Because that was what you did. You "recommended" a number of other treatments. Why?
Because some people (and I know this might blow your mind away as a addiction councillor) might not like AA.
They might not like the religious or spiritual aspect of AA.
They might not like the 13th stepping (that might not exist in your AA but does exist in some AAs)
They might not like sharing and working with a group that includes people who are sent there by the courts or have used AA as part of plea bargain to escape a custodial sentence (Again that does not happen in every AA meeting, but it does happen)
They might not like the dogma, and the insistence on following the steps.
They might not like the concept of god as "we understand HIM"
They might not like the people.
A.A. Alfie
they just might not like AA
So I recommended some alternatives.
I'm not personalisaing anything; you seem a little sensitive.
Yes you are, and no I'm not.
You made statements, can you support them.
I made a state that alternatives exist. Do I now need to prove their existence?
Nonsense. Now can you answer the question and support your claims or not?
See now you're demanding I prove that these alternatives are efficacy.
Correct. And when I make a recommendation I can support why I make such a recommendation. I was hoping you would be able to do the same.
I didn't recommend them I just pointed out their existence.
Show me which ones and why I should and I will be in a position to embrace them.
Dude seriously it's your job. If a client comes to you and says "I don't like AA" do you just say 'You're doing it wrong keep going back", or "Okay well lets look at some alternatives?"
Good. But does that make them work any better or worse?
It's a bit difficult when AA hides it's own yardstick to it's success. How can I say something works better or worse than AA, when I've no clear idea of AA's success rates.
Perhaps you could enlight me to AA's success rates. A good clinical study would be a very useful yardstick, then I can compare the alternatives to AA, to the grand daddy of them all.
Seriously A.A. Alfie you're asking me to prove the efficacy of alternatives to AA?
Where are the results that support your recommedations?
You're repeating yourself now.
Well you are.
I thought I was simply asking you to support your claims.
I thought we agreed that I never claimed these were better than AA, in fact you agreed with me.
I am starting to think that you can't, and that your claims have no validity whatsoever.
Is this right? If not, please show us why.
I've made no claims I've just said they're different. In case you hadn't noticed there's a awful lot of people on this thread with strong philosophical objections to AA, what's wrong about mentioning some alternatives, without you pouncing and demanding that I prove that they're more effective then AA.
Trying to prove a alternative to AA is more or else effective than AA is impossible because AA unscrupulously (for high minded reasons they say) hide all their statistics on their own efficacy. It'd be like trying to prove your car goes faster or has better performance than someone who keeps his car under locked and key in his garage but assures you it's "like super fast".