God".

You seem to be the only one stunted by the AA literature. You want us to believe the the Author was speaking as "The Only Authority" (Professor) that the principles Bill was writing about should go unchallenged even though Bill W. himself states these were suggestive in nature. Your opinions here seem to want to pigeon hole us AA'ers, put us all in a box, one size fits all.
I just don't see the "AA" you are referring to.
Yes AA can be religious for the religious members.
 
Originally Posted by Tinyal View Post
I feel relatively qualified to comment on this subject: I've attended 1000's of AA & 100's of NA meetings over more than 21 years of soberiety. I've spoken at large AA conventions, medium sized Area functions, as well as many hundreds of smaller meetings - there was a period of nearly 12 years where I attended at least 6 and as many as 10 AA meetings every single week. I've long ago lost count of the number of people I've spoken to, with many in-depth conversations stretching over weeks, months, and years.
I still attend about once a week, at a small meeting where most of the members know I'm non-theist (and frequently outspoken whenever someone mentions something stupid like 'it's impossible to get sober without a higher power' , or 'there are no coincidences, only god at work', or tries to close a meeting with the lords prayer, or some such nonsense.) My reasons for still going? Primarily, they are to associate with friends I've known for decades, and to demonstrate to anyone willing to listen that they don't have to buy the AA higher power package to get - and stay - sober.
So much for my experience in AA - back to on topic:

In my view, AA is not only a religious organization, but fully meets the qualifications of a religious cult.


Tinyal, can we please have some proof, maybe a citation where anyone can verify this latest judgment, AA is a religious cult.
I am agnostic (close to atheist) and I have never seen any proof to this claim in my 25 years of being affiliated with AA. I have been all over this country, Alaska and Hawaii, Mexico, South America, Europe, Southeast Asia, Russia and New Zealand. Never heard or read where anyone of intelligence has said AA is a religious cult.
 
Your opinions here seem to want to pigeon hole us AA'ers, put us all in a box, one size fits all.
I just don't see the "AA" you are referring to.
Yes AA can be religious for the religious members.

When I discuss AA literature I am talking about, well, the literature, not the members. AA as an entity can be generalized as a religion based on its literature. Now if a particular group does not use the AA literature and abstains from praying then I would be apt to term that particular group as not religious. But realistically what percentage of groups world-wide meet such criteria? Wouldn't such groups be likely sooner or later to run afoul of AA as a whole? Isn't there something in the traditions to the effect that groups are autonomous except in matters that affect AA as a whole? I think the "God" question would qualify in this respect, don't you?
 
When I discuss AA literature I am talking about, well, the literature, not the members. AA as an entity can be generalized as a religion based on its literature. Now if a particular group does not use the AA literature and abstains from praying then I would be apt to term that particular group as not religious. But realistically what percentage of groups world-wide meet such criteria? Wouldn't such groups be likely sooner or later to run afoul of AA as a whole? Isn't there something in the traditions to the effect that groups are autonomous except in matters that affect AA as a whole? I think the "God" question would qualify in this respect, don't you?
I think (assuming you think you may be an alcoholic) you should begin attending Closed Discussion meetings, and I then suspect you'll discover how wrong your analysis of AA actually is.
 
Experience may vary on an individual basis, but the AA literature does not. Any meeting that uses the approved AA literature or that displays pamphlets, posters or banners that make mention of the 12 steps are religious in nature because such material make specific reference to a monotheistic entity called "God".

?

I'm not sure why you choose post this in response to my post, as nothing I said in it, or anywhere else in this thread, could reasonably be interpreted to indicate anything to the contrary.

A.A. Alfie said that anyone who is actually in AA is fully aware of the very broad spiritual latitude that is given. Belz responded, saying that that seems like a bold claim, considering how many AAers have said the exact opposite in this thread. DannyB II responded to Belz, saying that every AA'er has been saying exactly what Alfie stated, to which Belz responded, saying, "So Tinyal and the others who have actually been in AA or around it don't know what they're talking about ?"

At this point I chimed in, saying that I take what Tinyal and some others have been saying with a grain of salt, because it is not consistent with my, admittedly limited (8+ years in the mid-south USA), experience of AA. I did not deny, and have not denied, the religious nature of much of what is in the big book and other AA literature.

I have, however, said that my personal lack of religion has not kept me from benefiting from participation in AA, probably because my priorities do not include passing judgement on the religious views of others, or the religious nature some of the AA literature. As I have no such agenda, I frankly couldn't possibly care less. It's not what I'm there for.

I have not been met with any religious requirements at AA. I receive and give support in the decision to remain sober. Some there are very religious. More power to them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom