Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think I'll be leaving this thread soon. I have gained much by the exchange of ideas.

I was hoping that someone might give an example of an instance when AA was detrimental to an individual. A real life portrait of what I have read as being so harmful.

None of us can jump from the specific to the general, but I really want to see, on this thread, the damage specified.

I know it is out there, stories of people that are already damaged, and are further damaged by ignorance. I simply haven't seen it yet.

Thanks.
 
I have no idea where you attended meetings, but those weren't topics in the closed discussion meetings I've been in and that were the reason I no longer have a problem with alcohol.
Apparently your disease isn't put in remission contingent on a daily reprieve like I read about in the big book. You sound like you're cured.
Perhaps you people never got beyond open Beginner and Speakers meetings. I usually found those unhelpful and at times jargon laden.
Sounds like your closed meetings don't allow newcomers. Are closed meetings not on the local meeting list?

I often heard old-timers say they needed to hear newcomers speak "to keep the memory green" about this terrible disease of alcoholism and what it does to alcoholics.

I recall an old timer Frank Gideon, he was getting tired of all the "young people" coming into the club, so he started his own closed, not-in-the-meeting-list meeting that was by invitation only. Everyone there had at least two years "sober" in AA. The gratitude meetings and people trying to out-gratitude one another got really old. At least when newcomers spoke in a meeting there was no telling what they would say.
Luckily I never met one of those members you seem to hang out with.
I made the choice not to hang out with AA members "a few 24 hours" ago. This thread is the most interaction I've done with AA members in years.

But reading your posts sure "keeps the memory green" for me about what AA was like.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Simply put, for the practicing alcoholic their spiritual core is self destructive manifesting itself in the alcoholic obsession. A change in their spiritual objectives or focus is essential for recovery imho.

But this thread is about whether or not AA is religious. Both the AA literature and the common practices seen at most AA meetings (e.g. prayer) make it clear that a monotheistic deity is recognized by the program as the source of recovery from alcoholism.

Do you agree?
 
Under the definition I have given, who would you describe as "non spiritual"?

I already said: under the definition you've given, someone who suffered from depression. Which makes the word "spiritual" superfluous, since it doesn't describe anything other than, well, normal.

I believe every "normal" person has some level of spirituality - and obviously this does not have to mean religion.

Which means "spiritual but not religious" should be synonymous with "not religious," since there's no distinction between a normal spiritual person and a normal non-spiritual person.

Yet, that's not how people use it. They use it as a weasel-word, like Maurice Ledifficile said, to distance something from both organized religion and evil atheism.

Imagine an anti-depression medicine advertising it will make you more spiritual, but not religious.

Or a group for people who want to be spiritual, not religious. Most people wouldn't expect the group to be full of atheists; they'd expect new-agers and crystal-healers and people like that.
 
I think I'll be leaving this thread soon. I have gained much by the exchange of ideas.

I was hoping that someone might give an example of an instance when AA was detrimental to an individual. A real life portrait of what I have read as being so harmful.

None of us can jump from the specific to the general, but I really want to see, on this thread, the damage specified.

I know it is out there, stories of people that are already damaged, and are further damaged by ignorance. I simply haven't seen it yet.

Thanks.


http://stinkin-thinkin.com/2010/03/16/tell-us-your-story/comment-page-1/#comments

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-not_good.html

I've known two people family members who struggled with alcoholism through AA, and kept being told AA was their only option. One committed suicide the other attempted suicide.
 
Alright, no problem. I'm responding to this for lurkers and other interested readers.

I mean by my statement, "the book's authors had no clue what alcoholism was about," that 75 years ago, doctors didn't know much about the dynamics of alcoholism and anyone's theory or concept of alcoholism could have worked. Then again, it may not have. It is well-known that Bill W. massaged the numbers to make AA look more successful than it was. Anyway, my point is that alcoholism/addiction isn't viewed in that way any longer by scientists and researchers and other interested parties. Chemistry, physiology, psychology... all fields which have some amazing inroads towards understanding and successfully treating addiction. Not saying that it's a solved puzzle.

But it sure ain't a spiritual disease, whatever that is.
I'd say science is at the stage of blind men examining an elephant re alcoholism.

It's seems a witches brew of pscho-dynamic interplays, perhaps at times coupled with possible physical maladies.

And Bill W and AA noted the behaviors are what needs fixing. On a case by case basis one can argue about the relative roles of symptoms that can be ameliorated by various pscho-active medicines vs the the problems related to drinking alcoholically. AA worries about the latter.

I respond for, in particular, untreated alcoholics who may have the misfortune to be reading the mish-mash we now have here.
 
I'd say science is at the stage of blind men examining an elephant re alcoholism.

It's seems a witches brew of pscho-dynamic interplays, perhaps at times coupled with possible physical maladies.

.

Rubbish we've got 75 years of science, brain scan and neurochemistry that help us cope with the physical addiction. We're seeing effective drugs coming onto the market, Naltrexone, Camporal and Baclofen.


And Bill W and AA noted the behaviors are what needs fixing. On a case by case basis one can argue about the relative roles of symptoms that can be ameliorated by various pscho-active medicines vs the the problems related to drinking alcoholically. AA worries about the latter.
We have psychologists and psychotherapy to help with that now. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy. A host of more advanced programs that benefit from our better understanding of psychology and physiological since the 1930s.

AA has a nickname for the sexual abuse of new members. AA tells new members that they have a incurable disease that must go untreated until you can reach for the cure (you must it rockbottom) a disease that can only be beaten by countless attendance to AA meetings for decades to come, where you must self flagellate yourself, and listen to the same monologues of drunks who have been sober for 25 years. A disease that will overpower you if you dare to drink

The fact that physicians recommend a 75 year old religious program to people coming to them asking for help is utterly mind boggling. If you went to your Doctor and told him you were depressed in 2011, the idea that he'd send you to a faith healer is obscene, that's what's still happening in this decade thanks to the perniciousness of AA.

I respond for, in particular, untreated alcoholics who may have the misfortune to be reading the mish-mash we now have here
For anyone reading this thread and having trouble with alcohol addiction I'd recommend

http://www.smartrecovery.org/
http://www.mywayout.org/

and the blogroll on the side of the page of stinkin thinkin has a list of alternatives available

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/

And is not to mention a place were you can find a litany of horror stories to steer you clear from AA.
 
Last edited:
Rubbish we've got 75 years of science, brain scan and neurochemistry that help us cope with the physical addiction. We're seeing effective drugs coming onto the market, Naltrexone, Camporal and Baclofen.

So true. One problem with AA is they won't allow outside literature. These things are "outside issues," so any talk of these things breaks their traditions. Of course, they only cite their traditions when it benefits them. Like the steppers who are expressing their opinions in this thread are breaking the sacred tenth tradition. But bring up naltrexone or anything not AA in a meeting, especially a closed one where the big book thumpers are the most dogmatic, and you'll be scolded. A few weeks ago I watched a helluva fight and multiple meltdowns because someone brought some book into a meeting that wasn't AA approved.

Any advancement in our understanding is in spite of, not because of, AA. As a religion, they aren't interested in change. That would be tantamount to heresy. So they're content with the 'Big Book' and a "doctor's opinion" written in 1938.
 
Rubbish we've got 75 years of science, brain scan and neurochemistry that help us cope with the physical addiction. We're seeing effective drugs coming onto the market, Naltrexone, Camporal and Baclofen.
Rubbish indeed. What are your statistics on effectiveness, and what type of misclassified-as-an-alcoholic do they assist?

We have psychologists and psychotherapy to help with that now.
We always did if one could afford their efforts; what do you cite to demonstrate the increased effectiveness of those techniques in treating alcoholism today vs 70 years ago?

Cognitive Behaviour Therapy. A host of more advanced programs that benefit from our better understanding of psychology and physiological since the 1930s.
AA basically is a type of CBT; again, your cites on the effectiveness of these 'more advanced programs', or at least see if you can name a few of them.

AA has a nickname for the sexual abuse of new members.
I assume you refer to 13th step, held in contempt in every AA group I've been in.

AA tells new members that they have a incurable disease that must go untreated until you can reach for the cure (you must it rockbottom) a disease that can only be beaten by countless attendance to AA meetings for decades to come, where you must self flagellate yourself, and listen to the same monologues of drunks who have been sober for 25 years.
You sure found crummy meetings to attend.

A disease that will overpower you if you dare to drink.
As true today as it ever was for the type of alcoholic Bill W was worrying about, which certainly doesn't appear to be what most here seem to believe 'alcoholic drinking' represents.

The fact that physicians recommend a 75 year old religious program to people coming to them asking for help is utterly mind boggling. If you went to your Doctor and told him you were depressed in 2011, the idea that he'd send you to a faith healer is obscene, that's what's still happening in this decade thanks to the perniciousness of AA.

For anyone reading this thread and having trouble with alcohol addiction I'd recommend

http://www.smartrecovery.org/
http://www.mywayout.org/

and the blogroll on the side of the page of stinkin thinkin has a list of alternatives available

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/

And is not to mention a place were you can find a litany of horror stories to steer you clear from AA.
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for moderated thread.

Smartrecovery: 600 meeting sites avialable.

Mywayout: a healthfood store.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for moderated thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'd say science is at the stage of blind men examining an elephant re alcoholism.

It's seems a witches brew of pscho-dynamic interplays, perhaps at times coupled with possible physical maladies.
And Bill W and AA noted the behaviors are what needs fixing. On a case by case basis one can argue about the relative roles of symptoms that can be ameliorated by various pscho-active medicines vs the the problems related to drinking alcoholically. AA worries about the latter.

I respond for, in particular, untreated alcoholics who may have the misfortune to be reading the mish-mash we now have here.

No. it's really just a matter of drinking alcoholic beverages.Nothing requiring higher powers.
 
Me too.
I do a poll with each of my rehab groups about once a fortnight where I see 80 - 90 % of the clients having some form of comorbidity. Depression features very highly.



Under the definition I have given, who would you describe as "non spiritual"?

I believe every "normal" person has some level of spirituality - and obviously this does not have to mean religion. For some it is family, work, sport, goals (in fact goal setting is hugely important), education etc.

Simply put, for the practicing alcoholic their spiritual core is self destructive manifesting itself in the alcoholic obsession. A change in their spiritual objectives or focus is essential for recovery imho.

So you apparently disagree with this statement: "Addiction itself is at least partly associated with a deficiency of dopamine, a brain chemical that plays a central role in the brain's pleasure and reward centers, while depression is at least partly linked to a lack of the brain chemical serotonin—and the activity of the two neurotransmitters is interconnected."


I'd say science is at the stage of blind men examining an elephant re alcoholism.

So you also disagree with the above-quoted statement regarding addiction and brain chemistry? Science with regards to addiction/alcoholism is blind while Alcoholics Anonymous sees the true way?


It's seems a witches brew of pscho-dynamic interplays, perhaps at times coupled with possible physical maladies.

Describes AA to a 'tee'.


And Bill W and AA noted the behaviors are what needs fixing. On a case by case basis one can argue about the relative roles of symptoms that can be ameliorated by various pscho-active medicines vs the the problems related to drinking alcoholically. AA worries about the latter.

Seriously? Scientists and therapists and family members, friends, co-workers -- none of these people are concerned about fixing behaviors? Sounds strange to me. That's the point behind the science, as if you weren't aware. Scientists do, in fact, worry about solving the symptoms as well as the cause of alcoholism/addiction. During the past 75 years, it's been discovered that brain chemicals are a better indicator and a better path to "success" in dealing with addiction than merely considering it a spiritual illness/malady/problem/disease whatever.



I respond for, in particular, untreated alcoholics who may have the misfortune to be reading the mish-mash we now have here.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for moderated thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I respond for, in particular, untreated alcoholics who may have the misfortune to be reading the mish-mash we now have here.

We can tidy up the mish-mash by becoming more focused on the OP. That is, why do some people insist AA is not religious? I wonder what harm such a discussion would do the untreated alcoholic, especially one who wants to be more informed about whether AA is in fact religious.
 
But this thread is about whether or not AA is religious.

The thread topic has changed and is now about AA efficacy too. My response was in direct response to Pup. Can or will you answer my question?

I already said: under the definition you've given, someone who suffered from depression. Which makes the word "spiritual" superfluous, since it doesn't describe anything other than, well, normal.

I disagree and honestly don't see how it is now "superfluous". If someone is lacking in a 'spiritual' core, replacing it or developing it with something different would take them to a place closer to "normal".

Imagine an anti-depression medicine advertising it will make you more spiritual, but not religious.

Imagine conflating a lack of psychosocial supports with clinical depression. :rolleyes:

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/2010/03/16/tell-us-your-story/comment-page-1/#comments

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-not_good.html

I've known two people family members who struggled with alcoholism through AA, and kept being told AA was their only option. One committed suicide the other attempted suicide.

I too have known many people struggle with alcoholism both in and out of AA that have suicided. AA is not responsible, Alcoholism is.

May I also ask you what other therapies and treatments they had tried? Psychologists, psychiatrists, priests, Smart recovery, drugs, self will, something else? What else did they try? Where else did they go and lose hope?

Rubbish we've got 75 years of science, brain scan and neurochemistry that help us cope with the physical addiction. We're seeing effective drugs coming onto the market, Naltrexone, Camporal and Baclofen.

Efficacy rates for alcoholics please.

We have psychologists and psychotherapy to help with that now. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy. A host of more advanced programs that benefit from our better understanding of psychology and physiological since the 1930s.

Efficacy rates for alcoholics please.

The fact that physicians recommend a 75 year old religious program to people coming to them asking for help is utterly mind boggling. If you went to your Doctor and told him you were depressed in 2011, the idea that he'd send you to a faith healer is obscene, that's what's still happening in this decade thanks to the perniciousness of AA.

Which speaks volumes for the efficacy of these ther programs you spruik.

For anyone reading this thread and having trouble with alcohol addiction I'd recommend

http://www.smartrecovery.org/
http://www.mywayout.org/

Efficacy rates for alcoholics please.

and the blogroll on the side of the page of stinkin thinkin has a list of alternatives available

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/

Efficacy rates for alcoholics of these "alternatives" please.

And is not to mention a place were you can find a litany of horror stories to steer you clear from AA.

Unlike other hate groups forums, anecdotal evidence doesn't cut much in the validity stakes around here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We can tidy up the mish-mash by becoming more focused on the OP. That is, why do some people insist AA is not religious? I wonder what harm such a discussion would do the untreated alcoholic, especially one who wants to be more informed about whether AA is in fact religious.

This has been explained ad nauseum. The reason people say it os not religious is because they see it as spiritual.

End thread.
 
This has been explained ad nauseum. The reason people say it os not religious is because they see it as spiritual.
In my observation, the essential difference between "religious" and "spiritual" is that one is supernatural beliefs in accordance with the orthodoxy of a church or large group, while the other is supernatural beliefs that are personal and not in accordance with any set orthodoxy. If you don't like the word "spirits", call it "powers" or "forces" or whatever, but it amounts to the same thing. "Spiritual" implies supernatural belief. Period.
 
Explain it to me.

How many times do I need to explain it to you? It has been done time and again.

In my observation, the essential difference between "religious" and "spiritual" is that one is supernatural beliefs in accordance with the orthodoxy of a church or large group, while the other is supernatural beliefs that are personal and not in accordance with any set orthodoxy. If you don't like the word "spirits", call it "powers" or "forces" or whatever, but it amounts to the same thing. "Spiritual" implies supernatural belief. Period.

Then you would be wrong according to much of the psychological world as per many previous links provided.

Spiritual or spirituality does not require the presence of the supernatural. This is the reason why AAers (like myself) can easily make the difference between the two. Some don't seem to like what they consider too broad an interpretation on the word, that's too bad, but frankly it isn't my problem.
 
This has been explained ad nauseum. The reason people say it os not religious is because they see it as spiritual.

End thread.

Yes, people may see AA as being spiritual (according to their interpretation of that word), but the written literature of AA makes specific mention, many times over, of a monotheistic deity called "God". This monotheistic deity is most assuredly associated with the Christian religious tradition, as AA itself has its roots in that tradition. Therefore AA is essentially religious in nature, isn't it?

I don't think we're ready to end the thread just yet.
 
Rubbish indeed. What are your statistics on effectiveness, and what type of misclassified-as-an-alcoholic do they assist?

AA Alfie has also asked for statistics in greater detail. I'll humour him first.

We always did if one could afford their efforts;
Medicine is state subsidised in much of the world and if AA didn't have such a stranglehold we would see much more.

what do you cite to demonstrate the increased effectiveness of those techniques in treating alcoholism today vs 70 years ago?
Again a moment please.

Can you cite real figures that demonstrate AA's effectiveness how many people have successfully tried and completed and remained sober through AA, as a percentage of the people who attend AA and continue to drink.

You asked for effectiveness

AA basically is a type of CBT; again, your cites on the effectiveness of these 'more advanced programs', or at least see if you can name a few of them.
It is nothing like a form of CBT.

ANOTHER NEW DEFINITION OF AA. AA Alfie thinks it's spiritual, Danny thinks it's religious and you're trying to tell me Bill W invented CBT 30 years before Aaron Beck.

I assume you refer to 13th step, held in contempt in every AA group I've been in.
But it exists and it has a name. Saying "we hold it in contempt" Is like a Catholic Priest saying "We hold paedophilia in contempt" while forgetting to deny the paedophilia occurs within it's ranks.

You sure found crummy meetings to attend.
And now the passive aggressiveness starts "Hey pal My AA is warm and fuzzy, I don't know what the deal is with the AA you found

Albell I didn't stumble through the looking glass and find some mirror universe AA, I found AA. I found the AA of 13th stepping, the AA of the meetings I talked about.

So riddle me this, if AA is so effective and works so well how can two different people have two radically different experiences of meetings.

As true today as it ever was for the type of alcoholic Bill W was worrying about, which certainly doesn't appear to be what most here seem to believe 'alcoholic drinking' represents.
Ah BRILLIANT the "no true Scotsman" argument of the AA. See the people here don't know alcoholic drinking here....No siree.

Perhaps it's this alternative AL Bell that these people are indoctrinated to believe that Alcohol is cunning (it's not it's fermented hops wheat and barley not Professor Moriarty in a bottle), and it's a constant battle, that once they drink they are so badly brainwashed by decades of AA, that they go off the deep end.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for moderated thread.

Smartrecovery: 600 meeting sites avialable.
I'm sorry is it the number of meetings that proves the effectiveness of a treatment? Smart recovery has been around for about 15 years.

How was AA doing after 15 years? And SMART recovery is going against the entrenched business model of AA, it's like opening your burger franchise in 1990, next to Mc Donalds.

And AA hates to advertise or mention alternatives now does it

[FONT=Arial, Arial, Helvetica] Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.
[/FONT]
Not, "hey you don't like AA there are options........."

Mywayout: a healthfood store.
Now look at the catty claws come out.

http://www.mywayout.org/research.htm

It's a health food store with a wack of Science behind it.

I'd take that any day over asking some God to cure my shortcomings.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for moderated thread.
[/quote]
 
Last edited:
In my observation, the essential difference between "religious" and "spiritual" is that one is supernatural beliefs in accordance with the orthodoxy of a church or large group, while the other is supernatural beliefs that are personal and not in accordance with any set orthodoxy. If you don't like the word "spirits", call it "powers" or "forces" or whatever, but it amounts to the same thing. "Spiritual" implies supernatural belief. Period.
We could discuss what 'supernatural' means, and if there remain unknowns in physics current description of reality.

Your statement will be preaching to the 'philosophical materialists' choir anyway. Period.

And it's a position that offers an alcoholic another opportunity to keep drinking; most when thinking alcoholically would rather be a drunk atheist than a sober not-atheist.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom