Dancing David
Penultimate Amazing
From DSM-IV
Those DSM-IV criteria have imo no relevance to the alcoholics AA is set up to help. Picking and choosing any three, then discussing the ameliorating effects of a drug (measured by self-reporting) is laughable when discussing what would be considered an alcoholic in any AA closed discussion meeting group I've ever been a member of.
The last two are where 'AA alcoholism' is at least a possibility.
Attempting to compare efficacy of the studies with respect to AA success (or failure) rate is comparing fluffy little kittens to wild tigers.
Funny AlBell!
So first off where is this an Official Sanctioned AA policy?
Then let us look at the first five shall we:
Tolerance
Withdrawal symptoms or clinically defined Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome
Use in larger amounts or for longer periods than intended
Persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down on alcohol use
Time is spent obtaining alcohol or recovering from effects
So AA while it supposedly helps people with a drinking propblemss does not help with:
tolerance-seriously a person abstinent from alcohol is going to have the exact same tolerance for alcohol?
W/D-ditto
Use in larger amounts or for longer periods than intended ; so if some one relapses you just say that the AA programs is worthless? have you really thought about this. I thought if you relapsed the goal was to get and stay sober ASAP? One would hope this would be a visible metric from AA attendance over time, that the individual used less and spent more time sober, duh especially if they 'period of use' is zero.
Persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down on alcohol use :same as above shortening the amount of time in a relapse would be crucial.
Time is spent obtaining alcohol or recovering from effects: double ditto.
I am sure that you meant something else but if the goal of AA is to help people stop drinking who are problem drinkers, then everyone of those criteria would show an impact.
So what the Fred did you mean to say? Your statement borders on the absurd on its face value, so what did you mean to say?
As to the final two criteria you say AA is meant for a life skills based program with CBT and relapse prevention planning leading to abstinence would be more effective.