Rubbish indeed. What are your statistics on effectiveness, and what type of misclassified-as-an-alcoholic do they assist?
AA Alfie has also asked for statistics in greater detail. I'll humour him first.
We always did if one could afford their efforts;
Medicine is state subsidised in much of the world and if AA didn't have such a stranglehold we would see much more.
what do you cite to demonstrate the increased effectiveness of those techniques in treating alcoholism today vs 70 years ago?
Again a moment please.
Can you cite real figures that demonstrate AA's effectiveness how many people have successfully tried and completed and remained sober through AA, as a percentage of the people who attend AA and continue to drink.
You asked for effectiveness
AA basically is a type of CBT; again, your cites on the effectiveness of these 'more advanced programs', or at least see if you can name a few of them.
It is nothing like a form of CBT.
ANOTHER NEW DEFINITION OF AA. AA Alfie thinks it's spiritual, Danny thinks it's religious and you're trying to tell me Bill W invented CBT 30 years before Aaron Beck.
I assume you refer to 13th step, held in contempt in every AA group I've been in.
But it exists and it has a name. Saying "we hold it in contempt" Is like a Catholic Priest saying "We hold paedophilia in contempt" while forgetting to deny the paedophilia occurs within it's ranks.
You sure found crummy meetings to attend.
And now the passive aggressiveness starts "Hey pal
My AA is warm and fuzzy, I don't know what the deal is with the AA you found
Albell I didn't stumble through the looking glass and find some mirror universe AA, I found AA. I found the AA of 13th stepping, the AA of the meetings I talked about.
So riddle me this, if AA is so effective and works so well how can two different people have two radically different experiences of meetings.
As true today as it ever was for the type of alcoholic Bill W was worrying about, which certainly doesn't appear to be what most here seem to believe 'alcoholic drinking' represents.
Ah BRILLIANT the "no true Scotsman" argument of the AA. See the people here don't know alcoholic drinking here....No siree.
Perhaps it's this alternative AL Bell that these people are indoctrinated to believe that Alcohol is cunning (it's not it's fermented hops wheat and barley not Professor Moriarty in a bottle), and it's a constant battle, that once they drink they are so badly brainwashed by decades of AA, that they go off the deep end.
Edited by Tricky:
Edited for moderated thread.
Smartrecovery: 600 meeting sites avialable.
I'm sorry is it the number of meetings that proves the effectiveness of a treatment? Smart recovery has been around for about 15 years.
How was AA doing after 15 years? And SMART recovery is going against the entrenched business model of AA, it's like opening your burger franchise in 1990, next to Mc Donalds.
And AA hates to advertise or mention alternatives now does it
[FONT=Arial, Arial, Helvetica] Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.
[/FONT]
Not, "hey you don't like AA there are options........."
Mywayout: a healthfood store.
Now look at the catty claws come out.
http://www.mywayout.org/research.htm
It's a health food store with a wack of Science behind it.
I'd take that any day over asking some God to cure my shortcomings.
Edited by Tricky:
Edited for moderated thread.
[/quote]