Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
That aside, word use is determined by society. Many use the word spiritual without any attachment to a deity. I assume now you understand the difference?

I didn't say anything about a deity. I talked about spirits.

What for? The English language has many strage idiosyncracies from country to country and region to region. You say tomatoe ......

Tell you what, why don't you provide a dictionary definition of "spirituality" that doesn't refer to the supernatural.

Seems the irony was lost on you. :)

Oh, I thought you were discussing seriously.
 
The odd thing is that no-one here that I recall has made any claims about AA. You on the other hand has said that other therapies work better (or to same effect). I assume by your continued attacks on others that you are unable to provide the evidence for your claims?

It's quite an extensive list that I have to collate and I have a day job that's keeping me busy.

Actually though A.A. I never once said "they work better" and I'd kindly ask you to stop putting words into my mouth. I said they were different, you demanded that I prove their "efficacy".

So what does it matter if they have more less efficacy they're help for addicts that don't muddy the water with religion and "spirituality" (whatever ill defined concept of divinity we're reaching for this page)

Meanwhile both yourself and Al Bell are happily telling us that there's no way to prove AA's efficacy, since it's anonymous (unless it doesn't need to be), and anyway those who drop out are according to Al Bell "not really alcoholics"

So you're asking me to prove other methods are more effective, while at the same time happily dodging the same question for AA.

When all I've said is that there are all alternatives, and you've demanded to know "are they effective" while steadfastly ignoring the question "Is AA effective" and Where's your proof
 
Sure, but it was written 75 years ago by a seriously religious man. His writings are his, they are neither my beliefs nor those of many others. Should I change the writings of Homer, Shakespeare et al because the language of the day has changed (I am not comparing the quality of writing btw)?

If you were a member of a society that used excerpts of "Hamlet", "Macbeth", and "As You Like It" liberally in their basic texts could you deny the fact that your society is Shakespearean in nature?

"God" pretty much means the same thing now as it did 75 years ago to most people. The concept implies a supernatural being, or spirit if you will.
 
Tell you what, why don't you provide a dictionary definition of "spirituality" that doesn't refer to the supernatural.

What for? I have shown you a definition that relates to the practical usage, nothing more is required.

Moving of goalposts noticed.
Perhaps instead you could explain what a football team's spiritual leader is? Is the captain suddenly akin to a God, a deity?
Or if I say my spititual home is Australia, does that mean it is a God?

In every day usage there are any number of ways spiritual(ity) is used that includes no deity.

If you were a member of a society that used excerpts of "Hamlet", "Macbeth", and "As You Like It" liberally in their basic texts could you deny the fact that your society is Shakespearean in nature?

"God" pretty much means the same thing now as it did 75 years ago to most people. The concept implies a supernatural being, or spirit if you will.

For you perhaps. And that's just fine. Myself and others do it differently and the concept of a supernatural being is easily bypassed when necessary. You (and others) seem to want to pigeonhole AA into a one dimensional religious arrangement; that is not how it works in pratice.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's quite an extensive list that I have to collate and I have a day job that's keeping me busy.

You made recommendations. I just figured you would have had a reason to do so.

Actually though A.A. I never once said "they work better" and I'd kindly ask you to stop putting words into my mouth. I said they were different, you demanded that I prove their "efficacy".

My apologies.
You did in fact "recommend" other treatments. Why?

So what does it matter if they have more less efficacy they're help for addicts that don't muddy the water with religion and "spirituality" (whatever ill defined concept of divinity we're reaching for this page)

But how would you know whether or not they work, with or without your so called muddying?

When all I've said is that there are all alternatives, and you've demanded to know "are they effective" while steadfastly ignoring the question "Is AA effective" and Where's your proof

We have made no claims on AA.
You have "recommended" other treatments. Why? Why do they work? What is it in them that makes them so attractive. You can either stand by your "recommendation" or not.
 
What for? I have shown you a definition that relates to the practical usage, nothing more is required.

I can also show you "definitions" that I make up and that supposedly relate to practical usage. That's why we have dictionaries, and the ones I consulted do not agree with you.

Moving of goalposts noticed.

Ha ! So asking you to actually support your claims is moving the goalposts ?

Perhaps instead you could explain what a football team's spiritual leader is?

Unless we're talking about the Fighting Christies, they shouldn't have one. Again, unless you make up some weird definition of "spiritual".

In every day usage there are any number of ways spiritual(ity) is used that includes no deity.

And all this because you're trying to weave and dodge having to admit that AA is religious !
 
You made recommendations. I just figured you would have had a reason to do so.

Because this thread has two hundred pages of responses, and innumerable disagreements with AA's philosophy activities

My apologies.
You did in fact "recommend" other treatments. Why?

I'm sorry why is "recommend" in quotation Marks?

And why are you personalising the debate?

But how would you know whether or not they work, with or without your so called muddying?

Again personalising the debate.

And furthermore, you're supposed to a Addiction Councillor A.A Alfie. and someone who recommends a variety of treatment methods.

Why aren't you embracing these alternatives?

We have made no claims on AA.
You have "recommended" other treatments. Why? Why do they work? What is it in them that makes them so attractive.

For starts there's no murky confusion about religion or spirituality in any of them.

You can either stand by your "recommendation" or not.

Again why is a addiction councillor getting so dogmatically entrenched in the defence of one particular program.
 
For you perhaps. And that's just fine. Myself and others do it differently and the concept of a supernatural being is easily bypassed when necessary. You (and others) seem to want to pigeonhole AA into a one dimensional religious arrangement; that is not how it works in pratice.

The basic AA literature however is chock full of references to "God". The steps in particular specifically present God as the solution to curing one's mental illness and moral character defects. The AA steps and traditions are often hanging on the walls at meeting places. A meeting that is literature-based is most assuredly going to encounter the word "God" often in the reading.

So saying that a person who attends AA does not have to buy into the supernatural is akin to saying that someone visiting a bar does not have to drink. This is true, but the venues themselves can for the most part be associated with certain concepts (AA:abstinence, AA:God, bar:socializing, bar:alcohol).
 
And all this because you're trying to weave and dodge having to admit that AA is religious !

Nope.
Just showing you that the English language has many variables and idiosyncracies. I choose to use a word differently to you. Too bad, but my explanation remains both valid and practical.

I'm sorry why is "recommend" in quotation Marks?

Because that was what you did. You "recommended" a number of other treatments. Why?

And why are you personalising the debate?

I'm not personalisaing anything; you seem a little sensitive.

You made statements, can you support them.

Again personalising the debate.

Nonsense. Now can you answer the question and support your claims or not?

And furthermore, you're supposed to a Addiction Councillor A.A Alfie. and someone who recommends a variety of treatment methods.

Correct. And when I make a recommendation I can support why I make such a recommendation. I was hoping you would be able to do the same.

Why aren't you embracing these alternatives?

Show me which ones and why I should and I will be in a position to embrace them.

For starts there's no murky confusion about religion or spirituality in any of them.

Good. But does that make them work any better or worse?
Where are the results that support your recommedations?

Again why is a addiction councillor getting so dogmatically entrenched in the defence of one particular program.

I didn't realise I was; I thought I was simply asking you to support your claims.
I am starting to think that you can't, and that your claims have no validity whatsoever.

Is this right? If not, please show us why.
 
We have made no claims on AA.

Pick any AA meeting anywhere, and you will almost certainly hear this read at the beginning, along with the other rituals:

"Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest."

So, yes; AA does make a claim on its effectiveness. There was actually a change from the original manuscript to "rarely have we seen a person fail," from "never have we seen a person fail."

And while we're looking at this, let's see how it corresponds to AlBell's and Alfie's description of the program. Again, it's fraught with contradictions and caveats:

In this, it is said that those who fail have not "thoroughly followed our path."

Is picking and choosing parts of the program that are palatable, or even re-wording the god part, thoroughly following their path? Of course not, and this is what the person who "takes what they want" will be told when they aren't getting any results. It goes further:

"Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program...."

This is, of course, a complete contradiction to Alfie and AlBell's contention that AA is a cafeteria of choices.

Then it goes on to blame any ineffectiveness of the program on the person, and not the program itself:

"...usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest."

I like the touch about "rigorous honesty." It's a great example of irony.
 
Pick any AA meeting anywhere, and you will almost certainly hear this read at the beginning, along with the other rituals:

"Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path.


And........
When did I say that?

You are putting words in my mouth that have never been uttered by me or any other poster here that I recall.

I assume that neither you, nor 8den or anyone else can actually provide the evidence to back up the assertions made.

What other treatments do you recommend Jack?
Why do you recommend them and what is their efficacy?
 
And........
When did I say that?

You are putting words in my mouth that have never been uttered by me or any other poster here that I recall.

I assume that neither you, nor 8den or anyone else can actually provide the evidence to back up the assertions made.

What other treatments do you recommend Jack?
Why do you recommend them and what is their efficacy?

This is the program you are promoting, Alfie. You are persuading people into going to AA, and misrepresenting it in the process. I'm simply pointing out what one can expect in an AA meeting. This "rarely have we seen a person fail" nonsense has been read at every meeting I've ever been to, in multiple time zones and two countries. It's also part of the material given to every newcomer in AA. It's also on AA's website. Anyone can go to the AA website and read it for themselves. It's simply a lie.

I have already given my recommendation in this thread. And that is, quit drinking. It's a simple, one-step program. That's what you did, actually. Everyone in AA who winds up quitting does exactly that. You just think that God swooped down and healed you, but the faith healing AA promotes is simply woo.

There are some alternative programs, which I would not recommend simply because I would not hold them to a lower standard of proof of their efficacy than I do AA. Of course, if someone is hellbent on going to a recovery group, I would definitely recommend them over AA. Not because they work, but because they aren't a cult religion that does more harm than good, as is the case with AA. They don't rely of faith healing or magical spirits.

The Sinclair Method is a good choice for someone who cannot quit on their own (not naltrexone as a tool for abstinence, as it isn't any more effective than a placebo). It is very effective, and yes there studies to support its efficacy. No, I'm not taking the time to fetch it for you because you don't really care. I've read a year's worth of your dismissal of things that you demanded others produce.

And just to make this point clear: I'm not arguing with you. I don't argue with people about their religions. I'm simply clarifying what one can expect when they walk into AA.
 
You are putting words in my mouth that have never been uttered by me or any other poster here that I recall.

Does it matter whether you have personally ever said these words? The phrase that was quoted comes out of the basic text of the AA fellowship and is read at many meetings. It is part of the approved AA literature.

"God" is also mentioned many, many times (hundreds, perhaps) in the AA literature, and it is common practice in most AA meetings to close with either the Christian Lord's Prayer or the Serenity Prayer (which was written by a 20th century Christian theologian).

So even if you personally distance yourself from those things in AA that are part and parcel of the program for most people at most meetings, you are still not taking away their significance. The very fact that they exist and are utilized daily means they are real.
 
Just showing you that the English language has many variables and idiosyncracies.

We've been doing that with just about every term brought up in this thread since the first page, Alfie. We know words can mean something, but I've already said before that unless we agree to use actual definitions, and not definitions used by some obscure pocket of humanity, there's no way to have a discussion. So why are we always nitpicking on terms like "religious", "spiritual", "god", "higher power" and the like ? What purpose could it possibly serve, other than deflect discussion ?
 
There are some alternative programs, which I would not recommend simply because I would not hold them to a lower standard of proof of their efficacy than I do AA. Of course, if someone is hellbent on going to a recovery group, I would definitely recommend them over AA.

I am rather confused; I'm not sure whether you are standing by your recommendations or withdrawing from them.

Could you please show me why you "recommend" them?

You sad earlier you were looking things up (or words to that effect), now it sounds like you aren't.

Can you or can't you provide the evidence of their efficacy or not?

The Sinclair Method is a good choice for someone who cannot quit on their own (not naltrexone as a tool for abstinence, as it isn't any more effective than a placebo). It is very effective, and yes there studies to support its efficacy. No, I'm not taking the time to fetch it for you because you don't really care. I've read a year's worth of your dismissal of things that you demanded others produce.

You might be unaware of how things work around here as opposed to some hate group forums, but if you want to make claims like this it is your job to support them not mine.

Please provide the studies that support the efficacy of the Sinclair method for alcoholics/alcohol dependant individuals.

Does it matter whether you have personally ever said these words? The phrase that was quoted comes out of the basic text of the AA fellowship and is read at many meetings. It is part of the approved AA literature.

Someone was effectively suggesting I was making the claim that AA was better than other treatments. This is untrue and I challenge anyone to point out where I have said this. I was not, and it was simply an attempt to deflect attention from their inability to support their own claims.

We've been doing that with just about every term brought up in this thread since the first page, Alfie. We know words can mean something, but I've already said before that unless we agree to use actual definitions, and not definitions used by some obscure pocket of humanity, there's no way to have a discussion. So why are we always nitpicking on terms like "religious", "spiritual", "god", "higher power" and the like ? What purpose could it possibly serve, other than deflect discussion ?

What you are basically saying is that I should reject a certain factual and common interpretation of a word so as to prove your argument!? Really?
 
Last edited:
I am rather confused; I'm not sure whether you are standing by your recommendations or withdrawing from them.

Could you please show me why you recommend them?

You sad earlier you were looking things up (or words to that effect), now it sounds like you aren't.

Can you or can't you provide the evidence of their efficacy or not?

I never once said I am "looking things up," or even words to that effect. You pulled this out thin air. I also said I don't recommend these groups. The good thing about them is they aren't faith healing, like AA.

I also recommended the Sinclair Method for those who can't quit on their own, and told you that I won't provide you the links because you don't discuss these things in good faith. You've demonstrated this for a year in this thread. Besides this, the links have been provided here by others, which you ignored. You can easily google the information.

Edited by LashL: 
Removed personalizations.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Because that was what you did. You "recommended" a number of other treatments. Why?

Because some people (and I know this might blow your mind away as a addiction councillor) might not like AA.

They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.

They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)

They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)

They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.

They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"

They might not like the people.

A.A. Alfie they just might not like AA

So I recommended some alternatives.


I'm not personalisaing anything; you seem a little sensitive.

Yes you are, and no I'm not.

You made statements, can you support them.

I made a state that alternatives exist. Do I now need to prove their existence?

Nonsense. Now can you answer the question and support your claims or not?

See now you're demanding I prove that these alternatives are efficacy.

Correct. And when I make a recommendation I can support why I make such a recommendation. I was hoping you would be able to do the same.

I didn't recommend them I just pointed out their existence.

Show me which ones and why I should and I will be in a position to embrace them.

Dude seriously it's your job. If a client comes to you and says "I don't like AA" do you just say 'You're doing it wrong keep going back", or "Okay well lets look at some alternatives?"

Good. But does that make them work any better or worse?

It's a bit difficult when AA hides it's own yardstick to it's success. How can I say something works better or worse than AA, when I've no clear idea of AA's success rates.

Perhaps you could enlight me to AA's success rates. A good clinical study would be a very useful yardstick, then I can compare the alternatives to AA, to the grand daddy of them all.

Seriously A.A. Alfie you're asking me to prove the efficacy of alternatives to AA?

Where are the results that support your recommedations?

You're repeating yourself now.

I didn't realise I was;

Well you are.

I thought I was simply asking you to support your claims.

I thought we agreed that I never claimed these were better than AA, in fact you agreed with me.

I am starting to think that you can't, and that your claims have no validity whatsoever.

Is this right? If not, please show us why.

I've made no claims I've just said they're different. In case you hadn't noticed there's a awful lot of people on this thread with strong philosophical objections to AA, what's wrong about mentioning some alternatives, without you pouncing and demanding that I prove that they're more effective then AA.

Trying to prove a alternative to AA is more or else effective than AA is impossible because AA unscrupulously (for high minded reasons they say) hide all their statistics on their own efficacy. It'd be like trying to prove your car goes faster or has better performance than someone who keeps his car under locked and key in his garage but assures you it's "like super fast".
 
What you are basically saying is that I should reject a certain factual and common interpretation of a word so as to prove your argument!? Really?

No, I'm saying that instead of trying to find some obscure meaning of a word in order to prove your argument, we should instead focus on accepted, common definition of that word so that we can move on and actually answer the questions that have been asked in this thread.

Switching "religious" to "spiritual" and then using a definition of "spiritual" that eschews any supernatural reference is a cunning way to answer "AA isn't religious", but it's actually just obfuscation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom